Live Q&A I 8th of April 2022
1:03:47
2 жыл бұрын
Drives part 1 - Freud's Drive Theory
9:03
Psychoanalytic Book Recommendations
20:34
Bion 3. - A theory of thinking
7:21
3 жыл бұрын
Пікірлер
@charlottewu9056
@charlottewu9056 4 күн бұрын
Thank you!
@fran00953
@fran00953 17 күн бұрын
You are a good teacher. The story also points to the phantasies of the book "American Psycho" , a critique on an era that is in a way being repeated (cocaine culture). Ambivalence, or else internal conflict, lies at the heart of many illnesses and of why humans in general engage in war. There is a lot of envy too that may stem from an unsuccessful resolution of the Oedipus complex that is a fundamental source of conflict (penis and womb envy).
@user-wh5mr4tr8u
@user-wh5mr4tr8u 26 күн бұрын
So basically those European colonising Africa, usa and Australia was the crazy ones they kicked out 😂seems likely wonder if craziness is just higher IQ then average
@willieluncheonette5843
@willieluncheonette5843 Ай бұрын
". Psychoanalysis is a futile exercise because it changes nothing: it does not create a new man, it does not bring peace to you. In fact even the founders of psychoanalysis like Sigmund Freud were so much afraid of death that you cannot believe it. No normal being is so afraid of death. The founder of psychoanalysis was so afraid that even the word “death” was not to be pronounced in front of him - it was taboo. It was not to be talked about. Three times it had happened that somebody mentioned death and Sigmund Freud fell in a swoon, in a fit, became unconscious. He was so afraid of death that he avoided going to any cemetery, he avoided going to anybody who was dying, even a friend or disciple. Wherever there was anything concerning death he was absolutely panicked - and this man gives you psychoanalysis! His problems are not solved. He gets angry just like anybody else. He is jealous, more jealous than anybody else. He is greedy. He wants to monopolize, he wants to dominate people. He creates almost an empire of psychoanalysts around the world, but everybody has to repeat like parrots whatever he says. Anybody who says anything different is immediately expelled. It seems it is not science but a political party or a fanatic religion - not scientific research. And the same is true about Jung. Jung came to India to meet someone… because in the East people have been working on the mind for thousands of years. But they have never developed anything like psychoanalysis; they developed meditation - a totally different approach. What is the use of analyzing the rubbish of the mind? - sorting it out… it takes years. There are people who have been in psychoanalysis for fifteen years and they have reached nowhere. They have changed their psychoanalyst in the hope that perhaps somebody else will help, but they have not reached anywhere else. They cannot, because all that psychoanalysis does - all the schools, whether Adlerian or Jungian or Freudian - is to sort out the rubbish of your mind, interpret it according to their minds. And what is the point of it all? In the East we have not developed psychoanalysis, we have developed meditation. Meditation simply takes you away from the garbage, takes you beyond the garbage - it is not worth bothering about. And if you want to bother about it you can go on bothering for lives. You will not come to an end. But just being a witness to your mind, without doing anything to the mind - just being aloof, just seeing it as if thoughts are moving on a screen and simply watching it without any judgment of good and bad - a strange experience happens: thoughts slowly start disappearing. Soon a moment comes when there is only an empty screen - no thoughts. And when there is no object, no thought for your consciousness, it turns back upon itself because there is nothing preventing it; that is exactly the meaning of the word ‘object’ - it prevents, it objects. When there is no object the consciousness goes… and just as everything moves in circles in existence, consciousness also moves in a circle. It comes back upon its own source. And the meeting of the consciousness with its own source is the explosion of light, the greatest celebration that a man is capable of, the greatest orgasmic experience. And it is not something that happens and is finished. No, once it has happened, it continues. It remains with you. It becomes almost like your breathing. You live in it twenty-four hours a day. Jung had come to India in search of someone, to find out what the East has done to create so many people like Gautam Buddha - not one but hundreds who have gone beyond mind and all its troubles and problems, worries, anxieties. What is the secret? He was going to universities, meeting psychoanalysts, and everywhere he was told, “You are wasting your time. These people are not the right people. These people have gone to the West to learn psychoanalysis and they are teaching psychoanalysis in the universities. You have come to search and seek somebody who is absolutely untouched by the West. And there is a man.” And there was a man - Shri Raman Maharshi. Wherever Jung went - and he was there for three months - everywhere the same name was given to him. “Go to Arunachal in South India and meet this man who is uneducated, who knows nothing of psychoanalysis; he is the man the East has been able to produce. Just go and sit with him and talk with him and listen to him. If you have some questions, ask him.” But you will be surprised: Jung never went there. And later on, feeling that he will be criticized, Jung wrote, “I consideredly did not go to Raman Maharshi because the East has its own way, the West has its own way, and they should not be mixed” - just to protect himself from criticism. Then why did he go to India at all? He was told again and again to go to a man who was available, which is rare, and he did not go there, although he went up to Madras, from where it was only a two hour journey to Arunachal! Jung did not go to the man, whom just by meeting he would have seen how a clear man is, how a man is who has cleaned his mind completely - his eyes, his gestures, his words, his authority. He does not quote scriptures, he knows himself. Jung did not go there, and he himself felt guilty. To defend himself he started writing that the East and the West have different ways. This is nonsense, because man - whether in the East or in the West - is the same. And it is strange that he was teaching Eastern students Western psychology. He should have refused because this is mixing East and West. If he was really honest then he should have said, “You go back to the East.” He was teaching Eastern students Western psychology, but he was not ready to go to an Eastern meditator, just to meet him. What is the fear? The fear is that Jung is as normal a person as you are - just knowledgeable. He has gathered from books, but he has no authentic experience of his own. Western psychoanalysis is just a business. It is cheating people. It is simply exploiting people without any help, and because there is no other alternative people have to go to it. The psychoanalysts themselves go to other psychoanalysts. And psychoanalysts go mad more than any other profession! They commit suicide more than any other profession; they are more perverted in every way than any other profession."
@willieluncheonette5843
@willieluncheonette5843 Ай бұрын
" . Psychoanalysis is a futile exercise because it changes nothing: it does not create a new man, it does not bring peace to you. In fact even the founders of psychoanalysis like Sigmund Freud were so much afraid of death that you cannot believe it. No normal being is so afraid of death. The founder of psychoanalysis was so afraid that even the word “death” was not to be pronounced in front of him - it was taboo. It was not to be talked about. Three times it had happened that somebody mentioned death and Sigmund Freud fell in a swoon, in a fit, became unconscious. He was so afraid of death that he avoided going to any cemetery, he avoided going to anybody who was dying, even a friend or disciple. Wherever there was anything concerning death he was absolutely panicked - and this man gives you psychoanalysis! His problems are not solved. He gets angry just like anybody else. He is jealous, more jealous than anybody else. He is greedy. He wants to monopolize, he wants to dominate people. He creates almost an empire of psychoanalysts around the world, but everybody has to repeat like parrots whatever he says. Anybody who says anything different is immediately expelled. It seems it is not science but a political party or a fanatic religion - not scientific research. And the same is true about Jung. Jung came to India to meet someone… because in the East people have been working on the mind for thousands of years. But they have never developed anything like psychoanalysis; they developed meditation - a totally different approach. What is the use of analyzing the rubbish of the mind? - sorting it out… it takes years. There are people who have been in psychoanalysis for fifteen years and they have reached nowhere. They have changed their psychoanalyst in the hope that perhaps somebody else will help, but they have not reached anywhere else. They cannot, because all that psychoanalysis does - all the schools, whether Adlerian or Jungian or Freudian - is to sort out the rubbish of your mind, interpret it according to their minds. And what is the point of it all? In the East we have not developed psychoanalysis, we have developed meditation. Meditation simply takes you away from the garbage, takes you beyond the garbage - it is not worth bothering about. And if you want to bother about it you can go on bothering for lives. You will not come to an end. But just being a witness to your mind, without doing anything to the mind - just being aloof, just seeing it as if thoughts are moving on a screen and simply watching it without any judgment of good and bad - a strange experience happens: thoughts slowly start disappearing. Soon a moment comes when there is only an empty screen - no thoughts. And when there is no object, no thought for your consciousness, it turns back upon itself because there is nothing preventing it; that is exactly the meaning of the word ‘object’ - it prevents, it objects. When there is no object the consciousness goes… and just as everything moves in circles in existence, consciousness also moves in a circle. It comes back upon its own source. And the meeting of the consciousness with its own source is the explosion of light, the greatest celebration that a man is capable of, the greatest orgasmic experience. And it is not something that happens and is finished. No, once it has happened, it continues. It remains with you. It becomes almost like your breathing. You live in it twenty-four hours a day. Jung had come to India in search of someone, to find out what the East has done to create so many people like Gautam Buddha - not one but hundreds who have gone beyond mind and all its troubles and problems, worries, anxieties. What is the secret? He was going to universities, meeting psychoanalysts, and everywhere he was told, “You are wasting your time. These people are not the right people. These people have gone to the West to learn psychoanalysis and they are teaching psychoanalysis in the universities. You have come to search and seek somebody who is absolutely untouched by the West. And there is a man.” And there was a man - Shri Raman Maharshi. Wherever Jung went - and he was there for three months - everywhere the same name was given to him. “Go to Arunachal in South India and meet this man who is uneducated, who knows nothing of psychoanalysis; he is the man the East has been able to produce. Just go and sit with him and talk with him and listen to him. If you have some questions, ask him.” But you will be surprised: Jung never went there. And later on, feeling that he will be criticized, Jung wrote, “I consideredly did not go to Raman Maharshi because the East has its own way, the West has its own way, and they should not be mixed” - just to protect himself from criticism. Then why did he go to India at all? He was told again and again to go to a man who was available, which is rare, and he did not go there, although he went up to Madras, from where it was only a two hour journey to Arunachal! Jung did not go to the man, whom just by meeting he would have seen how a clear man is, how a man is who has cleaned his mind completely - his eyes, his gestures, his words, his authority. He does not quote scriptures, he knows himself. Jung did not go there, and he himself felt guilty. To defend himself he started writing that the East and the West have different ways. This is nonsense, because man - whether in the East or in the West - is the same. And it is strange that he was teaching Eastern students Western psychology. He should have refused because this is mixing East and West. If he was really honest then he should have said, “You go back to the East.” He was teaching Eastern students Western psychology, but he was not ready to go to an Eastern meditator, just to meet him. What is the fear? The fear is that Jung is as normal a person as you are - just knowledgeable. He has gathered from books, but he has no authentic experience of his own. Western psychoanalysis is just a business. It is cheating people. It is simply exploiting people without any help, and because there is no other alternative people have to go to it. The psychoanalysts themselves go to other psychoanalysts. And psychoanalysts go mad more than any other profession! They commit suicide more than any other profession; they are more perverted in every way than any other profession."
@JohnSWren
@JohnSWren Ай бұрын
Robert Langs?
@sizesmall1756
@sizesmall1756 Ай бұрын
So according to this theory, the child of a very caring and devoted mother would be more prone to becoming a narcissist, and the child of a neglectful mother would be more prone to developing empathy ?
@richardprice9730
@richardprice9730 Ай бұрын
Brilliant at last a glimmer of hope for psychoanalysis, a movement in a truly honest, open and potentially intimate encounter with lasting usefull insight it might bring. Yes also a bridge to other forms of psychotherapy, Rogerian, Group work much more useful to patients in the real world away from the couch.
@pablomedinadiaz1795
@pablomedinadiaz1795 Ай бұрын
Muchas gracias Nicolas ❣
@aytys013
@aytys013 Ай бұрын
Great video! Very stoked for the next video on the mirror stage!
@fneedler
@fneedler Ай бұрын
thank you for the directions
@mrsmrs1200
@mrsmrs1200 Ай бұрын
Odlično obradjena tema. Hvala
@freydel0411
@freydel0411 Ай бұрын
Perfect explanation, thanks ❤
@JD-td8kl
@JD-td8kl Ай бұрын
Please resurrect this channel!
@michaelkulyk
@michaelkulyk 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for this wonderful introduction.
@HMBJJ
@HMBJJ 2 ай бұрын
did he ever make a 3rd part?
@xxxdftkkhgdrujj
@xxxdftkkhgdrujj 2 ай бұрын
Freud the Idiot
@lrod20101
@lrod20101 2 ай бұрын
The information is so good but I will admit Im struggling with the English. My Father had a heavy accent and I still find it difficult to focus and follow. Too bad..
@user-tv3lq1ey9u
@user-tv3lq1ey9u 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for this excellent video.
@user-tv3lq1ey9u
@user-tv3lq1ey9u 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for your offering such an excellent presentation of this vast subject.
@doodleroberts
@doodleroberts 3 ай бұрын
I love this
@bellakrinkle9381
@bellakrinkle9381 3 ай бұрын
Is there a written test that evaluates delusional thinking? I believe that such a test with a rating score must be taken before a psychoanalyst accepts new patients or analysands. Those who have delusional thinking will not progress easily in psychoanalysis.
@bellakrinkle9381
@bellakrinkle9381 3 ай бұрын
I, personally, believe the death drive is superfluous.
@bellakrinkle9381
@bellakrinkle9381 3 ай бұрын
I've followed my dreams since my early twenties. They've helped me understand myself.
@bellakrinkle9381
@bellakrinkle9381 3 ай бұрын
This series is my favorite to watch on this important topic.
@RobWalker1
@RobWalker1 3 ай бұрын
hi! Is there a reason why you guys stopped uploading? I really enjoyed your work!
@endegenabekele9989
@endegenabekele9989 4 ай бұрын
Amazing
@bellakrinkle9381
@bellakrinkle9381 4 ай бұрын
This technique seems better than "free associating."
@luc4lvar3s30
@luc4lvar3s30 4 ай бұрын
Thank you for your teaching!
@michaelvenne9386
@michaelvenne9386 5 ай бұрын
Very strong video. You are breaking the curse that people put on it.
@poochini7272
@poochini7272 5 ай бұрын
This presenter is excellent. Learned a lot. Ty.
@adamcullen8777
@adamcullen8777 6 ай бұрын
He is so clear and relays the concepts so well. I always enjoy and learn from his videos. I wish there was information about how to not feel overwhelmed by the counter-transference or how to use it ethically (my grad program said not to talk about yourself, your feelings, etc..).
@ddee9612
@ddee9612 6 ай бұрын
Explained beautifully but we need more of it . More depth.
@unusualpond
@unusualpond 6 ай бұрын
Truly excellent. Thank you so much for this.
@drumdrum2012
@drumdrum2012 6 ай бұрын
Out of a lot of stuff on youtube around these of topics psychoanalytic therapy and theory, I find yours the most accessable and well explained, even the more complex themes. Thank you. Really helping me in my training.
@charlesamrhein1292
@charlesamrhein1292 6 ай бұрын
wow, I'm fairly familiar with sexual boundary violations in the history of our craft . but your presentation is unique, beyond what I imagined anyone would produce outside of a book. amazing and well done, this is a vital contribution to our history, thank you.
@jackwilliamatkins5602
@jackwilliamatkins5602 6 ай бұрын
Live with Jesus Christ $1000 pw
@jackwilliamatkins5602
@jackwilliamatkins5602 6 ай бұрын
Frivolous treatment
@chinmaybhat99
@chinmaybhat99 6 ай бұрын
This is so interesting! Couldn't find the second part. Would be very grateful if you can upload. Thanks
@charlesamrhein1292
@charlesamrhein1292 6 ай бұрын
OBG-13 -- he said that that is not relevant to psychoanalysis, but I think Peter would recognize the truth that, obstetrics and birth is very relevant to psychoanalysis.
@annenicholsonmbtp
@annenicholsonmbtp 6 ай бұрын
I would love to hear a conversation between you and Byung-Chul Han whom I believe is also in Berlin kzfaq.info/get/bejne/mLSbd8iGptbWlaM.htmlsi=X2eVSW-ZkSla8Yf9
@gmabreak2864
@gmabreak2864 6 ай бұрын
What about Dr. Edmund Bergler,s books ?
@iamaliveyoucantstopnow
@iamaliveyoucantstopnow 7 ай бұрын
🥱
@dipankarmallick5543
@dipankarmallick5543 7 ай бұрын
only patients dream...not the other beings...
@vudoomunkyfut
@vudoomunkyfut 7 ай бұрын
"The first scientific psychologically theory..." It is not. Perhaps, In the West or within what we now construct as modernity need be added.
@user-fk8rb8ue5h
@user-fk8rb8ue5h 8 ай бұрын
3 to 4 to 5 sessions a week. Talk about a moneymaking racket because that's all it is.
@hassegawamkt
@hassegawamkt 7 ай бұрын
I do one session a week and I love it
@slickerdrips1984
@slickerdrips1984 8 ай бұрын
Psychoanalysis has no scientific basis. Imagining how the psyche works and instantly believint it is not science. Doesn't matter how many books are written and how many followers it has, that doesn't make it more evidence based. Not only the basis of psychoanalysis are terribly biased when it comes to gender and culture and then generalized as rules, but it is well known that freud manipulated his narrative of his cases to fit into the nonesense that was his theory. No one really got cured from his interventions and his "analysis" was speculation over speculation. Any modern psychoanalysis is still developed and constructed on a basis of nothing, so still doesn't work.
@slickerdrips1984
@slickerdrips1984 8 ай бұрын
Real studies can't be done when the theory's constructs can not be operationalized and observed. Doing the therapy and then seeing how the patient feels after is not a randomized double blind control study, it is a survey. When your constructs are not observable, anything else in the environment or situation can be the thing working. Someone can just feel good that they talked to someone or that they had an insight. That's not the effectiveness of a treatment, nor the proof that a theory is solid.
@psychotherapyinschoolsltd9160
@psychotherapyinschoolsltd9160 9 ай бұрын
The location of Northfield Hospital was not London, but Birmingham.
@Ibisco-Lavier
@Ibisco-Lavier 9 ай бұрын
Lacan have nothing freudian and was kicked out by the psychoanalitic movement. Why he is still considered a psychoanalist?