What's your favorite mission during Beaver Hollow? Would you agree this mission is the parallel to Blood Feuds?

It was right here. I realized that Dutch was absolutely a narcissist and saw everyone as disposable.

I always liked that scene just before Eagle Flies arrives. Arthur calling out Dutch and his actions, Micah stepping up to Arthur and then Charles, John and Sadie walking up behind Arthur as if to support him. You have to wonder what would have happened if Eagle Flies hadn't arrived at that time. It looked as if things were about to boil over at that moment.

I love how much Arthur felt disrespected when Micah asked what else he'd been doing without Dutch knowing, his "W h a t ?" Says it all

Pretty sure Dutch was livid seeing all those Braves riding with Arthur and not him. I’m guessing John rode with Dutch mainly because he was on thinner ice with Dutch than Arthur I do think Bill and Javier were trying to stay on Dutch’s good side even if it meant alienating the others. Mary Beth, Karen, Uncle and Pearson probably heard about what happened at the oil field and decided that was the last straw and fled.

This was the exact moment Dutch became Heisenberg.

Chapter 6 Dutch setting up the Wapiti tribe to be a distraction so the 16 of us could escape was......as evil as it was, a decent plan that could have worked. But noooooooooooooooooooooooo..............................we had to rob another fucking train.

The part when Arthur comes back out with eagle flies and says to Dutch ”You run away”, you can hear the shock and rage in his voice

10:44 As a native person I get MAD GOOSEBUMPS every time I hear this song

Micah pours the milk before cereal

Dutch is a lot like my father. He'll tell you what he thinks you want to hear, then do whatever benefits him.

My mom has a masters in communication and with as much programming and writing as she's done has far surpassed what's necessary for a doctorate. When playing this game for her to watch, I asked her straight how his first speech felt. She said it already had suspiciously manipulative language. Then with the three times in chapter 1 where he puts Arthur on the ropes for asking simple questions, forcing Arthur to backtrack and nearly beg Dutch to believe his loyalty, she xalled out that that is classic manipulative behavior and a lot of it. He's a cult leader and a narcissist. I already knew this because I've learned a hell of a lot from her, but her confermation makes me triple down that he was awful before, but the reason he went crazy is because he was losing his grip on his control of others. And a rabid dog doesn't back down when it's hurt or weak. It will drag whatever it can down into hell with it. There was no giving up for Dutch. He was clawing. He wanted "freedom", continuing to "seek" as he reads to Mary-Beth and Molly. No settling. Tahiti was a joke. A dream to lure the desperate and tired. And they followed. Desperate and tired. His end in Red Dead Redemption was clear to me. He still was the one in control. His last bit of control. John wasn't taking that from him. He was always sick. He was just better at pretending he cared, wasn't so obvious in his gaslighting. Those he saved felt they owed him their lives. Eventually, that wasn't enough for them to stay. But it took to long for them to realize they were trained, loyal meatshields, taught to do his dirty work to make him happy, their savior. I call Hosea "Real Dad". He doesn't call himself a father. Doesn't need to. Dutch is constantly saying "son", being called a father figure. If he really was, he wouldn't have to remind you at every turn. Him saying "son" might sound sweet, but thats the point. It got you in the heart, an easily manipulated part of us all. His golden words are guilding a hill of shit. Watch him, don't listen. That's good life advice too. If someone can speak well, if they have a silver tongue, take the message and compare it to who they are and what they do. Dutch is a fictional example of a real life monster. He's well written... Because people didn't see what was right in front of them til moments like this. No shame for that, just an opportunity to go back and recognize the signs with 20/20 hindsight.

If you go to camp straight after the mission and speak to everyone, Arthur sounds to upset and angry at Durtch for what he had done - Not just to him but to everyone including the natives.

I was blown away when Dutch walked away. And then tried too gaslight Arthur, the small bit of sympathy I had left was absolutely gone Dutch was 100% ready too leave his "Son" too die

When you play the first time, you dont notice much in all the dialogues in game but the second playthrough ? The hints are everywhere

I think it ended when Arthur and Sadie saved John from Sisika. It was very clear that Dutch didn't wanna save John and was probably gonna leave him there. He was really mad when John, Sadie and Arthur came back to camp.

the scene when dutch leaves Arthur after he's been blasted by steam was surprising to me because up to this point i was 100% convinced Dutch would kill Arthur, not that he'd simply leave him and be too much of a coward to shoot him himself

I think John rode with Dutch in that mission because for all the bickering and anger, he was still holding on to some loyalty to Dutch. I don't even think he is sure that Dutch betrayed him in the bank. But when he is shot in the train robbery and is left by Dutch, he not only gets betrayed again but it also confirms that Dutch left him in the bank robbery and then wanted to leave John to get hanged. This finally completely separates him from the gang and he has no shred of loyalty and confusion to Dutch. He knows what Dutch is and he knows what Dutch has done and he is no longer confused, and stands with Arthur at the last mission of the main story.

Dutch’s action makes more sense knowing he didn’t know about Arthur helping the tribe didn’t notice that first time it makes sense why he left him he felt Arthur had betrayed him and was cutting a lose end

Micah’s plot armor is the most infuriating part of the game. I saw him as the problem before I even saved him from jail on my first play through. Theres a dozen moments shown in this video alone that I tried to shoot that b*stard.

0:15 god damn slither tounge.

Arthur will forever be the saddest ending ever in Videogames.Arthur gave his blood sweat and tears for everyone and they were all he ever had and in the end he died alone.Early on you could feel how loved he is in Blessed be the Peacekeepers.

“ARTHUR WE NEED MORE MONEY” : Arthur casually walking around with 2.5 million in his satchel 😂

The mission my last boy and when Eagle Flies dies is the last mission you can do with Arthur Morgan if you want to keep him alive. Ofcource the battle against the US army with the Indians is legendary aswell.

not only did Rains Fall lose his last son here, so did Dutch, or at least, he lost the remaining bits of loyalty and trust Arthur may of had for him.

Dutch would make an amazing politician

My view on Dutch is that he actually agrees with Arthur that their time in the world is over and has been for a long time, but he doesn't want to accept that. So he just keeps coming up with new ways to lash out like a cornered animal while deluding himself that there's still a way out, and his animosity to Arthur and John comes from how he can't stand that they keep reminding him of the truth. His characterization in the original Red Dead Redemption is pretty useful for discerning this, as it puts a lot of his so-called plans into context as really being just him lashing out and trying to damage the "civilized world" in whatever way he can

Lore of My Last Boy is the exact moment when the Van Der Linde Gang Ended momentum 100

The moment dutch killed Heidi McCourt the gang was finished It was the first time dutch showed who he truly was

I'm pretty sure Dutch knew about Arthur breaking out Eagle Flies. Because after Arthur and Dutch escape the military by swimming downstream, Dutch tells Arthur to meet up with Charles in order to get him out. So he knew about that at least, but everything else regarding Rains Fall, no he didn't.

I wanna say it's during the failed Saint Denis Bank Heist.. nothing is the same... everyone's just going through the motions.

This is the exact moment thwt Dutch became plansenberg

I love watching and listening to these videos got me through some tough homeworks and courseworks keep it up man!

So I seen it in my game too, but why is Uncle's beard gone when you rob the stagecoach?

I would love to play as eagle flies and ride with Arthur.

Honestly i think when hosea was shot was the moment the gang started to crumble

Arthur on the thumbnail looks just like Jon Bernthal.

I’ve wondered when watching your videos what is your Arthur outfit?

The last time we actually saw the gang in a good state is after we got Jack back

It does tell you read the newspapers it tells a lot

Was I the only one who instead of saying I'm dead to the sister I did it to reverend swanson

I wish the song from My Last Boy was on Spotify 😢

The irony is Dutch always was such an egoist-narcissist. Always talking about money and manipulating anyone to get to do things for him while he never delivers or offers anything back in any deal. Milton was right to stop negotiating with him or the gang, Dutch is to egoistic to just give up and as long as his spell on the other gang members is strong, he can still push his weight around. Dutch on his own is nothing, he only stood for ideas and just liked to play boss. But he barely had any leadership skill besides his silver tongue to demand loyalty.

You say there were more action packed missions, idk, this is probably near the top.

What's the outfit you run here?

Early gang right here🔥 👇

i don’t think we need red dead redemption 3 we need a different game in a same timeline red dead retribution maybe or red dead rebellion

When I thought of this, Dutch is basically like the massive corporation who is willing to use social activism around the world where they only care about money they’ll get out of it like with Disney when they say they’re for LGBT and would cancel shows like the Owl House.

Dutch is a very weird character. It seems like he had to be like this all the time, but somehow he fooled everyone for so many years. Right now, whenever i play red dead redemption 2 again, i always wish that hosea could take the lead. He always seemed to be the one with open mind, one who wasn't crazy. It is hard for me to believe that dutch was like this always tho, as he seems at least, to care about for example, death of hosea. But since then, he seems to be even less caring and more manipulative. I don't know, it's a hard case lol.

real

Yea i don't think Arthur and John was apart of the plan

A cool Red Dead 3 idea could be a story about an outlaw on the run, taking refuge amongst a native American tribe and learning their ways, and then ending up helping them fight a winless battle against the US government and oil companies. Could be the outlaws “redemption arch” helping them fight the war and doing what he thinks is right in the end. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Mine would be angalo bronnte

bluhd went on yapping for 16 mins on something everyone already knew 2/10 I expect better from u

real