Imagine hearing disc 11 when you don’t have any torches in a cave

minecraft gets lowkey scary when you play alone.

the fact the warden was added 11 years after disc 11 was released is so trippy

Fun fact, disc 11 and 13 if played simultaneously actually match up..uncomfortably well.

The creepiest thing about disc 11 is the fact that we can literally see that it’s broken yet somehow it plays almost perfect audio of whatever happened to that man/mob

“The warden was released a whole 11 years later” “No meaningful connection” 11 years you say? HMMMMMM

To me, the "walking" sounds more like a player placing down blocks, which can easily trigger the sculk shrieker, which is why using wool is the meta.

I always thought of Disc 11 as a short tale of an unfortunate night in a cave. It always seemed to me like someone encountered something, ran back to base camp to grab a light source and check their mapping of the cave or their journal. After they cough they alert whatever they encountered and hurriedly put everything away with an audible click of the flint as they light their torch and look for the creature. They then start running before they are either caught or they drop whatever was recording the disc. I always felt like the disc was made from a recovered audio recorder back when the records were made. Like those lost recording scary stories.

imagine if killing the warden rewarded you with the missing disk piece

When you realize that the block game made for children is actually a horror game...

I just listened to discs 5, 11, and 13 all at the same time and I heard so many new things. I am totally not an expert or anything but the amount of crazy things I heard was totally insane and different from listening to them alone.

Wait Warden was added 11 Years after disk 11…. Edit :OMG I HAVE NEVER GOTTEN MORE THEN 10 LIKES THANK YOU

”Minecraft?” ”Nah it’s just a childgame bro” Then why do I get chills

“How to survive horror movies: be the cameraman” Apparently this applies to everything but Minecraft

I think you're right about it not being Herobrine, due to the timing. However, given how many of Minecraft's patch notes have included the phrase "Removed Herobrine", I think it's also fair to say that, at least in the pre-Microsoft days, something being a fan creation didn't stop the devs from referencing it.

disc 11’s sounds may have just been a hint at an upcoming mob they were going to add, which explains the warden’s similar sounds to disc 11’s shriek.

Endermen:Hey guys where gonna record this dude Steve: WTF IS THAT

Disc 11, 11.11.111 minutes long, warden was added 11 years later, and it was talked about in "Ask Mojang 11".

theory: disc 5 takes place before this and the end of that disc ends with sounds like a portal closing. Then in this he's trying to re-light the portal, while being pressured by the thing from disc 5.

And to think the newest disc built in the ancient city is even more world building. It was such a cool experience and cannot wait for them to elaborate more in this cryptic way

Anyone : this disc scary Parrots : AYYYYY THIS IS A VIBE

Minecraft: is a “kid friendly game” Also minecraft: here’s soundtracks that will probably stop you from sleeping tonight

I ran quickly through the cave, hoping to lose sight of the strange, purple glow I had seen. I only stopped when I thought the monster was gone. I lit my flint and steel to make sure the creature was gone, and stared into the blackness. I began to write in my journel about the thing when I heard a noise. I had only realized I had been holding my breath when I saw the glow again. I threw my flint and steel, rushing through the cave and hopefully towards an exit. The beast ran after me, but as I saw the light of day, a cold arm touched me. I faced back and killed the creature, its agonizing death cry ringing into the air..........

I feel bad for c418, he was just trying to see the world, recording things for people and someone killed it. 😢😢😢

Disc 11: I’m The scariest disc Disc 13: No I am! Amateurs.. What was that punk?! Disc 12: *Amaterurs*

we can all say that minecraft can be lowkey creepy asf when you’re alone.

For me the disc 11 is about what is like to explore a minecraft cave in real life.A dark cave in which anything can jump on you.Thats why there is this realistic breathing which stand out of the rest.

The story of Minecraft's disk 11... (as told by my crazy imagination right now) I knew I shouldn't've come here. I knew it was too dangerous. And yet, here I am, in the dark, all alone. Well, mostly. Of course, I knew there would be zombies, skeletons, spiders, and possibly Endermen, but never in a million years did I expect this... This all started a few days ago. I was in the overworld, above ground, looking for some mushrooms, when I saw something... strange. A beam of sorts, shooting straight up into the sky as far as the eye can see. Normally, I would not be one to seek adventure, but this intrigued me, so I decided to investigate. As I drew closer, I saw a green, grassy clearing. Right at the edge of the clearing, I stopped. Someone was there. "But that can't happen, because this is a solo world," I thought to myself. The person was standing near a large, iron structure with a teal box on top. They didn't seem to be doing anything strange, just mining wood and building a home. But this was strange. No one else was supposed to be there because it wasn't supposed to be possible. And yet, there they were. Their hair was brown and short. Their skin was tan, and their shirt was blue. I swallowed my fear and took a cautious step into the clearing. Then another.... and another, until I found the rhythm of walking. The closer I got to the person, the less afraid I was. Once I reached their structure, I drew in a deep breath. "Hello!" I said with a smile. The person didn't say anything and continued to gain wood. I figured they hadn't heard me, so I took a step closer and repeated myself. "Hello!" Again, nothing. At this point, I was sure they heard me. Frustrated and no longer afraid, I walked in front of them. "Excuse me? Who do you think yo-" I stumbled back and screamed. Backing as far away as possible, I cowered and tried to tell myself it wasn't real. It couldn't be real because it wasn't possible. They had no pupils. Their eyes were pure, blank, white. I summoned the courage to take another look, and sure enough, there was no color. The person continued to chop at the trees as if I wasn't there. At this point, I was more than a little afraid. I was terrified and ready to run, but I needed to know how they got here. I stood on shaky legs and approached them. Once I was only a few feet away, I spoke. "H-hello?" Still, they didn't react. I stepped in front of the tree they were mining. They stopped swinging, and their ax fell to the side. "Can you see me?" I waved my hand in front of their face, but they didn't react. At this point, I wasn't sure what to do. For a few minutes, we just sat there, staring at each other. Right before I was about to leave, they spoke. "You. Shouldn't. Be. Here. It. Isn't. Safe." Their voice was low and raspy, and they paused after every word. "Why?" I asked. "The. Fairy. Only. Flies. Underground." "What does that even mean?" "Do. Not. Find. The. Fairy." "WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?!" I screamed. But they didn't answer. They just picked up the ax, walked to a new tree, and began to swing. Dazed and confused, I wandered away. "What fairy? And how would it fly underground?" I wanted to find out, so I headed home and began to prepare. I grabbed a shulker box and began to pack. I stuffed bread, steak, armor, extra tools, water buckets, and torches in the box. After I finished, I grabbed a few books, a few maps, and my disk which I used to record things that may be important, and stuffed them into my backpack. I was packed, now I just needed to find the "Fairy". Whatever that meant. The person said underground, so I began to dig. I dug until my hands bled and my feet cramped. Finally, I reached a cave. I recognized it as my usual resource cave. I knew I had explored every bit of this cave, so I continued to dig. "The fairy only flies underground" wasn't much to go on, but I was determined. I wish I had just given up. After days of non-stop digging and mining, I reached a new cave. This one was large and open, with mobs around every corner and a large patch of dirt near the entrance. But that was normal, so I was not afraid. I began mapping it so I could find my way out easier later. I searched around for a bit and found some diamonds, but no fairy. Then I heard a noise. It wasn't a typical cave noise like a spider or a zombie. It wasn't even a slime or a zombie villager. It was deep like a zombie, but rattling like a skeleton, but also, squishy, like a slime. I turned to try to find where it was coming from, but it was like it was all around me. No matter where I turned, I heard it from every side. It was getting louder and louder until... it stopped. Quickly, I pulled out my disk and pressed record. Then the sound started again. This time it was deafening. I couldn't hear myself think, and the sound was now right behind me. I didn't look back. I ran as fast as I could. And that's how I got to where I am now. The sound, quieter now, is following me, but I'm faster than whatever it is. Could this be the fairy that person was talking about? I don't know, but I keep going. I fumble for my map to try to find my way out of the cave. My breathing becomes ragged and loud and my footsteps even louder. I can't see anything, and the sound is far away, so I take a break to light a torch. The smoke fills my lungs and I cough, but I am thankful for the light. With the help of the torch, I check my map again, and it seems I am only a few hundred feet from the exit. I'm still catching my breath when the sound became louder again. Quickly, I stuff the map into my backpack and continue running. I find the large patch of dirt that was there when I entered and breathe a sigh of relief. I'm almost safe. But the sound is again right behind me and is louder than ever. Then it abruptly stops, and all I hear is the flickering of my torch. Now, I am more terrified than ever. I keep running until I trip and fall flat on my face. My disk shatters into 15 different pieces. I try to pick them all up, but there isn't enough time. I take what I have and continue running until I am out of the caves and above ground again. I look back and see a figure holding a disk and staring at me with two pure, blank, white eyes. Then they blink and turn away. The noise recedes until I can't hear it anymore. After all of that, I am shaken, and more than a little confused. I don't think my jukebox will play my disk anymore, so I set it down on a small hill. After walking for about 2 minutes I turn back. I see a creeper carrying my disk away. I think about going back to get it, but I figure the creeper will have a better use for it than I will. Now, safe, but alone, I return home to sleep. *TADAAAAA* That took me way too long XD

Plot Twist: it’s just a player who heard cave sounds and immediately started panicking

This theory makes me feel bad about the disc, the enderman just wanted to record the world around it and was killed

Thanks for this video, man! I liked your conclusion.

I'm glad you used lemminos music it fits so well

Everybody gangsta till you try to sleep in Minecraft singleplayer says sleeping 1/2 player

imagine the devs just wanted a random creepy disc so they made it, and they're laughing their asses off while watching these theories

I think its a combo of a few of them. The disc definitely does appear to be from the perspective of a mob, but its about a player running from a warden that an Enderman watches. At the beginning if listen closely you can hear what sounds like faint roars. The panicked breathing and rustling of tools sounds like a player confirming with a compass and map only to put them away after another faint roar. The player resuming running only in a panic strikes the Enderman that's watching only now realizing its there

8:35 it's very possible they planed for him writing a sort of journal or some kind of novel but not the exact details. Writers do this trick often where they leave details without fully planing out the end product. When they officially made the mobbeastiery its very much possible they intended for it to be cannonically written by the thing in disc 11

When you play disc 13 at the same time with disc 11, they fill in each others silence periods.

The feeling when you work so hard to get a skeleton to kill a creeper.... but you get 11. Nothing is worse

When I first heard disc 11 in minecraft I was so scared that I immediately closed my game and NEVER came back for a whole 3 months or so

To me it’s nothing more than a record of an incident where an amateur explorer went to cave unprepared for what’s to come so as to arouse empathy

Parrots when they hear disc 11: Its not creepy, its such a big vibe

Warden is added 11 YEARS after disk 11 and it was talked about by the developers at ask mojang EPISODE 11

Another piece of information comes from the disc's sound file itself. When the sound file is opened in a sound editor, a spectrogram can be seen that includes a series of text fragments, including the words "where are we" and "end it."

I love this so much it’s became my theory and I really want you to make something like this about the new discs so bad🙏🏽

Overworld discs: calm Nether/Pigstep: *PARTY*

I always thought it would've been cool if Endermen became passive trader mobs after you kill the Enderdragon. Like they were only hostile because they were under its control, and now that you've killed it, they're free to be themselves

The howl at the end sounds like the wither to me, so maybe it’s explaining the ancient builders story with Steve summoning the wither that drives them all into the end

Thanks for using lemmino's fire song. Totally fit the vibe.

Plot twist: it was just a recording of an average day at the mojang head office

The scary part is that if you play 11 and 13 together, they fill in each others silences

I think the scariest part is how instead of most 'conspiracy theories' this is without a doubt skulk

LEMMiNO's Cipher is such a cool tune, and his videos are top notch too. Awesome to hear it in other videos.

Steve was just tryna light a joint and momma walked in

"There is no correlation with the Warden because the Warden was released eleven years after the disc" Yeah. ELEVEN YEARS. Sus.

bro electricity just went off when you played that bit from the disk 11 at the beginning and im alone at home rn💀

To me, C418 could be an Enderman, but unlike others, it's a curious one. A Enderman that wants to learn things, but as you mentioned, got killed when spying on a player.

minecraft creeps me out sometimes, that's why I bring my 10 cats and 2 dogs everywhere I go lmao

we need a music disc which is just Jeb talking about his board game collection for 2 hours straight

The sound at the end of disc 11 sounds to me like a distorted scream saying “Herobrine”. I’m always surprised everyone seems to think it’s an enderman sound.

love the Lemmino track in the intro!

I was always too scared to listen through the entire disc 11 hehe

Minecraft disc: talks about how a miner was attacked and had to run for his life. Parrots: *dancing intensifies*

Disk 11 now can be solved by the newly added disk 5, Disk 5 is crafted by 9 dismantled fragments. Disk 11 has a broken fragment too, both correlates. The screech matches the warden sound too.

“Me: play’s disc 11” “Parrot’s: *Dance’s* “

When I was about 9 years old I first discovered disc 11. I actually couldn’t sleep that night

Why are players so brutal poor enderman 😔 I wonder why players can't make disks of take some stuff from mobs though

To me it sounds like someone trying to make a fire with flint and steel, rustling of paper (possibly to add as kindling, implying that the fire didn't catch?), followed by another likely failed attempt to make fire, then some gravel digging or footstep sounds (likely trying to collect some flint to make another flint and steel), and, finally, what I think is the sound of rushing air as the protagonist is FALLING. I think the disc is a warning about one of the most bleak ways to die in the game, having a patch of gravel fall out from under you when disturbed and being plunged into a pit of darkness. It would explain why the disc is broken. This disc has a bleak and ominous overall tone to it that I think reflects well on the scenario I outlined above. Lots of cold silence and desolation. Under these circumstances, the human mind has been known to conjure up all sorts of creepies and crawlies to fill in the blanks, because we evolved in the wild and silence in the wild sometimes indicates the presence of a predator. I think this is why this disc has inspired so many to speculate on the presence of a hostile mob. And after watching your video on Herobrine, its pretty clear that the devs are more than willing to let the player base stew in their own fearful speculations inspired by vagueness since it drives engagement. I suspect that perhaps you are doing the same? Or maybe you fell for the tricks of the mind as well. No scary mobs, just an unremarkable death by gravity.

Good memories, when disc 11 and 13 were the origins of hundreds of theories on minecraft. It was scary, but I loved it. Good old Herobrine creepypasta. Passed a time where in my mind, disc 11 was just C418 trying to do some avant-guard music lol.

“And most importantly what secrets does it hold” Golem: **contineus burning to death**

What a child is scared of: clowns. What men are scared of: disk 11

You know damn well when you hear “THAT” music track playing during a KZfaq videos intro you know it’s gonna be good

This video was the first time I EVER heard disc 11. I'm really scared now

Fun detail: Enderman’s noises are distorted, sometimes reversed, and sometimes pitched down English phrases.

The real scariest thing is When Wifles Dosent say... OR IS IT

OH MY GOD THAT IS SO CREEPRY IT SOUNDS LIKE SO WEIRD I FREAKED OUT when I HEARD IT

It could have been a nightmare he wakes up to dogs barking

The disc 11 sounds like someone's POV of a group of players discovering a warden...

There should be a hidden achievement called terrible nightmares after you listen to this 11

To my suprise i hear a sculc sensor beeing activated in the first minute. Also i think i can hear the sound of the warden What i think could be the case: Its a recording of somebody escaping from the deep dark looking on a map placing gravel and then the cave collapes and burries the player. It also seems like the player has used a lighter for something.

The fact you could play a completely broken disc still blows me away

If you rearrange disc and add/remove a couple letters, you get eleven spelled out.

I’ve always thought it was always a miner getting chased by an enderman, that’s why the ambiance picks up suddenly because it teleported

I think that it is someone mineing up because they are getting chased and that dirt sound is them reaching the surface so the song stops because they are safe from that thing/creature and the metal click is them trying to light a lighter to see

This video was damn good quality dude

"disc 11 tales place on a cave due to the noises of dirt, stone and gravel" Me an intellectual: *echo noises*

*Wifies randomly talking* Iron Golem: *My time has come*

I remember being alone one night 8 years old playing my Xbox 360 and seeing this in my inventory. I put it in a music disc and stopped playing minecraft for a few months and had a few nightmares.

minecraft wasn't a children's game back when disc 11 was added it was still Notch's passion project Edit: Back in those days most players were adults and teenagers. Not long after though there was this tidal wave of children and young teens that scared away a lot of the older audience

Plot twist: He died and is trying to find his loot before it despawns

"In a game as lore heavy as Minecraft, i don't think they plan on doing lore reveals seven years in the future" Fnaf: _laughs_

I literally can't with the "Creepers shooting skeletons"😭

The mysterious character wasn't running on dirt / gravel etc, they were placing it. That's the placing sound effect, there were probably building up to escape something or maybe building a wall to block something off

Disc 11: i am the worst disc you can find in minecraft Disc 13: sad cave noises

Disc 11- steve running away from a creeper on 1 heart in a cave.

I always thought that the sounds were mining, and when the dirt sounds kick in, it’s the person boxing themselves inside with dirt to hide from something.

8:30 could also be them looking back at the older disc and using that pre-established lore as a point to go further.

Wifies in a nutshell:Nobody asked but everyone enjoyed

The creepiest thing was that Wifies said a creeper shooting a skeleton.

Man I loved being a kid and just playing this game clueless now I'm an adult and seeing all this lore gives me a child like sensation cuz it's a game I love so much

"Is the screech because of the scratch or the scratch because of the screech?" Love it