That's true ❤

U forgot Sharon

Amen to that. God bless. I’m a Marian Catholic and would definitely put Floor in first place though Sharon of Within Temptation is probably second. Each has a beautiful voice an amazing gift from Jesus through Mary.

The 'real' queens of opera metal.

Oh by far the best

Tarja 1, Simon 2, Floor 3😍😍😍

It goes to TARJA, aside from starting it all.

While not symphonic metal Noora form Battle Beast is an absolute monster on stage.

@@bmstylee I couldn't agree more!

@@Cromagnon7 Nah.. Seen her a few times but it was like being at an opera. Although good at her craft, I haven't seen alot of versatility like some metal vocalists. Including growling!

Absolutely agreed!!! No other than her!

So pity.

I agree with you, Tarja was only opera

Même l'ordre je le trouve assez juste...quand on parle de capacité vocale femenine

Amy Lee doesn't really do symphonic metal though, she's good nonetheless, but more in the pop/rock genres, because of the mostly contempary singing style that she uses

Agree it's not a contest. For me the list is great in that it creates a listening plan, irrespective of the order.

Did not even mention that Tarja was originally from Nightwish 🤦‍♂️

Agreed that is a tough choice. I would personally put Floor just a touch ahead as I like her overall versatility and style. Tarja is amazing and super talented but I have never been as big a fan of the Bel Canto style. Still love almost all her stuff though. Also why could he not at least mention that both are singers of Nightwish? Most casual metal fans will know them better from than that than the their other stuff.

@@MrMalve25 Agree! Even if it is tough choice. 😄

Just a reminder, Floor can perform anything Tarja sang while she was in Nightwish, but it can't be said the other way around.

thank you for mentioning Nicole Bogner! only two small albums with Visions of Atlantis, but I am so glad for them

Kalah Kelas 🤣

@@kiasmorogundono8218 ?

@@evsoldier1539 Goblok Koen

Neither Amy Lee nor Evanescence do metal.

Yes 🤟

Sorry Tarja the God of symphonic metal. Simone could never be as better as Tarja.

Tarja should take more care of her fans, killing them with her voice is not a very nice thing to do.

I have to agree her voice kills, death is a better choice than suffer that noise..

ANETTE OLZON IZ A GREAT SINGER TOO"" LISING WITH THE SONG """ BYE BYE BEAUTYFUL" IZ A WOMEN MARVELOUZ TOO

I mean I don't even know if I'd consider Amaranthe a SYMPHONIC metal band, but that's besides the point...

agree top 5

She definitely isn't in a symphonic metal band, but she is definitely very talented and is rising in the ranks. I would say top 10

Amaranth is Power Metal not really Symphonic Metal

Just listen the song "the most beautiful place" and change your opinion

Personally I do agree with him in most of his decisions..., Tarja is the best and he is right too about Sharon, she deserves the second spot... with her angelic voice, I could listen to her sing forever... I never felt that while listening to Floor Jansen But he messed about 3 things in particular : * He forgot about Anneke van Giersbergen * Anna Van Giersbergen deserves a better rank * And his biggest mistake is Simone Simons , for God sake, how the hell is Simone Simons in the 13th?? That's the parallel universe... she deserves to be at least in his top 5

Floor is a better singer. But Sharon is a better musician. Floor can't stand music industry on her own. She is well known just because of Nightwish. Sharon, on the contrary, is a really good song writer, lyricist and costume designer. She has unique, angelic voice in which nobody can imitate. Last but not least, she has unique dance too.

@@ahmadsukron2519 Oh man! I think should search about Floor's music history first before saying that she can't stand music industry by her own... In case you don't know, she had two previous band before nightwish, also she toured around the world with Afterforever and Revamp, she did a lot of partership in music with a lot of musicians and different projects beside her bands, on the other hand, we actually could say that Tarja is well known and got all success she has only because Nightwish.

@@carlosjj662 Yes.. She has done all those stuff... Btw, has After Forever/Revamp/Northward ever topped the dutch album/single chart? How much youtube view has After Forever/Revamp/Northward gotten so far? Did mainstream audience know her before she got hired by Nightwish? Has she ever performed at Rock am Ring, or Wacken, or Download before Nightwish era? Are all those stuff comparable to Within Temptation?

Tarja is a God. How could you put Floor as Tarja level. Floor could never with her pop voice

La primera de Erszebeth es mexicana!

Tristania and The Sins symphonic metal bands? Oh really?

Oh, you are the clairvoyant! She is singing in "The Veil of Secrets" now!!!

ok: in the description

@@omilongplay thank you very much!

listo

@@omilongplay gracias!!

This video is too old ... eight years. And then there is the question if Scardust is Symphonic Metal or - like they say about themselves - Progressive Metal. But you are totally correct - their Nighwish covers might even better than Floor's.

I wanna know too... :(

The intro of video is the intro of the first album of Visions of Atlantis, the first and have the song: " La culpa" : Erzebeth

@@omilongplay thank you!

Lacuna Coil is Gothic metal.

Tarja,is amazing but Floor is in a league of her own! God bless all musicians.

In your dreams.

Agree. Tarja is the best. She's the inspiration for all the other singers

tarja compered to the greatest female singer that ever lived floor? your having a laugh lol

If not Floor then Tarja is a very good choice. Floor can sing most of Tarja's song very very well...but not all of them. Some songs only Tarja does them well enough.

@@jimmyboy131 Floor can sing any of Tarja's songs, better than Tarja, and that's not even debateable.. Tarja has one style, of pitch, slow and in-comprehensible.. She's wouldn't even make the list id it wasn't for the fact she used to be in Nightwish

@@ChristianSander1969 OK no, you're wrong on many levels. Opinion is one thing; we all have one of those. Firstly Tarja is objectively a fantastic singer and would be on the list anyway. You have it backwards; Nightwish likely wouldn't be known, at least not as we know them, if she wasn't their singer. They were originally going to be a folk metal band but because of her ability they changed their style. Secondly, Floor cannot sing certain songs as well as Tarja. If you can't hear that then you're just not listening. They sing them differently, yes, but that's because their basic styles are different. And if you think Tarja can only sing one way then again that shows you don't pay attention. Plus your description of her style as slow, off pitch, is totally wrong! Yet again, you don't pay attention. You heard a part of one song (probably Bless the child from End of an era) and you used that to back up your prejudged conclusion. Try again after you've actually paid attention.

Amaranthine