Schar has been consistently better than all the center backs in both teams for almost a season and a half now. Truly the unsung hero in the team at the moment now that Longstaff is starting to get the praise he deserves. Schar is the best defender for Newcastle in my life time. Love him to bits. Shocked that there wasn't more discussion around that position.

The disrespect on Isak is crazy 🇸🇪

Schar so underrated.

Horrendous lack of knowledge from the rest of the panel on Newcastle

No way Rashford gets into that team

Livramento is perhaps the best player already among all the potential defenders . He's THAT good .

Yous got it right except it's Gordon, Isak Miggy, 😅 I'm not taking any of their front three over ours on this season, not even close.

The disrespect on Almiron is crazy here, didn’t even mentioned him, there’s no Manchester attacking player on better form than him right now

How was the pope/Onana even a question 😂😂😂 pope is literally outrageously good. He’s probably top 3 in the newbie. Also I’d go livramento over shaw any day

Disrespect for garnacho

Luke Shaw is the ONLY Man U player I’d take in this Newcastle team.

True Geordie is a fair weather fan, he's a London boy, back now we are performing

This is the problem with looking at this match, ppl are comparing man for man. As a newcastle fan,we know that doesn't work. When newcastle score 4 goals in a game, its never the same scorer twice. We don't do man for man, doing that has caused the infighting at man u. When you see a geordie match, we fight for each other as well as the badge, that's the difference. We truly are newcastle, united

Gordon vs Rashford - that aged well.

Hojland is not anywhere close to Isak or Wilson, he has alot of potential but right now there's no competition there

The love for Hjollund is amazing for a player who's done absolutely nothing in the league.

crazy jesus disrespect for somebody who has one og the highest G/90 ratios in premier league history. u forget ab that 10 game stretch at the start of last season where he was genuinely one of the best players in the league before his knee went out

Honestly Luke Shaw is a very underrated left back, just watching him play you can see how talented he is.

Expected this to piss me off but it was surprisingly logical and reasonable.

Calling McTomminay a future Newcastle legend is accurate af😂

Not even a mention for Almiron over Rashford? Mental, given the respective form of them both over the last two seasons. Arguably our best player in the first half vs PSG. I think a few reputations were being talked about over form in this video.

I love this podcast ⚫⚪

Wouldn’t take one Man United player to put in our strongest eleven

My days, soundboard of yes men

Rashford? LOL no chance XD

More of josh noshing true geordie off again 😂

The Disrespect 😭

Come round my house for a bit if Jellof 🔥 😂😂

As a United fan I’d take garnacho over rashford so I’d have Gordon, isak, garnacho

Wow .. the kick off have fell off a cliff big time !!!!

joelington over casiemero ??? ok yeah

People saying Almiron over Rashford are smoking some fukin dope mate lmaoooo.

Almiron has a chance of winning the Ballon D'Or if he keeps performing like this

Honestly, as a Newcastle fan, the only Man Utd players I'd consider taking is McTominay (and some of their young prospects for the bench)because the rest of them are arrogant, selfish, lazy sods who wouldn't fit in Howe's system and certainly wouldn't put in the effort needed

Brian saying that garnacho won’t ever be as good as Gordon is one of the worst takes I’ve heard

Almiron is better than Anthony Gordon and Rashford. British favouritism. It's a joke how he's not been mentioned.

Onana Trippier Botman Schar Shaw Mainoo Bruno G Rashford Bruno F Garnacho Wilson

Craig Mitch doesn’t even watch Newcastle matches “does Isak play through the middle”

Most cleansheets in the league

Pope, Trippier, Schar, Botman, Burn/Livramento, Bruno G, Joelinton, Longstaff/McTominay Gordan, Wilson, Isak Schar is crazy underrrated. I like honest local lads who give everything for shirt over "superstars". I'd choose either Burn/Livramento over Shaw. Dislike Bruno Fernandes as he comes off as a fanny. So either Longstaff/McTominay. Isak on left to accommodate Wilson. Wilson (7), Isak (7), Gordan (5), have PL 19 goals this season. Hojilund (0), Rashford (2), Anthony (0) have 2 PL goals this season. I don't rate Man Utd team at all.

Livermento 40 hall35 isack 60 brono 60 Gordon 50 tonali 60 plus bunch of 20 mil so they had spend but they act like they buy one player ..

What a disrespect to Isak!!! Isak is not just a no 9. Be is a better footballer than all Manutd, Arsenal or other Newcastle attackers. Isak is a true baller

This "we have not spent money" is getting old fast just in the 18 months you guys have spent more than €300 million 🤦‍♂

Joelinton?

First set of fans that dont seem like they're brats irl

Newcastle+Bruno F. is the best 11

hoijlund got 5 cup goals bro

No Almiron mentions...crazy💀💀

Pope Trippier Schar Botman Shaw Bruno F. Bruno G Joelinton Alrmion Isak Gordon I know I'll get stick there's better players but i love Miggy he was fantastic against PSG away the other night, IV put Bruno fernandes in on ability but i really don't like him i think his attitude and conduct stinks at times.

The only player id take from Man Utd is Bruno Fernándes

Rashford 😂😂😂

Almirón>Rashford

Tino has played 5 games for Newcastle and had 5 man of the matches, one including vs PSG. He plays before Shaw. Only man utd players that get in this squad is Fake Bruno and Rashford

Why Rashford not Casemiro 😂 if it’s on form no Man Utd player should be selected

Mental.

Am a Manu fan. But why Rashford? He has had just three good months in his entire career. Plays with his legs not with the brain

Gabriel Jesus or Eddie Nketiah over Isak 😂😂😂 please lord dont let this man comment on football again

Schar was 3million he is much better than Martinez

Should be Pope trippier schar botman shaw bruno g bruno f mcsauce gordon rashford isak

i agree trippier at rb but it's not so much a walk over as you guys say wan-bissaka is crazy

Thursday nights are Europa nights 😅 ahahaha ARSENAL ARSENAL ARSENAL

Man utd finished higher than Newcastle last season and also beat them in the final when it really mattered. This season utd even tho they have been terrible at times still above Newcastle but yet you pick 7 Newcastle players in this combined 11 and say you dont rate ten haag, make it make sense

Imagine saying Gordon is better than Garnacho 😂😂😂😂😂

This guy is obsessed with man united

More Toon players than manure. 3-1 tonight for me!

Garnacho is already playing with the world cup winners Gordon doesnt even have a cap this video is so one sided towards Newcastle its unbelievable joke of a video

Martinez and varane walk into this team ,so does shaw ,yall can have pope ,trippier bruno g ,almiron and isak,idk how that chelsea fan got away with that outrageous schar comment

I wouldn't take one single Manc

My expectations for this video was low but god you can see the anti-United shining through.

taking schar over martinez is insane (from an arsenal fan)

The way they talk you’d think Newcastle would be a good 5+ points above United

Just started watching the video but im guessing TG will try and argue Newcastle have the better player in pretty much every position and also argue Howe is better than EtH forgetting where both clubs are in the league

Fernandes is too lazy to get into Newcastle team

Y’all are just MAM UTD haters! Gordon over Garnacho?! 🤦🏾‍♂️ THATS MENTAL! Ask anybody except from British fans n u will find out the truth!

Is there a footballer more disliked out there, than Bruno Fernandes?

Anthony Gordon is overrated because he's British. If you ask someone with a bit of footballing knowledge like Mbappe or Roque Santa Cruz, they'd favour Miguel Almiron

❤

should be isak, wilson, gordon

These are a joke

Newcastle is so good and so better than Utd that they are 1 point below Utd int the current standings!

What’s up with the constant man United hate

Combined 11 in 2023 🤦‍♂️

Onana in nets 100%

Joey brother please stop a-licking true geordie and newcastle. All this brother does is say things to please that baldie across the table. Atleast craig and that other chelsea fella try to be rational and unbiased.

No Casemiro shouts is crazy, better than Joelinton and plays for Brazil still.

I’d take McTominay over Joelinton any day. Far more versatile & on a hot streak scoring at the moment too. He’s not just scoring well “for Scotland” he’s 5th top scorer in the whole qualifiers as it stands.

Money spent, individual brilliance, blah blah blah Same old rag and bone. But these lot undervalue the affect ownership changes had or would have at the respective clubs. They shortchange Ten Hag at every opportunity. VAR controversies and injuries aren’t framed the same way if it’s about United. At least in this context, a combined XI, TG’s biases aren’t entirely out of tune. Like I get going Gordon over Garnacho. But then say something so wild like he’s unsure Garnacho *could* ever get to Gordon’s level? 😂 Gordon is fine, a solid player. But he’s Tyneside Jesse Lingard at very fucking best.

Only player that gets in that team is Fernandes...rest is The Maggies

Every week they regurgitate the same arguments/talking points. Every week Brian does a half hour discussion about Man United and it’s getting boring to watch/listen too. I get why you do it because views are low and talking about Man united brings them up for you but it’s at the cost of the show. I used to tune in every show and now I don’t bother at all because I know the format, you compare Man United and Newcastle squads and money spent or Eddie Howe and Ten Haag every show…… It’s BORING now! Switch it up mate because I know I’m not the only one who feels like this judging by the views you get now compared to what you used to get .

If this is on merit, how would Rashford even make the bench?

Joelinton in any combined 11 as a cm is criminal 😂