spencer looked so upset when he realized he skipped over danielle lol

Amy Adams as Beverly. I honestly thought she was her real life daughter. And there was that superman joke, which I interpreted as a nod to the audience

If Amy Adams isn’t considered as Beverly Marsh I’m suing😂 She is in House talent, Sophia Lillis literally looks like a younger version of her and they can’t let that Lois Lane reference vanish into nothing 🤣

Robert Downey jr. playing Kirk Lazarus playing Mike Hanlon

Recast Pennywise with Tommy Wiseau

Tobey Maguire would be the perfect Bill.

I was thinking IT would be fun to cast Seth Green as the adult Richie Tozier.

Leo can't be Pennywise. He doesn't float!

Just in case you're interested, the kids themselves have stated who they'd want to be as their older selves. So Bill was Christian Bale, Ben was Chris Pratt, Bev was Jessica Chastain, Mike was Chadwick Boseman and then Richie was Bill Hader, Eddie was Jake Gyllenhaal and Stan was Joseph Gordon Levitt.

IDEA... can we do a mix of prestige and popcorn for a GOURMET POPCORN ...??? Cause I equally like a mix of both of those choices.. Also, sorry Spencer,

Spencer's picks though 😂😂😂

Jake Gyllnehaal, Leonardo DiCaprio, carrey Mulligan Adam Driver, Idris Elba, Michael Faasbender, Tom Hiddelston. And as Pennywise, Mads Mikkelson There, it just won an Oscar

omg Roth 'he.. or she, how dare you' 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Not sure how Jake Gyllenhaal wasn't mentioned by everyone. He'd be great as Popcorn Bill, Prestige Pennywise, Provocative Eddie, or Punchline Bev.

I, for one, just enjoyed the peak behind the curtain of Danielle's family and heritage.

I love this new show idea, please keep doing it regularly!

You need to remember the ages of the adult versions - all 40 years old during the time of the film. Casting choices like Matthew Lewis who is way too young and Michael Stuhlbarg who is too old wouldn't be believable. I hope the actors who get cast will be late 30s to mid 40s. I'm not saying my choices are perfect but I tried to think outside the box while keeping the age of 40 in mind. Bill - Corey Stoll Bev - Jessica Chastian Ben - Joshua Jackson Eddie - Colin Hanks Richie - Bill Hader Stan - Johnny Galecki Mike - Andre Holland

I enjoyed this video. I hope it is a continuing series. I especially appreciated how you each chose a different approach/theme in your casting.

-Bill Skarsgård returning as Pennywise -Jake Gyllenhaal or some other leading man type as Bill -Amy Adams as Bev (duh) -Tobey Maguire(!) as Ben because I think he can do that kind of sweet and pathetic thing and Ben isn't supposed to be fat anymore -Elijah Wood as Eddie -The skinny version of Jonah Hill as Richie -Sterling K. Brown as Mike -Mark Ruffalo as Stan. Considering the role the adult Stan plays in the story, has to be someone who makes an impact. -Michael Shannon as Henry

How cool is the name "Finn Wolfhard"?

Love these type of videos. Always fun

This feels like Movie Fights. *I approve.*

Jason Bateman as Bill. His performance in Ozark really sold him as Bill for me. Jessica Chastain as Beverly. She has worked with Muschietti in the past and they look so alike. Amy Adams is a bit too "big" for Beverly. Chastain still has that smaller film vibe.

Spencer is SO SWEET!!! “I’m sorry. Did we skip you?”

Cast Away is fun, do more of them.

Danielle's synopsis of "Her" KILLED ME

This was so much fun! Hopefully there will be many more of these. Every new movie vaguely announced should be cast by these guys now.

Loved this! More cast away screenjunkies! Also I would love a mix of Roth and Danielle's lists. It would be an awesome movie.

Joseph Gordon Levitt for Bill.

I loved this video! Loved all the cast choices ❤️

"Put those eyes on a cactus!" hahahaha!

This was so good and funny to watch!

The best part is the beginning where Spencer and Danielle half dab at the same time when they get introduced. LOL

YESSSSSSSS!!!Haven't heard your picks yet but I'm glad you're putting the debate in the mainstream! Super excited for Chapter 2 casting!!!!

Bill - Zachary Levi Ben - Josh Radner Beverly - Sarah Drew Richie - Adrien Brody Mike - Sterling K Brown Eddie - Walter Goggins Stanley - Ben Mckenzie I truly don't understand going with big name actors for chapter two. TV actors are the way to go.

Finn Wolfhard sitting on Gaten Matarazzos shoulders 😂😂😂😂lmfao

I can't unhear/unthink Masterchief for IT2 now. Thanks, Spencer. SO CONTROVERSIAL YET SO PERFECT

Now this is the kind of movie fights I’d like to see! As much as I like the game show feel with two opponents this kind of set up feel more like movie fights and I’m glad to see that you guys are still putting out content like this even if it’s not under the movie fights label

ABsolutely loooved this video, make more please

“Put those eyes on a cactus and I will take a risk with that cactus!” Lmao I died

what a fun show, all three of you are so funny especially together !! xx

Good call on Bill Hader. Not an obvious choice but you totally nailed it and it’s the only thing that makes sense when you really think about it.

My dream cast for IT chapter 2 would be made up of all child actors from the 80's. Wil Wheaton as Bill (he basically played the same part in Stand By Me), Molly Ringwald as Beverly (Spencer got that one right), Jerry O'Connel as Ben (again, basically played the same character in Stand By Me), Seth Green as Richie (literally played the same character in the IT miniseries) Will Smith as Mike, Fred Savage as Eddie, and Anthony Rapp as Stanley

I actually really like this idea. It's pretty cool that they are going at the casting with multiple intentions in mind.

Well damn she called Bill Hader

Amy Adams is perfect casting

The "Oh yeeeaaah..." 8:32 in unison was perfect.

I Present the Cast of IT: Chapter 2! Bill-Patrick Wilson Ben- Jerry O'Connell Bev- Amy Adams Mike- Chiwetel Ejiofor Eddie- Joaquin Phoenix or Jake Gyllenhall Richie- Bill Hader Stan- Larry David Henry Bowers- Kevin Bacon Pennywise- Bill Skarsgard

Love this idea, I want more!

I had a lot of fun watching this one!

This was a fun show. More CastAway please

I love this series concept!

Lol as soon as Spencer started talking i was like "oh boy, he's going for it". Awesome!

These are both ridiculous choices and so enjoyable to watch! 😂

This was 3 judges away from being the proper movie fights format.

I really dig this show. Hope you do some more.

Bill - Tom Hardy Ben - Matt Damon Beverly - Charlize Theron Richie - Jeremy Renner Mike - Chiwetel Ejiofor Eddie - Jake Johnson Stanley - Chris Pratt

Really thought they were going to be talking about Casting Castaway 2 but this is also good.

Danielle got Bill Hader right.

What a great format for a fan casting show! Love the breakdown of Prestige, Blockbuster, and Provocative. Can we please add Joe or Dan in with their Indie casting?

Spencer’s movie is making $1Billion opening weekend

Any ideas on who will be playing adult Georgie?

“SPOILSIES”... ❤️🤣 it Danielle!!!

Great show,as akways!

Tobey Maguire- Bill Chris Pratt- Ben Rachel McAdams- Beverly Danny McBride- Richie Anthony Mackie- Mike Paul Rudd- Eddie Casey Affleck- Stanley These people fit the adult versions of these kids so well, this would be the perfect cast!

My version of "IT: Chapter 2" (not including characters not yet introduced) - Bill: Bill Hader - Ben: Patrick Wilson - Beverly: Kate Winslet - Richie: Marc Maron - Mike: Sterling K Brown - Eddie: Michael Shannon - Stanley: Michael Stuhlbarg - Pennywise: Willem Dafoe - Henry Bowers: Edward Norton

Spencer's Ben if he's old enough, and Chris Pratt otherwise; Roth's Eddie and Mike; Matt Damon as Bill and not Ben; Jessica Chastain as Beverly, who has both interest in the role and Sophia's love; and Danielle's Stan and Richie, mainly because I've been pulling for Hader to get that role forever and I really do think he would kill it.

"Does he really look like the kid though?" - Says the guy who cast Master Chief as Mike. :p

Great video Guys :)

Casting a lot of old dudes who grew up in the 1970s, rather than the 80s. Makes about as much sense as Ewan McGregor becoming Sir Alec Guinness in less than 20 years.

Corey Stoll as Bill Jessica Chastain as Beverly Josh Hartnett as Ben Bill Hader as Richie Sterling K Brown as Mike Adam Scott as Eddie Giovanni Ribisi as Stan Stephen Dorff as Bowers

While reading the book I always pictured Eddie as Joe Lo Truglio. Even when they were kids. It was just a bunch of kids and Joe Lo Truglio puffing on his inhaler

You have to have Seth Green as Richie. He was little Richie in the 90s version. IT would be so meta, plus the timing works out so well

Jim Carrey as pennywise

Mike - Idris Elba Stan - Leonardo Dicaprio - I think the role demands a huge name Bev - Drew Barrymore (ET, Firestarter) Bill - Christian Bale (Newsies, Empire of the Sun) Ben - Jerry O'Connell (Stand by Me) Richie - Will Wheaton (Stand by Me) Eddie - Elijah Wood (Radio Flyer, The Good Son)

Yesss more Danielle!! Always more Danielle

This was hysterical

Eddie Murphy in every role. Done.

Danielle Actually called one of the casting choices. Nice job

I feel like Isla Fisher should be Bev

Roth perfectly explains how I never knew I always thought about Ben Affleck hahaha

I would seriously go for the popcorn edition 😍

This is such a good segment! I hope they'll do a casting for new upcoming stars too. Stars that just got big recently like Timothee Chalamet, Gal Gadot, Bill Skarsgard, Tiffany Haddish, etc.

I am totally on board for Spencer's picks loving it

Bill Hader as Ritchie Tozier is inspired.

this video was GREAT

Welcome to Screen Junkies' newest show, Movie Agreements!

Thank you for talking about how amazing Colossal was. Very overlooked movie. Jason Sudekis killed it. Also, Don Cheadle for Mike???

Y'all are high. BEN FOSTER - Bill CHRIS PRATT - Ben AMY ADAMS - Bev JONAH RAY - Richie RAY FISHER - Mike TOBY KEBBELL - Eddie JOSEPH GORDON-LEVIT - Stan

I really like this segment! Dream casting is my favorite activity/ conversation so this was fun to watch! I personally want John Mulaney as Eddie. Maybe next episode could be a CLUE remake cast? (God forbid a CLUE remake)

This was, possibly, the most inane video I have seen in my entire life.

I would pay a hundred dollars to see Spencer's vision come true

Josh Hartnett for Ben. Same eyes and a Minnesota nice guy. Jimmi Simpson for Bill. Sarah Paulson for Bev. Two words....Hair dye. You don’t have to cast solely on hair colour. Bill Hader for Richie. David Oyelowo. Gotta have a Brit in it 😃 As for Eddie.....no idea.

Bill - Patrick Wilson Ben - Chris Pratt Richie - Bill Hader Mike - Chadwick Boseman Eddie - Joseph Gordon-Levitt Stan - Jake Gyllenhaal Beverly - Jessica Chastian Audra - Amy Adams Tom Rogan - Jon Hamm

Bill Hader is actually exactly who Finn said he wanted in multiple interviews...

I don't think I've ever heard people say popcorn so many times in one video

To this day I’m still upset that Amy Adams wasn’t Beverly. She fit the role so much better in my opinion. (Writing this almost a year after It Chapter 2 released)

Lets be real here: Danny DeVito for Pennywise!

Jason Bateman as Bill, Chris Pratt as Ben, Molly Ringwald as Bev, Daniel Kaluuya as Mike, Bill Hader as Ritchie, Sebastian Stan as Eddie, Michael Stuhlbarg as Stanley

Spencer’s version shouldn’t be called “Provocative” it should be called “The Meme Version”