So this was basically me fangirling for almost 20minutes. Let me know if you enjoyed it!

Those dorky dance moves were the moves from the original song lol

On Wheein's vocals: "her voice sounds like it's soaring" You don't know just how much goosebumps that gave me. Her latest album is called "Soar".

In Korea, Mamamoo aren't really seen as kpop. Legendary singers and producers in Korea love them and always compliment them ever since they were rookies because they've always been this good.

"I will continue to shamelessly react to them (MMM) because it's my channel and I can do what I want" YEAH JULIA!!! Please don't go down the path of other reactors who would make review videos just for the sake of view counts. Some groups have an insane amount of fanbase and they will pester you to react to their idols (which are more of a dance group with digitally processed vocals)... continue to discover and review artists that you like. Have fun!

That comment about them being like the elements was interesting, and the more I thought of it, the more it made sense MoonByul-water: she can make her rap fit any style of song they do l, like water it'll fit into just about any container you give it Wheein-air: her voice is so light like the air, but it can also give you amazingly strong gust of wind and bring up a storm. Solar-earth: her voice is so steady and strong, its also absolutly beautiful. Hwasa-fire: just the passion and raw power in her voice, its gorgeous but also so so powerfull And just like here on earth these elements work together to give us this beautiful planet, mamamoo works together perfectly to give us this absolutly amazing group of talently girls

Title should be "Julia fangirling for 21 minutes" EDIT: Just saw Julia's comment basically saying the same thing...

" im going to continue shamelessly react to them " yes go girl ! I ENJOY your reaction..

Just letting you know Hwasa actually does a cover of Billie Eillish on the show Queendom (with Kei from Lovelyz) Also Mamamoo’s performance of I Miss You on Queendom is so amazing

A song by Wheein that made me cry is her song called Goodbye and you should check it out if you get the time(not necessarily react, just check it out) and Hwasa covered Orange Coloured Sky some time ago and Fly Me to the Moon. Solar's performances on Rewriting Charts are so stellar and worth a watch/listen. Moonbyul has a song called Snow(original) where she sings a lot and some of her latest covers are absolutely stunning where she shows off her vocal abilities. Hope you check some of them out and enjoy. Thank you for your commentary and stay safe.

when you started giving an analysis of their voices and said that one isn’t better than the other because they bring something different to the table, I SLAPPED THAT SUBSCRIBE BUTTON SO QUICKLY

Wait until you realize singer is just their part-time job, they actually are full-time comedians. Btw, I love the way you fangirling for 20 minutes straight.

Your elemental theory was quite interesting, loved it! Although they don't represent themselves as elements, they regularly call themselves as Star (Moonbyul), Wind (Wheein), Sun (Solar), and Flower (Hwasa). There are many behind the scenes videos and concert performances where they call each other by those names. There is even a song named "Star Wind Sun Flower" lol.

Wheein can make anyone cry, hopefully you haven't seen her solo ballads yet so you can do a react ('goodbye/let's break up', 'anymore', 'shadow' or even the duet she did with Hwasa 'loving one person'; can't go wrong with any of them) but thanks for reacting to another mamamoo vid! love seeing that someone can love them but also analyse them critically while explaining everything so clearly

For Moonbyul's vocals I'd recommend a cover of "Trying to Say Goodbye" she did some time ago: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/kNCYlteTys_Kh2Q.html Or one of her songs called Snow

you made a reference to Avatar... I knew I was a fan of yours for a reason

I thought you would like to know, when they sang in immortal songs they were in their first year of debut, their first concert called Moosical, just two years, unheard of in kpop, that is when they sang this. One concert was extended from 2 and half hours to four. Just noticed the end shot, the heels wow.

Yes Byul's rap in the original Wonderful Confession was a bit off beat but in this one it's dead on, I'm glad u noticed! Also the live band killed it. Please react to Forestella, you will be mindblown!

Nothing's wrong with fangirling, coach 😁 We read the text commentary as well.

16:13 of course no problem don't be sorry, watching Mamamoo performances give me so much fun as well. Agree with your elemental theory hahaha so true and yes you do you, this is your channel btw. Anw thank you so much for reacting to this honorable mention video. I love both you and Mamamoo.

Also another good performance is I miss you on queendom, it’s one of mamamoo’s original songs from their melting album in 2016. This performance is recent tho and I adore how you can hear the improvement in their vocals. Also wheein shines so much in that song.... ohh god she ate that performance upppp

Loved your reaction. You should check out the immortal songs performance "Passion Flower". Wheein's lower register, Hwasa's articulation, Solar's nasal but clear vocals, and Moonbyul's rapping shine pretty well in that performance to me.

I love your reaction, and PLEEASEEE shamelessly react more to Mamamoo. XD I love your comment about their singing technic although i dont really understand most of the music term. XD. I never have enough listen of this medley, bringing so much mixed emotion inside me. ❤️

UGH, I absolutely love your MMM reactions. It's like I'm re-living discovering them for the first time. I'm grinning from ear to ear just listening to you fangirl while they continue to drag me out of the pit I'm wallowing in haha. And of course your technical additions are always appreciated. Also, I'm an OT4 stan but I wanted to quickly talk about Moonbyul for a sec. Over the last few years, our hamster has grown comfortable and confident in her singing abilities and has thus been rewarding us with many self written songs like the angst queen she is. Her most recent cover, Trying To Say Goodbye (kzfaq.info/get/bejne/kNCYlteTys_Kh2Q.html), has all moo's tear-bending and I am *so* proud of her. So hopefully you can also react (or check out in your own time) to her singing as well!

I dropped everything to watch this 😅

When you pointed out how their mics went down the same time my first thought was, Wheein and Hwasa have been singing together for half their lives having been best friends since middle school, that's why they're so in sync.

I might be a little late, but one thing you really need to watch when you decide to react to Moonbyul’s vocals is her cover of Trying to Say Goodbye or "서툰이별을 하려해" This cover has the highest note she’s reached vocal-wise to this date. (Excluding the Cleopatra game because Jesus Christ that was an ear piercing high noise) Happy stanning :)

by the way Wheein's voice is known as 'honey vocals' among Moomoos (Mamamoo's fandom name)

Seeing Solar throwing up the confetti has me smiling like an idiot. Every. Single. Time.

mamamoo with a live band with their vocals? Definitely a chef's kiss

I love your reaction. Pls react to their studio vs live performances

1 year later and I am still watching this video again just so I can fanboy while you are fangirling. It's so nice to be able to experience something so close to my heart with someone who feels the same way.

I love how you wrote your critiques out instead of continuously stopping. Majority of the reactions from vocal coaches always stop and talk and its during every 5 seconds. They don't just sit and watch it throughout

I literally got chills when you're commenting to each and everyone of them. Pls react react to mamamoo studio vs live. Or to their solo stuffs. Thank you 😊

The fact that this group starting to received so much hate but watching this kind reaction make me really happy, I appreciate many people also appreciates their talent, i must say they are rare in kpop industry! Mamamoo is Queen of Queens of Kpop

Can you please never stop reacting to Mamamoo? Because it really makes me feel like watching their Immortal Songs Performance for the first time, even though I've seen them at least hundred times over and over again 😭

Moonbyul is now more confident with her singing vocals. She used to downplay herself and had a hard time looking for her place in a group with 3 power vocals. I'm so happy she's singing more now and showing that her vocals are beautiful 😭😭

Immortal songs is a show where they celebrate the classics through the ages. The girls were definitely not embarrassed about the dorky moves! They are too good and have nothing to prove. It is a celebration, every era is worthy and we should all be proud. Applies across all nations! Your channel is great btw, one of the best reaction channels and I love you time your inputs (good depth) with the songs to minimise disruption. You got a new subscriber and i look forward to more!

Wheein has been stated a lot of times as the Wind/Air. Wow, it must really be for her

Ugh this is why I love immortal songs so much. Most of these songs I’ve heard before covered by other artists and it’s incredible how completely different the songs can seem. The first song has been covered by Park Kiyoung Latin American tango style and the third one has been covered by Son Seungyeon RnB style (both of those performances won their respective episodes I recommend checking them out). The titles are in Korean so I had to translate them, Park kiyoung’s is called goodbye but to find it search Park Kiyoung immortal songs tango, son seungyeons is called wanderer. Glad to see you’re well Julia, stay safe and thanks for more great Mamamoo content.

You need to see them live. Nowadays their concert lasts for 4 hours straight with solo stages 20 minutes long for each member. It'll be worth the money.

everywhere mamamoo goes to perform it's like their concert and i love that for them. true performers!!

your reactions to mamamoo wow leave me impressed, thanks for reacting to mamamoo❤️

Ohmaaaaannnn your comments are just so.... on point. I see a lot if reactors just saying all "wow!" and "amazing!" without ever articulating just why mmm's vocals are so good. You're probably one of the legit "vocal coach" reactors ive seen Again i love the depth of your comments!

I LOVE your detailed breakdown and comparisons and how you took your time to analyze everything....AMAZING

The only elements I would change are Hwasa and Solar's. I feel like Hwasa has more of that earthy, gritty tone while Solar has that powerful firey explosive voice. Moonbyul's articulation crisp and flow smooth as water, Wheein's like that first soft breeze you feel early in the morning, gives you that slight yet delightful shiver. I could not think of a better selectiong for this group, truly are the complete package.

Was about to crawl into bed when I got this notification and came running lol. I love love LOVE your commentary on their voices and performance, and seeing you fan girl a little is like the cherry on top lol. The depth of your comments makes you one of my favorite reactors, actually! I would agree with your vocal elements! A fun fact: there’s a track on the Yellow Flower album composed by Solar called “Star Wind Flower Sun”-each represented by a member. Wheein is actually Wind! Because her name kinda sounds like it (iirc?), but it’s also so suitable for her voice. (For completion’s sake: Flower=Hwasa, Sun=Solar, Star=Moonbyul.) Another fun fact: you said her voice soars, and “Soar” is actually the title of her solo album! Lastly, it’s a shame there’s less harmonizing Moonbyul in the medley, but she wasn’t as confident back then. In many album tracks, you can catch a whiff of her harmonizing with other members occasionally. I find that her deep harmonies really add...depth(? for lack of better vocabulary...) to a song. I’d recommend “Spring Fever” if you want to hear more of Moonbyul singing in pairs with everyone else. She’s very prominent in that track. (I have a soft spot for deep voices so...lol.) Sorry for the long comment lol. Looking forward to future videos!

I'm loving these Mamamoo videos SO MUCH please keep them coming

This was great! I really like the way you break down their singing styles/techniques in a way that's so easy to understand for those of us without much singing knowledge 😅 I really feel like I learn a lot from your videos, and I get to appreciate the performances in a deeper way. Plus your personality is great, you're just really entertaining to watch (:

I've watch this for so many times and I still love and enjoy it!!💕..it reminds me why I Stan them😊💕💕

The way that your reactions are MAMAMOO ANN Nightwish WE STAN AN INTELLECTUAL

Their singing nineties songs and doing the original choreo from them as well 😂😂 we all cringed but it was a necessary evil since the fans would recognize the moves since their “classics” 😂

For Moonbyul singing pls react to her solo song “Absence” or “Snow”.thanks

Most of the KPOP groups are dancers that sing, and very well. But our girls are true entertainers. They sing to us and play on stage and make everyone happy. They can dance but they have fun and it wows all of the viewers. White Chix moves included. Who else would ever pull that off?

I swear I will never get over their vocals!!! Such talent, like I’ve already seen this but DAMN Mamamoo can take my heart & soul straight to heaven w/ their voices

MAMAMOO - KILLING VOICE 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

I appreciate your appreciation 🥰 loved the detail of each artist could not agree more 👏🏼

I came running for watch this 😂😂😂 Loved your reaction and I'm happy that you liked and had so much fun!

Las mejores,grupo femenino de corea y el mundo entero PARA MI, POR SI ACASO.

You should react to Mamamoo Immortal Songs- Backwoods. One of the most amazing performances ever

I'm in love with this reaction 😭❤️ Btw, mamamoo has this project called 4seasons 4colors, each member represent a season and a color, moonbyu was red and summer, hwasa was yellow and spring, solar was blue and autumn, and wheein was white and wind (you got that one right 😍) hope you can check them out one day 🎉 Also Moonbyul is gaining confidence in her singing, she recently release a cover called Trying To Say Goodbye, OMG it's beautiful 😭 also has solo songs like Abscense and Snow which are beautiful to, hopefully you can react to them Thank you coach 🙊

I have no idea how many time have I watched your reaction to Mamamoo here..I like how you point out every expect of their vocal.. Waiting for the next mamamoo reaction from you.Mamamoo at dingo music will be great

This is what a good vocal reacts for me I love every seconds along with the comments. I'll subscribe.

I watch this over and over again.. Julia it's time for a new mamamoo reaction plss 🥺🥺

Please react to Mamamoo's killing voice on Dingo...

Pretty spot on with the elements and Wheein name sounds a lot like the Korean word for wind. I’d say on stage Hwasa and Solar are definitely fire and earth respectively but off stage it’s vice versa because Hwasa is very chill and down to earth while Solar is a bundle of endless energy.

Hey Julia! Today, instead of commenting the video, I'm going to comment the comments. It's so cool the positivity from people here. Such a nice interaction :)

May be ，could you please react to their song “I Miss You “Queendom vers.😭😭😭😭

Please react to Mamamoo Killing Voice on Dingo :)

Love your reaction on MMM .I watched some of vocal coach reaction on MMM also but this one really interesting because i think i hv the same reaction when i watched this video 1st time. I fell in love with their vocals,performances..which i dont see in other kpop gg..they hv complete package...long story short..im MMM fan now..and manage to convert my other gal friends to be MMM int. fan too..Their songs,voices really suit my music taste.

Julia, I find your analyses of vocal talent to be the best on the internet. No need to apologize for fangirling MAMAOO either... it's only natural when you're confronted by such awesome talent.

Their live band during concerts are sooooo awesomeeee!!! I think that combination of great live music and percussion alongside the fantastic talent the girls bring is such an eargasm!! Thank you so much for the reaction, i was fangirling alongside you hahaha

6:18 I guess that’s why i find her voice to be relaxing at times

You should react to the new performance of MAMAMOO in DINGO MUSIC. They perform a medley of their most known songs. It's really impressive.

You need too react to their killing voice with perfect harmony on Dingo Music. You hear their harmonies so much clearly.

I never get tired from watching this medley

shout out to the baby, I hope he can continue his adventure someday

Really like your reaction to the video and the fact that you take the time to enjoy without having the urgency to stop every single second to comments makes us the viewer enjoy too!

This is truly the most entertaining and insightful vocal coach reaction that I've watched of Mamamoo.

Hwasa is my favorite too, although I do like the whole group.

Oh I'm so glad that I found your chanel! With every detail you gave I kinda understand more my babies. Hope that you'll continue to react them! I'm sure you'll fall in love more, thanks for the video.

I love the breakdown! Thank you!

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR REACTING TO MAMAMOO TT

I got chills when I saw this in my notifications! I’m so happy you reacted to this!

Again, since this is 2 years old I doubt that you read the comments any more. But I watch your reactions for MAMAMOO all of the time no matter how old they are. I love how you do it. Now since you have probably been in the Radish patch long enough now, that Heart Solar gave MoonByul was part of the moonsun antics that have pleased us over the years. Look that one up. Please continue to make these great videos.

Wtf, you are litteraly so beautiful. Usually in reaction videos I switch between watching the reaction and the video but my god, I spent like 85% of the time watching you. Sheesh 🔥

Oh my god I love your reactions! The way you write down such detailed analyses of each member.... Amazing!

Love your reaction video and clear analysis!😍 I look forward to your next MMM reaction!

Everything what you said is just right , I haven't think about them as elements until now but, I couldn't agree more with you. I will looking foward for more of your mamamoo reactions :3

I absolutely love your videos on Mamamoo, your descriptions of their voice and their techniques make me so proud of them and their talent😢💕

Oml the comparisons of the members to the 4 elements is so accurate 😭😭 couldn’t have said it better

Loved your reactions and commentary on Mamamoo. Would love to see more of your reactions to them.

Mamamoo is unique group, all 4 members are so good !

i’ve really enjoyed this. thank you for reacting to my girls x ♥️

I love this so much and I will continue to support your mamamoo journey any way I can 😁😁

amazing reaction ❤️❤️ loving your notes in the edited version

Drummer was great! "Never piss of the drummer..." LOL

There voices are so good, you have to check this video ''MAMAMOO Killing voice ''

I love watching you enjoy their performances

Thank you for my ongoing education, growth, appreciation, and exposure to music I would never find on my own. P.S. love Avatar