Like this comment if you think United should stick with ten Hag.

If we get Southgate I’m becoming a Salford Fan

This debate about Ten Hag is mental, he's one of the worlds top coaches and I was shouting to get him through the door. Right manager, right club, wrong time with regards to the idiots we've had running the the club. The shite he's had to deal with in 2 seasons and still managed to get that squad into the champions league and win the league cup. Bearing in mind EtH himself said when he joined he's going to need around 6 windows before we can start challenging (if I remember right). As a contrast Pound shop Pep has been at Arsenal with a proper structure behind him for what? 5 years and still won nothing?

You've had about 600 manager debates on this channel this season. Give it a rest

I want De Zerbi or Motta. I think we need someone with a clear uncompromising philosophy for the rebuild. With Ten Hag there's just too many issues with how we set up. It would be one thing if we were set up right but the players were failing I'd stick with Ten Hag. But now we are set up bad AND the players are poor.

I don't know if Ten Hag is the manager that will lead United back to glory. But I do know that bringing in a new manager in the summer is setting them up for failure. The squad is still a mess and the backroom staff still needs to be put in place and brought up to speed. Why ask a new manager to deal with all that nonsense? Let's set a manager up for succes for once.

Simple maths. So many variables leading to us being poor, if you keep changing all the variables you’ll never work out which ones are causing the issues. Deal with the variables in turn, we’re finally sorting the structure out, hopefully sorting player recruitment out, give ETH one more season, even if it’s to hone in on the problem points.

Problem with Thiago Motta is that he has a good concept, but it doesn't yield that many goals, nor do we know whether it can work in a quicker league. Why we just looking to replace experimental with experimental without sorting out the structure first?

I mean look what happened to Ajax post Ten Hag. He clearly has an idea of how he wants to play and is a good coach, he just has 5 other managers players not his own team

I really wish i had a voice. Why? Because i here people searching for a manager with a style of play due to the "lack of one that Ten Hag has". Ten Hag in Ajax had a serious style of play! So people need to understand that changing to a manager with a "style of play" is nonsense due to the clubs structure (or perhaps past structure now with INEOS..)

Honestly think people severely underrate how badly a job Ten Hags doing. We’ve been God awful since the league cup final last year. If a manager like Moyes or Mourinho had led to us to a season like this we’d demand their head and rightly so

The fact INEOS / Ratcliffe haven't publicly committed to sticking with ETH will not be helping the dressing room. They need to publicly back him otherwise some players will think he's getting sacked and this impacts performances. I personally think ETH should be given one more season. Yes, this season has been extremely poor and yes there doesn't seem to be any direction, but there's arguably mitigating circumstances, including a squad with gaping holes from prior team structures. The gamble on eriksen and casemiro only paid off for one season. The injuries to Shaw, Martinez, Malacia have been damming, whereby no left back is extremely detrimental to our left wing play and Rashfords game. That and our back up defensive options force an entirely different approach due to their strengths / weaknesses. Then there's the issues with Sancho, Greenwood, Donny and to some extent Antony (although Antony has shown improvement of late). There is also no manager available that guarantees anything. Only Pep arguably guarantees anything and that's not happening. The club need to decide what they're doing with Sancho and Greenwood. Cash in this summer or if deciding ETH has to go, there's possibly a role for Sancho or both. They need to let go of Varane, Lindelöf, Eriksen, Casemiro, Martial and those on loan like Donny, Williams and Fernandez. They need 2 x quality cms; one out and out DM and one who can cover DM. They need a left back and centre back. They need an additional and experienced striker. The like of Maguire, McTomminay and Rashford should not be sold unless significant offers are made such that quality replacements can be bought. For a start Maguire and McTomminay have been the few positives of the season. They're important for the squad morale and work ethic. They're useful squad members. Rashfords game will improve when paired with a left back and an experienced striker whilst hojlund develops his game.

There’s no chat Jay🤣🤣

A club the size of UTD need a manager to have time to build not 1 or 2 seasons this club needs even longer Youth system is what it's all about

I honestly think the last 10 plus years has been KARMA from the days I used to say we are winning the league too easy back in early 00s we need competition 😢😢😂

Changing the manager will not fix the problems at this club the same as it didnt get fixed with all the managers who have been here since sir alex retired. Im to the point now i dont care who the manager is to me its the players and their cohesiveness to all play a specific style of football. I dont even know what that style is going to be ineos havent said what they want and we do not have the personnel to play like ten hag wants either and thats a high line with pressing from the front 6 and a sweeper keeper to play out from the back.

Two seasons was a stick, IMO. Now it's time for a twist.

It’s a deep rooted cultural problem. Give Ten Hag total support, root out the bad eggs, reset expectations to that of an actual elite football club (perform and behave to the highest professional standards or you’re out)and give him the players he needs - which doesn’t mean giving him the players he wants.

Let’s try a new manager and keep all the 3rd rate players. Rumour has it mctominay is just waiting for the right manager to unveil his Xavi like abilities.

With Inzhagi or Motta, one thing you'll get with either of these is a structured style of play, and with a decent summer clear out and a few decent players in, we would make huge strides. ETHs been found out this year, his players haven't a clue what there at on that pitch, its under 10s football. Forget about the likes of Southgate, Potter or De Zerbi.

Well done to the under 18s team champions ❤❤❤

Ten Hag and MOTA , no difference. They are both good coaches.

It’s just not the right time to sack the manager. The situation at director level, the euros and the choice of available candidates all support sticking with ETH. If he was sacked tomorrow everyone would say he did decent on the whole and he’d walk into another job. Best to just stick with a decent manager while a proper strategy is put in place above him.

Gareth Southgates greatest achievement was being Roy Keanes Footstool!

The problem with the give Eth another season is that we could waste another season trying to figure out how the 3-1-6 in possession football will work. I can't think of any player or players that can cover the grounds and the gaps in midfield. The Dutch league isn't the EPL. The only way it could work is if we buy the perfect players in every position .

8th May 13 - Fergie retires Since then, we’ve had 5 permanent managers and a 6 month stand by in Ralf (ignoring Giggs and Carrick as caretakers). That’s pretty much averaging 2 seasons per manager. So accordingly to the averages, Ten Haag goes. How’s that trend working for us? It’s time to change now. Give him his last year. One year, doing really well with much less injuries with a top 3 finish, FA Cup final and Leauge cup. Second year, shit load of injuries, battle for top 5, FA Cup semi. It’s not a fall from grace exactly is it. How can a poor season, that 70% of it can be explained cost one person his job when we can all see the players on pitch are struggling???

Why was Zidane not mentioned as a potential replacement? 🤨 And Jay, I'm as close as being one of those ones you apparently can't believe exists..... I rate Southgate and think he can do a decent job at United. I'd put him second after Zidane. We need the players at United to be inspired, clearly Southgate is that inspirational figure because morale in that England team was ABSOLUTELY on the floor. And we absolutely are underrating the psychological achievements with England. - We never won a penalty shootout, ever now won one with him ✅ - we never won against Germany in a knockout game. We then did under his tenure ✅ - we'd not qualified for a final since 1966 in an international tournament. We then did with him ✅ - Let's not forget the the fact we got too a world cup semi. The first time done 1966, and the first tournament full stop since 1996 ✅ How can you not give him credit for all this? Why is the magnitude of all these achievements downgraded? They were HUGE milestones weighing down in the team. And we have HUGE psychological constraints on us at United. So on that front I can't think of anyone better!

Stick or Twist? Twist, Twist, TWIST!!!

I wish we had more than one striker

The whole point of the new Ineos structure is to identify a way of playing, then appoint a manager who plays that style or close as. It's then up to the Ineos team to provide players in the system and get rid of the others that don't fit.

Well said, all our problems predate tenHag. Getting him out now will just add to the long to do list of the restructuring and man is is long even to outsiders like me. Even if there's another manager in mind, lets get the structure straight before getting them cause if we get a new manager now, they'll fail like the many before him

Motta for me, if you watch in depth analysis of the 2-7-2 style he imposes, it suits the PL massively. His philosophy aswell when he describes when his teams attacking, they think of defending and when they're defending they think of attacking, sounds obtuse but makes total sense.

Look what he’s done to our academy and how the acedemy are performing and listen to what the academy staff say about him and what he’s doing our 11 just simply don’t care for the shirt they wear it’s that simple now it’s clealry players not giving a crap or trying hard enough and maybe Erik is sticking with these lot to show inoes who esactly should be booted out every single second season the players fall of the cliff it took arteta 4 years to get second just to get second and yet he’s still winning nothing but no talks of him being sacked we need to ride the storm and we need to aim for something that’s realistic and get rid of players before new players come in or they all fall down with the same lazy illness these lot keep getting. Plus how much does it keep costing us soacking managers but are happy to keep martial and Phil jones around some players should be released and we take the hit on them otherwise they stay and nothing changes we must ride the storm properly

Bro’s Liverpool had an exact same drop off last season before after so many games and going all the way in that champions league final, lots of people forget that. This squad and manager just needs a bit of rejuvenation and some rest and some luck with injuries and I think we’ll be able to at least complete 2 FA cup semi finals, potentially 2 FA cup final’s consecutively is no fluke is it?

We've had every type of manager since Fergie?? Now fans want to get rid of another one,before the right structure has been put in place? These players what have seen 3 managers off ( don't need to name them) need to be off loaded! Ineos should come out & back the manager & get rid of the freeloaders! No manager could sort this group of players out ! Overpayed, lazy & pre madonnas! We need young energetic players with fight in them!

It didn't take Klopp 5-6 years to show what he was trying to build so I don't see how Ten hag gets that especially with how we are playing.

My question to Erik ten Hag is that he has failed to use the players he bought for the club, only Casemiro and Martinez have been able to show their potentials.

Let CEO decide on Tens future. With player power and the injury crisis with 400 mil misspent its not an easy decision.

People forget ETH had a good first season. Sort the structure and the underperforming players first

ETH IS NOT THE PROBLEM. THE SHIT KICKING THE BALL IS THE PROBLEM GET NEW PLAYERS .

You pick RDZ who finished behind ETH in league. RDZ worked under proper structure still finished behind ETH who worked with no structure. I have started questioning from where this punditry coming from. Style of football is dependant on players, get rid of Rashy's, Mc's, Snacho's and recruit good players then you'll see ETH style.

I don't know if Motta or De Zerbi fits United's philosophy though, too much positional play/ possession. More speed/transitional football done at a top level like Klopp or Ancelotti's teams, but I can't think of a coach that can implement that besides them.

The issue nowadays is that fans think that just because we are Manchester United we can get whoever we want. Too many people think that simply we can just flex our muscles and everyone will come swooning. We stink man, no player or manager wants to come here the faster we accept that and be patient, the happier the outcomes will be

Stick please and thank you. Ten Hag Revolution incoming. U18s are champions, new structure is incoming, this job is created in his likeness. Jim is not dumb enough to let him slip.

Klopp was incredible straight away btw

Who has Southgate beaten in a tournement?

Rashford paddock trying to get eth sack so their poster boy can continue earning half a mil everyweek doing nothing

I love this endless debate

I don’t think it matters what we think! Ineos have already decided he done a couple games ago ☹️

Thomas Touchel will be the next Man Utd manager

I wouldn’t trust him with another transfer window yet alone another full season of him getting battered by other teams away and him falling out with players left right and center

If we do all want a clear out then even if we keep eth or maybe get mcKenna, tell the manager to get rid of 10 players and only buy a couple, the rest play the youth for a season, take a mid table but then we will have a brand new team the following season, we need to have a massive clear out and how else can we do it, anyways just an idea ha

I think it's gonna be another disaster if ten hag is replaced. This squad is shite. Give him another window and I think we'll see some massive improvement under erik.

I think this is a real tough one but I think give ten hag one more year albeit he could be gone Christmas 24 if results go badly wrong

When his biggest "success" is the Argentinian Phil Jones and his tactics are so poor even Jamie Carragher can poke enormous holes in them, surely we cant have him at the centre of an attempt to overhaul and rebuild the club.

Disagree with Adam's comments at 3:00 ... look how quickly Ange got Spurs playing decent football

What’s the point of getting another young manager in, another new style that won’t be implemented because these lot don’t want to work hard and lack quality

Stick with the manager, no ones named a better candidate

Back the manager and get him the fucking players to suit his system! Get rid of the players that are toxic to that dressing room and the average overpaid players.

Even god comes as manager won't change anything until u sell Rashford,Maguire, MCT and some of the few.

Just cut the crap jay,if ur short of something th chat on about,try listing the deadwood to move on. Get behind ETH instead of going for cheap clicks! Snide way of stirring the ship

Adam talks a lot of sense

Well changing managers is something that hasn't worked how many more managers do Man Utd need I mean for 22 years I've been a fan for 11 years it was great when it lasted won everything there was but then 11 years after a couple of silverware was decent but not great. But since 2017/18 it's been very downwards some shocking defeats and lowest points football started to becoming depressing but in truth how many good seasons have Man Utd had barely 2-3. But once Man Utd finish a decent position there's always something negative that follows. Till this day this season has been bad but not as bad it was 2021/22. But he's had almost 2 years Erik ten Hag he's got a bang average team 3rd with a league cup but this season the expectation was too much but I know from the past Man Utd have one or two good seasons then have a stinking season. The only suprise is Man Utd are playing so bad against everyone not just the best sides. I mean taking points from Liverpool feels like we actually lost knowing we should of lost. But that's not the case. Erik ten Hag tactics wise he's come up with some silly excuses but sometimes you just feel there's deep into it. These players are selfish and don't listen they stop playing the body language tells you players like Marcus Rashford in the last 4 years he's had one good season then vanishes into air. Man Utd we're pressured before this current season started 23/24. They finish 8th it's what they deserve because they've played bad. Gareth Southgate never want that ever not even when I'm old not good enough.middlesbrough was his only club management. Erik ten Hag should at least have until his contract until next year. If it doesn't work out then I think he will go himself.

If Nagelsman is off to Bayern why don’t we look at Tuchel? More proven than any of the candidates you’ve just mentioned

Jose still better than all those options

With united being united whoever is the cheapest option will be the one.

Tired of this southgate bullshit

I don't rate Ten Hag but I think they should keep him until they can get the manager they want. No point making a sub-optimal appointment just to get rid of Ten Hag. He is okay as an interim manager.

Id stick with ETH 1 more season, but if we move on, we need someone with huge personality like Zidane

Imagine this squad trying to play De Zerbi football lol they can't pass or run

The truth is ETH is at the worst run big football club in the world,with greedy and selfish players on and off the field,Ten hag is not allowed to focus on footballing for even a day.

What do u guys think of Xavi? young, idol for some players, currently doing a good job at Barca (after a problematic start) and he will be free at the end of the season. Sure probably he will take a sabbatical but we should try to get him. Could be an interesting project with him, if u want to build smth new.

Ten Hag ❤

What if bayern win the champions league? Is tuchel in with a shout, given two champions leagues and his experience with chelsea 🤔

no disrespect to any of these managers i would rather stick with ETH for 1 more year

get Ted Lasso in, couldn’t be much worse.

what is the point with a new manager when you have a bunch of losers on the pitch

De Zerbi. 2nd season dip in standings - excuses are made for him. Potter, at one of the BIG Prem teams. Blame placed on having too many players and blame placed on the owner. ten Hag. More injuries to starters - and out for longer - than any other team by a good sized margin. Player maturity issues, player effort issues, player age issues, player quality issues. Mainstream press and online peanut gallery pundits - TEN HAG OUT. Year one with players who sullied the reputations of three previous managers, 3rd-place finish. Now, beginning with INSANE U.S. preseason jaunt mandated by blatant money whore owners (conveniently forgotten is ten Hag being all but openly chastised for not playing Mason Mount IMMEDIATELY after his acquisition in the preseason despite him coming off an injury-ridden previous season because… jersey sales profits) that set the table for the inordinate number of injuries, plus having a non-existent recruitment team, (yes, it WAS MURTOUGH, et al who didn’t get Antony at 32-35M instead waiting until they had to pay 80M! - United is 7th. Immature players. Players deciding whether or not a game is worth 100% effort who then pout when benched the next game. A 19-year old striker who just finished his first season as the main #9… IN THE DANISH LEAGUE! A team captain who’s played more minutes than any other Prem player over the last 3 seasons outside of keepers. Immaturity on full display by your team’s star AND his 19-year old opposite wing mate… and the player with THE most consistent in and off pitch composure is… EIGHTEEN!!!! What to do?! Eric ten Hag -- OUT! Brilliant.

Stick or Twist? Sounds naughty. Noice Producer Ethan.

Southgate is a no no

De zerbi is better, because he have patterns of play Ten hag don't. United need to sell some unuseful players then we are good to go!.

Where is Joe Smith?

Don't get this idea removing manager with great credentials for building process, which some idiotic groups expected to be resolved within club chaos after two seasons "unbelievable" to replace him with 'pop up manager' 😅 who will have the same dog to teach new tricks..... Mental suicide.

ETH is my manager. Get rid of the same players thats downed tools again for another manager

574 shots allowed this season so far. Nearly 19 shots allowed per game. Most losses in a Premier League Season. Negative Goal Difference. Over 400 Mil pounds net spend... "TEN HAG NEEDS MORE TIME TO SEE THIS MANAGER DEVELOP HIS STYLE" "NOT HIS FAULT, HE HAS NO STRUCTURE BEHIND HIM" "PERFORMANCE ARE AWFUL BUT I THINK HES A TOP LAD" The absolute delusion of so many United supporters.

Do a poll Jay, TH in or out then please leave it will ya coz you do my fuc**ng head in with all this

Stick Let him get on with the job and clear out the dead wood

While I'm not completely convinced by anyone. I'm far from convinced by five Hag. Tricky one. If we win the cup is all forgiven ?

Dzerbi all the way

Majority wanted Ten Hag for his Ajax style. He was told we play transition football. It all depends on Ashworths headline if what we are going to be.

ETH keep the faith 🚩

Southgate in

Ten Hag too stay! If does leaves hope he’s the next England manager

Players First, even if we we're trying to get rid of Sunak as manager.

The team has been absolutely shite all season ..not one game here or one there ..all season!

When is Smithers back from experimenting in Thailand? I need some toxic positivity. The mood on this channel is miserable atm

Get your words out son

I think this page desperately wants him sacked. Too many videos about new managers and times up etc. Hes been here 2 years using the EXACT same players as the last 4 managers

Unai emery?

Where is JOE