I totally agree with moonlit seduction. So many people criticized it, but it's one of my favourites! I feel so confident using this palette because every look I do turns out amazing. The special shades feel like BUTTER and are so wet and shiny. And FINALLY SOMEONE WHO APPRECIATES MIDNIGHT SUN. It's my number 1 palette. The versatility of the palette insane.

Even though I disagree with your rating, I have to say that you have the best explanation for why you picked the palettes the way you did. You didn't just say "oh I like it and I use it" as every other influencer on KZfaq does. I watched this long video to the end and truly enjoyed. Thank you.

I ADORE midnight sun. I have that and Mothership 1, and I basically switch out between winter/spring summer/fall. It’s wild seeing them all lined up in the thumbnail, the vast range of the first six compared to those last four is kind of tragic :(

My mothership 5 works perfectly fine and I love it ! I use rephr brushes by the way . Or with other brushes it becomes patchy you are right.

Midnight sun was always a favorite of mine

I've enjoyed this video, thanks. Decadence actually had a gold limited edition Star Wars packaging, it was Midnight Sun the one with the sticker 😉

I love Moonlit Seduction so much I have 2 of them ❤

Gran revisión, gracias

I’m so glad u popped up in feed. I really enjoyed your video. Minus the subversive our top five are the same just a different order. I am always flabbergasted when bronze Seduction is not the bottom in people’s ranking. I feel like all the others you can pretty much rank based on color story preference. But the bronze seduction has formula problems and when something is that expensive every shade should work. The dark purple for me in that palette is a patchy mess and that guilty pleasure shade is some weird putty thing with hardpan. I think color story wise it would be up there for me but because of the formula problems it’s definitely last place. Had it been the first mothership that I had purchased I would never have bought another one.

Lol the way I died when you said that pink 003 is just meh. Ahhh it's my favorite shade! I do agree it's best as a subtle eyeshadow and highlighter, but I like that. Totally agree that the gold and coral/gold in Divine Rose I don't really belong. Imo, I think those shades should have been some bright pinks. Also, I agree with pale gold in subliminal. I get that gold is kind of pat's signature, but it really does not belong in every palette. Pale gold should absolutely have been replaced with a silver. Thank you for making this video! I enjoyed watching 🥰

Good video. But The last one which position it is for you?

I think we have the same top 3. Maybe the order is a bit different but still, top 3. 🤣

I’m sorry to say I don’t see the value. I’ve duped with Sydney Grace which always preforms at less than 1/2 the price & Phenomenal customer service

I have this palettes among my 60 palettes collection and for me Pat Macgrath eyeshadow palettes are the worst 😢 waisted money.