50 years..... and still when people listen to Pink Floyd it has that same effect.

Check out the live at Pompeii version to experience the full grandeur of this masterwork. YOU ROCK SCRIBECASH!

Pink Floyd plays "feelings" disguised as songs

That’s David Gilmour and Richard Wright singing together

I got lost driving around in the middle of the night during a storm while listening to this song. That middle part made it that much more intense.

Not every song has an insane screeching bird solo. This song give me a "lost at sea" vibe.

Glad to see you've made it back to Pink Floyd. In 50 years of going to concerts, the eight times I've been to see them are all at the top. Wish you could have been there.

Us and Them is the ultimate Pink Floyd instrumental vibe. Been jamming that song for 25 years.

thank you dear. its nice to see someone listen to music outside their comfort zone, and be pleased that they did.

Pink and Floyd were Pinkney Anderson and Floyd Council - pioneering blues musicians.

This is arguably the most 'Pink Floyd' song that Pink Floyd ever recorded.

Yesss Let's go!! I knew you'd like this song lol. It's a wild experience!

The Floyd just hits different. Are they a “band?” I guess. But it just feels odd restricting them to “band” status.

It cracks me up when reactors “love transitions” and then invariably pause at each transition.

This album put Pink Floyd over the top, into a mythical realm that captures your soul rather than just enticing it, as previous albums were.

This is one of their very best songs

Echoes is a masterpiece

I think you may have missed the song ONE OF THESE DAYS off of the meddle album.Many consider it their first great song.Also one of if not their first song to have that pink Floyd sound they are recognized for.

Their best song in my opinion. Ha a look at the album Animals; the whole album because it’s a concept album.

AAAAh Yes, When Music was hand made and grass fed...............Totally unlike Today!

Waters on the bass...mindblowing =)

This middle section of this song descends into Hell and when they climb out, they are the fully formed Pink Floyd we all know and love.

AYYYYE MY FAV PINK FLOYD SONG

Any Pink Floyd is welcome. Tool is the modern day metal Floyd.

i still love this generations reactions to this song in particular,i am 42 and vividly remember reacting the same way as you Scribe,bewitched and bedazzled.....love you and your reaction.....ps love the ne hairstyle

Try live at Pompeii not often you see them that young ,,

Those whale sounds are embedded in Echoes of the past... this is the true meaning behind this album. I've listened to this album since it came out and never knew until recently.. Here is the explanation for those interested.. explained in detail. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/i558dtSg2NW9o4k.html

You are the only analyst on utube. Music is too special to take for granted and Echos is Mozart and Betoven on the back porch, blowing our minds. Thanks, you added to this experience, keep it up.

Love your reaction ! As a long time fan, this is the soundtrack of my life,happy to see the younger generation experience excellense 🙏🏻

Scribe is such a great video DJ.

this song is so great. A little long but I imagine it was truly made for listening with an altered state of consciousness lol.

You just stumbled upon one of the greatest studio sessions of all time. Hell yeah! 🤘☝❤

A master piece and still valid today after 50 years

ScribeCash I wish you peace and prosperity. You are my favorite youtube music reactor!

Love you ScribeCash you're awesome. Respect, Bob Thompson.

My favorite Pink Floyd song. Perfect for a Coast Guard gal.

You are wise beyond your years. There hope for our future.

I used to play the spooky part of this song in my boom box on trick-or-treat night as the kids would approach I would turn it on held it up to the window to scare the kids. 😂. That was around 32 years ago

Please do try and react to a Echoes Live at Gdansk David Gilmour as sadly it was to be the final time he would play with friend bandmate Richard Wright a magician on keys before he passed on. . It will blow ypu away emotionally!! Swell reaction, thanks.

This track usually takes me on a submarine journey when I hear it...across the sand willowing in the shallows, and out across the reefs into dangerous deep water with the whales, and then through a storm - with all the sounds from above echoing down to me under the water; where the only man-made sound is my submarine's sonar ping. When I hear the crescendo at the end, it's like the sub is surfacing up to the sunlight. Sometimes, the journey involves going through dark woods, and damp caves. That's the thing with Floyd...they've always been bloody good at giving you a canvas to paint your imagination onto.

Always love your reactions! Always entertaining!

I haven't seen anyone else make this comment. This is the song that defined the Pink Floyd sound going forward. The band had a couple years of experimenting after Sid Barrett, their song writer, lead vocalist and guitarist went insane. Their next album was "Dark Side of the Moon."

I’ve just bought myself a new record turntable after not having one for about 30 years! Meddle was one of the first albums I bought to play on it. This song takes up the entire B side! It’s a trip! I would urge you to watch the boys singing it live at Pompeii. It’s in a Roman amphitheatre, just the band and their sound and film crew, no audience. It’s sublime. Watching David Gilmore making those sounds on his guitar…he’s incredible. And all the boys were seriously hot 🔥 back then..still are

The “scary part” is whales & birds talking…the song starts out underwater (“Everything is green & submarine”) and progresses to on land. At least in my mind for 50 years 😂 David Gilmour (guitarist) refuses to play this live since Rick Wright (keyboards & synth), who both sang on this song, passed away.

Glad to see you building your channel!! I've been around since 15k subs. More RUSH!

I love the crying guitar at the beginning in the right speaker. If I've said it once, I've said it a thousand times...when you world turns to shit and you've had a crappy day, you come home, pour a scotch (or similar), or glass of red, drink that offing it down. Then, pour another, woof that down too, then pour a third one and go turn off all the lights. Put THIS Pink Floyd record on. Go find a bean bag or deep leather couch, put your headphones on and sink down into your chair, close your eyes, sip away the final drink, and let the music sooth your soul !!!

The "Live at Pompeii" version from 1972 is better in my opinion. Plus seeing them play it live adds more

The 'Live At Pompeii' version is even better.

Yeah I just have two minutes here to make a comment because I'm so incredibly busy. Love your take on things

Alright my scribby you just stepped in a real legendary masterpiece yeah you could do that whole album It's called Meddle. We used to play the song Fearless and that whole other side is just the even got us a song that's kind of like the Beatles were they do that old timey Style type music they actually did this per se live there was no audience they went to the ruins of Pompeii you know where that volcano went off and took out a whole civilization so yeah they set up in this big Coliseum and had the whole performance filmed and they have this movie in the theaters and it was called Pompeii anyhow there's this one song called Sheamus I don't know I should give away the plot but it's like he got your bottles next slide guitar playing a blues and they got this dog and they got him up on stage oh my God it is so effing hilarious yeah so you'll have to watch that movie and react to the other songs on this album if you had the actual vinyl record they have this really cool picture you open up the gate fold and all the Hombres are there you got David Gilmour guitarist Nick Mason drums Richard Wright keyboards Rodger Waters bass player extraordinaire yeah it's just this black and white picture and it is so freaking awesome I remember I had that album that I was in Manhattan Beach and I somehow I just wandered off into the backyard I had the album in my hand and I was just dreaming about other great music songs with just come into my mind you know it was like I realize the potential for good music was just non-stop it was just never going to quit so I thought back then oh contraire how naive I was ok Scribbly check u at the next MONSTER REACTIONE

It is like being picked up by a spacecraft and making a journey through space and then taken back to earth, and witnessing of it taking off and leaving. I have heard others using this scenario but exchanging the spacecraft for a submarine and an under sea, which is probably more appropriate. Regardless it's a journey. Listen to it again without interruptions to experience the full affect.

Waaazzaaaaa darlin.

i listened to echoes in 1971 it was hard to lisren on radio they never played songs that were that long it started them off to super stardom u should really tey to react to :1 of these days and to sorrow bur the pulse concert versions are best and tyhanks for reacting to pink floyd

And so I throw the windows wide and call to you across the sky ✌️

That tune you liked from the 8:30 mark of your reaction vid, was plaigarised by andrew lloyd webber, for one of the most iconic sounds in "the phantom of the opera" musical/opera, but pink floyd did not worry about it happening though, roger waters also wrote a opera, it is called "ca ira", not too bad for an opera, (i dont usually like opera).

just when I was starting to worry you had forgotten about them ^_^

Pink Floyd could do the sound for the all time most scary movie, I believe they jammed in the BBC TV studios for the 1969 moon landings ...

I had heard" Meddle " album once at a party, so next day I went to the record store and bought it. Next time I heard it I was tripping on mescaline and when I got to " Echoes " it kinda freaked me out !!!

The (live PULSE ) 1994 ) concert is amazing!!!

Echos is the foundation of the sound of Pink Floyd.

"Live at Pompeii" 1972 was recorded live at the ancient Roman Amphitheatre that was destroyed by the eruption of Mt Vesuvius on August $th 79ad. the Amphitheatre hadn't been used since the day of the Eruption No Fans were at the concert, they band stated they were playing for the Ghosts every song from that show is a Masterpiece

I first heard this at Birmingham town hall the year it came out. I was 16. The concert hadn’t been that good. There had been some boos and heckling as the audience didn’t want to hear the new stuff. You know the sort of thing that Roger Waters might write an album about later! Anyway from the first ping of Echoes the audience went quiet. As the song finished there was a quiet moment and then the place went mad. I’ll never forget it. Needless to say I went out and bought the LP and it’s been a favourite ever since. I always imagined it was about two lost souls looking for each other. At the end of the dreamlike sequence when the ping comes back there’s eventually an echo as if they’ve made contact and the song goes into the crescendo. I’m probably completely wrong but I’m just an old romantic lol

good meditation song .. for sleep .. reelax

That was so nostalgic for me - took me back to studying for my pre-uni art exams listening to Meddle, Electric Ladyland and Marty Balin singing Miracles. Just a different pace of life then - more space, less external 'noise' - great choice! xx

Art for the mind

Great song isn't it? well worth just sitting back and just letting it happen to you :-)

I love this song so much! ❤️😊

Ride that wave.

vibe-ing

its all about you love

Namaste Coastgirl.

If you never had a bad trip....this song has the potential to straight put you there lol

Your hair Is so Trippy , love It ❤️

Glad you're still doing this. I thought we might have lost you for good to the Coast Guards.

Pink Floyd - Atom Heart Mother King Crimson - Lizard King Crimson - Epitaph Soft Machine - Penny Hitch

Just the thing for a Coastguard girl. Now you should listen to it again lying down in complete darkness.

You should check out their song “Dogs” it’s 19 minutes of phenomenal

You have so much hair; I'm jealous! R.I.P. Rick Wright (keyboards). Must see Echoes live in Pompeii, 1971, parts 1 and 2 when they were young. Have you listened to Dark Side of the Moon and/or Wish You Were Here albums? You're so right; you can't rush Pink Floyd! Great reaction btw!

Hey, thanks for doing this reaction. Your reactions are always great. If you ever want to hear another long Pink Floyd song, try "Dogs" (only 15-17 minutes) and the grand dog of them all, "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) and there is another video that is (Parts VI - IX)" Really great stuff, a vibe or groove they are.

"Where are we going next?" Space. :)

16:46 it sounds more like sands and tiny twisters on a distant planet trying to get through and out of the unknown

Lots more Pink in the archives! "Any Colour You Like" (from Dark Side of the Moon) has got some trippy Moog synth and crunchy guitar music, that sounds like looking through a kaleidoscope looks!

So welcome to Mildenhall.... if you can track down and figure out that cryptic clue you win a Tiffanny Cufflink.

Probably my favorite Pink Floyd song. It’s a trip. Nice to see you react to such a long track. I don’t think you reacted to Green Earrings by Steely Dan, that would be fun. Great to have you back scribe

Echoes on side 2 of Meddle is by far the best thing ever by them. But should check out Small Species on the album Ummagumma.

Try to watch their video Live At Ponpeii A trip maaan. Good version of this.

You'll love A Pillow Of Winds & Fearless for sure!

React act to their songs from 1994 Pulse live concert."Comfortably Numb", "Money", "Sorrow"

There are so many damn parts of this song that would make sick samples or as background on a loop! The live version from 1970 Pompeii is even more amazing FYI but the video is in 2 parts so make sure you catch both. It's cool seeing them live so young and just dripping with talent!

I see "Echoes", I click. Simple as that. :-D

Mid 70's ,,,,, Louisville, Kentucky,,,,, Freedom Hall Live Pink Floyd's Machine, no seats everyone stood and they showed the first music video on a large screen. Could not hear after the concert.

Funny story bout this song. Rock and Roll rumor has it that Stanly Kubrick approached Roger Waters to do the sound track to 2001: A Space Odyssey and Roger turned him down. It was said that it was one of Roger Water's greatest regrets. This is where the song comes in, if you sinc this to the end of 2001, its as if Pink Floyd wrote the sound track all along. This does a lot to explain the strange part in the middle, cause in the movie its when the main character is flying over some weird desolate alien planet. Thankfully some kind folk have already did the sinc for us. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hbl_obyjq8W1l6M.html

Check out the live version from Pompeii 1972

Psychedelic masterpiece.

now we got the wind blowin i feel it like gunna be some wizard of oz mess man i laughed my ass of ........ great reaction .

Yes do the live (1974) version in Pompii

you should watch the David Gilmour concert live in Gdansk from 2006 it was the last time echoes was performed with keyboardist Richard Wright still alive who died two years later it was an absolutely amazing evening you really need to check that one out even if you just do it personally. Richard was such a deep quiet soul yes so passionate. After Richard a David Gilmour said they were certain songs he would never play again without Richard and this is one of them and he has been true to his word

Yaaassss. Can’t believe you actually listened to this. A classic of Prog Rock by one of the founding members of the genre. Glad you enjoyed it. Their music has to breath. It’s 🔥. Suggest you listen to Dark Side of the Moon, each side, 1 & 2. That, will be a vibe and a half.

A good grade LSD made this an adventure with headphones. Live it wasn’t as polished but the music literally picked you up, took you to another place, and set you down two hours later. Best of the best.

😁 Cool! Echoes! I'll grab snacks! 🍿🐰 #ENRGYZRBunny