I know people have already mentioned the well-known fan theory that Charlie is the baby boy, Uncle Jack is the Night Man, and the troll is Charlie’s mum (with the rent Jack payed being the ‘toll’), but my favourite extension is that it’s actually Mac that is the Day Man (hence why Charlie wanted him to play that character, and because in Charlie’s eyes he is ‘the master of karate and friendship’). So as a silver lining to this very dark analogy, it was actually Charlie’s childhood friendship with Mac that helped him cope with and overcome everything that had happened.

Truly legendary episode. They actually went on some live gigs doing the Nightman show btw.

Let me tell you something, This show hasn’t even begun to peak. And when it does peak, you'll know. Because it’s gonna peak so hard that everybody in Philadelphia's gonna feel it.

The cast actually preformed this play live many years ago!

Can't forget about the troll toll if you want the boysoul.

Trust me, this show hasn’t even begun to peak. When it peaks, you’ll feel it

The truth is there is no peak. Even the seasons that are viewed as “lesser quality” by hardcore fans still have some incredible episodes in them. Some of my favorite episodes happen in season 13 and 14.

Yes! I've been looking forward to this one! 😂

The “dude do you have a boner right now” had me howling laughing when I first saw this episode. Comes out of nowhere 😂

This was the first episode I ever saw. Some friends said the new episode of Sunny was airing, I had never heard of it. I watched it with them and the next day went and bought season 1-3 on DVD. Been hooked ever since!

Oh man this episode is so good, I remember singing "tiny boy, little boy, baby boy I need you..." for like a week after I watched this for the first time

They actually performed a live performance of this at Comic-Con. One year. Whole cast. Full outfits and songs 😂

I don't know if anybody told you the popular fan theory of Dayman, but the little boy (Charlie), nightman (Uncke Jack), and the troll (Charlie's mom). I am sure you can figure out the story from there.

Funny thing is since this episode aired a lot of people have used Charlie’s ending song to propose to their partners 😂

i LOVE how much you enjoyed this episode. i seen too many reactors find the entire thing cringe (which it is, but that keeps them from enjoying it). you guys saw this episode for the ridiculous nonsense it is and i could tell you had fun with this one. it's a very beloved episode to lots of it's always sunny fans. the gang used to perform it live when they'd do meet and greets. as goofy as this epiosde is, you can see how talented they all are. i mean, glenn literally went to juliard and trained there. they all can sing and know instruments and can both film act and theater act which isn't always the easiest thing to switch between. i just love it so much!

Season 5 is where the show really comes into its own, and aside from a few weak episodes, its just top tier entertainment. Well, 13 had some behind the scenes issues that reflect in the latter half, but other than that.

Stage Freeze !! Dont SAY stage freeze just DO it ! XD XD XD

SO WILL YOU MARRY MEEEEEEEeeeeEe!?..........no Charlie I will never marry you

In everybody's top 5. If it isn't, I don't trust them 😅

"Is this one of your walking places?" lmfao Charlie

Recently on their podcast the gang said they didn’t feel like they really started to find the show until season 4.

Personally, I think the peak is as late as S12

This show never peaks. It has it's ups and downs and some episodes and entire seasons don't have the same punch as others, but for the most part it's a plateau of good (and often great) quality. There really is no peak.

I think the peak is in the season 7

This is probably my absolute favorite episode from its always sunny. Seing a reacct video and reading the comments makes me feel sooo good in my boyysssouull. God bless you all and this show and everyone that created it 💜💜💜💜

I think the PEAK of the show is somewhere around 7-12 ish, but the show is still great season 16 episode 1 came out this week and it was good

Widely regarded as the best episode… not in my opinion. But that‘s just because there is so many great ones more to come. Season 5 especially is fucking great :)

Best reaction is when Dean says, "What is this?" 😂

You guys had the energy of a really sassy English professor saying to a student “I don’t know, *can* you go to the bathroom???”

Dee’s a bird

Mac's "Sun sun sun" in dayman song always gets me.

Hasn’t even begun to peak, when it does, you’ll feel it 😂

My favorite season is season 7, but I know people whose favorite is season 9 or 12, so I'd say the show peaked from 5-12, but it's still to this day really really good

My personal favorite season is S7, although I'd say the show's peak is S3-S9. S13 is pretty uneven, but the last few episodes of it are up there with some of the best of the show.

Just wait until they peak…you’re gonna feel it. They are gonna peak all over you guys!! By the way I thought the r@pe scene went really well in this episode

What a classic Sunny episode!! Hope you're enjoying season 5! More great episodes are yet to come. And I like that low expectation thing you mentioned at the beggining, and I think is good to go with not low, but without high expectations. I went to see Better Call Saul without any good thing on mind, and man the way that show hit me, one of my favourites series of all time!

I am not super familiar with the later seasons. Not sure if I've seen anything past season 10, but 5 is my favorite and 6 is probably my second favorite. They are peak sunny, imo

Fun fact: People have actually used Charlie's wedding proposal in real life.

Happy happy joy joy. My all time favorite episode of the show

The ‘R Word’… you know, ‘rapper’.

The live version is even better.

Top five of all the episodes. Hilarious.

I think the peak is season 53

Classic!!!

Season 5 is great…cant wait

The best

Miss all that 🤣

Peak? Season 10, episode 4.

Ah yes! The classic- "Sweet Dee's Dating a Rascally Person"

If you have not seen it there are several videos of young kids quoirs singing songs from dayman, they are mostly from foreign countries so I'm not sure if the teachers fully understood the meaning behind the song but it's hilarious

People who focus on the peak will forget about the rest of the journey.

The R word rapper, checks out.

glenn howerton is actually an amazing singer

The peak seasons, in order, are seasons 7, 6, and 8.

Sooner or later, everyone pays the troll toll.

I thought the r2pe scene came out nice, Charlie.

My favourite episode

In my opinion seasons 7 through 12 are peak sunny, soore of a plateau than a peak. The show steadily gets better until 7, then I like season 13, season 14 is one of the weakest in my opinion but some people like it. And I liked 15.

Classic ep

Honestly peak is probably S10... not sure it is the peak in terms of overall consistent quality, but it has two, if not three, of the top episodes in the entire show. That being said, season 4 is also a really good one and I think the first one where they really settled-in and hit their stride. Enjoy the ride!

Dude on the right is always hiding a chip on his shoulder..

I think we have to be very careful about how we do the rape scene

Classic

If no one else has commented on it, but in this play the boy is Charlie as a child, the dayman is Charlie after he's grown up, the nightman is his uncle and the troll is his mum

You want this baby boysoul?

Rascal! Hahahah

So the R word is rapper?

1:55 bros so scared of getting cancelled he won't say the word retarded 😭😭😭

I thought the rape scene went really well.

Unpopular opinion - It's a good episode, but I think it's overrated. It might not even be top 30 all time for me.

Gimme dat leg boy 😈