Dokładnie tak.

Correct. He gets paid just as well as the rest. He wrote most of Pink Floyd's stuff, so he gets publishing rights.

So true 😘😁

I'm sure he's a good bassist. Never seen him play guitar before

Well said

@DYLAN COLLEY Probably somewhere playing both parts at the same time.

@@cl12pak lmao

@@cl12pak actually there is a video of Gilmour playing it live. his has a second guitarist with him. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/e9WUrNeB0tHNZac.html

Love his leg work too :)

@@cl12pak him playing God's part? You're an absolute optimist!

lol, that's absolutely laughable.

He's just an aries xD

True ❤

He ´s just drunk

reading this while my foot does the same 😂

True, but nothing can touch David’s dry, rusty studio version.

Maybe, shit voice compared to Gilmour though.

Wish you were here lol

wish you were there

I wish I was here.

Wish they were here

You are

beaux morgan david said that he cringes at the studio versions playing but then hed remind himself that the whole song was based around a kid playing beside a radio and jamming out with the song in the bg (hence in the beginning with radio signal sounds and the intro solo coming from the left channel only)

Clapton is God.

Eric is probably the most important guitarist of this era. His legacy and future recognition will endure. He's done so many different collaborations and mastered the blues as well as classic rock and been successful in bands as well as solo.

I saw Clapton play with Waters years ago doing half Waters material and half Pink Floyd material .Clapton sounded exactly like Gilmour.

@@radiorob7543 Even as a joke, that is not a good thing to say that "Clapton is God." No way! I never liked that line. I am sure Clapton didn't like it much either. Who would, really? You know, bare with me here. Even as a guitar player, there are about ten thousand guitar players that can play all of Clapton's stuff from memory note for note now days. He was an innovator and was at the right time and at the right place, but he was/is not technically, as good as many. I have to say that his playing in the Cream days was much more adventurous and energetic, than now. The "Crossroads" live version is flawless. All of his playing on the "Wheels of Fire" album was great, but he did not grow much musically after that time, in my opinion. Sorry to say, I have to say that Eric is unfortunately overrated, just in the same way that Bruce Springstein is overrated as a vocalist. Just my opinion. I know there are going to be many that disagree with me, but that is probably why the comments section has been placed here by KZfaq. Is it not? LOL

Tri Aryant To me, Waters was always the one with the feeling. Gilmour's focus is on the music.

Tri Aryant 7

given his manic depressive state its no wonder.Just listen to His,"Final cut".

Voice is shot m8 sadly from overgigging & recording

Unfortunately, I have to agree it sounds that way. This is either the wrong key for his voice or he is just not going for singing it an octave higher the way the song is almost always performed. Put some effort into it, dude! You are Roger Waters, and we all love you and respect you. But sad to say, I think vocally, Roger's voice pretty much sucks here. Even the typical Floydish trio of female singers could not rescue the song, I think. Clapton is there, sounding good and definitely contributed well with a good effort.... nothing shoddy here about Eric's performance. He is very good here, although he is certainly no David Gilmore, but that is to say just as Gilmore is no Clapton. LOL This could have been so much better if Roger gave it some kind of effort. He did not even remember the song on guitar at first. That is very unprofessional to start and then stop in a performance. Practice the material before making a public performance, I say. I know he is known for playing bass, not guitar... but the instruments are very similar. Most bass players can at least play rhythm guitar. After he got going, Roger's guitar playing was fine, I will say, however. And I agree with the people above that say that he is a great song writer and a man of high intellect. :)

👍 👍

You are spot on with that observation, regretfully there are too many musically ignorant people that want every rendition to sound like the album.

Viet Ha no, this is two legends jamming out, not just 2 any two guys....

Right on, Viet Ha, Videos like this are special.

i ansolouetely loved. it!

Viet Ha i

It's his ASMR version.

David is wonderful but it's almost like he's the best Pink Floyd cover band, in that he just plays true to the songs. Saw Roger Waters live a couple weeks ago and he's still innovating. They excel at what the other lacks. Wish they were both "here" instead of holding decades long grudges

That is true but on this particular song Gilmour is unreachable

Withnail and I reference? Aha

^_^

Ikr, he should start a music career

@@annazfiirizky1952 😂😂😂

😂

I don't believe I just read this.

Roger missed David for ever and ever. Best possible guitar player in the universe. In any universe.

The song is about Syd. If Roger wished to have David near him, he'd reunite.

Sebastián Bouzat lol he's not even top 10 Jimi Hendrix is N1 but I respect your opinion

@@uchihaitachi27 could you name one guitarist who has more feeling than gilmour when he plays the guitar? I cannot

You know they're singing about Sid Barrett

Not randomly.

This song makes me cry almost every time I listen to it alone.

I ball my eyes out every time..... RIP dad.... wish you were here

So true!

This is a very painful song for those who live it. Early onset dementia in my wife Margo How I Wish You Were Here

+angeamis Agreed

+angeamis For me it is Shine one you crazy diamond.

For me too...Right after Comfortably Numb.

I fell in love Pink Floyd on the album "Wish You Were Here" in 1975 I was 11 it was my father who had bought the vinyl 33 rpm and necessarily I also like "Shine one you crazy diamond" I love this album

The wall, also great album

I'd like to know their names too

@@kathleensauline I’m pretty sure that’s PP Arnold in the middle

​@@kathleensaulineI think it's Carol Kenyon on the right. She also sang with Pink Floyd at the Live 8 reunion in 2005.

@@A.staris he’s not a racist antisemite, he’s just antisionist. There’s a difference, you ignorant twat

@@A.staris "some of us Floydies" ummm yeah, about that. Pretty sure there's only one of you.

@@A.staris Calls roger a racist when he's literally performing with people of color. lmao you need to learn your definitions

@@A.staris It seems you lost the plot. Try to do better.

@@darthnyquil pretty sure he married to a Black lady

You're not alone, I loved it!

It comes with age... loved it too

I'm completely with you!!! Absolutely one of my all time favorites! Only E.C. could add anything to make it sweeter!

Loved it very much. Hardcore fan of Floyd and Clapton.

well put. I think this is great! Different perspective on Rogers voice and song.

agreed! Just saw him play at Desert Trip yesterday. i love hearing alternate versions. Songs are hard to sing when they mean a lot to you

awful cover, no respect for the song.

TheRockdoo he wrote the song, created alternate lower pitched vocal parts for this version, and had trouble emotionally getting the song started (he was being a bit of a thespian), and playing the song for a charity. how is that "no respect"?

Joe O'Quinn Well, he had no respect for the original by adding extra strumming, and many unnecessary parts. This was only to show off. And honestly, it isn't a big achivement to complexify wish you were here, an acoustic guitar song, and gilmour would have been able to if it actually sounded any better than the simple version we have today. He also played without any feeling at all. This is the perfect example of how not to make a cover, as a song isn't made great just because it's complex to play.

🙃

Lol

😊👍

4u25out indeed! 👍

Me too. I love the austerity and simplicity of Gilmour's style.

Maybe because they don't even have the same type of voice. Roger has a baritone and a negative way to sing, while David has a LIGHT baritone and a way to sing with a positive way.

Maravilhoso Roger

I’m pretty sure they both sang 2 different parts on the album cover so 😏

You act like waters didn't write whole the best pink floyd's song

+ef200359 Well except for Gilmour..

L

The lady on the left is one of Eric's vocalists, Katie Kissoon.

@@justafanintexas7913 Middle one is P.P. Arnold. Came to England in the 60s with the Ikettes and was taken under Mick Jagger's wing, who got her a recording contract with Immediate Records. Saw her live in Perth, W. A. earlier this year. Very talented singer in her own right.

Absolutely

I was thinking the same think.

Alles ist hier perfekt. Besser geht schwer bis gar nicht.

I wish that, too. But after watching several interviews I realized that it won't happen ever again... :(

Rick is dead. They aren't the same, and with one member resting there's no way they are coming together.

Ahmen brother

Roger started the fire. Then Rick, Nick & David was PF. Roger said "PF is over ", but the other three didn't think the same. I remember a live concert (Live 8) in 2005 playing the four members a setlist of 20 min. Wright's dead in 2008 closed PF reunion. Damned! Isn't it a pity?

They have put aside their differences. Floyd is done, simple as that.

Dayvid Mendes Roger sings better than David and David plays far better guitar than waters. I only wished they didn't part ways.

s v venu From my eyes it’s actually more like David’s a better musician, and Rogers a better song Writer.

s v venu and Davyd MendesNo way does Roger sing better than David. Nothing like. Roger has no range at all. He more or less speaks and does not sing.

Malc Holden , I'll assume you would have heard complete songs of Animals,TDSOM & The wall where Rogers is in control for most part and then carefully listen to the song learning to fly by gilmour, the vocals abruptly end before gilmour's awesome solo.at that moment you will realize the importance of Roger waters for Pink Floyd.

s v venu Roger was massively important to Pink Floyd. Up until and including the Final Cut he wrote more or less all the lyrics and I’m sure contributed massively to the music. My point was simply David has a better voice with more range. That said Roger is brilliant at what he does but IMHO he murdered this effort.

Restless leg Clapton disease.

Still a great song. 2019

Oh sure, that's easy for you to say.