I'm glad you're choosing to focus more on the victims lives and stories instead of focusing only on the killer

Do one where youre taking your makeup off and doing your skincare routine.

as a dexter fan i had no idea someone actually took inspiration from the show, this is crazy

Other than Hailey going out of her way to humanize the victims in these crimes, one of the things I love in this channel is how her future/editing self frequently cuts in to clarify some things or to just flat out drag herself 😂

HAILEY YOUR HAIR LOOKS AMAZING!

dexter didn't just kill bad people but people who've killed others and gotten away with it. Which stems from reliving his mother dying in front of him. Mark would fit dexters code which is hella ironic

This whole Mark Twitchell case was so twisted. I’m just relieved that at least one of them managed to survive. I personally wouldn’t go on public dating sites-there’s just something about them that doesn’t sit right with me. If I was given such strange instructions from an online stranger, I wouldn’t go through with it. That’s already a HUGE red flag. Anyway, that being said, be very, very careful when it comes to online dating. You’ll never know who you’re actually talking to unless they verify their true identities. Thanks for bringing light to this case, Hailey. Also, your hair looks awesome!

He didn't even try to kill bad people like dexter... He just went for random, GOOD people! How does that make sense??!

I personally loveeee watching the progression of the makeup tutorials. Almost because they make me be more attentive with the help of the visuals, it is nice to see a change though. I love watching you so whatever you do, I’m sure I’ll enjoy it

My moms good friend since childhood is “married” to him while he’s in prison right now. We since have distanced ourselves from her due to us thinking he’s messed up and not wanting to be involved but she will talk to my mom and tell us all about him. She goes for dinners with marks mom all the time and was trying to get my mom to go wedding dress shopping with her and his mom. He’s in a prison 30 mins from our house and shits just creepy af

I can’t imagine how the writers and actors would feel if they knew that they somewhat caused/inspired someone to these things to other people :/ I’m a fan of the show Dexter but like all other fictional serial killer shows/movies, it’s made to question our morals but to never praise the killer. It’s rlly upsetting to hear this.

Would love to see you try maybe like painting while chatting with us? Or doing crafts of some sort? ☺️

It’s good to have friends like Johnnys. Friends that know you so well they know when something is wrong.

I am a 30 year old lady with no social media and hardly any interest in that whole scene. I occasionally come into KZfaq and randomly stumbled upon Hailey a year or so ago. She's hands down my favorite KZfaqr I follow and genuinely feel excited when my scrolling leads me to a new video of hers. New hair looks amazing. Also, why does it seem like SO many psychos come from the deep woods of Canada? Hahaha

“Shorm short films” lmaoo you never fail to make these scary stories entertaining

I like both, when you do your makeup it's fun and relaxing to watch but this style feels more like sitting down to listen to a friend tell a story.

Jill is such a badass ngl, I don't think I would have had the balls to fight back. What a story to tell at family gatherings.

As feedback, I didn't realise how much I loved it when you did your makeup as you talked, like you said, it really adds a visual stimuli to the video This way is not bad at all, and whatever you prefer filming, but I kind of miss the makeup, especially cause with the makeup then you'd sometimes mess up or say something off topic about the makeup or what you were doing and it really brought me back to reality for a second, it was a nice break love your videos !!! :D

Your personality alone catches my attention. I put my headphones on while I make dinner lol. I don't necessarily need to sit and watch. So whatever you do girl I'm with it.

Girl i got ADHD and u putting on makeup helps me focus and stay connected and not zone out! If anything id love if u did every other one w makeup being done🥰

I personally prefer when you do your makeup while talking I pay attention more and am most likely to not get lost. I don’t think it’s disrespectful either, and I love your videos!

Also I definitely miss the visual stimulation, but it doesn't have to be makeup! I'd love to see some arts and crafts, maybe some painting, brushing a pet, eating some food, or driving (dual gopro situation? idk)

the Queen has posted! i’m so happy you’ve uploaded. i’ve just recently subscribed to u and i have already binge watched all of ur vids. i absolutely love ur personality, ur vibe, and i think you’re so hilarious. i’m v happy youtube recommended u. u are now one of my fav make up and true crime tellers along with Bailey Sarian. ♥︎♡︎

I was re-watching Gravity falls to kill time and here she is , right when i crave mystery 😌🌟

absolutely devastating. its so sad that people can be as disgusting as mark

I can’t believe I found Hailey before 100 k and now almost in a blink of an eye Hailey is over 700k! So proud to be supporting an amazing creator like Hailey! Thank u for adding some zen to my days :)

If you’re taking constructive criticism I like whatever! I love putting my airpods in and just listening to you as if I were listening to a podcast. Love your vids, take care!(:

I love the way you structure your videos! Also, in my op I prefer when ppl (in general) do their makeup and tell the story or just do something while explaining/ect. I’m not sure why tho but I personally can focus better! I‘m not sure if it’s considered as “disrespectful” since applying makeup itself has nothing to do with the case.. I'm pretty sure that this isn’t your intention tho!

I like it when you're doing your makeup while talking, showing how much you researched and understood the story before you tell us so you can focus doing two things at once. Plus, it has become somewhat your signature. However, do what makes you feel comfortable

Love the makeup look especially the lipstick with the hoop earrings ❤️

i personally enjoy the no make up video! i like both honestly, but some people think that someone doing make up while talking about horrible murders or tragic cases can come across a bit disrespectful, and of course you don't mean to do that, so I think maybe having some vids where you don't do make up in between would be a good way to show that :)

Most of the true crime Hailey posts I’ve already read and learned about, but I love her and the way she tells the stories so I’ll just continue watching them cause she’s a vibe. Love my fellow Gemini

I'm having a really terrible day, and seeing this notification pop up made me smile

I love the video, just wanted to say that it makes sense why people love the “get ready with me” type story telling videos. It feels like a friend is spilling the tea, like it’s just us. What about if you do a eating together, or making you meal and chatting 🤷🏽‍♀️.

Ngl I definitely prefer the videos with makeup and true crime. A lot of people copied Bailey Sarian which is really frustrating because they literally copy her thumbnail and title styles, and even name their series something similar to Murder, Mystery, and Makeup. I’ve never watched any other channel like that other than this one because it never felt like a ripoff of what Bailey does. It just feels like a more organic idea rather than someone seeing how huge Bailey’s channel grew from MM&M and trying to copy that success. The only other true crime channel I watch is Kendall Rae who I didn’t know started out as a makeup/beauty channel and then started doing true crime content, but I like how it sounds like a podcast but scripted if that makes sense, though I don’t think I’d like her videos as much if the majority of the time she’s just sitting there talking instead of showing a lot of pictures and videos like she does. Although I do love when she has one of her cats behind her being super precious and then I get sad when it cuts away to a picture or video related to the story lmao

your intro is always so calming to me, i don't know what it is but i love the tone of your voice! makes your videos that much more enjoyable (:

OMG HAILEY YOUR HAIR IS SO CUTE SHORT! I cant wait for every video you make, I've been watching for 10 months (omg what!?!) and I'm still obsessed with your presence and how amazing you are at story telling!

I like watching you do your makeup and speaking abt the topic, it makes me feel less anxious and also it makes me feel like I’m just listening to a friend talk while I’m also doing my makeup :)

I love that you are trying out something new! I personally love that you do your makeup because it adds a visual element that I enjoy while at the gym. It keeps my mind off of the time haha. I think it would also be fun to (as someone mentioned in the comments) do your routine for taking off your makeup. I think that's honestly what made your channel stand out to me. I don't really enjoy true crime, but the way you focus on the injustice these victims often face, as well as the lives and personalities, makes these stories something to learn from, not just listen to. I also love that you do your makeup, it just ties everything together.

i really like the makeup! it helps me focus more on the video, cause i can get bored easily lol! love your hair, it’s so cute!!

You do an amazing job of telling the victims stories. I JUST watched another video about this case and when you first started talking about him, I was like why do I know him? It’s because the other video I saw was so focused on the killer. Thank you for what you do. Love u!!!

It doesn't matter about how to tell the story it's still so interesting to listen to you💖

Love ya biiishhhh. I'm obsessed with the fact that you tell all these stories without looking at notes or continuing to looking off camera. It shows that you do actual work with these videos. I love it. And I love you doing your makeup. Bit honestly, you just doing a video makes my day. Haha. Love it.

tbh i usually don’t watch ur vids i just listen to them when i’m doing something so doing / not doing makeup makes no difference i just love your voice and the way you tell stories so pls don’t change that :)

I literally never watch your videos, I listen to them as I clean or go about my day. I love listening to your channel, so whether you just talk or do something I'll be here for it! 👌

I always thought that hair color would suit you I’m sooo glad you did it. It looks amazing and fits you so well girly ❤️❤️

You work so hard on your videos that can present them anyway you want. This story was so incredible! I just cant believe what people do.

Me: *watches video* Hailey: *doesn't do makeup* Me: *wipes sweat anxiously*

hailey- your new hair makes u look like u just stepped off set of _Friends_ & i am *l i v i n g* for it!

Hey, Hailey! Every time I see an upload from you I immediately get so excited and click the video. I really appreciate your commitment to making videos. Thanks for making my day better. Also, love your hair, another day another slayy xx

Why is it that Hailey uploads exactly when I need something to watch!!! Love your vids so much❤️✨

Thank you for being so respectful during your storytelling, while also giving us a lot of detailed information and keeping the atmosphere not too heavy.

Her self corrections give me life

loved how you started by helping us get to know the victim first. in regards to doing makeup or not, I normally listen to your videos like a podcast so I don't have a preference either way lol

Hailey! I just want to say I love your videos, no matter how you film them! Makeup, no makeup, who cares! Love your stories and your energy and personality. I tell friends to watch your videos all the time! Hope you keep it up for a long time

hailey makes my day so much better

YESS FINALLY IVE MISSED U SO MUCH☹️☹️☹️☹️🤍🤍🤍 i can’t wait to watch after school! :)))

Love that you're testing new things out! Personally I prefer it when you do makeup, but this was fun as well

i love these sit down videos too, they're so so relaxing!!

hailey girl u are so pretty!! the haircut, the hair color, the outfit, the hoops omg it just all working together you look so good!!!!

i like when u do ur makeup, i’ve learned a lot lmao

Hailey is so freaking pretty like I can’t even-

Love you girl! So happy to see u have so many subscribers!! When I started following u, u had way less. I know u would catch on like fire cuz girl u rule!! Sending positive vibes and love. Thank u for making these great videos, giving voices to people u can’t speak anymore ❤️

I personally like it when you do your makeup and tell the story but whatever makes you happy! I will keep watching your videos no matter what you decide. ❤️

Hailey I’ve got covid right now and so does my dad and honestly we aren’t doing to well but you and mr Ballen have been keeping us going! ❤️

I LOVE that we watch the same KZfaqrs lol - Kendall, Bella and Eleanor are absolute legends and so are you! Those three plus you are the only true crime channels that I watch because y'all have superior content :)

first of you look gorgeoussss, the hair, the makeup, the vibe.. yes yes yessss secondly i actually really like the switch up in video styles, i know theres some controversy around doing makeup while you're talking about something so serious and personal to individuals, so its actually really reaffirming to here you talk about the visual stimulation aspect of your videos in the intro, but also cool to see a video like this just to mix it upppp (((: thirdly.. im only a few mins in so im gonna go enjoy your videos as i usually doooo

Thank you for shorming a video Hailey , never fails to make my day. 💖

I love your short hair! you look so great!! I don't mind of you sitting down and talking to us that way but for me however, like you said, you doing your makeup as well helps me consecrate. but either way, I like :)

I also love Kendall Rea and Eleanor Neal but you’re also one of my favourite true crime KZfaqrs. Actually, you’re probably one of my favourites!! ❤️❤️

will say i looooove watching you do your makeup!! so relaxing and enriching and you do the best looks, my fave looks of true crime makeup youtubers!

I love all your videos and ofc it's your choice at the end of the day. However I personally really enjoy watching you do makeup while telling stories because it keeps me engaged (not to say the story isn't interesting enough) it just keeps my brain focused on continuing to watch💗

Hailey the new hair is amazing!

Your hair is amazing first of all Secondly if you want feedback on the style switch, it's a good idea. I like doing my makeup with you but i listen to you because i enjoy how you engage with us, how you edit and how you story tell. Thanks for this, i cooked my dinner to this today

Thank you so much for uploading, it makes me so happy ❤️ I love to do my makeup while listening to you ❤️❤️

I personally prefer watching you do your makeup as well, I feel like you are always very respectful while telling the stories and I don't really see the problem with putting on makeup since you don't really talk about it or focus on it, it's more of a visual thing, and I have adhd so it's the only way i can pay attention and finish the video.

LOVE THE HAIR!!

Home girl posted at just the right time she always knows how to make my day better😌

I baked jam cookies while listening to this one since there was no makeup. Absolutely love when your videos pop up in my feed. Always fascinating stuff and thoroughly enjoy your delivery of it all. You are awesome. ♡ Hope everyone reading this has a beautifully relaxing evening! Crazy world.

Poor Johnny. He looked like a really cool and sweet guy :(

12\10 my fav creator. I have a rough life and hard time sleeping and this is my calm. So detailed and enjoyable. Plssss do the abc killer !

Omg your hair is so gorgeous!!!! 😍 the new format is great as well, both are!

You can literally do anything and I’ll watch your videos. If this makes you more comfortable then go for it! I’ll be here supporting ya! Be safe out there🙏🏼

Girll First of all your Hair 😍 Second of all I will support everything you want to do 🖤💁🏽‍♀️ But i gotta say i like to watch you do your make up... Love from Germanyy 😘

The Dexter obsession is so wild. This year a person in my neighborhood dismembered his girlfriend and put her in a cooler. Her husband and kids had to go through the worst trauma imaginable. She had left with the individual but drugs were involved. Anyway, he was obsessed with Dexter and during the incident changed his fb profile picture to have a Dexter fb frame 😭

I like the sit and chill approach myself. Your new hairstyle looks really nice on you. Everyone of the stories you share just seems to get crazier and crazier every time! I just don’t know how these people can do what they do it just blows my mind! 🤯

Yessss! Thank you! This is literally the case I always think of when it comes to Dexter. Thank you for covering this! RIP to JA.

Ahh my hometown, we lived really close to this guy back when this was happening. I still can't believe it. It is such a scary world we live in.

Yesss a new video!!

Thank goodness you posted 😫 I was in need of content

OMG the excitement I had clicking into this video where Hailey talks about a killer where I live!!! EEEEK!! Love you Hailey xxxxx

Love all your videos, but i do like it better when you do your make up. You described why very well, its relaxing and helps me follow along in a weird way 😂also you always turn looks

Definitely prefer the visual of a make up application while listening to the story❤️ (just my opinion just in case you need it for the testing)

HAILEY. YOU HAVE NO IDEA HOW MUCH I NEEDED A VIDEO FROM YOU TODAY. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU ILY FOREVER

i’m obsessed with your hair and makeup omg

You might be surprised to learn that I did not even know that you did your make up while making the videos because I listen while I am cleaning houses. :-) I love love love these long format stories because I don’t have to pick up or interact with the phone while I’m working very often and I can still be entertained as I do monotonous tasks. :-)

I think I prefer you doing makeup. It's a really nice distraction when the story is morbid haha. Love your videos so much!

these videos are the only thing keeping me happy their sooooooo interesting and you do so good explaining it

I like the makeup progression too. I feel like you show your personality more and are just more relaxed in general. Either way, love your videos !

✨ The queen has arrived ✨