Help Us Grow: Please "Like" this Video (if you liked it!) & Subscribe to this Channel. If you prefer Audio you can subscribe on itunes or Soundcloud. Thanks for watching! itunes: itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/so-what-youre-saying-is/id1454511530?mt=2 Soundcloud: soundcloud.com/user-923838732

Why have I not heard these kind of obvious analysis for 20 years? It is horrifying what pc ideology has done to our political debate.

Fundamentally, Human Beings prefer their own kind.

Tired of hearing about moaning migrants? Britain has 80 thousand square miles; Africa by comparison has 11 million square miles. If so unhappy with our UK, migrants can all rush off to Africa's 11 million square miles and make it their own. That continent has oil, gas, diamonds, copper, coal, platinum, uranium, aluminium, bauxite, iron and steel. If migrants are so beneficial to the nations they go to, then they ought to succeed in having a great life for themselves and in making Africa great too.

"Diversity is our Strength" increasingly sounds like "War Is Peace, Freedom Is Slavery, and Ignorance Is Strength" in Orwell's 1984.

This style of interview, where a question is asked and time is allowed for an answer, is very welcome. More please. More you want MORE!!!!

Cosmopolitans already have super diversity, If we stopped mass immigration tomorrow London would still be majority minority. No one serious is talking about mass deportations so an end to mass immigration isn’t going to make London a white British city again. Cosmopolitans can indulge their love of Indian food, Jamaican music and the Muslim call to prayer to their hearts content. The fact is, it’s not so much a desire for those things which motivates lefty cosmopolitans, it’s a revolution they desire. It’s “rubbing the right’s nose in diversity”. They don’t just want diversity for them, they want it for everyone. Partly as a punitive measure to punish little Englanders and partly the utopian dream of making John Lennon’s Imagine a reality. A world where white racists are basically cleansed from the face of the earth by sheer numbers. For this reason, I don’t think the lefties can compromise.

I heard this guy on trigonometry. He’s a salesman for awful ideas. He said we need to slow down the change from white to other ethnicity’s. Not stop it. Not reverse it. But slow it so that the whites won’t get to upset as they are replaced, “don’t want to cause them to much anxiety” (he’s a very caring guy you know). I was so disgusted by him. I never watched trigonometry again. I get a strong feeling that like mr Shapiro this gentleman would be horrified at the idea of this happening to Israel. But for the west, the UK it’s great idea. I don’t want us Anglo-Saxons and Celts to be replaced by Africans and Middle Easterners. This man is a monster. I thought Mr Whittle might have cared for his own culture, country and people a little more than this? It’s very sad to see him here because I don’t think he got the full story out of this slippery character.

An interesting discussion and I'm glad to see an academic addressing such issues, however, he's still an a academic isolated from what going on with ordinary people, he has a somewhat positively view whereas most ordinary people don't, from experience. And how will he honestly address Islam integrating into Europe, he wont and he is ignoring history. This "multicultural experiment" will not end well.

I find his simplistic quantification of so called "Populism" troubling, also the notion that such a phenomenon is naturally "Right" wing - it clearly isn't . . I would suggest that "Corbynism" is by far the strongest manifestation of "Populism" in the UK . . His crass generalisation about "Brexit" voters being, in the main, motivated by Immigration is nonsense "Brexit" voters are motivated by many dissatisfactions with the EU, immigration may be one of them but concerns about Democracy, Sovereignty, trade and economic freedom, primacy of national law and governance and an overwhelming desire for the UK to continue to exist as an autonomous nation in its own right are far more important to many . .

Sorry man! You are leaving the whole issue of I5lam out of your argument. And thereby you are talking right past the debate.

Their conversation is a typical intellectual one, based upon their ideology of so called diversity. Truth is that in the end people will prefer their own so his opinion of this ultimate mixture of races isn’t likely. As should be noted he is also of mixed race so he’s selling his vision for diversity.

The Croats didn’t necessarily dislike the Serbs but didn’t want to be governed by them in a Serb/Communist Party dominated Yugoslav government

One of the best channels and series on KZfaq by far.

In the 1930's it started with the Frankfurt school of critical thinking...blue people.

I’m on bit of a rant Britain too is a small island, yet other British government ministers tell the British people that they must embrace mass immigration, and that it is simply racist for British people to oppose the altering of their country’s social, cultural and economic fabric. What makes the Caribbean and South Atlantic islanders noble in defending their culture, and the British racist in defending theirs? It is largely about being a minority, and being outnumbered. But western people are a global minority. For myself, I like Ireland because it is Irish, I like Sweden because it is Swedish, I like Vietnam because of the Vietnamese, and I like Japan because it is Japanese. Yet I like diversity; I enjoy (for example) London’s Chinatown and appreciate the economic and cultural contributions of Britain’s Indian community, but that does not extend to a wish to open my country’s borders - as the People Flow report suggests - to 1.3 billion Chinese and 1.1 billion Indians. In that case, Britain would no longer be Britain

Since ancient biblical times, humanity has been tribal. Have progressives ever postulated that tribalism and nationalism is an inherent DNA trait? Wanting to be with your own tribe is not racist in my opinion.

Importing people from all over the globe into countries that are already densely populated with long histories and cultures of their own - how can that work?

Great interview, so many interesting points. I am interested in the origins of anti white white people, political correctness, the obsession with diversity over homogeneity and identity politics. It seems to me that moderate immigration and natural assimilation is fine but the current high levels of immigration combined with the adoption of confrontational identity politics is likely to lead to disaster and a lot of misery.

Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely excersised for the good of its victims may be the most opressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies.the robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep. His cupidity at some point satiated; but those that torment us for our own good will torment us without end and they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to heaven yet at the same time make a hell of earth. This very kindness strings with intolerable insult. To be “cured” against our will and to be cured of states that we do not regard as desease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will. To be classed as infants, Imbiciels and domestic animals. C.S Lewis

No mention of State-sponsored invasion - elephant, what elephant in the room? - pity. Thumb down.

A huge problem with Eric Kaufmanns thesis is that he is simply assuming that this major demographic shift inevitably will happen. That the majority of western countries will loose their white demographic majorities some time around the end of the century. In other words, there is in his mind no room for a radical ideological or political shift regarding immigration policy. But if we have learned anything from the last 5 years or so, its that the natives will mount a formidable resistance towards this demographic replacement. And resistance will only intensify, the more their demographic majorities are threatened. I seriously doubt things will play out as he predicts.

Diversity is wonderful! Why? I have never heard an adequate answer.

Just bring money, bring good practices, try to fit in.....don't bite the hand that feeds you....don't start a revolution in your chosen land

Great point about differences being accentuated rather than lessened when a group feels under attack. Glad to hear some scientific underpinning of what I and many others have long felt anecdotally to be the case.

The most interesting aspect of this conversation for me came at the end: that postmodernists condense western culture as white, and have a target of “white plus diversity”, while ignoring other aspects of culture as seemingly trivial (and far too posh) aspects such as Saturday afternoon cricket. While I don’t particularly like cricket, I do see it as one of many important symbols of western culture.

Written by KAUFMANN! playing both sides.... anyone?

england for the english

The whole discussion does not deal adequately with the 'pace of change'... it creates conflict. Oh - I think you think I meant the 'pace of change' for the residents of the target country. Oh no - I mean the pace of change for the immigrants - they don't cope if their ability to set up enclaves is enabled - so they don't have to change when they hit their destination. So they fall back on their 'known' way of operating... not a good thing... exactly what they were seeking to escape.

For my diversity I am very happy to holiday in their countries but do not wish them to be in England!

If people come to Britain they should be prepared to integrate and accept our way,s , not form separatist ghetto ,s Th same way we would need to if we go abroad.

its ok to be white

Ofc english is dependant on race. White people created and built Brittain. We have this thing called history.

I watched an interview with the Hoover Institution and Ayaan Hirsi Alis, she has written a book called prey. During this interview she praised the welfare state in Europe. Also saying that you either have a welfare state or immigration state. But you can't have both.

It would be nice to listen to this without the constant apologetics It's rather annoying

Thank you for this important, and importantly balanced, discussion.

American High School Class: "I don't want to be white," says a white student from Poland. I'm in the library with a cross section of students who volunteered to speak with me. Others agree with the Polish-born youth, but I'm confused. They explain. To call someone "white" is an insult, as are synonymous terms like Wonder bread. "I don't consider myself white," says a young woman from Russia. She has white skin. "Whites act white and do white stuff." "What's 'white stuff?'" I ask. "White kids act different. They hang out differently. Whites are privileged. They're smart, do homework on time, run the student government, participate in plays and musicals, sell stuff, have parents who are involved in the school." "When you go to apply for a job," says one boy, "you have to act white." Most white students remain silent during these discussions. "I won't apologize for being white," says one. If achievement-or at least too much achievement-is unfashionable and achievement, as they have defined it, is "white," then "white" is not cool." Very sad. You can read the whole article if you Google the title, National Geographic Magazine September 2001 "Changing America", By Joel L. Swerdlow This has been going on for a long time !

Heading for minorities in our own countries due entirely to liberal immigration policies, which are a sacred cow amongst the media, but for what reason?

This featured some intriguing analysis. Some points were made concerning the causes and effects of populism that left me more informed. The segment where you bring up Religion of Anti-Racism and Maximal Diversity (although at a first careless glance carries a negative connotation) actually raises some fascinating points well worth investigating to achieve what I envision as a Rational middle-ground scenario, where a beneficial dialog can take place between many views. The "extremes" in these times are so imprisoned by their ideologies that they actually begin to share several irrational characteristics with one another. Thank you for sharing this.

Robin Hood was heavily informed by the Norman / Saxon split. I mostly missed that when I was a kid. I hope my grandchildren can read the same stories and ignore the ethnic tensions just like I did; I'm not a better person from being aware of them.

at 24:00 so true. i dont wanna canada segregated by ethnicity. and im dark skinned gal lol dude we left back home for goddam reason lol

If you look at history, I don't see the problem with looking at what's happened to other countries, like Lebanon in the 1970's & being concerned that it might happen again in this country, in fact I believe it is rather foolish not to look at that & not put laws in place to make sure it doesn't happen here, like religious freedom should be a right not a law so it cannot be changed in the future, because we shouldn't forget that the majority rules in a democracy, we are the majority at the moment but that will change in the near future if things as they are continue! I don't want to be killed for what I believe & I don't want to die because I refuse to change my beliefs! This happens today around the world, we need to wake up if we believe this sort of thing can't happen here!

Another great discussion. Thank you.

Can't buy Kaufmann's book on Amazon Audible. I wonder why? Oh, freedom of speech, where have you gone?

Very informative.

Multiculturalism is one thing, national democracy under a constitution, and common law is quite another. If we had confidence in the later, the former would be less of a problem, and to an extent visa versa. However what we have in the UK, is little confidence in either. It is clear to me at least that the former is being deliberately used to undermine the later, via the EU, and UN. In other words Globalism is our problem, and of course not just for those within the UK. The Globalist agenda was always going to be deeply unpopular, and therefore democracy has to go. Or worse, selectively so. Democracy will be used as evidence AGAINST you, and NEVER to protect you, as has been made perfectly clear post the EU referendum. When our Globalist establishment don't like the result, they will do all they can to ignore it. When they do like it, we will get it, and a whole lot more that we were not told, or warned about. Perhaps this has always been the case, but maybe not so obviously. Resistance may be useless, but resist we must.

Canadian is my ethnicity just like Punjabi is for some people. Acadian, Quebecois, Newfoundlander, and Canadian were distinct ethnic groups in the past and we are still around. "Sorry." But when I am in public I have to be white. If I am asked what my background is, I dare not say Canadian lest I suffer the consequences. I have to tell people that I am English, French, and German etc, to stave off the possibility of there being a minority around who might report me. Millions of us every day are walking around the rest of you hiding in plain sight as we are required by you to identify by our component parts. But English is just a blend of Anglo, Saxon, and Norman. Norman was an ethnic group that was a blend of Norwegian and French, but the French (the Franks) are a just a another tribe of German like the Saxons, or Bavarians. Why do they get to be recognized ethnic groups but not us? Are you a racist?

If displacing people and cultures is a good thing, when will we hear people calling for Africa becoming less black? How about Asia becoming less Asian or Latin America less Hispanic? Don't these other cultures need diversity strength too? If you don't agree with diluting these other cultures and ethnic groups you must be a racist hater, right?

Great interview. Thanks.

I liked it better when we treated people as who they were not their skin colour. So much of this is ridiculous because I have heard people with less than 1/4 native blood, talk about how evil the white man is. How does this make sense in their heads when they are 3/4 white. As racial groups intermarry this identity politics is creating a weird racial dissonance

Why should "white" people be disenfranchised from the cultures we built just to have different music or food??? Its assinine!

Most white countries, never got a vote on mass immigration!!! Do you think this is fair 🤔 especially on the native population, like in Britain or France??

America has always been multicultural, what is so horrifying about European Americans (it appears to be happening globally) developing a sense of shared identity as they shrink as a percentage of the population, Native and African Americans for example maintained their own distinct cultures that influenced and added to American culture as a whole. Americans used to celebrate the differences between ethnicity’s, learning about each other, enjoying each other’s cultural events, etc... and even building community’s not to exclude anyone but where people can celebrate their holidays and traditions , for instance Octoberfest or trick or treating on Halloween etc... the way that Diana de Los muertos or Chinese New Year are celebrated in communities around the country. like all groups before built communities where businesses catered to their needs and tastes, they could practice their faith and culture, elect representatives etc... and others can come take part if they choose. Why is it somehow unacceptable now for people of European ancestry? Not that the answer has any effect on whether or not it happens, ultimately people don’t need permission and will do what they feel regardless of what others may try to impose on them.

We are talking about European nations that have been homogeneous and existed for 1000 years and we are just nonchalantly talking about a whole new paradigm and that people must accept over the course of a few decades without any say in the matter. I don’t want a fast speed replacement or slow speed, I don’t want any, I’m sure many feels the same.

If England gets to the point where there are hardly any English in it, should the country be re-named?

I’m in Bulgaria, I hope they stay Bu

Toleration leads to domination if it is not done carefully

Its like dog and cat sharing same house. Both, recognise immutable difference and similarities. Are allowed to. Their 'nationality' is the home- address. Their 'ethnicity', dog and cat. Nature is funny like that, it allows us creatures to co-exist in (near) harmony despite primitive animosities.

They gave to options speedy multiculturalism or slower multiculturalism. Let's follow the example of Israel, no multiculturalism. Good for thee but not for me doesn't get it.

Does anyone have a citation for the data showing that ingroup identification doesn't predict outgroup derogation or whatever?

You are a Gentile!!!!!

I think the studio guest was Canadian coming from a country where there are two major ethnic groups geographically separated but peacefully coexisting whilst maintaining their own culture, language and ethnic cohesion. Could that voluntary apartheid arrangement work elsewhere..?

Sorry - this guy is being so careful that I’ve given up. I listened for 20 minutes and then realised that I have no idea what he is saying.

And the Welsh, mate. Original Britons, so they say. Definitely genetically different from the Anglo-Saxon English.

This dude obviously reads Moldbug

Just started watching this channel but this is one of the worst university based views of everything, he is just trying to make capital out of his views he doesn't really believe anything, what does he know.......nothing

Professor Whitey McWhitman

God bless Donald Trump!

I'm buying it...

how?...just open your eyes...............

give us percentages about these changes..................

Interesting points: We have two separate standards in the U.S. for what constitutes as 'white' versus 'Hispanic', because there is no actual 'race/ethnicity' as 'Hispanic'. It is to the point now where the bulk of racial tensions here boil down to the left-wing position that white people should be punished for their ancestor's role during the period of slavery ('white guilt' driving the discussion among the Left towards slavery reparations; using mass migration as means to add voters through expansion of the welfare state). Interestingly, even blacks and Hispanic Americans stand to provide Trump with record level of support for a Republican president on the basis of record levels of jobs for both demographics. If you go by purely European whites, the U.S. is around 61-62% of the population. But if you combine the Hispanic population into the white population, that total rises to something like 77% or so. For blacks, 'African' blacks as a pure race stands at around 12-13%. If you combine that with Hispanics, there are 14% of our population identifying as 'black'.

It’s Kenneth Williams ! Oh matron!

So....What is a Clinton voter? What is a Trudeau voter?

Well I began to watch but at the outset I heard, England and Scotland with no understanding of Wales or northern Ireland and I switched off.. Ignorance is always a turn off for me,

Britain is full! Go to Zimbabwe Congo South Africa and leave us to our tiny White Island of First World civilisation!

dance...

rwsinha, This guy is canadian. What did they do (ancestors) do to native canadians.

Blimey - he's talking about white people!

So what he's saying is "we need to legitimize racism"...

''A lebitimate moderate form " of identity. That is what I mean when I discuss English identity in my book St George and the Dragons (Fonthill Medi, 2018).

The is no such thing as "white identity" There is "Italian", "Russian", "Nordic", etc, etc identity. Sometimes it is Identity like "I am proud of my Ukrainian heritage from my mom and my Viking heritage from my dad" identity. It is easy to melt here "Egyptian" "Syrian", "Mongolian", "South Chinese", "African from Uganda" and etc. etc.... identities. We like to be different. We like what distinguishes us but we are curious about others too. It is boring to be just white. What is white anyway? Christian? Well, I am not really, but still what is Christian? Lutheran, Catholic, Greek Orthodox? Yea, they maybe have something in common. But we cherish not the old book translated many times so nobody knows what is it about. We cherish the greek orthodox singing or huge pipe organs in Catholic temples. Or culturally what is white? I love ballet. It was developed by Europeans. But I would rather watch ballet with a black ballet dancer than I would go to a pop show with Lopez and there are much more white men that would prefer to watch Lopez rather than Sylvie Guillem. So what is the white identity again?

Diversity can be good, can be bad, can be neutral - but its heresy to say it can be bad or neutral - religion.

BORING

The only way to have multiculturalism, in the end, is to mix the races, to one race, he sais.

This guy is talking rubbish!!! " your tribe, is not my tribe" People will stay with there own....

Reading the comments there is very much concern resentment to cosmopolitanism the mass non European migration to white nations the future ststs of this change if accurate don't bode well for stable future australia is under the pump too australia

white or whatever we all here for short period of time and we go and die alone somewhere it all belongs to god stop claiming whats really not yours

Are border one of the worst inventions ever?