Unbelievable that he's even eligible for parole, especially in light of the fact that he confessed to the murders and his DNA was found under both victim's fingernails. The legal system utterly failed both the victims and their families in this case.

6:28 Damn at first I was thinking how absolutely terrible for the mother to be the one to find her daughter's body, but then when you said she was still alive at that time, I immediately thought the opposite because even though what happened to her was horrendous and of course any mothers worst nightmare, at least this mother was able to hold her daughter in those final moments and this poor girl didn't have to die all alone in the woods.

I lived there when it happened. Armstrong was never the same after her death. Taylor was a friend of my brother’s and he was devastated when he found out. Thank you so much for sharing her story.

I can't even fathom the heartbreak of Taylor's mom finding her in that state 😩 I hope she and all of Taylor's friends and family (the whole town, really) are doing okay, as well as his other victims and their families

Knowing Taylor was just laying there still alive and in pain for so long is heartbreaking.

I am an eighteen-year-old girl from a small town in Canada, I feel like I am just starting my life and I have so many things ahead of me that I can't wait to do. I can't imagine this happening it's just heartbreaking that her life and bright future that was taken away in a matter of hours in such a meaningless way. I hope that her family is finding some peace.

So unbelievably infuriating his sentence was basically a slap on the wrist for being basically a serial killer

It is absolutely terrifying that there is a 50/50 chance this creep could get out. If he's done this 3 times before, what do they believe is going to happen? And why even take the risk? Great video, but now I'm terrified. Just have to be more alert, I guess.

The nephew selling his identity to Matthew for only $500 is mind blowing💀

i miss the makeup ones😭😭Love you regardless Hailey!!

Taylor's sister is Kirstie not Christy. This was hard for everyone in town. Taylor was an amazing musician. There is a lit up walkway built near the railroad tracks where she was found. Thanks for covering this

You’re recording space looks amazing and beautifully different than what I’ve seen elsewhere❤ love your videos girrrl😊

Matthew will get out and will absolutely reoffend. Hopefully police and the parole board will keep a close eye on him

hey hailey, i’ve been a fan since day one never missed a video! keep up the amazing content! hope u feel better!

HI HAILEY!!! So happy for this new upload, gonna watch it now

Great video thank you for making it hope you feel better and recover

I hope you feel better soon! I love your videos

Perfect timing cause I just started cooking😂😩 love you Hailey! 🥰💜

You are super good at this, even while sick you are a professional.

the jesse pinkman costume reference at the end- LOVE his character & love that idea! great vid as always too!

i love love your videos like you’re the only youtuber who i look forward to seeing and genuinely get excited when u post!!! love u girly keep shinning as bright as you are!!!

Dang this one video and the graphic description of her being slammed against the concrete, if you’ve ever had your head hit so hard to the point of a concussion, that shit is fucking painful. That is so sad… so glad I didn’t go out yesterday for Halloween, there’s just too many dangerous people around. Rest in peace Taylor she truly didn’t deserve that and her family either.

Hey Hailey thanks for the upload! Came at a perfect time ❤ hope you had a nice Halloween

Your room is looking awesome, Hailey.

I remember when this happened. Im from around the area and it was a shock to the community. rip this was horrible💔

I love you Hailey I love watching your videos with my friends and my boyfriend and I get snack and and cuddle up to your vids all the time keep up the good work your stories are so entertaining!

This story breaks my heart. I live close by and it gets me every Halloween. :,(

i opened youtube thinking pls let there be a new hailey elizabeth video pls pls pls and you delivered 🤩🤩

Queeen gave us a video even when she sick💓💓💓get better soon!

Thank you so much for researching the story, telling it, editing it, and you did it after having applied a full face of makeup😫 all while sick😫thanks Hailey!!❤️❤️❤️

Love your videoooos!! ❤❤❤❤ You have been such an amazing youtuber, lit a can't miss one of your episodes, they r so engaging!!! I joined when you only had 400 subs, and since the very beginning I thought "she is the best horror story teller" 😂

Thanks for telling us about this case.

omg!!! earliest i’ve ever been to a video ahah!! love your videos girl ❤

I hope you get well soon! We appreciate your content 💕

Sucks to see so many people give a shit about makeup instead of what shes talking about. (Awareness to the crime). R.I.P Taylor.

the nephew that sold his identity for $500 💀

I love the background!! So beautiful

It's crazy that if Matthew was just a little bit smarter he would have gotten away with everything.

These cases are why my mom didn’t let me party, it’s all so sad

I love watching your vids so much i get so excited

Love the setting

I wish you’d have mentioned the name of the masseuse, and the name of the other victim (if you have it). Calling her the masseuse over and over seems to trivialize her death. Maybe you did and I missed it though. I have ADHD and am sure I missed at least some.

as soon as you started talking I was like TWINS I SOUND THE SAME RN feel better Hailey!!

You’re the best storyteller ♥️

Damn... I already listened to this on your podcast. Loved it, but please make more content.

get well soon girl

Stuffy nose season coming in strong! Get well soon 🤧

How are you gonna murder 2 people, attack another, go on the run, steal an identity, and still be able to possibly get out that soon?

“Born to her mother Marie & twin sister…” frustrated me so much ! There is no way in hell that statement makes sense 😭.. yho. Anyway ♥️

LOVE YOU HAILEY!!!!❤️🫶🏼

ALLLLL THINGS SPOOKY SCARY ………

You did Great as usual! Not too “cloggy” (is that a word?? lol) feel better soon!

Ur voice is very soothing 😴💕

Thank you for making the title only about the victim

My strange delusion: Hailey is the best friend who comes to visit me when i’ve had enough and want to retreat in my room and she tells me morbid stories to lul me to sleep

earliest i’ve been! live ur videos!!

Hi Hailey. I'm glad he got caught. Too bad he will get a possibility of parole. Love your channel & you too! Peace yall guys👑😇 &🌹🧸 dolls, love, Janine Smiley😉😇💜

You said the bad person was born in 94 which would’ve made them 12 at the first crime. Pretty sure it was 84.

I'm stuffed up today too girl. Go easy on yo sick self❤

You're so outstanding Hailey

Hey girl, I hope you're better 🤧🤧

I have been watching your videos for years, and have always loved how you tell stories and such. I actually remember when this case took place - I grew up in a town 40 minutes away from Armstrong - and know a close friend of Taylor's. Thank you for covering this case so much 💞 this absolutely rocked the community and it hasn't gotten much coverage at all

Almost at 1 million 🎉 you deserve it Hailey.🙌💯 Love watching from Dublin Ireland 🇮🇪 ❤

Hey Hailey I loved the video

I LOVE THE MICROPHONE ONES

makeup vids are my fav, but i still love these. love this halloween true crime vid

thank you for this case and hope you get well soon!!! Also, can we talk about the Sesshomaru and Jaken at the end?? Are you an Inuysha fan? Cause if so OMFGG ilysm 😭

I would absolutely love to see your Jesse pinkman costume! Currently rewatching breaking bad lol!

hailey constantly using ironic or ironically wrong is so funny to me

Selling your identity for 500 dollars is crazy

I remember this case when it happened. I live a few hours away and its terrifying to think one day he will get out and be a free man.

hailey ive been watching your content for literly forever i love your videos so much and i think you should make a video about the case of the swedish killer twins ursula and sabina eriksson of all the 100s of true crime storys ive looked into this is the number one story ill never forget its absolutly mind blowing and just dousnt seem real yet it is real there are insane twist and turns throughout the hole story that will just absolutly blow your mind its incredibly interesting you should so make a video about the case and theres also many many many conspiresy theories about the truth behind it its a incredible story i think you should defenetly look into it i think you would find it extreamly interesting, love you hailey

Feel better soon xx

11:11 he was born in 1994? wouldn't he be just 11 back then in 2005?

Also the place that the trial happened is called Kelowna KEL-OW - NA

Wow, so sad.

You talk in a great rhythm for how I listen.

I love this background

I’ve been watching for at least a year now, and I keep hearing “mulptiple” every time instead of “multiple”. Even if I go back to listen again. Is it just me? 😅 idk, it’s cute though

I always hate when I start a true crime podcast and hear the case took place in BC (from a creator not local to here). Happens all too often it feels like, and surprises me all the time. Born and raised in BC, Canada and we definitely have our fair share of crime here.

sesshomaru at the end 😭

Oh wow im early! Love the vids and the respect you have!

very interesting case

Idk y it’s always weird hearing such cases from BC

I'm watching this from Ontario

I grew up there.. never heard of this case :(

I like your earrings, hailey.

I love how if he has good behavior he can get out early, like yeah he has no women to attack in an all male prison 😒🙄

you look gorgeous!!

So after the guy sold his identity, what was he gonna use????

why dont you say spooky scary skeletons anymore

Can you make one covering the case of Elisabeth fritzl!! Pleeease

Correction all things spooky scary skeletons

Honey can you do some more conspiracies. I often talk about the finders cult to people. It's generally terrifying how nobody was ever found or punished for their actions for what took place and I'm genuinely convinced that the Colt with how organized and meticulous they were back then and connections they had are still around today

Yay Hailey 🤩

Can we see you costume? I love Breaking Bad!! ❤

the correct term for a person who provides massage as a profession is ‘massage therapist’. masseuse has a sexual/unsavory connotations. just a little FYI! 😊

Thank you for covering Taylor's case! On another note, not to be rude or anything but this eyebrow shape doesn't flatter your face. In the older videos it looked a lot prettier.

i love you hailey but im british...we dont get sunshine till may😔

How did they guess that he had that facial hair though? Like he might’ve had it in 2005 but I wonder why they included the triangular mutton chops in the 2011 sketch