A Tell-Tale Sign of Safe People for Survivors of Narcissistic Parents

  Рет қаралды 31,772

Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods

Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods

Күн бұрын

In today's video I introduce and discuss a key to telling safe people apart from narcissistically abusive people. Safe people can take care of themselves even when others are not tending to them. This does not mean that safe people are super happy inside. It just means that they have the psychological strength to own their problems. They do not feel entitled that others solve them. In contrast, narcissistically abusive people feel empty and coerce others to keep them full. I will offer a way to find safe relationships that allow you to fill your own cup while the other fills theirs.
If you want to learn more about the most important aspects of what it’s like being a scapegoated child, why it wasn’t the scapegoat’s fault, and start your healing process today, check out the links below:
👉 FREE copy of my eBook, “Surviving Narcissistic Abuse as the Scapegoat” lp.jreidtherapy.com/optin?utm...
👉 A Map to Recovery From Narcissistic Abuse lp.jreidtherapy.com/narcissis...
👉 7 Self-Care Tools for Scapegoat Survivors of Narcissistic Abuse lp.jreidtherapy.com/webinar-r...

Пікірлер: 254
@TheOriginalXultar
@TheOriginalXultar 22 күн бұрын
As a child the only way I could get a moment’s peace was to isolate because my parents expected to see you moving and being productive at all times. They demanded obedience and compliance. The impact into adulthood is not being able to rest, and not knowing what my needs are. It’s devastating.
@TruthInspector
@TruthInspector 22 күн бұрын
same, but now i spoil myself. i say, if i had a husband who tduly loved me, would he let me do, buy, etc for myself. of course its always yes:) it helps to use to give yourself permission
@ahdiex7363sha
@ahdiex7363sha 21 күн бұрын
Wow same Constant movement,
@carminaburana9163
@carminaburana9163 18 күн бұрын
Don't !
@a.m.2239
@a.m.2239 17 күн бұрын
Correct. Because we not love ourself. We learned to love the others in a distorted way. With meditation we can heal. Taking out time and deeply breath.. In the most lovely surrounding we can built for us. Like a nest. This is when my soil starts rising.
@Scurvous
@Scurvous 17 күн бұрын
Same, but I eventually put religion/spirituality in place of the parent. I thought I had moved past the parent issue but took another 30 years to realize my image of God/Source was that of a demanding father that loved me but was never quite happy with my performance. My thought process: "I'm not sure what, but I must be doing SOMETHING very wrong or my life would be better." I basically created a replacement demanding oppressor in my own mind.
@marycrowley1442
@marycrowley1442 22 күн бұрын
Safe people seem to be interested in your opinions and experiences that are different than theirs. It shows acceptance and respect.
@abbasjoy4785
@abbasjoy4785 22 күн бұрын
Not all the time. Sometimes narcs are extremely interested in you, not because they care but because they're studying you, learning what makes you tick so they can plan their lives in yours
@annabelle1471
@annabelle1471 22 күн бұрын
abbas joy- exactly. some of the comments on here portray narcissists in one way. the fact is- prayer is the key and discernment to know what’s safe and what’s not
@muma6559
@muma6559 18 күн бұрын
It does show acceptance and respect and it is so beautiful
@muma6559
@muma6559 18 күн бұрын
though rare as hens teeth
@wayneherron2161
@wayneherron2161 12 күн бұрын
Yes, sometimes they listen for ways to trap you later on. Genuine people don't act like this. Usually though you can tell what they are about after a few interactions.
@ShirleyLaVerne
@ShirleyLaVerne 25 күн бұрын
I'm 58 years old. My father, older sister and exhusband are narcissists. Putting myself first makes me feel very vulnerable and like I'm walking into a trap. The only way I feel safe to do that is by living in isolation.
@ets5697
@ets5697 25 күн бұрын
I'm 43 and it's the same for me. My father, younger sister, and ex-wife are narcissists. I've been living in isolation for the first time for about 2 years now. Ironically during that time, I'm finding a kind of focus that I've rarely been able to maintain because of other people always being around. I'm able to concentrate on myself and what I need to do in my life without feeling guilt or shame, or worry or doubt or fear. I also - as you say - feel "safe" in a way I cannot ignore. I realize it's the first time, in many ways, that I've ever felt this feeling of simply being able to exist without some threat, punishment, criticism or pressure. In an ideal world, I would be able to share life with someone, but I also am seeing how safe I feel in isolation and how productive it has been for me, and it crosses my mind at times, that now that I've found this, I don't know that I'm willing to run of the risk of sacrificing or jeopardizing it for anyone.
@ShirleyLaVerne
@ShirleyLaVerne 25 күн бұрын
@@ets5697 Your description 'I feel safe in a way I can't ignore'. Is perfect. I know what you mean. I resent it when I have to engage with people in person. 'Safe' people seem to be a rarity and at this point in my life I'm not willing to give up the space I feel good in to seek them out.
@Dorythefish13
@Dorythefish13 24 күн бұрын
48 here - and same - father, ex-husband and sister :(
@peaceangel-rl2hf
@peaceangel-rl2hf 23 күн бұрын
Same - living in private isolation is ironically the ONLY way us survivors can live like a normal human being. It's hard to overcome distrust of others and find safe ppl when you escape in yr 40s and 50s
@Johannastairwellstudio
@Johannastairwellstudio 23 күн бұрын
I can relate to that
@kimberleyb4002
@kimberleyb4002 24 күн бұрын
I think what really strikes me about safe people is their ability to enjoy themselves in their life.
@kimberleyb4002
@kimberleyb4002 24 күн бұрын
Also, no negativity. Complaining, criticizing or comparing.
@alllifematters
@alllifematters 23 күн бұрын
Well and more freedom to be authentic, not having to mask so much. That's what I look forward to in my future safe relationships, what must it be like to feel completely yourself and feel accepted by those around me. What we all wish for
@Hippowdon121
@Hippowdon121 21 күн бұрын
I really don't think it's true that safe people are super happy, nor is it true that they have no negativity, no complaining, no criticising... In many many situations (consider, when you are the victim of narcissistic abuse) it is appropriate to not enjoy it, to see it negatively, to complain about it, to criticise the abusers.
@alisonmercer5946
@alisonmercer5946 14 күн бұрын
​@@Hippowdon121 THIS. I'm safe but I'm 😢
@alisonmercer5946
@alisonmercer5946 14 күн бұрын
​@@kimberleyb4002sounds like toxic positivity
@unapatton1978
@unapatton1978 22 күн бұрын
One small side note: narcissists are not empty. They are filled with dread. Empty would be less dangerous.
@sarahalderman3126
@sarahalderman3126 20 күн бұрын
Yes, they are quite literally the result of the same abuse.
@deborahfairbanks4012
@deborahfairbanks4012 21 күн бұрын
I always notice when people listen to me. I find that I isolate myself now more than ever. I feel that I have lost the ability to trust.
@a.m.2239
@a.m.2239 17 күн бұрын
Than you are in their game. If that happens the focus is on trying to please others, if we not feel competent about ourselves we not talk at all. So we isolte. The key is to notice the dussapearance of joy in us. Look out for what makes us happy and give it to us. Stop looking to find something worthy to give the other. So wrong. Life and do what you like 100 pro!
@JayBee-hk7ej
@JayBee-hk7ej 23 күн бұрын
As a child of two narcissistic parents, a shoutout to my gorgeous adult life friends who check all the boxes in safe relationships. I'm eternally grateful, thank you all.
@crshia
@crshia 24 күн бұрын
I found another point that was very helpful from Henry Cloud’s book on Safe People. Safe people don’t talk one-up to you but treat you as equals. I have also found a true indicator is to test whether that person allows you to have your own preferences, or if they need you to adhere to their choices/opinions.
@MeowNow494
@MeowNow494 22 күн бұрын
I appreciate you so much because I recently stopped dealing with a woman who got mad at me for not being the same religion as her, and looking back at her behaviors it’s pretty clear she’s got some narcissistic traits if not full-blown NPD. Thank you for pointing out that this is a common with them now I can watch for it ❤
@rl453
@rl453 21 күн бұрын
This (being ok with others having their own preferences) seems like a no brainer. But it was so ingrained into me since childhood that it took me well into my 60s to see how abnormal my family system was. Continuing to insist I must like the same music, TV shows etc as they do. When I finally moved physically to place where I felt joy and peace I was bombarded with “concern”. I’ve gone NC (without anger or malice) and things are FINALLY becoming clear. The peace is incredible.
@Peaceinmytime
@Peaceinmytime 25 күн бұрын
As a scapegoat, I was the person least capable of filling my parents up. Every other person had a bit of value to them in some way, but I had nothing acceptable to offer. So, I fulfilled their needs in that way, by being the designated loser.
@dreamscape405
@dreamscape405 25 күн бұрын
Same here ❤ I was so conditioned to be the "bad guy".
@REGjr
@REGjr 24 күн бұрын
Maybe, but even if that's true you became that way on their watch or as a result of inheriting their genetic material. It's more likely what you had to offer threatened to either expose or outshine them. One doesn't need to designate a loser (undermine competence) if he can find some way to take credit for it behind the child's back.
@kimberleyb4002
@kimberleyb4002 24 күн бұрын
❤️❤️❤️ sending you love ❤️ what a lie, remember they can’t really see you. They can only see what plays in their own mind. I hope you’re finding kindness and love for yourself. Through that a sense of who you are, and your inherent worth. I believe we are all made beautiful and miraculous beings. Don’t play their fake role for you!
@peaceangel-rl2hf
@peaceangel-rl2hf 23 күн бұрын
I experienced this too but you are not a loser in truth. This is their own projection of themselves onto you.. ThEY are mentally defective and immature losers
@Peaceinmytime
@Peaceinmytime 22 күн бұрын
@@dreamscape405I’m sorry that you also have experienced this. It is undeserved, and I hope you know that you are more deserving of compassion than you were led to believe.
@shashi3072
@shashi3072 25 күн бұрын
You can voice your opinion comfortably knowing they won't agree with you but won't get offended. With safe people their is solution oriented discussion. They are self development focussed so no bitching or talking about other's.
@joltjolt5060
@joltjolt5060 24 күн бұрын
Narcissist abuse "be useful or _______"
@Dorythefish13
@Dorythefish13 20 күн бұрын
Yeah, be useful and/or support my gradiosity - else you are nothing to nobody and deserve contempt
@foxiefair123
@foxiefair123 12 күн бұрын
Be gone.
@angelika87
@angelika87 20 күн бұрын
it was such a relief to learn healthy adults take care of themselves...anybody who regularly triggers those old guilt feelings is not a safe person.
@beachystarlovelife3869
@beachystarlovelife3869 24 күн бұрын
I gave up on having a good relationship with my two narcissistic parents. My role as the loser scapegoat was iron clad so I was wasting my time and energy. Now I am more discerning and choose to enjoy being with safe pleasant people. They ARE out there! I still experience some anxiety about what new friends think or if I am not fulfilling their expectations but happily this anxiety is being confirmed as unnecessary.
@firehorse9996
@firehorse9996 24 күн бұрын
It's so nice to read your positive comment. At some point we have to realize that by self-isolating and withdrawing from everything, the only people we're hurting are ourselves. Bessel Van Der Kolk, who, among others, says it's impossible to heal on our own and that it's only by finding connection with ourselves can we release the trauma.
@dreamscape405
@dreamscape405 25 күн бұрын
I have yet to find healthy people. There's a TON of people with very high narcissistic traits out here in the wild, and I'm finding it pointless to even go out anymore... .. Speaking about being social, and finding new, healthy friends. There needs to be a support group, with healthy people paired with us survivors, with the healthy people being vetted. I'm the scapegoat, only child, and had this belief even further cemented, due to my religious family...it was always about everyone else, except me. The more I served, the more praise I got, and my narcissist parents (both were), left me alone...but that was always short lived. Now, I'm happy my family estranged me in teenage years, and have been on my own ever since, and I'm 51. ❤
@lookupyourredemptiondrawsn7285
@lookupyourredemptiondrawsn7285 23 күн бұрын
Yes!!!!!
@HomeFrendsten
@HomeFrendsten 22 күн бұрын
Yes
@soniahathaway1
@soniahathaway1 22 күн бұрын
My family has been the same. Living in peace, just a few safe people.
@ArtemisSilverBow
@ArtemisSilverBow 21 күн бұрын
Healthy people being vetted and paired with survivors is called therapy. Otherwise you're simply using healthy people as a therapist. I survived a malignant narcissist mother and diagnosed sociopathic ex. It isn't our friends' or support group's job to act as our therapists; that's a lot of weight to place on them.
@raggaduxjones
@raggaduxjones 20 күн бұрын
@@ArtemisSilverBow I beg to differ. One cannot associate socially with their therapist. A safe person can just be someone to have fun with & not feel threatened by. They play very different roles, imo.
@a.m.2239
@a.m.2239 17 күн бұрын
1 very import NG marker of safe people is, that they always stand on your side. They can dedect immediately your hurt and injustice behavior of others towards you. They give you a hug, and offer their help as you need it. They are sensitive to your individual desires.
@bettyhappschatt3467
@bettyhappschatt3467 21 күн бұрын
This was the answerr to a question I have asked myself for 50+ years: Will something bad happen to others if I am me?
@DebbieLee-dr3hr
@DebbieLee-dr3hr 10 күн бұрын
Instead of the question Will something bad happen to me if I am me?
@sheilawilliams9080
@sheilawilliams9080 25 күн бұрын
My mother would say, "You would feel better about yourself if you put me first."
@jl3268
@jl3268 25 күн бұрын
So sorry, that is horrible!😢
@fionasmovies
@fionasmovies 25 күн бұрын
My mother accused me of being the cause of all her sorrow as well as her marital problems since I was little.
@yamlwoz
@yamlwoz 24 күн бұрын
Wow! I hope you're no contact now. What a despicable oxygen thief she is/was. So happy you can see her clearly 🥰
@sallyb4871
@sallyb4871 24 күн бұрын
OMG! 😮
@pebblebrookbooks4852
@pebblebrookbooks4852 24 күн бұрын
What, really?? Omg...
@daniellfourie
@daniellfourie 25 күн бұрын
I always need do double double check if someone wasn't hurt by my reactions. Even if it is completely normal to say what I want or need to do.
@streaming5332
@streaming5332 25 күн бұрын
How you know if they didn't like your comment... it only shows likes.
@medicscout3509
@medicscout3509 24 күн бұрын
Oh my God I never noticed I did this until you pointed this out. A lot of us are so conditioned to think there's something really bad/wrong with us, because of the people that were supposed to love and care for us. Sometimes it feels like a curse, a death sentence at birth that one is supposed to carry out, and often I've blamed myself because why on Earth would someone do something so horrible to another human being, the same as they are? It's baffling.
@sorelyanlie2784
@sorelyanlie2784 22 күн бұрын
Beautiful harp. Also a survivor of abuse, and your comment just caught my eye because of the harp in your pic. I’ve been binging harp content here on KZfaq (it’s been a dream since childhood to play one), I will give your channel a listen 😊
@sorelyanlie2784
@sorelyanlie2784 22 күн бұрын
Commenting again to ask, is that a welsh triple harp? I only just learned of them and I am seeing three rows of strings there.
@a.m.2239
@a.m.2239 17 күн бұрын
It doesn't matter if they like it. That question is such a scapegoat one. No offense. I know thus deeply ingrained fear of saying something wrong. Don't gibmve a f* what others think
@RawOlympia
@RawOlympia 23 күн бұрын
Love your dog. Was 'raised' by a narc who terrorized dad too. They ultimately kill thru vampirism. Your chan is deeply insightful and healing. KZfaq has become this well of wisdom.
@estrick4854
@estrick4854 23 күн бұрын
Jay, thank you for this excellent video! After reading the comments, I realize that so many of us are choosing isolation instead of exploring new realtionships. Some have lost decades of life to merely surviving narcissistic relationships and are now grieving that deeply. In an attempt to live fully and make the most of every bit of life remaining, we are not willing to gamble with our time. Isolation feels extremely safe. Although we know connection is important, we don't have the physical or emotional energy to risk it. Thank you for this information! It feels like I have guidance on how to begin. Many blessings to you and to everyone walking this path.
@bettyhappschatt3467
@bettyhappschatt3467 21 күн бұрын
Having a pet is one way to deal with it.
@vegasgirl3538
@vegasgirl3538 20 күн бұрын
You summed up my feelings perfectly. I grew up with an alcoholic father, narc mother and had a narc husband for fifteen years. I'm exhausted. I don't have the energy to meet new people and pray the cycle of abuse doesn't start all over again. The only safe zone is alone. I have a dog and that helps. I just wake up every day and try to make the best of things.
@Jaxmusicgal23
@Jaxmusicgal23 13 күн бұрын
I’m pretty extroverted… But my mirror relationship is so stressful and at times toxic- it is improving but the damage has been significant. I dont have the social energy sometimes to go do stuff cuz the toll my difficult marriage has had on me. Plus my hubby isolates and usually has close friends that validates him rather than challenges him and he doesnt like that in me… He wants to feel “comfortable”. I have learned while relaxation is important- lassie faire and laziness breeds bad things. We can rest and be content while growing and learning to be better. We can also be friends with people who are good for us and are safe but also challenge us in good, healthy ways to be better
@Sparrow0514
@Sparrow0514 12 күн бұрын
Maybe because being alone feels freeing to be oneself and one enjoys a rich interior life whereas being with others is what causes the feelings of isolation.
@engleharddinglefester4285
@engleharddinglefester4285 22 күн бұрын
My 12-step meetings are places where I can go where people are taking care of themselves.
@kathys754
@kathys754 25 күн бұрын
This is the best summary of my life. It now feels safe to me when my friends have lots of other friends! And they don’t love bomb me.
@annabelle1471
@annabelle1471 22 күн бұрын
just because someone has a lot of friends doesn’t mean their safe- some narcissists like a lot of attention. just be yourself and try to see who you can get along with....
@annabelle1471
@annabelle1471 22 күн бұрын
they* are safe^
@Jaxmusicgal23
@Jaxmusicgal23 13 күн бұрын
I’m learning that sometimes less is more… It’s harder to maintain a large group of friends and know who’s on your side who isn’t . It’s pretty easy to maintain a few friends , even if they don’t really know each other. You can really see who they are. There’s certain qualities that are needed to have a trusted friend … you are not gonna find that in a large group. Pay attention to larger groups of women: there is always the head chicken who tells everyone else what to do… they love having a large group of women around them for the influence and control. It’s pretty easy to pick that out. The harder time is in smaller groups of women where everyone is pretending to not want to control … you’ll find the women… usually in smaller groups. It’s passive control rather than overt boisterous control in a large group. The smaller group of women will try to convince you to put up with things you shouldn’t and will use their emotions and how they feel through their “heart “ what you should do. Real friends are honest with you in a loving way … they let you know when what you do is hurting them or bothering them. Real friends ask how you are doing… I realize I wasn’t a real friend for a long time because of my own problems and my own hurt… I didn’t care about others like I thought I did. That attracts bad people . Now that I am learning and healing from narcissistic parents and working through my part of what causes issue in my marriage and my husband either ignore or deal with his own issues- I’m not there to rescue him. He’s not here to rescue me… that is individual work. But since I have worked very hard on myself the past several years , I have much better friends and I’ve been to release those who seem unhealthy…. It doesn’t mean people don’t have problems or struggles … friends don’t gossip and destroy you behind your back; they care about you and they want to know how you’re doing but also talk about each other and get to know who you are not just what you are to them. Remember, even bad friends will be there for you if they want to feel good about themselves … can you show up on the doorstep at the moment. Are they there for you when no one else notices? Your friends don’t care about getting credit for things they’re just there and they want you not what you can do for them
@YouilAushana
@YouilAushana 23 күн бұрын
0:55 - this cost me everything!!. Instead of abandoning the stupid bastards.
@alwaysyouramanda
@alwaysyouramanda 22 күн бұрын
She was a single mother who, if wasn’t watching television while laying across the entire couch, cried loudly at night in the dark and told Amanda “your dad doesn’t love us”
@sarahalderman3126
@sarahalderman3126 20 күн бұрын
Sounds like she grew up with a narcissistic parent.
@Hippowdon121
@Hippowdon121 21 күн бұрын
I have joined a kendo (martial arts) class and just over a couple of months now, I'm finding that there are some people there who I feel are safe people and who I want to become closer friends with. On the other hand, there are also some clearly unsafe people, and I find myself not needing to look after or tolerate them, I just don't really care about them that much, and definitely don't want to spend more time around them or get closer. I look forward to seeing the safe ones again each week and to talking to them and getting to know them. I think one of the signs of safe people, is that, you tend to feel better about yourself after your interactions with them. Even if you didn't discuss something personal. I think this is because scapegoat survivors have a basic strength and feel good about ourselves, and if we interact with a safe person and can be natural and not have to restrict ourselves or look after the other person, then those natural feelings can come more to the forefront of our conscious experience. By contrast, with an unsafe person you might feel a more unnatural rush during the interaction, but are left feeling more drained, stressed, out of your body, or disoriented, afterwards.
@IMHip2
@IMHip2 20 күн бұрын
This is perfect ❤
@chiconapeacefulpath
@chiconapeacefulpath 20 күн бұрын
Thank you Jay! I'm adopted, which has made all of this worse. I already wasn't wanted and then the lady who picked me up has been trying to destroy my life ever since. I'm 44. My adoptive father divorced her when i was one...one year after the adoption. I would be unalive if he hadn't been in the picture. He passed in 2007 and as you can imagine, i became even better prey for her because i lost my safe person. I'm finally close to no contact with her. My God, i honestly just thought i couldn't do good enough for these people but at some point, God removed the fog and oh my! Well, i finally stopped drinking and now God is moving mountains. It's kinda scary. I don't trust another human anymore otherwise i would seek professional help. That's why i am extra grateful for you Jay!
@wg8517
@wg8517 20 күн бұрын
It is correct that narcissistic parents live from the outside in. My parents were superficial and shallow. And, yes, my mother tried to use me as a tool to make her feel good about herself. But I was a kid. I didn't understand what was going on. Yes, my mother thought she owned me.
@angelbulldog4934
@angelbulldog4934 20 күн бұрын
It took decades and many learning experiences to teach me this, but I am in no way responsible for what others think or how they react. If somebody gets upset over just words, they have a lack of EQ, which isnt taught. I learned to control my thoughts, emotions, and my speech. Others can do the same. Sigma empaths have strong boundaries. Mine came mostly from a narc mom. I now don't regret the past and the abuse. It has all conspired to make me the woman I am today, and I finally like and love myself. Sweet spot!
@Sparrow0514
@Sparrow0514 12 күн бұрын
Anybody else see it?
@user-du7ht7vi5w
@user-du7ht7vi5w 4 күн бұрын
Can you explain what a sigma empath is?
@aquariusstar7248
@aquariusstar7248 25 күн бұрын
I'm that person who was putting my needs last and fulfilling the role of making others happy, particularly men...although it was my caregiver of the same sex who required it. Navigating new waters now trying not to unconsciously take care of men's needs over my own and get entangled in affairs that blow up in disaster because of this pattern
@suediyg5595
@suediyg5595 21 күн бұрын
It's why I finally realized that it isn't worth pursuing another relationship, both due to my age, & how much of my life I want to live on my own terms. Every ex sabotaged my pursuing my own dreams. Today, I put all my energy into my SoulFam members, as well as working on my creative legacy
@jennw6809
@jennw6809 21 күн бұрын
I love the list -- you're right that it's just a handful of signs, but they are great ones. I couldn't help noticing that in your fictionalized example, the narcissistic father was a psychologist. I think that the mental health field actually attracts people with narcissistic personality styles. Thanks for being one of the good ones, Jay.
@deathuponusalll
@deathuponusalll 25 күн бұрын
Thank you Mr. Reid, I feel that for the lucky ones that grew up in healthy homes know all this intuitively but for us with these type of parents it helps to have these written down so that we can look back on, reflect and see where it’s healthy to be at and what to avoid.
@cel2651
@cel2651 25 күн бұрын
Thank you so much Dr Jay! I really appreciate your messages. This one in particular is really important. Often we’re drawn towards the familiar rather than what’s healthy
@yamlwoz
@yamlwoz 24 күн бұрын
Dear Jay, your videos have honestly changed my life. I feel free and happy. I often listen to the videos twice because my mind goes off at relevant thought tangents. You always hit so many truth spots that I need to think through. Thank you for the amazing, generous and insightful person you are ❤
@lapislazuliphoenix
@lapislazuliphoenix 19 күн бұрын
My mind does that too! So I then wonder what important things I missed, rewind, rewind! Sometimes I also wonder if something is too hard for me at that time to handle and so my mind zones off in a different way to a safer space for a while. Then I bring myself back and go, "Hey what was I thinking about that for"?, That's not what this video is about! Tangents have pros and cons, don't they? 🙂
@Sparrow0514
@Sparrow0514 12 күн бұрын
That’s a beautiful expression; agree with you!
@cosmicalchemist8219
@cosmicalchemist8219 21 күн бұрын
I’m neurodivergent & totally thought you meant an actual cup, like they don’t expect people to wait on them. 😂😂😂 especially after seeing the cup in the thumbnail
@jellyroll2102
@jellyroll2102 6 сағат бұрын
Safe people are open-minded, self-assured, and have an excellent sense of humor. They are always searching for ways to connect which of course means showing respect for other points of view.
@Goethe2andFro
@Goethe2andFro 25 күн бұрын
So helpful, thank you! Yes, those types of relationships have been so exhausting. Sadly, it's all I know so I avoid ALL relationships. Logically, I know they're not supposed to be like that. I've been isolating until I find a better way. I'll look into imaginary crimes.
@Lionshare333
@Lionshare333 25 күн бұрын
“I don’t want you to worry about me” then proceed to be miserable when I said ok and left. - mom It’s taken years to decode but I have made progress I think this next relationship will be an indicator if I have healed. I went through a lot of toxic codependency
@Sparrow0514
@Sparrow0514 12 күн бұрын
You may want to pause; thinking that a ‘next relationship’ has the answer to tell you something about yourself sounds unhealthy to me.
@Lionshare333
@Lionshare333 12 күн бұрын
@@Sparrow0514 relationships are the best teachers i think you may have misunderstood my intentions, i have been single for almost 3 years.
@keke7216
@keke7216 25 күн бұрын
Jay, you hit the nail on the head...AGAIN
@lovesings2us
@lovesings2us 25 күн бұрын
Thank you, Jay! This video was definitely helpful to me. I'm hoping to grow a few more healthy friendships. The challenge is - I've gotten sucked in by covert and overt narcissists so many times, in my family and beyond, that I find it pretty challenging to risk making new friendships. But the good news is - I find as I heal past trauma in therapy that I tend to gravitate more toward people who are kind. I mean people with honest kindness who don't spend large amounts of time talking behind other peoples' backs about how bad those other people are. I feel safer and have more fun with people who basically enjoy and value themselves and others, who know that the inevitable storms in life aren't the total picture.
@CastleHassall
@CastleHassall 21 күн бұрын
to be fair most victims of abuse have a deep need people for people to show love to "fill up" their need to feel loved but that is due to the hurt they feel but they are not toxic, just need loved due to chronic lack of love for most (or all) of their lives just because someone needs people to show love does NOT Make them abusive!!!
@conscientiousobjector9555
@conscientiousobjector9555 15 күн бұрын
It was so devastating when my mother told me as a teenager "I know you better than you know yourself". As if anything I ever did or was could only exist through the lens in which she saw it. When I got divorced, I was told "what have you now? nothing. who are you now? no-one". Like I was passed on from one narc to another. When I bought a nice home, she said I only did it to make my brother feel bad. When my kids got into ivy leagues, I only made them do it to "make myself feel good". I had to go no contact. The only thing is my kids still want to see her. I have to go with them because it's so destructive and I won't expose them to it alone. I always come away shattered.
@DebbieLee-dr3hr
@DebbieLee-dr3hr 10 күн бұрын
Thank you for being there for your children. I will no longer put myself in the company of my elderly parents. My son and daughter are grown, and I trust they can hold up to alone time. But, I find myself doing less and less in regards to my mother, especially her. I will never supply her with anything except silence.
@eenzaakvanliefde1969
@eenzaakvanliefde1969 15 күн бұрын
Yes.... Yes.... and Yes. Need to heal from this.
@TruthInspector
@TruthInspector 22 күн бұрын
good thing i like me, thats all i got now
@deborahfairbanks4012
@deborahfairbanks4012 21 күн бұрын
👊
@imsunnybaby
@imsunnybaby 11 күн бұрын
"their life is lived from the outside in" my face did a weird unconscious flinch of pain down the left side of my cheek +mouth
@sbpriesthood
@sbpriesthood 23 күн бұрын
that story about claire reminds me of a person who influenced me to expect more from my parents by how she operated. God bless her. I messed up with her, I miss her.
@mysticsuzi
@mysticsuzi 25 күн бұрын
augh. When I hear my story on this channel, I just cringe. I am not in a relationship until I feel like I know who I am and what I need. This is all new to me and feels weird but I will get used to it.
@PHJoy
@PHJoy 21 күн бұрын
For my vision board, I took notes of the 5 signs of a safe relationship AND paraphrased what made Claire such a good/safe friend. Thank you for helping me articulate this. It truly resonates!
@carmenl163
@carmenl163 5 сағат бұрын
I'm 58 and I never had a safe person in my entire childhood. Right now I am living in isolation, doing IFS therapy on my own and finally connecting to my inner child parts that are so traumatized. I'll connect with myself first.
@ekkamailax
@ekkamailax 19 күн бұрын
If a stranger broke into your house and abused your kids, you would get revenge by calling the cops, arresting the abuser, and punishing them with jail time. The public will worship you for your bravery and commitment to getting justice. So explain this to me - if your parents abuse you, and you get revenge, why is that considered "bad."? Why are you gaslit with stuff like "getting revenge just makes things worse for your, learn to let go and forgive." Again let's go back to the strange breaking into your home and abusing your kids. What if I told you "hey Jay, don't call the cops, dont try to get this person thrown in jail, that will just make things worse for you. learn to forgive"
@matthewwakeling4978
@matthewwakeling4978 25 күн бұрын
Yeah, my soon to be ex wife was always getting me to fill her cup. About 8 cups of tea a day, I reckon. Seriously, I *know* she could comprehend how the kettle worked, because she made her own tea before we met, but it always had to be me doing it. I don't even drink the stuff.
@aceofplymouth
@aceofplymouth 21 күн бұрын
This is pretty good. I'm now 30, living my life in opposition to my NP and the resulting trauma "Granted" by them.
@mediacreations5996
@mediacreations5996 25 күн бұрын
I asked a wise person once how do you know whether to keep giving money to someone in need, and I was told to watch the person once the money is handed over to see how they are managing it, also does this person keep coming back and asking for money all the time or are they finding ways and means to use whatever talents they may have to generate new income. This was something I experienced with a cousin who kept asking for help,but the underlying issue was that he preferred not to work and live off others. Definitely not a safe cup to be filling anymore. Thanks Jay 🙏Another in-depth and helpful video🎞📹Hope you and Brizo 🦴🐾🦴🐾have a lovely ⛵️weekend further✨🌈💫
@kristahackleylmt2064
@kristahackleylmt2064 22 күн бұрын
My x has 6 Aunts and plenty of cousins. He knows he can take advantage of them, live off them .. and smirks and brags about it. He's pathetic and will get caught in his true crimes.
@mediacreations5996
@mediacreations5996 22 күн бұрын
@@kristahackleylmt2064 👍
@sheilawilliams9080
@sheilawilliams9080 25 күн бұрын
Its also compounded when a sibling is disabled.
@somuch4allrightsreserved
@somuch4allrightsreserved 20 күн бұрын
that is so true
@yamlwoz
@yamlwoz 24 күн бұрын
I'm so close to being healed from my covert narc mother at last. I'm 68. It's been a very long, hard road. My only remaining problem is that when I'm looking her in the face, I can't bring myself to be truthful. I've never told her thst she's abused me, I just keep my silence and endure. I just can't hurt her in any way. Weird!
@jenster29
@jenster29 23 күн бұрын
Because you feel responsible for how she feels.
@yamlwoz
@yamlwoz 23 күн бұрын
@@jenster29 thank you for seeing this. You're right. I've spent my whole life trying to control everything around her so she won't get angry. It's a seething malevolence, and terrifying.
@TurtleHillTx
@TurtleHillTx 23 күн бұрын
Maybe it's because you know ....2 wrongs don't make it right. In other words, you aren't paying evil for evil!
@yamlwoz
@yamlwoz 22 күн бұрын
@@TurtleHillTx I definitely don't want to be evil. I would like to be able to protect myself though. Tell her that her words hurt me.
@marycrowley1442
@marycrowley1442 22 күн бұрын
You are a compassionate person. Good for you!
@dianeshoemaker6591
@dianeshoemaker6591 19 күн бұрын
I am just learning what safe even means. I thought all my friends were safe, but their behavior doesn’t match up with the qualities you describe here and elsewhere. I’m grateful you are listing these traits of safety so now I know what to look for. Better late than never at 51. Even though I am not a narcissist, I grew up with 3 of them and never learned what safe behavior was, so I believe I haven’t been a safe person either. Codependency is not safe, nor is being overly empathetic. I have been forced into isolation due to complex chronic illness and I don’t like it; yet it has given me the needed time to learn as well as develop a new way of relating to myself in safer ways. I have been brutally abusive towards myself - inner critic on steroids! But listening to Jay’s and others videos is helping me become more tolerant and sometimes genuinely compassionate towards myself. I would not have chosen isolation, but I have eked out goodness from it. Hopefully if/when I am better and can meet new people I will have a radar and criteria and be looking for qualities of safety I never previously thought of. If you would have me then that was the only requirement for friendship or relationship because I was so shame based.
@meowmeow1stgen668
@meowmeow1stgen668 21 күн бұрын
I like your channel because you’re really the only person I’ve heard talk about how to find safe people in recovery
@kforest2745
@kforest2745 19 күн бұрын
That’s right they’re self-content because they’re independent they fill their own cups self-reliance is innate they don’t have to feel victim they don’t have to feel insecure their strengths are the total opposite
@jenofthejungle3023
@jenofthejungle3023 21 күн бұрын
This seems more like what happens with a child of a borderline personality, not a narcissist.
@Fonn-ig1hc
@Fonn-ig1hc 9 күн бұрын
I have always put my happiness first, 😊😊mumzie expected too much from me. When I became a parent I never required my kids to fill me up like that. I was tough as nails when I was one ys old, when I saw a woman who can't take care of herself or me. I'm grateful I forged ahead and played my music , never stopping . My anger turned to the arts to soothe me . 😊 My animals teach me what true love is.❤
@happiknits
@happiknits 23 күн бұрын
Experiencing a conflict AND an attuned mutual repair attempt. I have a hard time navigating friendship as I believe I am a magnet for narcissistic relationships. Boundaries and workability are areas I work on balancing.
@HideYourKarmaChameleon
@HideYourKarmaChameleon 23 күн бұрын
I especially love this post because oftentimes people aren’t aware that they are born into roles that the parent, siblings, and the entire family assign. It’s best to find the safe people around us and know that being around safe and unsafe people look, feel, and be like. Thanks for another insightful video! 💜
@tq9vq
@tq9vq 25 күн бұрын
Thankyou so much for your videos❤️ I feel so validated when it comes to my experiences, and I get so many new insights !!! Life changing stuff !
@eyeonrecovery8319
@eyeonrecovery8319 24 күн бұрын
Great video Jay!
@user-uh5tb9er4o
@user-uh5tb9er4o 23 күн бұрын
thank you, this topic is super helpful!
@muma6559
@muma6559 18 күн бұрын
they are excellent points, nice to see you again. You're channel has grown a lot !
@siriuslili
@siriuslili 22 күн бұрын
This is great! Thank you!
@brian-d-berentsen
@brian-d-berentsen 21 күн бұрын
This is a great proactive and thought provoking video. Thank you!
@ajcraft-hello
@ajcraft-hello 22 күн бұрын
Glad YT recommended this. Thanks for thoughtful, useful content. Hadn’t previously considered this possibility and parts resonate.
@radianttiger2307
@radianttiger2307 25 күн бұрын
Thank you, Dr Reid!
@berit8940
@berit8940 11 күн бұрын
Excellent, thank you!
@twinflames_111
@twinflames_111 24 күн бұрын
Thank you. Happy sleepy doggy❤!
@AndeThompson-ex6sv
@AndeThompson-ex6sv 19 күн бұрын
Thank you! This describes my life.
@rubenvargas8288
@rubenvargas8288 18 күн бұрын
THANK YOU , THANK YOU, THANK YOU. Mr. Reid, the video describes very well my childhood. After 30 yrs. of studying and trying to fix it I can accurately state that. I needed to hear it in this context. It cleared a lot of things for me. I also learned a few things. You couldn’t gotten here at a better time. Keep up the good work. May the Universe bless you!
@kristahackleylmt2064
@kristahackleylmt2064 22 күн бұрын
Anwers to your 1st questions: Yes, Yes, and Yes!
@dreamsofturtles1828
@dreamsofturtles1828 8 күн бұрын
Wow. Good information. I listen to alot of videos about narcissist abuse- this really keys in on its effect on children. I relate very strongly, unfortunately. I always feel i MUST ATTEND to whoever im with. My attention must go to them at all times or i will be af hurt or insult them in some way. Its fear based. Its crazy and im going to practice not doing it anymore and, instead, deal with whatever feelings come up . Thank you for a great video.
@miss-winner
@miss-winner 3 сағат бұрын
Once again, you've nailed it.
@lauriepolden6594
@lauriepolden6594 10 күн бұрын
I have always believed in taking care of myself and loving myself because that’s where it starts when you love yourself when you think you are all you need it came from taking care of myself as a child. When both my parents were alcoholics both were narcissistic and they fought And never had time for children.. not only did I take care of my younger siblings I also took care of the house as I was the oldest daughter at eight years old nine years old 10 years old I was feeding the younger children who were six and two providing proper care, putting them to bed at night, giving them naps making sure they ate their dinner. I needed to take care of myself as I got older and I knew how to do that when I turned 17 I moved out and never returned home. I didn’t need to. I was a grown woman at 17. I knew how to do laundry. I knew how to cook. I knew how to clean. I knew how to work because I started working at 16 I had my own apartment, I was on my own. I am taking care of many people in my life my two children. I was a single parent and had no support in their father so I was on my own being on my own is not hard. I prefer it I can do anything I need to do alone. I mow my own grass. I fix my own roof. I have more tools than most men, including Skil saw and chainsaws and everything else I need if I don’t know something I learn it. If I need to know something I figure it out. I don’t rely on others, especially for love because I love myself. I am proud of who I am and I am strong enough to know that I am the best person I can be even if I have faults, even if I can’t do something even if I fall short, I am still, a great human being that is worthy of loving herself every day
@fairygurl9269
@fairygurl9269 25 күн бұрын
💞Grateful
@kristahackleylmt2064
@kristahackleylmt2064 22 күн бұрын
I feel screwed. I don't trust anyone anymore at this point. Everyone I've loved deeply has tried destroying me. Relationships aren't that difficult. I just want to eat, go to the beach, Disneyland, and Knottsberry Farm. Not sure why it's so difficult to find men that care about something other than porn and The Kardashians. I look forward to passing on from this life. The only man I'll entertain at this point is one that lifts me up and makes me want to live 50 more years. Otherwise I have no doubt I wont make it..Too many parents have taught their kids to drink alcohol and do drugs. The world is doomed. Narcissists are everywhere. I feel like I'm dying. 😢
@gavroche8620
@gavroche8620 22 күн бұрын
Don’t give up!!! FIGHT for your life! its the enemy wants take you down, rebuke all the negative thoughts, don’t drink, eat healthy, you will recover!!
@deborahfairbanks4012
@deborahfairbanks4012 21 күн бұрын
Disneyland is always a good idea
@MHLivestreams
@MHLivestreams 18 күн бұрын
Stuff like Disneyland is immature and illogical, it's irrelevant to a meaningful existence, and that's probably why no man is interested in it. Add all that expenditure and he's definitely heading out ahead of time.
@InfiniteMindset99
@InfiniteMindset99 25 күн бұрын
Safety as a scapegoat/narcissistic survivor combined with #1 physiological needs according to Maslow’s Hierarchy/Pyramid. It is so important until I reached the other side of healing. I would also stipulate without a doubt that the new pyramid regarding #3 was practically non-existent and that self-love and self-actualization NOW becomes #3. ❤
@LeighAnnWalters
@LeighAnnWalters 24 күн бұрын
im glad you said this ❤ i was looking at that pyramid a few times last week & thinking about how i prob/may never have #3. i kind of do w God though. it’s not human connection, but it is still connection for me. thank you for sharing!
@puglife6616
@puglife6616 25 күн бұрын
💚❤💙🥰 thank you!
@foxiefair123
@foxiefair123 12 күн бұрын
I guess I’m viewed as a safe person, which is why I’m very sought after as someone that people want to contact. Problem is that I don’t have enough in my cup to fill everyone else’s who is constantly coming to me for that. They don’t understand that, though. It’s like pulling teeth to find alone time to replenish my own mental and emotional energy.
@ssing7113
@ssing7113 20 күн бұрын
If they ask anything from you, it’s only advice never money or time or work or anything
@nekeploey4156
@nekeploey4156 25 күн бұрын
Thank you Dr. Reid for all the info you have been sharing. I have been involved in a young persons' life for 1.5 yrs as a safe adult. The info you have shared has helped immensely during this time trying to figure out what is going on! And I have more patience for their behaviours. A teacher pointed out that when they are rude/neg/condescending to me, they are acting out how they've been treated. Do you have info. on that aspect of being a child of narc. parents?
@LeiraHdezP
@LeiraHdezP 23 күн бұрын
Physiological safe people own their problems. This means 1st of all, they recognized their wrong personality traits on their own (people on their outside don't have to make big efforts for them to see them) & r wanting to better them. Also, what Jay said, " & dont feel entitled to others fixing what they feel inside." To elaborate, it is right to not feel intitled in some ways & amounts, but not others; also u should receive certain thgs from others, especially family members, like offering help to lean on & work against certain QUANTITIES of defects on ur personality/character, but not to the point of an abuser like narcisist & such.
@Sel817
@Sel817 7 күн бұрын
Nailed it in short 😊
@bogdanlazar3278
@bogdanlazar3278 20 күн бұрын
In my opinion, I don't think you've described narcissistic parents, in particular. There are parents that have other disorders or even difficulties that behave in the same way, depressed parents, with OCD traits, with borderline traits etc. Those with OCD my be very careful, cautious and/or worried about many things. They may be hoarders, expect you not to leave the house etc. People with borderline may never feel loved. They may have anger spurts, moments when they isolate themselves, become distant. They may be very needy, expecting the child to be like a parent to them or a lover or a caretaker. On the other hand, at certain times, they may become very apologetic, remorseful. At other times they may be very caring. There's an inconsistency there, and it can have high impacts, especially if those moods or emotions are very intense and the parent cannot "see" the child, essentially, as he/she is overwhelmed with his/her moods. Narcissistic parents, in particular, are those that treat their child as an extension of themselves, but based on performance and image. They care about certain aspects, certain values that they have deemed to be superior and expect their child to adopt them, as-well. These aspects are more important than the child's emotional development or wellbeing. They may enjoy having a baby, because it makes them look good, like a good mother or father. "Look at me! I am raising a child!". They may enjoy it when the baby giggles, as, again, it proves how great of a parent they are. "Look at how my baby is! He is ideal! Of course he is, as I'm ideal too!". However, if the baby throws a tantrum in public, making them look bad, they may slap him, when no one is looking. The child must get good grades, must act in the way they want the child to act, share the same values, even be the same gender, if possible. They may hate traits they believe to be of the opposite gender. When the child becomes an adolescent, all hell breaks loose. The narcissistic parent cannot handle a rebel. The parent himself is the forever adolescent.
@DebbieLee-dr3hr
@DebbieLee-dr3hr 10 күн бұрын
Hell, my siblings & I were slapped with onlookers. Kicked like bad little puppies with observers. So, now when the fairy tale doesn't make sense, it is somehow my fault. I forgive the physical abuse. The tongue lashes and emotional mistreatment that now take center stage are driving me away.
@bogdanlazar3278
@bogdanlazar3278 10 күн бұрын
@@DebbieLee-dr3hr I'm sorry :( I'm glad it's over now, at least. I don't know what to say. It's difficult for me to imagine what you've been through, to feel it myself... When hitting a defenseless child, you have no empathy... That goes hand in hand with narcisism
@jammyjay917
@jammyjay917 20 күн бұрын
Its been tough, I always had to fill others cup... tough lesson but I had to start saying no and distance myself... or else they would expect me to be there all the time for them, its impossible because they are never happy, maybe for a few minutes but that's it... it can be constant...best thing to do is distance yourself
@tonioinverness
@tonioinverness 25 күн бұрын
Another great video. Thank you! I was wondering if you ever considered looking at a specific situation that characterized my last relationship: that is people who demand way too much AND give way too much. This was a very confusing situation for me personally. My partner demanded that I "fill him up" in all the ways you've described in this video--needing endless attention, considering me responsible for his emotional wellbeing, etc. But he also treated me as thought I needed him to fill me up. And the fact is that I did not need that--so the result was always just TOO MUCH of everything. Over-the-top gifts, texting me back within 10 seconds of every message, never leaving me to have alone time, etc. This was very confusing because it was like he was giving me a zillion gifts I never asked for and then demanding payment for all of them. I don't know if that has a name, but I would be interested to know if others have experienced this.
@jenster29
@jenster29 23 күн бұрын
Yes. It's called love bombing and it's manipulation
@juliemickens1697
@juliemickens1697 23 күн бұрын
It sounds like codependent behavior. Codependents think they mean well, but can end up overwhelming others. I can see how it would be too much!
@Hippowdon121
@Hippowdon121 21 күн бұрын
But Jay... this means that I'm a safe person :D
@Suejd1001
@Suejd1001 9 күн бұрын
Yep!!!
@tcancella7286
@tcancella7286 7 күн бұрын
Could you make a clip starting at about minute 12- for young adult women that talks about safe people and Claire vs boyfriend- helpful even for those who would not identify as survivors of narcissistic abuse.
@redmoondesignbeth9119
@redmoondesignbeth9119 20 күн бұрын
After YEARS of Dealing, the TRUTH came out and I am free...kind of. I feel it close by. My family continued without me. They all were a Group and I ended up withdrawing to not be noticed. Now I'm 72 and my entire life was a LIE and I'm having a hard time dealing. When I try to think of memories all I "see" are white empty triangles. ??? Turns out, I did NOT ruin my Teen Mom's life because she had a secret son before me who was adopted by the CEO of SEARS. Turns out we grew up isolated...down a dirt road in the middle of a cornfield. Because it turns out my Dad was not some Midwestern Hick but the son of a powerful Chicago Gangster and I grew up in the HideOut. There is more but I don't want to write a book. It's just that without a History I am having a mental fracture and I hope I'm coping OK.
@nishanacht
@nishanacht 22 күн бұрын
Yep. Sigh 😑
@sowhat5939
@sowhat5939 13 күн бұрын
i have these same feelings but there with my wife
@alisonmorris4444
@alisonmorris4444 25 күн бұрын
@andriyandriychuk
@andriyandriychuk 20 күн бұрын
Doctor is it true that most of childhood trauma comes from narcissistic abuse?
@user-ir1fo4ne8e
@user-ir1fo4ne8e 13 күн бұрын
How do tell if you are survivor of a narcissistic wife and now you know. How do not let everyone walk on you?
@a.m.2239
@a.m.2239 17 күн бұрын
Is a narcissist a covert co-dependent?
@karenzilverberg4699
@karenzilverberg4699 22 күн бұрын
👍
The Problem of Anger for the Scapegoat Child of a Narcissistic Parent
23:14
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 9 М.
The Science Behind Gaining Distance from the Narcissistic Abuser
15:30
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 74 М.
Scary Teacher 3D Nick Troll Squid Game in Brush Teeth White or Black Challenge #shorts
00:47
LOVE LETTER - POPPY PLAYTIME CHAPTER 3 | GH'S ANIMATION
00:15
#1 Brain Surgeon: What Your Dreams Are Trying To Tell You About Yourself | Rahul Jandial
2:03:15
Six Signs of a Covert Narcissistic Father
8:40
Darren F Magee
Рет қаралды 22 М.
What you sacrificed is what saves you after narcissistic abuse
14:21
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 30 М.
8 Oddly Specific Symptoms of Depression
22:01
Dr. Scott Eilers
Рет қаралды 129 М.
Feeling like an outcast after being the narcissist's scapegoat
12:35
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 12 М.
How Parents React to NO CONTACT
19:20
Patrick Teahan
Рет қаралды 68 М.
4 Reasons the Scapegoat Child Is Stronger Than Their Narcissistic Parent
26:28
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 21 М.
Healing a Shame-Based Identity for Scapegoat Survivors
16:34
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 7 М.
Fear of Growing Up for Scapegoat Survivors of Narcissistic Parents
26:17
Jay Reid - Recovery from Bad Childhoods
Рет қаралды 47 М.