melvin schrute I get it

alexbeginswitha and anakin hates sand

Re watch the intro you dingbat

Lrthy ya that’s why I said I get it

Not like here. Here everything is soft........... and smooth

rofl

Of course! If we age 1 year for every lap around the sun, if you're lapping 2 suns you age 2 years at a time. No, I'm not high...

@@veedriver then one year on tatooine would make me 2 years older but that's not true because tatooine spins slower then 'earth'

Dear god. How did you actually get this as your name? 😂

Hello there

I wouldn't say Obi-Wan owned r4. More of a loaner from the republic which he never really liked.

R4? Ah, yes! I remember him! He was a better friend and pilot than Anakin!

R4 wasn’t actually his in fact Obi Wan often scolded anakin for his attachment to droids

though r4 was built in to his jedi starfighter, so you can't really call him HIS droid

@@michaelbrocaglia3827 I certainly would not describe it as that. Obi-Wan never disliked R4; I always thought that Obi-Wan treated R4 very well. It's just that Obi-Wan never really had an attachment to droids. He viewed them as machines, evidenced by the line "Well if droids could think, there'd be none of us here, would there". It's a unique trait among the gearhead Skywalkers that they form such a bond with their droids.

The movies aren’t that far from each other and they already have interstellar travel. You want them to all have iPhones or something?

@@robxaviped yes but anachronism is anachronism. He has that point.

At least research some real history before you talking stupid things. Remember when in the WW2 the US military became worst in the end of the war than it was in the start of the war except of the nuke! Is this how it happened?

@@Zodroo_Tint honestly have no idea what you said bc your grammar is bad

@@williamchapa3541 ikr lmao

yes, but Anakin redeemed himself before he died. So how does that work?

And also, Jedi become one with the force, not sith. Anakin was a jedi, Vader was a sith.

Exactly

No it’s because when the ghost, A FORCE GHOST is there it’s when the guy was first part of light or dark side

@@aa1589 preach.

GONK. exe lmao

"No, you're my bro!" "Bro! :`)"

Maybe he was suffering from dementia...

Yes you are joke to him you were destroyed by dismantler droids

Oof...

It may seem like Darth Vader is going easy on Luke but his suit limits his movement and he has prosthetic hands and legs plus he can’t sleep

Jacob Reynolds yea for sure, but to adapt to the suit he combined all 7 forms of lightsaber style and made his own.

I always thought it was because luke had a stronger connection to the force because he is the chosen ones son. While vader was the chosen one when he became more machine than man and lost a lot of midochlorians because of it thus he had a weaker connection too the force. I also think it has do due to the fact luke has a stronger connection to the dark side than vader. Vader has gotten used to the dark side and has nothing to live for so he doesn't have as much anger luke on the other hand has a sister, rebellion and a future he wants to protect so his anger would be stronger than vader and allowing the dark side to boost Luke far more than vader.

Vader was totally playing around with Luke- watch Empire, Vader is beating him holding his Lightsaber IN ONE HAND- in Return of the Jedi, Luke has way more skill, Vader starts cocky, gets pushed to an equal duel, then Palpatine pushes Luke to tap into his Dark Side, where he goes Berserk on Vader- Luke doesn't even mean to chop off Vader's hand- he's just hacking away and Vader's grip slips- Pop goes the hand- Looking at his own hand, and remembering his vision on Dagobah, Luke realizes he almost fell to the Dark Side and refuses to fight any more

Vader was trying to capture Luke for sure. He wasn't trying to kill Luke -- and even then Vader freakin' destroys Luke in ESB.

He also knew the dark side force use to gain immortality. Perhaps he knew his days were numbered and was looking for his replacement since he knew his spirit would continue on...

@@Meatball2022 rosw would like to argue that his days was not numbered 😂😂😂😂

but they both knew they wanted to kill each other....

I always thought Palpatine planned to bring Luke over to the dark side by sacrificing himself to Luke. Palpatine tells Luke to strike him down and his journey to the dark side will be complete.

Shane Exley shut up you.., DINGBAT!

Rewatch the intro you... DINGBAT

re watch the intro you scruffy looking nerf herder

Rewatch the intro you... DINGBAT

Emilio Batres rewatch the intro you DINGBAT!

To be fair, Yoda played a role in instructing all of the Jedi. So it *is* true, from a certain point of view. ;)

Yeah...but "You will go to the Dagobah system. There you will learn from a short, green elf-looking but not really an elf, alien troll. He was a Jedi Master and sat on the Jedi Counsel, so he is good. Just a bit hard to understand at times, but roll with it anyway. Trust me." wouldn't have sounded too good coming from a force ghost.

That has bugged me for years. 😂

@@TheGodofSteel and qui gon died with obi wan as a padawan. Yoda might have completed obi wan's training after that

@@TheGodofSteel as always *from a certain point of view*

Truly evil

@@-Darkrie_- In my opinion, the Jedi are evil. Taking away little infants from their parents is one of the most evil things I can imagine

So now they have a huge attachment to their masters... or the kids of the same class... or do friends not count as "attachments"? Those Jedi rules are the stupidest idea ever and just make the Jedi look extremely dumb and bad. Like, instead of helping each other when something bad happens they just are like: no nothing bad happens because you have nothing good to begin with, problem solved

@@juan95194 I think attachment to their Master, Other Students, and the Jedi way is the ONLY attachment that they did want. They wanted new Jedi's to put the order above everything else, even their own lives.

@@juan95194 thats kinda the point the jedi order were kinda starting to lose their way

Not to mention he hates Tatoinne with a passion and likes to pretend it doesn’t exist

Because she is. She doesnt know shes adopted.

Then shouldn’t she say “what do you mean by real?” I’m not adopted (as far as I’m concerned) and if someone said “your real mother” to me I would be confused. Also according to the supplementary material (Both Legends and Disney) say her adopted mom died in the destruction of Alderaan, and Leia says the mom she remembered “died when she was very young”.

It was obvious from the way the seen played out in the original that they where talking about there real mother. That's the point of this video. You changed your conclusion once the prequels came out to fit the plot hole.

@@commonsenseaintsocommon2354 Actually no, the prequels didn't create the plothole. The Return of the Jedi did.

@@Guy-cb1oh No the prequels created the plot hole. The original story never said when there mother died. It's assumed during that conversation that there talking about there real mother. It wasn't till the prequels that we saw the mother die at birth. There for no one would be questioning this memory of her mother if the prequels where never made.

Genius hahahaha

But he did go back by request of the emperor to talk to Jabba and messed another village of sand people up, didn't sense his master or Luke

More like simpleton

the bear grills of lamp stores His hatred for the planet and people probably was more powerful than thinking about Obi-Wan.

Shut up dingbat

Excellent point!

Needed to read the comments before I blathered my opinion. I think you covered my every point I was about to make. Although the books aren't considered canon, there are several people Palpatine would have liked to recruit to sort of usurp Vader. Even Prince Xizor was being groomed in the background, not to mention, Palpatine had the Mara Jade card up his sleeve. It was only the holographic communique in ESB where Vader tempts Palpatine with the Son of Skywalker. You can almost hear the gears turning when Palpatine approves of Vader's choice not to destroy Luke, but to lure him. Vader has one thing in mind, but unbeknownst to him, Palpatine has something different altogether. Sorry so late a rejoinder to your original comment!

Rey: "You guys trained?"

Ma-Rey sue

For a girl that grew up on a desert planet ... she sure was a good swimmer. WTF !?!?

@@michaelminervini1908 I didn't even think about that. It seems like every day, people find something wrong with the sequels.

She had about the same training time because she trained in between tlj and tros

It's rough and gets everywhere.

and who wouldnt? its course and rough and gets everywhere

Lucas Allen not to mention Vader wouldn't want to go back to the planet on which his mother died

What about the rest of the empire also looking for obi wan

Lucas Allen Yeah, on the Death Star everything is smooth.

The design for it comes from the prequels,so it's technically a technology from the prequels,not the ot.

Unfortunately that is one plot hole that you primarily have to go to the expanded material to get filled. Really the only example I can think of in the films of something that seems to advance technologically (Other than the Death Star [which while conceived of during the Prequel Era took years to build and was the most technologically advanced piece of engineering in the galaxy when it was completed]) are starfighters' hyperdrives. In the OT all fighters aside from TIEs have built-in hyperdrives. In the prequels we see a major example of a fighter that does not in the Jedi Order's starfighters that had to use those hyperdrive rings. Other fighters that don't seem to have a hyperdrive are: most Droid fighters, V-Wings (given their similarity to TIEs) LAAT gunships, and possibly ARC-170s (I know we don't see them enter hyperspace in RotS but I can't remember for sure about TCW).

Colby Geslison To be fair, most of the prequels were set in the core worlds, while the Original Trilogy was set mostly in the outer rim, also The Clone Wars could’ve affected the technology.

@@aributera4905 Exactly a good example of that in real world would be East Germany after WW2 and how long it took them to rebuild and catch up. They didn't till the 80's

@@aaronscott4984 This excuse works for the rebels, but certainly not for the empire. It would mean that a star fleet belonging to a massive superpower, commanded by the right-hand man of the emperor, made do with tech from *two* generations ago to crush a rebellion. Sorry I just can't see that.

Idk hes like 45 in new hope

if you are in the sun hella you look older plus double the sun

That’s not even a real excuse

@@Armyjayden33 Actually he's about 10 years older, and iirc the actor was only 57 at the time of new hope.

@@edwardegan2304 so you're assuming time works the same on a planet with two suns. Obi wan was in his thirties during ROTS. Assuming ANH happened 20 years later, the ages match up

Plus they go from shades of blue to a blue tinted full-color image.

I think he refers to the quality in the Star Wars universe, not real life technology/quality

@@JansenGlasc But that is a real life quality, it doesn't really matter. That's like saying the lightsabers look better as a plot hole

For someone bitching about a film being inconsistent, he's being a bit inconsistent himself. 😂

This Dude Is Out Of His Damn Mind & Needs To Move On With His Bullshit. We ALLLL Know Why 4-6 Were Altogether A Step Up, Were Gorge & The Crew Supposed To Keep The 1970’s Look Of Space & If So They Did A Good Job Of That. When We Were Flying Around Space In Pop Cans With The Computing Power Of A iPhone 1 In Real Life. They Had To Spice It Up To Compete With WHAT THEY STARTED IN THE FIRST PLACE. Can’t Really Hate On That. Now The Last 3.........🚮The Mandalorian.📘🔥🎥💣🔐

Days

@@kianvandenakker126 years

@@DragonofRiva Decades

What sequels? *waves hand mysteriously* "These are not the movies you are looking for...."

The Prequels: anytime they're criticized, someone has to bring up the sequels.

eah and he let him cut off his hand for fun too

Well you see, Vader didn't really plan for Luke to go all berserk on him, and he was still conflicted emotionally. Anakin was starting to take over, while Vader was dying. Anakin could never kill his own son. You should read up on some of the lore, the movies dosen't really explain a whole lot.

Kenny Spillman did you see him in Rogue One? That's very small compared to what he did to most other people

The movie covers this imho already perfectly.

Episode VI made your first point crystal clear.

moronmonkey1 and men tend to age a lot in there 40s and obi wan was living on a desert and also tattooin has two suns

moronmonkey1 are you aware 53 and 57 are not the same number

The big W Yes I am aware 😂. But it’s four years off. Which is not that much. Especially when you make a movie 20 years later and try to match it up. A person is probably gonna look pretty similar at age 54 as they would at age 57.

The big W They were also trying to act like the plot hole was that as Ewan Mcgregor as Obi-Wan he was 20 years younger than he actually should be but it’s not that. It’s only four years

The big W 4 years fuckin apart stop nitpicking

Watch the intro you.... Dingbat jk srry

Um...no Return of the Jedi is set 1 year after the Empire Strikes Back.

@@jedijessic no

@@irishspudlad From Return of the Jedi From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia: Plot A year after Han Solo's capture,[a] C-3PO and R2-D2 are sent to crime lord Jabba the Hutt's palace on Tatooine in a trade bargain made by Luke Skywalker to rescue Han.

Jessic is correct. You probably just got the movies mixed up a bit. Between ANH and ESB is 3 years and between ESB and RTJ is 1 year. Or like 6 months or something but its a new year 3ABY to 4ABY

Dude you just shot plot holes in his plot holes 😂😂😂

Johan Giggleburg Thank you!!!! No one seems to grasp this simple and obvious concept!!

Because he never knew what he truly looked like underneath that suite! Good point.

I don't think for many fans, those who grew up with the Original Trilogy, dislike this so much is because it wasn't always Hayden Christensen, and so it just didn't need to be changed. Of course those who grew up with the prequels think this is fine because that's the Anakin they grew up knowing, but if you now went back and changed parts of the sequels to have characters that were in some yet unwritten movie to that, or inserted other unnecessary CGI scenes just because technology has moved on, then I think these fans would get pissed off with someone tampering with the movies they grew up loving. I think the other problem those that don't like the prequels, they're bearable, but not in any way classics, is that Hayden Christensen was such a bad actor, or at least given such a bad script that reminding us that this was him at a younger age. I don't buy that he was that way as a force ghost because it was before he turned to the dark side, that to me makes no sense. He was redeemed before his death and turned back towards the light at the end of Return of the Jedi and at that point would have become a force ghost, otherwise he'd have had to made the decision before he turned and that's not going to happen. Anyway that's mute, it was done on a whim to make the movie appear more attractive and tie the Original Trilogy to the Prequels, nothing more, nothing less, nothing to do with lore or anything else. It was done on a whim by Lucas.

@Anakin Skywalker George lucas in an interview after the last prequel

But clearly Anakin wouldn’t imagine himself as the same person who killed kids. Also how is Luke supposed to know who it is? Some people can’t just get over the fact that it is undeniably a dumb change.

It's "come here my little friend" but it still checks out.

Brandon Kelly Its not, you need to read one of the book about the movie since the O.T. was created before the prequels obviously so that was explained later in a book so make both trilogies connections smoother

Brandon Kelly Well not reading the book doesn’t affect your understanding of the movies all that much it just eases the connection between the O.T. And the *PREQUELS* ya see how they’re called *PREQUELS* meaning they’re movies made after but set at a time before their correlating movies, prequels made 30 years after the O.T. that wasn’t meant to be a trilogy in the first place, with a situation like that you kinda need extra media’s so explain and help smoothen the flow between them so what can you do??? I never read any of the books and I get the movies, just heard about obi wan saying that from a you tuber and it don’t really affect me just something to say “huh” about

moldy_underwear _ he literally says in the intro that books are not being considered

Brock Mulhearn if books were considered than almost none of the points made would be valid. They only say that so that they can put out a video and net views. If books were considered, which they should be then this video wouldn’t exist making their points null they’re changing the rules of canon to make a video that doesn’t need to be made

Still it doesn’t fit with old Yoda and Obi-Wan.

@@enriquemedina3631 they died as Jedis, Anakin’s Jedi self died when he became Vader. Therefore the ghosts show them as they died as Jedis

I think it makes more sense when you consider the prequel era. If the point of the old one is to be if Anakin hadn’t turned (the reason he aged badly being that he needed to use the dark side to keep himself alive due to his injuries) then he should not be looking like an old man because Anakin was only 45 when he died. It makes more sense to have him be younger because literally everyone that has known Anakin, would think of the young one. This extends to Anakin himself. When he was Vader, every time he looked back on his past or “Anakin”, it was his younger self. Only Luke saw Anakin as that old man but Luke isn’t that stupid to not figure out that the young man is his father.

@Anakin Skywalker Read my comment, it doesn’t make much sense when you consider the prequels. It made sense in the originals but it doesn’t make the much sense anymore after the prequels came out.

Ahaha

In one of the most terrible movies of the franchise

@@Dazzler825 The best movie in the franchise

@@thegoodreylo4749 YES

Alec L. Exactly! Palpatine wanted Luke to kill Vader. Also Anakin probably never heard of t he rule of two. Remember that in Episode 3, Anakin thinks that the Jedi are hiding things from him. Also Darth Sidious never mentioned the rule of two, only Yoda and Mace Windu did.

Alec L. Yeah, Even if you were just a casual fan who watched the original trilogy you would have picked that up, this guy seems to just be trying to find ways to hate on the prequels which realistically weren’t that bad, I’d kill for a prequel like production over this new Disney shit

Hoerry Sheeeit the prequels were amazing tbh. At least 2 and 3

Zeke Robinett the rule of two and what you stated are two completely different things. The rule of two is a sith rule established by Darth Bane that there must be two sith, a master and an apprentice. Doesn’t apply to the Jedi whatsoever so Anakin even with that, still wouldn’t have known what the hell it is. What the original commenter said is correct though

To be honest palatine, at least in the movies, never states he follows the rule of two. Only yoda and windu mention it, even in the movies there's palpatine, dooku and grievous. Maybe grievous doesn't count because of the lack of the force but still

And Vader openly talked to Luke about killing the emperor and ruling as father and son, anyway. So yeah, pretty much exactly as Peter said, they both planned to stick to the rule of 2 but they were both planning on replacing the other. But the thing is, that's ALWAYS how Sith have worked, there's always two but they're always trying to find better replacements because they're evil power-hungry sons of bitches, so it isn't a plot hole anyway.

Dooku was training ventress

Vader was training starkiller

Demmrir actually before darth bane’s establishment of rule of two there where thousands of sith

@@niilorantala9582 What? He means that they all used the rule of 2.

Nope - watch the prequels again. The Death Star began as a Geonosian design. The first Death Star's schematics are visible in the scenes on Geonosis in Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones showcasing the early development of the Death Star prototype, the Death Star plans were designed by Geonosians led by Archduke Poggle the Lesser, a member of the Confederacy of Independent Systems, and is shown early in construction at the end of Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith.

Eclipse is Legends

@@jacksporran7468 Its not a Geonosian design Sidious was planning it since then and they were talking about his plan. The Geonosians were not smart nor advanced enough to make the death star. The geonosians had nothing to do with it the CIS befriended the leader of them so they could hide a droid factory on Geonosis. All the technology is from the CIS

@mjkalasky That might have to do witgh the fact that there was a 16 year gap between both trilogies.

Exactly

Rip hand

thats me in pokemon

StevieD Rey won because kylo was shot

Korven007 _ yeah, Kylo could’ve wiped the floor with Rey if he didn’t get shot.

StevieD i know

well actually time is based on Coruscantian time and Coruscant has a very similar rotational and revolutionary pattern as here on Earth so one year on Coruscant is basically a year on Earth too. Also, in legends it was described all humans were based in Coruscant as their home planet and them all being the same species, but that is still not canon.

"Every line in the sequel trilgoy"

Daniel Lopez what

@@sheevpalps3846 every piece of dialogue in the sequel trilogy is cringier than that quote from aotc

Then why does he keep going there to meet jaba the hut?

Sedados ersancobon Ncoreasco

I just would like to point out, mustafar would be pretty traumatic for him, and its where he created his castle

@@MegaPuggz Mustafar serves as a conduit for the dark side So creating his castle there is perfect

@@sarveshnathan7559 im aware and I agree its perfect, my point was, op said tatooine had a lot of traumatic experiences so vader wouldnt wanna go back there.. But i disagree as trauma is pain and that is more power in the darkside

Idk it still seems sketchy because if he had a death star the first place I would think he would blow up is the place he hates.. for science of course. ;)

Well, Vader never had a Death Star. (And even if he would get one, it would have been highly unlikely, Kenobi would predict that. Furthermore: Would you destroy your beloved mothers grave without any need?)

Alresu true Vader may not have owned one so there is that but as far as his mother's burial site sith don't hold their parents in high regard being dark and all

You are thinking pretty one dimensional there. He is a person. With feelings and motives. With people here cares about (even when they are dead).

Alresu which would be true if he was only corrupt. He was sith which is why he was willing to kill his own son and daughter if luke hadn't changed his mind later on after defeating him mind you

AngryGoats555 Darth Vader has every reason to be afraid of sand. Anakin may have hated it, but Vader should fear it. I mean think about it, could you imagine how much sand blowing around in a sand storm would really mess with Darth Vader's breathing apparatus? LOL In fact anyone who knows that they are about to come face-to-face with Darth Vader, or is worried about the possibility of an encounter with Darth Vader, should just carry around a pocket full of sand and when Darth Vader comes at you blammo sand in the face! Choking and hacking commence, problem solved. Giving them time to get away.

+Master Oogway You just gave me the funniest image in my head of Obi wan doing that in a new hope!! 😂

POCKET SAND!

Pretty Alright he went back to kill his mother killers. and storm trooper.

Exactly! As Anakin Says Before The Super Secret Wedding To Padme: “I don’t like sand, it’s course and rough and irritating, and it gets everywhere”

but luke was like 20 when he wanted to start training... Anakin was 10 years old.. how is that too old ffs? Are the suppodsed to enter the jedi order right when heir mother pops them out?

@@meganoob12 the theory goes that a child at anakin's age would have time to form attachments which is a big no no for the jedi. They usually take in humanoid children under the age of 4 before permanent memories occur so that they don't remember their old families

Awesome self-contained demonstration.

Who's that fake account?

Gary The Stormtrooper That’s from the movies... 🤦‍♂️

@@viloinvictus thats from the movies

Did Steve say that?

Twice

@@betterlatethannever4529 well, 1.5

@@Skypost4ever well the second one was more advanced than the first so it can count?

@@marcodestefano7119 an unfinished car with an advanced engine is still unfinished. 1.5

@@Skypost4ever uh, right

I agree some of the acting/dialogue is shocking but action scenes are great

I like them, but between the different trilogies there are way to many holes, like why can Rey transfer vitality to safe the wierd snake and Kylo Ren, but Yoda and Obi Wan just thought well it doesn’t matter whether Padme lives or not. Same goes for Darth Vader and Luke in Episode 6 and Qui Gon and Obi Wan in Episode 1

Originals + prequels > sequels

Jar Jar Binks mainly. No idea what George Lucas was thinking with that stupid character.

yee same

Slayed with facts and logic

Then debunk them

Most of these do not matter to the plot, so there is little need to defend them in the first place, but the sequels actively tear apart the originals and themselves

@@lukecaulley2922 Bashing another thing doesn't make the thing you are talking about better

Kislay Parashar I know, but why does that matter, it doesn’t change what said

which is exactly what was descriebed in this video, but doesn't solve the problem at all. The point is that they are discussing the option to recruit luke in Empire, whilst both should know very well that they try to get rid of one another by doing so... Why would they simply discuss this openly? The moment Palpatine orders Vader to not kill Luke, but to rather bring him infront of him, Vader should know that Palpatine tries to kill him

profit. its an absolute win.

Such as

@@omegaink5635 Changing how hyper space works, how lightsabers work, how the force works, how gravity in space works, how logic works...shall i continue?

@@hessianproductions5051 yes please, but before you go more in depth I just one say something. What you just mentioned has nothing to do with how bad the plot holes were in the prequels. Such as Obi wan saying Yoda was his master (prequels: Qui Gon Jin), & Leia saying she remembers her mother (even though she dies, when Leia was born). This is detrimental to the lore of Star Wars, not petty things that don't matter in hindsight. I'm sorry for the long response, please continue!

@@omegaink5635 I was just pointing out the plot holes in the Sequels, cus what I gathered from your comment was that you were asking the person what plot holes were in the Sequels, and I delivered. Has nothing to do with prequels.

@@hessianproductions5051 The prequels had everything to do with his or her's comment. It was apart of the hold my beer meme. The prequels were always apart of the disscousion.

Adam Bernal yeah but that is just one thing and also in attack of the clones dooku says that they are building a super weapon which means the death star is in progress so they actually could have had the deathstar in the prequels

In attack of the clones count doku gets the plans from the geonosis. Also in the revenge of the sith palpatine looks at them.

@@bobjim1286 sure but the empire is technically in peace mode. They dont need a huge military force since they are fighting a few rebells

@@diadokhoi5722 The Sith desire more and more power and control, they're never happy with what they got. The Death Star gives them absolute control through fear. It doesn't have much of a practical use, because by completely obliterating a planet, you loose all the resources from it. But as some sort of a statement and a reminder whose in charge, it's pretty good.

Also, in regards to the battle droids, they're shown to be efficient in numbers, but woefully dumb & easily destroyed.

Yeah I like this explanation, plus he loses to Vader badly in his first fight

Leia knew nothing of her biological mother... she didnt even know Vader was her father yet, she was even kissing Luke so I think its safe to say she didnt know she was adopted. Even if she was talking about Padme then it's easily explained by force visions. The prequels literally introduced force visions.

Brushing aside how Luke knew she was adopted in the first place (a plot hole in the originals, mind you), Leila says all she can remember of her real mother is images & feelings which is easily explained since we know she can use the Force.

@@TheBravesfan30 Just because she didn't know WHO her bio family was doesn't mean she was unaware of her adoption to begin with. I wasn't suggesting she knew she was Vader's daughter/Luke's sister just that she knew she was adopted. Plenty of adoptees are aware they are adopted but not who their bio family is.

Yeah I’d say the Organa’s told her she was adopted but not from where

he is addicted to death sticks

Keep in mind Kenobi Luke Leia Han and Chewie are all HUMANOID not Human. Their life span is never stated in any canon, and Obi Wans age in EP3 is never once stated to be canon as well. To be honest all 8 of his plot holes are stupid and easy to explain especially the Kenobi not knowing R2 one, cause Kenobi says "I dont recall ever OWNING any droid." Which owning and knowing are completely different.

Erm no actually, they are specifically stated many times to specifically be human. Anikin even says he's the "only human" to compete in pod racing.

yep, they are humans, execpt of course, chewie

Rewatch the intro you dingbat

Bullshit

@Conor Brennan... You do be spittin straight fax tho.

I liked the prequels tho. I especially loved revenge of the sith. The sequels on the other hand...

@33dbz... me too, ROTS is pretty fucking great. About the Sequels, I don’t love em, I don’t hate em. But at the end of the day it’s still Star Wars and acceptable I guess... 🤷🏽‍♂️🤷🏽‍♂️🤷🏽‍♂️

IKR

Almost got a limb in her til kylo died?

But Vader had a clunky suit that slowed him down so it makes sense that Luke beat him

100 rare candies= Jedi master

how many regular newb jedi got 1on1 training with yoda? then the "potentially most powerful jedi ever" gets one of the greatest jedi masters ever to tutor him almost non stop for however long. of course hes going to improve greatly very fast. I dont think the Jedi used to prefer to start training Younglings at such a young age because the basic fighting training takes a long time, mostly its because they dont have too many preconceived or ingrained notions of how the universe works at that age so can be easily taught Jedi doctrine.

Did he use a Game Genie?

Luke Skywalker was carrying a Lucky Egg. 1 & 1/2 × experience per battle

single handledly blows up the death star, the amount of XP from that alone should have him sitting on like 10 levels.

Nicolas Miari from my point of view, the jedi are evil

Nicolas Miari he couldn’t recognize R2 from the high ground

Nicolas Miari he said he never remembered OWNING a droid. He didnt say he didnt know r2. And you guys call yourself fans

Matthew McKnight he was making a joke dumb ass

It's only a joke... from a certain point of view

Lucy Hartwell BUT BOTH OF THEM WOULD KNOW THAT THE OTHER WANTED TO KILL EACH OTHER!!!! That's a terrible work relationship

That's the point of the rule of two, they're suppoesed to hate each other because that makes them stronger in the dark side to the point where they were strong enough to defeat the Jedi.

They're Sith, of course they have a terrible work relationship

Your explanation We know (before the prequels) from EU that the Emperor had other apprentices, he doesn't respect the rule of two. I know this sort of breaks the 'don't bring EU into this' rule, but in the case it isn't retconning anything. There's also the possibility that the emperor was training prequel apprentices simultaneously - he was certainly grooming Anakin whilst Dooku was still his apprentice. Dooku's death is also an allusion to the Luke/Vader scene in ROTJ, which in turn backs up your original point.

Maybe his force ghost was young Anakin because that was the age he was last, truly, Anakin before being turned?

@Anakin Skywalker what's your theory?

@Anakin Skywalker FINALLY someone said it.

Anakin Skywalker your theory makes sense but shouldn’t Anakin still have his burn wounds? ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Anakin Skywalker I always understood it as a force ghost cannot age. I assumed a Jedi stays the age they were when they learned how to be a force ghost. So if anakin learned to project himself beyond death around R.o.t.S, then he would look like that

Vader planned to recruit Luke to the dark side and kill palpatine together, therefore the rule of two would still be in effect

Ya and when he finally bested him in combat Vader still really didnt want to win. He wanted to give in to Luke's beliefs that there was good left in him. He loved his son as much as he loved padre or more

In empire, vader was testing Luke, to see if he is truly ready to take Vader's place.

and ntm. by then. Luke had at least got some training from Yoda. rather than Rey. who didn't know jack.

GrandAdmiral Zod and that's why it makes no sense. Luke wouldn't turn on kilo bc he saw a vision. what a load of shit. even mark hamil says. Luke in the new star wars isn't the same Character as the luke from the trilogy.

@@Jspotstudieos I love how people still like to pretend that it's 100% in-character though.

Close. Vader actually hates everything about anakin and sees him as a completely different person. So anything reminding him of anakin pisses him off so much. Especially the planet he was a slave on and watched his mother die on while he couldn't do anything

Plus, Vader did not know about his children until he felt Luke's presence.

So good

LOL

😂😂😂 great point👍

Um, when? I've watched that film a thousand times and he NEVER said that

when?

Lethal Edits Never. This guy is totally tripping

MyName is Jeff in the comics

Lethal Edits comics

Lucas could have had them sync up a little better but overall it was fine.

Mara Butler ya, I mean some stuff he could have done better.

They aren't even holes

I think it's funny that he mentions in the beginning not to mention the books to fix his holes. But yet his holes have holes that are already filled by the logic of running the movie narrative.

Omg someone had to saw it! Some of his points are just flat out wrong too!

That works for every trilogy, but the Sequels are horrible and have insane plotholes.

@@BGOutOfService To be fair, this video was made when only the Force Awakens had come out.

Doesn’t change the fact that the prequels ruined the Star Wars franchise. The sequels didn’t do much to help it, but they’re definitely better overall.

My little friend obviously doesn't mean he actually "knew" him. Let's also not mention that R2 was never given a memory wipe meaning "he" should remember Obi Wan. Also like he said it doesn't count if it was explained in a book later on.

@@jackthegreek6092 except that's what it means. He knew R2 tor alot of his life.

@Brandon Kelly naive to what? Anakin owned R2 not Obi.

@Brandon Kelly he still said it.

@Brandon Kelly why would he have to? Up until this moment he didnt know his father was a pilot or a jedi. Luke's only father figure was his uncle and his uncle told him lies about his dad. Be weird to tell him right away this droid belonged to Vader before he changed...

Exactly, I dont know how people can argue this, so many examples of more advanced tech. The only difference in the ATAT is in design that we can see. Does higher centre of gravity (which seems like a bad idea) mean its less technologically advanced - how could we tell. Maybe it has a more advanced fuel cell. It sure is a lot bigger which in itself seems like an advancement.

He was too old because he was connected to his mother

I'm currently rewatching Avatar the Last Airbender, so that's fresh on my mind, but it's the exact same situation. In Avatar, Aang has less than a year to master all 4 elements (something that normally takes a lifetime), or else all will be lost. Similarly, Luke is able become a Jedi because he _has_ to, & even then, he's actually only able to beat Vader by using the dark side, & stands no chance against Palpatine, himself.

Yes Yoda does not beleive Luke is ready, but like prodigies in life that can achieve faster results than people that train for years, Luke is favoured i think.

@@SeraphimCramer Aang is the Avatar he has already mastered bending countless times in his past lifetimes

@@HereIsZane Also true, though he can't access the memories of his past lives most of the time, so he's basically starting from scratch in every life.

Yeah I thought the same thing. Wasn't the battle to see who was the worthy apprentice but then Vader kills his master instead.

But then why was vader complying when he showed no indication of wanting to kill the emperor but also wanted to recruit luke so that he didnt have to kill him? Rule of two means Vader knew either he or his son would have to die and he obviously wanted neither

@PattySpivotDoe There's a new force in the galaxy that both Palpatine and Vader can sense. They understand that there's a great force rising in the Jedi and the question is what to do about it. There are options so I'll lay them out. 1) Both Vader and Palpatine team up to fight this force. There's a risk that one of them will die in the battle. 2) Palpatine could decide his own fate by having Vader defeat Luke or Luke defeat Vader (only by diving into the dark side power) so that he can have an apprentice either way and remove the problem. 3) Vader can entice Luke to his side and then together they can defeat Palpatine from the dark side of the force. Vader will then be the master and Luke will be the apprentice. That way, he ensures that both he and Luke survive. The point is both Palpatine or Vader like to be control of situations. Palpatine more so as that's how his mind works. They want to be in control of every move and option 2 gives that control to Palpatine and option 3 gives that control to Vader. Option 1 is far too risky for both of them. If I were Palpatine, I'd have both Vader and Luke fight it out and then claim the inner as the apprentice. If you're Vader, killing Palpatine before turning Luke to the Dark Side is incredibly risky. Instead of having two of you against this great force, you essentially handicap your side. Vader has no idea if Luke will even turn. Vader needs to wait it out until he knows that Luke is on his side and then they can turn on Palpatine. There's so much politics and backstabbing going on that one can easily be confused but it does make sense for Vader to deal with the threat first.

Also in ESB Vader tells Luke that "together we will rule the galaxy as father and son", a clear indication in the movies of Vader's intentions with Luke. Not a plot hole, both Vader and Palpatine believe they are the stronger sith and want Luke as their apprentice. Palpatine as the master believes he can exploit Vader's status as the apprentice to entice Luke to where he wants him, and Vader plays along, waiting for his opportunity to flip the script and become the master himself.

@PattySpivotDoe Vader literally wanted his Son to join him and not palpatine. Maybe he was intent to get his son to join himself and not palpatine. (You know the whole Imperium strikes back-thing with "No, I am your father!". The actual plot hole for me would be vader defending palpatine when luke actually tries to kill him in the return of the jedi. If i recall correctly he blocks the lightsaber that luke swings at the emperor. But maybe vader knew at that point that Palpatine was still too strong for both of them.

Why did he want mustafar then, the place where he killed the love of his life and child

@@arghunqon3774 To show that he had no fear (even though he did).

Meewm33 no he did it because he wanted to meditate on his anger and hatred

Also anikan hates sand because it's course rough and it gets everywhere

@@arghunqon3774 If you already knew why did you ask? Kidding. You have a point and are probably right.

Also to be fair Luke never quite fought Vader at his full slaughter capacity.

exactly what I was thinking, it's not "training" that takes the time, it's indoctrination

@@zacharytomes5202 Vader could fight fine, he was just restrained and clouded by emotions just like episode 3, because he was fighting his own son and saw the same perspective that Ob1 had during that fight, that's why Vader "lost".

But the issue with the length of time training is what OT fanboys always bring up about Rey. Thing is Luke had very little training and Anakin had zero training but could pilot a podracer and then just a few days later pilot a ship in battle against the Trade Federation. Can't complain about Rey's training and not do the same about Luke's and Anakin's training without being a hypocrite

Brian Reed Some are just more naturally attuned to the force then others. Skywalkers and Rey fall into this.

Obi Wan was hiding with Luke and didn’t change his name very well (I think he credibly hid his being a former Jedi from everyone except Lars bc he tried to convince him to let him take Luke). But that doesn’t mean in the prequels they had to place ANAKIN on the same planet in what appears to be a similar location. I think it works fine still bc Anakin hates sand so he’d never go back lol. But seriously he hated tattooine.

when was that explained in the movies?

ctgstudios421 I always thought that too, and R2's memory was wiped at the end of episode 3.

Yeah, he says he doesn't remember owning a droid and the prequels never showed him owning a droid. Not an issue.

Ya, If you remember R2 was the one lying, saying he was owned by Obi-wan.

Let's be honest. This wasn't going to be the first time he spoke in half-truths in the series :/

Let's not forget, the man loved to drink.

Yes exactly. The rule of two stands. Vader knows he will be killed and replaced or will kill his son (obviously in the end he kills palpatine) and palpatine knows Luke will replace Vader should he kill his father. Palpatine immediately tried to kill Luke when he wouldnt kill vader so palpatine was prepared to play it both ways but didnt realise vader would jump in. It's not a pothole

He did in Episode 3 too he motivated Anakin to kill Doku.

“Now fulfill your destiny, take you’re father’s place at my side.” Palpatine Vader: “Together we can rule the Galaxy like father and son.” He can’t rule if he remains to be the pet of the Emperor. There is selfish motives from both because they know that whoever enters the fray with much power either can be destroyed.

Alec G is an actor. It's a movie people, older people play younger roles all the time. His actual age doesn't have to apply.

44 to 63 seems plausible

Mathias Edvardsen thank you

@@920utdoors9 yea but ep1 doesn't fit in

Stress is also a huge factor and remember Obi Wan was around 20 when he met Anakin. 14 or so years pass until the rise of the empire then 18 more years until Luke meets Obi Wan officially. Ive seen older looking 40 year olds let alone 50+

Cuythulu More importantly, why didn't Owen Lars remember him when he finished building him?

I don't know if you ever watched the Clone Wars so, but they really give you a sense that people don't care about the droids. They are just objects. Not to mention all the protocol droids out there. They easily could have thought it was another one and didn't care whether it was the one they built or not.

And they also all look like C3PO. Most of the protocol droids.

Yeah but the thing is that one should not have to read another book in order to fill a plothole. I go with what I see in the films, as far as I´m concerned of a plothole is not explained within the movie is still a plothole.

I think George Lucas wanted to give C-3PO an origin and he probably thought I´d be cool to have Anakyn building it, he was wrong.

precisely. i dont know why people dont even think.

Cobbsta yeah but it’s so illogical to take a risk like that.

B 1 where’s a better place? Considering tat is hated by Vader, where he buried his mother, was a slave, hates the environment, clearly stated it’s not in the republics control so likely not in empire control later and if we’re failing it for hiding in plain site let’s fail the ot for hiding in/on the garbage ya know plain site

Plus tatooine is the Planet where his mother died and where he spent his childhood as a slave. Last time Anakin was there, he was with padme and he slaughtered an entire village. I don’t think Vader would like to go to tatooine

Prequel apologists are so dumb. Think about it like this. If a terrorist was destroying cities all over the world, would you hide his son in his home town even if the terrorist was abused there as a child. No you would hide him in a random place he wouldn’t think to even go. The truth is Lucas probably didn’t know anakin would grow up on tattooine. He didn’t know Vader was Luke’s father until empire strikes back, and by then Luke had already lived there.