You were right that this sits on the shelf. Finally bought it today after a few months seeing it behind the counter at my favorite local liquor store. $99.99, $108 after taxes. Kind of thinking I’ll wait until fall time to open it, seems fitting. Great review, can’t wait to try it.

You’re so right about people overlooking the 10 year Old Overholt. Even the clerks at my local had no idea where to put it. They ended up putting it 2 bottles over from the 4 year. Snagged one but haven’t opened it yet. I hope to get the same tasting notes.

Old Overholt 10 is amazing. Great review. Happy New Year.

We all love watching you drink whiskey...so Liked 😂. Have not tried any of the Old Overholt. I will have to find a sample pour. Cheers and a Happy New Year to you!

Great review. I have been looking for this. Happy New Year

Your reviews are great. Hope the new year treats you well.

Great quality review. Would definitely listen in again. Thank you for all the thoughtful insight!

Excellent review as always! I was waiting for this one after the last video! Can't be mad at the OO10 in the comparison as it is easier to find and cheaper!

Nice review David. I am still not a big rye guy, but have been trying more of them. I have the Old Overholt BIB, and will probably pick this up if I run into it. 🥃

Nice review! I've been eyeing this one for a bit but the 100 price point is a little high to jump on. I'm going to kill a couple more bottles and pick it up some time next year. Still working on my Knob Creek Rye pick and that's been an okay experience, aged at 5yrs. Happy New Years!

Absolutely love my Old Overholt 10 Rye. Halfway through first bottle and decided to grad second bottle. Great rye for sure!

This is so exciting because i just got one yesterday and tried it. Im watching right now and will give you my honest feedback

Great review David! This one is definitely on my list to buy. I have the Old Overholt 114 and it's dang good. The other juice I'm looking for is the Backbone Old Bones 10 yr Rye and price tag is close to $100. Never had Parker's Heritage 10 yr Rye and no way I'll pay above MSRP. Happy New Year and Cheers!

This is an awesome review. Considering I just forked over the money for one, and I'm really looking forward to trying it. Thanks!

Alright Dave! I just ordered this on Sip Whiskey after watching your video bro! Cheers!

Great review. I’m hopeful to get my hands on this bottle at some point

Great review haven’t heard of this one before I need to find 1 cheers

Would love to find this bottle! Thanks for the review

Great review. Thanks

If I want a rye the Overholt is the clear winner over the Parkers. The Parkers taste like a Bourbon. When I have a rye I want that spice kick and not just sweetness

Great review. Makes me want to run out and buy this one.

That Old Overholt is one that I have been keeping an eye out for. It just looks good! Great review! Looking forward to the Baker’s 13 review you have in queue! Also, which 1792 is that over you right shoulder? Couldn’t make it out. Can’t wait to til the next one my friend! Cheers! 🥃

I can’t find this anywhere. Dying for a bottle. I also love that the bottle is an OGD114 bottle. Great review.

Can't forget their 114 - it's a great value !

I agree. I give it a 8. It does have a lot of rye profile and after a while it has fruit and sweetness. Great review.

Looking to get a pour of the Old Overholt. Never tried Parker’s either. I’m still very new to rye whiskey.

I feel more times than not these "barely" a rye pours are right in my wheel house. Like Pikesville. Although the Jack Daniel's mash bill is quite good too. I just not sure if I can get past the fact that I can by two of either of the above mentioned for the price. I you said about the Parer's Heritage in comparison to Old Overholt 10. I mean... when and where do we draw the line and say "it's just brown consumable liquid " ? Each person has to set their own limits. My limit is right near that $100 mark along with the expectation to stay at or within say 20% of msrp, plus I refuse to support the whole secondary market that is driving the bubble. This sounds like a personal problem for me to work through. Perhaps therapy is in order? LoL I know it's the reason why I don't have really great bottles on my shelf. But the bottles I do have are every bit as delicious and I didn't break the bank. Thanks again for another great comparison and who knows, the bubble may burst and the price/availability may correct itself. I know... the world needs dreamers. Dana (So-Cal)

Have just got it. Have not had a chance to try it.

I've been torn on getting this bottle. I'm sitting on 7 bottle of the special release 114 proof bottles that were put out in pa and Ohio. PA was blowing them out for $20 a bottle. It's delicious and at 124 proof and 100 bucks will it be worth it.

Would be a nice one to find and don't get into trouble tonight lol

Some how I missed this, ryes always worry me that they are going to be too minty

I'm curious how it compares to the 114 or is this like the Jack Daniel's sbbp rye, a whole new animal 🤔 Cheers 🍻

Have you compared this Old Overholt 10 CS to Jack Daniel’s SBBP Rye?

There is no point to aging a rye.

If that 51% rye number is true, I've got to wonder how it might compare to a high rye whiskey, like Tumblin' Dice. Oh, and you may have overlooked Old Overholt 114! I just cracked that one open last night, and enjoyed it a good bit. Cheers and happy New Year, dude!🥃✌️

Awesome review, David 👏 love the comparison at the end as well. It puts pricing into perspective.