Is Manchester City's dominance a problem?

  Рет қаралды 26,101

The Athletic FC Podcast

The Athletic FC Podcast

Жыл бұрын

Manchester City booked their place in the Champions League final this week as they continue their pursuit of the treble. So is there any stopping their dominance - and is it a problem in terms of competitive balance? Jack Pitt-Brooke and Mark Critchley joined Mark Chapman to discuss on Thursday...
Check out the rest of this episode and The Athletic Football Podcast five times a week this season...
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast...
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/69AAB4o...
Subscribe to The Athletic UK channel 👉 bit.ly/athleticuk | 🔔Make sure to enable all push notifications!🔔
The Athletic is currently offering a special price subscription of £2/$2 a month for the first 12 months. To redeem that limited-time-only offer go to 👉 theathletic.com/footballpod
Follow The Athletic FC:
Website 👉 theathletic.com
Twitter 👉 / theathleticfc
Instagram 👉 / theathleticfc
Facebook 👉 / theathleticfc
Follow Tifo Football:
Website 👉 tifofootball.com
Twitter 👉 / tifofootball_
Facebook 👉 / tifofootball
Instagram 👉 / tifofootball_
Subscribe to Tifo Football 👉 bit.ly/TifoFootball
#manchestercity #ucl #theathletic

Пікірлер: 232
@PaddyMcMe
@PaddyMcMe Жыл бұрын
Look I don't want to be this 'Liverpool' guy but if you look at the 4 seasons between 2019-2022 Liverpool had 1 less point than than Man City. Man City won 2 League titles by a 1 point over Liverpool, then lost to Liverpool by 20ish and then beat Liverpool by 20ish. If you include this trainwreck of a season then yeah City now have a 20-25 point advantage over Liverpool from the previous 5 seasons. They haven't dominated alone, Liverpool were almost exactly as successful in the league over a 4 year period they just got terribly unlucky on the last day twice. As a Liverpool fan we were 4 PL points and 4 UCL final Goals away from having 3 EPL titles & 3 UCL titles instead of just 1 of each. Fine margins.
@Truebro79
@Truebro79 Жыл бұрын
Madrid got to 4 UCL finals in 6 years and won it 4 times, but Man City being in 2 UCL finals in 3 years is the end of the world.
@thedragonofechigo7878
@thedragonofechigo7878 Жыл бұрын
Such bias honestly but I guess Madrid get a pass because it's prestige
@chad9971
@chad9971 Жыл бұрын
Yeah you're actually right. Madrid assembled damn near the Avengers to hold the UCL by the neck for a few years.
@Truebro79
@Truebro79 Жыл бұрын
@@HarmvanderWilt yeah but in this video they mentioned how people are concerned that Man City are now in 2 UCL finals in the last 3 years and if something needs to be done about it lol
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Жыл бұрын
UEFA banned City on 0 Proof PL press 100+ charges on City When UEFA couldn't prove 1 City Vs Establishment?🤔
@CarlinConnolly
@CarlinConnolly Жыл бұрын
great point - although the same argument is used by Real themselves when justifying the super league
@subboid
@subboid Жыл бұрын
If City win the UCL this year then they have a good chance of matching RM's threepeat, because the only thing they've been lacking in previous competitions is the mentality. They, like PSG, have consistently bottled under the pressure. But winning the trophy will remove 90% of that going forward. They'll be playing with the same ease they play in the EPL
@WOOOPdoctorFROGhere
@WOOOPdoctorFROGhere Жыл бұрын
it's interesting watching that mentality develop/improve over the past decade or so. I still remember when they went to Madrid, City had a decent team back then, Kompany Toure Silva etc yet the collective mentality was like a rabbit in the headlights. The same when Bayern came to the Etihad and Robben and co had them about 3 nil up in the first half. It's taken a while for City to develop that belief that a big club should have. I'm not sure they'd have managed that without bringing in Pep.
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Жыл бұрын
UEFA banned City on 0 proof UEFA to let City win CL?🤔
@williambenner1790
@williambenner1790 Жыл бұрын
Dominance that comes from financial doping is a problem.
@davidevans916
@davidevans916 Жыл бұрын
Exactly, it’s cheating
@lorddiegocosta3307
@lorddiegocosta3307 Жыл бұрын
The dominance is Pep's. Its because of him you need to be one of the best PL sides ever in order to even get close to winning the title, the standards are just too high. Once he leaves City won't be as dominant and standards around the league will fall. If they win the treble this year I think a lot of their current crop will leave for new challenges. Lets not act like they've won it just yet though, given their European pedigree and the sheer unpredictability its far from a foregone conclusion
@brothatisfunny
@brothatisfunny Жыл бұрын
Where would he go thou? PSG is too easy, no club in Italy have the money he usually spend, Barcelona is very fine with Xavi and i doubt he will go to nation since it takes too much time between games to coach his style of football
@Kobble8
@Kobble8 Жыл бұрын
@@brothatisfunnyhe didn’t really spend much at barca tbf, a lot of the starters were youth graduates
@lorddiegocosta3307
@lorddiegocosta3307 Жыл бұрын
@@brothatisfunny Before covid I wouldve said Juve but they're in the gutter at the moment. Perhaps lets see who Inter's new owners will be and how willing they are to spend, that could be a potential option for him. Of course if he wants to try and shed his image of going to places with the resources already in place he should go to anyone of Italy's biggest clubs
@CarlinConnolly
@CarlinConnolly Жыл бұрын
Inter are in some ways a bad team for City since they play a 5-3-2 where it is basically 6-2-2 without the ball and they work ferociously hard to win the ball back so it won't be easy to score against them but they are too imprecise in midfield to beat CIty, unless they score at least one worldie, and CIty have a brain-fade. Pep won't overthink this one - he doesn't need to. They do have a threat on the break and Acerbi will give Haaland a hard time (painful might be a better word) but i can't see their midfield coping with CIty and that means they'll need luck and even then, City have plenty of gears and plenty of options on the bench. But if Lukaku starts and Dumfries finds space and the Ref allows some physicality then if Inter nick a lead they can defend it.
@lorddiegocosta3307
@lorddiegocosta3307 Жыл бұрын
@@CarlinConnolly Its a good thing its a final, all form will have gone out the window. Inter know they'll have to play the perfect game and they'll have all the motivation in the world to win. Practically everyone, including a few of those city players, believe they've already won it. Don think I need to explain more on that front.
@viktorviktorelius4032
@viktorviktorelius4032 Жыл бұрын
Amazed by how shallow this clip was.
@fader1912
@fader1912 Жыл бұрын
All I see is jealousy.. if city weren’t winning no one would care just like Chelsea who have spent so much and will likely spend 200mil more but because they’re not winning no one cares. This is just jealousy speaking
@aadirao9401
@aadirao9401 Жыл бұрын
So true
@hunterzolomon1303
@hunterzolomon1303 Жыл бұрын
Yup. Those big clubs in europe complaing, forget that in their own leagues they have pretty much absolute superiority. In the interest in fairness would they not give up some of their privilledges to make it more even.
@thariqrudywilloughby660
@thariqrudywilloughby660 Жыл бұрын
That was about as even handed as anyone could possibly be. Did you even watch the clip? They said Man City are dominant and more of a force than Barca/RMadrid/Bayern/PSG because the PL has the best revenues. At the same time, you can't deny that their road to success was paved by money from Abu Dhabi. City play amazing football, and is no doubt coached by the preeminent genius in football today. Hell, their recruitment has been amazing and puts Man U, Chelsea, even Liverpool to shame (i think Haaland, Akanji and Alvarez put together cost the same as Nunez). But the resources they have smoothes over all the friction you might stumble over if you were owned by individual billionaires (Glazers, FSG, Kroenke) as opposed to a rich government that literally makes a football club its soft power project. Look at Newcastle - from relegation bound to 4th place. Don't tell me oil money doesnt make a difference. Amazed how knee jerk and shallow your comment is.
@Sproles11
@Sproles11 Жыл бұрын
@@thariqrudywilloughby660not a single person here has said money doesn’t matter. You wrote a whole essay about stuff nobody said. The point is that it’s a shallow video. They spoke for 8+ minutes and didn’t actually say anything
@Jellyisamazing
@Jellyisamazing Жыл бұрын
The problem is, city are owned by a country, have broken several FFP rules, fixed the books to make enormous profits, despite not selling all their final tickets and struggle to sell home games. They are a good side, sure, but it's been allowed to happen by everyone turning a blind eye to the illegal proceedings
@gentleken7864
@gentleken7864 Жыл бұрын
Yep, but it all falls on deaf ears because we're supposed to be blinded by the football. The average cost of the City team that beat Real last week was something like 56 million quid. There were two players in the first team who cost under 40 million quid. Not one youth team player started the game. The total cost of the team was over 620 million pounds. If City hadn't won, it would have been a massive failure, considering how much the team cost. Football has become so 'meh' and it'll get worse.
@Jellyisamazing
@Jellyisamazing Жыл бұрын
@@gentleken7864 don't get me wrong, it was a game of old money in football, and new money, i.e. oil states buying clubs. I'm all for clubs getting investment, development in local areas, but it's so wrong how it's been passed off as a good thing. United had a Ruppert Murdoch take over rejected, on the premises of keeping competition, but how can anyone compete with city, Newcastle, and PSG? They can make endless mistakes and fix the boxes so they run at a profit. Atleast Chelsea could admit they were bleeding money. There's no way city pull in the profits they do, you don't just jump ahead of Liverpool, United, Madrid, Barcelona, Milan in a space of 10 years and blow them out of the water, it doesn't happe
@JD-mc3bl
@JD-mc3bl Жыл бұрын
Not their dominance, but their financial frauds - a staggering 110 cases is really concerning
@changingways28
@changingways28 Жыл бұрын
As a Madrid fan honestly City were just way better than us on Wednesday night and deserved to win. It's not a money issue as it is they have just put together a better team, and we have to respond. I think the other clubs in the "Big Six" are the ones who need to concerned. Because in a league where everyone has money if one team is still winning the title every year that could create a problem.
@Liamm_7
@Liamm_7 Жыл бұрын
If city weren't cheating they wouldn't be able to afford that squad and you would've beat them, they made real Madrid redundant, your fans and market don't matter anymore because one of the smallest teams in the prem just Cheated arguably the biggest team in the world, united and Liverpool dominate Manchester, city are tiny in comparison, you were robbed.
@eavyeavy2864
@eavyeavy2864 Жыл бұрын
Fun fact. The season we run the league vs Mourinho was our 3rd best season in 6 years. Jose’s MUTD (81) would only equal our worst side during covid (81p). both are lower to peak Poch Tottenham (86)
@kutlomahole7301
@kutlomahole7301 Жыл бұрын
Before Pep came the english media where so arrogant that they believed the premier league can't become a farmers league but here we are!!! If you want to win the league you have to have 95+ points to stand a chance.
@aakarmamtora3470
@aakarmamtora3470 Жыл бұрын
And cheat
@Loosetweezers
@Loosetweezers Жыл бұрын
I mean a PL team just walked over the supposed best teams in the world like they were mid table teams... Barca couldn't even make the knockouts and both milan teams are mediocre at best.
@abduraxmaan450
@abduraxmaan450 Жыл бұрын
@@Loosetweezers sevilla who are struggled all year made top 4 team look like sunday league side
@Sproles11
@Sproles11 Жыл бұрын
Crazy how we’re at the point where people just say that Abu Dhabi bought the club. That is not true.
@ymo6096
@ymo6096 Жыл бұрын
The way people are worried about City is worrying.. Take Pep out of City and players are regular players. City only has one 100M players while Madrid and Barca have multiple. What is the issue here????
@nicolasaldape3286
@nicolasaldape3286 Жыл бұрын
maybe, considering the 100+ FFP charges that won't go anywhere
@brothatisfunny
@brothatisfunny Жыл бұрын
Yes, cause they are not my team
@liammichon1784
@liammichon1784 Жыл бұрын
There's two points that I think they're missing: 1. Of City's four title winning seasons since Guardiola arrived, two were won by a margin of one point and this season will likely be won by a margin of less than five (assuming they win). In 2019/20, they finished 18 points behind Liverpool. So, in four seasons since 2017/18, Manchester City have had a serious challenger to the league title. 2. Manchester City haven't really been that dominant in the Champions League. Real Madrid won the competition four times in the space of six years (a run which includes three in succession). Before their final appearance in 2021, they had never progressed past the quarter-final stage.
@user-bh2xq6wg1e
@user-bh2xq6wg1e Жыл бұрын
Listen mate, this is The Athletic. Stop talking sense and get back on track with the "City are cheats" stuff the punters all love.
@Saeroye
@Saeroye Жыл бұрын
Narrative ignores all facts! If anything the premier benefited from city’s current presence and the league is competitive no where near being farmers league.
@Tiger_the_Gunner
@Tiger_the_Gunner Жыл бұрын
Only Rice can't help Arsenal to win major trophy, Gunners also must have to sign Caicedo and Kim-Min-Jae 💰 They also must grab the opportunity to sign free agents like Benzema & Gundogan to strengthen the depth of our squad 💪🏽 #Invest_or_KroenkeOut
@gofannon1943
@gofannon1943 Жыл бұрын
They are owned by a repressive nation state with infinite wealth. Imo the FA by allowing this to happen have ruined club football for generations. It’s not a competition anymore, it’s oligarchy.
@user-tw9mh2cu5v
@user-tw9mh2cu5v Жыл бұрын
You can definitely tell City just won an important game of football
@Loosetweezers
@Loosetweezers Жыл бұрын
115 charges
@user-tw9mh2cu5v
@user-tw9mh2cu5v Жыл бұрын
@@Loosetweezers 116 lawyers
@gomey70
@gomey70 Жыл бұрын
All built on cheating. And that's what this team will be remembered for.
@johnmurphy4915
@johnmurphy4915 Жыл бұрын
Was it a problem when Man United dominated for two decades,or when Liverpool dominated in the 70s, or is it because Man City , have broken the there stranglehold on winning everything, next it will probably Newcastle, and good luck to them.
@Saeroye
@Saeroye Жыл бұрын
When Chelsea came along and ruined the party in top 4 premiere became exciting. Man City took it one step further especially with man United being pushed off that season under Mancini where they went on to win the league still stayed with me. With tv deals that followed making prem richer showed impact of Man City breaking up the top 4. The benefit has been felt and it is crazy time now top managers coming to premier league look at Everton and Ancelotti. We really have to look at how bad Man City is making the league when next tv deal renewal soon is renegotiated. I don’t think it will be going lower.
@trakticks
@trakticks Жыл бұрын
All these pundits kept putting out videos all week about how Madrid was the most dangerous side in the world. The champions league is their trophy, they know how to win it. Now that Madrid have been slapped up like a non league team the tune has changed to money, sovereign wealth and passive aggressive nonsense. You want a fair league then start by requiring all clubs to only spend the equal share rights revenue on the squad. Clubs that have a huge fanbase is an unfair advantage because they can tap into those resources. Stadium revenue, gate receipts, sponsorship, should all be regarded as profits generated and shouldn't be used to strengthen the team. Leicester did everything the right way they won the league against all odds and then? Lost their players to bigger clubs. It's impossible to compete with historical clubs. If everyone has the same amount to spend then slowly the wages and transfer fees will start to come down, ticket prices will become more affordable and football clubs will be profitable. Cream will rise to the top but we all know the cartel clubs don't want that.
@ahasiikuyu8001
@ahasiikuyu8001 Жыл бұрын
In the Champions League, Man City are still underdogs this is the second Final they'll appear in having failed to win their first, but ever since Pep arrived at Man City it's all been about taking City to the next level and challenging the European Elites. They have raised the standards over the previous +-4 seasons and the other teams around them will just have to compete (including those in epl).
@aayanbhadoria9147
@aayanbhadoria9147 Жыл бұрын
the hell these people are talking about? real madrid have been to 11 ucl semis in the last 13 years and have won it 5 times since 2014, that is called a dynasty, reaching 2 finals in 3 years does not create a dynasty. Do real madrid barcelona and bayern care about man city's success?No they dont but they do care about the FFP breaches and inflated sposonship deals city have signed
@GamerFlair
@GamerFlair Жыл бұрын
If Man City win the CL, the will go along way to removing future FFP issues. The whole issue that City have had with FFP is down to them not being as big a club as others historically and therefore in order to spend as much as the european establishment (And especially Manchester United due to them being in the same domestic league) they have pretty much probably had to fiddle. Playing this brand of football and winning leagues and now champion leagues will get them the global reach so that there are not issues with FFP. And I think thats the whole issue with PSG and the french league. PSG kind of have to try and force a Glactico image to drive the base levels of revenue for the club to comply with FFP because thier base revenue from the league is fuck all because no-one watches it. Thats the core issue the european clubs really have. FFP is kind of a borked system at this point because what it will essentially do is over time, make it near impossible for any teams to compete with English ones, in the same way that overtime it makes it impossible for smaller clubs to ever catch the bigger ones unless that get absolutely mismanaged. City get alot of shit for spending money, but ultimately, they haven't actually spent more money then United, or Chelsea in the same league. They keep destroying those teams because they actually have good people running thier club.
@Jellyisamazing
@Jellyisamazing Жыл бұрын
Your right, they haven't spent as much, but we all know Chelsea run on losses and have to balance books with selling talent, Uniteds cash reserve's have all but run out, but city are now left unchecked to spend as they please as long as they sign a new dodgy sponsorship. It's crazy
@GamerFlair
@GamerFlair Жыл бұрын
@@Jellyisamazing Chelsea were basically doing exactly the same thing as City. There were also a small club. The main difference was that when FFP hit they were a bit bigger as they benefited from a massive bank rolling owner pre-FFP and the extra commercial revenue they get due to that success. Only reason Chelsea are in trouble is because they have spent more in the last 12 months then even the biggest spenders in world football spend in half a decade. United aren't out of cash. They haven't had "cash" since the takeover. They are able to continue spending due to thier revenue and regardless of whatever happens with ownership, that will continue since even if they don't end up selling, its clearly been demonstrated how much people ARE willing to pay for the club and therefore its valuation has shot up, enabling more money to leveraged from the banks. The fact is, whilst they have signed a few suspect sponsorship deals... they probably won't need to much longer. Because next time those contracts come up for renewal... well they will be worth that. A Team that wins 6 out of the last 7 leagues in the world most watched football league, playing a brand of football admired by all around the world, with a manager who most people regard quite fondly as a geninus and a pretty decent bloke. And now European success too? Look, I'm an Arsenal fan so I could sing a grand old song about how all these clubs spending money is unfair. But ultimately, it is what it is. If City were spending vastly more then thier peers then sure. Maybe thats a fair argument. But ultimately, City haven't spent more then Chelsea and United. Both of those clubs are been on a equal economic footing with City and they lost because City just did it better. They deserve plaudits for that.
@Saeroye
@Saeroye Жыл бұрын
There is a period that when City ‘s money is destroying the league narrative can be pushed for so long, when in it is actually mismanagement at other clubs who are not successful on pitch. This narrative can only go on for so long. There is so much money swelling in premier league and City being good only benefits the league getting more money. Watch next tv deals renewal go off the roof. The 115 chargers is football politics yet again.
@thechriscrowing
@thechriscrowing Жыл бұрын
As a Man Utd fan, it's not a problem because it's not boring dominance. City are about to win the league for the third Time in a row - a feat only matched by United (twice) in the Premiership era - but Arsenal ran them to the last few games, Liverpool lost out by a point last year. In the past ten years, six clubs have won the Premier League. That's healthy. In Germany, its all Bayern, in Italy its four teams (in the last 4 years as well), in Spain its three teams but with no extended dominance by any one. The EPL is healthy, although TBF City have raised the ceiling with 90+ points almost demanded to win the title now, but by and large, the challenge is met by ither clubs and thats the whole game, isn't it? Now, if City win five or more titles in a row, with a ridiculous lead so theres no drama, start retaining the ECL... then it's a problem. Like in wrestling, you gotta beat the man to be the man, and right now, City are the man and when they get beaten it'll feel so good for whoever does it.
@abduraxmaan450
@abduraxmaan450 Жыл бұрын
they are about to win 5 in 6 after this season. those other "farmer" leagues are not winnning the league by 20 pts every szn. its the same where team pretends they are competing and lose towards the end.
@lorddiegocosta3307
@lorddiegocosta3307 Жыл бұрын
In order to be competitive the standards need to be lower. Serie A has lost Juve's quality but has become the most competitive league in Europe, La Liga has decreased quality and become slightly less predictable but still rather boring. The last few years have certainly been more boring compared to older PL years due to a higher standard. The late 90s/early 2000s PL was much lower in quality but arguably the most competitive it ever was.
@fader1912
@fader1912 Жыл бұрын
@@abduraxmaan450 😂😂😂 I’ve got news for you… serie a was just won by a massive gap of 14 points… all you had to do was google and you would’ve not looked silly
@fader1912
@fader1912 Жыл бұрын
@@lorddiegocosta3307 😂 so you’d rather watch shit football as long as it’s competitive? There’s Sunday league for that, maybe stick to that and let the actual football fans watch some good football? Also, how on earth are you even talking to city as a Chelsea fan… you guys just spent like half a billion anyways and you’re going to spend another 200 at least when poch decides he doesn’t want some of those 40 players and wants more players 😂😭🤦🏻‍♂️
@fader1912
@fader1912 Жыл бұрын
Would we really be having this conversation if City weren’t winning? I don’t think so… this all comes from jealousy of city winning soo much. No one is talking about the amount Chelsea have spent and how much they did spend before under abromvic… no one cared about the money when United were spending more than the rest of the league when they were dominating but now when it’s city… all these kids want to throw their toys out of the pram… listen… cry me a river because city will carry on and won’t give a shit about any of these “pundits” 😂
@vijujacob63
@vijujacob63 Жыл бұрын
ManC went a notch higher than their own high standards when Pep shifted to 3-2-4-1 formation with which they are on an unbeaten run. With a the fine-tuning their front 5 has become really potent and sooner the other team work a system to counter this, we will watch their dominance continue. PS: I'm a lifelong gooner.
@gentleken7864
@gentleken7864 Жыл бұрын
Their team that beat Real cost an average of 52 million for each player. Arsenal didn't bottle it, they just couldn't swap out 50 million pound players for other 50 million pound players.
@nicholaswalker4791
@nicholaswalker4791 Жыл бұрын
Club's aren't worried about it because if it was their club they wouldn't bat an eye lid. As a Spurs fan, I have no issue with Man City's as they've not just gone and done what PSG/Chelsea have done and spent stupidly. Man City have invested in training, the stadium, the staff and players who will make the team better. The fact they've got the best team from this is just fantastic management. Man Utd and others could set out a similar framework if they tried
@lorddiegocosta3307
@lorddiegocosta3307 Жыл бұрын
How did we spend stupidly? We renovated our base and were the most successful team in England for 20 years. We did everything City did but we needed less investment as we were closer to the finished article than City were
@richardxraj
@richardxraj Жыл бұрын
Liverpool bottled for 4 years and Arsenal are going to bottle for next few years till next club steps in. City need to start targeting 105 points next season to be considered good
@devanman7920
@devanman7920 Жыл бұрын
Liverpool bottled for 4 years? They came close and didn't quite make it against a team who spent way more and are being charged now because of it. Is bottled and bottling just the new word for dumb football fans or what?
@EnchantedPhantom12
@EnchantedPhantom12 Жыл бұрын
Why Adam Crafton is absent from this discussion? Full of Hypocrites! Shallow conversation! Athletic has an agenda
@jovenguardian
@jovenguardian Жыл бұрын
Italian pragmatism has caused more than one surprise in recent times. Plenty of talent and energy in the Inter squad to cause problemas. Watch Lautaro expose City’s limitations at the back.
@victorkwachuh9907
@victorkwachuh9907 Жыл бұрын
You think l’autarcique is better than vini Jr ????LOL
@_orodrigofernandes
@_orodrigofernandes Жыл бұрын
Basically what was done in Manchester City was they gave the resources to the most capable manager available and now we see what happens once you do that.
@eamonreidy9534
@eamonreidy9534 Жыл бұрын
Farming premier leagues is one thing but doing it when you're likely guilty of financial doping is another issue
@strictlyfootball7859
@strictlyfootball7859 Жыл бұрын
I respect what they’re about to achieve a treble is something special but besides that it is a bit boring if no one can really compete with them
@TheHumanTheory
@TheHumanTheory Жыл бұрын
There are actually Man City apologists in the comments comparing their propaganda machine with a football club like Real Madrid. Manchester City isn’t old enough to drink, but it’s fans are drunk. You’re not a fanbase anyone takes seriously.
@azmcfc
@azmcfc Жыл бұрын
It wasn't a 'problem' when Liverpool were winning everything in the 80's and it wasn't a 'problem' when United were winning everything in the 90's so why is it a 'problem' when City, a club not in bed with the cartel, show a period of dominance? Salty
@koa972
@koa972 Жыл бұрын
The only problem is the FA & Premier leagues lack of punishment for their repeated FFP breaches, City have cheating for the last 8 years and will maybe get a slap on the wrist in 3/4 seasons time
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Жыл бұрын
UEFA banned City on 0 proof PL press 100+ charges on City When UEFA couldn't prove 1 City Vs Establishment?🤔
@brianshockledge3241
@brianshockledge3241 Жыл бұрын
Last 8yrs eh, in the last 5yrs City`s net spend is +£18.36m while their rivals doing it the right way are chelsea -£665m, utd -£595m, arsenal -£483m, spurs -£424m newcastle -£375m, and lpool -£278m. Yeah I can see your point?????
@ptbauro
@ptbauro Жыл бұрын
Sure, think if there's substantial evidence that city have cheated year in year out - they deserve the harshest punishment. It's dodgy as to why the Premier league didn't punish them right away. What's the point in throwing around allegations ? So it is one of 2 things : The premier league were forced by the cartel clubs to forcefully take up the investigation that took up many years to come to conclusion - but they never had substantial evidence to enforce a punishment. The other point is city are not guilty but Premier league wants to pretend to be strict and severe as a direct response to the UK govt's white papers on an independent arbitrator Look at what UEFA did - they found city guilty of cheating - and then banned them outright for 2 seasons from the UCL. Why not ban/relegate city straight away ?Why appoint a panel and then go through the judiciary process? It's important to note that the UAE and UK have vital trade links. The UK Govt wants this to be brushed aside asap.
@alfredthegreat9543
@alfredthegreat9543 Жыл бұрын
​@brianshockledge3241 Think you're not understanding how spending works. They spent ridiculous amounts to get the players....that they then sell later, which makes the last 5 years figures look OK. But it was the obvious cheating that got them to that point. And yes, it is cheating, and is not to be respected at all. No-one wants a a procession of owners cheating by spending crazy amounts to buy success.
@mikhailtaal7752
@mikhailtaal7752 Жыл бұрын
@@ptbauro what a stupid essy u wrote? When did city got 2 yrs. Ban??
@mujeebahmed7940
@mujeebahmed7940 Жыл бұрын
No; other teams just in and around just need to spend more.
@rw4025
@rw4025 Жыл бұрын
Generally a good discussion. But I'm slightly staggered that we've had seven minutes and not a single word on the 115 charges of financial misconduct against them. If a cyclist was about to win their 5th Tour De France in 6 years, but had just been accused by the Tour De France authorities of doping, people would be mentioning that when talking about their success. For me, as outstanding as City's players/manager are, there'll forever be an asterisk around their success because of this.
@aakarmamtora3470
@aakarmamtora3470 Жыл бұрын
No. On the footballing side the staff and squad deserve credit but that's pretty much it. We all know WHY their dominance is questioned so let's not be naive. The fact it took them so long to be in 2 ucl finals is evidence that this dominance won't prevail every season and certainly not in all major competitions. Even this season they're favorites to win the cup competitions and people are acting like they've already done it
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Жыл бұрын
City going after Utd 3peat Howard Webb made Chief Ref Rashford Offside goal given Vs City UEFA banned City on 0 proof CL,FA Cup Winner already decided?🤔
@johnclark1925
@johnclark1925 Жыл бұрын
It is quite simple. The tenets of Financial Fair Play (FFP) need to be strengthened such that clubs cannot resort to legal obfuscation. There needs to be a change in EPL rules to the model used by the Inland Revenue (a framework they apply for the same reasons the EPL need it) namely they face the wealthy parties who have more resources and focus to use courts to avoid penalties for clear breaches. In the revised framework clubs must submit to the FFP rules, comply with all investigation, be wholly compliant in all ways or be found guilty without recourse. Onus should be squarely on the clubs to comply. Anything other given the scale of the money involved should be seen as fraud and placed into the hands of bodies that can prosecute it i.e. Crown Prosecution. This is the only way one can stop the clubs using their huge resource to their unfair advantage. Denying them access to a raft of solicitors, courts to delay and influence. In addition, no State should be able to purchase a club. They are too powerful to control, they have money, resources such as solicitors, IT hacking and not spoken about but relevant is intelligence services that provide dossiers on players, managers and officials. Gambling problems, affairs and seedy behaviours are known… leaked and used. Look at some of the bizarre VAR decisions that have led to titles won… I have no confidence in any part of our League as the clubs are not controlled by the rules.
@nigl2807
@nigl2807 Жыл бұрын
Main stream media seem to always talk down or ignore the money and resources have at their disposal (PSG and now Newcastle). Guess they bought the EPL title again.
@AS088
@AS088 Жыл бұрын
The Answer is Yes its a huge problem
@StopLookingAtMyAcc
@StopLookingAtMyAcc Жыл бұрын
Smart state ownership is a problem but when Chelsea spend the same amount in a Fraction of the time it's fine because they're shit? City spend smart Akanji 15m pound Right back left back Centre back and could probably play the new double pivot
@philmisc3513
@philmisc3513 Жыл бұрын
This is just more City hate. What a shame for The Athletic to call this biased reporting “sports journalism”. Your biases and fear are so clear!
@CROSSNSHOOT
@CROSSNSHOOT Жыл бұрын
FFP will fix Man City back to normal
@shivmmehrotra
@shivmmehrotra Жыл бұрын
City football group has teams in almost every league not just premier league
@abduraxmaan450
@abduraxmaan450 Жыл бұрын
prem has become everything we hated other leagues being, uncompetitive and predictable.
@prateshramjohn
@prateshramjohn Жыл бұрын
UEFA and the FA have dragged their feet and enabled city to become the juggernaut they are now.
@applekicks3902
@applekicks3902 Жыл бұрын
fanless small club with no history dominating? Damn.
@Beyond_Belief534
@Beyond_Belief534 Жыл бұрын
It wasn't an issue when Man United won 9 titles in 15 years. Why is that?
@infinitedivisibility
@infinitedivisibility Жыл бұрын
Presumably because United weren't being funded by a Nation State and hadn't broken over 100 FFP rules.
@mozan33r71
@mozan33r71 Жыл бұрын
United didn't cheat to do it
@lorddiegocosta3307
@lorddiegocosta3307 Жыл бұрын
@@mozan33r71 United would intimidate referees and spend so much money that teams like Blackburn, Chelsea, and Leeds nearly ruined their futures trying to keep up. They would also make sure to buy the best talent in the rest of the league so the rest couldn't build their sides. It just wasn't considered cheating because it wasn't foreign money propping it up
@Beyond_Belief534
@Beyond_Belief534 Жыл бұрын
Just a reminder. Accusing a rival of cheating without proof IS cheating
@DB-uf6md
@DB-uf6md Жыл бұрын
​@@infinitedivisibility allegedly, unless youre willing to hang people without trial. Plus, blame the english FA for allow8ng this shit
@elixirix
@elixirix Жыл бұрын
not sure the question was actually answered in this video
@chrisl3314
@chrisl3314 Жыл бұрын
Financially doped clubs are the problem, not City per se. To call clubs that are not bottlers is seriously missing the point and smacks of willful ignorance of financial reality
@CarlinConnolly
@CarlinConnolly Жыл бұрын
Pep has the environment @ City that he did not have @ Barca or Bayern - no external pressure. He won't get sacked if he has a season with no trophies and the fans won't get on his back... he knows this is his perfect environment but i think it is precisely the competitiveness of the EPL that keeps him here - he knows he'll get a couple of seasons of no trophies if he is transitioning the team. That means that he and his staff and his players operate in a kind of virtuous circle... we have to win but if we don't win today we can win tmrw.
@Tiger_the_Gunner
@Tiger_the_Gunner Жыл бұрын
City's dominance has turned EPL into a workers league, obviously that's boring 😴 But surely not in Champions league yet, no UCL trophy 😂
@mrocto4839
@mrocto4839 Жыл бұрын
It’s only been 3 years
@caseyimiller
@caseyimiller Жыл бұрын
If we were to spend that much money and then raise no standards for the league then it would be detrimental, but many would argue the style and popularity of the EPL has been dominating for a good bit now with such rich tv deals they have. Now other clubs outside the top 6 have been playing incredible football and many teams work to play out from the back… the relegation battle this season has been quite insane
@Paddykelly8418
@Paddykelly8418 Жыл бұрын
All the big players wants to go to Spain with the exception of the Manchester clubs !
@joeschmoe2030
@joeschmoe2030 Жыл бұрын
Not the English, they cream themselves with the hopes to be ordered around by a rich person.
@Jtwe
@Jtwe Жыл бұрын
This didn’t answer the question?
@shreyam1008
@shreyam1008 Жыл бұрын
Its surely more of a Pep effect. Whereever he has een he has made a dominanat league team.
@tyneskipper
@tyneskipper Жыл бұрын
hahaha. Man utd fan, didn't have a problem with his club winning every year in the 90s.
@MsZeeZed
@MsZeeZed Жыл бұрын
When Man Utd dominated it was a problem. So a silly thing called Fair Play came in and everyone said that good we’ll do that & not go bankrupt any more. Then Man City were convicted of breaching fair play (a reduced sentence does not equal innocent) that means legally they cheat. And as cheats its a big problem. However, if City were rightly disqualified we’d all be moaning about Man Utd or Liverpool winning the league 80% of the time since 1970. So it’d be just something else to complain about. Did I mention how UEFA legally proved Man City cheat? Because the FA are still looking at their cheating and wondering what to do about that. Many of us think this wondering is asking Man City how much they’d like to pay FA not to call them cheats, because £10M seems small and £100M would taste better.
@Mrstik
@Mrstik Жыл бұрын
City on the field is a joy to watch, amazing club. How they formed that team though was through financial fraud. Don't care how good they've been if they are guilty every single trophy needs to be taken away.
@brianshockledge3241
@brianshockledge3241 Жыл бұрын
You work behind the scenes at the club do you? maybe your their accountant. You claim the team was built on financial fraud then say IF they are guilty. Most of the clubs trophies won under Pep have come since 2018 which dont come under the allegations the trophies are going nowhere. The allegations are the same as bent eufa tried to stitch them up with around five over multiple seasons. Thirty more are about non cooperation, nobody in their right mind would cooperate with somebody trying to stab them in the back. The rest are a lot of waffle to make the numbers up so it looks more serious than it is. By the way the pl can do nothing about fraud that would be a matter for a criminal court.
@Mrstik
@Mrstik Жыл бұрын
@@brianshockledge3241 Please go do your own research. They WERE GUILTY and got off on a statue of limitations. They ARE GUILTY now but that doesn't mean they'll be charged as such... that was my "if", there is zero debate if they committed financial fraud or not.
@brianshockledge3241
@brianshockledge3241 Жыл бұрын
@@Mrstik Which is the narrative the red media keep pushing, it`s not true they were not found guilty. The fine was for non cooperation nothing to do with guilt.
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings Жыл бұрын
UEFA banned City on 0 proof PL press 100+ charges on City When UEFA couldn't prove 1 City Vs Establishment?🤔
@prometheus6688
@prometheus6688 Жыл бұрын
@@Mrstik just accept the fact that Man City is the best team in the world rn and stop talking bollocks , you know absolutely nothing
@daveaum
@daveaum Жыл бұрын
I'm a multi-billionaire.. I'm gonna throw a dart at a map.. the nearest football club to where that dart hits get £2.5 billion of my money. They need do nothing to earn it and they never have to pay it back to anyone.. They buy all the world's best players, managers and facilities with this money and therefore go on to win everything forevermore.. This is how football tournaments and leagues are decided nowadays.. by my dart, and where it happens to hit the map. Some of you guys are OK with this, right?!
@julianaviles4244
@julianaviles4244 Жыл бұрын
man united dominance wasn't a problem it was glorified its just the media selling it because of favoritism sales and ofc $$$$$
@apagoogootwo7552
@apagoogootwo7552 Жыл бұрын
i suspect they've bought players like grealish mostly so that other teams don't have the option. but the bargain players on the squad contribute just as much. it seems to me that the system itself, taking a player with potential and transforming them into an akanji, is the kernel of the success. and that's likely the work of pep. in a few years we'll all be talking about palmer because he'll have come through that same system. he'll be a superstar in the 2026 season. i don't see it as a problem; guys like raheem sterling, zinchenko and gabriel jesus got itchy because the city roster makes bench warmers out of guys who would be starters at any other club. so they go to other clubs. i just hope we don't lose foden.
@ronanfitzpatrick1261
@ronanfitzpatrick1261 Жыл бұрын
I don't think Grealish was worth anything near his price tag but at the same time he rarely loses possession, carries the ball well, is good in tight spaces etc. So he's a good addition to the squad and will potentially develop into a first team player
@iain2298
@iain2298 Жыл бұрын
In the first 9 years of the PL Man United won the league 7 times.
@davidevans916
@davidevans916 Жыл бұрын
The difference is they weren’t owned by a scum Muslim country
@briankin1827
@briankin1827 Жыл бұрын
Not at all,especially if you are a City fan.
@fader1912
@fader1912 Жыл бұрын
Would we really be having this conversation if City weren’t winning? I don’t think so… this all comes from jealousy of city winning soo much. No one is talking about the amount Chelsea have spent and how much they did spend before under abromvic… no one cared about the money when United were spending more than the rest of the league when they were dominating but now when it’s city… all these kids want to throw their toys out of the pram… listen… cry me a river because city will carry on and won’t give a shit about any of these “pundits” 😂
@jimbojimbo6873
@jimbojimbo6873 Жыл бұрын
Wasn’t a problem when United won it for 2 decades
@JD-mc3bl
@JD-mc3bl Жыл бұрын
FFP IS A COMPLETE JOKE. Once again proving that money talks & city will just overcome these cases of financial fraud with even more money. A sad day for football indeed, a sad day....
@Batemann1980
@Batemann1980 Жыл бұрын
No
@hanx3560
@hanx3560 Жыл бұрын
Is Manchester City's dominance a problem? It's mostly a problem to Arsenal fans who after embarrassingly bottled their only chance of a title in 2 decades are now crying because "City are too good, it's not fair" This of course is the same Arsenal who last season paid Man City 80m quid for 2 injury prone bench warmers while City paid 67m for Akanji and Haaland. Ouch. Maybe hiring Peps former kit man and cone layer with zero managerial experience was a massive mistake for Arsenal too which imo it definetely was. Let's see how many EPL clubs make an approach for Peps assistant manager Rodolfo Borrell in the summer? My guess is zero...
@ufoc700
@ufoc700 Жыл бұрын
back in feb city get charged with breaking ffp rules since 2009 over 100 times and go on to dominate the league and cl - literally no commentary on how a team that has financially cheated it’s way to the top is making the sport uncompetitive. it’s a perfect example of how unfair and corrupt things have become.
@GWJUK
@GWJUK Жыл бұрын
Ok I’ve just accused you of robbery. You must be guilty because I stated it. Fool
@user-bh2xq6wg1e
@user-bh2xq6wg1e Жыл бұрын
Sounds like you've made up your mind on the issue of City's guilt. Oh dear; how sad; never mind.
@GWJUK
@GWJUK Жыл бұрын
@@user-bh2xq6wg1e yeah of course. Knobber
@ufoc700
@ufoc700 Жыл бұрын
@@user-bh2xq6wg1e not me - the premiere league made up it’s mind and brought charges. i’d remind you the prem league are a members only club so for them to bring charges on one of it’s own speaks to the extent of the problem.
@Mcfctreble23
@Mcfctreble23 Жыл бұрын
City are 10th in net spend behind villa spurs Arsenal Utd Chelsea Newcastle liVARpool😂
@user-tw9mh2cu5v
@user-tw9mh2cu5v Жыл бұрын
"City have turned the league into the farmers league, just like Bayern did" Yes we have won 4 out of 5 and soon to be 5 out of 6, but only 2 of those titles were won 'easily', the rest have always been up to the last game of the season and this season with Arsenal could go to the last game. We are 'dominating' but its been incredibly difficult, and yes we spend money, but so does everyone else. Im not gonna go on about our great net spend figure because it largely is irrelevant, the best indicator is a clubs wage bill and currently we are 3rd behidn Chelsea and United iirc. The uncomfortable truth is we are an amazingly well run club who have been self sufficient for years, we burnt through tons of money at the start to get our commerical gears going and now we live off our commerical revenues and fees we get from transfers. Our dominance is not a problem, it was certainly never a problem for United under Ferguson so why is it now?
@jayLo28829
@jayLo28829 Жыл бұрын
Well run clubs don’t get issued 100+ charges by the very organisation that should value them the most. Cheats.
@andrew_l1900
@andrew_l1900 Жыл бұрын
Plus their way around ffp has been to get massively over inflated sponsorship deals with businesses in bed with the owner that are way above market value, and they then petitioned for it to be outlawed to prevent Newcastle or any other club from doing the same thing but not making it retroactive so they could keep theirs in place. Scummy as hell.
@knottastu
@knottastu Жыл бұрын
FFP is a joke
@mrallyoop10
@mrallyoop10 Жыл бұрын
You lot are haters.
@chubbygreyhound1198
@chubbygreyhound1198 Жыл бұрын
Of course they cheated.
@6b3baz
@6b3baz Жыл бұрын
it was not a problem when it was Man utd ....
@DB-uf6md
@DB-uf6md Жыл бұрын
Facts.
@XavierJAlexander
@XavierJAlexander Жыл бұрын
It wasn’t plastic when it was Man Utd and wasn’t done by cheating
@adtastic1533
@adtastic1533 Жыл бұрын
No 1, It was a problem when United were winning every season. No 2 Man United weren't winning the League with 100 points every year No 3 United didn't have over 100 charges of cheating against them. Countries shouldn't be allowed to own teams. It's ridiculous.
@DB-uf6md
@DB-uf6md Жыл бұрын
@@adtastic1533 assuming theyre guilty without trial is not how the law works.
@the_walrus67
@the_walrus67 Жыл бұрын
United revenue was “organic” from TV rights and commercial deals (even during their downfall post SAF they maintained commercial deal strength). The issue with City (and potentially in the future Newcastle) is that it’s basically immense capital injection. When it happened to Chelsea, it wasn’t sovereign wealth but an individual wealth. Sovereign wealth is a whole different universe than commercial deals and billionaire individual wealth.
@andrewsouth1696
@andrewsouth1696 Жыл бұрын
If Pep leaves and Chelsea or United take things seriously, the dominance ends
@jerrycastaneda5262
@jerrycastaneda5262 Жыл бұрын
So winning constantly is a problem 😂 sorry as losers the premier league is the worst league ever
@RuperttWind
@RuperttWind Жыл бұрын
What a useless news outlet
@davidevans916
@davidevans916 Жыл бұрын
Man City are everything wrong with football currently. A plastic club bankrolled by a barbaric Muslim country. Money is ruining the sport
@Pobaika
@Pobaika Жыл бұрын
Tired of this talk now. Other teams has had their eras Liverpool in the 80s, UTD in their 90’s to esrly 2000’s and now city. Just enjoy it 🥱
Man City allegations explained: Conspiracies, lies and appeals
18:59
The Athletic FC Podcast
Рет қаралды 160 М.
Why have Bayern Munich appointed Vincent Kompany?
36:07
The Athletic FC Podcast
Рет қаралды 59 М.
Chips evolution !! 😔😔
00:23
Tibo InShape
Рет қаралды 42 МЛН
UFC 302 : Махачев VS Порье
02:54
Setanta Sports UFC
Рет қаралды 663 М.
КАКОЙ ВАШ ЛЮБИМЫЙ ЦВЕТ?😍 #game #shorts
00:17
Why Arsenal Will Be Even BETTER Next Season
9:42
Woklz Football
Рет қаралды 15 М.
Manchester City: Champions with allegations
17:41
The Athletic FC Podcast
Рет қаралды 29 М.
Glasner is CHANGING The Premier League.
5:06
Toby Westwood
Рет қаралды 3,1 М.
The new Club World Cup explained - and why 'football wants this'
15:15
The Athletic FC Podcast
Рет қаралды 12 М.
HANSI FLICK: HIS FIRST DAY AT FC BARCELONA 🔵🔴
6:34
FC Barcelona
Рет қаралды 1 МЛН
Will the Premier League’s dominance ‘break’ European football?
10:21
The Athletic FC Podcast
Рет қаралды 18 М.
Why multi-club ownership poses a huge threat to football's future
11:15
The Athletic FC Podcast
Рет қаралды 20 М.
100% Disrespectful Moments 😥
0:24
Naples90
Рет қаралды 17 МЛН
Ответил за слова здоровьем!
1:00
БЕЗУМНЫЙ СПОРТ
Рет қаралды 681 М.
HIGHLIGHTS | Dmitry Bivol vs. Malik Zinad (Riyadh Season)
3:30
DAZN Boxing
Рет қаралды 470 М.
裁判说了啥,懂得翻译一下! #格斗  #裁判#shorts
0:17
He Really Ran a 4.21...
0:19
NFL City
Рет қаралды 25 МЛН
格斗裁判暴力执法!#fighting #shorts
0:15
武林之巅
Рет қаралды 89 МЛН