So many important topics were not touched on, funds parked outside of Pakistan r being taxed there, yet ppl park it there and not in Pakistan....y ? Bcz Pakistan is unsafe, Pakistan is in the hands of foj and they r the most uncouth elements of this god forsaken land. Secondly, u don't get anything in return for ur taxes, no medical facilities, no safety, no security, in fact the state of Pakistan is the biggest enemy of the ppl of Pakistan.....ur life, honor and property r all at risk at the hands of this state. Thirdly, the FBR ppl, the army ppl, the politicians all parking there money out side of Pakistan, y then anyone else wld not......the state of Pakistan itself is the biggest criminal. This is the crux of the matter but ofcourse Zaidi was unable to touch on that and no one else wld either for the fear of reprisal from the state.....u c this is what this state is and this is the reason y u have to leave asap !

We can make friends ship with ifghan

Japan, South Korea defense expenditure was only 0.8% of GDP. Given Pakistan does not have luxury of IT exports, they have to cut defense expenditure which is a drag on the economy. Also it will help India to reduce defense expenditure

Thanks Allah for giving guidance to generals who continue to loot billions of dollars from chutiya awam

AND DO NOT DELETE MY COMMENTS.

JI HIND.

ONE OF THE PROMINENT "LIAR SHIA" AMONG "HONEST URDU SPEAKERS", IMPORTED BY TRAITOR JINNAH. SHUT UP.

HE NEEDS BONE, THIS IS THE REASON THIS CORRUPT URDU SPEAKER IS BARKING.

He should talk about those assets which has been given to officers by law...and those assets are more then what we have in other countries 😂

Shabar zaidi is the most chechora person of pakistan… hos chehora pan is very mush like punjab mindset

Shabar Bahi you are right ✅️ ALLAH bless you 🌹

Fazal e Haq for drug trafficking was the man,

Debating club of elite . All gab management. Disconnected with the masses . Representatives of interests groups.

No amnesty was given in India in 2018. The last amnesty was given during the UPA Govt.

Shaubber Zaidi sb! Ten provinces who would constitute? Kyani, and Bajwa sb etc despite service extension could not done the desirous conceptualized jurisdictions.

Where did the young generation of Pakistan go? At least the host must be young, and why is this in English language, when 97% of Pakistanis don't know / speak English. Thank you

I see actual issue is Intelectual corruption; janab now humonoid robots autonomous can accurately do the all job tasks. Its simple solution is campanion humonoid robots do not recognise and characterised the influencers, leaders and haves hence no-corrupt practices would be happen.

I agree with Shabbat Zaidi’s point regarding non-filers. In Canada, if you don’t file your tax return the government sends an immediate court order to all financial institutions stating your tax liability and asks them to immediately send money from your accounts, investments, etc. to the govt to settle the tax liability. If there are any refunds or incorrect calculation of tax amount, you can claim it by filing the tax with the government.

Alternate hypothesized. Nonfilers are thieves their leakages ceased by track and trace of Mekanzie due to untax money of other service men not empolyee; term coined by Sharif. Job opportunities would be losened; the next age is humanoid robot would transformitive of teachers, labors force and service men by large due to AGI technologies.

koch yahya khan ka qaumi teraana........pak sar zameen ka nizaam.. lootmaari dakaithi iska kaam... qaum molk sab Lunnd pay chard, paae paae qarzdaar saai ghaddaarou tabbah haal... BhairNdh chodai yey saaray sobha shaaam... behri goongi hai yey choothiya awaaam....qaum molk sab Lunnd pay chard, paae paae qarzdaar saai ghaddaarou tabbah haal.

I am righting an article on pak economy what is the problem how we went in debt and how we can get out from it

Finding individuals of integrity in the politics, bureaucracy, judiciary, and army within interior sindh and punjab is like looking for a virgin in a whore house.

If we aspire to enact significant reforms, it is imperative to dismantle the existing business empire of the Punjab army and armed forces and establish a new one characterized by a majority of Urdu-speaking, Gilgiti, Pashtun, and Baloch individuals, with a limited representation of Punjabis. The overwhelming influence of Punjabis/Sindhis in every sector poses a considerable security risk. Our economy thrived when Karachi served as the capital. However, the moment the Punjab army unlawfully shifted the capital from Karachi to Punjab, a downward spiral commenced. After over 50 years of Punjabi/Sindhi dominance, we find ourselves on the brink of collapse in a defaulted state. Punjabis/Sindhis should not be permitted to persist in its control, as it has proven to be a catastrophic force over the past five decades.

The corrupt Punjab army has truly shown its true colors once again, Dumping these PPP scumbags onto Karachiites purely to reap illicit gains. In a recent move, DHA has ordered 5000 acres of land in Hawks Bay, with Murad Ali Shah directing the revenue board to allocate it. The last clean seashores we enjoyed will now be plagued, transforming into yet another Phase 8-style open sewage drain system. Bravo!

You might not agree with Shabir Zaidi, at least he has the courage and insight to speak .

This foolish person hadn't done anything good for Pakistan while in FBR and in government. Now, after retirement, he is b.....g! It doesn't mean that a Pakistani was born to keep money in Pakistan. If business conditions and Return on Investment (ROI) are not alluring to Pakistan Businessmen then he has the full right to move money to a better place. Instead of focusing on making the business environment better for investors, these foolish persons are still aiming at others' legitimate income and assets (This is the similar approach of Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto --- who Nationalized Businessmen's Assets and now Pakistan feels the RESULTS --- NO BUSINESS IN PAKISTAN). Just ignore these foolish mad people and start changing the approach for a better environment for the Business Community! Remember, the Businessmen Community is like a bird --- once feared --- never return!

Former Pak General Kayani has property in Australia, Musharaf has property in Dubai. All Pak Generals are thief.

Settle the assets that don’t have a money trail against the loans!! Simple

These are the most depressing and sickly people ive seen in my life. Straight out of an ICU

شبر زیدی صاحب نے کبھی نئے انڈسٹری زونز کی بات نہیں کی، جب تک انڈسٹری نہیں لگے گی تو اس وقت تک ایکسپورٹ نہیں بڑھی گی۔

Not only in Dubai....All over the world billion dollars invest there....

اس کرپٹ سسٹم کو ہمارے ادارے اور سسٹم خود چلا رہے ہے۔ ادارے اور سسٹم منی لانڈرنگ میں ملوث ہے۔ تو یہ سب کون ٹھیک کرے گا؟

ایکسپورٹر، لیبر کے پیشے اس سلسلے میں منی لانڈرنگ میں استعمال ہو رہے ہیں۔

ڈالر باہر اس لئے نہیں گیا تھا یا ہے یہ باہر واپسی کے لئے نہیں گیا۔

Offshore Assets And Money is black money and corruption money.

Property, Business, Life is not safe in Pakistan. When judiciary protecting the corruption and protect the corrupt bureaucracy, protect the mafia, protect the corrupt Generals, protects the corrupt system.

Very informstive and useful presentation by the three distinguished speakers. Yes we have very capable and intelligent people who have the capacity to dive deep down and identify the real problems in our system. But it is always the state machinery ( includes politicians and bureaucracy) who can practically implement a change in the system. Unless they have a resolve to do it, nothing will change. I am sorry but I do not find such an awareness or resolve in them to address the present system .

Bheek mang bhikaristanio 😂😂

Laura lega Kashmir ke badle 😂😂

Very respected teacher Dr Muazzam khattak at Quaid e Azam university . We are so happy that we got to learn from you. May you have the opportunity to mentor many more students.

Why is this in the English language when 99.99% people of Pakistan don't understand or speak English ? It makes no sense at all. Thank you

There is no objective observational evidence that we are living in a global climate crisis.

Kitna hiduphobia hai in pakiyo me.

Kashmir ka rr abhi Tak chalu hai.

i wish we had people like javaid jabbar who would have been better prime ministers ,academics and genius,who could have built a better narion.

i wish pakistan could produce more javaid jabbar.he is remarkable

in future pakistan case study will be studied how army destroyed nation

DR Bengali is far superior in his critical analysis. next is Zaidi & then come others. Good discussions & informative. Thanks. PK is doomed already. No way out AT ALL!

हीसा हला 😂 दला तला 😂 🕉️🚩🇮🇳❤️

Looking back in 2024, the questions raised by Mr. Bengali remain important questions. Is Chinese project beneficial to Pakistan?