Reply to this comment with your Mario RPG video ideas and make sure to join my discord server, link in the description

Dreamy Mario is so freaking underrated and doesn't get the respect it deserves. The first time through, I didn't think much of it but I can't express enough of how enjoyable it was to play in Hard Mode.

Cackletta's boss fight is WAY better in the GBA version. She has the same number of attacks, but they're much more fast and exciting. Her clones are also nearly impossible to distinguish in the original, so you have a much higher chance of activating her tricky counterattack. For that matter, the remake is much slower-paced in general and doesn't seem to understand that Superstar Saga's fast pace is a large part of what made it so fun.

I personally think partners in time itself is underrated, besides it didn’t get a remake while superstar saga and bowser’s inside story both got one

The problem with Junker is that you fight him in the end game, he would've been perfect mid game (for the context, Mario and Luigi try to enter the fawfulized Peach's Castle, Junker try to stop them and after the fight, Fawful ditches the party back to Toad Town and put the barrier to block the entry)

Tbh there should’ve been a second fight with dreamy Mario somehow. It’d be really cool for him to use the Luiginary attacks, or even their own unique special attacks.

Top 5 Overrated bosses: 5)Blizzard Midbus:definetely a difficult fight,but come on,his attacks are not THAT difficult to avoid 4)Commander Shroob:now,I didn't notice whether I was overleveled or not,but this fight was so easy 3)Koopalings from Superstar Saga:ah yes,let's just fight the same boss 7 times(let's say 6 because Ludwig is the only one with a brain) 2)Pi'llodium:fun boss,but it was a bit underwhelming once I got to it 1)Morton,Iggy and Lemmy:the only Koopaling fight in Paper Jam where I didn't die or even take damage,and I was also super worried because it looked difficult Top 5 underrated bosses: 5)Dreamy Mario:the concept is really cool,and for being the 1st Dream Boss it does a great job 4)Sunnycide:really cool boss,sometimes it drags for far too long but still fun 3)Pokey Duo:pretty difficult if you aren't enough skilled 2)Midbus(theatre):this fight gets too overshadowed by the Blizzard version 1)Fawful(Superstar Saga):love this fight,it's simple yet fun and once he emerges is so satisfying to just bash him with everything you have in your arsenal

Honestly I feel like the most underrated boss is the Sea Pipe Statue from Bowsers inside story.. it’s also my favorite boss in the entire series but it’s just so unique and fun I just can’t ignore it

Yes, Bowser the Beyblade is annoying to control, but the whole reason people hate dimensional travel is because of how hard it is to precisely dodge attacks. Here, you are dodging the lava while trying to hit Bowser. That is 2 things to keep up with while dimensional shots from the Zeekeeper can number up to 5. Maybe not the best reasoning, but certainly seems like a reason

To be fair, Giant Bowser is great until the beyblade section. Especially the first time I reached it I was in a bumpy car ride...

Popper and rookie are loved because of how charming they are as a duo and they are fun side villains

Count how many times Shroob said "disappointing" in this video.

Dude, the most underrated boss of all is your channel, the editing is so good! And you actually managed to slightly change my mind abt the junker and popple fights! Such a good channel

more roast on kretin: an earlier boss has 3 attacks and it’s an enlarged normal enemy, the scutlet some cooling water for kretin: his fight is two puzzles that are done twice in the fight and that’s the main challenge

If dark star core is here, there will be hell to pay

I honestly ADORE Dreamy Mario's concept so much. He's such a wonderful play on Dreamy Luigi's existence and the way he uses his 'Marionoids' is probably the most creative rendition of the "Dream World boss summons a bunch of minions" trope that gets used a lot. I find myself sometimes wondering how much more fun he would be if he was a bit later in the game (maybe Dream's Deep for instance) with more attacks, but he's still a /really/ good early boss. As for Giant Bowser... I dunno if this is a thing people pick up on, but in the gyro-control segments you're supposed to hold the DS completely flat, and the icons in-game clearly show this. But it's so unintuitive to do it that I wouldn't be surprised if most of people's issues with the gyro controls against the Zeekeeper and Bowser would be fixed just by opening up their DS by that last little tick.

For me Junker was a hard battle becuase I HATE the falling star attack and had to use something else and I struggled on the Junker Boss battle becuase of me not using the falling star becuase of the fact I hated it. Also after the battle I went and got the Magic Window and I used the magic window and was doing more damege then people using the falling star were doing while I was just using the magic window becuase I got really good with the timing on it and was able to always destroy two of Fawful's leg and his glasses on one turn then I just did a snack basket then Magic Window to defeat Fawful on the next turn after dodging one more attack.

I think dreamy Mario is an underrated boss it’s really fun and challenging and I love it

1:49 I have never seen Cackletta do that attack.

Wow I took so long getting the next Flat mates out that now I might as well not bother censoring the bit where you mention this video lol

15:08 I mean hey you got to admit Bowser Junior has some of the best fights in the entire Mario series

Great criteria, always good explaining things like beforehand. I accept your opinion, always Nice to hear someone elses view!!

That list was amazing and unexpected. Overall nice list and amazing video like always

Regarding the cackletta fight, it was the first fight with more than 2 attacks, so it was kinda "amazing" then played first time and the idea of conjure holes was kinda unique at the time. (I also played the GBA version only, which is much faster) regarding Junker, it was the first time in the game I actually struggled with a Boss Fight. Reminded me of the good old times in PiT, very loooong Boss fights. Yeh it took me a while to defeat Junker.

Underrated no 1: the channel "Shroob Invader". This channel is an extremely great channel especially if you enjoy Mario RPG games. Not many people are as good at debating as "Shroob Invader" especially when it comes to Mario RPG games. Not many people even know this KZfaqr exists, and I'm sure "Shroob Invader" understands, but for us that do know you exist, we're supporting you. We also understand that most people don't enjoy Mario RPGs as we do, but for the channels that also enjoy RPG Mario games too, we support them too, for taking time out their day to entertain us. That concludes why "Shroob Invader" is the most underrated Mario RPG KZfaqr.

Little late to the party with commenting, but I think a cool way they could have made Junker more unique and difficult is so any attacks from above wouldn't affect him. And how he could do this is by hiding away closing his lid just like his minions, making it a fun way to improvise with not being able to use your strongest option of attacking.

Trivia. Dreamy Mario's Russian name is Марио-баюн, which is Mario followed by a lullaby expression, basically meaning Mario-gotosleep.

I’m pretty sure the bowser motion control argument can be made because it’s 1 part near the end of the fight.

Its just werid how junker only sucks up luigi because in the original he went for both mario and luigi but in the remake he never goes for mario

I think the reason people hated the gyro control in the zeekeeper fight but not the giant bowser fight is 4 reasons 1. The players got used to the gyro control after attempts at the zeekeeper fight 2. You have way more space to move around in the giant bowser fight than the zeekeeper fight 3. There are basically no projectiles besides bowser being thrown at you in the giant bowser fight unlike with the zeekeeper fight 4. You don't have to go back doing the beyblade phase again after finishing it in the giant bowser fight unlike with the zeekeeper fight where you had to go back there a 2nd or 3rd time "Please don't call me a nerd" -🤓

Finally Shroob will post a video, after this I see you guys in the next Shroob's video, after 3 months

My personal issue with zeekeeper honestly is just how tiring dragging the stylus down is because it kills my arm. Dragging the stylus up feels slightly more natural. Oh yeah I died like thrice to Junker.... Somehow... I was definitely underleveled throughout the entire game but the attacks didn't really spark joy. Yeah the boss is mediocre. I liked Swiggler alot, especially since I dislike Sunnycide for requiring me to destroy the eggs in order to do any meaningful damage.

I might make a new Mario and Luigi game with AlphaDream with me as a new hero in it called Mario and Luigi: Elemental Bonds!

My personal underrated is Bowser and Antasma from Dream Team. It's real cool how Bowser keeps his overworld moves from the previous game and applies them in combat.

Haven't played any of these games in a long time, but I've never had issues with the motion controls for the beyblade section. If anything, it's the steering controls on that last finisher, and I have less issue with that than Zeekeeper's gyro control attack, which I'm pretty sure he can bust out more than once per fight whereas the Bowser finisher is once only so long as you don't fail. It's not a case of giving Bowser a pass. It's a case of his instances of motion controls just not being an issue for me compared to Zeekeeper's. And this is coming from someone that doesn't dislike the Zeekeeper fight or even his rematch.

In defense of each and every entrant on the overrated list: -Even if Cackletta doesn't have that many attacks in hindsight, what attacks she does have are pretty cool and fairly tough to dodge, and between those, the special music, and the 2nd phase, it does make for a fairly climactic fight. Also, you have to keep in mind that it's a mid-game boss, so of course it's not gonna be final boss levels of climactic. Also, her cloning move was made easier in the 3DS version. -In defense of the "beyblade" phase, it does give the player a lot more leeway than the Zeekeeper's dimension attack, and it only happens once in the entire battle. If anything, the surprise second phase where Bowser turns even bigger is what _really_ gave me trouble in that fight. -Keep in mind that the 3DS version is made much easier than the original DS version so Junker may put up a better fight in that version, and regardless of version, while the original Junker may not stand a chance against Falling Star, the X version certainly does. Regardless, I think you were too harsh on this one because you judged it based on an overpowered attack at the bros' disposal rather than the fight itself, which in my opinion, is pretty competent. -Alpha/Beta Kretin is actually one of my favorite bosses in the game, because not only is the gimmick extremely innovative, but while I do admit he does have limited attacks, the two he does have are also innovative. Also, I don't know about the 3DS version, but the DS version at the very least never felt like it dragged at all. -I admit, the 3rd and 4th Popple fights are definitely better, but the first two aren't that bad either, not the best but, aside from Bowser (Rookie) countering each time you attack Popple, it's still not bad. Honestly, it's Popple's special boss theme that makes me keep coming back to those fights.

Junker with challenge medal is unironically a nightmare but in a good way He steals Luigi like every other turn but since everything is stronger, the Junker Cans will start trading him before you can kill one and the Thwomp attack is a OHKO unless you’re overleveled and if Mario dies then so does Luigi

My top 5: Overrated 5) Midbus (bowser’s castle) 4) Wisdurm 3) Bowser memory M and L 2) Pi’illodium 1) Popple and Rookie Underrated 5) Swiggler 4) Fawful Express 3) Koopalings (superstar saga) 2) Popple and Wiggler 1) Chargin Chucks

Its gonna be great as usual shroob and thats a fact

The Giant Bowser fight Beyblade part isn't hated that much because its short and it either controls fine or a nightmare because IT KEEPS PULLING ME INTO THE DAMN LAVA, but with the Zeekeeper it happens often and the attack is a lot longer because with Bowser you can still get lucky if Bowser goes for you and falls in and manage to stay on for long enough. Speaking of which F*** THE ZEEKEEPER FIGHT

I hate the zeekeeper giant battle because for me the motion controls just sometimes didn't work leaving me with like 10 to 15 minutes later. The Bowser battle never gave me problems

When fighting Alpha Kretin X I learned Bros Attacks work on him like if its say Luigis turn and you need to destroy green orbs or whatever theyre called a bros attack works on him even though mario is involved with the attack so that just pissed me off

Fawful Express I strangely beat on my first try and I failed with the mic, and got hit by almost every attack and I didn't heal because you basically can't heal because theres basically a turn limit. So Idk

Here is my list of Mario and Luigi bosses underrated to overrated Superstar saga Hermie III (underrated), Cackletta soul (overrated). Partners in time Elder princess shroob (underrated), Petey piranha (overrated). Bowsers inside story Dark Fawful (underrated), Dark bowser (overrated). Dream team Antasma (underrated), Giant bowser(overrated). Paper jam Bowser junior duo (underrated), Paper kamek and kamek (overrated).

The thing I like about cretin is the design and the fact you have to hit each segment with specifically Mario or Luigi. From what I can remember I don’t think there was a boss that made you attack with specific characters. I could easily be wrong tho.

People are complaining about the Beyblade part of Giant Bowser that hard? I thought the attack where you have to lift up Bowser’s foot or failing to dodge the fireballs and have to that phase all over again would have take the cake of being able the reason of hating that fight.

Lol even if I have watched your videos and played Dream Team twice(normal and hard mode) i always forget about Dreamy Mario xd its so sad because is such a cool concept.

How is swiggler an underrated boss i like it so much, it's the 1st big boss in the game

I am terrible at the falling star action command and thus never do it and thus, yes, I did get to actually battle junker... until I got good at magic door and that is arguably more broken

Shrowser is definitely the most underrated Mario and Luigi boss!

The Zeekeeper fight I dislike not only because the tilt controls break, but I also dislike the chase gimmick along with the tilt controls since you mostly always have to heal after it. In hard mode, the Zeekeeper 's tilt controls were SO BAD, that even though I played through the game like 3 times before, I was actually STUCK on it, and it was very frustrating. Your argument on Giant Bowser doesn't work as well because you have to go back to the Zeekeeper phase MORE THAN ONCE. Also it's easier to get the motion controls unstuck for Bowser, I was still constantly stuck in the corner for the Zeekeeper and then I take a bunch of damage or just die.

In my opinion, the Shroob bowser final boss in Mario partners in time is underrated

Popple fights are loved because of the concept of them and how fun they are to fight and his theme do I need to say anything else about his theme

Merry Christmas Shroob! Also, why is this coming out on the 27th?

Totally agree with Cackeletta being overrated. Me when fighting Cackeletta: "I'm not mad, I'm just... Disappointed."

Great video as for some I find underrated: shrooboid brat or commander shroob and my fave boss jojora and friend, also wisdurm. I feel that people think these are solid fights but they don’t get discussed much from what I’ve seen. An overrated one would be giant bowser for example I do agree with that

Missed the premiere, so to compensate, I'll pick my overrated and underrated for both M&L AND Paper Mario. Overrated: 64: Crystal King, cool design, can't remember anything else. SS(DX): Popple and Rookie 2, literally just the same fight as the first one, but with one extra attack. TTYD: The SNORE that is Grodus PiT: Double Bowsers I guess? I don't have problems with this one, its just that I think it has a bit off too much more praise than the other fights. Super: Haven't finished yet, sorry. BIS: Dark Star, it was hard to choose for this one, so this could be inaccurate. SS, PJ, CS: These have overrated boss fights? DT: Elite Trio, I like this fight, but it gets a TAD too much praise OK: Rubber Band I guess, again, I like all the Origami King fights, so I just picked the one I think is slightly overrated compared to the others again.

I was just playing partners in time, and I fought elder princess shroob for the first time, and not to brag... but I SOMEHOW got the timehole attack. why can't I be that lucky playing other games

Merry Christmas Shroob :)

New subscribe goal for Shroob:5 thousand subscribers and Mario Plus Rabbids is in the channel🤣🤣just kidding, but for me it would be a great idea

Heres my list Underrated 5 blooper statue 4 shriggler 3 mid bus round 2 2 Peter piranha pit 1 tower of yik Over rated 5 fawful Express 4 super princess peach castle 3 wisdurm 2 young princess shroob (dont hurt me ) 1 commander shroob and shroob bombs

I can agree with the underrated fights being underrated, but the reasons for the others being “overrated” feel too personal or overall conflicting reasoning :/

My opinions on all of the fights you went over: Cackletta: Like you said, people only like this fight because it's Cackletta. I never saw the attack you showed at 1:20 before watching this video and I heard that someone beat the fight in one turn while underleveled. Hoohooros: It has an actually interesting concept for a boss this early. Giant Bowser: Yeah this boss sucks! Another commenter made a good point that people only like this fight because its story significance compared to the Zeekeeper. I even hear some people claim that everyone that dislikes this fight is bad at the game, and even if they are, can you blame them when this is only your 5th time battling in this abnormal format? Dreamy Mario: Honestly, I prefer this fight earlier in the game when you don't have Luiginary Attacks to destroy the clones easily, which would ruin the fun concept. Junker: I never used that Bros Attack so I enjoyed the fight, but I will admit that it's the worst boss fight in Peach's Castle. Fawful Express: Thank goodness for the 3DS version. Kretin: I enjoyed the fight, but still 2 attacks is really lame. Bowser Jr. Duo: I really hate it when people disregard everything about Paper Jam for being Paper Jam, and this fight is one of the best examples of that. Popple and Rookie: Unpopular opinion, I prefer fighting Popple on his own and with Birdo to with Rookie. One Bros Attack feels like Popple doesn't need to be there, the other feels like Rookie doesn't need to be there, and all of their other attacks are lame. When Popple fights with Birdo, they actually have some attacks that can only be done with two or more people. Swiggler: Partners in Time bosses are rage fuel, that's all I'm gonna say.

go rank the unavoidable enemy encounters in m&l games please no bosses but normal enemies maybe those of the paper Mario series too

Shroob, what do you think about making the top 5 most overrated and underrated Areas in every Mario RPG series???

I see SunnyCide, I see underrated, I click

Shroob Invader back at it again roasting Giant Bowser

I think swiggler is that forgotten because is the only major boss in the game that isn't a pain in the ass, because I think partner in time is the game with harder bosses in the series, making me lose at least 1 time in the mayority of bosses, with the exception of kamek, swiggler and the bosses before it, making it less memorable than the others

I'm surprised you still have the patience to talk about the crappy Giant dreamy Bowser and Zeekeeper battles after doing so like ten times before lol

What editing app do you use. me iMovie

the falling star should have been impossible to get until the dark star area in bowser. Also fawful express brings me bad memories so thats exactly why I hate it. In one of my videos i said it was my least favorite mario boss but I explained it horribly. i just said "this fricken boss has a timer kinda... kinda wish I didnt say that lol.

Watching this really makes me want this series to be on the Switch. Anyone?

After watching this video during bosses I will only be using normal attacks and not use any bros attacks. Just so I can experience the boss and see any attacks that I have not seen.

I think fawful express was the most satisfying boss to defeat

My Lists, Overrated 5. Giant Bowser (Dream Team) Hot Take… I actually don’t like hard mode in Dream Team. And Giant Bowser is one of the biggest reasons why. A super lengthy fight, almost impossible to deal with, and well, having to do all of this multiple times zapped everything good about it because it’s a dope fight. 4. Bowser Jr. Duo (Paper Jam) Another good fight with creative attacks, but it takes about as long as a Partners in Time boss. 3. Hoohooros (Superstar Saga) All you do is jump, use bros attacks, and break pillars… Excitement 2. Scutlet (Bowser’s Inside Story) First boss syndrome… need I say more? 1. Sunnycide/Commander Shroob (Partners in Time) Kind of a cop out, but they have the same problem; the two coolest bosses in the game, shot down by having waaaaaaay to much HP Underrated 5. Cackletta (Superstar Saga) Has some really good attacks (albeit easy to dodge) and has one that’s quite tricky; the lightning attack. 4. Elder Shrooboid (Partners in Time) The first phase is subpar. The second phase is incredibly intense with the bomb thing from Hollijolli Village coming back. 3. King Boo (Paper Jam) Has a bit of choose your difficulty within thanks to Paper Mario being captured and having to attack the Paper Boo holding him. 2. Dreamy Mario (Dream Team) Interesting attacks, the doppelgänger effect, and Antasma’s inclusion in the fight. Need I say more? 1. Super Peach’s Castle (Bowser’s Inside Story) Easily the best giant battle in the series. Giant Battles are not that great in either BIS or DT, but this fight hits every mark without being too difficult GIANT BOWSER, making you pass out FAWFUL EXPRESS, or being those lousy Papercraft battles. And it’s not so long like any of the DT battles either. Masterpiece in this department.

The underlevel part about BIS is because in the original its harder to level up compared to the remake it's easier to lvl up serious I got to lvl 40 in the remake Fawful express the reason why it's hated well like you said its mostly because of the DS version because it uses the mic it doesn't 100% work all the time thats what makes it frustrating

I just think junker is a cool karakter and the dance made me laugh a lot as a child

can you rank every mario and Luigi RPG enemies in all of the games?

Overrated: 5. Pillodium 4. Elite Trio 3. Bowser Duo 4. Commander Shroob 5. Popple and Rookie fights Underrated: 5. Kamek Duo (Dream Team) 4. Dreamy Mario and Antasma 3. Swigler 4. Bowser Jr Duo 5. Mamoushka

the reason giant bowser is liked more then Zeekeeper is bowser motion controls doesn't go for the entire fight

I changed from cheddar cheese into Apollo 7

I feel like cackletta is weaker than she should be due to her technically being the miniboss of the area, and popple n rookie (2) being the main boss of the area. Also ngl i feel like nobody really talks about big masif all that much, cool gimmik based on his minions and cool attacks. Pi'illodium is a boss i also quite enjoyed too

Ok, i'm making this comment separately, not in my "base" comment, in the hopes of you reading it. In my opinion, your PMSS Mini Bosses ranking video is the best of your PMSS videos. It's very entertaning. Usually, i entertain myself with the comments i make in these videos,(and in the 1st 2, with the literal 1st few seconds of them) but a video actually being entertaning in itself, that's excellent.(like the "Why PinT's Bros attack system dosen't suck" video.) Sorry again for this being not related to the video. I am unable to help myself.

I'm sorry for this comment of mine being unrelated to this video. This comment was sent in your M and L PinT Area Ranking Remake/new video, but i don't think you read it. So, i'm remaking it here, in the hopes that you read it. Here we go. My favorite areas of PinT have to be Thwomp Caverns and Star Hill. Star Hill, because i really like the music, it's literally the only music of the game that i like, let alone love, and Thwomp Caverns because of the Adult Bros Ball Gem Minigame, because you can farm beans to get the God-like Ulti-Free Badge for all of the 4 characters. Honestly, in my opinion, these areas are pretty straight-forward(i don't remember how you write that). They usually are a hit because of the enemies, and they usually fail because of puzzles and minigames. And the bosses, in my opinion, are better than avarage, but i can't point out that one boss is better than another, just like in SSS. Here it is. Yeah, i'm sorry for not watching your channel in a long time, so this is my punishment for that. And now i'm trying to make up for it. Are you going to make this list for the PM games, too? Probably not. I know that you make your videos based on polls and stuff, not on comments. So you might never make the list for PM.(🤔)

Entirely ignoring the difficulty, Junker has a few issues. He seems to suck up Luigi a bit too often, which only leaves Mario. When it does end so soon, that’s not much of an issue, but when it doesn’t, you notice. Also his Thwomp attack goes on for a while. Still among my favorite bosses in that game, but certainly with flaws.

Bro you deserve way more subscribers

To Giant Bowser: I hate Gyro Controls in General! If I could turn them off, I would do it without having a second thought!

When I was young. Swiggler gave me so much trouble.

BS the most overrated fight is Dark Bowser and the most underrated one is Dark Bowser

Shroob, technically Mario Plus Rabbids is a Mario RPG, are you gonna make videos about it or is it not in your plans for the channel???

Junker was really hard my first time playing. I guess I was too underleveled. I can’t say the difficulty made me like the fight though. It was too hard. I was stuck there for the longest time. Nowadays, he’s pretty easy for me to fight, but he isn’t a personal favorite or anything like that. Also, I do unfortunately have to agree with the Popple and Rookie fights. I love the concept, but they’re definitely too easy.

Omg I am so excited for this

I mean you are right, i hate gyro controls! Also do you like the antasma/antasma X fights? Cuz i do!

Interesting idea

10:02 Wait was I under leveled for this fight? Or was it because of Luigi constantly getting shoved in the trash?

no way someone using footage of the bis remake

why do the giant battles in bowsers inside story 3ds remake look way worse than dream teams giant battles.

I don't really think there is many overrated bosses in this series so here is what I think are the most underrated & overrated bosses. Underrated: Hoohooros. It's got an good gimmick with alright execution for Early Game SS Overrated: The 1st Popple & Rookie fight. It's easy for the 5th boss, it's already over before 1/7th (maybe 1/8th) of the theme starts playing Honorable Mentions (Underrated): King Bomb-omb. It's gimmick is terrifying in concept but can be cheesed easily. Honorable Mentions (Overrated) Cackletta. A close 2nd place & relatively easy for mid-game no matter the version Dishonorable Mentions: The Kamek Duo. I just find them underhated rather than overrated & it's my least favorite boss in the series if not any Mario RPG

always been looking for this rpg community glad i found it lol

1:39 I think that's because of bowletta that's why he's overrated