ROGUE REVIEW! | Doctor Who Season 1
9:40
Пікірлер
@bobjordan69
@bobjordan69 Күн бұрын
Homeboy is more than just a timelord yo
@TheCarbonFreezer
@TheCarbonFreezer Күн бұрын
Great video lads. With the glasses, I was wondering if you guys knew if there was a big difference between the sizes (S, M and L) or if they looked about the same? Was thinking of buying a pair but the medium is out of stock and wasn't sure if small would work
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 16 сағат бұрын
Joe says Tennant's glasses were a 'fixed' size, produced before the S/M/L versions were introduced. So none of them are completely accurate, but they'd all look the part!
@colinjones-pm3hj
@colinjones-pm3hj 6 күн бұрын
All I have to say 1066?
@CineScarborough
@CineScarborough 7 күн бұрын
I can't believe you liked that Ruby's Mum Louise is ordinary. It's so uninteresting and would have been so much more impactful to have made her Mum Susan Foreman.
@59rlmccormack
@59rlmccormack 7 күн бұрын
Ruby will return. And can we find out who Mrs. Flood is?
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 7 күн бұрын
It was utter rubbish
@Shadow.172
@Shadow.172 7 күн бұрын
He did a damn fine job of it though! Though we didn't see much of him, he gave us such a great thing
@CulturePhilter
@CulturePhilter 7 күн бұрын
Am I the only one who has ALWAYS assumed the Memory TARDIS was created for the show first? When Tales of the TARDIS first came out last year Russell said something along the lines of “you might get more answers about what the memory TARDIS is next year” so ever since then I expected it to show up in the main show and assumed that’s what it had been created for.
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 7 күн бұрын
I remember seeing that quote, but I thought it would end up being something more obscure myself (e.g. a throwaway reference in dialogue). I never imagined the Memory TARDIS would actually appear in the show… though looking back it’s obvious!
@thefonzkiss
@thefonzkiss 7 күн бұрын
Sad and embarrassing
@juliandarch9278
@juliandarch9278 8 күн бұрын
So the Legend turned out to be not legendary, the God got defeated by a spoon and a bungee cord and no one realised the TARDIS was a duplicate from "Giggle" so none of it made sense in the 1st place.
@shangothrax
@shangothrax 5 күн бұрын
It is. Sutekh just moved TARDISes, obviously. Remember, Toymaker was still at play when that happened, so that is possible.
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 5 күн бұрын
@@shangothrax he was never on the Tardis to begin with! He died in the Time Corridor before the Tardis even left the cellar.
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 5 күн бұрын
@@shangothrax he was never on the Tardis to begin with! He died in the Time Corridor before the Tardis even left the cellar.
@robertrawley1115
@robertrawley1115 8 күн бұрын
*With all of the negativity from primarily UK KZfaqrs about this series and the finale, I have to ask why would Disney Plus ever bankroll a Series 3?* If there's a strategy in the criticism of the series and finale to make the show BETTER to let Disney know that we WANT to see more I'm just NOT SEEING it. I can only hope Disney's viewing numbers around the world from new people who don't follow KZfaq will encourage them to fund a third series and a fourth...And some spin-offs. Richard, at least yours is among the milder and slightly more balanced negative reviews I've watched and for that I thank you.
@craigelement1858
@craigelement1858 8 күн бұрын
There's only one person who can make the show better - and that's Russell. His writing style, with unexplained plot lines, wasted characters and the classic "re-set" button just doesn't cut it anymore - we've seen this all before. Unfortunately I don't think he's the sort of person who will take any criticism onboard and change his ways. Perhaps the best thing to do for the longevity of the show is for him to step aside after the next season (if that's also a bomb). Be careful what you wish for though - the next showrunner could "do a Chibnall".
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 7 күн бұрын
The negativity is justified, trying to ignore that people dislike what Chibnall and Davies have done to the show, telling them they are talking nonsense or labelling them as something or other is just another form of censorship. Also, sticking your head in the sand and ignoring the fact that the public have deserted it in droves is like fiddling while Rome burns. For me personally, trying to shoehorn in an explanation as to how Sutekh survived Pyramids which is clearly untrue if you watch the original is unforgivable. It's like the way George Lucas ruined the original SW trilogy by constantly tinkering with it or even cultural vandalism. It's made even worse by the arrogance of Davies, thinking he's actually a good enough writer to do that. There's reasons why people criticise the show and stop watching. For me, that was the last straw.
@user-tc6tu6ni8m
@user-tc6tu6ni8m 8 күн бұрын
This will definitely empower the haters. Don’t know how the show is going to last. Fingers crossed for the next season 😅
@peterd788
@peterd788 8 күн бұрын
It was totally empty with a meaningless story. Even if you ignore the vile identity politics of the series which are unforgivable there was no escaping the fact that it was just threadbare nonsense. The actress who played the spoon lady did a great job even though the scene was bullshit.
@thorkilosborn3925
@thorkilosborn3925 7 күн бұрын
Vile identity politics? As in having characters who are different from one another?
@RobertShippey
@RobertShippey 8 күн бұрын
I think I agree with you on almost all of this. I did like the kind woman and spoon thing however, because it showed the real impact of Sutekh. As you said, seeing Unit and Ruby’s family die felt like “ok so this will all be undone” whereas the woman and her child, I felt they suffered so it adds to the scale and impact of what happened. Plus it’s nice to have a message of among all this death and destruction, people will still be kind to each other.
@HenryCLHarries
@HenryCLHarries 8 күн бұрын
There's good bits within it I've learned to appreciate ...sadly this era just isn't for me it'd made for younger audiences and you can tell in the dialogue ....it didn't take until the finale for me to get that ....and it astounds me people only now get what I've been saying ages ago when star beast aired ....now the finale has aired I feel I GET the era ....but this will be the best it gets. ...next run of episodes will be lower ratings sadly because the buzz of NEW era will have gone so they'll need to be careful how they go about the next series ....overall though there's worse episodes this era
@joeeeee256
@joeeeee256 8 күн бұрын
Poor story, but very well excecuted! Idk if that makes sense :) I wonder, should Russel write the finale resolution before anything else in the season and work back? Surely that'd provide a much more satisfying ending.
@gemgoska9102
@gemgoska9102 8 күн бұрын
There was still no explanation for the snow. My thoughts are Ruby was created by another god, but was still born to human parents. We find out Susan Triad was born to human parents even though she was a creation of Sutekh. Perhaps it could go this direction with other human creations from different gods? And that final scene with Mrs Flood. She looks like a fluffy Mary Poppins. It’s funny how they put snow in that scene. A connection to Ruby? Although I’m not too sure about that. I do wonder with Mrs Flood breaking the fourth wall could mean she’s a god of stories. It could explain why she takes a narrative role.
@stephenwinfield9657
@stephenwinfield9657 8 күн бұрын
I think the reason Sutekh wasn't presented as he was in Pyramids of Mars.. Millie asked the Doctor in the remembered TARDIS why the whole Egyptian thing after seeing the video? The Doctor commented, cultural appropriation.. so he was presented as a Jackel..
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 7 күн бұрын
No, the ancient Egyptians appropriated Osiran society and culture to form the basis of their religion. That is retcon nonsense.
@hotdog1214
@hotdog1214 7 күн бұрын
But the image of Sutekh as a Jackal like creature is from Egyptian mythology, so it would still be appropriation (which I argue the line about it is wrong anyway - its depicting the Osirans, an alien race who were perceived by the ancient Egyptians as gods because of their incredible power and advancements - that is not what cultural appropriation means - I think RTD mis-stepped there). However, I think Richard may be suggesting what some other fans have mentioned, that Sutekh was a frightening and powerful being when he was just portrayed as a man sitting in a chair and that perhaps that could have been brought in at some point. Oddly it was more intimidating than the giant CGI dog, perhaps a case of less is more - but on the other hand I can see that maybe its geared towards younger or modern audiences who want a big gnarly monster.
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 7 күн бұрын
@@hotdog1214 I don't think he mis-stepped, I think he knew what he was doing. The Egyptians appropriated from the Osirans, not the other way round. The CGI Sutekh was appallingly bad, as was the manner of his defeat.
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 7 күн бұрын
Could be… but they could have easily done a humanoid Sutekh that wasn’t obviously ‘Egyptian’.
@Farsight-nc1ib
@Farsight-nc1ib 7 күн бұрын
@@StetsonDoctor they should have done Sutekh like the Draconians for example. And he should absolutely have been 'Egyptian'.
@tmarasenior5618
@tmarasenior5618 8 күн бұрын
I watched Unleashed and Russel said that more will be coming out about Ruby's parents so maybe the mystery isn't quite over yet, We'll find out who Mrs Flood is and the family theme is still continuing. I like this new direction, gives the show a bit of a refresh.
@StevenHughes-hr5hp
@StevenHughes-hr5hp 8 күн бұрын
It was dumb because you can not portray something as all powerful and then just chain it to the back of your stationwagon and speed down the Interstate dragging it.
@JulieK352-Who-nj3ll
@JulieK352-Who-nj3ll 8 күн бұрын
I know some viewers had disappointments, but honestly I really enjoyed this episode and the whole series of episodes. The more that I think of the season, I have some ideas running through my head - most are probably just flights of fancy, but I’m really getting excited for what comes next. I just wish we didn’t have such a long wait.
@GT3NB
@GT3NB 8 күн бұрын
I had fun. I thought it was just “good”. Not as good as RTD’s other finales, but “good” is good enough, after many years of “not good.”
@nurmukhametabdullin9887
@nurmukhametabdullin9887 8 күн бұрын
She might be the master from "The Mind Robber" - a story with the Second Doctor. Mrs Flood's purpose seems to have a good story. No matter who die, no matter who wins - her primary interest is a catch story. So as the master's from "The Mind Robber". As oppose to science fiction's nature of the previous seasons, this one is getting more supernatural/fantasy as it breaks the boundaries between dimensions. As a result it returns The Toymaker and other supernatural creatures that break physics laws and even canon for the sake of plot development. That's why think that Mrs. Flood is the master from "The Mind Robber".
@rendezvouzwithrama
@rendezvouzwithrama 9 күн бұрын
As Shakespeare pu it: It is a tale Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, Signifying nothing.
@Sol_Black
@Sol_Black 9 күн бұрын
oh what a massive disappointment it was.
@triplejazzmusicisall1883
@triplejazzmusicisall1883 9 күн бұрын
Sadly there are now about 10 reasons (minimum) to be bery disappointed for what Empire of Death delivered. Dreadful finale.
@NileSWPhotography
@NileSWPhotography 10 күн бұрын
The part oneiest part one 😂😂😂😂
@joeo_18
@joeo_18 10 күн бұрын
10:04 It's called 'Ghosts' from the Last Christmas soundtrack in Series 8.
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 10 күн бұрын
Ah, of course!!! Thank you, that had really been bugging me! 😂😂
@lukerob9130
@lukerob9130 10 күн бұрын
Yes Miles! Waterloo Road!
@andrescarnederes2295
@andrescarnederes2295 10 күн бұрын
My prediction is that Sian Clifford is playing Horus.
@CineScarborough
@CineScarborough 10 күн бұрын
I really hope you are wrong that Ruby's Mum is just an ordinary woman. That would be so disappointing. The way it has been built up, it would need to be a character we already know for it to work.
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 7 күн бұрын
lol
@CineScarborough
@CineScarborough 10 күн бұрын
What if Sian Clifford isn't actually in the episode and is a fake listing to hide Carole Ann Ford as Susan?
@neilyb4590
@neilyb4590 10 күн бұрын
I’m so excited I can’t wait for this rubbish to be off the tv once and for all
@hermancharlesserrano1489
@hermancharlesserrano1489 10 күн бұрын
Mrs Flood is the Dr’s granddaughter, tasked by the Dr (DT in the near future) to leave Ruby at the church in order to set off the events that will defeat Sutekh. She’s been watching over Ruby from next door for all these years…maybe 🤪🤣
@garfar912
@garfar912 10 күн бұрын
I rather hope that we either don't find out who Ruby's parents are or, it turns out they're just normal humans but that's when Ruby leaves the show at some point in the future arc completed. Ruby learning to make peace with her origins and lead a full life despite them is a much stronger story that a reunion story. There's a lot of misdirection going on, Russell knows how to play us at our own game! The eps are peppered with little things that might mean something. One thread seems to be the Doc being carefree and not having responsibility. So it would be interesting to see him saddled with - say - a great granddaughter. So many Susan comments, he needs to reach out to her, and it would need to be an un-regenerated Carole Ann Ford. Maybe Mundy is her daughter. We don't know how timelords procreate so we're probably applying very human attributes. It would be so cool to watch a 6 month pregnant Ncuti waddling away from legions of cybermen. There's lots of references to Ruby's age and date of birth. Also Mrs Flood still existed when the goblins ate Ruby, but didn't know what a tardis was, but did know when Ruby's timeline was restored. So not Ruby's daughter, but some sort of connection. Would quite like it if Cherry Sunday was a timelord in hiding, and the flat was a tardis.
@DaveLynchWriter
@DaveLynchWriter 10 күн бұрын
He's definitely trolling viewers.
@CashelOConnolly
@CashelOConnolly 11 күн бұрын
Well I can guarantee ‘the kind woman’ won’t be Suella Braverman 😂✌🏻🔷
@CashelOConnolly
@CashelOConnolly 11 күн бұрын
As long as Mel (Bonnie Langford) doesn’t start SCREAMING and SCREECHING like she did in classic Who (my ear drums bled 🩸😂) I’ll be happy ✌🏻🔷
@mickking7364
@mickking7364 11 күн бұрын
The main thing to look forward to is the end of this crap show.
@patrickhurley5604
@patrickhurley5604 11 күн бұрын
Wow bro 😂 why are you even watching it then😂if you're watching just to smash on it, then frankly you're just a hater, or a troll😎 take your pick😂
@SpikeyMikey341
@SpikeyMikey341 11 күн бұрын
Well unsuprisingly it's lost a large portion of its audience so maybe the best thing would be to shelve it for a couple of years then bring it back hopefully with a better Dr, less ideologically driven scripts and decent plots.
@neilyb4590
@neilyb4590 10 күн бұрын
Made a similar comment before I saw yours I 100 percent agree it’s a travesty what they’ve done to dr who
@Katanya67
@Katanya67 10 күн бұрын
If you just put aside your feelings about Woke and see it as a regular Doctor Who story you will see how brilliant it is
@Katanya67
@Katanya67 10 күн бұрын
It is sad because he really is a good doctor!
@stinchjack
@stinchjack 11 күн бұрын
Correction: Final episode of Season 14
@tulliusexmisc2191
@tulliusexmisc2191 10 күн бұрын
Correction: Final episode of Series 14. Season 14 was 1976-77.
@59rlmccormack
@59rlmccormack 11 күн бұрын
The return of Sutekh is crazy, especially since we were getting new stories this season.
@bennettnez4711
@bennettnez4711 11 күн бұрын
Anybody in the comments that can help a pleb American watch the new Tales episode tonight? Who is my favorite show of all time but jesus christ it is so hard to stream in this country without giving yourself an aneurysm.
@TheSuperDuperLS
@TheSuperDuperLS 11 күн бұрын
If you have a VPN you can set your region to the UK so you can access BBC Iplayer. You will need to make a BBC Iplayer account, so when it asks if you have a TV license just mark yes, and when it asks for you address, just put a random address located in the UK.
@billivee
@billivee 11 күн бұрын
If you can avoid annoying dangerous ads , Google ‘doctor who’ and ‘bstsrs’
@rwrobwalker
@rwrobwalker 11 күн бұрын
Disney+
@billivee
@billivee 11 күн бұрын
They deleted my comment? Google bstsrs and the show
@TheSuperDuperLS
@TheSuperDuperLS 11 күн бұрын
@@rwrobwalker Tales of the Tardis is UK exclusive.
@shemdellashemygd29
@shemdellashemygd29 11 күн бұрын
W design
@BayAreaJaybo
@BayAreaJaybo 11 күн бұрын
I hope we find out who Mrs Flood is. I keep going back and forth between Flood - Rain - Rani and Pond, River, Flood. I hope RTD isn't just trolling with this one.
@kbg12ila
@kbg12ila 11 күн бұрын
I think she's the one mystery that'll be kept for season 2.
@jasonpudwill1587
@jasonpudwill1587 10 күн бұрын
BBC does not own the rights to the Rani.
@ChazaMazza_
@ChazaMazza_ 11 күн бұрын
1. N 2. C 3. U 4. T 5. I 6. G 7. A 8. T 9. W 10. A
@dkimuk
@dkimuk 11 күн бұрын
He's been amazing hasn't he? He's without a doubt the most charismatic actor on screen right now.
@ChazaMazza_
@ChazaMazza_ 11 күн бұрын
@@dkimuk exactly my point! He has that charm that the 11th doctor had that just lights up the mood of any scene hes in
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 11 күн бұрын
Thought that was another anagram for a second!! 😂
@bobnotbobff
@bobnotbobff 11 күн бұрын
​@@ChazaMazza_he reminds me more of the 9th
@CashelOConnolly
@CashelOConnolly 11 күн бұрын
I wish he’d turn off the crying and grow some 🏀🏀
@JamesShipman-ef1tj
@JamesShipman-ef1tj 11 күн бұрын
Anyone notice that the multicolor background looks like identical to the time corridor they trapped Sutekh in
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 11 күн бұрын
Yes! Such a cool touch 😎
@akshaytrayner1960
@akshaytrayner1960 11 күн бұрын
Great review
@liamneeson7926
@liamneeson7926 11 күн бұрын
Just putting it out there wouldn’t be surprised if we see a 14th doctor cameo as back when filming took place there was someone covered up by others when filming for the finale took place
@dkimuk
@dkimuk 11 күн бұрын
I hope they don't. Ncuti Gatwa has been fantastic and I don't want anything to overshadow the end of his first series.
@tylercarter8033
@tylercarter8033 11 күн бұрын
They confirmed this was davina McCall doing reshoots
@CashelOConnolly
@CashelOConnolly 11 күн бұрын
It’ll not happen,anyway I want Ncuti to get the spotlight ✌🏻🔷
@Katanya67
@Katanya67 10 күн бұрын
I believe that was Sian but maybe Carole Anne
@ugolomb
@ugolomb 13 күн бұрын
I find difficult to believe they'd use Susan *only* as a red herring. Even if she doesn't come up in the next episode, I'll be surprised (and disappointed) if they don't circle back to her in the Christmas special and/or in Season 2
@StetsonDoctor
@StetsonDoctor 13 күн бұрын
Agreed!