Also I figured it was fake because Super Princess Peach didn’t sell well enough to motivate Nintendo to make another peach game at the time

I knew it wasn’t real when you brought in daisy and rosalina. nintendo would never include them 😭

Deadass I was about to search for this game on ebay or something you had me so convinced im actually pissed I cant play this game!. I recognized your style on the art but when you showed the pixel versions I was hooked. Great job as usual!

I love all three horse designs.

Nah, bc if this was an actual game i would be ALL OVER THIS. I not only grew up as a big Mario girly, but I was also a horse girl. So this is the like the best of both worlds

im mad that this isnt real bc it would have been soooo cute [also imagining horseradish is a donkey and worcestershire is a mule]

NO CUZ THIS ACTUALLY HAD ME FOOLED I WAS LIKE "aw i wish we got this game this sounds so cute :[" ONLY TO BE BAMBOOZLED- But serious note you did great, all the horses have great designs and I love the outfits the horses and princesses get!!

You NAILED These Pony looks as they would totally look if this game was true

i was actually invested and believed this- honestly i would love to see this as a game

I caught on as soon as I saw the horses. I’ve been watching your animations and viewing your art style in general is so distinctive and once I saw Cream, it clicked into place. Keep up the amazing work!

I could tell because your style is so distinctive. It's a beautiful style, but it definitely gave it away for me lol. You did an amazing job!!

I had actually recognized the way you drew the lineart and the knees of the horses from your other horse art. But honestly you had me pretty fooled with the game screen shots.

I feel like the Bad Bros would be like the Gorman brothers in Majora’s Mask for how they would take over the horse land, and maybe their horses are tired of all the cutesy things so that’s why they teamed up. I LOVED their names, really went well with them. And honestly, I don’t think I would have noticed this wasn’t a thing if I hadn’t seen the comments first on accident lol. Well done! Keep feeding us more games that don’t exist that should exist! 😂 (Also still recommending a Zecora dragon pony :3 lol)

I almost got caught but, naah clean lines don't "scream" lost game. But the blurry ones made me believe it for a second lmao

This was honestly really convincing ! If I wasn't so familiar with your artstyle I would have fallen right into it ! But now I'm so sad this isn't a real game ! 🥲I love the concept so much !!! 😍😍😍

Bro your art looks like official nintendo art! Bro I got garfuncled

Aw man but the concept is soooo good ❤

You had me at first lol. Ngl, I'd probably play it if it were real. I'd imagine the premise would work well as an auto runner or a 2D Sonic style game.

God Dammit, you nearly had me! The only reason i realized it was fake was cause of all the art and info you had LOL Like 4min in I'm like "Wait, this is a lot of art and info for a Cancelled sequel that no one has heard of!" That being said, god damn this looks SO good and official!

Ahh you got me. The screenshots looked like mock ups but the concept art was really on brand.

Horses are my all-time favorite animals! After elephants, of course.

Ok I was so convinced Deadass thought this was either gonna be a redesign video or just an analysis video But uhm,,, Now I need more-

The way that i wouldve being obsessed with this as a child. Also as soon as you said Daisy was in it i knew it was fake... which breaks my heart, but thats how Nintendo be

She had me in the first half, not gonna lie XD

the fact that this isn’t real is sooo heartbreaking though I would have loved this game 💔💔💔 BUT this shows your amazing conceptual skills wow!!!! 💗🌸💗🌸💗🎠

Wdym all y'all saying this isn't real I remember playing this on my hot pink Dsi after I'd get home from school way back when. Game was fun but the horse mechanics were a little jank. Didn't like how Cream would sometimes throw you off of her back mid-jump when you'd double tap the a button :[

i would have LOVED this as a kid as well as now. i had a bit of skepticism bc your artstyle is so recognizable, but the brushing screenshots are what fooled me XD ughgh i want this game so bad the horsie designs are so so cute!

I want this as a game so bad, nintendo please contact this artist PLEASE.

Dude, I would love to see more game concepts from you. I know your art style so I knew this wasn't real. But you made a concept that actually got me super interested in. And I'm not even a horse person, I just thought it was neat :D

Djwjsjdjthe horse designs are so cute!!😭💖

Someone should make this into an actual game!

Oh wow the concepts look so cool! You know that would have been a great April Fool's Day prank!

I love all of this!!! I wish they’d come back on the idea and actually do it!

I would 10000% buy this game. This needs to exist like, yesterday

I think Worcestershire and Horseradish could be motivated enough by Wario and Walugi promising to cut them in on the profits (probably lying tho), but I also like the idea of them wanting to like... Participate in horse races, but cheat so that they get the glory of being winners. So the hypothetical tracks that Wario and Waluigi want to build could have various tricks hidden in them that Worcestershire and Horseradish know about and can take advantage of.

I believed it enough to send the link to my friends and say “I’d eat this up” but the pixel art is really what pushed me to believe it

Honestly that was really impressive I love the idea and I was fooled

It was right around 4:00 that I pressed x to doubt. Something about the costumes and the pristine quality of the 'found' images was throwing me off. These are amazing!

WorcesterSHIRE... pun well done 👏 Loved the designs, especially for the horses 🐎 ❤️ Wish this was real because we horse girls deserve better horse games

I got the game ad on this- LMAO

WHAAAAAAT!?! You really convinced me, I even looked it up! And I was just thinking to myself “ Wow this game sounded really amazing and well thought out.” I’m convinced that you can even make up your own game!

I am so mad that this game was never real, it seems like it would've been adorable. Especially with the carrot power ups and potential for all kinds of horse theming. Like, maybe the snow land could be a sugarcube mine or something like that As for why Horse Radish and Worcestershire teamed up with Wario and Waluigi, maybe they wanted to ensure that they wouldn't be captured and were willing to throw everyone else on their island under the bus if it meant that they could still be free

IM OBSESSED!!!! I probably would have totally been convinced, but I looked at the comments and got spoiled :( Wario and Waluigi’s horses are incredible and I love them. I love all these designs. They’re so cool gaaa

this would devoure actually

I'm genuinely angry these characters aren't real now. I've only just been introduced, but I'm already so attached to them regardless of how silly a princess peach horse game is

i was confused cuz at first i thought it was just fanart then i thought you were talking about an actual game but it all looked like your art 🤣

Adult me will buy the game 😂 and I was thinking this feels My Little Pony🤔

That looks so good! I want this to be real!

why would you fool me like this

No way i actually thought this was real!! Omggg i love this idea so much!!

Ngl if I weren’t way to into Mario I probably wouldn’t have batted an eye

Someone actually make this a an actual sequel to super princess peach i would play this

The horse designs are AMAZING but I feel like they're the wrong types for each princess. Peach would absolutely have a unicorn. Daisy's tomboy personality makes me think she'd pair well with a normal horse. Rosalina is from space, so I can see her having a pegasus. Just my thoughts tho, I was completely fooled up until the end 🙃

i was fully convinced omg i would Love to play it.. honestly kind of want to try making something similar XD

😭 it looks like it would be so fun if it was real!

The way this was all made felt very convincing! I was shocked by the reveal! I was wondering why I'd never heard of this canceled game and was about to actually go tell people about it baha-

You have my 5 dollars, thank you for the feeding the little horse girl within me

You almost had me there! This is a really good concept, and it makes my heart sad that it isn’t real

I was completely convinced

it would’ve been more convincing if i didn’t read the comments as i watched the video lol

why.. would you do me like that I texted a friend about this halfway through the video🤡 my disappointment is immeasurable

Yo I love there designs they look amazing :)

I immediately got My Little Pony vibes from this! Too bad some Nintendo games with creative and interesting concepts never get to see the light of day... UNTIL YOU SAID IT WAS A LIE!!! Very cool concept for a Princess Peach game!

I'm not quite convinced this isn't fake but I'll hear you out.

You even had me fooled! 🦄

I had no idea omg

Welp, you sure fooled me! Would play if this was real. And I would 100% main Hot Sauce bc he's just a goofy yeehaw boi.

Oh, man. I was fooled until I read the comments and then I finished the rest of the video. Lol! XD The concept for this sounds really cool. I can totally imagine Nintendo making something like this.

This need to be game 😢💙🖤

got this on my recomended :DDD

i want to see waluigi become an villain again way back to dance dance revolution mario mix

NOW IM SAD THAT ILL NEVER BE ABLE TO PLAY THIS GAME 💔💔

This is so cool omggg

Why did I believe this???? DAMN YOU TRICKED ME WITH DAISY >:(

well i hope this game is real

I honestly never thought this game exist. It looks like a Mario crossover with My little Pony for some reason.

100% would play

I miss this game :( Sadly my mom got rid of it..

I was seriously believing that this game was real for the entire video until the twist at the end. The game concept was very unique but still close enough to what I feel Nintendo would do with a side character like peach that I believed this game was real. Especially since Nintendo could have reused the idea of cow girl peach for princess peach show time if the game was real. Really cool video. I love the au. 🤍🎀

I wish this was real or even a fan game. I would dead ass play this, as i liked both super princess peach and show time. Im a sucker for equine characters especially when they look cute, and im a horseback rider, i work at a therapeutic riding ranch for people with disabilities. I also ride competitive.

I need someone who knows how to code to make this a thing😭

I knew it was fake as soon as waluigi was mentioned lmao

I was genuinely and thoroughly tricked! I would’ve never caught on!

Missed opportunity to make an April's fools video lol but awesome work.

God dammit I was so convinced 😭

NO!!!!!!!!!!!! NOW I WANT TO PLAY THIS GAME!!! like yeah I knew that it wasn't a real one and the art is still amazing but not my ass wanting a silly horse game for my ds that follows up from super princess peach. (Jk I WANT TO PLAY THIS SO BAD NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

If you make a series based off this idea I would definitely buy things based off this idea

I had suspicions when you showed the art for this hypothetical game, but I became convinced as you talked about it that it was real! I legit thought that the way you drew the horses was just a coincidence and that it was official art. One thing I think could’ve fully sold the idea is making alts of the official art that are jpg style compressed.

You convinced me REAL GOOD! Dammit!🏳️

OMG HOW DARE YOU FOOL ME JAJAJAJAJAJAJA I THOUGHT IT WA A REAL GAME AND I WAS SO EXITED TO MAKE FANART😭😭😭😭

You had me fooled right from the start dude omg. The art, gorgeous!!! It looked so official like, holy cheeseballs. Once you said it was fake the first Super Princess Peach started to make sense because, why would Nintendo make a game where Princess Peach is just a crybaby to defeat her enemies, that's just silly. You had me so hyped for a Nintendo game with horses. Now time to make you horsey designs into MLP Ponies if you don't mind lol

Just make the game now but without the copyright charectors and it could be a parody game and you can get rich making horse and dragon side scrollers :3

I had super princess peach

I got so excited, but then you told me it's fake. Now you have to learn programming to make this game.

This had me fooled. Think this can def work for Mario fans but not too deep into lore and history so this would come off believable.

I have been bamboozled 😂❤

4:17 This part here made me suspicious, not cus of the designs, but the way they’re laid out kinda.. If this was a real ds game, I think the poses would be different for each piece of armor/power ups, and not placed next to each-other. Maybe the less-powerful thing would start in the left smaller, and then the middle one would be on the right side a bit bigger, then the best power-up much larger on the left lower corner. Maybe some sparkles emanating form it too.. :o Or some arrows pointing to each “evolution/leveled up armor” thingy XD I duno.

Very legit! I would love to play this game. 🦄

I'm so used to not trusting videos because how gullible I am from April's fool videos so I stopped believing around 2 minutes in, my trust issues finally payed off lol xD

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah I thought it was real!!!😭 (good job tho!!!💖💖💖)