I personally think Porky got unfairly excluded from Ultimate, as every other Smash Brawl boss makes a return in some way. However, I do understand that the joke could be he's still stuck in the capsule spirit. He's such a unique character. I remember when Sora was being revealed, seeing that Ness and Lucas were near up front with Mario, thinking that it could have actually been it, but then Mario stepped off the platform with the Disney dust, lol. My bias aside, I think Ninten would be nice to fulfill the Mother 1 representation.

Hear me out: A duck hunt clone of Salsa and Boney. A truly unstoppable force.

To add to your point about the unidealness of Giygas's inclusion, bringing him down the level of a Smash fighter would be antithetical to his portrayal in the MOTHER games. The point is made that you cannot defeat him with brute force -- Maria even spells this out during the final battle. Whereas Smash is centered on victory through combat.

I think Teddy genuinely has good potential. He reps mother 1, is a non psi user and has a unique silhouette. As a non psi user and larger character he would t be another floaty zoner. He also offers a glimpse into mothers darker themes without potential spoilers. While yes he'd potentially be another sword fighter his personality would prevent him from coming off as derivative. I think people are sleeping on him.

Everyone Wants The Masked Man To Be In Smash! & They Want Ninten Too!

I cant believe nobody wanted jeff, he would have been an amazing choice, due to his machines, he could play kind of like snake, accept more goofy, and his final smash would have to be the sky runner, im sorry there is no other option

I think Paula should join. Need more Little Girl fighters in Smash. As well as Jeff the nerd character who uses guns as weapons as well as the kid who represents non psychic. paula could possibly be a 2nd clone to Ness, but i do believe she'll be the Wolf of Ness.

Thanks to Smash Ballot we know who are the most wanted, 1-Porky 2-Ninten 3-Masked Man/Claus (Claus as a Lucas Echo) 4-Kumatora

I've been wanting Porky in Smash for years as well as other mech characters like Tron Bonne and Dr. Eggman. So much moveset potential in all 3 of these characters that I can't even begin to start where to write down. Their potential is almost limitless and I wish more people in the Smash community would want mech fighters in because we don't really have them and Porky, Tron Bonne and Eggman are the best choices in my opinion.

Heh. Starman stuck in one pose. I think I suggested that one. Half-joke.

Ninten's addition would just be so perfect to complete the trilogy of protagonists, he's one of my 3 dream characters for smash (and the most realistic one... lol) I love the way PMEX Remix handled him, with him basically being a semiclone of ness but with almost no PSI moves i also have a huge soft spot for EBB...

I just love the Porky boss from Brawl. Especially after playing Mother 3, it’s just cool seeing a Mother boss fight visualized. My main complaint is that Master Porky’s theme should’ve played during the battle. If Porky were to get in, that theme has to be included! If there was another Mother 3 rep in general, I wonder how much Nintendo would risk the music, considering the music is theorized to be the main thing holding back a localization. Though, there are some tracks beyond Ultimate that don’t cross copyright laws, so I don’t think it’s a huge problem.

Paula would honestly work well as a Ness echo. I'd say Kumatora for Lucas but I think she's too tall for that

I actually have a few good ideas for Kumatora if she was playable, she would be a heavily altered version of Lucas. her grab would be different. the charged attack, instead of being a stick, would use her power gloves, she would also lean forward for it. her normal down smash, when in air, would be PK thunder, she would set down lightning right below herself. her down smash would be PK Ground instead of PK Magnet, PK ground would stun enemies in an area and make them unable to move, it'd also deal gradual damage. PK Fire is unaltered, same for PK Freeze. Her up smash would be the unused PK Teleport, having the unused animations and sending her upward. Also the normal attacks would be completely melee instead of being based on PK Love, since she doesn't learn it. edit: ALMOST FORGOT, the Final Smash would be PK Starstorm Omega, looking different from Ness' and Lucas' and dealing a bit more damage

Still feel the horribly fumbled the Porky Ultimate “joke” like if the whole joke is he’s in the capsule then why not add a pig spirit to the crafting recipe?? It just gives the vibe that they legit didn’t care about Porky and didn’t even bother to throw the most basic reference to him. Plus we should’ve had a Porky spirit and then have it be apart of the crafting process

I feel like it boils down between Porky and Ninten which I feel both deserve to be in. Ninten for representing the start of the series since without the first game you wouldn’t have the two sequels, completing the Trio of Protagonists, also the Charlie Brown side of the series. In a perfect world where Sakurai did more with Echoes, Ninten would obviously be a Ness Echo but with Buffing (like Shulk) and Debuffing PSI, he can even utilize his Boomerang and Slingshot in his attacks, and more Bat attacks than Ness, he’d have a Mewtwo-esque recovery in 4th-D Slip but I’ll stop there for Ninten. For Porky there’s a lot of possibilities as the Brawl Boss Battle has shown us and I very much agree, Porky could be a different functional mech archetype aside from Bowser Jr., and of course Smash could use more Villains, heck Kamek should be in Smash too as a Yoshi Villain, he was an important character in the Mario Movie, and Black Shadow as an F-Zero Villain that could inherit Ganondorf’s non-sword attacks assuming Ganondorf gets a True Zelda inspired move set but I’m getting off topic lol. Thanks for reading! Hopefully this inspires future videos!

Mad Taxi in Smash

I dont see Ninten enter the roster... I think he's better as a assist trophy, but I really think that Masked Man or Porky could enter, specially Porky, because he was a boss in Brawl and he is the antagonist of EarthBound and the villain of Mother 3

I would love if instead of psi magnet, Paula used the teddy bear. Kinda like toad in Peach's moveset

Honestly duster would be cool to see, especially with things like wall staples or siren beetle.

I think Mirror could work similarly to Kirby's inhale

I think you should look at the rivals of aether workshop because there are a lot of high quilty earthbound characters on there!

Look at how bro disincluded my girl Paula on the thumbnail. The disrespect smh

Either Ninten with his PMEX Remix moveset or the Masked Man

"Attack in time with music to deal extra damage!"

I know you tried picking a more creative choice in this video, but Ninten should be added to give each of the triology a representative. He could use many different PSI attacks that Ness/Lucas don't use (like PK ground, brainshock, hypnosis, teleport, and telepathy), singing, and a slingshot. Also he could use Eve as a final smash.

Duster. Idc about Rope Snake going to him and Lucas at the same time, if Ness and Lucas get elemental PSI and Starstorm we can have 2 rope snakes. Duster could grab with the wall staple, use Scary Mask or Hypno Pendulum to stun the enemy, and use his shoes in general kicking attacks for jabs/tilts/smashes

I think the next Mother character that should be in the next Smash game should only be Ninten. It'll finally close off the trilogy of Mother protagonist as fighters.

Well since Giygas in unlikely to join, I guess he is gonna be to similar to Mewtwo. I guess Mewtwo is considered the Giygas to Ness.

jeff also poo because i think it would be funny if they had to pay the announcer to say poo

I understand if people think he’s a lame choice but I want Ninten as an echo just so we have all 3 boys

Im surprised jeff isnt on this list, hes a very good protagonist for a bit and his machines give endless moveset. Maybe his final smash can have bubble monkey call tessie or smth

Thanks yet again for a shout-out Johnathan! ...... However Mr. Saturn should be #1 grrrrr. : ) EDIT: Watched later through the video. We don't take requests : )

I actually think Flint's Mother 3 skill set would be overwhelmingly conducive to Smash. Power Smash could be his neutral special and function similarly to either Donkey Kong's wind-up punch/Samus's charged shot or the homerun bat. His side special could be Swing, where he unleashes a quick barrage left and right and is invulnerable while doing so. Strengthen Up and Toughen Up could be down special; one is chosen randomly and the effects are applied until Flint is KO'd. The former would increase the power of Flint's attacks and knockback range, while the latter would decrease the damage he takes and make him harder to knock out. Up special could be him springing into the air upwards with the Drago Fang like a dragoon. It'd be hard to come up with a Final Smash, though; maybe Hinawa could appear behind a sunflower field and cause all opponents to fall asleep, which would allow Flint to finish them off with Power Smash. They made movesets for Captain Falcoln and the Duck Hunt dog---Flint would be relatively easy in comparison. Besides the adapatability of his skills, I feel that Flint's design would resonate far more with a western audience, possibly expanding the overall appeal for the Mother representation in Smash. If, say, Kumatora or Paula got in, it'd be playing it very safe by catering to the Japanese crowd, which is already well accounted for. However, it isn't just Flint's aesthetics that I like: he'd be far more interesting to have in Smash than most of his peers. Lucas and Ness use most of Paula/Kumatora's PSI and stole Starstorm from Poo. Pippi may as well be inconsequential. Teddy is completely barren of any transferrable abilities or skills and adds little to the story anyway. Loid and Jeff (espeically Jeff) would be better choices, but we already have children fighters. Duster would be another interesting pick, but I don't think his skills are quite as relevant in a game like Smash compared to Flint. If Flint wasn't cut from the main cast at the last second, he'd be the most obvious choice for the third Mother rep besides maybe the Masked Man, in my opinion.

Hmm. I'm struggling to think of any worthy mother characters that AREN'T already in Smash in some way. Like Rosalina, Samus, a bunch of the Fire Emblem characters (only in certain routes), Yoshi? (I mean he DOES lay eggs...) Oh, and Zelda.

Have you ever seen the Giygas and Kumatora mods to rivals of aether?

I'm still really dissapointed that they didn't add Porky or Giygas as spirits. And I know the Absolutely Safe Capsule is sorta Porky's spirit, but it's just not the same

The character we all want is bubble monky, hands down (also electro specter)

Why not all of them if mid emblem can get like 47 fighters then why can’t earthbound

I'm really sad Ultimate never went crazy with the Echo fighters. Like you've said, a lot of the characters would be too similar in moveset, but getting those characters in at all would be amazing, even if as an Echo Fighter. Way better than Mii fighter costumes. I think they really dropped the ball with only 7 echo fighters

but like imagine if they replaced fourside with moonside when it was in omega/battlefield eve would be an awesome assist trophy tho maybe ninten as an echo too starman would be awesome playable, like genuinly a lot of potential and porky like imagine getting shoved in the absolutely safe capsule for a final smash

I’ve always wanted kumatora

I want majority of the characters in mother 3 to be in smash. Specifically Kumatora, Boney, Duster and Flint to be in it! They honestly deserve to be in the game more than any of the none Nintendo dlc character we’ve gotten….

heres an idea: ho about we add a character called paula/kumatora since they both have some similar moves, and it would be like pyra mythra

Honestly every character in the mother series deserves to be in smash. More than Most of the dlc who aren’t from Nintendo.

My top four 1. Porky 2. Duster 3. Jeff 4. Masked Man I think they would have the most unique movesets, and while Jeff is an assist, how cool would it be to see his other tricks. For the masked man, I don’t think the spoiler thing would be an issue as long as the game doesn’t say anything (even tho they kinda did in smash 4 smh)

Was this video unlisted or something because i low-key don't remember this video in the channel before despite catching up pretty fairly with new videos. Great video though i personally would love to have Porky in Smash one day.

Please help me figure out how to download the fan translation

I feel like Ninten could work if they could make him different enough from Ness. But besides that, yeah Porky is the best choice.

Teddy needs to get into smash 😢

Honesrly Poo is my fav character hands down! I agree wifh your reasons but ive always liked Poo the best.

Duster & Anna AND FLINT, got higher than Pretty Paula, and Koolest Kumatora? Okay... yeah....SURE!

why some characters are consider a joke and others not? just because u dont like them doesnt mean they aren't as important as your literal whos

Every single one it needs to be like fire emblem

I always find it odd that "too similar" is a big deal to smash speculation from fans when the devs keep proving game after game how little they care about that ever since making Ganondorf a Falcon clone lmao. I get it because as players, uniqueness is something we should want, but is that an actual priority for decision making? For example they could have picked Azura instead of Corrin because she would have been much more unique, but they didn't care, Elma instead of Aegis, Edelgard instead of Byleth etc. While movesets are the bread and butter of the game, it seems that character importance is always the top priority above everything else. The biggest proof of this is how characters like Sonic still have weirdly unrepresentative movesets that are criticized, but it doesn't matter to Nintendo, they just care that Sonic is there. Unique playstyles only become important when the character is for sale as DLC, this is why I'm sure MinMin was made DLC instead of base game, it seemed odd to us fans, but to the company it made perfect sense. That said I think Ninten and Giegue "Echoes" would be a very smart idea as a way to throw a bone to a franchise they don't want to take up a "big slot" down the line. Porky is the most unique dream come true choice, but there's one thing I personally think would be a problem in his way. Due to his unique mech playstyle I'm sure he would 100% be DLC, but if he's competing for that Mech DLC slot, Dr. Eggman is almost assured to have the absolute greatest chance of taking that spot. Almost a lock honestly. But fingers crossed for both of them of course I'm just trying to be realistic. Eggman is just unbeatable competition.

Dude where’s Mapson?? I really wanted him

Duster, no debate

Paula gets a higher place than Kumatora because it would be hilarious to see a little girl in a pink dress using a frying pan as a smash attack.

if smash bros was good they would cut every fire emblem character and put mothere characters there instead......... also postal dude would be in the game (JOKE) also, since you used that one clip of chapter 7: i think an interesting video idea to make would be about why they don't just pull the needle in tanetane island in mother 3 and wait so long, because it's a really odd cutscene to me

I think Po would be perfect for smash!

A non PSI character like Jeff or Duster

what about eve??

PIPPI FOR SMASH 6 DLC!!!

Personally my number one pick is Ninten He just seems like the most logical choice

erm actually mr saturn should be added

Ninten not even on the list? Edit: Aight

NINTEN

Flint.