The thumbnail had me dying, great choice of words.

the medicine cat rule is so dumb because literally any of these kits could be kestrelflights or alder hearts and nobody would know it like only applies to the shecats

I saw the whole problem with Starclan and decided to make an oc where they are the villain. In this oc they intentionally send morally gray or good cats that made mistakes to the Dark Forest to fuel their control over the living cats by strictly enforcing the Warrior Code down to a tee. Buuuut some living cats are confused and angry when their old friend visits them from cat hell and says Starclan sent them there for no real reason and things go crazy from there. I also made lightning a symbol a Starclan cat’s presence to show that they’re using their power to intimidate the living into following their command (cuz lightning is scary and powerful).

Well yeah, in my opinion, i like traditional one more than lyrical because you can name your cat based on how they look like. For example, i have an oc which was brown solid cat with golden eyes. It took me for weeks to think for suffixes for lyrical name to match the personality. But for traditional, i just come with brownfur, woodpelt, tawnynose and smth like that.

hope you're doing okay!

I’m pretty sure that on the characters section of the Warriors website Tree’s photo in the short-haired one and Mothwing’s is the long-haired one. I think that’s where it comes from. Maybe they’ve changed it now.

where'd ya go?

i got here from trying to find the megaman version of sunstar

missing your videos 💔 hoping you come back someday, your videos are very watchable!

Ravenpaw: “ I - have feelings for you..” The authors : “ the feeling was friendship tho none had ever experienced it before “

As someone with epilepsy, I was happy to have a character that could show representation for me, but the holding down and the hinted at idea that Shadowsight was mentally ill because of his seizures and that his visions were fake BECAUSE of them rubbed me the wrong way… :(

"I learned more from Graystripe than any other cat" My brother in christ during your apprenticeship he was with SILVERSTREAM

i Have not seen ANYONE cover this arc and it took me FOREVER to find this video. i honestly loved this arc on a first read because i had just finished PoT, didnt know OotS was a thing (I was a young, autistic reader, like, 11, with no access to the internet), i came across the sun trail at a local library booksale, and i was honestly hooked, I loved gray wing as a protagonist absolutely HATED clear sky, (dawg literally acts like Brokenstar at some points and these books want us to LIKE HIM? HELLLLL NAH. ANYWAYS, putting together the whole canon into a timeline is something ive wanted to do for a while, and your video is DEFINITELY going to help, because as an adult reader, looking back at the books now, I could not stomach that particular arc anymore. GREAT VID! :)

I just noticed an error in your calculations that makes the dissonance between SkC and the main series even worse. The Apprentice’s Quest doesn't begin eighteen months after OotS, it begins eighteen months after _the Great Storm from Bramblestar's Storm._ I still have yet to read BSS, but I remember Brightheart's second litter being apprentices in the book when they were newborns in TLH, making it six moons. Lilyheart was made a warrior sometime late in this book, and I _think_ she's a month or two older than Dewnose, but don't quote me on that. Either way, adding BSS to the OotS-AVOS timeskip makes it around three years total.

9:55 written: Crookedstar Said: Longstar Probably meant: Tallstar

im surprised that whitestorm turned out the opposite of thistleclaw unlike tigerstar

I noticed too that I think either the first or second book in the broken code they removed him from having seizures. I wonder if they got backlash from how it was handled.

5:50 Tree got it from his connection with the Sisters, as the Sisters (group of she-cat (rogues?)) have this ability to see spirits walking in the real world

They’re such good friends that they adopted children and some kit even asked if they were mates and they both smiled

where can you find the audiobook you play in this video?

I can't hunt in wcue, only fish, so I always make my warrior half riverclan when I am not in riverclan (which isn't often, windclan and riverclan are the most popular it seems, and I just join the most populated server), and see where the drama goes. Riverclan hating cats, a war with riverclan, maybe a cat who's in love with a riverclan cat, exiled riverclan cats causing trouble (my last rp had this, the guy killed a dude, and my character was trying to not look super sus). It's good fun and I get to only hunt fish all the time because I can't get the dang land hunting to work. I also play the other two games religiously.

It would be way cooler if clear sky went to the DF. So the clan founders would be missing one when they give lives to new leaders

Warriors cats has the worst editors ever, never noticing mistakes

The old covers give so much nostalgia to me and now as im collecting the warriors book mainly the older covers (the only newer covers i collect are avos). Personally the older covers help me with cat anatomy.

let's make it an actual warrior cat's holydays! mark your calendars on July 14, 2024!!

not to be rude but you don't look very exp when playing wcue

I think it should be the characters who Repent of their sins in life go to StarClan, whereas, the unrepentant ones go the Place Of No Stars. Characters like Juniperclaw should've gone StarClan, BECAUSE he REPENTED as he died saving the kits.

I kinda miss the old StarClan...

good friends who are married ❤❤

I honestly can't see Sunfalls way of handling bluepaws grief as acceptable. He kind of just quilt tripped and implied that she is a bad person if she (a child) doesn't get sadness together. I don't remember him actually saying anything useful or kind after the first few sentences

Considering these cats have a relatively functional health system - and mostly seem to die of fighting (each other, ghosts, and/or other animals) except for the incredibly high greencough-related death count exclusively for minor characters between books - their life expectancy should probably exceed that of the average US American...

Jake and Tallstar: Hello Ravenpaw and Barley: WHY ARE YOU A CANNON SHIP AND NOT US 👹👹👹

I never really cared about Sparkpelt until I start to read River of Fire, when she decide to be suck toward SkyClan and be a bitch with Twigpaw just because she was confuses about what clan she belonged. I mean, I'm so frustrated seing how ThunderClan cats always acts sucks with kittypets, loners, half-borns and all, even that they got so many good things from cats like this. Like, they just close their eyes and pretend it's okay to be asshole with this kind of cats and forget that ThunderClan has a lot of kittypets roots. I was especially mad about how they reacted when Twigpaw decided to stay in ThunderClan for good. Like, there was so many cats that has "betrayed" and then come back and got accepted, but it was different with Twigpaw? Why? Because she was a SkyClan cat before? Bluestar, Graystripe, Ivypool, Hollyleaf and others have made mistakes that got forgiven by their clanmates (sometimes, really easily), but when its about "outsiders" they make a fuss and keep questioning loyalty anytime they can, while the others just look and say "uh, nothing wrong, deal with it". I mean, I just realized how ThunderClan (and the others clans too) can be really hypocrit . I don't know if I wrote something wrong, but anyway, sorry for the bad english btw.

My mother, when she was a child, had seizures and through that she learned how to deal with them. My dog had a seizure when I was young, and my mother told me to make sure they were in a safe environment, away from any spot they could fall from, and make sure they get water, and that the patient usually doesn’t know what’s happening, and its basically the brain restarting (she might have said more but considering it was so long ago I can’t remember everything.) She also told me about different kinds of seizures, and that the one my dog was having wasn’t that serious. I agree that how Warriors dealt with this was very irresponsible and, considering how they deal with other situations, shouldn’t be in the books. Unless they get their act together and correctly portray it. (Edit): If they are having a very bad seizure, then definitely take them to the ER

warrior cats minecraft servers is a niche i don't see people talk about often. the ones i've played on feature insane custom plug-ins that allow for complicated hunting and healing mechanics, level-based progression and skill unlocks, daily apprentice training, a huge map with borders you can claim and fight over, customizable cat morphs and so much more. you can focus on grinding and maximizing your character's skills and abilities or roleplay in chat/discord and take part in the extensive story the writers come up with. it's genuinely a great experience. the only thing to watch out for is the community, which consists of a lot of really young people and can get exhausting quickly. it is minecraft after all

Even in Greek tragedies that talk about the Fates never say that people are absolved from their crimes just because it is fate...

no words can describe how much i hate this arc. good video

Sunfall was an asshole as Bluefur’s mentor

why did they have to make star flower become “hi i dont have a personality anymore because i have children lolll”

Incase your curious I just rented the Ebook version of the guide from my library and the off colars are there so I don't think it was a printing error it was probably laziness and or some intern who was given his lunch break to get the colars dimmonds in order. And they didn't knoe anything about Warriors. Lol

I love greywing he's probably my favorite cat ever, I wish more people read these books :(

This was my comment on a different video but I think it makes sense here so I’ll copy paste it I hate thunderclan They’re main-characterd the entire series and I’m sick of it, ESPECIALLY the ones related to Firestar, like, he’s dead! We can move on! They break the code so much and yet are considered the most pure and just of the clans I read on kindle and highlight every sentence where thunderclan shows narcissism and self love. There’s a LOT. They have so many plain-out perfect hunters and fighters and leaders. Like Sparkpelt, who as Sparkpaw would just walk into a bush and be like ‘oh wow a mouse guess I’m just so LuCkY and sKiLlEd’ right in front of her obviously discouraged brother who has been mopey and emo after being demoted/promoted to med cat. Firestar. He has no flaws and is practically WORSHIPPED throughout the series. ‘All hail Firestar!’ They all say. ‘He’s so great!’ They all say. He’s also so dead! Thank you for reading my vent about why thunderclan should go rot in a pit bc they’re overused

I adore the original Wayne Mcloughlin art- it's just fitting. It just feels like warrior cats to me, even if the newer art looks more serious or 'cooler' etc. I just really like the original ones.

Is that Okami Reset in the background music?

I’m SO worried Ivypool is going to leave or step down from deputyship and that’s what her book is going to be about. It comes out three days before my birthday!

11:27 i dont think its just a printing error because the ebook has the fucked up colors too though maybe that doesn't count idk

The reason the art looks so offputting is because it's AI. It can't accurately represent the characters because the input image selection they have isn't diverse enough to do so, which is also why a lot of the images end up having weird dopplegangers. Because the AI used the same base image to form the details around. It can't accurately represent the disabilities because there are no/very few images that SHOW that disability, so the ai doesn't have a lot to work off of. The lighting is weird because the images used as input are mostly photography, but the prompts they use are made to look "epic" and the AI doesn't know how to make something look epic unless it's given enough inputs to get an idea of what that's *supposed* to look like

The new art style really looks AI-generated... The old art had its issues but it at least had a style and some charm. Even if the new depictions aren't AI, they're a serious downgrade

Maybe I’m misremembering, but didn’t Sunstar admit to Bluefur that he wasn’t going to appoint Thistleclaw as deputy, nor was he planning to at any point? I thought he did because I remember thinking, “Oh, good, something you could’ve mentioned to her YESTERDAY!!” Before she had to give up her kits I mean. Anyway, just wondering. Plus, Moonflower made the comment in StarClan when Mosskit died that maybe being appointed with new responsibilities would change Thistleclaw into a more responsible cat. They were arguing about Bluefur giving up her kits for the good of the clan.