The guy is innocent

He wanted to be sure he killed them, if he did touch them, which I doubt. He just tried to get Paul’s cell phone so he could delete that video at the kennels. He’s clean because he went up in the quad to the house and showered. Probably buried or burned the bloody clothes. He’s a serial criminal and liar.

My dr doesn’t see me because he knows he participates in a murder scheme. He passes me off. For years. To nurse practitioners.

When he arrived at the oil tanks those girls were alive. What kind of "father" either kills them right before or puts them in those tanks alive. Some people do horrendous things.

Alex a lawyer would know he’d have to make it look gruesome and not like a professional clean hit?

@@jeanlaubenthal698 look at all he's capable of. What I was referring to are the lies the defense wants us to believe that Alex is broke when he's not, Alex is an addict, which he's not, Alex went to rehab, which he didnt, and the roadside incident was not a fake suicide attempt either! Poot has snuck all of these lies into his basis of defense to make Jury see Alex as a victim and feel sympathy for him, which is clearly not the case. It's more lies covering up more lies!!

There's a few story's like that. Unfathomable, the faux love of a sociopathic parent and their child. Bless the children who trusted such parents. 🩶

@@likka3823 "faux love of a sociopathic parent" is an excellent expression 🤔

Yes... his wife had been away for a few days. He had the children.

Now he just looks like some dug-up corpse who needs money badly enough that he has to work for a thief at what I assume is the age 92. His sack is empty and useless

His own denial and his disposition showse ow's his guilt

With Alex or one of the defence lawyers?

Pretty sure I'd kept THAT to myself.😜👌

Are you referring to his attorney or Murdaugh himself? I can see both being intolerable pricks

This reminds me of the Delphi. Murders

He never had a spot of blood on his hand! How is that possible? Hopefully they will let people know that he must have showered as they had blood all over their bodies. I thought they found blood and gun residue on the t-shirt and shorts that couldn't be seen by just looking at them. That night he insisted that his wife come over so they can drive together to the hospital to visit his Dad. She texted a friend and told her that she thought it was peculiar but still went. Why did he and his wife not go to the hospital when she got there?? That hasn't been explained.

Really? I once picked up my dead cat in the middle of the road and still took her to the vet to see if there maybe would still be some life in her. Hope overrides common sense.

Exactly this. They make me want to vomit

Yep!! Ffr

Yes!!! But really turned on the fake emotions whenever the prosecution was describing the victims wounds.

A shower with Pinesol.

ARE YOU REALLY SERIOUS? HE WASHED HIMSELF AT THE KENNELS, WITH THAT BLUE RAIN COAT ON, THEN HE WASHED THE BLOOD AWAY WITH THE POWER HOSE, AND WAS IN SUCH A HURRY THE HOSE WASNT HUNG IN THE NORMAL WAY IT ALWAYS WAS. THEN HE WENT TO THE HOUSE AND TOOK A SHOWER. HE PLANNED THIS FOR A LONG TIME. COLD HEARTED, SO SAD. HE IS SO INTO HIMSELF, AT THE END OF EVERYDAY, HE NEVER TAKES TIME TO LOOK BACK AT POOR BUSTER. HE WILL NEVER REACH OUT TO BUSTER WITH A SMILE OR ANY KIND OF LOVING GESTURE. SO SAD. BUSTER NEVER SHOWS ANY EMOTION WHILE STATE IS SHOWING PHOTOS OF HIS MOTHER AND HIS BROTHER. SUCH A SAD FAMILY. BUT ALEX IS GUILTY!!! THE MAN IS GUILTY NO MATTER IF JURORS DONT SAY HE IS, WON'T CHANGE THE FACT THAT FOREVER, HE IS GUILTY. BREAKS YOUR HEART.

It’s getting late in the day- he’s sundowning. 😂

where r the clothes?

@@amandam1137 either set on fire after leaving kennels or somewhere sunk with weights in the low waters of the lowlands of this county.

@@Mulcahy22 well which is it?

@@amandam1137 I don't know, but I know where they ARENT. He would have had enough time to change into something else, especially since it was summer and clothes are light and easily switched out

@@amandam1137 somewhere between his house and his parents No one will know unless he tells them

Harpootlian is trying to build contrast by saying “Murdaugh, a man he’s honored to defend, who’s a good husband and father” isn’t consistent with a man who could act with such brutality. For what is worth…

Wrong. It does the opposite, it's seeding the jury that it was so brutal that Alex could not have done it. It also preps them for the photos they will be seeing.

It’s clear what he’s doing hes defended someone no matter if he’s guilty or not just doing his job , all he wants is to win the case scary to think how many guilty people have got away with horrible crimes just because they have someone who’s good at there job and are good at twisting what happened not because they found the truth 😔

That was a bit jaw dropping analysis

Good point. He’s basically a criminal from the get-go.

I disagree he is relating in a folksy to the jury and doing a good job, whether you hate the defendant or not.

He did have snot dripping up his nose during the trial I can remember which day LOL don't know if it was drugs or what! I watched it! Doesn't mean that he was crying and upset or maybe he's crying because of guilt I don't know.

No he didnt say that..on slower version he said ' they did him bad"

​@@ritaeichler2066 Some paid hitmen, perhaps ??

No he did say they I heard several times in trial

That is what I think

Alex M. sitting in the police car said “I did him so bad”.

Has to create reasonable doubt in the mind of at lest 1 juror I guess.

The more I watch and listen, I do believe someone else was at the kennels, what if Alex and someone else killed Paul and Maggie, then , that's the reason he said, Here, to someone who was with him. someone else was there for sure! did the cops read Buster's GPS or Busters girlfriends GPS, did investigators check their cell phone activity, their every movement on June 7th and 8th. Also the blue tarp is still evidence in this murder. Alex as much as called Shelly Smith a liar, when he said, he doesn't know anything at all about the tarp. He thinks he has the jury on his side, you can see his actions when he's looking at the jury. I am surprised each time he wipes his nose then wipes his eyes and face with the tissue he just wiped his nose with. they do have clean tissue for him. but honestly folks, don't we grieve for Paul and Maggie. even for Buster, who seems to have a cold cold heart. he almost looks happy when they are questioning his dad and others. he thinks he will not be caught. A senseless cold hearted murder. a sad case.

They don’t have to. State has the burden.

He acted stupid about it like he didn't know if it was replaced...HE HIMSELF VOLUNTEERS PAULS GUN BEING STOLEN AND TRIED TO PLAY IT OFF...Everything this guy says makes me sicker than a dog. He even tries to cast doubt on the old man who cared so wonderfully for his dogs. Robbed millions from the housekeeper of 20 years who cared for his children and helped raise them with Alex just putting commercial home owners insurance 1 month prior to her death! On and on and on . .....

@@gmaw23beauties37 Wow! They killed the housekeeper too. 😢

If you watch the 3rd interview with AM somebody whispers I can’t wait to get those guns….odd thing for somebody to say….

@decencyanddemocracy6013 I don't believe so. Well not Dick at least. Possibly Jim?? His buddy? Not the old one.

were u there?

@@amandam1137 no but ALEX was

I thought the same thing.

It's to emphasize the difference between a life of being a devoted husband and father- - as Alec led - and the gruesome reality of the murder scene. The lawyer is emphasizing the incompatibility of the two. It's the lawyers best defence strategy. I'm just telling why IMHO why the lawyer adopted this strategy - so dont attack me if you believe AM is guilty.

@Marthie Nel so it's the best defense strategy to talk about their heads busting like a watermelon and brains everywhere? It's in bad taste . He could have still done it and not been in there giddily relishing the gore . The son and brother (Buster) the loving husband and father (AM) the aunts, uncles, siblings, and friends don't need that extra imagery. It's just too much and I don't think it portrays the defense team in a better light for it , it makes them seem cold and cruel.

@Marthie Nel do you think someone else did this? I'm just curious- I haven't made a determination myself. (Although him being at the kennels, the discrepancy with the shirt with Blanca, and the timing of the financial issues are definitely cause for an eyebrow raise)

@@kneesandtoes44 Maybe I just don't want to believe he could do this and still claim his innocence. Will be interesting to see the defense chipping away at the evidence. It will be a brutal fight to the end. That old guy Mr H is beyond shrewd. He is looking for any opening and mistake to drive a truck through. All he needs is one doubting juror.

Everyday is kinda pushing it 🤣

Good point!

Take your god nonsense elsewhere.

To make it look like 2 shooters….reasonable doubt, etc.

How did he have time to? Wouldn't the son have reacted to the mom being murdered and vice versa? Seems like maybe there were 2 killers. Maybe the other person who would benefit from their deaths? Just speculation but think about it...

Probably the reason he was confused with the bullet in his gun later.

To pretend there were two shooters which his lawyers have been trying to sell from the beginning!

@@kneesandtoes44 the mother was shot running away

As well as supremely annoying. He should stick with information and cut the really bad persuasive bs. He's leaning WAY too heavy on persuasion.

Just because he might be “there” doesn’t prove that he pulled the trigger.

Every time he opens his mouth another lie falls out but we’re supposed to disregard them.

He’s clenching his jaw I believe, high anxiety imho…

Watched him for several days and dawned on me when I saw bags of candy. Opiate and alcohol users after detox will eat candy a lot because it works on that same center in the brain related to “pleasure”.Kinda helps with cravings. AA mtgs I have been to have bowls of candy on the tables

In ALL the court trials and court dates and proceedings and hearings I have been too Nobody is allowed to have any candy gum or mints at all.

@@joann5075 Well Murdaugh seems to be a special case huh?

Attorney Feeding Him Pain Pills Under The Table..

Sir Nigga Niggarson

@@pandaman1968 In the military your guilty until proven innocent

@@thurstonpowell8687 yeah well he’s already pled out to extensive thievery so his guilt is a fact. Maybe try reading about things before commenting on them and you won’t sound as silly to peopl

@@markieffmorris9263 don't get your panties twisted over trivialities

@@thurstonpowell8687 like having a clue what you’re talking about 😂

durrr

Could have something to do with his drug and money problem. Was he being blackmailed about something? He hints to Buster on a recorded call that his problems all lead back to 23 years ago. I wonder what happened 23 years ago in Alex life?

@@selecttravelvacations7472 Start of his drug use?

@@jennifer60515 i dont know if he was saying his drug use started 23 years ago or something happened 23 years ago that lead to his “troubles”, which could mean drug use, or possibly money issues? It wasnt clear but i think it’s key to understanding him and decisions he made after for sure. It has me very curious.

@@selecttravelvacations7472 corruption

Remember, AM set up his own shooting , by his own cousin.Nothing surprises us anymore.

You are so wrong. My mother was murdered after they stold all her money first. So it's not leap.

No and they've never said where all the money went , he's been blackmailed by someone no way could he go thru that many pills not fifty grand a week he could charter a plane to mexico once a month for way cheaper than that! Somebody had to help and put Maggirs phone a half mile away the OnStar proved he couldn't have gotten rid of it or the murder weapon.

@K And were any of their voices heard on the video recorded just minutes prior to the murders, like Alex’s was?

If he plotted his own attempted murder, he's capable of arranging his family's murder.

Yes. Listen to the opening statements of the prosecutor:)

He would have had gsr because he and Paul were out shooting guns earlier in the evening, target practice. (Almost like he made a point to say this so that it would explain the gsr on his hands...)

He drove to his home which was a 3 minute walk to get a gun in case the "murderers" were still on the property. I think he had a shower and then put on clean clothes. Somehow he had gun residue on it as well as blood you couldn't see with the naked eye on those clothes. Not sure how that happened. Hopefully it will all be explained.

Yes. Remember he was handling the shotgun that he retrieved from the house. In case the bad guys were still around.

I agree

Bawling.

He left. He could have dropped them anywhere between there and his moms

Well he did

He did because Paul and Maggie are working together to keep an eye on him.They have now become a thorn in his flesh. He is too deep in his mess. He cannot trust Paul. I believe he is desperate and not thinking correctly and of course he think he can get away with it(privilege) mentality. He is a druggie and an abuser of his Oxy but i believe he has bought in to a Drug Dealer Role. He is funding the purchasing the Drugs as well as using. Buster is just like him.

Chris Watts. He also killed his baby girls. You never know what a desperate person would do.

Reaching is seeing the evidence that in a snapchat he was there minutes before they were murdered? Alex admits he was there only after the snapchat is produced. 3 people were at the kennels night, 2 died, and 1 is a pathological liar with many skeletons in his closet.

You ma5he sense except for one thi png. They were ALL THREE DOWN together at the kennels, all alive, as was captured on the snapchat of Paul when he checked the dogs tale. Maggie didn't come running down from the house when she heard the shots. She was already right there at the kennels when Paul was shot. She was meant to be dead, too.

being a lawyer, a loving husband, a loving father, Why in the world isn't he asking law enforcement, to find the murderers? Any innocent lawyer would be screaming, Find who killed my wife and so!!!. He is guilty as sin, He probably had another person help him kill them both. how can John Marvin not know to wash away a crime scene ??? helping his brother. Guilty!!!

This lawyer is just like him

Getting away implies he’s guilty without his just process of being presumed innocent. Which is what he described to the jury. Glad you aren’t on the jury

@@iskeet011unless you are on the jury, it doesn’t really matter. I can think he is guilty all I want. That’s what an opinion is called

I said that out loud 😂😂

Money talks and bullshit walks

what? only one?

@@georgvonclausewitz2024 😂