That took a 180 real quick.

Its funny how he said he wanted to become a gunslinger. He ended up becoming just like one

@@SalmxZ I think after jack kills Ross years later he gets a letter to register for the draft and thus kickoffs a new set of events but I think after awhile he does writes a book about his life seen in GTA 5

@@mikeyholland150 I think the book is about John not Jack.

@@65firered well it could be told from Jack's point of view since John died when he was 16 maybe his mom told him about a lot about his life

KingRayque oof

Mega oof

Shaggy full power indeed

Oof

Then he became a writer.

OH MY GO-

😂 rdr1

I thought the same XD

Little did she know...

Rip Van Winkle lol

The true tragedy about both RDR1 and 2 is that Jack doesn't truly get his freedom.

@@Wildlink123 We dont know about his late life tho. All the know is that he wrote a book later on which suggests he didnt die young as an putlaw

@@elite1361 The Red Dead book in GTA V is likely just an easter egg. Though perhaps it is possible Jack wrote about the story of the Van Der Linde gang using Arthur and John's journal as reference. But there's no definitive proof that's what happened. Like I said, the GTA V book is probably just an easter egg.

@@mcgoldenblade4765 Yes it is an easter egg without any further proof, but at least it implies that Jack lived long enough to write a book. In my head canon, Little Jack leaves for Los Angeles (Los Santos for that matter lol) after killing Ross. He then became a successful author and film maker, had a family and died peacefully in the last third of the 20th century.

@@mcgoldenblade4765 still a really cool idea to have red dead and GTA take place in the same universe.

And a few more, he writes a book.

@@Dashinix a book so famous that people still read it in modern times

@@chumunga648 what? Modern times?

@@slide_thru it's an easter egg in GTAV. There's a book called 'Red Dead' by J. Marston. It's speculated that that author is none other than Jack

Books were like internet back in that day

GB he’s got a good sense of humor that’s for sure

*Why are you booing me?* *I'm right.*

Pretty sure he was talking about himself.

Arthurs way funnier in antagonizing mode

That got me

To be fair, i learned english through Top Gun of all things when i was 6. And a friend of mine was also first exposed to english from the Matrix. Kinda gives you a headstart, i guess?

@@DrSabot-A You know what? Fair enough.

@@DrSabot-A Top, Fucking Gun? Learning English? 6?

@@EmbeddedWithin Probably started learning a different language before

@@watersnortmoment3734 oh ok

Underrated comment

Haha haha that funny

Nice mii

Hahahahahahah what a great joke 😂😂😂

XD Oh that was great! XD

Damn, that is sad.

:(

You could delay it but still :(

😭

@@Klosop I think tonally it fits better if it's the day before tbh

@@johnny9199 lol troll

Did I ever tell you the definition of lumbago?

Makes you wonder where was John in the early stages of his sons life.

@@TheEmpiresStrongest Drunk in the floor of a bar most probably

@@TheEmpiresStrongest in the story it hints that Marston tried to ran away and go AWOL but returned. That's also why Morgan kinda hates him at first 🤣

And a lot more articulate than you, apparently. Ha, just bustin ya chops.

@@TheNinja94a Catch you later then

acculturate is a fancy word for assimilate. Yeah, he's probably the easiest to assimilate because he's only a 4 year old, whats he gonna do, rebel against against of gunslingers? I wouldn't put it past Micah to kill a child so yeah

@@Wildlink123 Do you read books or eat them? Not even Bill Williamson would mix those 2 words up.

@@mikevignola4213 I was trying to correct him. Assimilate is what I think he was trying to get at. Either way, the answer is neither I don't have spare time to read a damn book like wtf

Nothing happens to him

@@divyanshrana1925Jack became what John, Abigail, Arthur and others tried to make he not be, an outlaw

@@saymyname281 After gunslinging he does manage to "retire" and become an author. You can find out about this through an Easter Egg in GTA. There is a book called "Red Dead" written by a J. Marston. Plus one of the devs confirmed it in an interview.

@@griffs3283they confirmed that the RDR is not cannon to GTA but my headcannon will forever be that the book is written by Jack himself and RDR is canon to GTA

I did not hear that at all and I replayed it several times

@@drewsaluk6860 it's a JOKE

Sore Throat How?

Drew Saluk Do you know what Joke is ?

Amarson 232 Ok I’m stupid, whatever, just what does it mean? What’s the joke?

And writes a book called Red Dead Redemption.

65firered wait what

Jacob Epstein Its a reference to an easteregg in gta v that can be found in franklin's house. In his bookshelf there is a book called red dead redemption with the name jack marston, obviously indicating that it was written by him.

@@idontcareaboutyouropinion8999 his book is in GTA V

“Over my dead body” became so literal

It's actually 12 years later

What about me

UFCfighter2125 tanks buddy

I miss Lenny,Sean,and Hosea

@@Itsyabooiiiii fuckin fake sean

That shot broke my hearth. Why not the idiots. No, hosea. Damn rockstar. You better make rdr 3

Lucky young jack, has a grandfather figure like Hosea

@Bick Dig he was also kinda lucky with Dutch (when he was sane)

@@CD-hn2po Not many admit Dutch's contributions. He found Jack, out mouthed Bronte to take him back, and then humiliated him.

Crime aside, he’s the type of man I hope to be.

He reminds me of my grandfather Always the wise one and full of love This scène makes me think About him

Yeah And i love it when he plays with his wooden horse toy

Ikr

The game guilt-trips you into rescuing him when you see Abigail crying in Shady Belle

Literally over her dead body.

"over my dead body"

Which makes me believe Jack remembers that whole conversation even as a young man.

@@MarvinT0606 I think Abigail knew that some sort of vengeance was brewing within Jack. I imagine Abigail startled awake in the middle of the night to Jack practicing his shooting and drawing outside.

@@bigsmilereviews100 Or maybe Jack waited until his mother had passed away to finally have his revenge. After all, with John dead, Jack is now the man of the house, and his first duty is to taking care of his mother. But once Abigail passed away, Jack finally had only revenge left.

so "gunslingers can read too"

Syed Muddassir Iftikhar he’s talking about the Easter egg In gtaV

It was written Red Dead by J. Marston, Idk if it's John or Jack

I Hate Click Bait it was most likely jack because 1. John is dead and 2. Jack was the only one in the Marston family who had any interest in books

@@AntonioConman yup!!! That makes Sense

He was the real mind behind the group. Dutch was just the leader, I mean the bank robbery would have worked if molly and Micah weren’t involved and they would have got away

wellll guess milton didn’t feel the same as you.

Hosea was the foundation of the gang. Everything and everyone had stuck together or at least had this sense of ease while he was around whether others believed it or not. He wanted nothing but the best intentions for the people before he passed away which he knew was coming but came sooner than expected sadly. Then when he passed is when shit went down creek.

smackdownv123456 the beauty of Hosea is he listens and only speaks when it’s needed. That’s wisdom.

So true that wisdom is on fleek though

yeah it is painful your family is broken apart

Reminds me of that old quote. "It takes a village to raise a child"

I didn't know 💩 was cute

BrobotDj lol

@@BrobotDj ...You listen here BOAH.

kid he said "some of the cutest *shit* he's ever seen"

666 likes on your comment

It did.

i think both of those reasons made him a gunslinger

Tbf, I don't think his ambition as a child had much bearing on the path he eventually took. Lots of kids want to be gunslingers or astronauts or kings

It's knew not new

@@ry_bread9173 Oh look a grammar Nazi

Oh nooo ;-;

Such a shame that guy didn't deserve that.. the reality hits hard and this game damn realistic :(

The reason why they said that is because you have a mission from sadie which once you get to the cutscene you’ll see kierans head on his hands and yet shady bell was ambushed

@@Guestyinnit we are aware

@@Inkognito-ts4to ok

And him shooting agent ross

Honestly Jack doesn't become a gunslinger it's mostly up to the player what he does after in my playthrough Jack is a good samaritan that helps other people who are in trouble

MIKE2111ful In my playthrough Jack killed Ross and escaped to Mexico, where's he's now serving as a bounty hunter who helps people every now and again.

They did. Read dead foreshadowing

@dr103 The government didn't care about Ross at that point: > He had a bad reputation with the Army > Decided to live outside civilization in a place full of bandits > He was retired when he died. Plus, his family only saw Jack once, They probably forgot about him 10 minutes after he left.

He was pretty much the moral compass of the gang and voice of reason, specially for Dutch

Ye that was my first time properly fishing I think

Don't you forget Hosea and Dutch raised both Arthur and John 20 years ago

​@@Subham1418 I cannot believe John has the ability to teach himself

@@TheMartyrNeverFades there, I corrected it so your feeble mind can understand

@@Subham1418 i was just joking you uncultured simpleton

That won't happen since we know how both hosea and uncle die it would be cool though maybe as a dlc?

Soranutt Wilawann what about Arthur’s father?

No I wanna dlc for red dead redemption 2 where U play as everybodies past and to see how they ended up with the gang. Or a black water DLC

@@immjaded-2676 That's the best idea, a 2-3hr dlc that shows what happened in Blackwater. I'd love for them to have RDR3 be an even further backstory, but that would take at least 5 years to develop.

Yes I believe rdr3 will be with young Hosea, and maybe Dutch.

I found a hidden horizontal

What about a vertical?

Ikr so much hidden diagonal in this amazing

Found one yesterday Hosea threatened Sean that he’ll slit his throat

I found a hectagonal in this amazing

Pretty much everything besides riding a horse: Hosea.

He was 16 when he joined. He’s 36 in 1899

Wait, really? I though it was 13y old.

​@@nadja9055 no he was 14 he says "20 years something like that" don't remember where but it was confirmed he was 14, pretty sure Hosea said it

Hosea for all of the above most likely. Remember, Hosea used to be younger (maybe Arthur's age in the game) and had a lot of skills to teach while Dutch did all the planning.

Grandfather, father, uncle, friend, brother. Hosea would be an incredible human being in general

@@jostar987 is that a jojo reference

I agree with a rat for onece

His heart is bigger than bullet wound from when he as shot

@@migueljamero3756 hey it's me

Go fuck yourself micah

And Lenny also became a gunslinger "oVah hIs dad'S dEAd bODeh"

Alex Tatum and he died at 19..... 😳

@Izzy Zilla here some tissue, i saw your tears dripping again

I bet Jack could of fought in ww1 if I remember the time settings correctly

@@copporn1615 I want some tissues too, I needed to *M A S T U R B A T E*

They are not criminals. They are outlaws.

​@@1th_to_comment. They kill and steal their definitely criminals

@@mrpringle9479 Dutch himself says in one mission that they’re outlaws not criminals

@@jds8438 please explain to me what's the difference

@@mrpringle9479 why should I?

So a game ?

I believe video games will one day be seen as a great form of art due to its interactivity.

@@chillcapybaracitrus yea probably

Because it's 1st Person as well, it looks like a sitcom with him breaking the 4th wall.

Senan Kearney ok

Oh i thought he was pointing at Arthur because Arthur is a gunslinger and he was in front of Jack.

William Foster The first commercial flight was in January 1 1914 of memory serves.

You can fly with hot air balloons c:

Emily Klemstein if you count Brief flights as successful flights, then the Wright brothers did it first in 1903

Imagine following RDR1, Jack gets drafted into WWI as a pilot. After that he writes his book 'Red Dead' which can be seen in GTAV

Emily Klemstein The inventor of the plane is the wright brothers because they invented a plane that didn’t crash under 6 seconds

He's d e a d

John Marston is also dead yet he appeared in RDR2 Because there is a thing called P R E Q U E L S

PingedMirror47 And in RDR3 we meet Hosea's wise and badass mentor, and in RDR4 we play as him...

No this will take too much time when we can make RDR3 about Uncle and how he got lumbago

How about young dutch and hosea's adventure?

@Jack Marston Child you will be child

Abigail: No you will be a lawyer!

Ovah me dead bodeh

@Jack Marston Child Jack how do you have phone back in 1899?

@@tvalokibatman6563 Francis Sinclair

I like all characters,except Micah.(Sorry for my wrong english i am german)

@@edgareckstein2799 You wrote nothing wrong though, you don't need to apalogize for bad English everyone isn't from an English speaking country.

@@TortoiseBlaster Of course he need (Sorry for my english, I'm African).

Mine are Dutch, Lenny, Sean, Bill, Javier, and Uncle

Casey's Vinyls they probably would if Hosea didn’t die when he did and he lived till after guarma they would have taken down Dutch and Micah

James Lit it’s really not Dutch’s fault, it’s just because Hosea died.

Just Micah

Bongo Cat nah. Dutch would have busted out Hosea. He loved him. The biggest reason he went crazy was because he died

True. I agree

Like chichi and Gohan

I think he was just making a point that not all gunmen, specifically him are completely uneducated fools, I doubt he ever wanted Jack to live like them

@@ClaytonTheCrackeryou got it exactly right

"Gunslingers can read too, you know" -Arthur

Fun fact, in franklins house in gta v, there’s a book called red dead redemption written by J. Marston, we can only assume it’s got to be written by Jack

You are right for the most part, but don’t mistake kindness for weakness, in a interaction between Hosea and either Bill or Uncle (i forgot) he pulls his gun out on one of the 2 when their drunk and even twirls it around before putting it back into its holster, and he pulled it out just as quick. he’s still a professional gunslinger and con man. but that doesn’t mean he wasn’t sweet because he was one of my favorites in the game and his death still makes me sad

@UrGayLmao But he was more calm and tempered. A great man? Not really, he silver tongued his way out of many situations and into a lot of scamming and leeching money off of people. However, he still has moralistic traits and openly attempts to deescalate situations or spare those who aren't involved with their situation or aren't deemed much of a threat. Only resorting to gunfights to defend himself and his group or during the raid on the Braithwaite Manor. He is a pragmatist and someone who possesses a lot of foresight and wisdom beyond the short term as well, which made him such a good right hand to Dutch. Think of him more as a wise thief, who doesn't involve those who aren't actively a threat/part of the situation, seeks the most bloodless or otherwise most moderate solution, and generally attempts to be a fatherly figure, mentor and best friend to everyone in camp. He's like a weird mix of chaotic good and chaotic neutral with some, still working for himself, but showing immense care and work ethic for his fellow gang members and wishing to do jobs with the least amount of collaterals or needless bloodshed. He's a team player and a good friend to most of the gang, and actively puts them equal to his ambitions, yet doesn't feel locked to a specific code either since he's both a criminal and because of his ingenuity and more mentor role, rather than an absolutist Dutch sycophant.

Not really a father figure to Dutch he was like his older brother

@AnselmoBabimbola Yes for sure, he wasn’t a good man by any means, but he was better and he always wished and tried to work with Dutch to get everyone a new life. I think any typical brigand or roaming gang of thugs would either be in this way of life until they die, or find more brutish ways of managing their criminal holdings. You could argue it was more a means to an end for him at some point and less just cons for himself and his own personal pleasures. He wanted to see the succeed and maybe find himself a life to settle and to put his criminal skills aside. I miss Hosea and wish he had stuck further

He's out bounty hunting and got stopped by government agents who know his past and they draft Jack into the war.

I can see that being story dlc

Lol yes

Or when jack fought in the mexican revolution with the rebels to overthrow Reyes

That would be awesome. He has a wife and child by 1917 and is forced by the government to join the military or go to prison for RDR1 SPOILERS, SPOILERS FOR A 10 YEAR OLD GAME murdering Edgar Ross in the RDR1 epilogue. The final chapter could be him in the trenches and ends with him dying or going home to his wife. And they could continue the story with some of his military buddies getting into the growing mob business. Then in 90 years when we are all old or dead the story will have progressed so far they’ll be in the GTA timeline and maybe THEN they’ll make GTA 6 lol.

No I think its about Eagle Flies getting killed because of Duch's greed. Jack always tends to refer to the future in his readings, He did it at the end of Red Dead 1 when reading to John (foreshadowing him avenging his death) and in Undead nightmare ("The brave man has to kill everyone"). But they only made in super obvious in undead nightmare

The man being thrown out for his greed might as well be Micah (falling out of Dutch's grace at the end) or Dutch himself, losing everyone because of him trying to come up with new schemes which costed him so many people

@@stefanosiclari I do think it's mostly Dutch. A LOT of the books and readings you find are allegorical for him and the gang.

Did Blind Man Cassidy write the book?

Jack: Ok.

FluffyPurpleUnicorn that name

Jack: Deal..

Skyline D They do that at the house camp, not this one

kieran dies 2 chapters later

Did none of you actually watch the whole video? They're are at Shady Belle camp when the girls are asking where Kieran is

I don't see how I mean ik she can't read but still it's not much of a roast

@@mikeyholland150 It when Hosea says see your smart hinting that Jacks smarter than Abigail.

@@tempcrusader9727 I kind of see it now that I went back and watch it he was kinda correcting her you know for a kid his age he sure does speak very well and proper given the environment he was in.

Mikey Holland True

But jack still respects his mother

Glenn Funderburk maybe that’s why he died

Hoses is to good for heaven, he is the sole SUPER angle

Fr only my parents say "you will be a teacher or a doctor" 😒

Then Edgar Ross turns him into a bad boy years later

Hosea didn't deserve that faith, he was a good man, he was wise, he wanted the best for everyone...damn it he shouldn't have died! >:'c his death left an open wound in me

He killed himself with the life he lived

@@BaneKlv same man sean and hosea and kieran and lenny deaths were heartbreaking ....sorry for replying after 2 years