GW you can't just drop these big bombs on us and then never talk about it ever again... also yes 1:46 was suppose to be 2013 but I guess I still have bleach seeped into my brain. To get a taste of the 2024 Cosplay Claendar, go here : www.patreon.com/majorkill

I always just assumed it was Omegon being Omegon. Uniting together a bunch of loyalists to cause a ruckus for his own nonsensical reasons.

The false primarch being one of the many clones Fabius Bile often makes is something that makes sense.

5 chapters beating 11 chapters is actually very easy to explain. It was 5 chaoters and like 50 billion guradsmen and a big amount of imperial navy ships vs 5 chapters

Omegon: What an absolute disaster. Alpharius: Yup. All according to plan.

My headcannon is the 2 missing primarchs are gork and mork

The vagueness is intentional. For the longest time, GW's approach to lore was to create setting for players to have their own adventures in. The 'false primarch' and the two 'lost' primarchs and the like were all lore openings fore players to insert their personal characters into the lore. Mysteries the GW writers never intended to be 'solved'. For the same reason the Horus heresy took place 10k years earlier, the history of the imperium was intended to be shrouded in myth and legend so players could fill in the gaps with their own adventures.

the False Primarch being the 11th Primarch is actually cool and plausible theory, all 11 chapters could've been his sons that are integrated into Ultramarines and Imperial Fist after his purge from all memories, regaining back their memories as their primarch returns, that would also explain why the High Lords keep everyone's mouth shut about it, if it's just Badab war prequel, they won't go that far to cover it, the involvement of Custodes would also explain why they can take on a Primarch and 11 Chapters with 5 Bloodlust Chapters, it's freakin Custodes, a shadowkeeper nonetheless Chaos Machinations like false Sanguinus is a possibility, but i doubt it would go that far, even without someone like Mephiston, it would be pretty easy for the first or second founding chapters to identify their primarch and since none of them involved here, it makes it all much weirder it being a loyalist primarch is unlikely, we have seen how the loyalist primarch react to current imperium, they dislike it, but tearing humanity apart in a new civil war is out of the question, especially people like Vulkan or Corax, Corax literally go out of his way to try to save his sons, do you think he would leave 11 chapters to their deaths? yo know, but i can also think of a possibility, what if it's one of Alpha Legion's primarch? we know that one of them died, but one still there, whether it is Alpharius or Omegon, even though in Horus heresy books it is said that the Surviving one are loyal, what if he became dissilusioned with current imperium ? it is very much a possibility

I have this stupid theory, the False Primarch is a clone of Angron created by Fabius Bile. Why Angron? Because his power was the most terrifying of all the Primarchs. Angron was an empath, he could take someone's pain, which shows that he was able to manipulate the emotions and feelings of others, he could change someone's feelings and make, for example, space marines from other legions turn against their primarchs. He could make entire worlds become his loyal servants/slaves. He could make people feel unlimited loyalty to him and a desire to serve him.

I like the second to last theory you brought up because I really enjoy the idea of one of the Loyalist Primarchs, probably Jaghatai Khan, coming back and deciding the modern Imperium isn't worth saving so he rallies his sons to form a successor empire.

GDub just came up with the name "Pentarchy of Blood" and the name was so O.G. they just crammed some random lore around it and just ran with it.

I finally figured out who the False Primarch is after watching this video, Ming the Merciless

I didn't even know about the fact their was a fake primarch and got shocked that there is Lovecraft thing as well

In thay most recent book Genefather (also Genefather video when) Bile said he has actually cloned every Primarch. Which feels accurate given their habit of bleeding all over the galaxy and him having at least one full corpse to work with.

Maybe it was a young sensei bursting out the warp uncorupted. Then recruted by a Sm chapter seeing him as a "fucking good warrior". So add some Sm geneseed to an half big E and bam! False Primarch. That could explain why the sensei are exterminate by the inquisition

Random theory to add more to the grim darkness. Where the false primarch comes from an alternate imperium one were the entirety of man including the imperium has fallen to nothing. Meaning it could have possibly been a duplicate primarch due to the cracks in reality caused by the warp.

GW probably wants us to theorize that its one of the lost primarchs just to reveal its just genestealer or chaos shenanigans.

I subscribe to the Lost Primarch being the 'False Primarch'. Although I think its #2, I think #11 was recovered after the Randan and placed in the Dark Cells (subject 11). My theory is The Custodies did in fact "help" Although, they stopped the fight and convinced the Primarch to come back to Terra. Currently, on Terra in stasis but instead of a Black Cell, #2 is in stasis in their villa under the Imperial palace.

Considering that Charcharodons are Raven Guard succesors with culture swirling around the figure of their mysterious father (Corax ) - as mentioned frequently in Red tithe and Outer dark - I think Corvus is out of the question here. They would definitely chose him over bunch of bureaucrats.

A video of the top ten community made wholesome moments would be great

Could you make a video about each legion's best accomplishment/battle/victory? Counting unification wars, crusade and heresy. Also, First.

I think I like the False Primarch being a Fabulous Bill creation best. I really like your idea that he could have actually been a loyalist clone, just without the plot armor.

Well if all the primarchs are perpetuals like the emperor then that would mean the the expunged primarchs should be coming back as well provided they're not improsoned.

0:59 I just stumbled upon this channel last week and i fkin love it! Been binge watching ever since

I'm betting it's a Thunder Warrior Primarch. There's been a few TW's that have become functionally immortal. He probably turned up and disclosed all what happened on Terra and how Big E killed off his line and that they were next making many disillusioned. Primarch was also a rank in the TW's as seen with Ushotan primarch of the fourth legion. He'd also be taller than a primarus marine so he'd be giant for his time making him more physically imposing as well as more deadly than your bog slandered space marine given his augments and experience and seeing at the Thunder Warriors were more resistant to chaos it makes sense there would be no influence.

It's about time, been waiting for you to cover this for a while

A video on Solomon Akkura and his Alpha Legion space marines would be awesome

It was a surviving Thunder Warrior.

6:40 Fun Fact: There is a prisoner in the dark cells known only as “Subject XI.”

I forgot if it was canon or not, but there was a thing called The Angel I believe, and it was some kind of proto primarch the emperor had to put down. I could see something like that getting out.

It being a returned Horus would be an great way of getting Inquisitions Horusian faction some more lore.

need more lore videos about ORKS!! WAAAGGHHH!!

Really enjoy the lost 11th legion primarch theory Ay, a vid on current status of librarians/sorcerers from chapters/legions who opposed Magnus at Nikaea

Superb video as always @majorkill. Could you make a video dedicated to the Navigators, the major houses, their politics, relation to the overall Imperium and factions, etc

There's a chance that it was an Alpha Legionnaire that got juiced to be more like a primarch and these 11 chapters were potentially corrupted or the Alpha Leigon needed the Pentarchy to exsist to help the imperium kill rogue space marine chapters

Great video MajorKen, very cool

Remember, during the 13 founding(dark founding) they find a fundation of a verry big astartes

Your music sounds like the theme from The Last of the Mohicans with a little Skyrim exploration music laid over it.

Well, hope I get my birthday money when it comes around on Friday. I want this calendar.

My headcannon is that we never actually see the end of Arik Taranis in the Outcast Dead. In fact, he may have found a way to cure his condition. So it could very well be possible that the “false primarch” in question is a thunder primarch coming back, convincing the 11 chapters just how much the emperor appreciates their sacrifice, and pulls some shenanigans. I mean a thunder primarch could 1v1 a custodian, but they ARE very much killable

I want it to be retconned to what ends up happening with the Valdor and city of Dust storyline. If they are in a timeless bubble maybe came out at the wrong time and fought the imperium only to escape back into the pocket dimension

The False Primarch was a surviving Thunder Warrior that was the primarch of his Legion before the emperor betrayed them.

Personaly i like the idea of it being a creation of bile mainly because my personal headcannon has Tyberos as the missing 11th primark

Video idea:"Space Wolves vs The Minotaurs. Who would win?"

I had WAAAYYY to much fun hitting the backskip button at the beginning of this video while listening to some old school hiphop for a record scratch effect.

Praise be to Space King.

Thank you for mentioning the Flesh Eaters, You have all my Love and Lust!

I'm of the idea that it might of been a ploy by that Chaos God that may or may not be canon still, Malice. As his number is the number 11 and this might of been him trying some of his own Chaos tomfoolery

i would love to see a video about who went on to lead the loyalist legions after their primarchs were gone, aka the first chapter masters.

More Badab!!! lol that was a great reference

Don't you love that number II looks lot like the Roman number for 2... Food for thought

I actually like the idea it was an escaped Fabius clone. From a story point of view it creates a level of tragedy on the 11 chapters part and especially a Horus clone as was mentioned on the video

This is gonna be awesome

I had thought it was odd that the Minotaurs were not included in the Pentarchy of Blood since they are known for brutally and ruthlessly crushing rebel Space Marines such as during the Badab War and Macharian Heresy. Until now learning that the War of the False Primarch which prompted the founding of the Pentarchy of Blood happened in M33 and the Minotaurs weren't founded until M36.

Only getting the calendar if we getting an oiled up unarmoured Baldermort Custodes pic

Other idea This "False Primarch" was a Man of Gold who appeared due to warp shennanigans, or was finally thawed from that Cryo or whatever it was

im only 3 min in going through the vid now and as soon as i heard space shark i knew shit was about to go down

It's clearly Lorgar; Dark Prophet? THE traitor primarch? It fits

Everyone is a primarch before Tyberos enters the room.

What if the false Primarch is an experiment of Fabius where instead of cloning a Primarch he decided to create his own with some qualities of the other Primarchs

OR, It’s actually Alpharius/Omegon being a little prankster~

My theory is that it was actually misspoke and it was all over the prime-arch. Which was the first arch of the Imperial palace that malcador and the emperor put there together. When it was stolen by the 11 chapters, took 11 because it was a rather large arch and they didn't want to hurt their backs, everyone was understandably confused and angry so they sent the 5 chapters to go and get it back. These 5 were able to get it due to their fork lift certifications as a requirement. It was all covered up because if knowledge of successful grand theft Imperial arch was known, the imperium would implode or trazyn would just steal even more of them.

I think the Fabius clone seems more likely to be the False Primarch. He's the OG of cloning

A video on Valerian and Aleya would be pretty cool.

It would have to be a theory where every major chapter would have chosen not to have gotten involved. None listed in the video fit a theory where Mars, Space Wolves, and Imperial fist would have sat it out. It could be a rare situation where the inquisition and the high lords genuinely proved their necessity and worth while everyone else was strangly compliant.

Literally just I was struggling to down this rabbit hole we get a bud on it

Hey, majorkill i would apprechiate a lore video about solar auxillia or just mortal auxilarries to the space marines or a video about scout marines in general

The False Primarch was just a GW customer who still remembers lore from the Rogue Trader edition that GW wanted silenced.

DO ALPHA LEGION LORE DRUNK RAAAAAAAAWHHHHHHH 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥

YoMAJOR you gotta talk abt the Lion soloing a hive tyrant

@majorkill A video on each of the primarch’s favourite food would be cool. Also a video on how each of the pirmarch’s would react to being implanted with the butcher’s nails would be cool as well.

A lost primarchs homebrew competition would be rad

The 11th primarch makes sense it's a little on the nose but it makes sense. With subject 11 being something in the dark cells and all.

Attempt number 36: What if the Primarchs where found in the order of their creation. So the Lion was first and Horus was nearly last. I think that could change quite a bit, don't you think? P:S yeah, I'm definitely doing this till it gets to a 100. JOIN ME MY BROTHERS!

Now how the hell do you manage to do your "magnum opus" with every single large merch drop. You are truly an impressive bloke

the thumbnail art is BAD ASS! OH MY GOD!

Wake up babe, new Majorkill video just dropped

Hydra Dominatus

Hear me ou what about a thunder warrior primarch who had enough. Being smart and strong enough to survive or remedy his body, his mind the crusade, the heresy, scouring, black crusades , war of the beast, the apostacy and many more while the adeptus terra was initially hunting him. Like ypu said he could have had enough and tried to reforge the dream of his leige or used it as distraction to get rid of bad actors and plots.

Not sure if you've covered this before (I've seen so many of your videos I'm losing track), but how about a video on 'what if Magnus did nothing wrong?' Yes he did wrong, but how would the siege of terra, the heresy in general and the setting as a whole be different if he didn't screw up and wreck the webway project...? Would the wolves have been able to aid in the defence, would magnus have stayed loyal to help in the defence, how would Big E of interacted with everything, would hawkboy still be alive, preventing the black rage from happening? Sooooo many things could be different if that giant red bellend did as daddy told him

I would love a lost primarch story

Releasing the Calendar on International Women's Day is some devilishly good marketing.

a video about Rafen and Arkio would be cool, or the adventures of Rafen

Really wish the Calendar was ready before January.

I always thought it would be a Emperor made Angron clone made to cure Angron of the butchers nails. Honestly best method to cure Angron, produce a clone then transfer mind/soul into it. Such a clone being awakened and potentially empowered by the Angron soul after Angron ls descent into a demon prince would have been confused and confusing.

With the next Scoring series, eventually, GW gotta do something about it

The 5 chapters give major Suicide Squad vibes, of just "condemned" chapters fighting for good

Hello Majorkill, Would you kindly make some lore videos on the Imperial Truth, the Imperial Creed, the Ecclesiarchy? Pretty please? Thank you.

Can you possibly do a video on how space marines from StarCraft would fare against Space Marines in 40k?

I relly wuld like a 40K tv series about the false primarch. Since the primarch of the 11 legion is compleatly sencored. It wuld bee dificult to make a series featuring him. So I personally wuld love a false primarch tv series featuring one of the clones of Horus trying to redeem himself and save his fathers dream. Only to have the imperium that he himself is partially responseble fore cruating, chrush him. It wuld be interesting to more or less have the imperium as the willans.

A video suggestion: how would modern weaponry or armies fair against certain enemies or armies in 40k?

Maybe it was that surviving Thunder Warrior who collected a bunch of space marine geneseed.

Seeing Majorkill commission artists for his videos makes me so happy. He could easily do like others and use AI, but instead he supports artists to create awesome works.

Honestly from the name, I just assumed that it was that incident with Arkio and Rafen the Ready

Hi! Can you please make a video about the battle of Calth? And Titandeath? That would be cool!

I personally find the most boring option the most interesting, one expects a primarch or chaos shenannigans to be behind the war of the false primarch. hence why I find it more interesting if it's an alliance of chapters basically beginning to rebuild into a space legion and have the term primarch be pretty much the term for the chapter master that is commander in chief of this pseudo legion

MajorKill, the first person to ever have me seriously consider participating in Patreon.

Day 38 of asking for a dedicated series of videos detailing in depth the Lion El'Heresy

Though unlikely as it may be, and glad to see you also hinting at it, is that this might be the 2nd legion (at least to me). Reason being that I hold that the 11th legion are the Sons of Malice and were "destroyed" by the High Lords because "wacky extreme cannibalism" and the 2nd was destroyed because...high lord shenanigans I guess. The only other loose thread that I can think of for this being the 2nd legion is that when the high lords want a "space marine (but not chaos yet)" problem solved, the carcharadons seem to show up often (granted they are effective, but they also showed up to slap around Hurron as well in the Badab War)

Have they listed the 11 chapters that went with the False Primarch? If they are more a certain geneseed then that could hint to perhaps what Primearch it could be.