You're right and in fact, all animals are to some degree, some far more than we realize.

@@paulhomsy2751 YOU ARE 100 % RIGHT ON

Who sold these Elephants?

And after a year, today #NoorJehan is fighting for her life at #KarachiZoo.😢

@@irenedavo3768 These 4 elephants were captured from the wild in Tanzania, the Tanzanian Government and traders facilitated the babies capture along with a Pakistani trader. The latter boasted in a recorded interview that he encouraged the Karachi authorities to buy 4 instead of 2 and other wild caught animals besides. They were at the time protected under CITES 11 which deemed that elephants could only be removed from their home terrain if they were going to a suitable location. Pakistan’s zoos and the safari park were well known to be highly unsuitable with their history of inappropriate care of elephants.

So agree! But zoos are getting better!

@@Saucyakld Better for whom??? These are wild animals and they deserve to be free!!

@@Saucyakld It's good but it's heartbreaking to see such majestic creatures reduced to entertainment for people.

@ Loretta Perrone Many zoos have large enclosures where the animals can roam freely and engage in natural behaviors

Yes!

Not only abused, but slaughtered. And for what? Jewelry and hokey medicine.

@@nancydemoss7904 and that makes me soooo mad I could scream!!....to waste beautiful, unique and highly endangered animals just for one part of their body!! AND very often useless part to humans!! I never even knew about pangolins before covid....I actually wept ...what a slaughter!! such beautiful, gentle, sweet animal...absolutely heart breaking...I donate to few orgs...as much as I can put away...wish I was filthy rich just so I could give it all away....

@@Nitka022 who sold these Elephants?

@@irenedavo3768 Not sure as they are not saying, but if you google, two females in a ZOO were born in Tanzania in 2007. So they are pretty young elles.

Thank God for vegans!

I am right there with you. I absolutely love elephants since I was a little girl. I love watching the channels on utube of Elephant sanctuaries where they finally get to live a great life with lots of love and care and lots of other relationships with other elephants. They are such beautiful animals.

they're not pets but animals with their own families that to be able to live where they belong. It wouldn't be fair if someone kept you as a pet away from your homeland either.

You can sponsor a baby elephant in Africa. I did that for my grandson one Christmas. They sent him photos etc. Same as you can do with zoo animals. A great way to educate children about animals

Copy that!

I agree!

I think the ladies should join kaavan ;)..

These ones are African elephants.

@UC9ZUdiEaEBC9UG8t8zOP95w Thank you for the information. I hadn't realised. I'm still learning. I hope Lek can help these other elephants ? I wish it wasn't an issue in the first place. If demand would cease, so would supply. 🙏💗

Time for veganism!

They have not been rescued. Karachi refuses to let them go. Moreover since this video was made Noor Jehan became seriously ill with multiple other issues and died in April 2023. To date and since Noor Jehan’s death Madhubala has remained alone at Karachi zoo, where she’s seen to be growing more mentally unwell by the day. There is ongoing campaign to reunite her with Malika and Sonu/Sonia at an improved facility at Karachi safari park that Four Paws have offered to help build. Karachi authorities have to date blocked this, in spite of Dr Amir Khalil attending a week long meeting with Karachi authorities in August 2023 to plan it. Verbal agreements have not been backed up by written guarantees and Four Paws cannot begin training to relocate Madhubala or work on the new site without guarantees, they are ready to assist as soon as the zoo and safari park officials/managers give them them a written guarantee. It’s a very sad situation for the elephants, particularly Madhubala. We carry on campaigning for them with local advocates and via social media on Facebook , X and other platforms.

No, they're scam artists that take your money even after you tell them to cancel their debit orders.

@@moonstryder1740 I don't have direct debit i donate thru paypal. So i don't have a problem with them

Dear Moon, thanks for your support! Please send us an email to office@four-paws.org with your details so we can take a look. Thank you for your cooperation! Best, the FOUR PAWS team

@@MrCharliefarlie123 ditto...use paypal for all my donations to few orgs..NEVER EVER any problems!!

Soon They Will Plz Pray For Them

@@nabeelsyedali9040 🙏.

@@nabeelsyedali9040 Pray to which 'god'?! So far it seems NO 'god' has been particularly interested in them.

Why did they leave Tanzania 🇹🇿

@@irenedavo3768 I can’t answer that about these elephants but in some cases they are sold on the black market for the money.

The public who goes to this zoo to amuse themselves at a poor elephant's expense are vile human beings.

There is an elephant sanctuary in middle Tennessee that is great. They have a big barn for them to shelter in bad weather and open fields to graze and roam. The sanctuary is truly for the well-being of the animals as they don't allow visitors anywhere near the elephants. One of the elephants killed a worker several years back and the lady's family asked that the elephant be spared. The elephant was from the circus and was philologically damaged from being mistreated there. There was an elephant that came from a zoo that was old and crippled . The zoo no longer wanted the elephant because it "looked too bad".When she got to the elephant barn she excitedly trumpeted and stirred up a ruckus and actually bent the bars. It turns out after they researched it, the elephant in the next enclosure was in a circus with her 30 years earlier. Both elephants were severely crippled and never leave each other's side.

@@beckyshell4649 This Tennessee sanctuary offered Lucy a place there years back, many influential animal advocates have spotlighted the terrible conditions Lucy has to endure, and here we are entering another winter with Lucy still in EVZ. The campaign to relocate her is strong and ongoing

We can all be guardian angels by going vegan.

Dear Roberta, thank you! Best, the FOUR PAWS team

we all can care if we go vegan.

​@@extropiantranshuman 100%

So amazing to find one male is really a female.

@@susannorman4476 -- please search KZfaq for video: "How to Distinguish Between Female and Male Elephants" The channel "HERD Elephant Orphanage South Africa" has many videos about the elephants they have rescued, from babies to mature adults :)

All elephants should be released from captivity and placed in free roam areas that are protected from poachers and other despicable characters. There are so few elephants left in the world. It's all so sad that my heart is broken.

I thought, "Wha-huh?? Did someone rip out the tusks a year ago and while the elephants were in that zoo and everyone is mumm??" I was not sure what was being said, exactly.

@@rhobot75 from what i heard in the video, the tusks got broken somehow. Not sure if the zookeepers did it or what happened. Regardless if it happened during the elephant's stay there its on the zookeepers for not helping her. Even if it happened before they got her its still on them for not noticing.

Yes! Bloody disgusting 🤢

I don’t believe they “broke”. Free these animals. I’m beyond sickened.

@@renaarmstrong2838 If you don't have any evidence, be careful what you say.

Correct, the zoo officials at Karachi local government declare that they don’t how come the tusks were missing in the first place though one appeared to have a straight edge indicating that it had been cut out. I can’t imagine how painful that was, nor how the elephants coped with the infections and resulting pain for so long. my Grandmother would never go to zoos or circuses, and I don’t either.

That was my first thought, too. They are broken off way too deeply, which makes me suspicious they were "broken" by some unnatural means (meaning: human). Animals in the wild do occasionally break a tusk while digging or pushing down trees, but that usually leaves a stub showing that grows to a tusk of size again.

I think so too. The tusks are ripped out.

Put your biased negative 'feelings' where they belong and deal with 'facts'.

@@nicoshaun1941 In the professional specialist's words, the tusks are BROKEN! But, I'm sure you know better, just by watching the video.

Commercial male cows and pigs are usually castrated.

Thanks should go to the people. The Lord had nothing to do with it.

All creatures great and small belong to God, humans have been charged with their care. They need to be treated with respect as such. Gen 1:25 And God went on to make the wild animals of the earth according to their kinds and the domestic animals according to their kinds and all the creeping animals of the ground according to their kinds. And God saw that it was good.

@@PLS.54 And later on God spent a long time giving detailed instructions on slaughtering and dismembering various animals to please him. Please leave God out of it.

@@pearlbonnie1369 You can’t leave God out of it if your talking about His creation or mandates. Instructions given *by God* for appropriate preparation of animal sacrifices that were burned on the altar, were a total offering *to God.* And as for eating meat, God said Genesis 9:3-4 - New Century Version (NCV) 3 “Everything that moves, everything that is alive, is yours for food. Earlier I gave you the green plants, but now I give you everything for food. 4 But you must not eat meat that still has blood in it, because blood gives life. I believe the commenter meant only as a form of expression, “thank God” to express their gratitude for Dr Khalil and others in helping the elephants.

@@PLS.54 You said that all animals should be treated with respect. You think slaughtering them and dismembering them and burning them is treating them with respect? I'm not talking about God's creation or mandates. I'm discussing the beliefs some people have about God.

Thank you so very much for your support!

No elephant should be killed by humans, unless absolutely necessary.

Thank you for your concern for the Karachi elephants and especially for Madhubala. Due to the elections at the end of June, there is now a new government in place that will ultimately decide on the future of the elephants in Karachi. We work tirelessly to convince the representatives in Karachi to enable all three elephants a life in a species-appropriate sanctuary with international standards. Please be assured that we are working towards this goal. We are not giving up on the Karachi elephants. We keep you updated as soon as there are new developments.