Why Paul doesn't like B and W tweeters

  Рет қаралды 69,646

Paul McGowan, PS Audio

Paul McGowan, PS Audio

3 жыл бұрын

Paul has long suggested that B and W's tweeters are not to his liking. Find out if that is true and why.

Пікірлер: 351
@epi2045
@epi2045 3 жыл бұрын
I own several B&Ws however I also own several other brand’s. The opposite of B&W to me is Magnepan’s which I also own. And this is all perfectly fine to me.
@jkherberger
@jkherberger 3 жыл бұрын
As a high-fi salesperson I'm baffled by what other people hear. It's all good though as long as they are happy with their purchase.
@captainwin6333
@captainwin6333 3 жыл бұрын
Why? People are bound to have different ears and brains which make sense of sound. People see differently, it's not a stretch to understand that people can hear differently too.
@jkherberger
@jkherberger 3 жыл бұрын
@@captainwin6333 it's baffling but I understand people have different ears.
@wa2368
@wa2368 3 жыл бұрын
B&W fanboys get really agitated if someone doesn't like it.
@jkherberger
@jkherberger 3 жыл бұрын
@@wa2368 I'm a KEF fan myself.
@DavidKowalski
@DavidKowalski 3 жыл бұрын
When I sold high-end audio, people often asked me what the best speaker was, and my stock answer was "the one that sounds best to you, and you should not let anyone dictate to you what that is." The proper reason for buying audio gear is to have personal enjoyment -- not to impress anyone.
@bear8myparents734
@bear8myparents734 3 жыл бұрын
I love the sound of planar for upper frequencies. There's a big difference between ribbons, tweeters, and horns. I just recently discovered Emotiva's tweeters and I'll be buying myself a set of bookshelves for Christmas.
@wilhinds8144
@wilhinds8144 3 жыл бұрын
My B&W 804s speakers are amazing I love them. Bryston amplification, Well Tempered Classic Black TT with Shure V15MR cartridge and PSA Power Plant, Perfect Wave DAC and Transport makes for a very musical combination!
@justins.1283
@justins.1283 3 жыл бұрын
I figure everybody's ears are different that's why there's so many different speakers. I have about five pairs of speakers that I hook up and switch around according to my mood or the music I'm listening to that way I'm never get bored and none of them are high and speakers but all of them sound good in their own way
@the_sheet
@the_sheet 3 жыл бұрын
I was talking to someone who owned a high end stereo shop for 30 years and he was telling me that b&w speakers tweeters are very harsh. I thought yeah yeah, personal tastes and all... 5 months later, I am at a audiophile show in Toronto and we are coming up to a room around a bend, hiding the stereo brand, I could hear the music however. I Heard this high pitched sound that actually hurt my ears, I had to put my hand up to my ear, "What the hell was that?" It was a B&W system. So my point of view, I have to agree. A side note: we brought our service dog as well, and he loved all the TUBE AMPS!
@ramonvives1674
@ramonvives1674 3 жыл бұрын
Agree, my dad owns 802d's he says he like them a lot, hes very proud of them and so on, but guess what... he never, NEVER listen to them, that tweeter is unbearable.
@renierhugo
@renierhugo Жыл бұрын
@@ramonvives1674 the diamond tweeter is the thing that makes your ears ring...the nautilus tweeter is not that much of a problem (the difference being in the type of material used in the cone...)
@perge_music
@perge_music 3 жыл бұрын
I've always loved B&W, they use them at Abbey Road studios and you see them often in studios as a reference. I figure that if the music I listen to was mixed with them, then it makes sense to play back the audio with them also :) I'm running mine dual-amped with Linn Chakra and I think they're lovely. But as he says each to their own :)
@NicolaDiNisio
@NicolaDiNisio Жыл бұрын
I've recently bought a pair of 804N. Twenty years old. Paired with my Marantz PM-KI they are fantastic. A huge step up with respect to the LS50 I had before. I really don't think I'm ever gonna change speakers again😊
@Mixing_It_Up
@Mixing_It_Up 2 жыл бұрын
Paul, I doubt you will ever see this, as this little video is nearly 2 years old at this point, but I agree wholeheartedly. Since I was very young, reading Stereophile, Audio (it was a magazine and a good one way back), Stereo Review, all those old stereo magazines, and since then as well, Bowers and Wilkins has been held up as the best thing to happen to sound since, well ever. Fast forward to me being in my 30's, and I purchased not one, but two pairs of B&W. The first was a pair of bookshelves, and while they were okay...I was so unimpressed that I thought they must be wired out of phase, mine must be defective, maybe I'm just stupid, because what I've heard my entire life in the magazines, I did NOT hear in my room. Another year goes by and I buy a pair of floorstanding B&W speakers. Guys I'm sorry I don't remember the model numbers. Well, I liked these even less. It's not me, B&W, it's most definitely you. Unless I would get into the $15k line of B&W, I just do not believe they are the speaker for me (and even at $15k, the tweeters ARE fatiguing!) So yeah, at my middle income household, give me a nice set of Andrew Jones ELAC speakers, much more smooth and musical, which is what I am listening to now and I vastly prefer them to the Bower's and Wilkins' speakers that are collecting dust in my attic. Anyone want to buy them? lol
@RBHADD
@RBHADD Жыл бұрын
Now that is so funny as I had Elacs and loved them but when I replaced them with similar sized B&W CM10s I realized the top end was harsh on the Elacs. The B&Ws were just more refined at the top. Personal taste I guess.
@JB-ku5ml
@JB-ku5ml 7 ай бұрын
all depends a large extent to the room they play
@ryanj9235
@ryanj9235 3 жыл бұрын
The picture quality is so good, better than the sound! Good job.
@AALavdas
@AALavdas 3 жыл бұрын
Couldn't agree more, about ribbons! Once you have been exposed to them, there is no turning back. This is especially true if you are listening to types of music where natural timbre reproduction is very important, such classical music.
@justanotheryoutubeuser5029
@justanotheryoutubeuser5029 3 жыл бұрын
I have a pair of 607 and wharfedale 4.2. I like them both one does what the other doesn’t 607 - they are the very opposite of evos. The goods of these speakers are clarity, speed, holographic. I like them if im in the mood for live music, electric, rock. Evo 4.2 - sounds very big, sweets highs, room filling bass, turn it up, listen for hours, and no fatigue will come your way. I like them for primarily for jazz and reggae I was thinking of selling the 607 but having both serves me very well. And in the end both are impressive to me. Im set on my gear and i dont see me wanting for more... well maybe a cd player or turn table (it just never ends).
@stingray1irwin0
@stingray1irwin0 3 жыл бұрын
You're cool. I like you. I'm over here with minimus 7s matched to a hilariously cheap Panasonic sub from the early oughts. Still enjoying your dulcet tones. Whatever works! One day I'll support you with dollars instead of just words, but in the meantime thank you for the great content.
@andrewwood4504
@andrewwood4504 3 жыл бұрын
I remember in 2014 I began to buy higher end speakers, I tried mid level Def Tech's, Paradigms, Boston Acoustic, etc.. just kept buying them and selling them a month or so after. I decided to go for it and really spend some money, got a pair of B&W Nautilus 903's I think it was.. So disappointed, I honestly thought they were way to laid back and just kind of boring. One day I purchased 10 pairs of different speakers at an auction, In that lot was a pair of Infinity RS-4B's, I knew they were older and looked cool but didn't really expect that within 5 minutes I would be saying "That's it, this is the sound I've been looking for!" I think I paid $70 for those! The magic of the EMIT tweeter and that fast, tight Infinity bass had bit me and I was hooked, Next came the RS-3B's then the Kappa 8.1's, and now my final resting place with Original Kappa 8's and Ren 90's. And that's only because I can't afford the Epilson or Beta's lol.
@ShortHandedNow
@ShortHandedNow 3 жыл бұрын
I had some older DM series bookshelf speakers from B&W. (Made in the mid 80's to early 90's). They were definitely a little on the bright side but to each their own. We all have different tastes.
@hugobloemers4425
@hugobloemers4425 3 жыл бұрын
Speakers are just very personal because everybody likes a different flavour of fake :)
@Turtleback8024
@Turtleback8024 3 жыл бұрын
So true.
@hocheye
@hocheye 3 жыл бұрын
B&W are known to be brighter sounding, most know this but with the right gear and the right room all is good.My speakers are very neutral some would say boring in a fairly bright room with the gear I have they sound fantastic all about synergy.
@plblo858
@plblo858 3 жыл бұрын
Totally agree!
@DaveMichalakChannel
@DaveMichalakChannel 3 жыл бұрын
I’m with you, Paul as far as tweeters go. I love my Adam A7X AMT tweeters. Even my $50/pair of Dayton Audio B652-Air AMT tweeters are very musical. Keep up the good work.🎼
@GBatya
@GBatya 3 жыл бұрын
I think depends on the dome material, for example alu/magnesium has low break up frequency around 20khz (causes metallic coloration?), but diamond is around 70khz!
@stofopdenaald132
@stofopdenaald132 Жыл бұрын
I have acquired a set of B&W's DM14 recently. Had lots of different speakers and amps over the years, and I can't say the tweeters bugg me at all. Well roundend sound, no Shrill highs, and the bass...d#ng that bass just fills the room like no other, while never getting muddy even with the loudness button on. I use them with a vintage Sanyo A35 plus series amp at the moment.
@ganck1147
@ganck1147 7 ай бұрын
Thanks Paul for being so diplomatic. As u said, its all a matter of taste. As for me i recall being attracted to b&w precisely becos of their highs. I was thinking wow that tweeter sounds very sweet, open & transparent. That was many years ago. Many yrs later i have owned several b&w spks and still continue to enjoy them. I also like ribbon tweeters and the best i heard so far are those designed by Bo Bengtsson. It was used in the Red Rose R3 bookshelf spks. However good as they are, ribbon tweeters are very difficult to mate seamlessly with a normal cone driver. Those that sounds coherent are those that have their output severely limited. For me that defeats the purpose of having a ribbon tweeter in the 1st plc. While i hv not heard all the hybrid ribbon/cone spks but most of what i heard are not totally seamless, even the very exp Raidho spks. Spks like Alta audio seems pretty seamless bcos they limit the output of their tweeters to a large degree. At least that’s what i heard. Ribbon tweeters are supposed to be very airy, extended & sparkling but those on Alta audio seems very dull & muted. In the 80s i have also heard many Infinity spks with Emit tweeters & somehow still felt that those didn’t really sound seamless too. The smaller infinity with dome tweeters sounded more musical & seamless but they lack a bit of refinement. At the end of the day, pick what u like & enjoy the music.
@johnstone7697
@johnstone7697 3 жыл бұрын
I had a pair of the original 801's for about 10 years. They were highly regarded on both sides of the Atlantic. For their day, their measurements were impeccable, and they had very extended bass response. Yet, I spent most of my time searching out amplification that could power them properly and sources (turntable at the time) that would complement their tonal characteristics. Turned up really loud, they sounded great. At moderate volumes, not so much. I finally sold the to a good friend who enjoyed them for many years, and still has the stored away in his basement after building himself a set of Linkwitz Orions.
@peterbaugh51
@peterbaugh51 3 ай бұрын
I have six various CM speakers by B&W. They are not bad, but I prefer my Elac Debut Reference DBR62's by far. Much lower price. Much more balanced sound. Deep bass down to 30 htz (with tube preamp into 200 watt Class D amp). I dont care how pretty a cabinet is. I will not pay thousands of dollars for a nice paint job and shiny parts. As a musician, I want realistic sound with a big 3D soundstage. Elac does that. Well, mine do in my room! To BETTER the Elacs, I would expext to pay 10x. Thanks for the video.
@therugburnz
@therugburnz 3 жыл бұрын
Good points Paul. Listening and taste\preference are as important as engineering when It comes to choosing loudspeakers for home listening pleasure.
@ucantrefuse03
@ucantrefuse03 Ай бұрын
I am actually on the same page as you are on B&W, its really odd though because the same brand sounds Much better in newer Volvos, however I purchased and returned a Zeppelin McLaren edition and my Harman Kardon onyx 4 and 7 both sound better and were way less expensive ! thanks for the content :)
@shaynakash4222
@shaynakash4222 3 жыл бұрын
hey paul exellent review for my ears i love ribbons as well but there are amazing tweeters like scanspeaks d 3004/6600 that sounds like high end ribbons and have amazing dynamics that not all ribbon has it sounds more lifelike to me.....
@goobernoodles
@goobernoodles 4 ай бұрын
I have a couple of pairs of B&W 602's as well as Ascend Acoustics Sierra Towers (dome tweeter) and Sierra 2EX bookshelf speakers. The ribbon tweeter on the 2EX is just phenomenal, and I absolutely agree with your stance on them. I do really the 602's as well - I feel like the bass & mid-bass is fantastic for rock music. They've really got some teeth.
@vitalyginak8441
@vitalyginak8441 3 жыл бұрын
Pol, north Finland at the same time north of Norway!
@ParadigmAC
@ParadigmAC 3 жыл бұрын
I really enjoy Cerwin Vegas from the 80's and 90's. I love heavy hard hitting bass. Models with 12" or 15" drivers can go really deep with the lows. With that said the mids and tweeters sound good on the models I have no complaints from me.
@derek15boom
@derek15boom 3 жыл бұрын
My pick and all time favorite, the Cerwin-Vega AT-15. That model debuted in 1987.
@ParadigmAC
@ParadigmAC 3 жыл бұрын
@@derek15boom That's one of the pair a have. They are awesome.
@steveaustin7306
@steveaustin7306 3 жыл бұрын
I have 703s. Great for me with super tweeters. Yeah I had some French 3 ways speakers with a ribbon tweeter and a servo woofer. Amps gone years ago. Closer queens but wow were they great sounding. 3k list in 1980
@trucchuong1726
@trucchuong1726 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks Paul, I'm 100% agree with you regarding B&W sound signature. I have listened to many B&W speakers including very extensive one; however, they are too bright and dry to my taste.
@homeopathical
@homeopathical 3 жыл бұрын
I always thought it was just me that didn't like the tweeters on B&W speakers. I've owned a pair and listened to a pair that I thought I'd end up buying but couldn't gel with them either. I found the B&W tweeter threw the sound out in such a way as to make it difficult to place the high treble position in the soundstage. Well-off axis they sounded good though. When I demoed some B&W against the AE1 MkII and some AVI NuNeutrons, I ended up with the AE1's. The treble was actually better on the AVI but the overall joy was from the AEs. Still have the AEs 20 years on, and with the original surround foam! My listening tastes have moved on, so I now tend to listen with some TDL Studio 0.5s and a dinky pair of Alexander SE2. Much more 'musical' speakers as opposed to 'analytical'. Thanks for your great vids.
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 3 жыл бұрын
which b&w model did you get to try?
@homeopathical
@homeopathical 3 жыл бұрын
@@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 I owned a pair of B&W ZMF2002, albeit briefly and auditioned the B&W CDM1NT against the AVI NuNeutron and Acoustic Energy AE1 MK2 and settled for the AE1s. I've listened to many pairs of B&W speakers at HIFi shows in the UK in the 90s and although the look and finish of the B&Ws was and remains fantastic, I came to the same conclusion about the tweeters.
@tommygun5vsrocky
@tommygun5vsrocky 3 жыл бұрын
Your right Paul, I don't like B&W for the same reasons and I always liked Thiel Audio way better all around including price compared to B&W. Sad Jim Thiel passed he was a amazing engineer. I like Monitor Audio hands down over B&W there I just so many speakers better then that company to me anyway so I agree with you here.
@louisperlman8030
@louisperlman8030 3 жыл бұрын
The Kevlar midrange of my B&W 804N's was as much to blame ad the tweeter for the often aggressive sound. With work, I got good recordings to sound good, but they were close to unlistenable on bad recordings. B&W said to have them pointed straight ahead, and specified a 10 foot listening distance. This was not possible in my living room, which no doubt, was evident in the overall sound.
@goldenears9748
@goldenears9748 3 жыл бұрын
Good for you Paul. Decent and honest 😃
@HighhScore
@HighhScore 3 ай бұрын
Having lucked out on a pair of Matrix 804 floor standing loudspeakers with matching center unit for 75$, I think they’re superb when compared to my old Polk t50’s. I do like to hear a lot of treble though. A lot of speakers hide the details that these provide for me. Couldn’t bash on em but again 75$ was a heck of a deal.
@villageroma
@villageroma 3 жыл бұрын
You nailed perfectly about B&W.
@llee4225
@llee4225 3 жыл бұрын
I had older Dynaco A25 and B&W DM6 that have silk dome tweeters. After upgrading to 805 matrix and 804 nautilus and other speakers that have metal dome tweeters , I find the treble to bright and harsh. Most metal dome tweeters have very high resonance peaks in the ultra sonics region which you may not expect to affect the audio range. However, I wonder if it would intermodulation with lower band signals to cause audible distortion?
@BB..........
@BB.......... Жыл бұрын
I've owned a pair of B&W Matrix 802 S3 since 2001 and it wasn't until 2019 when I bought a used pair of Dunlavy SC-III when I realized how bright the B&W tweeters are. They definitely sound slightly aggressive, and the drivers don't blend as well as the Dunlavy speakers. I've since gone from SC-III, to SC-IV to SC-V.
@trekjudas
@trekjudas 3 жыл бұрын
They are bright as hell!!
@bradleydurbin6784
@bradleydurbin6784 2 жыл бұрын
I think it's also the CD that is playing and the room. I have PSB xt1 tower speakers and they sound very similar to my Bowers and Wilkins 685s2 bookshelves. Except the Bowers and Wilkins are bit more revealing. But PSB speakers are bright also. So are the vintage Polk audio monitor 4a speakers. Very fatiguing after awhile. Alot of it is the recordings.
@MrMaxi3140
@MrMaxi3140 3 жыл бұрын
I think personally, this topic can be very complex . It's Iike what would a person prefer as far as "room temperature" goes, at a particular time of day, evening, and at night. Now factor in the different house space locations, and finally the individual's age. I love these type of challenges which keeps the audiophile in me alive and active. Or maybe it's just that I'm losing it.
@scarabeo500gt
@scarabeo500gt 3 жыл бұрын
I totally agree 100% with you Paul on most things Audio, B&W are not for my taste in the tweeter as well. I sure wish I had some PS Audio speakers but still getting the shaft! lol
@ranseus
@ranseus 3 жыл бұрын
I wonder if Paul's referring to B&W's diamond tweeters, which I believe most of their line doesn't have.
@DougMen1
@DougMen1 3 жыл бұрын
They design ALL their speakers, no matter which tweeter they use, to be very tipped up and hot in the treble
@arksurvivalevolved9190
@arksurvivalevolved9190 3 жыл бұрын
Hello Paul, Pedro here from Barcelona. i have a doubt maybe you could clarify me. If we have 1 DAC connected to your computer (music source) via usb+opt then goes to receiver, which DAC dominates? The 1st connected to computer or the receiver as the last device in the chain? Is actually my setup, from my DAC into my receiver where speackers are connected... thank you
@67daltonknox
@67daltonknox Жыл бұрын
50 odd years ago I built a pair of speakers using the Decca/Kelly ribbon tweeters which I loved. Too heavy to bring when I emigrated, I ended up with Maggies which have a similar treble. Over the years I have found metal dome tweeters do not agree with me, though I have not heard beryllium or diamond faced ones.
@timgreen7208
@timgreen7208 3 жыл бұрын
Had B&W 706 s2 for 6 months. They were to replace KEF LS50 which I had for 1 month. Both speakers auditioned well for an hour or so in the demo room. But at home quickly the KEF started to hurt my ears - too bright and aggressive , tiring and fatiguing to listen to. The B&W were better, but then after a month or so I felt they too were not as easy as I wanted. Used with a NAD M10 so I did a lot of tweaking with the full range DIRAC room correction I bought. Still too bright. Eventually replaced with Spendor A1. Nicer, easier and more intelligible mid range. I think I just might not like modern metal tweeters.
@gizzy2403
@gizzy2403 3 жыл бұрын
Sounds like Elac might b right up your alley🍻
@plblo858
@plblo858 3 жыл бұрын
Once the B&W speakers run in properly, never get tired even after whole day listening.
@timgreen7208
@timgreen7208 3 жыл бұрын
@@plblo858 Hi, I used them a lot for 6 months, so run in enough. They were not bad but still made me wince now and them. I thought do I want to be living with this for another 2 or 5 or whatever years ? A dealer let me borrow the Spendor A1's for a week and I switched them back and forwards. The Spendor were instantly less harsh - and the mid range vocals were unexpectedly clearer. As the B&W cabinets were larger their bass was a bit more room filling, but the Spendors were quite good enough for me in the bass. It's always a compromise - I am much happier with the Spendors.
@nestorjlimph
@nestorjlimph 3 жыл бұрын
American & British speakers , different preference, to each his own of course
@stevekarr4613
@stevekarr4613 3 жыл бұрын
B&W typically uses aluminum dome tweeters that have a big ultrasonic peak (somewhere around 8dB at 28kHz), which could create some type of intermodulation distortion. I also think there is significant phase distortion from their use of second order crossover slopes. To me, they sound "Hi-Fi" vs natural.
@renierhugo
@renierhugo Жыл бұрын
in some of their speakers yes...there are also soft dome...diamond, and various other materials used in the domes all depending on the specific design of the speaker
@nicktaylor7680
@nicktaylor7680 3 жыл бұрын
Other adjectives to describe B&W speakers sound could be revealing, transparent,airy and precise none of which are faults but questions of synergy. I listen to B&W and when matched with valve pre amp gives a smooth yet detailed sound.
@fabrisony7729
@fabrisony7729 3 жыл бұрын
transparent and clear, no other brand comes close in this regard
@ruk2023--
@ruk2023-- 3 жыл бұрын
I would agree - I have B&W 702 S2's and if they made them with a ribbon tweeter I'd snap them up. As it is I knock the treble down by 1db in my amp and it's enough to keep me happy. Overall I love the speakers but they are a pain in the ass to get positioned initially.
@michaelmityok1001
@michaelmityok1001 3 жыл бұрын
I had a pair and I had zero problems positioning them, and the tweeter was bright when the recording was crappy. Upgraded to 804s a few months ago and could not be happier. The treble is refined, airy and extended, never harsh except again when the recording is not up to snuff. I think this issue is the real knock on B&W, and the fact that most of them require quality power to sound good.
@ruk2023--
@ruk2023-- 3 жыл бұрын
@@michaelmityok1001 I'm blaming my room, not the speakers for the positioning problems. I do need a decent amp - currently the PS Audio Stellar Strata, Rotel 1592, Parasound halo 6 and Musical fidelity 6si are on the short list. What do you power yours with (specifically your old 702's)?
@andreasmoller9798
@andreasmoller9798 3 жыл бұрын
@@michaelmityok1001 i agree, but i don’t even have 700 or 800 series, i am down with 600 series line as they was in my budget when i bought speakers for the first time 5 years ago, but i am intrested in the 702 s2 in the future
@michaelmityok1001
@michaelmityok1001 3 жыл бұрын
@@ruk2023-- CODA No. 8 Version 2, best amp I have ever owned by far. If there is a chance you can save up the money patiently, buy a CODA integrated (I think they are 6K approx). High current (75 amps!) and Class A bias, 10 year warranty with a buy-back program for when you want to upgrade - bonus is that it is all made-in-the-USA (if that is important to you). If not get the Kinki Studios EX-M1+ or Denafrips Hestia/Thallo pre/power stack through Vinshine Audio if you don't mind made-in-China gear. Vinshine Audio is the distributor, Alvin is the boss and a great guy, very professional and reliable when it comes to any warranty issues.
@ruk2023--
@ruk2023-- 3 жыл бұрын
@@michaelmityok1001 Thanks man, I'll look into them.
@longshanks8255
@longshanks8255 3 жыл бұрын
I wanted to hear the diamond tweeter when it came out. Also in the room was the Sonus Faber Toy I believe. B&W sounded like real cymbals. Yes incredible! But! Being in close proximity to a cymbal will make your ears bleed! The chocolate smoothness of the SF was milk and honey for the ears.
@cuttinchops
@cuttinchops 3 жыл бұрын
+1 for ribbons/planars. I had them all, horns, domes, etc. I got my first set of megnepans (vintage MG IIIa’s) and I am HOOKED! I’ll never go back unless it’s for HT. Keep in mind what paul said... MUSICAL. So for HT I would say B&W type/horns/sharpness is what one might want in a movie room
@andreasmoller9798
@andreasmoller9798 3 жыл бұрын
I find b&w bright but still musical in my opinion
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 3 жыл бұрын
why though, why not just have 1 setup for everything
@gen-X-trader
@gen-X-trader 3 жыл бұрын
b&w works really really well with EDM, dance, modern music. not my favorite for classical or instrumental....that said i would love to see you cover the dynaudio emit m10 and m20. they are the best under $1000 bookshelf speakers i have ever heard. the midrange balance which is so wicked hard to pull off without shrill....they did
@RanTausi
@RanTausi Жыл бұрын
Did you at the end buy the Emit20?
@remiandrepedersen868
@remiandrepedersen868 3 жыл бұрын
It's with taste, but it also has something to do with what kind of music we are talking about as well. For my part who likes almost all kinds of music, it becomes difficult to find the most perfect speakers for it.
@andreasmoller9798
@andreasmoller9798 3 жыл бұрын
I still use b&w 683 s2 that i bought 5 years ago love them, great match with hegel h190, the best part about them is the midrange, but the treple is very good as well, bass is tight, great for the most part but can become a bit muddy at times
@andreasmoller9798
@andreasmoller9798 3 жыл бұрын
@Lloyd Stout the room is not treated, but i have improved It in some ways like adding a carbet in between, the room is still ok for sound, what i meant by muddy bass, was not boomy bass by Any means, more expensive speakers will have a more defined bass, but for the pricepoint there is not much To complain about
@oysteinsoreide4323
@oysteinsoreide4323 3 жыл бұрын
@@andreasmoller9798 muddy bass comes if you don't have good isolation between speakers and floor.
@andershammer9307
@andershammer9307 3 жыл бұрын
I prefer electrostatic tweeters. It was a real revelation to me when I heard KLH 9s. Now I listen to Acoustats. Only new speaker I heard that sounds as good are Sound Labs.
@bizyz
@bizyz 3 жыл бұрын
if you like the bright sound,go for anything by klipsch.
@matthewduran3949
@matthewduran3949 3 жыл бұрын
I hate to admit it but I used to own Bose, I upgraded to JBL and now have B&W. I just love the sound of B&W bookshelf & subwoofer combo.
@plblo858
@plblo858 3 жыл бұрын
me too, 805 D3 + subwoofer, sound great
@AyushP2014
@AyushP2014 3 жыл бұрын
I have the Quad S-2 Bookshelf Speakers which has True Ribbon tweeters! 🙂
@Goldenhordemilo
@Goldenhordemilo 3 жыл бұрын
my tweeters wer made in the seventies.I got them in 1999 so you know i had a loud system, the tweeties still work as they are the voice of the music
@DavidDarrow
@DavidDarrow 8 ай бұрын
Obviously I'm late to the game, but FWIW I also hated the bright sound of B&W speakers, and had written them off entirely. Then one day a pair of 90s 802 Series 3 popped up on my local Craigslist for a price that was absurd. I immediately agreed to buy them with the plan to just flip them. When I got them home and tested them on my system my jaw dropped. Long story short, I've now had them over a decade as my primary speakers. I love these things! If you have the chance of giving some of there 20th century speakers a listen, you might, like me, end up surprised.
@leekumiega9268
@leekumiega9268 3 жыл бұрын
Paul planar ribbon tweeters while having excellent detail and fairly wide horizontal dispersion have narrow vertical dispersion and should be used in a line array ,is that what you are doing with your new speaker. Don't AMT tweeters sound as good with better vertical dispersion.
@djzoloft
@djzoloft 3 жыл бұрын
Had a pair of DM 10's a while ago...the ferro fluid was gone and so were the highs.....great speakers though.
@ToyotatechDK
@ToyotatechDK 3 жыл бұрын
I have the same opinion. JBL, B&W and Infinity tweeters. That also comes to car stereo
@AllboroLCD
@AllboroLCD 3 жыл бұрын
There's so much beyond science that makes the industry, and this is a perfect example. It is far more "preference" than it is "standard"
@stanislavshokurov6532
@stanislavshokurov6532 3 жыл бұрын
The higher end B&W’s are very decent. But they are starting at close to 10k for relatively small speakers. But almost all decent contemporary speakers are at that price range
@viziontex
@viziontex 3 жыл бұрын
Hi Paul great channel👍 what do you think of paradigm speakers,
@craigcoughlin1834
@craigcoughlin1834 3 жыл бұрын
I have an old pair of Matrix 804's and I'm realizing the highs are just too harsh for me when the music gets complicated. 80%-90% of what I listen to is rock - Wilco, GBV, Dylan, Pretenders, Courtney Barnett etc. I thought my NAD electronics were the culprit but upgrading electronics to Musical Fidelity and a new Denafrips Aries II dac, although much improved, the highs are still hard edged at volume enough to get the air moving.
@hhsstergios9126
@hhsstergios9126 3 жыл бұрын
Warrior nodding to warrior. Nice vid Paul. Love B&W!
@joeblow597
@joeblow597 Жыл бұрын
I picked up a pair of DM1400's cheap, they were overly bright in the top end, installed a fixed L-Pad in each which cost me less than $20.00, problem solved, sounded beautiful after that.
@bneyens
@bneyens 3 жыл бұрын
I absolutely love my B&W’s for 2 channel.
@humanitech
@humanitech 3 жыл бұрын
Funny old game really... even if hifi equipment and speakers could accurately reproduce a near perfect representation of the musicians, venue and recording. Not everyone would like that sound. So we are lucky to have so many options to mix and match to suit our personal tastes and needs.
@Badazz08
@Badazz08 3 жыл бұрын
Do realize that when we listen at a concert, we are listening from whatever speakers they are using also. I think most of us forget that bit of info. I for one am glad we have so many speakers to choose from. I have ran across some I like and alot I dislike.
@humanitech
@humanitech 3 жыл бұрын
@@Badazz08 true and we can save ourselves a fortune if we demo stuff before buying.
@Badazz08
@Badazz08 3 жыл бұрын
@@humanitech heck yeah. I always demo stuff. I listened to my focal 836v for a while before pulling the trigger on em.
@SimonLloydGuitar
@SimonLloydGuitar 5 ай бұрын
i have 802's and i adore them...they must have very, very good amplification to drive them though otherwise they sound bright with weak bass. serious amps smooth the high end and deepen and tighten the bass. i also own a pair of Adam Audio monitors in my studio that use a ribbon 'x-art' tweeter but these are harder sounding than the 802s (still very good though)
@DrJLins
@DrJLins 3 жыл бұрын
Yeah, Paul. All in all, it's the one's perception that counts.
@jameslaidler2152
@jameslaidler2152 6 ай бұрын
1980s B&W is phenomenal. Especially the DM-220s and 330s.
@Slickman2006
@Slickman2006 3 жыл бұрын
Paul what do you think of Triangle EZ speakers?
@jaakanshorter
@jaakanshorter 3 жыл бұрын
I had BW605 for a short time right before I got Maggie's, when I still had a pair Genesis genre 2s. The tweeter hurt my "cat ears" , too bright. I ended up giving them to goodwill.
@WillyJunior
@WillyJunior 3 жыл бұрын
Why don't people use EQs?
@jaakanshorter
@jaakanshorter 3 жыл бұрын
@Jingle Nuts that was over 10 years ago and I had a Yamaha DSP-A1 at the time. My first experience with speakers was with my dad's Quad ESL 57 , so I have a bias for a type of sound I like. Oh I messed with dsp and eq settings, and other things. Tried a quad 405 amp and moscode 300 too. Was never really happy with the 605. I have magnepans + rotel class D power amp and a few pairs of stax now.
@jareknowak8712
@jareknowak8712 3 жыл бұрын
Ha, thats strange as hell Jaakan, bc a few years ago (probably in 2015) i bought my pair at goodwill :) Not joking.
@jessielees
@jessielees 3 жыл бұрын
@@WillyJunior best I can figure it, is they'd rather shell out thousands of dollars and waste dozen of hours because turning the treble up or down is supposedly blasphemy. lol.
@thunderpooch
@thunderpooch 3 жыл бұрын
@@WillyJunior People don't like the phase issues caused by EQ.
@savvassidiropoulos5952
@savvassidiropoulos5952 3 жыл бұрын
Many people complain about the squeaky sound of the KEF T27 and the honky resonances of the B110. But go check out the prices of BBC LS3/5a units.
@ThinkingBetter
@ThinkingBetter 3 жыл бұрын
Most audio brands with a long history have made some excellent as well as some bad products. Just ignore those bad ones.
@ThinkingBetter
@ThinkingBetter 3 жыл бұрын
@Fat Rat We indeed have a lot of vinyl stores (selling those discs moving around) here in Southern California: www.google.com/maps/search/vinyl/@32.825346,-117.3912312,10z/data=!3m1!4b1
@jonmccarble7677
@jonmccarble7677 3 жыл бұрын
I just sold my B&W CM6 S2's almost exclusively because of the HF. I'm definitely new to the HiFi / Audiophile world, so excuse my verbiage: The tweeter is very bright, and feels like it's playing louder and prouder than the mids. I find in most of my listening experiences that a) i have to get up to a moderate volume to get enough mid range (running 120W/channel) ; b) after listening to 30min + my ears will actually hurt from the HF sounds... it's almost ear-piercing. The accuracy with which they played was phenomenal, but it was just not something I could enjoy over an extended period... which is what I like to do. So, I've purchased a pair of Tekton Design Double Impacts. Obviously huge difference between Bookshelf and Floor standing, but really wanted something that had presence and oomph without trying so hard.
@Harald_Reindl
@Harald_Reindl 3 жыл бұрын
the most likely solution would have treat your listening room as it demands - it is 50% of what you hear - been there, after made my room perfect I stopped turn down treble
@toffe2ventil
@toffe2ventil 3 жыл бұрын
Kinda depends on which B&W tweeter we are talking about? The diamond tweeter on my 805D3:s are bloody marvelous..
@mw4609
@mw4609 3 жыл бұрын
I keep a pair of B&W speakers in the stable to occasionally remind myself what too surgical sounds like. Allows me to adjust my perception by A/B comparison when voicing new builds or re-voicing old builds. It is too easy to climb that ladder toward accuracy - occasionally one needs to be reminded what has become painfully bright. For me, B&W is a few levels too far, and immediate torture to my ears. Because of this I've learned (and re-learned occasionally) to stay away from metal tweeters - as a general rule.
@DougMen1
@DougMen1 3 жыл бұрын
It's not the metal tweeter, it's the crossover design with the tweeter too hot
@thedayones4918
@thedayones4918 2 жыл бұрын
On a blind test no one can tell speakers apart. These audiophiles folks are pure comedy 😆✌🏽
@bc527c
@bc527c 3 жыл бұрын
B&W speakers need -extensive- acoustic treatment in order to sound right, they are super hard to dial in in a room, if you have evil reflections then that tweeter mounted on top will be a problem. Excellent comment, Paul, and I completely concur- B&W speakers play -music like- sounds, yes, it can be very sweet and tick all the audiophile boxes. Funny thing thought, as 'good' as my B&W rig sounds, it just does not move me, not at all. On the other hand I have another rig that is not sweet, does not try to make the music sound special, it just plays the content I send and does so in a raw direct way that sounds like I'm in a practice studio with the band, instrument sound like real instruments, music sounds like music and it moves me deeply. So, yeah, I agree with Paul 1000%
@brianmoore581
@brianmoore581 3 жыл бұрын
So what's the other rig?
@bc527c
@bc527c 3 жыл бұрын
@@brianmoore581 Open baffle speakers I designed, pro drivers and amps, hifi source, which I built after doing extensive room acoustics for the B&W system and concluding I was not getting what I want from the speakers, so the new project became an exploration of all the things I wanted combined with a deep think on what sounds and sound systems in my past experiences actually rang the bell for me.
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 3 жыл бұрын
hmm so which b&w model was that?
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 3 жыл бұрын
@@bc527c @
@josephah2000
@josephah2000 6 ай бұрын
The CMs are great! They give you lots of bang for your buck. Keep and enjoy them!
@MichelLinschoten
@MichelLinschoten 3 жыл бұрын
I had a Bowers and Wilkins 802, I liked it....I liked it a lot. Until I went magnepan, sold the 802 never slept less over it
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 3 жыл бұрын
which model did you choose?
@marktran630
@marktran630 3 жыл бұрын
I have to agree with Paul that ribbon / planar tweeter sounds better than other designs like dome or horn ect. I just prefer the sound ribbon or planar sound as they sound more natural.
@Leysner77
@Leysner77 Жыл бұрын
And what about focal do you like the speakers lines ?
@rbyington22
@rbyington22 3 жыл бұрын
I think some of the speaker co including B&W we're much better in the late 1980s when in my opinion more focus was attributed to how a speaker sounded. But once a company becomes more interested in mass-marketing of their product things change. ( like B&W being available at Best Buy) I also understand the difference between an entry-level set of bookcase speakers and a pair of $20,000 top of the line speakers. I had a pair of 802’s that sounded great. Some people have said the same thing about Sonus Faber once all speakers were handmade in Italy, Now unless you want to buy the Olympica series they are not all made by hand anymore. My current set of speakers are Olympica 3 I had Focal’s before and as I got older Beryllium tweeters started to sound harsh and gave me listening fatigue
@andreasmoller9798
@andreasmoller9798 3 жыл бұрын
I disagree i find the sound on the new b&w models better, more clarity than the old models, i have not campared all models of course, but with 683 s1 vs 683 s2, 683 s2 is the clear Winner in my opinion, they don’t dig as deep but they have better midrange and treple
@rbyington22
@rbyington22 3 жыл бұрын
@@andreasmoller9798 at what price point are we talking the B&W speakers I had in the 1980 had an MSRP of around $6000 and I don't think any sneaker they manufactured at a much lower price point would have sounded better please advise
@andreasmoller9798
@andreasmoller9798 3 жыл бұрын
@@rbyington22 i think the new 800 d3 is better but more expensive
@liquidamber
@liquidamber 2 ай бұрын
love it
@jyrkih6960
@jyrkih6960 3 жыл бұрын
B&W’s have some problems (or house sound) in their tweeter. The dispersion pattern of the tweeter becomes very wide on the transition from the midrange that is beaming at it’s upper range. This is very much visible in their power response. As peaker’s frequency response pretty much follows the power response in untreated room, it means that this sudden change in the dispersion is very much audible.
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795
@skylordsrebornpvpreplays5795 3 жыл бұрын
what does that mean in the end?
@juliaset751
@juliaset751 3 жыл бұрын
They do measure flat, and that could be the problem. I read an article in Stereophile many years ago where they talked to many reviewers, audiophiles, speaker manufacturers, etc. and the speakers that most people loved had a roll-off in the highs.
@angusvanhalen2886
@angusvanhalen2886 3 жыл бұрын
I got into headphones about a decade ago, and I just don't care for Sennheisers 'phones, their house sound, if you will. I love the company, they make some killer mics
@chielwouterscw
@chielwouterscw 3 жыл бұрын
Me too! The "Sennheiser sound" does nothing for me. I bought a Bose QC 35 (which Paul once recommended I think) and I absolutely love it. Perfectly fits my kind of sound.
@jareknowak8712
@jareknowak8712 3 жыл бұрын
I had many, but i love only AKG.
@puddleglumsmusiccollection9151
@puddleglumsmusiccollection9151 3 жыл бұрын
Love my B&Ws. They are older
@milesdufourny4813
@milesdufourny4813 3 жыл бұрын
B&W speakers especially the mid and upper tier ones are fatiquingly bright. They may sound exciting at first but after a month or so the highs are so bright you don't want to listen to them for any extended time. I'll take Harbeths over them any day.
@stevezodiac6025
@stevezodiac6025 3 жыл бұрын
Likewise, I have owned my 801's for 30 years and never quite been comfortable with the upper mmids and hf. As I age and my tastes are not so much for ZZ Top and Robin Trower etc. the mid and tweeters bother me more. For years I have told people that the mid honks and the tweeter squeaks....even after the Northcreek upgrades.
@pweb4941
@pweb4941 4 ай бұрын
I am looking at a pair of Matrix 800. It has a tweeter needing replaced. I was thinking of upgrading to another set of tweeters eg satori berylium tweeters. Thoughts Paul?
@Paulmcgowanpsaudio
@Paulmcgowanpsaudio 4 ай бұрын
That's a tough one because the crossover in the speaker is designed specifically around the original tweeter. If you feel confident in your measuring abilities and are able to redesign the crossover then go for it!
@lonestarlive4757
@lonestarlive4757 3 жыл бұрын
Like any transducer.. the final "this is good" is all about the Human experience.... Good is ALWAYS in the ear of the listener in the transducer world. (Mics and Speakers)
@googoo-gjoob
@googoo-gjoob 3 жыл бұрын
oh no!!! ....you got _east_ on my _west_
@dariusmoldovan6202
@dariusmoldovan6202 3 жыл бұрын
ANY OPINION ON THE Q ACOUSTICSQ3050I?
@chuckmaddison2924
@chuckmaddison2924 Жыл бұрын
Bit like North Carolina. ( the south or north thing ) Anyway what's your opinion on Dali ?.
Why do musicians ignore high-end audio?
5:19
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 344 М.
Why don't more preamps have XLR?
11:23
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 143 М.
The day of the sea 🌊 🤣❤️ #demariki
00:22
Demariki
Рет қаралды 106 МЛН
Heartwarming: Stranger Saves Puppy from Hot Car #shorts
00:22
Fabiosa Best Lifehacks
Рет қаралды 19 МЛН
How to listen at low volumes
5:22
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 149 М.
Is Emotiva Audio a reputable company?
3:17
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 18 М.
Are cheap Beryllium tweeters any good?
32:54
RAW-CAt
Рет қаралды 25 М.
Why are preamps expensive?
6:58
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 101 М.
Are toroidal transformers better?
5:51
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 81 М.
What the HECK?! Bowers and Wilkins
19:17
GR-Research
Рет қаралды 111 М.
Optimal distance between loudspeakers
6:29
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 266 М.
What happened to Class H amplifiers?
6:01
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 47 М.
How do you know if your caps have aged?
6:00
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 98 М.
Is MQA a good thing?
5:23
Paul McGowan, PS Audio
Рет қаралды 110 М.
1❤️ #shorts
0:24
Saito
Рет қаралды 61 МЛН
路飞这是生了个啥? #海贼王 #路飞 #funny
0:47
路飞与唐舞桐
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Incredible magic 🤯✨
0:53
America's Got Talent
Рет қаралды 44 МЛН