You have an amazing comprehension of this story. I love your explanation. Yes, this should be shown in all school, religious institutions, etc. My favorite Dimash song.

Ma che canzone rega!!!! Vincitore del popolo!!!! ❤‍🔥There's no going back!!! Woao!!!!!🔥

ti suggerisco di vedere la versione live di questa canzone. la migliore versione è la fan cam vietnamese,incredibile. la migliore performance di tutti i tempi,batte pure la live dei queen a wembley ed è tutto dire

Felicidades! Pocos reactores han interpretado tan bien el video! Tiene muchos simbolismos, Dimash es sumamente inteligente, sus trabajos no son fáciles y son de gran calidad! Este video me hizo llorar cuando lo vi, y admiré más a Dimash! Debes ver la presentación en vivo en su concierto en Almaty! Prácticamente dejó su alma en la actuación! Es increíble! Ojalá lo veas! Gracias por tu reacción! Saludos desde México! 🇲🇽❤️💕🇲🇽❤️💕🇲🇽❤️💕

Capo,lavoro.Paolo.Calido abrazo desde URUGUAY 🎉❤

Ora, vi suggerisco di guardare la sua esibizione dal vivo al concerto di Almaty, dove un Dimash assolutamente intriso del suo ruolo, dona la sua anima e il suo corpo per la pace. Oggettivamente non ho mai visto un'esibizione dal vivo con così tanta potenza. Devi vederlo ...

Gracias por reaccionar a ésta obra maestra de nuestro querido Dimash!!!Un video con muchos simbolismos y un gran mensaje.Saludos desde Argentina 👋👋🇦🇷

⚡⚡🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥⚡⚡

Thank you. I have subscribed for more Pentatonix. You should react to Oh Holy Night or Kissed From a Rose next.

The Story of one sky ...... Live concert Almaty--- fan video kzfaq.info/get/bejne/sLCbh8uIz7Wvdpc.htmlsi=AS1XyxRL78ftnvyS

Grazie hai fatto un’analisi molto intelligente e chiara. Per favore 🙏 fai la versione live , sono certo che ti piacerà molto. La trovi sul suo canale: Almaty concert , terza parte minuto 25 . Grazie 🇮🇹❤️🇰🇿

exelente reaccion , te felicito , todo muy ilustrado , sos muy inteligente , abrazo desde uruguay

Ti avevo detto che questo brano era importante ed è nota la battaglia di Dimash contro la guerra.Ti consiglio War and peace versione live cantata a Kiev dell' arnau tour complimenti per la tua reaction

WINNER ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Dalla terza parte del concerto Almaty, dalla sua pagina ufficiale KZfaq,al 25,28 minuti

Ascolta la versione dal vivo quando l'ha presentata la prima volta tratta dal concerto di Almaty, è scioccante

Thany you for your reaction. Dimash is amazing.yes we choosing life.peace from Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸

First place!👏👏👏❤️🙏from 🇮🇱

Nulla da obietare per me si meritava di piu puodarsi che ha sbagliato vestirsi pero ragazzi macchio e macchio 😂😂😂😂 non ce la gonna

Thank you for the sincere reaction & excellent analysis! This is a monumental work, a true masterpiece in any way. Greetings from Finland:)

👍посмотрите эту песню на концерте Алматы, официальную версию

Bellissimo e profondo,il dolore per la morte della figlia ,uccide ma viene ucciso,morte porta morte ...

bonjour j apprécie toujours vos commentaires sous tous les aspects du clip video clair , .précis . je voudrais vous soumettre de regarder le la même chanson analysée comme vous par "le Professor Georgievsky" qui a une analyse proche de la votre avec quelques éléments qui devraient vous intéresser. compliments pour vos commentaires.

Paolo, muchas gracias por tu reacción. Con este video descubrí a Dimash, y me atrapó. Siendo aún un joven es impresionante su talento, su capacidad artística que tiene y el mensaje tan profundo. También su equipo es asombroso, y tu reacción es sensacional. Muchas gracias! y sigamos disfrutando a este gran artista

Thanks for your reaction to this masterpiece 💕💕💕🙏🙏🙏 I am enclosing a deep and knowledgeable analysis by Heiderose Kober that you might appreciate : « This is subtitled "Requiem” but it is also a vision and a call to action. Dimash is steeped in sacred music and has a deep understanding of the mystic teachings and symbolism of the major world religions as well as Kazakh shamanism. It is not by coincidence that the first performance of this work took place on September 14, 2022, at the Congress of Leaders of World and Traditional Religions in Kazakhstan. The written statement at the end of the video is directly from the “Document on Human Fraternity for World Peace and Living Together” signed jointly on February 4, 2019, by Pope Francis and the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar, Ahmad el-Tayeb. Dimash met and spoke with both men at the September meeting. Everything Dimash does is intentional, and this piece has layers that would take a dissertation to unravel. I only touch on some of what struck me in the symbolism. The music is a dissertation all by itself. The pendant is an interesting element. It is a gnomon from a maritime compass sundial. This triangular blade is attached to the sundial, casting a shadow on the sundial while the perforated pinhole projects the image of the sun onto the dial. It was used for both timekeeping and navigation, with the gnomon oriented to True North. (Thank you, Snarky Tart for that information). In the MV, the child who later becomes the military commander never puts on the necklace. After Dimash, the boy, gives his friend the pendant, the camera focuses on his hand and shows that his friend has bent the gnomon in anger over being rejected by the girl. Thus bent, it can never be oriented to True North, and he has lost his moral compass. Later, we see a version of the gnomon as the military insignia on the uniforms of the commander and his soldiers, but distorted and without the hole that allows light to shine through rendering it useless as a compass. When we lose the original intent of a symbol by twisting it into something it is not or by just paying lip service, it no longer has any spiritual meaning. At best it becomes a useless prop, at worst it is used to mislead and manipulate people. Contemporary music is also present: With the phrase "We have passed the moment of Imagine," Dimash reminds us that we are past the sentiments evoked by the song "Imagine" by John Lennon. It is time to stop dreaming about a world of peace and harmony. If we choose life, if we wish for peace, if we want a world without war for our children and grandchildren, we must act and take up the long hard path up the mountain towards the light. It is the only way. The storyline is a very human one: we start as innocents until our hearts are broken, we fail, or our dreams are not realized. If in our pain and disappointment, we turn to anger and blame instead of acceptance, power instead of love, greed and envy instead of generosity, hatred instead of forgiveness, and revenge instead of justice, we sow the seeds for conflicts that can turn into war. The Piper's call is seductive as it promises redress for our grievances, control over our circumstances, and power over those who thwarted us, and this appeals to our wounded ego. However, let's remember that the Piper is a symbolic figure of Death from the Middle Ages, often used as a metaphor for trusting and following charismatic but dangerous and malevolent leaders to certain death. Even if we resist, as the adult Dimash character does, we often employ the same methods and weaponry as the Piper, and thus those who fight back betray peace as well because peace cannot be won through violence. That is the dilemma of those of us who did not start the war, who do not support the war, but are forced to respond in order to defend ourselves and those we love. How can we rid the world of evil without becoming what we fight against? The burning sign "Waldenberg" is a reference to the end of WWII when the US Army destroyed the last of the resistance by the German Wehrmacht close to the end of the war in April 1945 in the part of Germany where I grew up. I have seen the aftermath of war as I was born a few years later when much of Germany was still in rubble. Waldenburg is only 28 miles from my hometown and was completely destroyed as you can see from the picture. Many of the dead in those bombed-out buildings were women and children. The good guys defeated evil but at what price? War is not the answer. We must find better ways to keep evil in check. iowaculture.gov/history/education/educator-resources/primary-source-sets/world-war-ii/american-troops-move-through The last movement is powerful: The cries over the loss of a beloved child and the cries of giving birth to new life are presented as a call-and-response grounded by a powerful Om chant that creates a sacred space, reminding us that death and birth are both sacraments and are interwoven in the tapestry of life. Dimash's vocalization and the pilgrims representing world religions and religious leaders, past and present, walking together shift the narrative toward the final conflict and finally redemption. When Dimash’s character decides to avenge the murder of his daughter, his state of consciousness is reflected in the darkening sky with lightning bolts of anger accompanying the storm of his emotions that buffets the pilgrims and hinder progress. The fog of war obscures the light. When he is killed after exacting retribution, he is dropped back into the "sacred womb" of Earth, the ocean of love and mercy, and is cleansed of the old hatreds and grievances that only bring more death and suffering. He breaks the wheel of endless war and suffering by choosing life. Dimash's scream of “we’re choosing life” is that of giving birth: the old earthly consciousness of an eye for an eye has to die to make way for a new spiritual consciousness that embraces all life. Soul is breaking free to return to its natural state of love and purity as exemplified by the images of the children and the newborn baby. The blowing of the shofar signals God's mercy for humankind when it turns from wrong to right: in the Zohar, the book of Jewish mysticism, it says: “When human beings repent of their sins, they blow the shofar on earth. Its sound ascends On High and awakens the heavenly shofar, and so mercy is aroused and judgment is removed.” Reborn as a leader for peace and love, Dimash's character in the form of his son becomes a spiritual guide for all of mankind on our shared journey up the mountain towards the light of God, however we may interpret or name the divine. We are all on the same path, even if our personal narratives, cultural heritage, race, and spiritual orientations are very different from one another. By focusing on our common destination rather than on our differences, we can walk together in peace and love and mutual respect. Carl Jung wrote: “Knowing your own darkness is the best method for dealing with the darknesses of other people. One does not become enlightened by imagining figures of light, but by making the darkness conscious. The most terrifying thing is to accept oneself completely. Your visions will become clear only when you can look into your own heart. Who looks outside, dreams; who looks inside, awakes.” This is what Dimash has done with this work; he has made the darkness conscious. We can only raise our individual and collective consciousness by bringing to light what needs to be healed in our lives and our world, and then we need to work together to restore wholeness to what is broken and bring about peace and unity, one step at a time. We don’t have to wait. We can start right now. As the hymn tells us: "Let there peace in the world, and let it begin with me." Baraka Bashad. »

Thank you for your beautiful reaction to Dimash's masterpiece, The Story of One Sky.

Grazie per la tua reazione e analisi così profonda di questo capolavoro. Questo è un lavoro molto potente dal punto di vista emotivo e fin dall’inizio non potevo immaginare come avresti potuto abbracciare tutto in una volta. Il significato di ciò che sta accadendo, grazie all'esperienza e all'osservazione, era a tua disposizione, sono contento. Tuttavia, anche l’accessibilità testuale è importante; guarda il video con i sottotitoli. È importante. Con questo video Dimash ci svela la sua missione in questo mondo... Спасибо за Ваши такие глубокие реакцию и анализ данного шедевра. Это очень эмоционально сильная работа, и я с самого начала не представляла, как Вы сможете все разом объять. Смысл происходящего, благодаря опыту и наблюдательности, Вам оказался доступен, я рада. И все-таки текстовая доступность тоже важна, посмотрите видео с субтитрами. Это важно. Этим видео Димаш приоткрывает нам свою миссию в этом мире...

Реакции респект!!! Фильм Димаша пробивает насквозь!!! И смотреть его нужно всем!!! Это его посыл всемв миру!!! ДИМАШ, БРАВО!!!!!!!! РОССИЯ. СИБИРЬ.😊

I have to tell you, your reaction is one of the very best I've heard. Thank you for clearly loving Pentaonix. I will be subscribing.

Wow! Vídeo espetacular, Intenso e profundo! Uma obra prima completa! Música simplesmente extraordinária do nosso Príncipe Dimash! Letra emocionante e incrível com uma grande mensagem para humanidade! Orquestra e instrumentos tradicionais incríveis! Dimash simplesmente extraordinário e repleto de emoção! Transcendental! Incrível! Dimash é um cantor magnífico, um roterista espetacular e um ator fantástico! We choose Live! PEACE! 🕊🕊 👏👏🏿👏🏿👏🏼👏🏾👏🏽👏🏽👏🏻🎶🎶♥️♥️🇧🇷🇧🇷

The video took 4 months, the music took three years,

Hello Paolo! Thank you for your sincere reaction, you understood the story line remarkly well, I completely agree! When I first watched this MV, it broke me, I became very emotional, it was heart wrenching, to say the least! I'm sure you have noticed that Dimash is the main solder right from the very beginning of the war scene, when he was walking under the overpass, also when he was shot in the arm, many people miss that? Dimash has worked very hard for 3 years composing the music for this song, and around 20 days to make this MV. It turned out to be his most valuable MV, in the ideological sense, ever made, a real Masterpiece! I believe that Dimash deserves THE NOBEL PEACE PRIZE for his selfless hard work and tireless efforts, not only for this MV, but for trying to bring the world together in love, peace, and harmony and through his many charities. He is a Legend in the making and will go down in History. This is my breakdown of the story, as I see it: This mini movie is full of symbolisms, it's the story of 3 youths, and the necklace which was created by the young Dimash and shared with his friends symbolizing lifelong friendship and unity. The boys both loved the same girl, but she loved Dimash, so the other boy grew resentful over time, started a war, using the symbol of the necklace given to him by his friend Dimash, as the crest on his army uniform. 1) Dimash, was the boy drowning at the beginning and at the end. 2) The Piper, is the one who saved Dimash, became the leader, and was killed by Dimash at the end. 3) The young girl, who died in childbirth, became Dimash’s future wife, had two children together; a daughter who was killed by the Piper's army; and the birth of a son who inherited the necklace from his mother…, they were all affected by the war. “People are the caravan…. Life is the way”: Dimash spoke these words in Kazakh, when he found his daughter dead. For the symbolic aspects, Dimash is showing the different cultures and religions (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hindi, etc.), through throat singing, which is called the REQUIEM (mass for the souls of the dead), from different religions. The Pilgrim or (Shepard or a Wise Man) at the end of the video was Dimash’s baby boy, born in his image and grows up to guide the Representatives of different religions and race from different Nations to the light, for a new beginning living together in peace, tolerance, love, and harmony. I’M CHOSING LIFE!! 🙏🙏 See you in your next reaction. Love from Canada 🥰

Paolo you are crazy !!!

TRUE WINNER 2024 !! BRAVO CROATIE!!!!

CROATIE WINNER 2024!!!

Thank you so much! Such a good reaction too!😊

Congratulazioni per la reazione! Bene, alcune considerazioni: (1) Dimash ha composto la canzone e ha partecipato all'arrangiamento, oltre a recitare nel mini-film. Il testo della canzone e della poetessa russa Lilia Vinogradova e la regia video di Alina Veripya! (2) Il manufatto che il ragazzo ha ritrovato nella cassa e che è stato trasformato in collane è uno "gnomone", un ago per meridiana (un dispositivo rustico per segnare il tempo); (3) Il nome "Piper" (pifferaio o suonatore di cornamusa) è noto come sinonimo di "dittatore", "despota": trae origine dal racconto del "Pifferaio magico di Hamelin" (racconto popolare riscritto dai fratelli Grim), dove un suonatore di cornamusa venne assunto per far fronte all'infestazione di topi della città di Hamelin (Germania, 1284). Dopo aver ipnotizzato i ratti con il suo flauto magico e averli annegati nel Weser, l'artista andò a riscuotere la somma dovuta (una moneta a testa) e non fu pagato (sostenevano che non avesse presentato le "teste" dei ratti). Quindi ipnotizzò centotrenta bambini della città di Hamelin e li rinchiuse in una grotta. Sì, beh, il "pifferaio magico" (chiamato anche "acchiappatopi") è diventato sinonimo del tiranno che usa un linguaggio ipnotizzante e conduce alla morte! (4) Il termine "Imagine" si riferisce all'omonima canzone di John Lennon; (5) Il testo finale fa parte del documento generato al Congresso dei leader religiosi mondiali del 2019 e della musica presentata al VII Congresso dei leader delle religioni mondiali e tradizionali, tenutosi a Nur-Sultan (Kazakistan) il 14/09/2022 e caratterizzato dalla presenza di Papa Francesco, in rappresentanza della Chiesa cattolica e che ha consegnato a Dimash, per l'occasione, una medaglia di gratitudine.

Presento esta canción en el concierto de Almaty días antes de lanzar el video. Exactamente igual en directo, poderosa voz, los melismas, la distorsión a voz frita, impresionante y poderosa. No hay nada igual que yo haya escuchado. Efectivamente este video tendría que estar más difundido. Excelente análisis Paolo Muchas Gracias 🎻🎺🇪🇸

Maggiori dettagli sul film: (1) I due ragazzi gareggiavano per attirare l'attenzione della ragazza; (2) Il personaggio (che Dimash rappresenta da adulto) ha creato un simbolo per confermare l'amicizia tra i tre, dopo essere stato salvato dal suo amico; (3) Sempre nel video vediamo la ragazza scegliere "Dimash" e poi si sposano e hanno la bambina (che è stata uccisa) come figlia e la madre è incinta di un altro maschio; (4) Il ragazzo più grande (che ha salvato "Dimash" dall'annegamento) non accetta di essere abbandonato dalla ragazza e diventa un presidente/generale dittatore; (5) Dimash diventa un soldato che decide di tornare dal combattimento per proteggere la sua famiglia di rifugiati di guerra; (6) Dimash trova sua figlia morta e pensa che anche sua moglie sia morta, quindi decide di vendicarsi del suo amico; (7) Uccide il dittatore e viene ucciso rimpiangendo le violenze commesse in vita; (8) La moglie di Dimash è ben accolta da persone di diverse religioni che concordano sul fatto che il figlio di Dimash è una persona speciale; (9) La moglie muore di parto e il figlio di Dimash diventa un leader che guida i rifugiati verso un luogo migliore di tolleranza, rispetto e accettazione.

excellent analysis, thank you

Don,t shit

Ajd ne seri covjece

Bellissima analisi. Ascoltalo dal vivo, è impressionante. Realmente impressionante perché non puoi credere che dopo ore di concerto lui abbia la forza vocale e fisica di... Bellissima analisi, ribadisco. Grazie

Hola !Nuevamente con usted porque Dimash es mi hacedor de suspiros,sueños, amor y felicidad Costa Rica 🇨🇷

Beautiful and precise understanding of the video and the message it bears!❤ thank you🥰 love and peace

En realidad Dimash lo que defiende es el diálogo en lugar del enfrentamiento. La guerra desencadena un conjunto de bajas pasiones. El rencor. La venganza. Esto se evita con el amor y la fraternidad. Termina con esos gritos desgarradores. Nosotros elegimos la vida..saludos

Sei l'unico che ha colto il significato della storia di primo acchito.Non solo.....estremamente arguto nel dare un significato ai dettagli.Grazie.Ti isuggerisco la versione live. A me sembrava impossibe potesse replicare fedelmente,e invece....si supera.Questo è il link kzfaq.info/get/bejne/f65nm8uE3Jynlok.html

This was an excellent analysis. You understood the story line and the characters, and the message he tries to bring (relentlessly, in all his performances and in everything he does), and you noticed all the exceptional vocal moments. Hats off to you sir!

Спасибо,прекрасная умная реакция.Всегда приятно смотреть ваши профессиональные реакции.❤❤❤

Thank you for sharing this with us!