Can you send me the link to the original video?

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html He explained well

What about the prohibition of the printing press in the Islamic world?

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/bJZ6ldKXy7XMkas.html

What who said that ?

Lol read the “Inconsistencies of the Philosophers” by Al-Ghazali before you talk about the issue.

It’s now 2023

@@yesthisisyoursign yep

@@speadskater the fact that you still have your KZfaq account after 6 years is commitment 😭 I could never

@@yesthisisyoursign oh, buddy, this account was made when people could do video replies to other videos.

Just checked. My first liked video was 16 years ago. This account is old. I'm old. Damn...

The progress of science in that period is due to the encouragement of Islam to learn science and its teaching by the shia Imams Some of the infallible shia Imams had the opportunity to be educated. Others could not do so due to exile, imprisonment, war , social problem ,and government pressure, while all of them had divine knowledge. Imam seadegh, imam bagher (They are twelve. Eleven of them were martyred and one of them is in absentia (Imam Mahdi) who will appear with Jesus Christ and save the world from oppression)had opportunity to teach some student that some of them They became scientists like razy (Alcohol discoverer and chemist and other science) I dont remember all names They are became big sciecifict) These are just some of the exceptional references in the Qur'an 1400 years ago. Fingerprints, stellar orbits, lack of air at high altitudes, properties of fruits that have been discovered today. Iran (shia country) now have incridible science grow rate and it is one of reason that israiel and usa and zionist become enemy with it They dont want world know what can muslim do Please go read about islam shia religion It is last update version of religion from god How you care about updating you windows or android or geting new tech tv or car ..... It is your order and plan from god for healty live in this world and Salvation in other world Dont lesson to bs in media about shia muslim Go find your way yourself and from honest soureses. I cant say all thing here.

@Gabos DOn't read about Shai Islam They are fabrication

Arguably, it came from automatic adherence to religious authorities................................. "*revelation* replaced *investigation*" .... "Read the Koran and listen to the Prophet" replaced something like "Figure it out and write about it and write about it and write about it" ---- Most Jews have given up this approach long ago. They embrace science. They ignore dogma. They embrace a sort of pseudo-racial tradition. They reject old MYTH, even if in their own religious writings.

@@SwobyJyou are so wrong. Revelation did not replace investigation it actually incourages it. It has been revealed to the Prophet of Islam that we should investigate things before believing it. Also in science you have the scientific theories which is a theory and could be false and you have science which could be proven and is of no doubt. The science that has been proven goes hand in hand with the Quran. The Quran does not defy it and many things where proven to be scientifically true in modern times while it was already there written in the Quran 1400 years ago.

😂😂

Apparently he taught Mike Tyson how to box, too

What about printing press ? Was it actually banned or Al Ghazili invented it ?

So he was criticising abstract mathematics because it has no practical applications? That is a short sighted way of looking at maths and science in general🤔

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/m9Z8m8R4rNDKgqs.html late but better than never

This is the last minutes of a half hour talk that covers stuff from Plato through Newton and others.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html

@@dhiabichedli9503 they said the complete lecture, not a weird 20 minute religious rant about science vs Islam

@emrysgaming here you go: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hJ2ihZuk2du1lp8.html

@@quinnlance9487 It's strange to find someone setting themselves up as moderator of other people's comments on KZfaq. I'm free to comment, if you don't like something you can pass it by!!

@@dhiabichedli9503 and I'm free to tell you to piss off as well. Just because you have free speech doesn't mean other people have to sit there with a smile and listen to you. 😉

Come on, anti philosophy, read his book Tafsir Surah An-Nur it was written before his death. He even said "If I death in my younger years, I'm going to hell". That younger years is when he criticize Ibn Sina whit his book Tahafut Al-Filsafah which Al-Ghazali get criticize by Ibnu Rusyd by his book Tahafut At-Tahafut

@@emeraldaxx8631 Philosophy poses existence questions and doubts, which are all addressed in the Qur'an. He was anti-philosophy in the sense that certain philosophical ideas of his time went against Islam.

I think its because most of the time they dont use their technological discoveries for war, hence losing to mongols. And that shows how religion prevent technology to be used to kill.

@@MasalaMan I am very content. No need to cope with anything, thank you.

@@MasalaMan I don't need to lie to anyone, Alhamdullilah.

2020 No ads now. Thank you from the future.

Yeah but you must think about the time period and why scientific ideas were a hurdle for them.

​@@RoqueMatusIII at the same time, there is more aspects that lead to discoveries than just faith and philosophy. People want to live comfortably before anything else. So before blaming religion, there is economy, safety, and happiness. I mean how did islam capable to reach that 300 years of peak technological advancement before? I mean the religion was as strong as before, if not stronger, because of the prophet influence.

I don’t understand the issue of not thinking that there is some cosmic purpose from some supernatural deities or musical forces. Nihilism sounds scary. But as far as I’m concerned, it’s just an act of taking ownership over defining and arriving at purpose for one’s life rather than believing that there is some cosmic purpose that one is not meant to fully understand too much, but that one is meant to revealer. I don’t understand how/why one is supposed to take something as super serious even though it’s beyond one’s understanding by definition. To me that is a much more scary notion than nihilism. Even if I don’t have some spooky label for it.

i mean, nihilism is the only alternative. if you are an atheist you eventually reach a point where the only logical philosophical viewpoint of the world is nihilism

+Brian McConkey 1939.

+Brian McConkey About a decade ago, it's from the first year of the Beyond Belief annual series of conferences, here's the full version, it's spectacular kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hJ2ihZuk2du1lp8.html

+Brian McConkey thesciencenetwork.org/programs/beyond-belief-science-religion-reason-and-survival

october 2006

trigonometry, astrology, navigation the number zero the, heliocentrism the round shape of earth, law of gravity, the distance between the moon & earth, metal casting process, first plastic surgery & the list goes on most of the western discovery are mentioned there in writing with 100% authenticity in vedas i think mr Neil should do some research on vedas because he name given all this to arabs but actually arab & Chinese took it from india.

Yes yes the world was barbarian you indians taught us how to eat food, speak and everything.

Because it is not important

@@daywinde2201 its the center of his argument genius

@@daywinde2201 just shows how backward you are Pls Shut up

@@daywinde2201 it’s the central theme of the talk idiot.

Search MOHAMMAD HIJAB NEIL DEGREESE TYSON that muslim intellectual has refuted neil de greese on this video

It's largely incorrect. The downfall is mostly attributed to the Mongol invasions and destruction of scientific work in the library of Baghdad.

Hollister David : I mean that there are people on the Internet who will argue that everything that he says here about the decline of Islam is suspect because he messed up the bit with Bush. Yes, the Bush segment is destroyed, the rest stands. (Well, you are also claiming that something else is wrong, which I'll have to look into separately.)

@@tobybartels8426 not really as most of his claims can be countered although there is truth in his claim that the Islamic world did stagnate but he conveniently misrepresents certain aspects to solidify his position.

+MilitantAntiTheist There's no Iranium or Afghanistanium either, but regressives just can't resist comparing Christianity and Islam.

+MilitantAntiTheist yeah and whats ur point?

+victor martone fuck you i was first.

+slaynprey lol

Apparently I touched a nerve with Zamir Raza.

"that's what everybody did....take work and refine it and better it. Idiot" Have you seen the state of the middle east?

@@azmanabdula yeah thats fine job you did there you underdeveloped humans

The Persian Muslim Khwarzhimi formalized Algebra. Before him, it was a loose collection of notations, etc. he standardized it into a discipline. But yes, mathematics is originally created by ancient Indians. Also, NDT is wrong here anyway, the downfall of the Islamic Golden age has to do with the Mongol invasions destroying Islamic libraries that contained scientific work. Not Al-Ghazali.

I doubt it

@@qusaimustafa5350 then you should read the book that he mentioned or at least the sumamry of it?

Read the "Inconsistencies of the Philosophers" by al Ghazali before commenting on this topic. Ghazali was highly critical of the study of metaphysics because they questioned the existence of God.

@@qusaimustafa5350 NDT is wrong here, the downfall of the Islamic Golden age has to do with the Mongol invasions destroying Islamic libraries that contained scientific work. Not Al-Ghazali.

Yes, but metaphysics has nothing to do with mathematics. Al-Ghazali said math and logic of the philosophers was fine.@@farzana6676

And the painful part is that people really think that they can learn things about history in 10 min lectures like this! Bruh... I'v seen a lot of lectures like this one and almost in all of them I'v seen people interpret history as they please.

NDT is wrong here, the downfall of the Islamic Golden age has to do with the Mongol invasions destroying Islamic libraries that contained scientific work. Not Al-Ghazali.

Funny my last name is Al-gazali...I'm a relative of him,but I have grown to trust Tyson's over all judgment....he only got to talk for a little while I'm sure he did more research

So you would trust a physicist with a hobby over historians who are peer-reviewed (in their field) ? That in it self makes your understanding of science weak.

You don't know me or what I study or read.

Wow, that was quite a come back. But I will desist. There is no point in trying to talk sense to a fanboy.

or to someone who is in love with their own ego

Well, he was wrong, so there ya go.

Find an adult, kid

+MuzeXC u r an adult u tell me ,, why do i need an adult grandfather ?

don't jump

+MuzeXC thx grandpa

If that's the only thing you learned, then you may suffer from a learning disability. How are you doing in school? Do you often get bad grades? You're certainly not doing well in English, that much is evident.

The progress of science in that period is due to the encouragement of Islam to learn science and its teaching by the shia Imams Some of the infallible shia Imams had the opportunity to be educated. Others could not do so due to exile, imprisonment, war , social problem ,and government pressure, while all of them had divine knowledge. Imam seadegh, imam bagher (They are twelve. Eleven of them were martyred and one of them is in absentia (Imam Mahdi) who will appear with Jesus Christ and save the world from oppression)had opportunity to teach some student that some of them They became scientists like razy (Alcohol discoverer and chemist and other science) I dont remember all names They are became big sciecifict) These are just some of the exceptional references in the Qur'an 1400 years ago. Fingerprints, stellar orbits, lack of air at high altitudes, properties of fruits that have been discovered today. Iran (shia country) now have incridible science grow rate and it is one of reason that israiel and usa and zionist become enemy with it They dont want world know what can muslim do Please go read about islam shia religion It is last update version of religion from god How you care about updating you windows or android or geting new tech tv or car ..... It is your order and plan from god for healty live in this world and Salvation in other world Dont lesson to bs in media about shia muslim Go find your way yourself and from honest soureses. I cant say all thing here.

Quran is bullshit

You didn’t listen to the video carefully enough or you didn’t finish watching it. He pins the collapse of science in Islam on an Imam in the 12th century who taught that mathematics and science were the tools of the devil. And I’m not sure what you’re talking about him saying scientists are doubters. Where is that in this video?

Muslim achievements: Engineering: The Banū Mūsā brothers, in their Book of Ingenious Devices, describe an automatic flute player which may have been the first programmable machine. The flute sounds were produced through hot steam and the user could adjust the device to various patterns so that they could get various sounds from it. Astronomy: In about 964 AD, the Persian astronomer Abd al-Rahman al-Sufi, writing in his Book of Fixed Stars, described a "nebulous spot" in the Andromeda constellation, the first definitive reference to what we now know is the Andromeda Galaxy, the nearest spiral galaxy to our galaxy.[40] Nasir al-Din al-Tusi invented a geometrical technique called a Tusi-couple, which generates linear motion from the sum of two circular motions to replace Ptolemy's problematic equant The Tusi couple was later employed in Ibn al-Shatir's geocentric model and Nicolaus Copernicus' heliocentric Copernican model although it is not known who the intermediary is or if Copernicus rediscovered the technique independently. Anatomy: In the cardiovascular system, Ibn al-Nafis in his Commentary on Anatomy in Avicenna's Canon was the first to contradict the contention of the Galen School that blood could pass between the ventricles in the heart through the cardiac inter-ventricular septum that separates them, saying that there is no passage between the ventricles at this point. Instead, he correctly argued that all the blood that reached the left ventricle did so after passing through the lung. He also stated that there must be small communications, or pores, between the pulmonary artery and pulmonary vein, a prediction that preceded the discovery of the pulmonary capillaries of Marcello Malpighi by 400 years. The Commentary was rediscovered in the twentieth century in the Prussian State Library in Berlin; whether its view of the pulmonary circulation influenced scientists such as Michael Servetus is unclear. In the nervous system, Rhazes stated that nerves had motor or sensory functions, describing 7 cranial and 31 spinal cord nerves. He assigned a numerical order to the cranial nerves from the optic to the hypoglossal nerves. He classified the spinal nerves into 8 cervical, 12 thoracic, 5 lumbar, 3 sacral, and 3 coccygeal nerves. He used this to link clinical signs of injury to the corresponding location of lesions in the nervous system. Evolution: Modern commentators have likened medieval accounts of the "struggle for existence" in the animal kingdom to the framework of the theory of evolution. Thus, in his survey of the history of the ideas which led to the theory of natural selection, Conway Zirkle noted that al-Jahiz was one of those who discussed a "struggle for existence", in his Kitab al-Hayawan (Book of Animals), written in the 9th century. In the 13th century, Nasir al-Din al-Tusi believed that humans were derived from advanced animals, saying, "Such humans [probably anthropoid apes][citation needed] live in the Western Sudan and other distant corners of the world. They are close to animals by their habits, deeds and behavior." In 1377, Ibn Khaldun in his Muqaddimah stated, "“The animal kingdom was developed, its species multiplied, and in the gradual process of Creation, it ended in man & arising from the world of the monkeys.” Architecture: The Great Mosque of Kairouan (in Tunisia), the ancestor of all the mosques in the western Islamic world, is one of the best preserved and most significant examples of early great mosques. Founded in 670, it dates in its present form largely from the 9th century. The Great Mosque of Kairouan is constituted of a three-tiered square minaret, a large courtyard surrounded by colonnaded porticos, and a huge hypostyle prayer hall covered on its axis by two cupolas. The Great Mosque of Samarra in Iraq was completed in 847. It combined the hypostyle architecture of rows of columns supporting a flat base, above which a huge spiralling minaret was constructed. The beginning of construction of the Great Mosque at Cordoba in 785 marked the beginning of Islamic architecture in Spain and Northern Africa. The mosque is noted for its striking interior arches. Moorish architecture reached its peak with the construction of the Alhambra, the magnificent palace/fortress of Granada, with its open and breezy interior spaces adorned in red, blue, and gold. The walls are decorated with stylized foliage motifs, Arabic inscriptions, and arabesque design work, with walls covered in geometrically patterned glazed tiles. Many traces of Fatimid architecture exist in Cairo today, the most defining examples include the Al Azhar University and the Al Hakim mosque. Geometry: Islamic art makes use of geometric patterns and symmetries in many of its art forms, notably in girih tilings. These are formed using a set of five tile shapes, namely a regular decagon, an elongated hexagon, a bow tie, a rhombus, and a regular pentagon. All the sides of these tiles have the same length; and all their angles are multiples of 36° (π/5 radians), offering fivefold and tenfold symmetries. The tiles are decorated with strapwork lines (girih), generally more visible than the tile boundaries. In 2007, the physicists Peter Lu and Paul Steinhardt argued that girih from the 15th century resembled quasicrystalline Penrose tilings.] Elaborate geometric zellige tilework is a distinctive element in Moroccan architecture. Muqarnas vaults are three-dimensional but were designed in two dimensions with drawings of geometrical cells. Trigonometry: Ibn Muʿādh al-Jayyānī is one of several Islamic mathematicians to whom the law of sines is attributed; he wrote his The Book of Unknown Arcs of a Sphere in the 11th century. This formula relates the lengths of the sides of any triangle, rather than only right triangles, to the sines of its angles. According to the law, {\displaystyle {\frac {\sin A}{a}}\,=\,{\frac {\sin B}{b}}\,=\,{\frac {\sin C}{c}}.} \frac{\sin A}{a} \,=\, \frac{\sin B}{b} \,=\, \frac{\sin C}{c}. where a, b, and c are the lengths of the sides of a triangle, and A, B, and C are the opposite angles (see figure). Calculus: Alhazen discovered the sum formula for the fourth power, using a method that could be generally used to determine the sum for any integral power. He used this to find the volume of a paraboloid. He could find the integral formula for any polynomial without having developed a general formula. Scientific method: Ibn Al-Haytham (Alhazen) was a significant figure in the history of scientific method, particularly in his approach to experimentation, and has been described as the "world's first true scientist". Avicenna made rules for testing the effectiveness of drugs, including that the effect produced by the experimental drug should be seen constantly or after many repetitions, to be counted. The physician Rhazes was an early proponent of experimental medicine and recommended using control for clinical research. He said: "If you want to study the effect of bloodletting on a condition, divide the patients into two groups, perform bloodletting only on one group, watch both, and compare the results." Jim Al-Khalili gives the example of the classification of materials as a sign of new ways of thinking. While the classification of the material world by the ancient Indians and Greeks into Air, Earth, Fire and Water was more philosophical, medieval Islamic scientists used practical, experimental observation to classify materials. Rhazes, for example, classified minerals into six groups based on their observed chemical properties: Spirits, which were flammable, Material Bodies, which were shiny and malleable, Salts, which could dissolve in water, Vitriols, Stones,and Boraxes. Algebra: Muḥammad ibn Mūsā al-Khwārizmī played a significant role in the development of algebra, algorithms, and Hindu-Arabic numerals. List of muslim physicists: Sind ibn Ali (? - 864) Ali Qushji (1403 - 1474) Ahmad Khani (1650 - 1707) Ibrahim al-Fazari (? - 777) Muhammad al-Fazari (? - 796 or 806) Al-Khwarizmi, Mathematician (c. 780 - c. 850) Abu Ma'shar al-Balkhi (Albumasar) (787 - 886 CE) Al-Farghani (800/805 - 870) Banū Mūsā (Ben Mousa) (9th century) Dīnawarī (815 - 896) Al-Majriti (d. 1008 or 1007 CE) Al-Battani (c. 858 - 929) (Albatenius) Al-Farabi (c. 872 - c. 950) (Abunaser) Abd Al-Rahman Al Sufi (903 - 986) Abu Sa'id Gorgani (9th century) Kushyar ibn Labban (971 - 1029) Abū Ja'far al-Khāzin (900 - 971) Al-Mahani (9th century) Al-Marwazi (9th century) Al-Nayrizi (865 - 922) Al-Saghani (d. 990) Al-Farghani (9th century) Abu Nasr Mansur (970 - 1036) Abū Sahl al-Qūhī (10th century) (Kuhi) Abu-Mahmud al-Khujandi (940 - 1000) Abū al-Wafā' al-Būzjānī (940 - 998) Ibn Yunus (950 - 1009) Ibn al-Haytham (965 - 1040) (Alhacen) Bīrūnī (973 - 1048) Avicenna (980 - 1037) (Ibn Sīnā) Abū Ishāq Ibrāhīm al-Zarqālī (1029 - 1087) (Arzachel) Omar Khayyám (1048 - 1131) Al-Khazini (fl. 1115-1130) Ibn Bajjah (1095 - 1138) (Avempace) Ibn Tufail (1105 - 1185) (Abubacer) Nur Ed-Din Al Betrugi (12th century - 1204) (Alpetragius) Averroes (1126 - 1198) Al-Jazari (1136 - 1206) Sharaf al-Dīn al-Tūsī (died 1213/4) Anvari (1126-1189) Mo'ayyeduddin Urdi (died 1566) Nasir al-Din Tusi (1201 - 1274) Qutb al-Din al-Shirazi (1236 - 1311) Shams al-Dīn al-Samarqandī (1250 - 1310) Ibn al-Shatir (1304 - 1375) Shams al-Dīn Abū Abd Allāh al-Khalīlī (1320-80) Jamshīd al-Kāshī (1380 - 1429) Ulugh Beg (1394 - 1449) Taqi al-Din Muhammad ibn Ma'ruf (1526 - 1585) Ahmad Nahavandi (8th and 9th centuries) Haly Abenragel (10th and 11th century) Abolfadl Harawi (10th century) Mu'ayyad al-Din al-'Urdi (1200 - 1266)

Vito Corleone Thanks for the lengthy reply. Islam sure has had some great contributors to mankind.

Skepsis Rollins you're welcome!

I was 100% genuine in my question. I was uninformed about ancient Islamic achievements and wanted to know. what in the fuck are you on about?

Still waiting on an explanation on how I was being a 'clever joker'

I dont think that was the point

Islam is the enemy of science, both can not exist simultaneously without clash. Modern science destroys every claim of islam - muslims have to do mental gymnastics to keep islam still valid, but they will not go far on lies - islam is collapsing.

Lmao, what a retarded take. Tyson is black, and he is american.

I think he's a bit of an idiot who is full of himself. He contradicts his own conclusion. He talks about Islam accomplishments in science first. Well to be islamic is to believe in Allah/God. SO at the height of islamic accomplishment was clearly a belief in God. Then he says islam fell and he mentions Jews who win every nobel prize. Well, to be a jew is to believe in whom? God. So at the height of Jewish accomplishment in sciences and nobel Prizes is the belief in God. God did not stop the muslims or the Jews from scientific achievement in the speaker's own example. Yet he comes to the conclusion that belief in God stops scientific achivement even after giving all examples of scientific achievement and naming the group (Muslims and Jews) by their belief in God. He would make a better argument if he named a bunch of atheists who accomplished something but I guess he could not find them. Instead he names muslims and jews and concludes that belief in God does not allow scientific achievement. His argument contradicts itself yet he speaks like he has the bull by the horns. He may be a good scientist but his argumentative skills are lacking as he defeated himself with his contradictions. He's a bit of an idiot outside of his field which clearly is not theology.

Jake Deloso I totally agree with you, if god actually told everyone to learn, so how did the Arabic islamic world was golden back then, because they created and invented. There were Arabian philosophers who discovered so many things, and they were actually muslims! Then how is god stopping you from getting scientific achievements

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html&ab_channel=MohammedHijab

@@diamondblazerodq1167 The progress of science in that period is due to the encouragement of Islam to learn science and its teaching by the shia Imams Some of the infallible shia Imams had the opportunity to be educated. Others could not do so due to exile, imprisonment, war , social problem ,and government pressure, while all of them had divine knowledge. Imam seadegh, imam bagher (They are twelve. Eleven of them were martyred and one of them is in absentia (Imam Mahdi) who will appear with Jesus Christ and save the world from oppression)had opportunity to teach some student that some of them They became scientists like razy (Alcohol discoverer and chemist and other science) I dont remember all names They are became big sciecifict) These are just some of the exceptional references in the Qur'an 1400 years ago. Fingerprints, stellar orbits, lack of air at high altitudes, properties of fruits that have been discovered today. Iran (shia country) now have incridible science grow rate and it is one of reason that israiel and usa and zionist become enemy with it They dont want world know what can muslim do Please go read about islam shia religion It is last update version of religion from god How you care about updating you windows or android or geting new tech tv or car ..... It is your order and plan from god for healty live in this world and Salvation in other world Dont lesson to bs in media about shia muslim Go find your way yourself and from honest soureses. I cant say all thing here.

@@Mostafa-vs8bd Are you shia muslim ?

About stupidity of islam

The progress of science in that period is due to the encouragement of Islam to learn science and its teaching by the shia Imams Some of the infallible shia Imams had the opportunity to be educated. Others could not do so due to exile, imprisonment, war , social problem ,and government pressure, while all of them had divine knowledge. Imam seadegh, imam bagher had opportunity to teach some student that some of them They became scientists like razy (Alcohol discoverer and chemist and other science) I dont remember all names They are became big sciecifict) These are just some of the exceptional references in the Qur'an 1400 years ago. Fingerprints, stellar orbits, lack of air at high altitudes, properties of fruits that have been discovered today. Iran (shia country) now have incridible science grow rate and it is one of reason that israiel and usa and zionist become enemy with it They dont want world know what can muslim do Please go read about islam shia religion It is last update version of religion from god How you care about updating you windows or android or geting new tech tv or car ..... It is your order and plan from god for healty live in this world and Salvation in other world Dont lesson to bs in media about shia muslim Go find your way yourself and from honest soureses. I cant say all thing here.

NDT is wrong here, the downfall of the Islamic Golden age has to do with the Mongol invasions destroying Islamic libraries that contained scientific work. Not Al-Ghazali.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html&ab_channel=MohammedHijab

Arrogance

@@adfsdasd4362 You're absolutely right. You don't need intelligence to accept Islam, you need humility.

The fuck, the science in islam makes no sense. You have a cow and a whale lifting our world. Atleast The ancient greeks had Atlas. Like come on man

@@jaysonsfleece this is so interesting.. I'm just gonna listen

@@ibanezmakki you have to sell your brain to believe in islam, I found hunders of stupid and disgusting hadiz

+John Blume did you got triggered? Geez! The video clearly shows the guy's opinion towards Islam and the mistake they made... You are actually barking at the wrong tree... and do you honestly believe Christianity is beyond criticism?? Not sure you are, but your comment is quite retarded and regressive...

It may be because he grew up in an overwhelmingly christian society. It's the religion he is most familiar with and it's the most relevant in his day-to-day life.

I can't speak for NDT, but my guess is based on my own experience.

Ruben Campbell So, does personally attacking someone make you feel better? I just ask a simple question. I am a fan of NTD. Because I ask if he slams other religions other than Christianity makes me retarded? Do you personally attack retarded citizens too? Geez.

John Blume I was only answering, not personally attacking you. The tone I used was identical to the tone you used to ask the question itself: did you personally attacked Mr Tyson? No I don't think so, if I thought you did I wouldn't have responded in the first place.

+damyll2011 because he is talking about Islam, and not Africa?

+Slavko Delic i know he is but islam is not the center of knowledge.

damyll2011 It was in the period he was talking about. At that time there was no Grece, and Egypt was under Islamic rule. Did you even watch the video?

Kemet was amazing though good point

Because he's talkin' about propagation of knowledge. When Baghdad was the centre of learning, knowledge was travelling freely between europe, africa, and Asia. Which is why he gives the Abbasids ( the muslim rulers of baghdad) the credit they deserve.

Lol good one

So you need to correct Britannica and Wikipedia, right ? From Britannica: the Baghdad mathematician Muḥammad ibn Mūsā al-Khwārizmī wrote his famous treatise al-Kitāb al-mukhtaṣar fī ḥisāb al-jabr wa’l-muqābala (translated into Latin in the 12th century as Algebra et Almucabal, from which the modern term algebra is derived).

You do realise that muslims were doing exactly the same thing in indian subcontinent the whole time.

It's almost never one thing. Rome didn't fall to the Goths. It crumbled because its leaders became arrogant and hedonistic. It expanded its grasp further than it could hold and its central philosophies and those who taught them fell to petty squabbles and excesses. The golden age didn't just end because of the Mongol Horde. It buckled because of the rot too.

@Russell floyd braindead it's been in Quran for centuries .And BTW it's a belief system book not a thesis. But if get some scientific knowledge from it than it's like cherry on the top.

@Russell floyd And BTW why are you listening to Neil DeGrasse Tyson's words he ain't even a intelligent/wise man.

Oh? Are dinosaurs mentioned in Quran as well ?

​@@praneshhimself of course not

Lmao and Tyrannosaurus Rexes too isn't it?!

Islam is utter ignorance on the real world, science only exposes this false pagan cult made by Arabs.

@@texas0075 the "end" was never given an exact date. Seems like hogwash to me. If you're going to claim your religion is the truth and that the end of the world is "near", I'd assume "near" remarks a specific time/date....so when is it?

@@fitzburg63 stfu if what you were saying is true then the religion wouldn’t be a world wide scale. Most muslims in the world are not even arabs

@@hamzayoseph6241 Hello, where is your brain? Being made by Arabs does not imply all muslims are Arabs - Christianity was made by Jews, are all Christians Jews then? Stupid cult, stupid followers...

@@fitzburg63 send me a picture of your face

Aww..

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html

no, it was the mongols

Al-Khawarizmi was a zorostanian in the first place and he lived his entire life in arabia and all of his publications are in arabic,Your point being?

Moetassim Rady Lots of americans today write papers in english ;) Doesn't mean in 500 years historians shouldn't bother pointing out that Richard Feynman was american not english

+Cyrusislikeawsome But but.... Yeah you're right.

Oooooh ur persian(I'm an arab and the guy is an arab too i don't care about history books :P :P)

Moetassim Rady Oh I see XD Well yeah sorry buddy I'm afraid you're wrong, and its called cultural appropriation. Take pride in what your own people have done without trying to lay claim to others as well, you have plenty to choose from :)

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pMyCobx_zs2dmok.html&ab_channel=MohammedHijab

Don't be jealous bro, every civilization reaches a golden age. Islam had its golden age, so please don't downplay the importance of the contributions of Muslims to our world culture. I really don't want to invoke the crimes against humanity that Europeans have committed in the name of their lord, got it?

+thearchitect27 killing in the name of religion is not cuz of religion its only for power. No religion tell u to kill innocent. People change it to suit thr needs. Religion is not evil people r.

+Malak Adil its not evil but as you said is too dangerous to have in a civilized world because of its influence in people, the only religions we can afford to have (for our own good) are the ones that can't pose a threat, for this they would need to be inclussive and not represent something greater than the existance of the believer himself (maybe as a personal objective), this way people would not be able to see their religion as more valuable than anything and only as a way of life

Malak Adil Of course no religion wants to hurt innocent people, the problem is your definition of innocence.

+adolfo manzur sir , one more think. my religion teaches me. 1. give share of ur earning to poor . maybe gold , harvest , money in the bank , even give money for ones Life , living for one year .(depend on ur weight) 2. don't kill innocent . 3. dont drink cuz it cause more problems thn good. 4. no adultery cuz it destroy homes. now tell me if u implement this in a society , will thr b poor people or problems we face today. Problem is we cant , cuz humans want everything , power , money , sex day n nit . People want thing , they dont give doesn't matter if someone is hurt in a process. civilisation will not b destroyed if u give share of ur earning , or dont drink till u pass out head inside a toilet , or dont sleep with new girl every night or maybe someones wife , if for example for a second think someone created this whole infinite universe billions of stars n planets. Can a mare human live on a tiny planet in this universe that can comprehend someone like that.

God. If you believe in God, if you believe in Truth. Then research and seek the truth before talking wrongly. For your own sake, not mine.

The progress of science in that period is due to the encouragement of Islam to learn science and its teaching by the shia Imams Some of the infallible shia Imams had the opportunity to be educated. Others could not do so due to exile, imprisonment, war , social problem ,and government pressure, while all of them had divine knowledge. Imam seadegh, imam bagher (They are twelve. Eleven of them were martyred and one of them is in absentia (Imam Mahdi) who will appear with Jesus Christ and save the world from oppression)had opportunity to teach some student that some of them They became scientists like razy (Alcohol discoverer and chemist and other science) I dont remember all names They are became big sciecifict) These are just some of the exceptional references in the Qur'an 1400 years ago. Fingerprints, stellar orbits, lack of air at high altitudes, properties of fruits that have been discovered today. Iran (shia country) now have incridible science grow rate and it is one of reason that israiel and usa and zionist become enemy with it They dont want world know what can muslim do Please go read about islam shia religion It is last update version of religion from god How you care about updating you windows or android or geting new tech tv or car ..... It is your order and plan from god for healty live in this world and Salvation in other world Dont lesson to bs in media about shia muslim Go find your way yourself and from honest soureses. I cant say all thing here.

Don't let Saudi Arabia fool you when it comes to the religion. Muslims around the world can do just as much as they did centuries ago, but it's more of a culture problem that puts them in a box

Unfortunately just like any manmade thing it came to its end. Islam is kept artificially alive by its believers thinking that the glory of that time will comeback again.. or it's the end of the world. Or their messiah will come and make them rise again... or ... or .. They became sad ghosts of their past who can't keep up with the world anymore. The modern Westernized world couldn't completely erase these superstitions but if China and Russia take control, they gonna force everyone to give on their santa clause in the sky.

+Living the Dream this is a bad attempt at being sarcastic bro.. anywho pls check Ahmed Zewail, for example

+Johnny T Doe - that is the big question: could such an intellectual decline happen to the western civilization in the future? Looking at the various flocks of deniers, "truthers", and conspiracy "theorists", there's certainly a cultural element here that could favour such a development.

+steve1978ger I hope not we will have a better view of tomorrow's dream after the next election.

+steve1978ger It's frightening to me that the Bible might end up being passed off as scientific in our schools, if that happens tomorrow is worth what gets flushed down the toilets.

The average women has like 7 kids

the average hater comments are like above

+Moh'd Saidely there is no hate in that comment I answered your question. You asked why is Islam still increasing I said because women tend to have more children. Yemen for example is 99.99% Muslim and the average woman start having children at 15-16 so by the time they have 9-10 children who will following the religion whereas in Northern Europe like Finland Sweden etc women tend to have one or two children and those children may choose not to be religious. I live in Jamaica for example my parents have 3 children 2 are religious and I am not. May I ask how many children your parents have

this might be true as well but depends on the region ofc. however, i was talking about non-muslims who are more converting to islam nowaday, that all.

Bla bla bla you're being proud of your ignorance, looks like you're the uneducated one with no respect to others. do you have anything against religions? fine but don't insult them, discuss and try to explain, my friend.

The sheer amount of lies in this video tells me you need to look harder for that rational being

@@salman13 you mean elsewhere because "Dr" (Only in the west you can point a liar and fraud as doctor) Tyson has not made any poinst about the decline of science in Islam.

I did not die. My brain died. 😐

There were muliple reasons. Muslims lost to mongols due to internal cobflict as well. The Islamic Caliph of that time was pretty weak. So, muslims collapsed and never recovered to this day.

Islamic Golden age didn't end until 1400's. There is seminal work in all the fields NDT listed post-Ghazali, by 200 years.

@@kabz3354 It was more complicated than that. Decades prior to the Mongol Invasion, Baghdad was one of the most significant capitals of the Islamic world--militarily, politically, and economically. However, when the major dynasties collapsed, the city lost its political relevance. When the Mongols arrived, the city was more similar to Venice. An economic trading center, but with very little to no military protection, and outdated methods of defense. There wasn't a predictable trend in the "decline". The game simply had changed, and different groups were taking charge like the Ottomans.

Islam is an Arabic religion, it relies on the Arabic Language however, not the people.

Arabic is the language of Islam, the Coran is actually an Arab book.

Omar Abouelazz Adam is Islam, no body knows what he uses of language.. Jesus and Moses is islam, every one knows he is not using Arabic language... So IsLam is IsLam... Arab is Arab.. IsLam is belong to All Nations.. not Arabs alone.

Zamir Raza Your comment is so informative I'm actually impressed. Get lost.

LoL

Everything can be used for corruption even Islam itself, was Islam banned? No it wasn't.