Like this comment if you think ten Hag must win the FA Cup to save his job.

Signing two 30-year-old midfielders in one window, then two years later realising they are 32. United style!

Nagelsmann is a good coach and it certainly looks like he's turned Germany's fortunes around but I'd always be suspicious of a coach that chooses an international position so early in their career before achieving anything spectacular at club level (YES I'm also talking about YOU Southgate stay away from our club).

Bournemouth and particularly Brentford are changing my mind in TH. I think he has been incredibly unlucky with injuries, mainly in defence, and when Hjolund got injured after injecting some life into us. However, those 2 performances in particular were unacceptable. However, I am not impressed by any suggested replacements. What has Nagelsman really done!. Not overwhelmed at his record.

The scouts didn't like Amrabat? The same scouts that didn't like Camavinga and Erling Haaland?

Isn't anyone going to mention the fact amarabat has played about 16 mins in midfield for utd. Any other time has been at full back. Not sure luke shaw could do well in cm, so why is he getting hammered like this? Can we give him a start in cm just once - really can't be any worse than casemiro is showing atm

Bayern's managerial decisions have been just as puzzling as their performances on the pitch. How do you sack a coach, appoint a successor, then fire the successor and rehire his immediate predecessor in less than two full seasons.😂

Mourinho was quite frankly over the hill when we got him. I don't understand why people felt like we just had to go and get him when we did.

What annoys me is that ETH keeps picking players that are letting them down. Why would you pick a lazy out of form Rashford, instead of Amed who would put more effort in. Also Casemero, put amrabat in.

Jay you keep saying we should have sold Martial when we sent him to Sevilla, WE COULDN'T SELL HIM. That's why we loaned him out. He was on £250,000 per week, no club in world football that pays those kind of wages had any interest in him. We'll face the same problem this summer if we try to sell Sancho (£350,000), Antony (£200,000) & Maguire £200,000).

On amrabat i think he definitely could be a better option than Casemiro has been since hes been back from his recent injury. Amrabat is more moblie he is a better passer and he has alot more stamina. Most importantly he will stay back and shield that back 4 which we need so badly. The midfield is our weakest part of the field all season. Yeah the front 3 aren’t pulling up trees as the saying goes but our midfield has been ran all over because of how we play so open and far up the pitch but then have our backline back because they dont have the pace to get back. We need to control the ball better and more often and amrabat does that better than most hes happy to take the ball off the back 4 and make simple passes that keep the ball. We need that desperately now and have all season.

Nagelsman is interesting because at a minimum things will get updated behind the scenes. Hes someone that wants to be on the cutting edge of everything. On the pitch, we'll see. But off the pitch i think there will be improvements that we KNOW United need as well

Ten Hag had put his faith in Mainoo for the start of the season which is why he was played against Arsenal and Madrid pre season - lets be honest, had he not got injured - it wouldn't have been as bad this season. Top that with Martinez getting a serious knock, Ten Hags choice cb (others inherited) and the financial shadow over the club due to spending the max possible for a couple of years - had to resort to loan deals for cover - in the twilight of the window, United announce they've signed Amrabat - who looked amazing during the World Cup - It's like we've got an identical twin, who was always picked last in PE May I just point out - Arsenal fans wanted Arteta out when he had a bad spell - look at their progression under him 2 years is not enough to build your own squad and get them playing how you want them to - this is not a computer game, it's real life

If nevez is that good then it costs what it costs. Think about what other teams ahead of us are spending on players in this position. Liverpool spent on multiple midfielders but the price is still similar well over 100mil and if de bruyne leaves city or falls off then city will spend huge to fill that midfield hole.

Why would any manager want the Utd job? It's a serious question because what this club excels at above all else is ruin and failure. This club WILL NOT be winning or competing for anything significant for a very long time and anyone taking up the managerial post will have to have the kind of character that accepts that situation and is able to deal with the pressure that comes with it.

FA Cup or not, for me, Ten Hag and Manchester United must part ways. Once Ten Hag has sailed back to the Netherlands, Sir Jim must wield the axe on around 6 players at the club. We MUST see year-on-year improvement if we want to get into a position whereby the greatest club in the world starts to challenge for major honours once more. GGMU.

Play Mainoo and Amrabat together. He was getting started at LB

It was announced yesterday that Nagelsmann has signed a one year extension to continue coaching die Mannschaft

The sad think is that we are at a stage where we need to build the club back up, we are not going to get a top manager and may need to look at bringing in someone to start the building and then bring in the top name

Fact is, every manager is a gamble. You take a Di Zerbi and you're probably taking an absolute fire cracker that could burn bright for a short period of time which is almost unsustainable. But if you took the likes of a Potter, as an example, you're looking at a manager that's a slow builder of a team but could get results in 4,5 years, which fans don't have the patience for. And I don't, not ANOTHER 4 or 5 years of trudging through seasons. Those are only "types" of managers I'm talking about, and those extremes you'll find everywhere, and we them in Mourinho (Di Zerbi) and Moyes (Potter). It's the one that's in the middle, got that energy and prowess to turn things around quickly but be able do that for the long term that makes them like Unicorns and therefore incredibly hard to get. With that being said, if there's no obvious candidate then everyone is a risk, and you choose the best risk.

Does anyone else notice the referees are in the way. Lots of times they are cutting off passing lanes better than a defender

❤

He’s the only manager I’d take in place on Ten Hag. Although he is going to need new players too, I don’t know if he can do better with the same set of players.

Give eth time at mo we don't have the players to play his style I say give him this window

Question1: What has Nagelsman done to be given one of the biggest prize in football?? Question 2: who else is out there? Final question: will the players who remain after the cull of time wasters in the summer. I’m sure the academy players will. But who else.

I'm not too bothered about Nagelsman and happy if Ten Hag gets given atleast another year and sees out his contract, I believe he is the right man for the job still, especially under a good structure.

Available managers for Man united; 1. De Zerbi 20M release clause 2. Motta - another experiment 3. Southgate - Trash 4. Potter - not good enough 5. Amorim - trial and error. United can consume a good manager 6. Unai Emery 7. Conte - Chaotic & short-term 8. Tuchel - chaotic and short-term

Sir Jim didn't say they wouldnt spend big monies he said they won't spend big monies on Big names he would rather buy less know and younger player and turn them into big names... like Neves he is perfect profile .. Only thing is Neves is an 8 really we should get him anywys but also Need to buy Hjulmand .... Hjulmand would be perfect 6 to sit , could prob get him for 50 mil. 24 and moves bit like Frankie . Lacey don't play anything like messi he like mk2 Foden .

Ten Hag will likely face the brunt of the criticism for not being able to shift the dead wood this summer, despite not even being the manager when these daft decisions/signings were made as well as having little to no say when it comes to negotiating the price of players. I agree he’s made mistakes but was he ever going to be flawless? Hardly any manager is, if any. Last season we overachieved, this season we’ve been poor. I think the level sits somewhere in the middle and hopefully with a better structure in place behind the scenes and some better work in the transfer market, we’ll start to see improvements in the playing style and consistency. I think as football fans we can be a bit reactionary at times. It’s gonna take a while, there’s a lot of shit to fix, we’ll be back. Hopefully.

If ten Hag goes we will end up with Potter. Nagelsmann was the only candidate I thought we could realistically get that I would be happy with, surprised Bayern are going after sacking him so recently.

Neves at 120m makes zero sense. We need a squad rebuild and with sensible targets would could get 4 quality squad players for 120m. That would be a cover CB, back up CF, back up LB and a decent young DM. Then spend 60 to 80m on a proper DM and we would be sorted

I can't get over the brass balls on Bayern. To sack Nagelsmann despite them winning the Bundesliga his first season, and then being 1 point behind Dortmund with only 3 defeats for the following season. To hire Tommy Tickles in his place, realise HE isn't good enough and is problematic, and THEN wanting Nagelsmann back again. If I were him, I'd tell Bayern to do one.

Ten hag out! He said so himself that his style is playing form the back. Not going to the top with that.

Nagelsmann is just a name fans recognise and that's it. Winning trophies at Bayern is like being successful at Celtic or Ranger and being Germany manager during a period where they haven't had any competitive games is even less convincing. With the exception of the Super League, listening to fans about anything to do with the running of the club has been shown to not be a good idea.

The players are accountable for these results. These are not committed professional performances, there's only so much accountability that can lie with The manager. You don't just forget how to play football if your manager gives you the wrong instruction

We need a mass clear

Spending big on one player might be worth it even if it just gets us into the top 4 next season as we need that Champions League money for FFP.

Give Amrabat a run of games in midfield we can’t get any worse drop Casemiro and watch.

For me regardless of where we finish this season, give ETH first 15 games of next season

Amrabat has an obligation to buy at the end of his loan as his contract expires at fiorentina and that was the only way it fit for ffp to get him in

WE NEED TEN HAG!

Leverkusen on a Leicester vibe.

Isn’t ETH on a 3 year contract? Which means next season he will be in his last year, so why not ket him see out his final year and see what he can do under the new structure of Ineos, this way they have a year to search and do their do diligence on the next manager or if it turns out ETH has a good season and can pick his full strength first 11 90% of the season, then may be Ineos will extend his tenure

Nagelsmann is levels above other managers that we've been linked to and thats why Bayern wants him back. The German league is second to the EPL and will improve us massively. I am sure that He will pick us ahead of Bayern Munich if we go for him. I will be sad if we loose him and give Ten Hag another season of torturous football 😭. Reshuffle that squad and the manager and we will be on our way up before the 3rd world war breaks out 🙏

As bad as it is to admit only Alonso is the truly obvious appointee. Nobody else is pulling up trees.

Erik Ten Hag has been given time -- the entire season. Are there ANY (managerial) positives at all to cling to this season? Not a chance.

Where have these rumours come from?

Got a feeling ten hag will stay one😮 more season, because there is no one at the moment suitable or will come.

i would love to see erik get another season and if they get rid of all the dead beats i think he can pull the club around

Why dont united get paul mitchell

Has Sofyan been paired with case????

Unai Emery should be number one choice

We are way too Rubbish for Xavi Alonso

If ETH can win the fa cup I would hold on to him for 1 more season. But beating Chelsea and city is no easy job

What we need to do as a fan base is not get gassed off hype on new up coming players or players, we as fans haven't even scouted ourselves. For example, we did this with falcao, di Maria, Schweinsteiger, that Southampton lad schniederlin, we did it with amarabat and now Braithwaite, jao neves etc. please please just stop falcao knees gone never the same, di maria bad attitude, Bastian Schweinsteiger legs gone, schniederlin never good enough, amarabat never good enough never played in this league.. Then recently sanchez, sancho, casemiro. We don't need jerrard Braithwaite he's bang average and another harry Maguire low block merchant, todibo could be a risk as the league is more physical, however he is clever and has pace so he can work and build strength. We need 3 x central midfielders, 2 x anchorman/central defensive midfielder. 2x wingers and 1x forward either a quick low center of gravity striker or,,,,, a taller technical striker with medium to good pace, and 3x center backs, 1x right back and 1x left back. According to the above,, we need 13 players as a minimum over the next 2 summer windows and top up in january, plus any break through youth players. I would sell heaton, shaw, bissaka, maguire, lindlehoff, malacia, mc tominay, mejbri, brandon williams, varane, eriksen, casemiro, sancho, pellistri, donny, rashford, martial, evans, send amarabat back. I would bring back de gea on 150k pw. I would then build around dalot, licha, fernandez, antony, mount, bruno, mainoo, armass, any academy player worth their salt, amad, kambwala, garnacho, hojland, onana, de gea as back up and potentially number 1, id bring de gea as back up to see if he still has it and if so then transition. its a big big rebuild but i'm just outlining the above for you all to see, it just shows the scale of our issues and this is a 3 year rebuild but we start heavy and hard this summer, mass clear out and then add quality and sprinkle class on top.

Bring back the gunna ole s

It’s a bit weird that Bayern sacked Nagelsmann last year and they are reported to be talking to him again.

Nah, Nagelsman's not happening. I trust the Muppetiers channel and James already explained that Nagelsman is not a profile fit under Ineos. He would also want control over signings.

Nagalsmann is going to bayern Munich not man utd

Martial wanted to leave when he went to Seville,

Give EtH time.

If Nagelsmann is the only Manager available that I would swap Erik ten Hag for because of his understanding of the game, tackticks, touch line antics and more.

Alonso?

Weather must be awful in Manny.

Unai Emery anyone?

WHY WOULD HE GO BACK THERE IF THEY SACKED HIM FOR NO REASON 😅

If Alonso is staying another season then we should stick with ETH at least 1 more season, see out the contract and let him build a platform for the future. If he pulls it together then great, if not there's an obvious target that summer

Stranger things have happened, Jay. we’re going to wembley

Amrabat is 10kg overweight for a kick off.

Swapping Ten hag for Nagleann makes no sense the man got fired mid season for being so poor in a league that 98% of the time Bayern win and they let him go as he was struggling Stick with Ten Hag it’s a process we have to follow we can’t keep rebuilding every 2 seasons as the last 4 managers proved that don’t work Arsenal stuck with arteta Liverpool stuck with Klopp and we are again going to give up because it’s been a average season ( short memories forgetting horrendous injury list) young talent being developed and the squad struggling for quality back up as well as some players too old and slow whilst others are injury prone or just not good enough and 1 or 2 seem to be just going through the motions Trust in the boss let him now with real football people above him helping develop the club and team and let’s see what we get out and in during the summer and let him his young talented squad around Bruno or risk another manager coming in who don’t want youth but wants to buy older experienced players just for a quick fix rather than development

100% fresh start required; Bye bye to ETH, seller Rashford + Martial + Lindeloff + Casemiro + Sancho + Anthony, promote the youth in Mainoo + Garnacho + Kwambala + Lacey, give hard working players like Williams & Amad more time, bring in 5-6 decent young players under £50m mark. We can't get worse than we currently are.

I'm very confused at how you guys are expecting ETH to show up and get different results from the same shity players? ETH isn't the issue. The players are. And it's time we stick with ETH and get rid of like 10 players. Especially Rashford.

ETH can't manage this team and he has to go.

This is getting ridiculous. You know that ETH is unlikely to win the FA Cup…if you want him out, just say, don’t set-up silly conditions that he has to meet.

If he leaves Madrid

Florian Wirtz is WAY better than Neves - If you're going to spend £120m, spend it on Wirtz

36 year old wouldn't be big enough to handle the pressure at utd

Jay. Love u but literally zero chance of nagelsman. ETH 100pc there next year

Jay, you have to stop with these asides on how much you like the players. We don’t care how you feel, these players haven’t been good enough. You constantly speak out of both sides of your mouth making your opinions irrelevant.

Will Emery or Ange get the sack this time next year when they don't repeat this season? Shiny new toy syndrome. 🔴❤️.

i dont want ten hag to be sacked he is good manager that being said any manger which comes in man utd will fail and get sacked this club is being run to ground

Can someone give me a membership please

Carlo

Nagelsmann brings nothing to the club at all. Concentrate on a new team, not on a new coach, that has never been the solution at this club. That said, if I were EtH I would happily head to a club in Spain or Germany. I wouldn't wish the bullshit he had to deal with in Manchester on anyone

Nagelsman at Bayern is a ridiculous appointment. It makes no sense whatsoever 🙄 Never been a fan of his anyway. He's not done anything. I'd be far more keen to appoint Southgate The stage out candidate for me is Zidane. Please get him 🙏

Amrabat is complete trash. There's a reason he was available so cheap and no one else was interested in signing him. I've never seen a worse passer than him at United. Even three yard passes are always a yard wide of where they should be. He makes McT's passing look like Pirlo's. He also gets pushed off the ball too easily and looks like he's running through treacle. There is literally nothing good to say about him, and it would be crazy to sign him permanently.

Murhinio back with money and backing he's the man 🎉

Martial is one of the biggest wastes of talent I have seen in my time as a football fan! The way he dribbles with the ball so close to his feet, his control and his finishing are that of a world class player. A mixture of attitude and terrible luck with injuries have ruined his career though!

Garnacho is selfish. He shows no respect for the manager who played him so much and trusted him. garnacho, rashford same crap mentality. Boot out these selfish players who think just of themselves

Get the first option defender and a first choice Defensive midfielder(not someone who can play there someone who is best at playing defensive mid). Let Martial, Varane, Casemiro, Erikson, Van de Beek, Amrabat, Wan Bissaka, Tyrell Malacia, Anthony, Mctominay, Rashford( if we get over 100Mill) go. and then buy cheaper alternatives or get free players. Play kids in the Cup tournaments like we used to.

Oh nice we're interested in another reject...great

12:36 Jay u can't be serious, WE HAVE BEEN SPENDING SOO MUCH MONEY ON PLAYERS. What u saying is nonsense in my eyes

This playing not wanting to go to a club because they're not in the Champions League the next season is a bit of a false narrative to me. It's not as if it's a permanent situation. The opposite could also happen in that a player signs for a club who has qualified for the CL and then fails to for the rest of the players' contract.

Swapping bayerns former A manager for former B manager?😂if they can bring Nagelsmann back We can bring Ole back, he's united through and through we've seen before this Dutch game don't work for us. Ole has to be the only choice, even Carrick, at the moment we're not enjoyable to watch and won't win any games in Europe!

Pep is coming to Manchester United after next season. Remember this comment.

Maintaining ETH is a stupid act of manutd, which even lay people have long considered his stupidity.

A bit left field but, give EtH the final year of his contract, start the process now to replace him. Maybe looking at how Kieran McKenna does next season (hopefully) in the PL for Ipswich. He knows the club and Ipswich are playing some excellent football right now

Give Ten Hag the resources to do the job.

Ten Hag is not a winner. He can't win anything more with this team. 😊

Who cares. Don’t want him. Nagels…….who?