I think John DiMaggio does the "Killing Joke" better than Mark Hamill because of how cold and scary it sounds when he tells it.

I love mark hamill but I feel like they put his performance so high on a pedestal that other actors don’t put their own spin or voice into the role like so few have. This is a terrifying performance and I love it.

That's what I appreciate about Dimaggio's portrayal--he never tried to imitate Hamill. He made the role his own.

I always liked how everyone acted around this Joker. You can really tell time has passed in this version of Gotham and that everyone knows that the Joker is a big deal and no good. Black Mask breaks Joker out of prison not just cause he's desperate but also because Joker's reputation means something. Barely anyone is brave enough to confront him and those that do like Batman are extremely cautious. Joker is Gotham's apex predator in this

While I love Mark Hamill as Joker I gotta admit my two personal favorites are John DiMaggio and Kevin Michael Richardson, both criminally underrated Jokers. When ever I read the comics I hear John DiMaggio’s voice every time and also I’d love to see a live action interpretation of the Kevin Michael Richardson one since it would be creepy and unlike any interpretation we’ve ever seen.

The "GOTTA GIVE THE BOY POINTS!!!" Line is my favorite joker line

This was the first Joker I saw that made me think "this looks like a guy who may actually stand a chance against Batman in a hand to hand fight." He just didn't look as emaciated as he usually does. Those broad shoulders, thick neck, and yeah, that raspy voice all added to this dangerous looking Joker. It shows that he doesn't only need psychological tactics to get his way. He has the ability to use force if he needs to.

Under The Red Hood just did so much right. I wish Jensen could voice Jason Todd more. Plus I would like more Bruce Greenwood Batman projects with him. Especially with Kevin's untimely passing.

I think what really helps that laugh is how... random it feels. It doesn't repeat over and over, it's constantly changing pitch which makes it come off really wrong. Laughs tend to remain somewhat constant in pitch, his jumps all over the place.

The fact that he didn't sound like Mark is what I liked. Same thing with Ledger. The joker is a hard character to bring an original take to, so I appreciate it when it's done well.

Would love to see him in more animated projects as the joker. Killed it in both performances. Also Bruce Greenwood was fantastic.

What always gets me is the face he makes as he goes to smash the water glass. Just screams, “Alrighty, let’s do this.”

I really wish DiMagio did more turns as the Joker

What a joker! John DiMaggio was great. Then again, so was pretty much everyone in Under The Red Hood. Bruce Greenwood did a good Batman and Jensen Ackles is the definitive Red Hood.

I was just watching your worst ever Joker video, and I started thinking of John DiMagio's Joker performance, because it really was very good, especially because it's so different from Mark Hamill's Joker, yet still SO on point for the character. I love the scene where he kills all of Black Mask's goons and then says "I'm gonna need some guys...not these guys, because they're, you know, kinda dead" lol

DiMagio's Joker may be one of the top 5 people to portray the Joker. Perhaps underrated though many may have thought Red Hood Joker was done by Hamill & Batman done by Conroy

John DiMaggio is my 2nd favorite animated Joker VA (behind of course Mark Hamil) and just like you, I never would have imagined him voicing the Joker but he delivered his lines so effortlessly and cruelly. My favorite scene with his take on the Joker is the Killing Joke scene with Jason.

I love this Joker because of his voice, especially that laugh, his laugh is just filled with so much malice and spite, your pain brings him absolute joy. Any chance of doing a review of Brave and the Bold Joker? He's definitely one of my favorite versions of the character. A step down from all the gritty and edgy Jokers back to the goofy Joker of the early days, but can still act menacing when he needs to.

John DiMagio did a magnificent job as The Joker! He is my fourth favourite after Mark Hamill, Troy Baker and Kevin Michael Richardson. Michael Emerson ( The Dark Knight Returns ) is my fifth favourite Joker.😊

I remember when John DiMaggio said that he and a friend did a bee box performance at the Apollo in Harlem and didn't get booed off stage.

Exactly! Not every incarnation of the Joker _”has”_ to be Mark Hamill (no disrespect to him whatsoever). The fact that Mark himself approved of John’s performance is really testament to how _well_ he pulled off the role (👍)!

“A little louder, lamb chop! I think you may have a collapsed lung, that always impedes the oratory.”

I think Mark said he’d no longer play Joker without Kevin’s Batman. So maybe John or even Troy can step up to the role more.

Brooo john dimaggio's take on the joker is one of my favorite versions of the character, i absolutely loved him in under the red hood and death in the family, would love to see him come back in another animated batman movie or heck maybe even a new batman game

Thanks for this video. I had been praising John Dimaggio as the Joker for awhile. No idea why not many more people noticed.

I think what gave him the edge was how great the script was.

John DiMaggio's take is probably my 2nd favorite, behind Mark Hamill's But Above Kevin Micheal Richardson's take, i really love this joker

John dimmagio is one of the few voice actors i know by name purely from the wuality if his work, hes one of the goats and really underrated

Troy is the only person that should be allowed to Mimic Hamills Joker since he does it so perfectly. I feel like people just overlook him just cause he does a Hamill impression. He puts just of enough of a spin on the character to know it's him

I'd love to see a three jokers story concept with if time willing Mark Hamil (i'd settle for Jeff Bennett's performance in Brave and the bold for a "oldschool" joker), John DiMaggio as second joker and maybe Richard Epcar? or Kevin Michael Richardson? as third and have three jokers with three different takes on the same madness.

To forget Dimaggio's role as Joker is to not know what brilliance an animated Jason Todd is.

You know what I dislike most about the Joker is that the character is indirectly responsible for the arch-nemeisis obsession. As much as I like the Joker, it does annoy me when fans get obsessed over a superhero having an arch-nemeisis that they just exspect will always show up in almost every story involving the superhero. For example, people who complain that the Shredder doesn't play a role in some of the TMNT stories.

6:16 I absolutely love this part of the video! I'm glad I'm not the only one that realizes that this joker was inspired by the Dark knights Joker, for me the messy hair and the eyebrows and the black makeup near his eyes really suits him and makes him look 10 times menacing! I always prefer this Joker design over the other designs we received, Surprisingly, I think they brought this design over to Mortal Kombat 11 as well and of course My favorite is Joker! God I love this joker! 🃏

Let me tell you something vee infuso you are right john dimagio is a great joker

John Dimaggio's joker is my second favorite to mark's. its sadistic without being up its own ass about it. the humor is on point, no one has ever made me laugh more about a crowbar and on several occasions at that. he's grounded but still larger than life. its almost perfect on its own but since mark has had decades with it, there is no point comparing it with each other since mark has fleshed him out like no one has or will ever do.

Had the honor to meet him and tell him about how amazing his joker was and wanted an autograph of that joker but some reason he didn't have any pictures of this joker he told me why I just can't remember...but yes...a greatly underrated joker

This one and The Joker from The Batman cartoon are my absolute favorite versions of him outside of the books. The one from Under The Red Hood is very much The Psychotic hilarious maniac while the one from the show is the very zany and very acrobatic clown. Another thing that really makes them stand out compared to certain (Read it: Certain) other versions of Joker is the fact that they can actually take Batman in a fight, especially the one from the cartoon in the first two seasons

Would have loved a 3 Jokers movie with DiMagio as the Criminal, Hamill as the Comedian, Baker as the Clown, Ackles as Jason, and Conroy as Batman. Every time I revisit that comic I hear those voices.

To me, John DiMaggio is my second favorite voice for the Joker (third been Heath Ledger and 1....we all know), what he brings to Under the Red Hood is just incredible and he easily is one of the highlights of an already masterpiece of a film.

Yeah, that's about right. John DiMaggio did a surprisingly good job.

Y'know at this point, I think I would love to see a breakdown of every Joker performance (animated and live-action). Probably too much work, but your breakdowns are very well thought-out and entertaining.

Personally Kevin Michael Richardson Joker is one of my favorite depictions of the character. One of the main reasons is cause 2004-2008's The Batman was the first Batman cartoon I ever watched when I was a kid, think it might've been my first real introduction to batman in general actually. Even now I still watch an episode from time to time, its underappreciated to be honest. Also Batman V Dracula is a banger of a movie and the vampirized Joker in it is so cool, go watch it if you haven't.

I feel like Mark Hamill is better as the silly yet serious villain that you could see return day after day but for a sadistic psycho who cracks jokes while cracking necks, John really is the best! The darkest moments in the comics for me have his voice in my mind!

"what a joker." this was splendid vid, vee. also, i don't speak for all batman fans i'm sure, but there are more than a few of us who purposely avoid certain adaptations of batman (i.e watching only movies and ignoring the animation) when possible due to not being in the right headspace to consume that type of content. still by the sounds of things this joker is pretty good. i may give these movies a chance at some point.

Finally we give this performance a shout-out!

John DiMaggio is just amazing and a terrifying Joker and down right hilarious.

"i'll need some guys. not these guys, because well they kinda dead." love johnny D as the joker.

The day this man talks about Batman The Brave and the Bold is the day i'll be happy.

Honeslty, one of my favorites

I like that this guy proves the Joker can be more than just a copy of Hamill’s voice to be good.

i always loved that in DiMaggio's appearances as joker, that his joker seemed to act out of sheer boredom. killing just for killing isnt the fun part to him. its leaving a mark. he likes to see others around him destroyed by his actions. its why in death in the family he is so excited whenever he sees robin. because he understands the damage he dealt to robin and sees how far he has fallen entirely because of jokers actions. its why he attempts to kill jason in the first place; to see batman hurt. i always liked the scene where he kills masks guards. he enters the scene i feel with a genuine sense of boredom. and by the end he is exhilarated by his total dominion over mask, and that he has caused him problems for literally no reason. he enjoys doing things intentionally irredeemable and things that dont have a justification. even in the scene where he beats jason to death, he seems bored. sure hes reveling in robins pain. but it isnt enough for him. he wants to get to the punchline. "tell bats i said hello" is the perfect summary of this version of the joker. he is my favourite by far.

I used to think Lego Joker was John in the Lego games now I know it's Chris Smith.

"And...here...we...go" 🦇

I think what helps with John DiMaggio voicing Joker is that he's had experience voicing a Joker-like character in the past (albeit he didn't have the same level of intimidation as Joker) - Dr. Draken from Kim Possible. As someone who grew up with KP, DiMaggio had fit more for Joker than people realized. ^^

I thought of Under the Red Hood immediately before clicking this video. I thought that was one of the most incredible performances, and the only thing that made that film stand out.

"This isn't Batman, this isn't your inner demon, this is YOU! The deep down INSIDE you!" "SO ADMITTED, SON!!! Who's your daddy?" Probably the BEST lines of John DiMaggio's Joker

Also joker trying to get that Lighter to light is the most realistic thing i have ever seen

I love how unexpectedly great DiMaggio was as Joker He did his own thing and he did it perfectly, it’s why I like him as a voice actor

DiMaggio's voice for this Joker was perfect. The voice cast is one of the top reasons why this movie is as good as it is.

finally someone put my thoughts into words, he's absolutely my favorite animated joker ever!

What a Joker.

Kevin Michael Richardson's portrayal was great. John DiMaggio's delivery sounds like Bender from Futurama was playing the Joker.... Oh Wait A Minute

The way he says "boy wonder" in the Death of the Family ending will always be awesome.

He really is fantastic. I would love to see more of his Joker, in this kind of material.

I feel joker from the dark knight returns needs love, dude was the actual devil in that movie

I've always loved this version.

I think DiMaggio should be the new go to animated joker voice

Omg the cameos are so good! I have chills

My 2nd favorite Joker voice. He's amazing. "Tell the big man I said... Hello.... HAHAHAHA"

Even though Mark Hamill is inseparable as Joker, John DigMaggio did such a fantastic and unique performance with Joker. Honestly he is my second favorite voice actor of the character my third being Troy Baker.

I love John DiMaggios joker I’m glad someone else is talking about his version of the joker.

John Dimaggio made a great job. Thanks for this video, it’s a good tribute this movie and the character.

What a Joker, again? I like how some of your videos are like trading cards. Makes me wanna collect all the Jokers you got. Btw, I’m gonna have to see if you have any “merch”.

Love the cameos at the end!🙏🤘

I love this Joker because he seems to genuinely trying to get others to laugh.

bro how can ppl forget about his joker. dimaggio's "Tell the big man i said...hello." still haunts me

We might get more John DiMaggio now since Mark Hamill is retiring his Joker (he wants to do the role with Kevin Conroy only).

John's Joker is such an underated character from a very great film. this is truly crimminal

His speech to Jason Todd while Todd had a gun on him was perfect. He seemed proud of what Todd became.

I'm really glad this video was made since it was a video I commented I would be interested in on one of the community posts 😁.

John DiMaggio's Joker was the first and scariest version I've seen of the character. Which made me love the character as well.

You've convinced me my friend I didn't see him this way

I think the main issue is that for the longest time, John DiMaggio wasn't listed in most people "favorite Jokers" top 3s/top5s because he had only played him in *"Under the Red Hood"* , in which he was arguably the tertiary antagonist after Red Hood & Black Mask (and I guess Ra's al Ghul was also important, voiced by the fantastic Jason Isaacs, who would make a fabulus live action Ra's... in my mind he's probably the only one who could top Alexander Siddig's portrayal of the Demon's Head in *Gotham* ) And sadly, despite being awesome, the interactive movie *"Death in the Family"* suffered from a very, very confusing promotional campaign, in which many people got suckered into buying the digital version of the film, which was just a shorter retelling of UTRH with a couple bonus scenes (Bruce Wayne and Clark Kent having a chat in a diner at the end was nice, but hardly worth the money they asked for it) And even to this day, there are still Batman fans who never realized that the physical version of that film is completely different and full of amazing new scenes. ... and you just taught me that John also voiced Joker is a couple Lego movies (I'm not a massive fan of those so I didn't know). In short, => _First issue: he hasn't played Joker enough_ The fact that he was pretty much the first "major" movie Joker after *"The Dark Knight"* (2008), just 2 years after Heath Ledger blew everyone's mind with his performance as the Joker, also didn't play in John's favor. I feel like most people just wanted more Ledger, or more Mark Hamill (the game *Arkham Asylum* came out just one year after TKD, and Joker there was very well received... but Mark is the most famous animated Joker, from *Batman:TAS* to *Justice League: Action* ) in short => _Second issue: had to compete with Ledger & Hamill /!\ pre-posting trigger warning edit: from here I don't talk about the Joker much, so you can stop reading, unless you want to read my rant about Black Mask /!\ And then there's my selfish take on UTRH, when the movie was announced I was ecstatic because my man Roman Sionis, the Black Mask, that I fell in love with thanks to Matsuda's *The Batman* (voiced by James Remar) , and who was played by John DiMaggio himself in *Batman: The Brave and the Bold* , is absolutely hilarious in *Under the Hood* (funny how the movie was such a success that in future reprinting, the name of the comic book arc would be changed to Under the Red Hood instead of simply "Under the Hood" , but hey it does ring a bit better IMHO) and even if I realize that most people enjoy Wade Williams' role as Black Mask in that movie, and I enjoy it myself, his characterization is very different from the one in the comic book arc. So even if I loved that movie, I kinda resented the extra scenes that Joker got compared to the comic book version of that story, since I felt like the extra Joker scenes took away from Black Mask's own arc... I really wanted to see him interact with Mr Freeze, Deathstroke, and even go toe-to-toe with Red Hood himself. Ironic how I had to wait for friggin' *Batwoman* season 2 to finally get a proper adaptation of _my_ Roman Sionis (played by Peter outerbridge) who is the Big Bad of the second season of that crappy show. I mean, a crappy show/season can still have some great characters & episodes here and there, and for me, that second season of *Batwoman* had some quality versions of Black Mask, Victor Zsasz, Cluemaster, and to a lesser degree, Hush (only in one episode, but he was still way better than how he was in season 1 pre-facial surgery). On the good guys side, we got out first live action Stephanie Brown, who was really good, much better than the mediocre one from *Gotham Knight* (the CW show, not the video game) and a badass cameo from John Diggle, who helps Luke Fox/Batwing take on his old comic book nemesis Russell "Menace" Tavaroff, and give him some sound advice. Wow, I really went on a wild tangent here, sorry about that (if anyone managed to read all that mess ^^') Keep up the good work, Vee!

"What a Joker." Very good video and I totally share the sentiment of John DiMaggio's joker being underrated👍 No kidding my top 3 Jokers are: 1. Mark Hamill 2. John DiMaggio (Under the Red Hood) 3. Kevin Michael Richardson (The Batman, 2004 animated series) And the honorable mention goes to Troy Baker because he sounds too much like Hamill's Joker. Also the designs of the Joker in UTRH is awesome. A great work all around with the character.

What a Joker

Man why doesnt KZfaq recommend your videos i always gotta look for them myself

I love his joker, he’s intermediating looking. probably one of the only jokers I wouldn’t want to come across of.

DiMaggio is my favorite joker of all time I'm glad it's getting a spotlight

Under the Red Hood, joker does not get enough love, unpopular opinion I think his version of the joker is my favorite. I'm so glad you did a video on him.

A personal favorite Joker VA of mine is Anthony Ingruber. He played John/Joker in Telltales Batman. He definitely pulls inspiration from Mark Hamill, but adds his own flavor to it.

This video needed to be made. This joker was awesome

I am glad there is still people talking about this joker and his voice actor. IT WAS.....YOOOOOO. An older joker that has been many battles with the Batman. Title of the video is the truth.

He’s evil and despicable, yet I can’t help but laugh with every line he says. I hope we see more of him in future projects.

John DiMaggio is a such a great voice actor

100% agree! I adored this version of the Joker for standing out amongst the others and trying something new. His voice and characterisation was perfect for the story being told; dark and menacing whilst still having that unhinged Joker energy. Wish we had seen more of John DiMaggio's Joker.

5:49 is actually my favorite Joker laugh of all time. The way John's voice starts off high & hoarse then devolves into hysterical laughter gets me every time. Dude is a phenomenal Joker.

Thank you...finaly someone talked about him

I think his best scene is when Red Hood is going to bomb the entire building with Bats and Joker inside, Bats runs to defuse the explosive and Joker stops him and starts choking him and laughing maniacally. He gives a very ominous feeling that this joker is completely out of it. Like, all Jokers are completely iinsane, but most of his iterations have at least a modicum of self preservation, but DiMaggios Joker literally just pure madness.

7:25 - that, good sir, is the Trickster.

If I ever get a chance to say one thing face to face with John DiMaggio, I'd tell him he's my favorite Joker. Of all his many many great roles, I think this one's the best. Flippant, petulant, genuinely unsettling, it really hits.