100% agree.

Beautifully said by EVH!

As a Brit we celebrate "less is more!"

Well said

Very well said!

max haokip 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

My Favorite Song Of All Time. This REALLY Does Take Me Back To The 70,s

Maureen Brown your generation had the best bands ever. It must have been such a privilege to witness these musicians live

Go dad 🤣🤣🤣

Max, you're dad is absolutely in the right!

Makes me cry with the fender. My leaving song if you know me you'll know what it means to me

I'm 75 and I agree 😊

Anche io la penso come te ciao coscritto

Even Mozart, Beethoven, Bach, Paganini get on their knees when they lissen this..............

Me too. Simply the greatest version of the greatest rock ballad ever gifted to the world.

💯

the first one is great second one is overrated

I’ve never disagreed more in my life. Do we have the same ears?

Probably not, mine are human.@@dereksiegel255

THE BEST GUITAR SOLO.....EVER !!!!

how could you not be , this is the best solo ever made ever

It seemed to me that I was the ONLY ONE who got on this! I was buzzing off him. I don't see how that isn't the most noticeable thing about this video, after the amazing rendition by David Gilmour (in a league of his own I believe. The man is early 70's here cool as ya like, no bouncing about giving it ego as most) I had to bring it to every person's attention I've watched it with. As one post here says yea look who he's playing with. I said that smile is him saying"WOW I'm Drumming with DAVID GILMOUR...!!!!! Soon as I seen him. Love this version

Looks to me like David's having a high time too. Not so many grinnings but plenty of picking!

Maybe he is! ... Who knows? 😂

Si yo estuviese allí, también lo estaría.

Is

It is

Kaleb Krail it is

It absolutely is!!!

I second that view, it's amazing - god like.

☝️

Here on St Pat's 2024. Still outstanding even w/o Roger Waters.

I was at Pompei last week (March, 2024). They have photos of first Pink's gig.

I am

❤

Brilliant comment

❤

That's fucking cynistic. But it's brilliant. :-)

Man 1972 Floyd concert!!

lmfao

Hair standing up on my arms every time

I could watch this every day all day and still die a happy man. After I got sober, 13 years ago, it took me awhile to get back to Pink Floyd. Now I have much better appreciation for their work. Hell, I still listen to Radio K.A.O.S. from Roger Waters.

exactly!

Ahem to that. ☺

It makes my heart happy to know so many appreciate this music.

U r not alone ma dear I'm here by ya side were pinkflyod is.luf from manipur kuki.

Always listening

And to think that we can watch/rewatch this at our leisure. What luxury.

We all are let’s hope Roger and David make a pact soon!

Me, Flávio. From Santa Catarina, South of Brazil.

Wish I could feel that Good.!music is Magic. When they put everything in, it and then some 🤗

I'd be honored if David Gilmour fans would take a listen to my piano & vocal performances of WISH YOU WERE HERE and SLIT SKIRTS by Pete Townshend on my YT channel in tribute to the masters of lyricism and composition. Done live with no autotune or digital editing. Thanks and peace.

Goddamn that gives the chills to tears every time . Theres something ethereal to this

the best solo i ever heard, its touches the soul, gives goosebumps

You are right and it feels good to hear David Gilmour play guitar. He is one the best Rock Guitarist on our planet.

On my option, this should be somehow 120% or more on guitar part. ;-)

I’ve heard both 👍

Yes indeed 😊 FINE WINE 😍

Seriously insanely talented

@Mind Control Experiments lol

what did you fight for?

kaan yeşildal i’d be happy to just be one of the dancers on stage with a legend 😂

So would I if I had the chance

I agree

I would breath my last

His in heaven

🤣❤👍

😂😂😂

😅

I vote this one as best comment.

sick!!😂

Maybe some of them aren’t….🧚‍♂

I totally agree

Same as live8 not a note out of place the whole set, never be matched will Floyd.

Damn Straight!!!

I hear you brother

Yes Gilmour is one of the best a Legend.

David ❤

Oh 2zh6ñ

History not needed.

Counterpoint: The time solo

Was = is....

I have asked my self .what song can you listen to for internty ??? It's comfortably numb.i don't think it's the greatest David Gilmours best solo but is the context of the song .it's truely the greatest mean .he's like Michael Angelo with a 🎸

Yes

so true

I don’t have one, but I like the song lol

@@hugowaltner1677 it was late when i listened you feel this energy

Patrick Sautron what is that supposed to mean ? I’m confused.

Said it all.

@michael lee I am LoL beyond my control and I thank you for that😂😅🤣🤓🤓

My dude so do you

ah you men of culture!

8=======D

You too friend.

@@jordiduran4499 gey

I never saw a drummer having so much fun, and i've seen some pretty high times up there on the stage.

It looked like he was getting tired at the end lol

YEAH he was eating it up

Nick Mason..... 👏

@@melmayhem6001 Nope

True that 💯

His voice isn’t bad either.

I am getting a guitar because of this man

That's because you know what's comin'!

Marcus Jahnke oh hell ya hes got a killer voice

yes!!

Eugenio Garrido my thoughts exactly!!

I have seen this live multiple times and await it again

I just hope selling some of his guitars doesn't mean that he will not tour again. It would make sense tho.😫

I would die the happiest man of all time if I could ever witness such greatness

He's got a naturally "smiley" face, but most of the time it really does look like he's thinking "THIS CANNOT BE MORE AWESOME!!"

Ist auch meine Lieblingsstelle😊❤

He knows he is in the presence of greatness.

And then some Ernest!!!

It is THE greatest

You mean the Universe .

Totally amazing always listening to it

Yep

your father was a... smart man!!

Totally agree !

I love it, amazing just💐

A wise man preach.

can`t say blame him

And what an amazing tribute this is!

So sorry for loss x

I'm sorry for your loss.

I'm so sorry my friend... RIP

Rest in peace

ain't that the truth

A gift as it is!

Max Murphy Amen brother!👍👊✌️

I like em especially after smoking weed.

Max Murphy Agree

Sooo jealous

You a lucky bastard…

Agreed. It encompasses all of his blues roots along with all of his own, unique voice and skills.

History of rock, perhaps, but there's Pat Metheny in jazz-rock, and Mike Stern, did you hear about that guy?

Absolutely agree 👍

Hmmm! Debatable. Far too many to compare with. Gary Moore played a few.

to me high hopes solo is better

Well yeah, bee playing with david Gilmore that would look good on your CV.

David Gilmore belter on that carter

The drummer had dental surgery earlier that day and his mouth was frozen numb in smile mode.

@@thedorp lol, yeah sure does look like that.🤗🤗🤗

Yes living the dream, can you imagine? The problem is there would be nothing in this life thereafter that could compare to that moment. I wish I had know about this concert before hand, I would have been there. Wish they would do it again, but probably not. I stood in that place 40 years ago, what a perfect environment for that masterful music! Thankfully this music will live on forever in recordings.

It's just you

He did , he is eptiome of gos

Gent t better than.

He's 73 now. Same age as the year Dark Side of the Moon was released.

Gent t No. It’s not just you. Look at the audience and also look at the comments here.💕

Not maybe. THIS IS IT! PERIOD! FOR ALL TIME!

🙏

Agreed, the greatest of the greatest!!

Idk that solo from Another Brick in the Wall on Pulse is also pretty magical, the bass kicks in with slap part before playing an extended version of the solo. But yes, cherish David and I mean that. His soloing and the way he plays helped me build myself up as a better player, myself. Easily top 3 guitarist for me , of all time.

Sorry guys, I'm 71yo and was around when Hendrix was alive!😆

And The Greatest Big~Daddy Of *ALL~TIMES*

@@nathanjones2447 yeshhh

Not coolest But CLASSIEST !

@@souvikchatterjee5920 yea but just imagine if you had an uncle like gilmour.A person who is cooler than most of the teens,not becuz of his style but because of his talent with the guitar

I think David Gilmour is the coolest dad ever

Awesome

What? I thought it was Gangnam Style.....

@@isagunalay5602 What we are seeing and hearing is a man's soul flowing through wood and steel... A couple other versions, where at the end Gilmour makes that Strat absolutely scream with anguish and despair is like nothing I have ever come out of a guitar before. A guitar player poster on one of these vids said that he didn't even know what the sound was...he had zero idea how that sound was made on guitar. Name them, Page, Clapton, Van Halen, whomever, for my money while all those top players are phenomenal players, Gilmour is transcendent. SO much raw emotion in this song. IMHO no one comes close.

@@jamespobog3420 anytime I listen to a really good guitar solo and I mean a really good one it just feels like im seeing into the eye of the universe in a way. Its very few dong that have made me almost cry because of all of the emotion being put through the instrument in a such a raw and visceral way. Maggot brain, weight of love and comfortably numb are those songs.

@@freshlypouredbingwater7913 Yep, know what you mean. There are actually a few songs that to me are borderline unbearable. Boys of Summer. Travelin' Soldier (Dixie Chicks...not a fan of them tho). The Flame (Cheap Trick). Ain't Missing You (John Waite)... et al. All extremely painful, yet they are all great songs...

Joseph Novit xand he can sing..oh jeez david, please do not die

@@normatible9795 I am 73 and listen to him almost every day ...he is a Legend and his music will live on

unbelievable ! My hero musician. If I am a billionth of him I'll be something special lolol

@@normatible9795 he's 73, not 90... at 73 you still have a lot to live

Damn near makes ME cry !!

RIP 🙏

Rest In Peace to your grandfather.

R.I.P

If his favourite band was Pink Floyd, he is in a really good place rn :)

Thanks for making me cry, jerk. 😢. jk. RIP to your awesome Papa.

lol no kidding, he's having the time of his life. I'm guessing this is his favourite song

btw - actually, it's not a concert hall, it's the Amphitheatre of Pompeii... ;-)

I would definitely feel like I'm at the height of my life playing with david gilmour one of my favorite songs

Lucky guy...

I still would have preferred the original drummer Nick Mason - his laid back style was soo cool

hahahahahhahaha good one

So you’re a 3 year old or your name was changed and btw I know it’s not really your name

@@avishoshan4047 :(

Gurke it was 3 years ago

XDD

I know it was a incredible when he took off his headphones just because he wanted to hear David solo

I'm talking about another video where Pink Floyd played for the last time together Nick Mason takes his headphones off so he can hear

It must be the first time this drummer heard It

I don't know maybe he just gets amazed every time

Drummer was just clearly amazed how this solo feels in live performance and you get to play along with it. What more can you ask for if you re the drummer? Its once in a lifetime you get to play along with this kind of musician.

Mucho bueno

Agreed

They have been playing that solo for a very long time, still amazing tho

They are all swimming in the groove they are making, just to serve this solo. They are spectators just like we are. They just get to add more glorious sounds to the solo of solos!

Wouldn't the greatest moment in history be the beginning of the universe, this would be a close second though

He had high hopes

totally agree skanoza they just all knitted together he just loved playing drums in the band

Every single person in Pompeii at that time was gilmoured

Steve distanislao. Great drummer

ikr

He looks like he having the time of his life...

And the bass player, the band have the best seats in the house!

🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

I would sell my soul to be able to see david gilmour play live. I cannot even fathom what the people on stage feel ♡

@@leahlebangood , i saw pink floyd live in 1994 in foxboro stadium in foxboro MA in the USA, during the division bell tour. 1994 was great to me. Probably the greatest year to me. PINK FLOYD IN MAY, WORLD CUP IN JULY. All in the USA

He is like "mommy, mommy, look I'm playing with Gilmour"

He looks pretty much younger than David so I think Pink Floyd had its best times when he was young

Absolutely agree with you dude

Thats definitly James Hetfield

No, not at all

he was for sure, sooooooooooo fucking good.

Exactly my thoughts about Davids 5 min solo he must have felt the effect that this song at that time would still be listened to for centuries to come.

No Gilmore is not from this planet. He's from other planet😎😎

Pure Brilliance

Definitely. Then afterwards Keith Richards went back to being the coolest guy on the planet. He deals with Mick Jagger who is probably more of a megalomaniac than Roger (love them all, regardless. Sometimes theses inflated egos are very important for this line of work.)

That made me laugh - so true

Made my day 😂

Truth was spoken

Gold

Yes indeed

I am fell that..

If you listen very carefully, you can hear some of them sing the first few notes.

Releve toi..... Tt n'est pas fini.... Ça commence 😊. Vit

Become experienced;)

Smile laughing that's so great ! Thanks for the message !

I think he is hot and cute

Holy sh*t, that's so true, it just hypes it up so much!

You've not seen me then!

Voice and guitar.

@Ziva David the songs melody and chord progression was a song Gilmour made a demo of for his solo album.. Also roger waters didnt write Davids solos on any of pink floyds songs

Get high. It makes so much more sense.

@@JayWater well said, Roger was a class act no doubt but david makes his guitar sing

billvill61 and it’s actually amazing.

*Prince* on the *George Harrison* tribute was up there! 😮

That concert was the first time anyone had played there to a live audience since the eruption in A.D. 79 of Mount Vesuvius.

This will always make you being together, music is the language of souls 🎶💖🎶💖🎶

🤍

Matt , I'm so sorry to hear about your girlfriend dying from cancer . It took my mum in 1962 . It's great you had the cool year to remember . God bless , dude .

Check out Anthony William, prevention is better than cure. May she rest in peace.

It is pretty raw

How many people can say they played with David Gilmor

He looked pretty content.

@@jasong.1295 Yeah, as in "the Pacific is wet"

4:08

@Captain Obvious seems about right.

How about PULSE

@Lalramchhani Ralte Pulse is freaking amazing as well, all versions are amazing.

@@albynorthwest7383 Try the "Royal Albert Hall 2006" version, that's excellent, too.

the solo on delicate sound of thunder cannot be beat.

Music expresses the things that our words cannot

Beautiful words Koben. And I hear YOU loud and clear my friend. XxxX I know exactly what you mean. Sometimes words fail to communicate and music does it way better. I hope you are OK buddy. I had two stints at psychiatric hospitals in my late teens/early 20s and I know how scary mental illness is. I wish you happiness Koben!! XxxxxxX You are a beautiful soul.

Koben my mate , you're not so far away from the rest of us. I think I'm a fairly normal bloke but this track always sort of "resets" my mood and brain. It takes you in and blanks out the world , it's a wonderful rollercoaster.

Oh go awayyyy

I hear you, brother. Incredible sonic and emotional experience , every time. 🤘❤

HA HA HA> U FUNNY

AYE! ! Watching him sing and make love to that guitar makes my 64 year old lady parts tingle! WORD!

Yesss 🇧🇪🇧🇪🇧🇪🇧🇪🇧🇪

That is painfully true man. I can see my whole childhood with my parents’s struggle with money and all their effort to bring me up where I am now. It just makes me burst me in tears. My dad loves Pink Floyd. He was the was who showed me the The Wall. It connects with so much memories from my childhood. Pink Floyd is something else. It’s a soundtrack for your past life. (I am 32 now)

Damn right, where music should hit ya

57

while evading Viet Nam doing enlisted 98G work in Berlin in 70-72, saw that "early" PF twice along with many others still at the top of the play list

hes 74 now :D

Saw them in 1972, in Orlando, Fla.!!! Righteous concert...4.5 hours!!!

A song celebrating drugs. Satan at work.

I'm 🇬🇧 so extra bragging rights. Not that the UK ever gets any recognition for the music we've brought to the planet....😕

It is the best guitar solo, officially declared

Hi dear.... Can you tell me the name if the batterist?

Hi dear! Can you tell me the name of the batterist /percussionist here in this video?

@@antonellagallo9190 Steve DiStanislao was the percussionist

Dont seethe solo! FEEL IT!

MrZuul25 yesssss

scrolled down to see if there was a comment about the drummer ! totally agree !!

Exactly what I was thinking throughout the video. Also the other vocal guys and girls were enjoying it and thinking the same as well.

It's Steve DiStanislao he's been playing with David even before On an Island, but yeah he looks happy, who wouldn't?

Something awesome was created there, and he was right in the middle of it