I am a retired 28 year police officer, and I can't wait until this Trooper Proctor guy gets on the stand, because he is gonna get destroyed

Someone commented today that the prosecution is spending so much time trying to defend the Alberts that they’ve forgotten to prosecute KR. I keep wondering if they’ll get around to it but who knows at this point.

Best part of the day was defense asking the animal DNA lady “would you store samples in red solo cups?” and her response is just “…I’m sorry, what??” 😂 amazing

“Re-homed their phones” Peter, you’re the best! 😂😂

My 19 yr old eyes bulged when the screen shot of texts came into evidence. He said those so easily could be doctored or created at a later date! This trial is mind blowing.

An overwhelming amount of reasonable doubt and more doubt gets raised with almost every witness so far

HOLY FREAKING HECK!! I watched this live on EDB. I completely MISSED that she said "When John was there." Just freaking WOW! 😮 😮

So…the state is saying that Karen hit him on purpose, then came back to the scene when police arrived hours later just to say, “I hit him!” over and over? None of their theory makes any sense.

I didn't catch Allison stating "when John was at the house" before, but now that it's been pointed out to me, I'm guessing that slip is part of why she broke down crying; not only has she been harassed but she's covering for someone or more than one person and she knows that didn't sound good for the prosecution.

John was there, everybody knows it.

Poor John O’Keefe…RIP……💙🖤 I hope he somehow gets justice💙🖤

You dont even need to edit the messages. I could get a second phone, save the number on my phone as anyone I want like say depp, have a back and forth with myself where "depp" admits to hitting his misses for fun when she did nothing wrong, screenshot it, and based on the screenshot alone you have no way of telling if that convo is authentic or not. screenshot of that fake convo would be indistinguishable from a screenshot of the real thing. here theyre using the screenshots as evidence that supports them not not being at a location at a time, theres evidence that goes against the texts, but the witness vouching for the screenshots came across sympathetic to the jury with her cry about harassment, so who are the tech illiterate jurors gonna believe? All of this being allowed in was so messed up. I hope the defence has enough material and by the end the jury wont put much on this witness and her "texts".

I'm hoping the verdict is not guilty, but even if it isn't, we'll never know the truth of what happened. Which really sucks for John and his family.

Too bad they didn’t let the Federal investigation finish before bringing this to court. ( iMO)

Peter, can we have a “What’s. Up. Every. Buddy.” shirt? I say it with you every time.

I don’t think Life 360 is off enough to create entire trips accidentally.

The solo cup part had me rolling this morning 😂

Complete incompetency of Police investigation!!!!

If Allison didn't think the "screen shots" of texts weren't relevant then why did she take them?

I give Peter SO MUCH CREDIT for remaining objective & only watching & discussing what the Jurors see/hear. This case is wild!

I totally caught the Feds comment and the one about John being at the house! Life 360 was a great find too.

The defense AND the Commonwealth agreed that none of the harassment issues should be brought up, the Judge disagreed!! Btw, her MOM is the one that brought these poor kids in.

It feels like everyone had something to hide in that house and the guests. Then the series of the unfortunate events we will never know about happened and it led to this tragedy. The more we get through the trial the more confused I am…..

I caught that too, Peter! She said “when John was at the house”!!!! HUGE Freudian slip! I wonder if that’s actually why she got emotional, because she knew she slipped.

One of the investigators who took DNA swaps failed the course to make sure they were proficient. Ryan sat behind KR car for 5 mins and didn’t notice a broken taillight. He said the break lights were on, meaning there would be one white and one red break light if one was broke

Have been watching all of trial from beginning. I didn't have any prior knowledge and have now found myself skipping the prosecution as it got to the point where I was losing the will to live.

1:27:20 Allie: "He was not at the house when John was there. So, I drove him home. 1:27:57 "So he's, people are harassing him saying he was at the house when (pause), not true." At the pause, was she going to say it again, that John was there, but caught herself because of the previous Freudian slip?

That month with no texts between best friends is smoking gun evidence that cell phone data was tampered with

As a jury member I am voting to acquit. Way too many inconsistencies and things not tracking.

Trial today was such a roller coaster! Thank you Peter for taking the time to recap the trial on a daily basis with all of us! 💗 I appreciate it immensely and always learn something new.

Important detail Ryan and the girlfriend in the truck said the dome light inside the dark SUV (KR Lexus) was ON, This giving them better visibility. Only saw a women, not a man like they had noticed when the SUV first drove up. Plus, all 3 in the F-150 said they were not watching the SUV or front yard/ house when Julie Nagel talked to them at the truck for close to 5 minute. J O Keefe could have walked into the house at that time without them seeing him. Their focus was on their phones or on Julie during this time. AJ brought thought out in his cross. Did anyone hear what time of the night this was?

Do you realize the prosecution keep bringing witnesses that help the defense more than it help them? Could it be that they're trying to throw the case instead of dropping the charges? Maybe they're afraid to drop charges due to the power play in that small town.

I'm outside of Boston and when I saw you on the news, I laughed and sent it to my friends and said, I TOLD YOU HE'S THE BEST! Haha great job!

“He was not at the house when John was there” the Prosecutor has always said John was not there. Whoopsy… I’m not doubting she’s been harassed. Imagine how Karen Read feels being framed for murder! IMO

This is getting juicy. I knew it I'm originally from Boston, and we are very hot 😮blooded and loyal to the end and I live in upstate NY. I remember when you said you didnt really want to cover this case. Thanks for covering this case you break it down so simple for us. Justice for John O'Keefe. And Karen Read. Love ❤️ and hugs 🫂

Great coverage!!

Why was everyone hiding the fact that Colin Albert was at that house that evening ? It’s even more concerning when you see a photograph taken a few weeks later & his knuckles are all cut up from obviously punching someone or something. His explanation on how he got those injuries is absurd.

Somebody has flipped imho. The defense has their ducks in a row. She is innocent

Love your channel. Thank you so much for the nightly recaps and the time you give all of us with your busy life!!!

Hello, I have watched all of your videos and I really appreciate your explanation of the process and overview of cases.

I don’t feel sorry for them.The defense didn’t put them on the stand, their parents and the corrupt system did.Nobody from their family was found dead in the yard.

If there's a silver lining to see here, I think it's the way so much of the public has had Karen's back and expressed disappointment that she's even in this situation. Not that it makes up for much but it's atleast good to know the public has the good since to see through the 🐂💩.

Great analysis!

Great coverage Peter

Would pig DNA come from a pig ear being chewed on by the dog?

When candy crush was popular it you lock you out from game play for a few hours and my mom would go in the settings on her iPhone and change the time which would speed up the time in the game to unlock the next game

Peter thanks so much for your coverage! I like hearing your recaps. LIke most people I can't watch the entire trial and miss things and having recently sat as a juror I can also say even being there you sometimes miss things. Also yes you can change time and time zones I live within 20 miles of the where Eastern time switches to Central and sometimes my phone has switched to Central so I force it to stay Eastern.

Why did Ally think to take screenshots of the conversation of she didn’t think it was relevant until over a year later? If the texts were still on her phone why are these texts coming in from a screenshot and not an extraction report?

Regarding Allison McCabe's 360 data I think the defense is going to introduce evidence from video cameras after the prosecution rests.

She is lying. We have life 360. Never off like that. The whole crying thing. She seems very manipulative to me.

Peter, your coverage is so great. My next membership will be to your channel for sure. ❤

I ❤ your recaps, you are so straight down the line. Court facts and commentary not taking sides.

You ROCK, Peter!!! 🚀💥 I’m a fan of your channel (from the beginning) because of your integrity and quality of character❣️ Thank you for being you!!! ⚖️

I want to know why if Allie and Colin are such good friends, according to her screenshot,after she picked him up, their next text is February 20th with a random text of "on a zoom"? Really, after what happened that night they didn't even text about it for 3 weeks? Is that because there are deleted texts? We'll never know since this is just a screenshot.

Peter I’m so happy your getting the recognition you deserve! I see those views and subs sky rocketing! Been here since the beginning 💪🏼 so cool to see how your channel has grown

Outstanding coverage Peter! As a fellow 40er love the Mike Gundy reference!

The screenshot- fonts look off- there are no outline’s bubbles on the other side from her blue- plus no emojis at all- maybe not but I’d like to see some recent texts for comparison purposes.

The photos of Colin introduced in court today were weeks after John was killed. There are photos online where he has a swollen eye and scabs on his knuckles. If he were injured during this fight, I wonder if he missed school the following week.

My best friend and I have a text thread on my phone going back to April of 2021, both iPhones, all iMessages… there is NO second comma. There’s a month and day, a comma, the year, and then ‘at’ with the time. The only comma is like ‘April 28, 2021 at 8:30pm’

Problem is their texts say 12:10, but waterfall video shows BA & N.A. leaving around 12:14, they testified that N.A. bumped into him in the foyer and BA said he was at the table.

At this point, im convinced the prosecution is going for quantity over quantity. Ive taken to watching other YT videos while Lally is questioning the witnesses cause we all know it was snowing, but he continues to ask every witness if it was snowing. Along with a litany of other cumulative questions. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Messages usually only show a timestamp if a certain amount of time has passed between messages but that doesn’t explain the texts from Colin having no bubble around them or the comma after the year in the timestamp among other issues

Hi! I've been watching you from day 1. How are you so "normal" and you are a lawyer? I don't know what I would do without your points of view. LOL. I'm obsessed with trials because I was in divorce court for 7 years and lived through a nightmare. Now I watch all the suffering of others and try to give them support! You are AMAZING!

just wanted to say that, i am watching the entire trial.. but these recaps are so good... Peter touches on every important point, and some points that i didnt even realise were important. starting to wonder why i am sitting through every repetitive description of the same things, when i could just watch these and still be aware of everything relevant 😂

Allie said something like “mine is the blue bubble, Collin is the light grey bubble” - there is no grey bubble. But should be.

Colin not there when John was there…….WOW big slip of the tongue😄😄😄😄

You can change the transpareny and bubble color of the imessages through third party apps and the acessibility function of the iphone.

I believe they’re asking whether or not he heard anything from the vehicle in front of them, insinuating, the two arguing or someone yelling.

It is sad they were harassed but how convenient she cried after admitting John was there when Collin was not!

I believe that when Karen pulled up to the driveway, John jumped out and hurried in the side door. Then pulled up to the mailbox, this is why none of the 3 in the truck saw him go in and why it was only Karen they saw in the suv when they pulled away.

“Would you use a solo cup?” “What now?” 😂😂

Peter Thank you for picking this case apart as a juror. I think your experience as a lawyer nails each day of testimony. I NEVER watched KZfaq before you, and now I'm hooked on LYK!!😊

Wow ! Missed the slip up re John at house ! It would be so hard to be a juror on this trial! Thanks for your thoughts Peter 🇺🇸♥️🕊🇺🇸

12:10 seems significant. It’s the exact time Julie Albert said Chris Albert got home. Per the video, he didn’t leave the bar until 12:14.

Ty LYK ! I appreciate your unbiased breakdown. Love you and your father!

I've never had texts transfer to new phone. I always have to reset up new messenger ect account

I don't think jurors find not guilty because of a bad investigation. Theres a very big difference between saying this person probably did it but they are not getting a fair trial so i'm going to find them not guilty (which is a very high standard to met as a juror and more of a matter for an appellate court) and knowing that the investigators and prosecutors are intentionally not collecting and providing evidence because that information would cause me as a juror to find Karen not guilty and demonstrate somebody else was responsible. As a juror I would also be very angry that the prosecution thinks i'm stupid enough to not see through all of this and not be aware of very basic things, like when Brian said he didn't hand his phone over because he got a new one, a juror knows Brian AND the police would be aware that apple would prompt him to sync all his data on his new phone. The would only do something like that if the data demonstrates a different person was responsible for the crime. That gives me a reason to go beyond reasonable doubt and believe that the evidence has been intentionally withheld by the police and witnesses because it proves her innocence and someone else's guilt.

She could have simply changed the contact name, and she could have been talking to someone else. I can't believe this screenshot was allowed with no real authentication.

She is a decent actress. Notice how she rarely looks at the Jurors during all questioning. Except cue the "The Door has been opened, ill allow it" questions on harassment. She then looks directly at the jurors and wells up some amber tears (no tears). The staring at the jury along with the facial expressions and the "Cant I have a moment" was well played buy her and I think she scored points with the jury. Of course no door was really opened for it. But that does not matter if you have biased Ref/Judge

1:19:30 There is an argument to be made that the “turn wifi on” notification supports the idea that she had re-set the time and date on her phone. If you have WiFi on, your phones time and date should sync to local time, re-setting the time/date change

Thanks for the daily recaps!

Karen Read gave an interview that aired on Nightline a year ago. She said she was waiting in the car for John to confirm they were actually invited and welcome there. She told John that she did not hear the two of them be invited. She seemed to think John admired Brian Albert and wanted to go, but it was really other family members at their table who were being invited. She said she saw John walk toward the side door and waited for him to check with the residents and call her, but he didn't call her or answer her calls, so she left. I've wondered how she expected him to get home with no jacket. She may have thought he would call her when he wanted to come home. In any event, it appears there was a lot of snow under John's body, and there should not have been. Even when Julie Nagle left at 1:45 am, she said you could still see some grass. It's as if he vanished. Heather, the former girlfriend of Ryan Nagle, saw a male in the passenger seat of Karen's car when it made a right turn into the street right before they made a left turn into the same street. The next time she looked in the car, it was only Karen. There was no high speed or reverse movements of her vehicle. All I can figure is that maybe John snuck off to take a leak on his way into the party and that he was assaulted then. His body was moved, because there wasn't enough blood under his body from that gash on the back of his head. I think those are claw scratches and claw punctures along the outside of his right arm from a dog. I don't think a racoon would do that. The dog may have found John's body after it was already down. The fact that people upgraded their phones and deleted evidence means they were hiding something, but I don't know if it means they were hiding evidence related to John. His death may have been an accident, but I think his body was moved. So, why?

Peter,I have seen Dateline episodes wiith far more evidence where charges still are not brought.I am surprised that this case was allowed to go forward.

In my case when a vehicle is approaching me at night with their headlights on, I can't see anything inside the vehicle due to the lights in my eyes and glare on the windshield. This is also worse when it is snowing.

There is at least a 10 minute time black hole. Homeowners saw him when they got home but they didn’t leave the bar till about the time she texted she was there to pick him up.

Wi-Fi wouldn’t need to be on if you are using your data when you are out and about driving around

how do we know the swabs were of the torn area of the sweatshirt and not from the lower hem. As far as I know, the clothes are missing. the sweatshirt itself should have gone to the lab. It was refreshing to hear ryan and heather, two witnesses that seemed to be truthful

Peter, you have been great with this one. Your excitement makes me listen better!!!!

Peter, You are the Best Lawyer on KZfaq! Your Channel Outshines all others! Your analysis and explanations are Amazing! And I Love the Grace You give to people! Thank You!!! 🙏🏻

The dna persons response to the solo cups was just brilliant

So a witness saw her sitting in the vehicle with the light on alone - so where was John????

Also, I’ve learned by being hyper focused on this trial and all of the different people/lawyers covering it a couple of things. 1.) Peter deserves his own Primetime show or to be appointed to a circuit court as a federal judge. 2.) It reminded me to upgrade my phone.

The Life360 data sounds like exact gps and tower gps alternating when the exact gps didn’t register. Your Apple API gives obfuscated data to 3rd parties. Only you signed into your own icloud looking at Find My can see exact gps data in real-time. Otherwise you are getting data at 30 to 60 second intervals. It’s not uncommon for this obfuscated data to give a gps location centered on a cell tower or centered on a poorly localized location circle.

Erin Brockovitch is rumoured to be en route to Canton to take water and soil samples to see if she can get to the bottom of the mysterious memory loss.

The pig DNA is important I think because that is found in dog treats!

Chicks check photos always. Take a ton of pictures. No way she keeps a random screenshot of useless text for that long. I don’t believe any of these people.

Think maybe Julie Nagel admitting she was drunk Was Julie's possible way out of being charged with perjury

I enjoy how you're so open minded. Just keep looking at the evidence, before judging❤

Peter's explanation of why witnesses remember some things and not other things due to preparation and review of previous statements just made so much sense. Just dropping knowledge like it ain't no thang. We are lucky to have him as a resource. Truly.

Holy crap look how her face changes immediately after she says John was at the house 😮😮😮😮 The defense heard it but they don't want to call it out they wanted to keep going they want her to feel comfortable telling the truth.