Eddy finding every excuse to let the world know that he has perfect pitch

Eddy Only Did This Because He Was Taken Off Wikipedia For Not Being A Celebrety

What is also interesting to know is that absolute pitch tends to shift as one gets older. Now, Charlie did seem to get the wrong ones slightly sharp each time, so it is very possible that his perfect pitch has already begun drifting sharper and sharper. Adam Neely made a very good (as always) video about this subject

i like how brett sings all the note perfectly and eddy gets the note perfectly!!

The whole video: Eddy appreciates Charlie’s pitch, then roasts him, and appreciates him again, and roasts him again

"I would hate to do that on camera!" - Said Eddy while doing that on camera.

7:55 Charlie Puth was listening to the upper pitch. When the glass was hit, multiple notes ringed. The lower note was more obvious, which was the F that Eddy focused on. But I think Charlie was listening to the upper ringing note, which happened to be an F#. That’s why both are correct.

5:44 what happened was that the producers got it wrong when editing it and somehow what was a boat-horn C# became an Eb. That’s why Charlie is saying it changed pitch because he didn’t get it wrong it’s just what he heard while recording was a different sound to what we heard while watching.

Twoset in 2020: instrument wars Twoset in 2021: WIKIPEDIA WARS

Conclusion: it doesn’t matter, but Eddy’s just salty he isn’t on the Wikipedia page anymore.

Love how Brett and Eddy are yelling and laughing at Charlie one second then calmly singing the notes in unison to figure out the pitch the next second. Almost like they're doing an "om" meditation after a stressful event.

I "believe" that with some of these sounds, the overtones from different keys clash together and are up for interpretation. It's like that yanni/laurel sound test.

Eddy's resume: • 1/2 of Twosetviolin • Has perfect pitch • became the whole orchestra for Tchaikovsky 2 million subscriber livestream • the soloist for Sibelius 3 million subscriber livestream

And the battle over Eddy's perfect pitch continues...

The interviewer had no business interviewing him on the stuff because he knew no different. They should’ve got somebody who actually also has perfect pitch so that when he got it wrong they could call him on it.

6:23 your horrified faces, i can't- 😂😂😂

Brett is like your supportive friend who has your back like “I'm here for you bruh!”

Even though Eddy isn’t on the English Wikipedia page for perfect pitch, he still made it to the French page. And they haven’t changed it since June 1st so I guess France appreciates your perfect pitch ☺️

Eddie just thanking the god for his gift while Brett just begging for it with a cup and straw is hilarious 😂

I know I'm a year late, but there actually is a way to train yourself to have perfect pitch! A friend of mine used to have an A tuner, and he would listen to it every night before bed, and when he woke up he would try to sing that pitch. He repeated that until he had the A down, then moved onto other notes (CGDE) and now he has perfect pitch.

"god-given talent, a gift" Brett: "DAMN IT, WHERE'S MY TALENT?????"

Twoset really going for everyone this year

Charles Cornell did an amazing job on this video describing absolute pitch, that C#/Eb note was a switch in production. You also have to take into account that Charlie is coming from a production world so his viewpoint is very much in that direction. It is also possible that as this video was edited, some sounds were changed out because they weren’t recorded at the right volume, or they just didn’t like the sound in post. Love your videos guys!

whole video Eddy: I have perfect pitch Brett: and I don't **makes noises**

"Does Charlie Puth REALLY Have Perfect Pitch??" Nope, Eddy is the one with perfect pitch

Eddy: I'm not sure if I have perfect pitch. Also Eddy: *flexes his perfect pitch every time he has a chance*

You guys are so fun!!! So enjoyed this video

to explain the physics behind the 7:28 gaffe: imagine any string on any stringed instrument, as you make it shorter by pressing your finger on it, it resonates at a higher frequency; frequency is the number of waves at a given point in one unit of time. since waves travel less distance with a shorter string, their frequency becomes higher. (and vice versa) now replace the string with a glass; as you pour the liquid out of the glass, you're increasing the portion of the glass that will resonate (akin to increasing a string's length), therefore, the sound will be at a lower frequency.

"Damn it. WHERE'S MY TALENT?? Please, sprinkle some more talent on me" Same Brett.. same 😂

I think his face is not him trying to be cool showing off his perfect pitch, but just him being tired that no one talks about anything else in interviews with him. Just constantly making him demonstrate and talk about perfect pitch like he's a circus attraction and not an artist.

This was the best :) hahahahhaa I hope you guys do more like this!! Hearing u guys sing notes 🤩🎉🎉

The "they're also on camera" joke is funny and I thought of making it myself, and it's a valid argument that they can take as many takes as they want but I think the main thing there is they're filming for us, a relatively small fanbase who accepts mistakes, while Charlie Puth is a celebrity

Charlie looks not enjoying this interview that's probably why...

What Charlie puth doesn’t have is perfect pizz

Eddie definitely deserves to be on the wiki, but I understand they are probably only limiting the list to some of the most documented and famous cases. Thats the only reason I can imagine the list only being a dozen. Absolute pitch is rare but not that rare. 😂

You don't need perfect pitch to transpose on the spot, but if you know what keys are good for an artist (ie you know their range) then you have an aid in transposing. Makes you a hair quicker at finding notes outside of range in a transposed key to know if a given key will work

TwoSet: "He's on camera; There's pressure" Also Twoset: Is on camera

Things that never gonna end: 1. My loneliness 2. Videos about perfect pitch

I can't with brett doing an analysis everytime 🤣🤣

I can only admire people with perfect pitch. It Is just really amazing how you can hear the tiny difference and say it on spot what note it Is. Only thing I have is sound memory. Hearing the song or piece one or two times and I can play it (of course not perfectly but at least right notes) on Violin or one hand (usually melody line) on piano... (And it Is really useful at school since I don't need to learn much if I can remember what teachers said.)

I swear to god Eddy's high school yearbook quote was 'I have perfect pitch' I need TwoSet to confirm this.

"I support all the Pitches", that's a T-shirt idea if I ever heard one.....

Eddy, what do you think about auditory illusions? Would be cool to see what you guys think about stuff like circular tones, tritones, etc

You can try learning perfect pitch. Think of a thing that you always hear. For example, your phone's vibration produce a# sound. or empty glass produce c# and so and so forth. when you were used to it, you can make those things as a reference to tell which thing does this note sounds like. my friend a perfect pitch said that to me when i asked him how does he do it. but it maybe different for every people

The C# and Eb note that the guys were confused about, they played a different note in the original recording, but fixed it through post I believe. So Charlie heard a different note than what was played in the video, aka what Eddy heard. (I believe at least. I heard this from Charles Cornell's video).

I want to see them react to Jacob Collier's hearing. The man has arguably the best musical hearing in the world, he can hear microtones even. He can tell how many cents two frequencies are apart. He's inhuman.

He has great note recognition, he has trouble with high initial notes (note heard upon contact between spoon and glass) that overlap into a gradual quick decline that then straighten out into a harmonic. Also the slight vibration felt coming from the spoon held in his hand being of a different material might have thrown his judgment a bit. then the sound of the two materials coming in contact might have thrown his brain off by a bit -assuming he has such a sensitivity to resonance. Basically he hears *tink* (of contact between glass and metal) Then *harmonic traveling from initial contact area of glass then reverbing around rim to meet dying harmonic pitch* How he heard a higher pitch from the fog horn could be explained by him hearing the initial split second sound of the horn before the vibrational device within the horn that causes the lower distorted pitch kicked in and quickly tick between two different pitches one high and one low pitch. The rubber duck is expessially difficult to explain as its a high initial sound that dies at a constant due to the material contracting where the air escapes,so an extremely smooth decline transition between notes sharp,regular and flat resulting in a overlapping combo of the three pitches while transitioning into the next octave then the inhalation starts with flat then normal then sharp so its essentially reversed. Monkey is just duel notes that transition quickly from eachother then jump to another slightly different pair then a very different duo.Its mostly just alot to reconise all at once in a short amount of time.

I always have difficulty with the term "perfect pitch" and especially, "god given ability". The ability is to recognize notes in equal temperament. Which must be a learned skill, because there is nothing innate about equal temperament.

Off topic but 10 secinds in and you can tell how charlie does NOT want to be there😭😭

I love how Eddy's salty that Charlie is on the Wikipedia's page about perfect pitch🤣🤣

I have perfect pitch and was especially good and picking notes while in highschool school, but I haven't practiced for years, this video was a fun reminder I still got it!

Perfect pitch plus perfect relative pitch allows you to transpose in your head very easily. I think that might be what Charlie was talking about when he meant “analysis.” I had to do this when I sang in acapella choir as they would start to lose pitch and slide down the scale. As I sang a harmony part, I either had to learn the song in several chromatically descending keys, or transpose in my head as we were singing it.

this is just eddy being all humble about his perfect pitch 🧍🏻‍♀️

5:50 If you can read Charlie's Lips he says "That was an E Flat"

This guy in the video looks so done with the perfect pitch thingy. I reckon he has been asked like a million times.

I'm pretty sure a different music Channel stated that the boat sound was edited in so that's why Charlie got it wrong, they played a different sound in studio

EDDY BEING LOWKEY SALTY IS A MOOD

So funny!! They changed the boat sound effect in post editing 😂😂 so it’s not the same sound we’re hearing that he’s hearing

Lmaoooo this video really cements you y'alls snobbiness hahaha embaRRaaaazing

WIKIPEDIA PUT EDDY'S NAME IN THE PERFECT PITCH MUSICIANS LIST

TwoSet is literally the only KZfaq-Channel where you would hear Egmont in the background xd

I have a guitar and you guys made me want to start practicing every day

I heard somewhere that since the boat sound is so weird, it was distorted. So the sound we hear in the video is distorted from what was actually played in the studio for Charlie to hear. I think Charles Cornell did a video on it.

I think I remember the editors saying they changed out the boat horn in production, which answers why he's saying C-C# but the post production sound is Eb

This atcually feels like a "perfect pitch" saga and I'm here for it 😂😂

you guys' content are so funny and enjoyyable

It's sad, but watch your videos it makes me feel less alone. And motivates me to re-start on music. Thank you so much guys, you don't know how much I really appreciate your work. I wish you read this comment, you makes me laugh when the only thing I want is cry. Thank you with all my heart.

Whenever Brett is doing "analysis" I just can't control my laugh, man he's funny.

I used to think I was special for having perfect pitch, then I went to music uni and every second person and their dog has perfect pitch. In every new chamber rehearsal someone would ask 'okay who's got perfect pitch?' to tune to, always expecting at least one person to have it even within a quartet. One of the conducting students asked their chamber choir for a perfect pitch starting note, and the professor quickly said "no one answer!" fully expecting people would have it.

i love their reaction when he compares the glas to the boat sound lol

Both of them: "He changed to B!!!" Me who has no pitch knowledge whatsoever: YES YES HE DID

note to everyone: the horn was not a C sharp because the editors put in a different boat sound

Though Brett doesn’t have perfect pitch, he has perfect pizz🌝✨💯

Looks like I'm not the only one mixing up C and F when doing this. I don't claim to have perfect pitch though.

This video is gold content!!

Hi pitches, Me as a pianist with perfect pitch, That C# - Eb thing is a distorted sound, a noise, it could creat an audional illusion for us and for Charlie. We hear distorted sound in different ways in different enviroment. It is possible that he actually heard a C#. The F - F# problem: you can hear a high (low pitched) F# too maybe he heard that stronger in the studio. Glasses make irregular "overtones". It depends which one of them your brain listens to. He cannot recognize accurately notes so fast at the beginning then screw up these easy tests later. Calculate please with the fact that he heard the notes differently in the studio. The only thing I do not understand is that why do people thing that perfect pitch is such a great thing. It is literally just knowing the names of the pitches, as you know the letters or colors. But knowing and recognizing the letter and colors doesn't necessary make you aa great poet or painter... Relative pitch is more valuable because you need to understand the relations between the notes, the scale-degrees, harmonies etc. That's really something. Anyway what Brett sang at the end was a high G# Kind regards, Check Saxologic's video abbout perfect pitch vs true pitch

For those wondering, the background music in the beginning is "Dvorák - Serenade for Strings in E Major, Op. 22, B. 52: II. Tempo di valse".

Not me pulling out my tuner to double check everything👀

LOL I'm now going to do Brett's "analysis" technique everytime I need to process complex thoughts XD

*yOu DoNt SaY* *wE kNoW yOuRe SuRe* Editor san represents all of us

Tbh, on Charlie's defense, it's really hard to keep calm cuz everyone asks him about his perfect pitch and everyone wants to test it. He's under a lot of pressure and I won't blame him for messing up. No one is perfect anyway.

LOL so this video made me realize that I might have perfect pitch! In high school I had to do the performance thing and I wasn't sure if I did or not because I was so stressed out having to be right the first time.

This is the most genuine form of open jealousy i have seen So humble and fascinating

they changed the boat horn in the edit to make it sound more like a boat horn. that’s the reason for the “slip up” haha

Alternative title: Perfect pitch vs. Perfect pitch with Eddy pointing out all the mistakes

@8:30... "wondered into no pitch land"... lol 🤣 this should have been the title of this video

2:48 ✨😌 perfect pizzicato 👍🏼

4:19 either the editors added a different sound than what they actually played to Charlie in the moment, or the speakers/whatever audio device he was hearing this on altered the pitch in some way. There's no way that he listened to the same thing as us and heard a C#, especially considering that he nailed every single other pitch that they played for him

We will always crown eddy as our perfect pitch king

9:00 actually was an Ab

You are so respectful ! I love you guys so much ! Even if Charlie messed up, you give him what he got !

I love how brett doesn't even process what he says sometimes until after he says it and then confuses himself 😂

Whether he made a mistake or it was the production team in post, I think this video was just fun and not to hate on Charlie Puth! I think he’s a phenomenal musician either way and there’s no disputing that he has perfect pitch lol

I'm pretty sure that the problem is that the sound that it was reproduced live for Charlie is different to the one that it's in the KZfaq Video. Maybe it's because they edited with the wrong sound, or maybe it's because at some point in the editing of the video, the sound change. Some probable options: -maybe the speed changed cause it was a better fit for the video, but the pit changed -maybe the pitch sound was too low yo work on it on the editing program so they either changed it or edited it. -maybe they Lost the original file that was used live and they used another The guy editing the video doesnt have perfect pitch

i read something that says the boat sound got messed up in post production, so it came through on the youtube video differently than it sounded like in the studio they were in, cause it was so different to the glass especially, but yeah

It's pretty undisputable that Eddy has perfect pitch. Unfortunately, the Wikipedia battle was over whether or not Eddy counted as "notable" in the eyes of Wikipedia editors 🥲 *We* all think you're notable, Eddy 💕

Brett got to flex his perfect pizz. It’s Eddy’s turn (aGain).

Special thanks to editor sans for editing the part "We know u r sure" 😂😂😂😂😂

6:41 EMBARRASSING 😂

tbh? I think they played the wrong sound afterwards(in post production), because getting a note wrong once is one thing. But, someone with perfect pitch who gets the wrong note twice and doesnt notice seems pretty weird to me