Aimee Weasley that comment is the best I have come across ages. Made my day😂😂😂

Aimee Weasley oh my god. I would have died laughing.

hahaha

Best thing I've read in years 😂😂

that would actually work.... voldemort cant kill the car and his defenses are for living things presumably

Some stuff school teaches is actually useful

Also in Harry Potter if a spell was useless why would they invent it

Owen Mitchell anime is useless why was that invented

Ben Thatcher it’s a form of entertainment dummy

@@owenmitchell1469 yes, like mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell

but the Weasley family is a family of "muggle-loving traitors'

@@gabriellel1118 In Order of the Phoenix, Ron shows he doesn't understand what doctors are. At best you could say that Arthur included the dentist and the others just humour him.

@@jamescallanan2443 oh yeah, that does make the most sense out of anything you could come up with

@Kefou Kefak yea, which is why I said the other guy's explanation made the most probably sense out of all the theories possible

I love your observation but he doesn't care about the books.

Good point there Bro This Dude won't shut up if u watch Netflix with him

Harrry Potter isn't about the movie, it's about the magic and power of the story being told in the hearts of the public. Diversity, right, wrong, respect, love and friendships.

@@Rainydaz3 Diversity?

Turnip Yes. There were those things in the books

Luke Mills wait weren’t theses movies made before 2010 tho? No hate, just a sincere question.

How Harry would've said it in philosopher's stone: Daicjiaijdjiigon airudjjsjxhjloalpey

Raven889 im cryinf

200 like!!

Raven889 in the book he actually gets ash caught in his throat.

Diagonally

No wonder Hermione brought Ron with her in the final book. He was a chicken!

ginny killed the roosters

Cocks out for Harry-bae

What a useful lesson.

Ginny kills Hagrid’s roosters and uses their blood to paint the bloody messages on the walls so there isn’t any roosters on school grounds

haha that is right!

I would say that Harry Potter played it a little better than to call it cliche, plus its shown in the books, its the character itself whose like that..

Aderinsola Ogunlabi ding

And this asshole filch

@@mamudere67 That's squibist

@@ziqinchen2629 Who cares about a fooking Squib

@Bro That’s racist [Ding]

That's because youtubers actually have stuff to do

Chara Dreemurr You somehow have 2 subscribers. Why? UNDERTAIL! (To clear the shitstorm, I genuinely like undertale but MOST of the community is shit)

Chara Dreemurr Did the book say that?

Lockheart is the guy who tries to pass an oral exam by taking all his knowledge from Wikipedia. he has time to answer his fan mail.

yup

XD

Sergeant Johnson because of his horcuxes

Tanvi Mishra but the horcuxes prevent voldemort from dying but they don't prevent him for changing shape because he would still be alive

Alexandra Lee​ true, but even if u smashed the goblet. He would be alivr

Tanvi Mishra they don't need to smash the goblet,if voldemort would be turned into a goblet he could't do anything.just standing around and...do nothing...

Nope

I'm not even sure what my parents do for work.

Yes. I did.

I still have no idea

Nope

Yeah, it's explained in Pottermore.

Well then Dumbledore doesn’t care about his students education

@@jaimelannister1797Dumbledore's reasoning was something along the lines of "Bad teachers can still give you a lesson: They teach you not to be like them." But yeah it's debatable whether that's worth enough to sacrifice a whole year of education over.

@@jaimelannister1797 yeah dumbledore is stupid

@@jaimelannister1797 He's portrayed as a genius but really Dumbledore is the senile old idiot he supposedly only pretends to be. "Oh I'll risk this guy wiping the memories of my students and teachers just to expose him as the fraud he is." Then there's the excuse he uses to keep Snape around which is supposedly to teach the kids that some teachers are just horrible. Nah Dumbledore. It's because you need him as your inside man in the Death Eaters.

True

same lol

in film they don't, a film needs to stand on its own merits because a large portion will not have read the books.

Only movies that come to mind that have stood on their own without the books are The Lord of the Rings

M. Fi

Wait what would have happened if pettigrew turned into a cup🧐

@@nicolemay4964 in the first train ride on Hogwarts ron tries to turn his rat yellow

I'm quite certain that's a school rat, not a students "pet"

Yooo imagine peter hiding as a rat and one day transforms into a half rat half goblet and then panicking and turning into a human

Jackson Sainsbury That would be quite funny actually ahha

It would would have been better to have at least told a number of the key ones in the series, but, because of who was waiting, possibly not Snape, to at least get them to lend you something if not come with. And even at that, they could have gotten more of the students involved. Jeremy and the page noted they could have just brought a rooster.

they tried to tell dumbledore but mcgonogall stopped them as he was no longer in office but on his way to the ministry or something. Nobody else would believe him. And this way the get to paint Harry as a hero yet again.

@@tasmayshah5539 you’re thinking of the first film.

Also, did none of the teachers ever try to find out what the creature is or talk to moaning Myrtle?

@@DarthViperious unionized cinema sins. For when sins slip thru the cracks

I kinda took that sarcastic "I hope.." as he wished it didn't happened tbh

I think it’s more how the different actor portrayed Dumbledore so differently.

@@nevermore7285 Agreed. The original Dumbledore seemed more mysterious and Merlin-like to me. The new Dumbledore seems to have more of a powerful sense to him.

Agreed. He should not.

Yes he can and that's what makes this channel great

I like to imagine that was Arthur's doing. "It appears that there's one spot missing on our board, dear. There's this muggle place that I have heard of known as 'the dentist'. I haven't a bloody clue what that could be, but it seems like the perfect thing to put there" and possibly secretly watching it, because if one of his children's faces happen to land on this one he has full reason to question them about it thoroughly.

Silentgrace11 That is genius. I will never be able to unthink that everytime I watch Chamber of Secrets haha :P

FearlessStar1000 Haha well I'm glad to be of service x3

Remember its Arthur's job to investigate/learn things about muggles so he probably found out what it is and put it on there.

FearlessStar1000 not everyone is good at teeth spells

But over here at Ilvermorny School of Witchcraft and Wizardry we have a high payed since we have casinos on the land.

adam erixon Teacher jobs in general are low paying

u know because of the thing in half blood prince

I think he just assumed it was an American school. IDK, maybe teachers in the UK get shit pay or something?

Hogwarts is a premium school though, almost like a university.

facts

LATER, THE INTRODUCTION OF AURORS CREATES A MASSIVE HUGE SUPER-BIG HYPER-PLOT-HOLE!! There is totally a profession specialized in this. There are literally Armys that you can call when you have a Basilisk Problem or any Problem with Dark Magic at all. WOW!

The same thing I was thinking when Sirius said that in “Goblet of Fire”

Least a basilisk wasn’t released just a psycho teacher and a TROLL IN THE DUNGEON

wait wait wait... if the restricted section of the library was really locked and restricted... would voldemort learn about the horcruxes at all? like how is that smart

Nice catch!!! Now would you like to disprove the other 82 sins??

@@vinodhcashout6711 Thank you, but no lol

@@vinodhcashout6711 I can't do them all, but here's what I have lol 2. Dobby brought the letters AS PART OF his attempt to get Harry not to go back to Hogwarts. He literally explains this. 4. Um, simply, yes. It was completely possible for Harry to hear it. All you need is for him to be a light sleeper. 5. Just senseless. Sinning someone for saying people's names in surprise is dumb. 13, 14, 15. It could be argued that there's a distracter spell on things like this to prevent Muggles from noticing. They notice Harry and Ron crash because the barrier went up so they never passed through the potential distracter spell. 16. Well, yeah, if magic were real, maybe it could. How would you know? Magic isn't real, so we can't determine how it would or would not malfunction, can we? 19. They weren't that much later, actually. Everyone's at the feast, and that's literally where they go directly from the train as soon as it stops. 21. The camera angle you're referring to hardly even displays the ceiling at all. The panel on the far right is above the top of the viewpoint so it's impossible to tell whether it's open or not. As for the left panel with the beanstalk, we can see the SAME beanstalk in the next shot again, and it goes up behind one of the slats holding up the roof, which blocks the second panel from view, so it technically COULD be open, just not visible. 25. Probably because he thought students would be easy to fool into thinking he was legit? Most other career choices would land you around many more adults than those at Hogwarts, and unless you bounced quickly from job to job, such people would unmask you pretty quickly. 31. She's just doing it for the theory. I didn't see you sinning the kids learning how to make feathers float in the first film. 32. Filch is a Squib. You clearly outlined this with the three panel shot earlier. Attacking Mrs. Norris clearly would be meant as a punishment to Filch (it's just an accident of course, but that's still the way her attack should have been perceived). 34. The wand chooses the wizard. It's extremely difficult to just find a spare wand laying around that'll decide, yeah sure, why not let this random stranger who just found me in a broom cupboard become my new master. 39. If Snape was the one who could have stopped the snake from attacking Justin, then why didn't he stop the snake AS it was about to attack Justin? Why'd he wait until Harry startled everyone with Parsletongue first? 43. Seeing as all three glasses contain identical amounts, it could be easily figured that Hermione only needed to measure by pouring a certain number of ladles into each one, like four or five. Maybe the ladle itself is the measurer. 49. See above comment 50. The Defense Against the Dark Arts job is pretty jinxed, isn't it? Lockhart's probably the only one who WANTED to take the job. Dumbledore might have had no choice. 53. He literally explains seconds later that he's taking power from Ginny, and that's why he's more solid. He wants to talk to Harry and find out why he survived the initial attack, and that's why he's waiting. 66. While this does make sense, if you give it some thought you realize that it's probably not possible to teach all the students the same techniques since Hogwarts contains wizards who are as young as eleven years old and just beginning. It's logical that they'd have to start with the basics. When there's a creature or killer going around attacking people, you can't just immediately teach kids the most advanced things to deal with a monster. Plus, they don't know it's a monster, some still suspect a person. 72. What is the sin here exactly? It doesn't address anything except the next part of the plot. There's nothing wrong with it. 79, 80. These are the same sin, just explained in more detail and then re-sinned. It should still just be one. 82. You couldn't figure out that they were just trying to get Lockhart out of their hair for the time being?

I'd assume that McGonagall went straight to the staff room and ordered an evacuation after seeing the message saying "she" had been taken. There's no feasible way for her to know it was Ginny unless she did a head count before she ordered the evacuation (which she didn't) or if she went into the Chamber herself (which she couldn't)

​@@Bro-cx2jc he's just padding the sin coun with 79 and 80.

when ron was drving the magic car

well, yeah, but later, when they missed the train

+DBZCOURT Well, Fred and George were fourteen back then, so it doesn't really change anything (when it comes to that specific scene).

+DBZCOURT ah! to young to be driving under muggle law!

***** come to think of it i've just remembered that the wizarding world has no cars, the only reason rons dad has one is because of his connection with muggles due to his role in the ministry of magic, and since the wizarding world has no cars they have no car laws which means anyone can drive a car in the wizarding world.

The Percy Jackson movies: Im about to end this whole mans career

@@ananyavallurupalli673 movies? There are no movies, Idk about movies all I know it's that we have a Disney+ series

@Leviathan lol I think he's joking

@@burhanuddinmaskawala187 I heard that too.

@@ananyavallurupalli673Imagine if Peter Jackson directed the Percy Jackson films?

+knbISlife testuya she killed all of Hagrid's roosters

+seichiro772 then how has the blood not dried.....

+knbISlife testuya It was paint. I just read the book again, she killed the roosters by strangling them. Didn't use any blood.

+A Dark Shade of Green I'm sure she just thought it was paint. And at 11 years old you'd probably make that mistake...

She finally became a woman during this movie.

Human transfiguration is actually very difficult so I’m relatively impressed.

Explain!?

Unlimited Stone9 I think they mean 4:27

Crazed oh ok, that's false anyways

Otaku Obsession wormtail is an animagus, he's not using transfiguration

Check the post recently?

I thought about that too. The only possibile handwave would be to give Myrtle a valid reason to stay quiet about the matter, but I can't think of any

omg hi master its wormtail :D

Bruhhh

Huh

*does that mickey mouse thing in the air with his wand*

Best comment ever

Snape, Snape, Severus Snape.

@@devinandcarrietotaldrama505 DUMBLEDORE

@@nicolefrances8744 Snape, Snape, Severus Snape, Ron, Ron, Ron Weasley

Harry pottaH hArrY poTtah 😂

@@kohaneluvvvv Hermione, Hermione

the videa was showing the extended version

There are fan theories about Harry being in St Mungos after the trauma of his parents's deaths. That all of it is just a lunatic fantasy. Some debunk this but whose to say what a rating mind imagines? And it gets more complex as he tries to hold it together.

Sean Wei holy f*ckin sh*t

You deserve a lot more attention for saying this.

You had the same question as this guy: scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/60829/why-does-the-weasleys-clock-have-a-dentist-setting

Well shit

In the movie yeah... but not in the books

Dillon 812 no yeah.. but the books

iamasquid 5 throughout the entire video there was a text that said “the books do not matter” because you shouldn’t assume someone has seen the source material when the adapted version

Ultracombo I know exactly that’s why I said it to be funny

those kind of jokes don't work well with text

Ultracombo can’t you take a joke

I think there would’ve been a better way to expose a man for fraud than have him as a teacher when you know he’s subpar, like as a headmaster at a school that’s kind of a dick move

So it is like the Percy Jackson oracle thing? I call rip-off

+Mihir Beeharry The Harry Potter books were out way before Percy Jackson.

+Mihir Beeharry you do realize that Percy Jackson copied Harry Potter

+Mihir Beeharry well Harry Potter came out before percy jackson so I call rip off 🙂

Conner Tobey That is what I meant .-., the percy jackson ripped it off HP

Because a good laugh is more important than the education of hundreds of young wizards... Imagine being a 5th or 7th year and needing to take your OWL's or NEWT's with that kind of teacher.

camaka that makes sense

Classic Dumbledore

camaka Actually it was because Dumbledore suspected Lockhart to be a con artist but with no proof to back it up, and that putting him in a school environment would lead him being exposed. Not caring about student welfare the whole way.

That's actually worse

Really? What time mark in the movie is that?

Fraser Souris J.K. Rowling has said she hates slytherin herself like really hates slytherin because she made them to be portrayed as villains and menaces. Although she doesn't hate them in a way of regretting making them just that she doesn't like them because they are supposed to be portrayed as minor villains.

I think Slytherin is portrayed negatively because mostly all dark wizards were in Slytherin.

Dynamo HD But that is in appearance and prejudice The series is supposed to be about choice, the whole "we choose to be monster" thing. Harry even tells his kid "he was named after a Slytherin" suggesting Harry has grown past his biases, and talks with Dumbeldore told Harry that he and Riddle were in equal positions, yet Harry chose to help people instead of gaining power (which he still could have) while Riddle did the opposite)

Fraser Souris I know not all slyithern are bad like me ummm alright mabu that was not the best example but you get my point

Ron isn't slytherin

I wheezed-

Sounds about American

@@idk-uv7mt Yep, and the Malfoys are British so they wouldn't think of that.

Isn't there an edit of Philosopher's Stone but all the wands are guns?

If there is such a spell, these kids aren't gonna know it.

You're asking why 2 year students who just learned about transfiguring animate objects into inanimate objects wouldn't do the opposite ? Really ?

@@theonewayroad3867 They only learned to turn animals into goblets. And bringing life into an object that was never alive before, has got to be a whole 'nother ball park. Transfiguration is harder than it looks.

@@ethanpetersen810 I keep forgetting than sarcasm doesn't translate well in text form. Next time I'll just write it.

@@theonewayroad3867 Lol

R.I.P Richard Harris

Demon Rantz R.I.P Real Dumbledore.

We know, Jeremy was just being a prick.

+Liam Powell lot of that going around

i liike turtle

Tom Riddle left Hogwarts in the 1945, it was there 1945-1993, that's forty years However, it was owned by Salazar Slytherin Who put it into a thousand year sleep until it was needed again and After Tom riddle left it ate rats.

It was there WAY before Riddle. The legend says that Slytherin left a monster in the chamber. What, is the Basilisk in a family of his own, not a single monster?

When Harry, Ron, and Lockhart fall into the Chamber, there are rat bones all over the ground. Draw the conclusion.

The only way this thing is getting enough food is "magic." Which is fine! But seriously. Snakes eat stuff way bigger than their entire bodies. No way the basilisk found literal TONS of rats down there lol

Tim Chaos I take it you're not familiar with the speed with which rats breed. 2 rats can become 2,000 in a year. and given the age of the castle, yeah it found tons of rats.

Even the frickin video game did it correctly too, but nope, it's cooler if we have Harry say "diagonally" and LITERALLY end up one fireplace diagonal to the one he's trying to get to XD

because they did not care to do the movie right, to consult the book when in doubt. somehow Chamber of Secrets is still very good compared to the Goblet of Fire or Half-Blood Prince where they completely f*** it up

But he can't properly use the one he does have, and it IS broken.

Not to mention Neville suddenly turned much more competent once his father's wand got broken and he got his own.

@@moriseyusa Yeah but why would I replace one broken wand with another. Either way it's not gonna work too well

Harry pickpocketed someone else's wand and used it in one of the films if I remember correctly, so that's null and void.

@@titanictnt7476 No, the wands might or might not work. It's not a unanimous yes or no. Sometimes they work but not very well, sometimes they go all Elder Wand like it did to Voldy, etc.

I doubt you will! I graduated HS in 2011 and I couldn't tell you what trigonometry is if my life depended on it.

Not everybody wants to be an engineer, though.

Nobody ever said anything about it being "all about you". You really need to get off your high horse.

His comment isn't particularly stupid simply because engineering is a vocational subject; not a core (foundational) one. The sort of subject you elect to pick in later years at school. I'd hazard a guess less than 1 in 20 school-leavers ever cared about or used trigonometry ever again in their lives.

Say you wanna be in the FBI. Is the FBI supposed to care when the Declaration of Independence was signed?

Rafi 666 I laughed so hard reading this

And I choked on my spicy food after reading this twice

What a mood

i dont care how long ago you commented this, you need to know how much this made me laugh. like i snorted lmao

Thx

Magically modified earmuffs I guess?

I thought a mandrake's wails killed you, not made you faint? I guess J.K is making shit up again.

Apparently if they're young enough it only knocks you out, not kill you.

***** Yeah, that's what it says in the book. Young Mandrakes' screams won't kill you, as they aren't very developed.

Yeah... Someone mentioned that in the above comments. It's cool.

Except....those "weird carrot monsters" are mandrakes, which they explicitly state are used to make a potion that cures the people who had been petrified by the basilisk.

+Topher1286 lol, I posted this comment just so I can get a hermione explanation of the carrot monster. Thanks man.

+Doctor KoolK You're quite welcome. I can be a bit of a "NEEERRRRRRD" like Hermione. haha

+Topher1286 don't get me wrong, hermione is cool, there's nothing wrong with that.

+Doctor KoolK Nah, no worries, friend. :)

That's... a good question. Well, she said she was in the bathroom crying because Olive Hornby was teasing her about her glasses. Maybe she took them off while crying, to wipe her eyes?

So you're telling me that Harry was completely safe all the time?

@@timoheinz2879 It's certainly possible.

@@timoheinz2879 He probably would've been paralysed like Hermonie

........ 𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐝𝐢𝐝 𝐧𝐨 𝐨𝐧𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐬 𝐛𝐞𝐟𝐨𝐫𝐞 𝐧𝐨𝐰??? 𝐓𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐢𝐬 𝐚 𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐲 𝐠𝐨𝐨𝐝 𝐩𝐨𝐢𝐧𝐭

6:42: Yes. Yes, this is a giant, laughably big Plot Hole. This is really something impressive.

The Lazy Vlogger And Gamer yeah but they only say that in the book, and Cinamasins only judges movies (and songs)

Plush Video Studios I don't think the first one was full-grown, since it wouldn't make sense to plant one Mandrake before the others. Plus, if that one was full-grown, they would've unpetrified one person at least

Maisy Williams That and I'm pretty sure a full grown​ mandrake's scream is supposed to be able to kill you without ear protection that seems a bit risky

magic.... potions.... herbology.... always show the final example before expecting people to deal with a subject so they have an idea of where your going with something

Because something they failed to explain in this movie is that Tom Riddle forced Ginny to kill all of the school's roosters. They do show Hagrid carrying a dead rooster in one scene, but anyone who had not read the book wouldn't make the connection.

I was just quoting the You-Tube video... but you're right, Hagrid does frantically wave that rooster at Dumbledore.

Fair enough. "Rooster-less" is a pretty funny non-word. haha

So is "Cockless", and the connection made thereof . haha

No way, I simply cannot imagine a cockless Harry. haha

And cowardice to stand against

if myrtle wears glasses, how come she didn't just get petrified by the monster instead of getting killed? idk if that's how it works but it only makes sense

Justin though? He saw it through Nick

YES THATS THE POIMT

Yes. The first two movies got extended editions.

@@Killer4fun damn. Guess I have to add to my bucket list

Its in the books.

@@mr.halfbloodprince394 lol

YEAH...

Oh wow I didn't notice that though I have watched this like a million times.

I saw that part of the video at 5:49 PM Central Standard Time. Coincidence, I THINK NOT!

Not till I saw this

It means you can speak package.

@Rainbow the Dragon Cat :0

Ding! Sinning Cinema Sins LMFAO

@@ophie71 Check out their video 'everything wrong with cinemasins'

LATER, THE INTRODUCTION OF AURORS CREATES A MASSIVE HUGE SUPER-BIG HYPER-PLOT-HOLE!! There is totally a profession specialized in this. There are literally Armys that you can call when you have a Basilisk Problem or any Problem with Dark Magic at all. WOW!

***** He seems to like having shitheads for his Defense Against the Dark Arts teachers. Its really no wonder why Snape gets so pissed every time he gets passed up.

Marcel Chagnon I mean, to be fair, with the position cursed it is extremely difficult to find anyone to teach that class. Dumbledore actually explains this to Harry in book 6. Obviously not in the movie, so that's a moot point in the context of CinemaSins, but basically Lockhart was hired only because no one else would take the position at the time.

+Blue Sparx "Books Do Not Matter"

Cody Parks Why don't you read my whole comment? "obviously not in the movie, so that's a moot point in the context of CinemaSins" *I addressed that already.*

I thought he was fucking ugly. Am I the only one?

@Gracie Johnson Yeah, he gets a new one. Arthur won a contest at the Ministry where he works and they used it to get Ron a new wand and take a family trip to Egypt to visit Bill

@Gracie Johnson They went to Ollivander’s like normal. It really isn’t explained much in the movies, but we do know about the trip and that he has a new wand. Technically Ron never even went to Ollivander’s his first year, his wand was a hand me down

His wand was Charlie’s, he was already using a wand that didn’t chose him

@@Skyebright1 Which apparently means Charlie's shit out of luck without a wand.

@@steelinghades9655 hm maybe Charlie’s was also a hand-me down?

Look at the top of the screen

DAMN!!💖😂

“Parcel tongue” Is that the language of mail?

I can speak parseltongue.

So?

@@jassyanimations8947 criminal

I know or at least turn a pet into a rooster!

alex mane Transfiguration is one of the most useful classes of magic that also gets completely shafted most of the story. :P

9Kualalumpur Dude...Ginny is a member of a family that raises chickens, catches garden gnomes, and knows magic. I don't think it's going to be hard for Ginny to catch a rooster.

Mr4theLulz1 Yeah, but Ginny was busy being almost dead at the time, I don't think it would have been a problem.

9Kualalumpur if Malfoy can summon a snake why can't Harry summon a gosh darn chicken

Basically, all the honest descriptions for the movies/books

Lol

3rd one is actually "Innocent prisoner"

Razor Blade he still killed

@@paperman8583 No, only when needed. Never killed innocent people. Also, you don't need to write "You know who" in the title. "Voldemort returns" works nicely.

Exactly what I was thinking

+SirCraigius well they could have casted someone better as a replacement

It would have still been a different person. Would still have looked and sounded different.

+SirCraigius obviously. but this new Dumbledore always annoys me, he doesn't feel like a Dumbledore to me.

+Marianna Anagno "casted someone better"? Michael Gambon is amazing. I don't think there is one person that could beat him in the role. Great actor. And, it's not like they could hire a guy that sounds and looks exactly like the old Dumbledore.

its set up at least, they mention it earlier on

Ah yes, the mythical bird's (whose associated with immortality and rebirth) tears have healing properties is convenient plot armor..... yes... certainly..

Ditto 73 but u also might have to do 4n-1 so yea

Oh shaddap, I'm not in the mood for algebra.

Ditto 73 neither 😁

I am very sorry to ruin the like count of 69, but I must like thus comment. Please forgive me. 🙏

Adriana Is Me dats ok

***** the same way you enchant a car to fly, stairs to move, portraits to have LIFE AND SENTIENCE, the whole ceiling to show the sky, you know...MAGIC!

MrKlausbaudelaire Actually, if I remember correctly Ron's broken wand wasn't even his in the first place, it was Charlie's (or maybe Bill's) old wand, because the Weasley's couldn't afford to buy him his own. So if the school let him borrow a wand it really wouldn't have been all that different from before. It's also clear in Deathly Hallows that just because a wand isn't yours/didn't choose you doesn't mean you can't use it, like that time Harry broke his wand and then Ron gave him one he got off a snatcher, and it seemed to work just fine for him (however he might have said something about it not "feeling the same" or something, but that didn't stop him from being able to use it.

Srbuckley Actualy, I believe its easier to use a wand from someone you know such as close friends and family, because you know this person as you know his wand, I mean, they hammered in the 7th book how wads have a strong mind on their own, so maybe thats how they behave.Also, the wand from the snatchers also didn't work very well, the movie even had a brief scene where he tests the wand and..well, it was quite hilarious xD But I believe, in the wizarding world, only wand professinal can handle wand distribution.

MrKlausbaudelaire 'the movie cut off a scene where Hagrid comes to Dumbledore's office complaining that all his roosters had been killed, considering how we have 2:30 hour-long movies, that 20 seconds scene shouldn't have been cut off. ' that would make sense if the world population of roosters happened to live at the school. ' they most likely did that out of reflex, once they knew how reliable the earmuffs were, the screams didn't bother anyone.' okay.....no if you look at their facial expressions it looks like the earmuffs ar doingshit all ' the position of a teacher in Hogwarts is quite prestigious in their world, so for Lockhart, it boosts his ego.' I doubt he needs an ego boost 'oh come on, he said he was getting stronger, more alive. That includes SOLID!' doesn't really answer the sin 4 out of 83

slowpoke slowells I don't know about the earmuffs, it still looks like reflex. besides, notice they can still hear the teacher's voice, so those earmuffs must be enchanted to filter sounds. Also, we are talking about Lockhart, there is no such thing as "not needing an ego boost" xD

THANK YOU

THIS IS WHAT YOU SHOULD LEARN IN SCHOOL. THESE ARE THE USEFUL THINGS

and liek who cares I mean

@@hithere4289 like*

@@rosag2277 not really I only corrected the spelling r/whoosh is used most when a joke is mis understood

Agreed

in a deleted scene hagrid goes to dumbledore's office to talk him about his dead chickens.

On the top, it says "the books does not matter" :')

@@pifi3764 Not just the books. There is an actual deleted scene (kept in some movies) which shows Hagrid taking roosters to Dumbledore's office. This means that they couldn't use roosters to kill the basilisk.

Daniel Bickley Gorman yeah it happens in the film

ya and the blood was rooster blood

Lab Matt It's because she's annoying, and specifically hangs out in the bathroom which is probably a little awkward (I imagine most ghosts aren't in the bathroom).

MrServantRider Peeves is an annoying little shit, and he hangs out everywhere!

Lab Matt she's dramatic. she cries and yells at them. if she weren't a ghost, they'd still avoid her. lol

Lab Matt And people DO try to avoid him... although it's hard to do since he just floats through walls lol.

Lab Matt Well Nearly Headless Nick is a gentleman, and there is nothing about him to be afraid of.

Vi S I agree.

Cinemasins: Assholes who don't care!

YEH I WAS SOO MAD WHEN I HEARD THAT

True, it's rude to mention it or at least that way. We can blame the producers for making the new Dumbledore look so much different.

But the sins are not all complains. And they only remove sins when there is something great about a movie. Its not great that someone dies and it would be wierd if they didnt mention it

Yes it is!

+lasseplatburk Not all teachers are paid poorly. Hogwarts has unions. :O

+lasseplatburk Americans are used to low-paying teacher jobs..

+nonnanevrotica what do u mean by that

+Anna Boscia It means exactly as they said.

He can, and he could easily leave and never come back. It's in their blood to stay though as they are brought up to be servants.

Thank you.

Accio Rooster? no? ok..

That wasn't in the movie The books don't matter when it comes to cinema sins, he is only judging the movie

Actually, in the movie you see Hagrid holding dead roosters in his hands.

Like...made the species extinct... cause I'm pretty sure an 5 hour round trip to the muggel world for a rooster would be worthwhile... also... why don't the hogwarts teachers ever do the minimal research on these historically insane monsters (Basilics info: 1 page total of info).

Reading ding

Arnold Rivas its good for the mind and soul. And for knowing what happens in the movies.

Spoop I know it is. I've read the books too. But I long accepted that not everything will be explained, mentioned or make a cameo in the films long ago. But the films are good, very good compared to other YA adaptations, there are other exceptions however.

Arnold Rivas yes I will give the movies that, but still.

Spoop I know. I know. What is the worst YA adaptation you've seen?

hahaha, incredibly true.

you know they get paid for ads right

Zachary Cordry You get very little money from ad revenue. A lot is taken by Google and if you skip the ads (those 30 second+ ones where it lets you skip after 5 seconds) the advertiser doesn't have to pay. People also use AdBlock, so a lot of it doesn't actually get given to the creators. People like the Yogscast now don't mind their fans skipping ads/using AdBlock as long as they compromise like buying a shirt or something, as they get more from selling merch

They need to do this... seriously :|.

Skitty Unfortunately he's currently in Azkaban, where his "powerful friends" in the Ministry cannot help him and the Dementors suck every last bit of good cheer out of his day. P.S: Nice Draco reference, though.

YESSSSSSS HE WILLLL

no siriusly [lol] i hate this vid

Yes. Yes he will.

Yeah,that guy is really rude😡

@efun milum about dumbledore cast change 8:31

also don’t play it for laughs holy sh*t!

@@mr.halfbloodprince394 yeah ikr.. its fucked up he trolled dumbledore death..

Everyone in this comment thread obviously isn't used to Cinema Sins, it's not a really big deal ya f*cking snowflakes

YellowStarCTC Because he have a huge ego.If he used the quill to answer his fan mails,it won't mean anything to him.All the fan mails are just food for his ego.

YellowStarCTC He would've wanted to use Harry for this task so later he could boast how Harry Potter served him by answering his fan mail.

It wouldn't have that personal touch?