SMH 🤦‍♀️ damn shame

I think he do care just don't want to bear the responsibility. he look like those everything I say is right type of dudes

He's next. They are known to turn on their owners...

He owns 3 "rescue" pitbulls, it's never gonna be the fault of his babies. He will continually blame it on their bad reputation.

Why do people say "could care less"?? That makes absolutely no sense at all! He could care less is not the saying. It's couldn't care less!

I couldn't even listen. I love animals so much, these cases tear me up inside

That was a brutal attack..2 the hard way🥶

Yeah I almost had to stop the video... so sad this dude is a douche

@@joeythemoose 😥 POOR BABY MUSTARD 🐶 I CRIED WHEN I WATCHED HIS VIDEO. THAT MAN IS A SCUMBAG 😑

Yeah, that pitiful cry made the tears start rolling. Poor little thing.

That was my first thought

I agree. The owner even said, she's an older dog. The injury didn't look life threatening. I think it was the shock and trauma of the attack that killed the poor dog. And the judge is right. Its NOT the Pitbull's fault. Its the OWNERS who don't control their dogs. My sister has 2 bullies. They are the sweetest dogs I have ever met. Very affectionate. But at the same time, the plaintiff should NOT have allowed her dog to join the Pitbulls if she felt it was not safe.

It absolutely couldve

@@CeltycSparrow My Best friend has a Pit. She unfortunately Does. Not get along w other dogs. When I come, she comes to the door window throws down alot of smack. Even if she isnt home, I crack the door & talk to her. She gets all wiggly " I'm sorry, I'm sorry I havent seen you on awhile. Scratch my butt"?

You're a 100 % right !

I agree. Having a dog for 13 years, it becomes family. So, she should've definitely been rewarded the emotional distress.

Judge Judy would given her the $5000 for the defendant laughing. He's a jack ass!

WTF has happened to the English language?

@@margaretakins6829 No matter what condition the dog was in.....she didn't have the right to be attacked by other dogs.

Unfortunately, I don't think the law in that state or perhaps even the federal laws regarding this sort of situation allow that to occur. In many cases - but not all - a judge's hands are tied by what the local laws state they can and can't rule. Hence why there is such an outrage when the public believes a criminal should get one thing, but the Judge rules something far less than expected by the public for the crimes that occurred. It's often not because the judge doesn't agree wholeheartedly with the public, it's because their hands are tied on some cases - again, not all. In saying that, there are some judges who do the opposite, they can issue far greater lengths of time but make the conscious choice not to due to their own particular biases and they do not take the actual law or the crimes committed into account.

Lol I’m fucking dead 😂

Technically it's not. Pitbull is just a slang term for the multiple classes of the breed

@@miss_anthropy stop being so technical it was a joke...

😂😂😂

@@jazmynbrown6820 a joke is a complete stranger telling me to stop doing something 😂

I agree

Same with any large dog. Nothing pit specific. My Australian Shepherd drew blood by stepping on my feet all the time.

The breed has nothing to do with it. I am glad the judge immediately said that it is not the dog but the owner. We have a neighbor’s lab mix that immediately attacks any other dog it comes in contact with and has come onto my property more than once and caused injuries (one requiring surgical intervention) to our dogs. We had to get the sheriff involved to make them control that dog! Meanwhile, we have a pit, a husky, a Great Dane/GSD mix, two beagle mixes, another shepherd mix, and a boxer mix that have never been aggressive but that are always controlled in some way by US because they are all our responsibility!!

​@@lesliemassey-or6cvI still think she has a bias against pitbulls because of previous court cases ....

❤❤❤

💜 YES SWEET BABY 🐶🙏😇💜

Thankyou for this.🙏🏻🕊🌏🌻👍🌹🌺🦋🤜🏻🤛🏽

Omg 🥺

🐕🐶🙏🏽💔

There is no accident in dogs attacking other dogs, it is the owner problem in not being a real dog owner.

Nope normally not. Dog aggression is viewed different than human aggression.@Velma

Denial. Common in pit bull owners! (though def not only them)

They do put a dog down if that dog gets to many cases where it bites dogs or humans. They don’t out a dog after one bite maybe not 2 but 3 and so hold they will put the dog down

Made me tear up listening to video

It IS the dog. Pitbulls are bred to be attack dogs. That was their initial role. You mate an aggressive dog with another aggressive dog and the result is aggressive puppies. Then the most aggressive of those puppies are bred with other aggressive dogs. And on it goes. Pitbulls should be banned. They cause more deaths than all other breeds together.

it is both: the dog and the owner. Some dogs are like some humans whether through genetics or soul inherently troubled.

@@pmabrouk In Quebec, Canada where I live, a few years ago a 55 year old woman was attacked and killed by her neighbour's pitbull that jumped the fence. Since then legislation has been tabled and is in the works to ban pitbulls in this province like has been done in Ontario.

Thank you

In reality they’re dogs(animals)that’s what they do though! 🤷🏽‍♂️

All dogs have the potential to kill...doesnt mean his dogs are just violent animals.. he should of did more to know if his dogs are are friendly with other dogs that are not in his family unit....so sad for mustard

Totally agree. I was like, seriously? You just walked out of court seconds ago- where you/your dogs were found to have KILLED another dog (and this was AT LEAST the second dog killed).

He's a horrible dog owner. If he would watch a 15 minute segment of Cesar Milan he could teach his dogs to be submissive to small dogs. He needs to back them away from the front gate to the middle of the park.

I feel the same way. To add to the injury, the plaintiff’s attitude and, even worse, his son in law’s aggressive responses really made me sad.

Yea true, but this defendant was kind of a jerk. The guy was laughing. He doesn't care about what his dogs did. He had the nerve to say he wasn't notified about the complaints of the dogs. Smh

@@gregoryemeagwara5933 He's definitely why pitbulls have such a terrible stigma

A pitbull recently attacked a girl walking down our street Knocked her down and went for her throat ... A neighbor shot it The dog owner just had his other one shot a week before because it was in someone's yard Some ppl shouldn't own dogs

Idk what it is but I've never had a dog act aggressively towards me. They may bark at the person right in front of me but never me. I always have dogs run up to me and try to lick or sniff me. I remain calm the dog never bothers me

@@lawwhi4204 And a lot of the people who shouldn't own dogs like pitbulls. Pity the dogs.

I totally agree with you !

Dog attacks are very few and far between. You being afraid of dogs isn't based on facts, only your imagination.

@@ukmedicfrcs What a dumb reply!

@@chainsawsally1802 Well then it must be true if YOU say so.

@@chainsawsally1802 In the United States there are 16 dog bite fatalities per year. That's out of 328 MILLION people that more than 50% of them own a dog.. 4.5 million own a pit bull. You do the math. Although I'm pretty sure you can't. If you need help let me know.

RIIIGHT. I own a Pit Bull. I KNOW she's aggressive towards other dogs. I would NEVER take my dog to a dog park.

Because he's entitled and think it is his right to take his dog's to the dog park without a care in the world for other people's dogs.

It be the most irresponsible dog owners that will have their dogs out in the world without a leash.

This is why she should have won he knew they were aggressive

I agree. His aggressive dogs hang out at the front gate to "guard and approve of who comes in". She asked him about them and he said "their fine" then boom they attack. He needs to back them way off the front gate to the middle of the park and have them submit to other dogs as Cesar Milan has taught us since 2005.@@ashleyquam

I hated going to the dog park because I'm super introverted and didn't want to have to talk to anyone. Lots of dog owners don't seem to understand this, possibly because extroverts and more drawn to dogs and introverts to cats. I would wear headphones and pretend not to hear people, but they would tap me or whatever rude thing to get my attention. It was always the same questions to the point where I wanted to get a t-shirt made: NAME: Sonic AGE: Three BREED: Mutt If you tried to actually talk about anything other than dogs, which is not my favouritie conversation topic, they would get uncomfortable. So I can hear all about your dog's BMs and stories but if I ask you what you do for a living, that's too personal? Only owned a dog for the partner, who really wanted one. I ended up having to do most of the work. Since the dog was very sweet and charming (but way too smart and a rule breaker), it was okay, but never again.

What a liar!!! Those 2 pitbulls should be euthanized before they attack another dog...or child.

I just watched a video before this one and the lady got paid for emotional distress. The exact same incident. Exact same judge.

Under the law animals are property and so no pain and suffering can be given

Well she put her dog around 3 put bulls she didn’t know- she caused a lot of her own pain and suffering. I would never do that to my dogs. I can’t believe anyone would just trust other dogs like that with their dog! I can’t even imagine just throwing my dog around 3 pit bulls. I wouldn’t even put them around 1 pitbull that I don’t know. That’s the same as leaving your child with a neighbor that just moved next door. You have to be a real stupid and careless person. Where is her protective instinct? You don’t just trust anyone or anything. I’m so upset for her dog she didn’t do right by her dog!!!

Wherever those litigants are from, it sounds like compensatory damages are not permitted in animal-to-animal cases. There would be jurisdictions in which animal-to-animal situations may call for compensatory damages and, more importantly, had the plaintiff been attacked, she would have been able to to go to civil court and ask for tens of thousands of dollars.

She meant there’s no reward for that. It’s the law. She’s a dog lover for sure.

Yes it's ridiculous 3 pits

I have 2 pit bulls, it's 100% the owner! Not the dog! The breed has nothing at all to do with attacks, its the nature of the animal! ANY dog can bite and be territorial!

Kyla Haynes you are DANGEROUSLY wrong. I agree Pits can be sweet under the right tutelage... but the breed in of itself is more on the aggressive side and that is a fact (think about it... there is a good reason ppl use them to fight and for protection and it aint cause they passive sweethearts.) and a responsible owner that understands that and is hyper aware of it at all times.

@@SheBeDoingNailz It's definitely a case of nature vs. nurture. The breed has been bred for certain traits and, conversely, some people own them for those very traits.

@@kylahaynes4099 you're absolutely right. People are purposely ignorant to this point. They think their uncontrolled ankle biters are adorable when they are always barking and snapping at people- I have been bitten or chased by more 10 lb dogs then any large breed dog

Lol 😆 pittbull

Are you talking Staffordshire bull terrier?

I dc what they call it. It's a pitbull.

One is a heeler/shepherd mix

Same!!! I was wishing the judge would’ve told her to do so as well 🙄

Look now, he can’t hold three of anything!! I’m hollering 😂😂😂😂

I was looking for this comment!! Because please!! Omgosh!

No not really. It’s really how you raise them.

@@TheYamayah Bull. I have a sweet chihuahua EVERYONE loves, including the vet. She's a marshmallow! That doesn't make me stupid enough to think "It's all in how you raise them". I know the breed is often nasty and snappy. Just because I own an exception to that does not make me blind to reality. The "it's all how you raise them' pitbull crowd is in serious denial about them.

@@granitemoss1451 of course you must consider the nature of the breed. But my pits were the sweetest and I knew my dogs reaction to people places and things. Just my experience.

Please don't blame the breed or the dog

@@granitemoss1451 i have 2 what americans would call pitbulls. Altough they are FCI registrated american staffordshire terriers. I keep obedience trainig them EVERY day. Key is to socializing them very early age. It is a breeders job from day 1! And from the day they come home owners job, not let them grow randomly. And that actually applies to all breeds.

Judge judy would have given her 5,000. She chose the wrong court to come to.

Dogs are legally property. It’d be like giving someone pain and suffering for a broken computer. I get why it is that way, and I think it’s probably better this way. Otherwise I think people would get dogs, and set up “accidents” and sue for pain and suffering. People already do that with themselves.

She can but it just wouldn't be the same.

Emotional guide dogs and support dogs? Agee: extremely precious, valuable animals. Police dogs? Not so much. It's been proven that like with lie detector tests, they are most a sham.

I just had to put my miniature schnauzer down. The saddest day in my life! 😭😭💔

I love miniature schnauzers 🥰🥰🥰🥰

OMG wasn't he!! He little beard was just WAY too cute!!!!!!!

I had to put my mini schnauzer down a couple of months ago. Still sad.

I used to hate Schnauzers, miniature or otherwise (they just look gross and dirty with their beards), until I met someone with a mini. It was definitely one of THE sweetest, most loving dogs in the world. Totally changed my mind on the species.

You're a cold hearted jerk. It's not the dogs fault.

@@ukmedicfrcs That breed is inherently dangerous!

@@vkatvkat9590 Well it must be true if YOU say so. There are only 16 dog bite fatalities per year in the United States. That's out of 238 MILLION people. 4.5 million people own Pit bulls in the United States. Can you do the math or do you need help? They are not inherently dangerous and it's small minded people like yourself that give the breed a bad name.

@@vkatvkat9590 no the fuck it’s not I grew up with having 6 pit bulls they never attacked it’s all about the owner it’s obvious he didn’t have the pit bulls when they were younger he should have taken them to behavior school for dogs you’re just as ignorant as the rest I seen tiny dogs attack kids and they don’t get a bad rep Because they’re cute

@@ukmedicfrcs 1,040 pit bull attacks in Birmingham Alabama Go check state by State to read how many pit bull attacks. I'm not counting death by a pit. Was I rude to you?

But socializing is important. You need to go at a quiet time of day and take a look at who is in there before you enter. Dogs absolutely flip out when they know they are going to the dogpark. Imagine never having friends again. It't the same for them.

@@bluepuppy1139 -not socializing my dog keeps him safe, I don’t want to end up like this. This plaintiff is rediculous, “ my dog is very loving”, well, not with someone else’s dog.

.... Because of dumb owners?

@@lepoindexter because I don't want one! Has nothing to do with someone else.

You said "this." ..a reference to this case.

@@lepoindexter Not talking about this specific case... What difference does it make anyway? I just don't want a dog. Simple as that.

@@jazmynbrown6820 then why did you say “this is why...”??😂

Yes they do! Everyone I know that owns one ends up having trouble with them. Doesn't mean the owner is negligent, the dogs just choose to be vicious!

@@jazmynbrown6820 Omg you can't be serious. Ignorance like this is exactly why some breeds have a bad name.

And your comment is completely false. Pit bull attacks make the news because it makes a good news story. They're not the breed that bites the most, they're not the breed with the most powerful bite. They get a bad name because some ghetto thugs think that it's cool to own one, put a chain around it's neck and then use the dog for fighting. It's the people NOT the breed.

@@ukmedicfrcs Sweetie, I'm just telling the truth. I'm not trying to offend anyone. Don't call me ignorant because you don't know me boo. Imma spare you this time.

@@jazmynbrown6820 You're not telling any truth sweetie and bring all you got. I'm here waiting for it.

Harvey is way too ballsy when it comes to dogs, but I'm not sure why someone would bring an aggressive one to a filming / interview booth of TPC. You dealt with dogs in stressed out situations. These dogs were not stressed out from being in the dog park. I am a total lovable bastard, apparently, when things are going well. When I'm super stressed, stand back! I won't attack you physically, but I definitely have some things to say to you.

So you tryna say pit bulls are naturally aggressive?

@@kaylabrown4699 I’m not tryna say it. It’s FACTS! They are

Another fact... pits are not the most aggressive breed. they dont even make the top 5 but 8 on the top ten. There is no reason to say all pit bull will attack as you're implying. As the judge said there's no bad dog just bad dog owners. The owner of these pit bulls were neglagent of taking proper care of dogs that had temprament issues stemming from how they were cared for before them. They should have known better and taken proper precautions. They didn't and the dogs were put into a situation they never should have been in. All dogs here suffered because of the actions of the defendant. Perhaps you were meaning to say those pits attacked and there's no argument there.

@@bornwolfgirl3155 Yeah they are

@@PrettyYellaTV im sure that are many pit bull owners who can dispute that. Not all pitts are aggressive and it usually takes certain triggers. I repeat its all in how they are raised. Do they have a great genetic predisposition and they takes a little more care and training. Yes.

was looking for a dog awhile back and went to county and private rescue places.....kennel after kennel of pits!!! to the point where there were no other choices of rescue. i was astounded!!!!

Same law on the books in Miami-Dade County, FL. It is against the law to own pitbulls or pitbull mixes. Of course people break the law and have them anyway, but anytime I see one in someone's yard I call animal control.

@@Childfree334 I thank God for you. We don't need those dangerous animals in our city or state for that matter.

Right! Stupidest shit ever

I’m sure it’s more of a hassle to find somebody without a last name unless you KNOW somebody on here

Haha TRUE! Especially when he started to do that familiar rhetoric " they're Staffordshire terriers, not pit bulls" argument a lot of them use. JJ would have tore him a new one, especially after laughing.

It's a shame some people like Judge Judy claim pit bull attacks are common and that all pit bulls are bad dogs. It's 100% the owner that makes the dog behave in such a way.

@@ukmedicfrcs She never said they were bad dogs; she said they are dangerous. 100% truth.

@@lisabinhawaii324And that is false. There are only 16 fatalities per year from pitbulls, that's out of over 239 million people. 4.5 million own pitbulls. You do the math. Over 80% of Pitbull attacks are caused by the owner. That's a fact.

@@lisabinhawaii324 Here’s something that should interest you: a 2016 study conducted by the Journal of Interpersonal Violence found out that most aggressive dogs are owned by people who have criminal records for aggressive crimes, alcohol abuse, drugs, domestic violence, and illegal possession or irresponsible use of firearms. You can't make a blanket statement about an entire breed. Every dog is an individual. I run a rescue and I have many so called dangerous breeds that are the most gentle loving dogs you could be around, once they're removed from their horrible environment. Being chained up all day, alone. Physically being struck as a form of discipline etc. People murder other people for far less. We are the dangerous species not dogs.

Seriously? You think killing more dogs is the remedy?!

Yes lol Rufus is huge, cute, and so friendly