What's your dream piece on the violin?

Prodigies be like: 😏 I learned that in one year.

I've been playing for 5 months and I just discovered vibrato by myself because my hand was very relaxed. Still in progress.

5 years of lessons and I have had to stop for a time because I cannot Play that Minuet that you make sound so light and lovely. I have worked hard but at 66, I've still got a lot to learn.

I have only 6 months of violin, in the first one I’ve played Minuet 3 by Bach, and now, I play Concerto no 3 part 4 by Seitz. So…I don’t think we speak here about years or months

I am still suffering from learning the right position of bowing even though learning for 3 weeks hahahaha😂

It honestly depends on each person individually. I had mastered vibrato and basic shifting (1st and 3rd position) after 1.5 years. I'm left handed, so the learning curve was easier for my vibrato, and it also depends on your dedication and practice time, along with teachers and such. I had a school teacher who greatly helped me with auditions for conservatories and such, and I have always been dedicated. Don't look down on your progress, as everyone is different. Great video!

5 years of practicing 40 hours a day

Today I had my first violin lesson of 40 mins.... I can play happy birthday melody....cant wait to learn more❤

By next October it will be my 3rd year of learning violin and I love your statements because they are very true. Now I'm starting to play simple bach and vivaldi concertos. At first i used to feel nervous because of getting influenced of some youtube videos that some people show they have progressed all of this witin a year. But the fact that violin is not how fast you learn but it's how persistent you are on practicing, how in tune you play and how much technique you learn and apply.

Better than I could ever do I love what you are doing right here!

Been playing for 3 years and I am currently learning the double concerto by Bach. I can play with decent vibrato. I don’t know she was so accurate.

Played twinkle twinkle little star after one lesson but I’m a guitar and ukulele player so left hand technique is similar. The bow is a whole new thing 😂

Well maybe you can fit in this time element. After ten years I still can't do vibrato. My tone definitely doesn't sound like you 😜

This was well said , my first song to learn was exactly that , twinkle twinkle little star, learning from you tube about 3 months playing … Some where over a rainbow , country road , still learning Dance monkey , despacito , some Christmas songs and other covers, I don’t know why but I can’t help wanting to learn new songs , love the violin , still got a long way to go but I am really enjoying this journey with the violin , and thanks to you I am learning a lot as well. 👍

I didn't even start 😂 but i love the violin 🎻❤

Thank you very much for pasting. You play beautifully!❤

My dream piece is zigeunweisn and erklöng 😅😅😅

I've been playing the violin for 8 years, and I'm barely in Suzuki book 2 and I can't do vibrato! I can do some vivaldi though, like concerto in a minor, summer. I'm 12 going on 13, I stopped learning for about 4-5 years.. and my violin teacher didn't really pay attention to teaching which caused me lack of practice and knowledge. any tips? 🥹

I’ve been playing violin in school since I was in 4th grade, but I started getting lessons only 3 years ago in 8th grade,,

I started playing the violin over two years ago and now i'm learning Fiocco Allegro and Vivaldi concerto in G minor, It is very fun and relaxing to play violin

I’ve been playing for a year (I was self teaching for a while) and taking lessons since June 2022. I have made it up to Etude in Suzuki book 1. I can definitely see progress since when I first started!

Me: vibrato after 2 months and playing concerts

To the people in the comments, thats cool that you learned a seitz concerto in X months, but where are you now? Are you still playing seitz concertos or are you playing Tambourin Chinois?

Thank you dear teacher!

Me on my third year and did play twinkle twinkle little star in my second year and now can maybe play like you could play in your second year if I was that good❤😢😮

Man i can play twinkle twinkle little star after 1 day i'm buying it

There is not time periods for anything! You could learn anything anytime if you practice enough

Thank you sharing ♥️

I was playing simple songs on day 3. I've played guitar and mandolin a few years, and studied music theory the same, but around 5 hours a day of practice and study. The mandolin and violin are tuned the same, so my biggest hurdle is bowing, and the G string 🤗😅😅😅

How long: the REST OF YOUR LIFE! Because all violinists usually play the rest of their lives.

I 27, have been learning for 2 month and I am practicing to play the twinkle twinkle little star now 😂 hope I can play the minuet after 1 year 🥹

.....but i learnt to play twinkle twinkle the day i got my violin which was yesterday. Well its understandable because I know a good amount of theory

I feel like a prodigy only 5 months of lessons and half way through book 3 and also twinkle little starts on my 2-3 week

I have played violin five months,but I play as good as you showed how people play violin when they have played one year.😊My Dreams song with violin is Rivers Flows In You.

I am midway through accolay and im on my first year of violin

I played twinkle twinkle little star in 2 weeks without any prior instrumental knowledge 💀

day 3 of violin was my playing of twinkle twinkle 🤩 little star ✨

I started 6 mouths ago and I'm able to play the god father and harry potter, I'm 20 btw and i always feel late

I played bach a minor concerto after 10 months and bach sarabande from partita 2 after 1 year.

amazing share

Any recommendations for a beginner violin? I have a cheap one off Amazon but it will not hold tune. The tuning pegs spin and I have rewound the strings too.

I guess it's different for each person then- - 1 year I barley played in tune with the basics - 2 years was the same thing - 4 years I masters 3rd position and is able to sound decently without sounding like a cat scratching on chalkboard - 5 years I masterd vibrato And almost moving into 6 years and there's still things I have to know about 5th and 6th position 🙃

I’ve been playing for 7 years and I mean I’m basically playing ATCL-AMusTCL so I’m not quite sure is that’s slow on track or above average could someone tell me? 😅

Not me actually learned vivaldi winter on 2 month i got the violin tuned it then immediately went to learn vivaldi winter

what is the name of the second song, the one she said you'll learn in a year?

I feel like speaking in general this is the normal time it would take to learn an instrument like violin but there are some people THT are just fast learners like for example I just started clarinet in 2022 in like august and I’m now playing things like pirates of the Caribbean and stuff but that’s just clarinet and violin is different 😅 bottom line is some people just learn faster than others❤

after 9 months of playing i can proudly say that i can play bwv 1043 🙏🙏

idk i learned twinkle in my first hour once i got that i learned ode to joy and hallelujah then in three days i learned lovely by billie and a few other songs in 3weeks i learn some vibrato no lessons but some one told me how to hold the bow that's it

what is the first year song name please

After 2months i've played here is a pirate, 4m i've played canon in d with vibrato

It also depends on what you seek. I learnt to play fairy tale in about 2 months, but I can't play any other songs, nor have I really even tried to, because I bought the violin just to learn to play that one song from my childhood.

watching this after it took me 8 years to learn vibrato ☠️☠️☠️

Can you learn violin on you're own? Or is it something you need to take lessons in?

I want to learn how to play the violin but i don't how and what to start And i don't know how to read musical notes

Interesting. I always thought I was way behind when I started vibrato at around year 3. Not that it was in any way stable or refined. I heard that students start Wohlfart etudes after 8 months. That was when I was still fighting with getting the rhythm of simple folk songs right.

Me:I would love to play the violin it’s so beautiful! Also me: heck nah I ain’t practicing for 3+ years

when will i be able to play paganini caprice no 24, ma'am?

Why are some violinists so discouraging - almost like making music a very exclusive thing? 2 months and just twinkle twinkle? Good thing I'm reading the comments section. Some people got to play something in 2 weeks - now that's encouraging. ❤

I can play vibrato for only 6 months of learning violin

It all depends on how much you practice.

I had a bit of vibrato in one day because im left handed

You have a dutch accent, are you by any chance dutch?😍❤️

What where the names of the songs you played in the video?

seriously 2 months for twinkle star? I don't know if im cheating but i did it in 2 hours, genuinely not sure if the 2 months take in account of good bow control, and decent basic foundations and twinkle star is the first piece after learning all the stuff, but i for sure jumped straight in the moment i could make a sustained sound with my bow...

What about pagnini

I learned vibrato for only 2 months.

What about the Rieding violin concerto in B minor op 35?

Either I'm a fast learner or this videos are not so accurate about the times because I touched the violin for the first time two months ago but I can play the etude (it is the 12th piece) from Suzuki violin book 1

3 and a half years, and i still can't do vibrato 😭

How about start learning at 20?what do you think about?(please the truth)😁

People say that "that 6 months is my 3 years" or something but maybe JUST maybe its because you dont practice 40 hours a day

I have learned vibrato in less than a year.

My goal is to be 1 year worth of good. Just to show off and add it to my belt of skills

Im 1 year and 8 months , ican play pop covers like my immoratl, treat y better .. :D

What about not playing classical music, but contemporary instead?

❤️💙

This is an amazing dutch accent

I’m playing the Shostakovich concerto cadenza after 6 months 😳

I feel like i can reach year 5 in one year. Ive been playint guitar since 2005. Lol does that count?

Wait I’ve only been learning for a month and I’ve finished Sibelius concerto and the Bach chaconne. But I did already have a head start from cello. But you sound so good 😊

5 years

Well, Teacher, I want to self teach myself, I've just got a violin on my birthday, Is that possible?

2 hours you mean?

I could play twinkle twinkle in 7 hours

Once simply violin comes out ppl be playing vibrato after day two💀

Me learns National anthem in 2 weeks and look at this my face 😐 Edit: self taught

How long for sherlock holmes theme

I learned twinkle twinkle my first day ☠️☠️

You play vibrato in first year 😂 then you mentioned you can play vibrato in third year.... I'm just teasing for fun I'm a beginner just reach first year ....love your channel keep up the good work 😊

I've been playing for 4 years and still haven't learned to shift and vibrato

Dit lijkt op nederlande mensen die engels praten?

i am learning vibrato after 1 year of playing

I absolutely hate it when people try to make timelines like this. They're complete and utter bullshit. Yeah, you're trying to make interesting content and help people manage their expectations and all that, good for you. But even trying to make a rough estimate like this is just absolutely ridiculous, bordering on insane. Even when you're talking about a young child this is stupid af but for an adult? Someone actually old enough to watch this video and understand what it says? That just shows you put zero thought into it. How much practice time does the person have? How much motivation? What is their learning mentality? Do they move on too quick? Stay on the same "safe" piece for too long? Do they get lessons or not? How good is their teacher? How often do they get lessons? How much musical experience do they have before this? Did they ever play a string instrument before? What are they trying to achieve at all? Hell, did they do fucking clapping games in primary school?? The idea that you can say anything at all of value on the topic of a timescale for learning an instrument that is valid for even just 10% of learners out there is insane and quite arrogant.

Lmao im learning that same exact concerto by Accolay after 2 years of playing;-;;-;

Yeah for a talented if not it will take maybe 20 years

I dont understand this concept and it annoys me. You can "play" most compositions early on, however the sound might be bad. Measuring in the compositions is stupid, measure in sound...

Done all of them in 2 years by just practicing about 8 hours a day

In one month I learned hallelujah, isn’t that normal???

Am i the only one here who can play suzuki book in just 5 months???