Alan Shields Hamilton South Lanarkshire Scotland Elete Hibernian , Hearts , Saint Mirren Pretty Good Dundee United Rangers , Celtic Needs Improvement Ross County , Motherwell , Saint Johnstone Pish Aberdeen , Dundee , Livingston Sam what you sead in terms of Saint Johnstone's club crest looking like a blind drunk man had drawn it is pritty offensive to be honest with you I think you could of made your point in a much better manner. The Hibernian Crest is one of the very best in World Football in my view only missing out on top spot for be because I personally prefer The Locamotiv Moscow crest more. In terms of The Saint Mirren Crest I would say as someone that grow up locally there is not to much scope to change the current crest without it looking terrible Saint Mirren have had worse in the past the only thing you could myb do is put the outline in black of The Saint Mirren Satue that is near Saint Mirren Cathedral in the town on the shirts as a crest but for me I would just keep it as is. In terms of Celtic they would be better useing The Celtic Cross as they did in there centenary season to represent both The Republic of Ireland & Scotland. The Dundee United crest I do agree needs slightly updated but I still think it's one of the better crests in Scottish football. Saint Johnstone should just get rid of the Middle part of the crest as it's impossible to make out from any distance away the kestrel as I believe the bird is I would keep as is just make it yellow not gold. Hearts have had variations of the current logo I remember it looking slightly different in 1997 I think it was updated in 1998 but looks spot on to me but it dose nothing for me esteticly at all. Aberdeen have a terrible crest if it did not say Aberdeen on it you would not know it was an Aberdeen F.C crest it day zero about the city or club it's self. Dundee I would say needs updated I just dont know how though it could be done. Livingston have a fairly dull crest nothing to say Livingston or West Lothian about it other than text. Motherwell's crest could do without the football in the centre other than that keep it as it is. I dont see Rangers changing there crests drastically any time in my life time I fo think they need a crest that pays more homage to there roots have always thought that. Ross County need to drastically simplify there crest just use the Stags head in this day in age. I honestly think German clubs crests are buy far the worst in would football. Keep Safe Sam. Vlog was right up my alley can you do the same with The English Championship clubs next.

st.johnstone should make it a real image and not a cartoon

I'm sorry but I respected everything you had to say about the badges until Ross County. Their badge is an abomination. Why is "Ross" straight but "County" is wiggly? The font is terrible, and that red bar at the top is just begging for a year of establishment or some kind of detail at least

@@thelastmelon9446 its about the badge obtaining information that immedietely stands out and promotes it as a brand like jaguar or ford for example

Can you do Scottish championship?

Nice thanks!!!

I think your a bit high bud if you don't think Aberdeen should be elite.. STAND FREE 👊👊

@@thebat7048 the badge looks like one of those massive inflatable footballs next to a goal from the 1930s

The Aberdeen badge is fantastic

I agree. I actually think the Dundee Utd badge is alright.

Obviously I’m a Dee but i think the Dundee United badge is horrible, not even trying to be a prck by saying that but i personally think tangerine is a horrible colour

I am not just saying this because I support Aberdeen, but your badge is not great. Proof, you've used an edited version of it yourself! I see it's for a trust, but it's already better than the main badge. The colours of it look very early 90's, but not in an interesting retro way, just messy and dated (a bit like the city - jokes -). But no, you do need something smoother and simpler, like he said in the video the Aberdeen badge is a good example of effective simplicity.

@@paulrussell1207 yeah but reverting back to my initial point, it keeps the badge heritage and authenticity, if you try to modernise badges then you could do that forever, could say the same for aberdeen

Also not just saying this because I'm a united fan but How is Dundee's higher, there badge is just DFC with a crest... They used to have a better to look at badge years ago

Hi

@Antonio I'm not a fan of either but come on. Rangers is a bit generic for such a historic club. Just a lion with the name of the club. So many clubs could have the same. Hibs is pretty unique. It represents the club really well with the ship, Castle, Harp and a ball which sums up everything about the club. It's class. Hearts just edges it though.

The gold one is disgusting

or all 42 SPFL clubs

Celtic badge should have a peado on it

@@onceuponatimeinscotland7036 Why?

@@stevenwilcox8631 you know bheasty bhoy

@@onceuponatimeinscotland7036 Umm nope. As s Forest Green Rovers supporter with no affiliation with Celtic myself. I am curious to know how you came to that conclusion.

But they are a modern club. 2012-present

Rangers fan here and I agree with u pal. Never ever change it or update it 👍🏻

R u a hearts fan ,

As a Celtic fan me too

I'm a hibs fan so can't agree. But just a side bar.. it's taken from a stone mosaic in the royal mile that everyone spits on.. so is the hearts badge the most spat on badge in the world...? Discuss.

@@robertcormack7199you spit on it for good luck 🤦‍♂️

Thanks for confirming my theory that Motherwell fans are just tims in yellow👍

Typical reply from a Rangers fan. Anytime they take criticism they just use the religious path so you must be a catholic if you disagree with the mighty Rangers fans

The shield was added as I believe it was the same one used by Meadowbank Thistle pre-franchising.

@@toph8298 - If I remember correctly the Meadowbank shield had a bigger and more colourful symbol in the middle. Was a really nice one. Thanks for reminding me of that mate.

Good on you sir.

Same

Haha I think my graphic design skills leave a lot to be desired but I like your idea!!!

How does Rangers badge represent Britain though? Its just a lion which features on loads of badges eg Scotland, England, Dundee United etc. Celtic's badge actually suits the club because like you say it was formed for Irish people.

@@paulot4646 when you see a prancing horse you think of a fast racing car that everyone would like to own, the ferrari, if it represented a mini cooper it wouldnt mean the same thing, Rangers have the reputation because they usually take a large folowing into games in europe and fly the union jack, this is why the Rangers badge is iconic because it represents the union between england and scotland

@@jamesi2018 You are just judging the club rather than the badge then but fair enough. I know that Rangers is one of the biggest and most historic clubs in the UK, but I also think their badge is quite generic and doesn't really give the feel of Rangers. Their oldest badge from back in the 60s or 70s actually felt like Rangers. It looked like something you would associate with the British Army or the Royal family.

Haha cheers Nick, these vids are always gunna cause a few disagreements!

@@FootyAdventures saw my first penalty shootout in the flesh yesterday lots of fun it was Ipswich v colchester papa JOHNS 🚜🚜🚜

Saints are named for the town. Not the church. St johns town or st Johns Toun.

I AM A RANGERS!!!😡😡😡

@@miagielkens6440 I don’t think no one asked mate

Thank you sir

Where would u rank Falkirk's badge 🤔

@@TheUniversalGamer87 I would 2 or 3. Top pick would be Cove Rangers

Ross county could have an excellent one if they did it right, but would be no easy feat.

It’s just always been like that. The embroiled letters just looks better on the kit than the official club crest.

He did

the gers is miles better than celtic from a thistle fan and you have your profile pic as a union jack? 😂 your a hun plain and simple

@@stephenpatton703 Okay lmao. I was at the thistle vs raith game today. Why do people think unionists have to be rangers fans? Very one dimensional.

Nah the hibs badge is shite

@@loganpaul9759 better than rangers.

How silly right? We're fucking Scottish.

Sure mate, I did them at the start of the season... check them out below! Home kits: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/o7mKns53sNqugJs.html Away kits: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/Z9RlebmLr6ypZXk.html Cheers for watching!!

The Celtic Cross would represent The Republic of Ireland aswell as Scotland so that would be a much better option. As in The Centenary season crest or just The Celtic Cross that has been used on Celtic third kits in more recent times.

Its got no braid of gold, nor silk, nor hat with feathered plume

Yet me mother has preserved it all the while 😉

@@alanfox691 Good point but then that's just the same as the name of the club. The Scottish and Irish connection is in the name of the club to represent the Celtic people. The four leaf clover just emphasises the Irish connection for a Scottish club.