Kinda reminds me of when in T1E2H3's Engines of sodor, Henry is accused of bashing the express coaches and henry tries to say he's innocent but sir topham hatt wasn't having it and henry stood up to him and when topham said "How dare you talk to me like that!" henry spat back "how dare you accuse me without evidence!!!"

Yes! Yes! This is what should have happened in the actual film!

If Thomas stood up to The Fat Controller, he would've decided to send Thomas packing to the mainland. At which point, the other engines would go on strike for this grossly-unfair treatment.

If Lady Hatt know he hurt Thomas feelings she be angry at Sir Topham Hatt

Looks like Thomas the Tank Engine snapped at Sir Topham Hatt, which he was told to go back to his shed, because, Topham stated that he’s enough of his excuses. Also, Thomas has turned himself into, when he argued with Sir Topham Hatt like that.

Good point back there I really hated that part where Sir Topham Hatt get's super mad with Thomas for thinking he was chasing Ryan with freight cars full of lit up dynimate but he's not he was trying to save Ryan and the other friends from lit up dynimate.

Sir topham hatt: go to your shed! Thomas: you’re free trial of yelling at me has ended.

I never seen Thomas that pissed off at Sit Topham doesn't believe it wasn't his fault Thomas stood up on his own he was angry at him for making him mad at him for not listening to him

Well, might I say, Thomas is part of the problem that started, cause he knew Ryan was getting bad coal, didn't warn him, then the sparks from the smoke coming out of Ryan's funnel lit one of the dynamites, causing the trouble. However, Thomas I assume didn't know Ryan was collecting more dynamite, and probably thought he was collecting more rails, ballast or some crates of material, so I can see why, it's not entirely Thomas' fault, but part of it is to blame on him. I do think though if Sir Topham Hatt also decided to at least listen to Thomas' side of the story, to know why he was "chasing" Ryan with a truck full of dynamite, then maybe he would have gotten in less trouble, especially if Ryan also said something as well, saying Thomas was trying to get rid of the danger. I think that would have made a better scene. Or, if Ryan had been the one to throw the dynamite into the cave, things would have been alright. Also, didn't Sir Topham Hatt hear the other engines and Jack and his pack and the crew men cheering for Thomas? He could have at least put the pieces together, that Thomas did something good to save them all.

Well said, Thomas! 👏

Now that's what should've happened.

Damn I never seen Thomas this mad at sir tophat doesn't believe that Gordon was being mean to Thomas was puffing away from him before he can say a word to him about him being there for him Thomas control your anger

Thomas : 😠 No I will not go back to my shed !

I love that comic

Thomas was like whoa whoa i didn't mean to say that i was just so angry at sir Topham hatt i need to control myself I'm just going to hurt his feelings that i will leave sodor forever said Thomas was crying so loudly

Uh huh, this is way worth it than the original one, but man, I had never had sir topper hat being mad at Thomas before, like that got me off guard.

This is what should have happened in the actual movie/film

Very very true

Thats a fanmade scene i love it

I can tell that Thomas is not a little blue tank engine because he grown Thomas leans to stand up for himself to Gordon wasn't being a nice friend to him Gordon is mean to Thomas in the first place

Bad Boy Sir Topham Hatt😂😂😂😂

I would agree Thomas could have stood up and told Topham about the Ship and the Dynamite. But we all know that it was Thomas's fault for the accident at Knapford and lying too.

Love this!

Can u try Si Topham Hatt voiced by Keith Wickham next?

But the Unlucky Tug said Topham had every right to give out to Thomas.

YESSSSSSSSS i wanted this to happen but it didn't

This should’ve happened in the movie!

This scene would have made much more sense if it was in the 2015 SODOR'S LEGEND OF THE LOST TREASURE movie.

Sir Topham Hatt: Thomas, what have you done now. You…(gets interrupted) Thomas: Wrong! (X2) Now shut up! Or else I’m come up there and teach you a lesson

THOMAS LET GOOOOOOOOOOOO😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀

By the way, how did you get the Robin smith voice on Uber Duck?

Yeah you tell him thomas

Thomas (Cgi Series,Joseph May)

Sir Topham Hatt: YES YOU WILL THOMAS! YOU THOMAS ARE AN ENGINE ON MY RAILWAY YOU WILL DO AS I SAY WHEN I SAY IT! DO YOU UNDERSTAND? YOU HAVE CAUSED CONFUSION AND DELAY THE RAILS AND SLEEPERS ARE ALL IN THE CAVERN THE MINIATURE RAILWAY ENGINE TRUCKS ARE ON THE RAILS AND THE TRACKS ARE BLOCKED! YOU WILL PUT RIGHT EVERYTHING YOU DAMAGED! Thomas: Ah, [dolphin chirp]! [quickly covers his mouth as he realizes his mistake] Jack: Oh...! You said number 11! Thomas: [babbles for Everyone to understand] I didn't mean... you gotta understand, guys, I was trying... what I meant to say was... some things just slip out. You gotta understand!

0:56 Thomas: Never Had a chance full picture which gorn Was responsible for the exsanity make me dew i found the shed then you unlisted by the exam Rocky founded and now Is- you know what i Will never be your number 1 again il'z leave sodnor fwever.

Roaring Sir Henry Topham Hatt 😂😂😂😂

Thomas needs to control his anger was out of control with his emotions Thomas you need to settle down from getting out of control with yourself Thomas was annoyed with Gordon be responsible for making a wrong mistake

What is he saying at 0:56 didn't quite catch that

Ryan should leave with Thomas incase if he feels sorry about what happened to him and maybe Percy too.

Where are the voices from

Damn Thomas snapped with his anger on his eyes don't make Thomas very angry at Topham hatt for not believe him it wasn't his fault but sir Topham hatt didn't listen to him Thomas wasn't happy about him not believing him it wasn't his fault

You know, I think Thomas should have gotten way more revenge than that on sir Topham hat.

Leave him leave him go to the bluebell railway or go to the national railway museum

i was think why this is not on the film?

what if.

New Friend the love the tank engine: don't wrorry Sir i well Thomas bcak

What if Thomas works for Jimmy Crystal Jimmy Crystal: Hello Thomas Thomas: what do you want can you see I'm upset Jimmy Crystal: what are you upset about? Thomas: Sir topham hatt won't listen to me anymore so I ran away Jimmy Crystal: well Thomas since Sir topham hatt doesn't need you anymore I'll take care of you Thomas: you you can? Jimmy Crystal: of course I can and don't listen to Sir topham hatt anymore he doesn't want you anymore but I want you as my new engine So Thomas went with Jimmy Crystal

0:10

:0

I don't agree. Thomas never said horrible things to Sir Topham Hatt like that! Thomas usually obeys and listen what the fat controller had said and maybe, Thomas can be very cheeky and made mistakes but he is a really useful engine and he is very kind and willing to help others when someone in need! Thomas The Tank Engine is Sir Topham Hatt's number one engine and Twilight Sparkle likes him very much as a friend! So this video is impossible and unbelievable: Thomas is a really useful engine and he never argues with their controllers and like Sir Topham Hatt says "Really useful engines don't argue. If Thomas behaves like that to Sir Topham Hatt, maybe he would be scrapped by now and never existed on Sodor. I'm sorry but this is the truth.

Thomas is blushing😮😮😳🥵

Sir Topham Hatt: YES YOU WILL THOMAS! YOU THOMAS ARE AN ENGINE ON MY RAILWAY YOU WILL DO AS I SAY WHEN I SAY IT! DO YOU UNDERSTAND? YOU HAVE CAUSED CONFUSION AND DELAY THE RAILS AND SLEEPERS ARE ALL IN THE CAVERN THE MINIATURE RAILWAY ENGINE TRUCKS ARE ON THE RAILS AND THE TRACKS ARE BLOCKED! YOU WILL PUT RIGHT EVERYTHING YOU DAMAGED!

That's not very nice to Sir. Tophatt

Wrong. 😠👎

0:30