GAME OF THRONES | THE RED WEDDING - Show vs. Book 7 MAIN DIFFERENCES

Рет қаралды 1,789

Күн бұрын

The Red Wedding is one of the most significant plot twists in TV and Books alike but which piece of media did a better job?
Watch along to see an in-depth analysis of the red wedding in both media and to get a greater appreciation for the red wedding.
Don't forget to LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more content like this. Feel free to leave a COMMENT on anything else you'd like me to cover.
Music credit:
- Game of Thrones theme song mp3 official music video (no copyright music)►
• game of thrones theme ...
- Game of Thrones Theme Song - Copyright Free -Safe Music ►
• Game of Thrones Theme ...
- Cory Alstad Darker Places (a favourite of mine) ► • Darker Places
- I Just Want Quiet ►
Music composed and recorded by Oak Studios.
Link: • [No Copyright Music] I... | Creative Commons - Attribution ND 4.0
Time chapters
00:00 - Intro
1:52 - Robb
3:00 - Jeyne vs Talisa
3:59 - The Buildup
11:30 - The music
13:06 - GRRM's brilliant wordplay
14:16 - Arya
16:07 - Robb and Catelyn's deaths
22:24 - Conclusion (which was better)

Пікірлер: 28

@happybee7725 Ай бұрын

In the books it’s insinuated that Lord Tywin arranged the whole Westerling thing with Jeyne Westerlings mother.

@FilmCritiqueHub 17 күн бұрын

correct, good spot.

@happybee7725 17 күн бұрын

@@FilmCritiqueHub I had someone completely disagree with that opinion about a week ago. According to him Robb and Jeyne just happened naturally which makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. The Westerlings are said to be an old and proud family. A proud family doesn’t allow their virgin daughter to be ploughed by the just visiting leader of their leige lords enemy without some kind of assurances from their liege lord. There are several other reasons it doesn’t make sense but I can’t really be assed typing it all out again.

@FilmCritiqueHub 17 күн бұрын

Yeah it definitely makes more sense that they had assurances from Tywin. I remember reading about it elsewhere as well. I do think however while Jeynes mother most likely pushed her to “seduce” Robb, she did actually fall in love with him. IIRC, GRRM did say Jeyne was going to be a central part of TWOW prologue, so it might get confirmed there. I’m very interested to see what role she has to play. I’m almost certain she’s not pregnant, but whatever happens to her it’ll most certainly tie in with the blackfish.

@happybee7725 17 күн бұрын

@@FilmCritiqueHub Yes I agree that she did love Robb. I assumed jeyne wasn’t in on it. Just that her parents let it happen or which is not something a noble parent would usually let happen in that situation. If their daughter sleeps with a guest it’s coz they let it happen. Maybe even encouraged Jeyne without Jeyne realising it. She is just a naive young girl after all. I dare say we will find out.

@ZestyPhresh 7 ай бұрын

Hope to see you continue trying with this channel! You've got a lot of potential and seem passionate!

@matthewwhite3967 10 ай бұрын

Definitely liked the book better. As you said, you could cut the tension leading up to the Wedding with a knife. It was so well done in the book. The show did a good job, but it loses some of it's impact. Still it was a great scene from a time before the show started going down hill.

@GoetzimRegen 2 ай бұрын

The first chapter begins with dead direwolf mother who was killed through an antler or that Caitlyn Strong will dye in a fight for the crone of Robert.

@steve_en5903 4 ай бұрын

Replace that battery bro

@Kaboomboo 2 ай бұрын

Fr fr

@chocolateanimegirl9910 2 ай бұрын

@@Kaboomboo on god

@JordanRiddell 3 күн бұрын

High quality video mate. Defo make more 👍🏼 I've just finished GOT and this scene fked me up big time lol

@FilmCritiqueHub 2 күн бұрын

Glad you enjoyed the video. You now have got almost 2 seasons of HOTD to watch now!

@OmgItsTania 14 күн бұрын

Great video. I agree with you in finding the show version better. But i watched the show first so for me its difficult to compare because it was a total surprise to me, rather than when i read the books and knew what was gonna happen. Great breakdown in the video 🙏🏽

@FilmCritiqueHub 13 күн бұрын

I also watched the show first so I get where you’re coming from. In the books it’s a slow buildup which I appreciated more. But the show did great because I remember still being in shock for 20 mins after the episode ended 😂😂😂

@OmgItsTania 13 күн бұрын

@@FilmCritiqueHub omg the trauma was REAL bro

@masteroftheassassins Ай бұрын

I didn't read the books and I didn't watch the show when it aired, but everyone kept talking about this particular event that there was no escaping it. Even so, I was truly caught off guard of just how brutal it was when I finally watched it. Just goes to show you that even hearing about it doesn't do it justice and it's something you need to see for yourself to truly grasp the horror of it.

@happybee7725 Ай бұрын

@masteroftheassassins I’m a book guy. I do enjoy the show but I think the books are MUCH better. However I agree with you on the point that the red wedding is better seen than read. I have thought that myself for a long time. When read it’s not as much of a surprise as It is when watched so I think you’ve hit the nail right on the head there buddy.

@FilmCritiqueHub 17 күн бұрын

The show is usually limited on what they can show, however watching big moments like this is always more emotional than reading it in a book.