Yes! My heart goes out to her 💔 $500.00 does not even compensate for the tissues to dry her tears 😭the stitches to mend her heartbreak 💔heart or the balm to comfort her soul!JM explained the law but THE LAW “is not” a HEALER!

The defendant did seem sincerely and genuinely remorseful for what happened. I could even see the anguish and remorseful tears behind him.

Poor woman….poor dog🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻😢😢😢💔💔💔

@@traceyjackson4470he was remorseful…genuinely.

I feel bad for this lady. But, she put her (own) dog in danger. She's so nosey, she took her dog across the street just to find out if the defendant got a new dog ? She could've found that out the next time she saw him. My eyes are always open when I'm walking my little dogs. I keep them away from bigger dogs, at all times.

Not at all she could have given her something better then $500.00

@@dionnehawkins9395 not by law. Legally, dogs are property. You can't do pain and suffering for property cases.

@@dionnehawkins9395 And it's an old dog that has no value. No sentimental value. She's lucky she even got $500

I have two cats...and I will be so sad if I lose one

My dog and 2 cats are my world! If I watched one of them being attacked and/or killed I would NEVER be ok again. I pray something like this never happens to me!

@@blessedwithaperfectlife6880😇🙏 make sure and have the dog's leashed and Harvey had good advice at the end and when I am out and in public if I see a big dog I cross the street to avoid anything

Legally, pain and suffering cannot be awarded for the loss of a possession. Under the law, dogs are no different than any other possession, like a table or chair. I don't agree with it personally, but that's the reasoning behind it.

@@BrunkDartender234 i didn't know that because it is considered property and someone damages your property..you can't get pain and suffering? This happened in DC were a lady actually left her small breed dog at a doggie day care while she was on vacation. The dog was attacked by a bigger dog and she sued the place. Last time I checked the lady was actually had a case because they said the dog was property. This is so interesting

@@DC45193 Yes, there is no legal precedent set for pain and suffering for a damaged/destroyed possession, even if that possession holds sentimental value. The standard is to award the value of the item at the time of loss. I'm not familiar with the DC case, but the dog owner in question would have a case for veterinarian bills as a result of the attack and the value of the dog, but not pain and suffering. Edit to add: Anyone can bring suit no matter the merit of the claim. This specific DC case also depends on the contract (if any) the owner had with the dog daycare. The owner may have to prove gross negligence on the part of the daycare to win her case. Some contracts include clauses that absolves the business of things beyond their control, but if the business can be shown to have acted with negligence the dog owner will have a better chance to win the damages of her lost pet.

@@BrunkDartender234 great thanks. But its so weird because you literally can sue for something else at a any value you want. Like a malpractice suit or discrimination but pain and suffering you can't name a price?

@@DC45193 Pain and suffering has a pretty narrow definition in law. It strictly applies to physical damage suffered by the complainant. Say the dog owner tried to stop the larger dog from attacking her dog and was bit in the process, causing bodily harm to herself that she could prove. Then she would have a cause to sue for the pain and suffering she directly received as a result, but still no cause for the pain and suffering of the dog or the loss of it. Hope that makes sense!

Omg yes. I cried lol and the judge was upset to cuz I’ve never seen her give $500 for a 9 year old dog.

Same 😢

Yeah, she started crying & I started crying right along with her. I can't imagine having my dog brutalized like that. Horrifying.

@@JamieM470 This case was sad, judge Milian feels her pain because a pitbull attacked and killed her cat in front of her daughters.

@@0T772 How u know🤔

True

yeah but he was also acting like a victim

@@neafilipovic3273 how one it wasn’t even dog

@@Tattedmoni ha?

@@neafilipovic3273 it wasn’t even his dog to begin with why don’t they sue the original dog owner

Why?

@@coffeeinthenebula So she had the comfort of her husband. That is either a very innocent question or a very dumb one.

@@bluepuppy1139 maybe the husband had work that he couldn’t get out of.

I agree.

Yeah when she said she called her husband. That was sad...

I agree n not sure how i guessed she was gonna say 500 b4 she did but she did lol anyway um my other guess was closer to 700 nice dog, and the crown noone said that its also the type and strenght of the jaw of a pit, and also perhaps their energy level, owner type yes but also these things play a big role coool i tyepd this as a advertisment playedn fisnhed as it did lol

I would of shoot that pitbull right there and the owner if they got in the way

@@thecheshirecat299 you sound like you would go to prison for life for your dog.

The show picks the cases not the other way around. Though if JJ had taken the case I think 5k punishment would’ve been possible

Amen!

@Lady Jupiter shut up

Why?

Yes!! Judge Judy loves dogs

Love her look! Fabulous! 💅

He did offer to pay for the cremation, pay to get her a dog, and even some cash. He offered and she refused it.

Cause he laugh at what happen and that is why she refuse it

@@jessicamcgaughey8551🤦‍♂️ it's not what he wants its WHAT SHE WANTS

@@payableondeath9091 she can want $5000 for a dog that let’s say she paid $500 for, doesn’t mean he should give her $5000. He doesn’t automatically owe her whatever she wants, especially if let’s say it is a ridiculous demand. There is a difference between paying what your responsible for, and being guilted into paying more than someone should get just because they want it.

@@jessicamcgaughey8551RME but she wasn't being unreasonable asking for another $750 dog, she isn't the type to be OTT then he says LOL to her

You are right about that the other dog gets a chance to live after it had killed a dog

The $500 is the negligence 😂Can't believe people like you get to be on juries.

Wish we could.

I am not sure if pepper spray would halt a dog in the middle of an attack because it would be so wound up and intent. Does anybody know the answer to that?

The pepper spray would hit both dogs.

No pepper spray .. a glock fixes that problem.. I have done it before it solves the problem .. no dog of my neighbor has been back

jim h Labradors, thank goodness. Mine saved me from a water snake when I was a little girl!

So many people don't understand this. Breeds were created to pass down desirable traits. Maybe dog agression and human agression are not considered desirable traits now, but they were at many times in history and generations of line breeding doesn't just go away because some people have sweet bully breed mutts with mixed genetics and don't like it when people tell the truth about pit bulls

Exactly!!

He offered money did u miss that?

@@Tattedmoni exactly it’s like people missed the whole part where he offered to pay for the cremation, pay to get her a dog, and even pay her some cash as well.

@@Tattedmoni She refused it cause he had laugh in the text he send

Me Me you fought off 6 pitbulls......

Smh...

How terrifying!

Pit bulls are known to turn on other dogs and animals, even those they are raised with. Experts attribute this negative trait to years of interbreeding the most aggressive dogs for dog fighting. With regards to attacks on humans, a 2018 report showed more than 35 dog breeds contributed to 433 deaths in a 13-year period, but pit bulls contributed to 66% of these deaths, followed by rottweilers at 10%.

@@jcspider7259 Pitull refers to about 50 different breeds. Not fair to lump them all together to get a 66 percentile.

😂

you are spreading lies -pitbulls are not wolves- it depends on how you raise them sir

@@rxnupe Definitely how you raise them. I've been around Pit Bulls that are well behaved because of their owners. They act like babies and mind their own business, but will protect their owners or the property if there is a threat.

All dogs are aggressive. The only difference is that a pit bulls bite will do more damage . little dogs actually tend to be more aggressive, because they don’t know they’re little .

I completely disagree with you. I had a pit that was over bred, attacked by the people who owned her in an attempt to kill her, and ultimately surrendered to a pit rescue. She was an amazingly gentle dog. She never did anything aggressive towards a person or other animal. She loved my cats and they would sleep curled up together.

Ace of Spades It has nothing to do with how YOU RAISE THEM.. that’s a really ignorant statement.. They are animals with a small brain. You might want to get yours checked

👍🏾

But she was just out on the street. Right? I sometimes walk my chi on the street or a park. I don't deliberately take her near big dogs but what if one came our way? Very scary. I may start carrying a big stick.

Yes I hate it when some owners have their bigs without leashes at the park

Most people can’t be bothered to properly train and socialize their pits. It really also has a lot to do with their nature as well. Sometimes you get lucky with a really laid back pit who isn’t dog/ people aggressive.

Yeah, yeah. You haven’t had any problems with your cuddly put bull…. Yet.

@@riandraegon556 you’re disgusting. Pits don’t “snap” unless they are poorly trained. but guess what? all badly trained dogs snap. they just have strong locking jaws. but if they are trained well and have good, loving owners, they are fine. I truly hope you don’t have any pets.

I think it's not that pit bulls attack more often, it's when they do their anatomy is designed to do massive damage. I know folks who own chihuahuas and their dogs have attacked every single person in the home and every person who visits but the damage is minor. A big problem is containing the dog. Pitt bulls are great diggers and jumpers so they escape easily if you don't have the yard designed right

Oh here we go with the same delusional anecdotes. 🤡 All the pit dog owners are just that. Delusional owners. Other dog owners know exactly what their breeds are capable of instead of the rose colored eyes pitbull owners. I wonder if thats why theyre the most dangerous killer dogs. Maybe their owners are in such denial all the time. And not because I say so, look at the statistics and real life cases where they kill and kill and kill. Have fun.

I totally agree with you

Get a tougher dog then why should my dog die. 🤡

@@mykelltaylor8441 so if people view their pets as humans… love them as such-right?!. If someone kills ur family member, someone u love to pieces, do u need a tougher love one? Should the attitude be-damn they should have been tougher. 🤔

I think "had no teeth" is the operative sentence. Next to ALL THE SIBLINGS...WERE VICIOUS. Do you even read your own writing?

@@TreasureOne the teeth rotted in her old age. She never bit anyone and died at 13 (91 in dog years).

Much better safe than sorry.

I’m glad you won’t let around. I’ve read they attack a certain blood type. But I’m not sure if it’s true. But I will say my grandpa and my dad were both attacked by a dog on the forehead and low and behold I was attacked on my head by a pit bull and my daughter at age five walked by one didn’t touch it run by it simply walked by it and it attacked her. We joke it’s a family curse getting attacked and scarred on the forehead by these dogs. But I do believe they are dangerous

@Sjanae90 The chances of surviving a pitbull attack VS a pomeranian are pretty bleak & pitbulls attack by nature.

Ὓὄὗʀ L·ἷғἔ Ṃᾄҭҭἔʀṩ I have two pomeranians and 1 female pit bull and they all act the same.

@@yourenotready82 I have a Pomeranian & I can tell you first hand you're lying. Every dog has its own personality. Poms are the yappiest & yet the most loving, compassionate & extremely smart, curious, energetic & playful dogs. Pitbulls are agile and powerful dogs, they are dominate, territorial & are tempermental. Their jaws lock down & when they do they do not let go until their prey has stopped moving. The two personalities are night & day & so are their behaviors. Your pit could be sick or not feeling well one day & you are unaware of it & all it takes is for your Pomeranians to make one false move, nip or yap in a way that doesn't make your pitbull happy & you're going to tragically eat those words like thousands of pet owners have in the past by trusting mixed breeds around each other, especially one that is known to be deadly. The biggest & most deadly mistake you can make is putting your guard down & thinking because your pit hasn't attacked, means he won't.

@Robin D. Wow, poor lady, Glad to hear she didn't lose her life. Hopefully your brother had a change of heart & decided to giver the dog away to a shelter or something or he doesn't have the dog around children or other family.He should have listened to you. Yeah I am the same way. I've got nothing against them in general either but I also am not going to be ignorant to the statistics. There is someone here in the comment section talking about her friends child rides their pit like a horse on its back😳😳 These child neglecting parents who video their kids pulling on their ears, jumping on them as they say "See, pits are so loving & friendly, they would never hurt my child" While that pit is sitting there taking ti at the time, it's just a matter of time before it snaps. Sadly the child doesn't know any better & they end up paying the price. I'm like you, I have to laugh when I hear idiots say they are no worse than other dogs. I beg to differ, no they certainly are not.

Ὓὄὗʀ L·ἷғἔ Ṃᾄҭҭἔʀṩ do I have to send you a video of them as proof lol my poms do talk more but they shut up when I tell them too my pit bull makes no noise unless given a command to speak. My pit is so calm it’s like they act like me. I’m sorry my pit isn’t aggressive like you want her to be.

Like morons with guns who know nothing about using, buy them for "protection", never actually educate themselves about guns, then ended up shooting themselves or someone in their household.

People in certain areas like pit bulls to protect their cash and drugs...I have neighbors! Those pits are often chained outside not kept like family pets.😢 I've come across very sweet pits at the dog park, I'm a fan of the dogs, not their owners!!!

Exactly! Most of the time, people buy pits because they “look mean and tough” and are often treated with cruelty. It’s really very sad. There are so many animals in this world that are treated worse than dirt. People are mean and treat animals as if their live doesn’t matter. Don’t know how people can do the things they do.

@@NONPOINT420 true.

@ŁÜVŁÜV KÃÇTÜŠ Not in the US. In many cases, they live in kennels most of the time, and go to live with their handler's family once they retire. The K-9 units belong to the police force, not the handler. Should a handler leave the force, The dog is usually retrained with another handler. These dogs weren't brought up like normal puppies. A lot can have socialization issues.

Right!! 😂 😂

How do you know

Greedy? Unkind to extreme. She may have needed more money for the vet bills and to get another dog.

@@bluepuppy1139 he offered to pay for the cremation, pay to get her a dog, and even pay her some cash as well.

Correct. But am u really the only one who find it weird af that ur 9yr old dog died n d 1st thing I ask for is for another dog? I've had my dog for 3yrs now n if he died, I cant even look at another dog so soon.

@@bluepuppy1139 she didn't want any of that even tho the defendant offered. The defendant offered her money which was the amount that her dog is worth. She was greedy in wanting a different breed of the dog and wanted him to pay the full amount. That is greedy.

@Robin D. this. 👆

@Robin D. Agreed. Humans are not cats. Cats can control dogs, if they want to. Humans, not so well.

Exactly!! Some ppl go into depression over lost animals.

He did offer and she did refuse

You spoke nothing but the truth

So true

It's not really about depreciating. It's about what people would pay for dog. She got much more than she would get if she had sold it. In any event, this type of case can never really be satisfactory.