But it’s a difference between close calls and blindness (or not knowing the rules/to be able to count) ...

Umpires are also totally useless too!

@@green-grass. are you mean the player itself should count the points without umpire appearance? LoL 😆

Nowadays they can challange the decision to see camera evidence, so both works fine

There is a test tube baby then ur parents useless

Can’t agree more.

Umpire call for Ginting's was correct. Watch the match here kzfaq.info/get/bejne/irNop8SU3K7bhmQ.html . Change the speed to the lowest at 1:26:52 , and you can see Ginting's racket was over the net.

Honestly in today’s world with improvements in technology why dont we have fully machine guided line calls for these international tournaments… why at all rely on humans who are prone to make errors.

what's strange was how Beijing was able to have its own empire to oversee the match. Empire is supposed to be from a 3rd country (so there won't be any bias toward any individual/team in the match) kzfaq.info/get/bejne/is98bJCgy8_Gd6M.html

Because we are pretty

Because it counts as a challenge

@@RXCI unless 2 challenges are wrong it’s fine to do as many

Replays are only for challanges and they can only did it twice (if you got one wrong there will be no challenge remaining but if you got it right it won't). Umpire is an umpire but they're also a human like us, but they should get a punishment for their mistakes smh🤷‍♂️

It happens in all sports

yes the umpire is supposed to be from a third country (other than the players’)

The umpire can’t be from China since one of the players is from China. Do you really understand the rules?

@@cliftonlimzhixuan0923 Of course we know the rules. I'm just going to leave this here for you: Official BWF full match here. Tiemstamp 7:35 . kzfaq.info/get/bejne/is98bJCgy8_Gd6M.html He's from China. We know they shouldn't be.

That umpire is a complete asshole.

@@cliftonlimzhixuan0923 we all expect you to come back with an apology that you were rude AND wrong

Not good for the youtube algorithm man... but i can understand haha

I couldn't finish it also.

At the Scottish open - I know the person who called it 😂

@@pleaseenteraname9414 yo can they line judge my games i will be world champion in no time

Why he didn't challenge?

@@tohmatochicken9013 maybe no challenge in small tournament or still doenst exist

lmao i dont know what was the line judge smoking

They have to find new rules for serving, and also for receiving the service.

*coughs Chinese team

😂 But few people tastes their own medicine.

Yeah, it shows that they trust each other's sportsmanship.

imma pass

Referees don't make a lot of money, ofcourse a lot means something different around the world but they are not there for the financial gain i think.

line judges and referees don't make money. They are rich old people who has lots of time on their time to do stuffs like this (oh and with pretty large ego to go with them). Can't complain when they need side money for a nice meal or gas money.

@badminton rally I don't buy that.

Umpires are volunteers, but their flights, hotels, and meals are paid by the tournament. Line judges are local people, so only meals.

@@lting001 I know it is like this for lower-level tournaments, are the umpires at the biggest tournaments like All-England also volunteers?

I agree, but at Lee Chong Wei I wonder if his honesty affected his game after the incident.

You mean under the net on the opponents court, that is allowed as long as he is not hindering the other player. Above the net there are other rules.

Thanks for the sub!

@@badminton_rally can help to sub mine? Thank you

Yeah, that has to be one of the worst at least from this replay

and that chinese umpire too

I know these umpires get years and years of education and training, before getting on this level. Despite of this there are indeed really bad umpires between them.

Endless Motion from Bensound

never underestimate the french umpire in denmark opennnnnnnnn

@@yuanloongtay9954 I don't underestimate any umpires of course, without them, we won't be able to win a match if you think about it

@@aarizfirdaus8220 xD lmao

I don't know of any sanctions. What I do know is that an umpire gets a lot of evaluations. But in my opinion the assessors prefer often a good presentation above making good decisions. You can see that happen in this video. I know this because I have been umpire for a while, on a lower level than this.

Thank you for watching till the end. The song is "Endless Motion - Bensound"

@@badminton_rally my amazing pleasure for your channels🙏

Most umpires I knew were playing badminton on a really low level or were not playing at all. That can indeed be a problem, not always. In my childhood I often had an umpire at matches and he said the following to me:"I can't play badminton, I am really bad in that, but I like to umpire." And he has made mistakes in my matches, but most of the times he was not prejudiced to any player. He made faults on both sides. And if he had made a fault he admitted it after the game. Therefore the players respected him, I never heard players complaining about him. This umpire has led one England Open Men's Singles final years ago and stopped about 10 years ago. Unfortunately, not every umpire is like this. So I agree with you.

With the age does come experience, but I get your point.

If the shuttle is already landed you can even hit the net, that's the rule. From replay the shuttle is already touch the field so its not fault.

Even when the shuttle is in play you may invade the opponents court with your feet under the net as long as you do not hinder the other player.

And if the umpire was wrong, he/she should be punished also with a fine or a dimerization marks

It was still out

I think this is quite rare