Согласен полностью, цирковой номер, а не Бах.

Excuse me, but your comment is too harsh considering that this piece must have been written for harpsichord, not the piano (there was no piano as we know it now, in Bach's time), and so this whole arrangement is a bit of an experiment. I think it was a bold and worthy one.

@@victoriainhongkong È vero senz'altro e ben capisco il tuo punto di vista..! La mia asserzione però é data solo come un audiofilo che ama il rispetto, la forma, ed i "colori" originali dei brani. Di recente avevo perfino sentito la celebre "Toccata e fuga in Rem" di Bach eseguita da una chitarra......! Orribile....!

Я думаю, что фортепиано и струнный оркестр победили.

Magistral interpretación por parte de la solista

The Adagio (2nd movement) is an original from 1903. Only the 4th movement with a soprano voice was composed by my great-great-aunt in 1942. See also the complete symphony with all 4 movements. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/qJmPrNVjvq7IYKs.html

@@Klavicus Thanks! Does that mean that the original symphony have a different Fourth Movement, or that there wasn't one at all before 1942? By the way, this symphony is just gorgeous - it's weird that it hasn't really got much traction sofar.

@@bomcabedal my great-grandaunt Mathilde composed the symphony in 1903 and sent the sheet music to a competition in Prog. Unfortunately, the symphony was never performed during Mathilde's lifetime. She had never heard them. I can't say exactly whether she only composed the fourth movement in 1942. I guess -yes- because she was already old and sick. She was a strict Catholic and believed in God. In the lyrics of her hymn she describes her impending death as passing through a great gate into eternity. Please send me your email address and I will send you the text in the original German and English translation.

No, the piece was not designed by Silvia Spinnato, but by the conductor Finnegan Downie Dear. By the way, the composer Mathilde was my great-grand aunt. See also my webside: www.Kralikklassik.de

@@Klavicus Thank you. Apparently, the piece will be played on 1 and 6 March of next year in Cottbus.

The concert is not in March, but on June 21st and 23rd at the Cottbus State Theater. Look here: www.staatstheater-cottbus.de/programm/philharmonisches-konzert/8-philharmonisches-konzert/

@@Klavicus My mistake, I got it confused with another concert. Thanks for the correction.

Hi Ken Ward. Thanks for answer. Mathilde is my great-great aunt. Here I upload from Eduard Hanslick on the year 1880 to this TRIO from Mathilde. I hope, you can translate this in english. : Wien, Neue Freie Presse, 17. März 1880. (Eduard Hanslick.) Gleich die erste Nummer war eine Rarität: »Trio« von Mathilde von Kralik. Denn sind komponierende Damen überhaupt nicht häufig, so gehören solche, die über das Lied hinaus sich an größere, schwierigere Formen wagen, zu den größten Seltenheiten. Fräulein Kraliks Trio verrät ein entschiedenes Talent von auffallend männlichem Charakter, der sich in trotzigen Motiven, in gewagten Modulationen wohl fühlt und fast ängstlich allem bloß Tändelnden oder Schmachtenden aus dem Wege geht.’