For like smaller Sample Sizes, McGrattan and Carkner good picks for Ottawa, But as a Sens fan since the early 2000s. Neil was the heart and soul for his entire career.

Dave Brown in Edmonton as well

CGY - How could you forget Sandy McCarthy! As well, not a lot of games in the NHL but Brian McGrattan! Was anyone tougher in the NHL than Brian McGrattan? Don't think his fists could fit inside boxing gloves if he tried. Another guy who was absolutely underrated tough and played a regular shift - Engelland. Lastly, really tough guy who wasn't around long was Eric Goddard.

Calgary era Sandy McCarthy = Nailz!

I love Domi, dude fought some monsters without a second thought, but that being said I think Clark was the best for the Leafs.

Dennis Vial for Ottawa should be a mention

Big Ern? Feels like he should’ve got a mention for Calgary

Winnipeg had Domi, Shaun Cronin, Jim McKenzie, Jim Kyte and Gord Donnelly.

What about Belak?

Toughest is different than best fighter. Small guys who always answered the bell, fought out of their weight class and lost to some heavyweights were tough but not necessarily the best fighters. Tiger Williams and Wendel Clark come to mind. Another great example would be George McFee when he played for the Rangers. 5’10” 170 lbs. but man could that guy throw em.

Lyle Odelein was with Montreal for 7 seasons. Topped 2300 career PIMs. Dave Manson is another interesting name, but he only played a bit over 100 games with the Habs. Almost 2800 career PIMs.

Flames also had Goddard and mcgratten who where pretty good at fighting

Arron Asham dont forget ,absolutely drops Jay Beagle,Asham didnt mess around tough dude

Hayes says at the end that they'll keep it ''the last twenty years'', which would mean 2001 - 2021. Yet they keep talking about players who played in the 80s and 90s. Most mentioned didn't even play past 2000, and basically all of them were at the very end of their careers at that point.

domi was the best he even fought the fans from the penalty box

Canucks Rick Rypien

Thank you Noodles for mentioning Kevin Mclelland. I might be the only guy that feels this way but in my opinion if the Oilers didn't add him to their lineup they might not have won their first Stanley Cup. He was actually a pretty good hockey player and tough. He scored the only goal in game 1 in the 1984 finals against the Islanders. If they don't win that game I'm not sure they would win the series.

Canucks: Rick Rypien, Gino Odjick, Tiger Williams

I personally think the chris Simon slash to ryan Hollweg throat was worse than the stomp.

Winnipeg Jets. Jimmy Mann Kyte. Domi. King Cronin Manson. Tkacuk.

Google Tie Domi runs from Luke Richardson lol Orr gets our vote for best Leaf fighter.

Playing Midget hockey in the late 60's during a game between Stouffville & Sunderland, players and coaches were fighting at centre ice. Management turned the lights off and cops were called.

Orr? Over Clark, Domi, and even Martin

Vancouver 1. Odjick 2. Brashear 3. Rypien 4. Tiger Williams 5. Tom Sestito 6. Dan Cloutier

Wow didn’t think this would happen

Winnipeg: Dave Manson, Keith Tkachuk,

Debating what the toughest groups to join are: Mr Hayes you referenced a Seinfeld quote and one of the group's buddies got a new area code... I'm referencing Elaine's new area code conundrum and why.she doesn't get phone calls, it's long distance across the street.

Yes, Turgeon was the guy who stayed on the bench. Some say that's why he is still not in the HHoF to this very day.

Wade Belak

Dave brown for Edmonton and McGrattan for Calgary

rip vancouver

R.I.P. Gino Odjick

Forgot Dave Brown when he played for Edmonton.

Not on a Canadian team but Kocur is hands down the scariest fighter of all time.

Rocky Thompson.. was a beauty

Domi, or Wendel. Belak was also a beauty.

I would like to see a change in the POINTS given in HOCKEY games, to spread out teams and put more presser to win in regular time. 3 POINTS for win in regular time 2 POINTS for LOSE 2POINTS for overtime win 1 POINT for LOSE 1 POINT for shot out win NOTHING for LOSE , I think it would be better for the game.

O mailed it it here

Simon stomped on Jarkko Ruutu.

Chris nilan used to beat up all my dad's friends growing up

RICK RYPIEN

That dude really said Montreal doesn't have as long of a history? Corson, Ferguson, Laraque, Richard, Odelein, Mario Tremblay... Get your head out of your ... Toronto bias

Winnipeg had Randy Carlyle, Gord Donnelly, Tie Domi, Jim McKenzie, Jason Doig, Shawn Cronin, Kris King, Dave Manson, Bryan Marchment, Jim Kyte….

John scott

Tony Twist in Quebec.

the best thing about this segment was the fact that O'Neill barely said a word.

Who else loves hockey 🏒

Flames, where was Nick Fotiu? How do you not include Chara on the Senators simply based on him rag-dolling Bryan McCabe

Ottawa it's McGratton Carkner Neil Chara

What about Wade Belak

Sens ray emery

flames Brian McGrattan

Andi patrrillo overdrive

What about tucker

Winnipeg = Shawn Cronin possibly.

Devane for the Leafs, he would destroy Domi

Wendel was the toughest - come on, he was taking on Probert 35 lbs bigger and held his own. Wendel fought to hurt.

Mcgratten?

Domi ran away from fights. Wendel Clark put you through the ice.

Brian Mcgratten

Would not want to fight Tucker

Cronin the barbarian in the peg

Rick rypien

No love for Wade Belak?

Domi was the best no doubt

Clark

Hi

These segments are why TSN will always be far superior to the annoying other sports network in Canada.

Kris king Winnipeg Jets

Wendel Clark went them all

Dustin Byfglyn.

Winnipeg = Gord Donnelly

Kordic, Clark and Orr. Domi ran from too many fights and went after a lot of non fighters which offsets some of his huge fights

3rd

Surprised ray isn’t talking about how fighting doesn’t help your team and you shouldn’t do it and how he used to dangle all the time and score on breakaways. Dude literally ruins the NHL Games every time he opens his mouth, I truly wish I could mute just him lmao

"best fighter all time" is pretty representative of a fighter's brain post-career

Best fighter Who hasnt made suicede or have drug problem? But Who cares? Only what is important thing is that you guys get your fun and thrill To watching fights.