Yellow, Red, and In-Between: Refereeing Analysis of Springboks' Historic Win Over All Blacks

Рет қаралды 49,172

Күн бұрын

In the tapestry of rugby history, when the Springboks and All Blacks clash, it's nothing short of epic. These are matches painted with power plays, strategic brilliance, and sheer determination. The recent showdown in south-west London will be etched in the annals as a testament to the Springboks' might and power.
Setting the Scene:
The Springboks and the All Blacks have given the world some of rugby's most iconic moments. As the two titans squared off in London, with the looming World Cup casting its shadow, it wasn’t just about victory; it was about legacy, momentum, and pride. The match was officiated by Referee Matthew Carley, flanked by ARs Christophe Ridley and Craig Evans, and aided by TMO Tom Foley.
A Game of Moments:
Rugby is often a game of moments, and this match had its share. The dual yellow for Scott Barrett that resulted in a red card was certainly a pivotal point, but it's worth noting the meticulous deliberation that went into the decision. Barrett's actions, particularly in the high-stakes environment of this matchup, were closely scrutinized, reflecting the importance of player safety and discipline in today's game.
Pieter-Steph du Toit's tackle on Sam Cane could easily have become another flashpoint, but the officials, after careful review, deemed it worthy of a yellow - a testament to their emphasis on balanced judgment. Faf de Klerk's playful mischief and the dynamic around the lineouts and scrums further underscored the challenging task the officials faced. Their decisions, though occasionally debated, showcased a commitment to upholding the spirit and integrity of the game.
Springbok Supremacy:
Beyond the whistles and cards, it's impossible not to marvel at the sheer dominance of the Springboks. Their clinical execution, coupled with raw power, had the All Blacks on the ropes. The lineout mastery, the formidable scrum showings, and the relentless pressure, punctuated by moments of individual brilliance, made this a match to remember for every Springbok supporter.
The forwards of South Africa encapsulated the Springbok spirit, combining strength with strategy, ensuring the All Blacks felt their presence throughout. The scoreboard might tell a part of the story, but the Springboks’ control of the game narrative was absolute.
Conclusion:
While the final whistle marked the end of the match, discussions and analyses started brewing. This video delves deep into the key decisions, offering a lens into the challenges and responsibilities of rugby officiating.
00:00 - Scott Barrett & PSDT Yellow Cards
02:34 - Lineout Analysis
09:35 - SA Getting Lucky
11:17 - Scrum Analysis
13:02 - Bonus Content
Lastly, I would also like to thank VHA Accounting Solutions for their partnership during this 2023 Rugby Championship. This video was sponsored by them. We look forward to a great partnership during this Rugby Championship
For this Video I used CoachPaint from TRACAB, they're the best in the industry with regards to telestration software:
For a 14-day Trial you can use this link: bit.ly/coach-paint-tasanalytics
Check them out on:
LinkedIn: / tracab
Twitter: / tracab_
Facebook: / tracab.ok
Instagram: / tracab_
#CoachPaint
#Tracab

Пікірлер: 180

@tasanalytics 9 ай бұрын

This is a reupload from my video on Sunday, it initially got blocked in New Zealand, but I did appeal the claim and Sky Television New Zealand submitted a fraudulent takedown request of that video, which results in it automatically getting taken down. I immediately filed a counter notification, since my video follows the fair use guidelines, but now I have to wait 10 business days for that video to be reinstated. So this video will be blocked in New Zealand, since Sky Television New Zealand do what they always do and abuse KZfaq's Copyright system, or they're trying to protect their fans from witnessing how the Springboks destroyed their team.

@sergiobenjamin6601 9 ай бұрын

Thanks for this. I came back looking for the video and saw it was removed. Been watching New Zealand pundits point of view on the game and it seemed quite personal and hard for them to take a loss. I like your unbiased approach to these videos. As a Saffa, I don't think we should get ahead of ourselves just yet, but great performance by the boks.

@hellcocktimes154 9 ай бұрын

well yea, its not news that the bad side of the neozed rugby is very often hidden from the people over there...from roids to obvious red cards , and now this hilarious no suspension scott barett....surely a relative of owen farell, or maybe just the paycheck from the nz federation had the same amounts of zeros on it

@tasanalytics 9 ай бұрын

@@sergiobenjamin6601 Yeah I saw that, and them basically saying Malcom Marx faked an injury, was just a stupid take. And I agree that we shouldn't be too confident just yet, but it is definitely nice to see the boks getting form at the right time, especially our forwards because that game showed us one thing, and that is that if the boks forwards are at their best, we'll dominate any team in the world. So hopefully the forwards can keep it up.

@gibean 9 ай бұрын

Fight the good fight brother, hope everything goes well 💪

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

Great job Tas. You just keep doing what you do. We saw their podcasts and how they were portraying the match. Just Mark ( Tc) and Tony (DS) were fair. Never back down no matter what. Our boys are our pride. Nobody should ever think it's ok to treat them like garbage. Our blood is green👊💚💛🇿🇦

@HamishBanish 9 ай бұрын

My head is spinning trying to read the text and watch the play Voiceovers please, so easy to do and so powerful. Your analysis is some of the best, don't neglect this

@rfhVO 9 ай бұрын

I offer doing it for free. For me these videos are not only for pointing out right and wrong calls. These videos educate people about the rules and to gain a better understanding about the wonderful game of rugby. Many people are either not educated on the complexities of the the rules of rugby OR they still think the laws of the game are still the same as it was back in the day. Making these videos serves the fans to understand the game making them more likely to enjoy it. Doing voice overs will deliver a better experience by allowing the viewers to focus on the game footage without distraction. Mr TAS. Please consider. No, my accent will not give away my country thus will not be the cause of comments calling these reviews biased. I can even switch my accent. 😄

@BbBb-sd2bs 9 ай бұрын

Its calles a pause button jou poes.

@tasanalytics 9 ай бұрын

@@rfhVO Check your email

@StaalBurgher0 9 ай бұрын

@@tasanalytics You guys should consider a series that go through the rule book with live video examples. Not seen anyone do that. Then you can refer current videos to your benchmark. Maybe also develop a ref scoring system that you track over time by team by ref vs team ref etc. Put it on a website with search function. Big job of course but possibly a wsy for you to monetize in the future.

@rylanhartze7914 8 ай бұрын

@@rfhVOyou sir are an mvp

@sbok9481 9 ай бұрын

Referees did put themselves under pressure for always only looking at SA infringements. Nick Mallet eloquently put it in an interview when we started in the URC. The referee would position himself to on see and concentrate only when SA teams faulted. He said you need to look at both teams. That make Referees good. Suddenly, when referees look both sides, they now miss 50/50 on both sides, to make the errors equal and it is supposed to cancel out. Yes, the referee made mistakes, both sides, in contrary to one-sided officiating in the past against SA.

@ollie-qu8ny 8 ай бұрын

Personally, I feel like the decisions favoured SA alot in this game.

@riaazlewis7336 8 ай бұрын

Go check the last game these two teams were playing in the championship New Zealand were favoured by the ref

@Josh-Kai2626 8 ай бұрын

You know at the end of the day it’s easy to go back and forth with video analysis after the game but when it’s full paced and full on this is a tough job for any ref.

@sheldonboshoff6441 7 ай бұрын

Great videos, TASanalytics. They are super educational! Keep up the good work. 👏🏻👏🏻

@SAS477 8 ай бұрын

Brilliant analytics TAs. I really appreciate this accurate and unbiased analysis. Please keep up the good work. Nothing else like this globally. 👍🇿🇦

@willempretorius6700 9 ай бұрын

According to every New Zealand rugby pundit it was the NH referee's interpretation and he was obviously wrong. Sooo, NZ is not above blaming the ref after all 😅

@shaheempashua6924 9 ай бұрын

I'm enjoying every minute of it 🇿🇦❤️ I'm actually searching for their channels just to hear them "not" moan

@willempretorius6700 9 ай бұрын

@@CapeTown-xj7sx by all means do it, but then you can't turn around and holler from your soapbox that South Africans always blame the ref. THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT NZ IS DOING.

@shaheempashua6924 9 ай бұрын

@@CapeTown-xj7sx but according to them it's only ever us that do it Even you wannabe All Blacks say the same thing all the time So what's happening now 😂💦

@roluss4297 8 ай бұрын

It's called Aussie ref syndrome, they're brilliant between world cups and to try and grow the game in their native regions but usually gets discarded for real refs come world cup time.

@ash_17406 8 ай бұрын

Whatcha got to say now after the Wales v Fiji match?! Did you think all those line penalties the Boks were awarded in the first half were legit?! Of course you do 🙄

@crusaders9861 8 ай бұрын

Hi, I am an All Blacks supporter but that should have no bearing on what I am about to say. Firstly, South Africa clearly dominated the game and frankly destroyed the ABs. It was a fully deserved win. To be a great team, you must take the referee out of the equation (which 🇿🇦 did in this case). Bad calls happen all the time but you must adapt (another thing which the ABs failed to do). In this game I think it’s clear that the referring was not biased but it was inconsistent. This is how rugby has been for around 6 years now and it is seemingly getting worse. The rules of rugby are in an even worse state. Foul play rules are ridiculous (not to mention judiciary). I don’t even think that PSDT’s yellow card should be a penalty (ABs player was leading with head). Scott Barrett’s yellow was justified (reckless but no head contact). The fact is that rugby is a contact sport and is stupid to believe that we can have no dangerous collisions. These rules incentivise teams to make passive tackles, leading the attacking team to just hold the ball for endless periods of time. There are way too many penalties. I am not an expert but if I delved into the rules I am sure I would be able to eliminate tons of rules that slow the game down. This leads me to my next gripe. Time wasting is rife in rugby at the moment. Players who are injured (or pretending to be injured) should leave the field immediately. Set pieces should start within a time limit (and while the set piece is happening the time should be off). Same applies for goal kicks. This game lasted for 107 minutes and only 33 minutes saw actual play. This is disgraceful for an 80 minute game. 20 minute red cards be brought in. I don’t know why World Rugby didn’t allow this. They seem to like picking and choosing innovations from super rugby (E.g. 50-22) so why don’t they use this? Overall, the rules must be tidied up and the refereeing must be far more consistent. If you do not agree with what I say please tell me and we can have a friendly debate. At the end of the day, we all want rugby to be better

@RaymondOConnor911 7 ай бұрын

Incorrect. Rerefees have been this inconsistent for more than 2 decades with New Zealand sitting as chairperson of the referees board...

@rfhVO 9 ай бұрын

I would love to do voiceovers for these videos for those who can't read as fast and or focus on the text and video at the same time. Anyone think this is a good idea?

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

Tas said you'd get a lot of hate. If you're willing, we'll support you as long as it doesn't come out as being biased.

@aphiwemagengelele2975 9 ай бұрын

I actually battle reading so fast i have to pause and it takes me a good 40 min to finish the video. Otherwise great job by TAS if it is in his strategy to have voice overs then would be a plus for some of us

@rfhVO 9 ай бұрын

@@wot4922I don't mind the hate. I am just a voice. Voice-overs wil not be biased. Basically just reading the text and adding a very brief explanation of the exact law that was broken per the official rugby rules if absolutely necessary and if omitted from the text.

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

@@rfhVO go for it 👊🇿🇦

@NickSchoonwinkel 9 ай бұрын

Goto setting of the video and slow down the video speed.

@RebelRose31 8 ай бұрын

Your video breakdowns are on another level. Thank you

@bellscafricano8942 8 ай бұрын

Great stuff as always. Thanks

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

There was also this one guy...Matt Williams, I think ...who was spitting the word " abusive" because how dare we play a 7/1 bench. Just crazy.

@Forest9528 9 ай бұрын

Just wait until the day the boks pull out an 8-0 Non SA pundits will have a heart attack

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

@@Forest9528 😂😂😂

@glen1482 9 ай бұрын

Ag shame man... poor Kiwis

@RianaBotha40 9 ай бұрын

Is there a law against a 7/1 ? If not then WTF is the issue?

@glen1482 9 ай бұрын

@@RianaBotha40 Exactly! Frikken chops

@glen1482 9 ай бұрын

Stick to your guns TAS - let the truth be known for better or worse! Looks like NZ tactics in the media mirror their rugby team's defensive manouvers...

@Apexgambling 9 ай бұрын

This Game was Brutal but the All Blacks had it coming The SpringBoks were just better on the day but i am hoping for an AllBlacks vs SpringBoks Final that would be legedary😮

@hotshot243 9 ай бұрын

All stepping offside at the same time usually when the ref has his back turned is trained into new zealanders they have been doing it for decades

@listeningto8371 9 ай бұрын

Ohh. There there

@crusaders9861 8 ай бұрын

South Africa were massively offside as well

@samgreer8274 8 ай бұрын

The ref was influenced by the players. Love your objective and unbiased analysis. Excellent stuff. Im an All Black fan but I respect your channel.

@letmebleed510 8 ай бұрын

Carley is on another planet

@edwardmurray2139 9 ай бұрын

I seem to remember the NZ guy with the Black Jersey review channel calling the Boks paper tigers after the last test... that comment didn't age well.

@corbanbenthannon2081 8 ай бұрын

Can someone please send this to Jeff Wilson.

@jaunschambreel 8 ай бұрын

What does the rule state regarding props scrumming in at a angle?

@jaanc8047 9 ай бұрын

We need lineout lines sprayed on the field by referees to make the rule enforceable. Just like the vanishing foam to mark the freekick walls in football.

@Stooeybear13 8 ай бұрын

I am dying for your analysis on the SA vs Scotland game that happened today. Im not sure but defo felt fishy in terms of analytics!

@petestewart9442 8 ай бұрын

That one of the SA no 8, the ref was going to carry on playing. Smith was pointing at him and screaming for play to be stopped. The ref was just there who had to have heard NZ 9 calling and shouting for play to be stopped

@kakpraat18 9 ай бұрын

The ever pious New Zealanders, never do anything wrong, never get called out for there endless gamesmanship, never like hearing anyone else's opinion.

@gerhardburger6777 8 ай бұрын

That is good, shows how much the game ischanged by a ref and power. With ref beeing fair, now everyone can see what is going on really....

@roleinc7204 9 ай бұрын

You didn't look at Scott Barrett's first yellow card. It shouldn't have even been a penalty. Barrett was pushed by a SA player over the ruck and forcibly rammed into the SA 9. I agree his second yellow card was utterly stupid and deserved. I also agree that ABs should have been far more heavily penalised for the scrummaging collapses - geez... Fletcher Newell ... he didn't even play Super Rugby this year. He is not ready to be back in the Black jersey. The Lineout laws you are citing, some of the occaisions you point out are correct, but some you claim are offside are absurd claims. You are allowed to prepare for the other teams maul by readying your arms. Mauls are 1) boring 2) ugly 3) lacking skill 4) difficult enough to defend as it is. If you want referees to properly govern exact technique for every single lineout, god what an awful game to watch that would be ... I would prefer more stringent rules around attacking with a maul than defending it. Like you shouldn't be able to wheel a maul around to the side, like you can't wheel a scrum. Either you have the power to advance or you don't. If you don't then get the ball out so the fans can see some entertaining attacking rugby instead.

@nerdyali4154 9 ай бұрын

Who cares what you would prefer. The lineout laws are clear and you take your chances if you step offside like that. It is interfering with the opposition. I would strongly disagree that mauls lack skill. It takes coordination and appreciation of the laws to maul properly. Mauls are very entertaining and are certainly attacking rugby, just sucks to be on the receiving end. Perhaps you would prefer watching touch rugby?

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

Barrett's first yellow was not about him. It was for all the teams mistakes. He just happened to be picked. Unlucky, but the ref was sick of what the ABs were doing. That's what I heard during the game on Friday.

@roleinc7204 9 ай бұрын

@@nerdyali4154 Obviously I care about my preferences as much as you care about mauls and pedantic refereeing of lineout laws. I never said a maul isn't attacking. It's just boring and no, it does not take skill. It takes strength. World Rugby wants an entertaining game and have tweaked many laws to promote a spectacular and fast version of the game. IMO they aint there yet. If what you saw in the SA vs NZ game is your definition of an entertaining game ... well shit, I don't know what to tell you. Perhaps you would also like gouging out your own eyes with a spoon?

@roleinc7204 9 ай бұрын

@@wot4922 Totally correct. I was pointing out that the analyst did not examine the footage in depth to establish whether or not Barretts first action was deserving of a penalty. You can see the SA forward tackling Barrett over the ruck towards the SA half-back. Barrett didn't leap over and play the 9 on his own accord, which would be deserving of a penalty and given the high penalty count and warning a deserving team yellow card.

@duvanlewis9855 7 ай бұрын

Did world rugby remove all your newest vids ? Was just watching the SA VS FRA analysis and now its gone 😂or am I just not looking

@tasanalytics 7 ай бұрын

Not World Rugby, it's a angry French fan using a fake account. My videos will be up again soon

@duvanlewis9855 7 ай бұрын

@@tasanalytics dannggg , I knew the ref was bad but yoh , to go to that extent 😂thanks Mate love your vids

@edwardmurray2139 9 ай бұрын

Where Moody is offside at the ruck, at 14:44 it is an AB hand moving the ball rearwards out of that ruck... surely no hands are allowed in a ruck unless one is the scrumhalf?

@tasanalytics 9 ай бұрын

The ball was out, when the AB player scooped it back, so can't be hands in ruck. Now if he was off his feet, it would be penalty, but he was also on his feet when he did that.

@edwardmurray2139 9 ай бұрын

@@tasanalytics Thanks. At 13:53 after Eben plays the ball on the ground, NZ4 Sam Whitelock is lying on top of SA 13 Moodie and pops the ball back to NZ 11 who knocks it on... surely NZ 4 is also playing the ball on the ground here?

@kalimstanney8437 8 ай бұрын

Watching a few of the world cup games, the closing the gap in the line out is happening all the time, why no penalty??

@johnjohn-fe4ev 9 ай бұрын

Any footage of the SA bloke hitting the all black player? Looked to be hitting him in the back of the head at first glance but can’t find a reply. Was around when Barrett went off his feet into Marx’s shoulder

@JeyesFluid 9 ай бұрын

You mean when he was trying to dislodge himself from Luke Jacobson who illegally entered the ruck and illegally clung on to his leg while on the ground prevention Vermulin to play or break away. He's (Jacobson) is lucky didn't get another yellow or a boot to the head instead. Have you actually played a game of rugby I wonder.

@johnjohn-fe4ev 9 ай бұрын

@@JeyesFluid haha wow settle down mate. Eben done the same thing to ardie in the build up to Marx’s try. That exact tactic. Except the AB’s player didn’t start striking eben. Simmer down

@nerdyali4154 9 ай бұрын

"Went off his feet into Marx's shoulder!" That is some seriously heavy duty spin. He f**king DIVED onto the guy with his shoulder turned in with no pretence at even trying to bind. Worthy of a suspension as there could have been no other intention than to hurt someone by means of an illegal act.

@jordanh4017 9 ай бұрын

He did bring it up with the ref and ref said its his fault for holding on to him

@michaelbaxter7452 9 ай бұрын

When NZ lose there's all these calls for the laws to change, complaints about the ref, comments that the game means nothing or that they are playing their second team. Humiliating IMO

@ruin2253 9 ай бұрын

What rule change?

@ThunderCat_za 9 ай бұрын

I saw a clip on Tiktok where they are complaining about our 7-1 split and going to appeal to World Rugby to change the laws because SA is abusing the bench lol. Man the rugby world was salty about our 6-2 split, now the 7-1 split. SA welcomes all the hate and negativity about our Boks, we will just keep doing our own thing. 🤣🤣🤣

@Forest9528 9 ай бұрын

@ShudleyAdams Wait until the day they whip out an 8-0 experiment. Non bok fans will have a heart attack Your allowed to split your bench any way you want to fit your playstyle. It's not "abusing the bench" it's called having a strategy

@roleinc7204 9 ай бұрын

WTF are you even talking about? When teams lose SOME of their fans whinge. For every single team. You think there aren't SA fans who cry or complain when the Boks lose? Or England or Ireland? Or anywhere? Your opinion is humiliating.

@dantewalters5209 9 ай бұрын

@@Forest9528 they simply don't have the depth in their forwards to do a 7-1 split, therefore it should be against the laws of rugby.

@faizalvally1340 8 ай бұрын

With all their damn infringements, we still moered them! ❤

@xavierwolmarans6391 8 ай бұрын

can u do France vs All Blacks opener please ??

@tasanalytics 8 ай бұрын

Of course, busy with it as we speak.

@goranblevi1924 9 ай бұрын

I guess my question is.. For Moodie's ungiven solo effort, HOW the HELL was the clear "hands in ruck" missed. I mean It's as clear as day.

@tasanalytics 9 ай бұрын

The ball was out, when the AB player scooped it back, so can't be hands in ruck. Now if he was off his feet, it would be penalty, but he was also on his feet when he did that.

@edwardmurray2139 9 ай бұрын

This one stumped me too. However, at 15:43 the ruck is already over as no Bok player is bound so the NZ players can use their hands.

@goranblevi1924 9 ай бұрын

I understand your point but the ball can not be out because the ruck was still formed, that's the reason Moodie was given as offside. The ball was still under the ruck and therefor it is irrelevant if the player who played it was on their feet or not. fine margins, but that ball was not allowed to be played.@@tasanalytics

@barendvanderlinde2530 8 ай бұрын

@@edwardmurray2139 the ruck was already formed, even if all the boks left the ruck it stays a ruck, like wise with a maul, once you made contact it is a maul.

@barendvanderlinde2530 8 ай бұрын

@@goranblevi1924 hindmost point of any ruck participant. Moodie was standing in the middle of the ruck

@jaunschambreel 8 ай бұрын

I understand nz inched in every line out but I beg you to show me a team who doesn't do it... Even school boy rugby it happens I don't think the ref and AR will call it through out the whole game they get gatvol too granted they should be punished for it but I think it will cause more harm to the game to penalise players all the time for it since literally all teams do it

@Stefaans007 9 ай бұрын

He tells Kitshoff to be carefull but it was PSDT that made contact with him😂

@commentwell3870 9 ай бұрын

I have an idea and I will patent this comment: Get an AI ref in the form of a drone which hovers over the field to "ref" the game. I will bet my bottom dollar that the Boks will win every 3 out of 4 matches they play vs the Abs using the AI ref.

@MrVenom5150 8 ай бұрын

yeah its tough Mr. TAS man, NZ has gotten way with a boatload of infringementa in the past. It probably stings a bit that referees are on to you.

@janstander7830 8 ай бұрын

Some of your calls are a bit of an extreme exacerbation. Possible yellow for everything. But mostly good analysis!

@TheThinkingMathematician 9 ай бұрын

Since they are complaining ! How about an analysis of the last significant rule changes - every time a team other than NZ was number 1! Notice how it was always a rule in favour of NZ and not the current number 1 team! England, SA, Australia all had it happen to them when they were number 1 instead of the all blacks

@eubo383 8 ай бұрын

I just love how us SA fans have been complaining about how NZ infringe on the rules pertaining to lineouts and breakdowns for years. We were labeled cry babies and mocked if we blamed the Ref... Finally a ref blew a SA v NZ game according to the written rules and not according to the players on the field. NZ is crying about the Ref... And I'm here for it. 🖕🏽🖕🏽

@sweetnsourtrading 9 ай бұрын

You probably check your valentines' cards for spelling mistakes.

@edwardmurray2139 9 ай бұрын

Why are you watching this channel? Do you not read the channel descriptions?

@bobbybobby3070 8 ай бұрын

Scott Barrett’s first yellow was because of the team being in a warning!! Not because of dangerous play (so why compare to PSDT yellow?). The ref had earned New Zealand as a team for continuous infringements and the next one would be a yellow! Scott Barrett infringed again … he was it then

@rylanhartze7914 8 ай бұрын

This ref is great. The AR was pathetic.

@kalimstanney8437 9 ай бұрын

Good to see your video back up. As a n.zer I did think during the match s.a were driving the line out into nz. But as you explained that wasn't the case. S.a dominated the scum. Can you see if the disallowed try by nz was given by the ref,? As I thought it was but called back by the tmo? If that's the case it's pretty odd. Yes nz fouled a lot, and yes you show some that sa got away with. There is another video of sa 2nd try, and ardie getting intentionally get tripped up by a sa player on the ground. With the sa neck rolls should the nz player stand down like the sa player and got the tmo to look at it? I hoped rugby wasn't going down that road. So although we were out played if things went a bit more our way it might have been a bit closer.

@MrAvw777 3 ай бұрын

Rugby is a contact sport, I think it is getting ridicules with the calls, on head contact as that will happen, I agree clear foul play should be penalized but to be honest allot of Yellow's are not Yellow or penalties, secondly officials needs to stop these soccer behavior coming into the game of faking injuries!

@markbrown-sb2zm 9 ай бұрын

Why do the Saffa commentators sling PSDT under the bus.If an Ab punched an opposition in the face,their commentator would say " nothing in it ".

@pixelpotato4874 9 ай бұрын

Should have 2 ball boys holding a 1 metre length marked by 2 Flags(Like in NFL marking downs)and halfway determines where the hooker stands

@peterlangan1181 9 ай бұрын

I can agree the ref missed some calls against the Boks but we have been penalised in the past unfairly game after game while some not so saintly All Blacks got away with things. So we have endured this often. So stop whinging All Black supporters, get over it, and move on, because if you are honest you were second best on the day. Play the same game this weekend and it would be very different. We know that, but we for sure enjoyed the moment!

@pheasantplucker6117 8 ай бұрын

If the game was stopped according to TAS analysis . There would be no play ever. TMO intervening calling out an infringement 5 phases ago or indeed reversing a try decision, with the benefit of slo mo, sucks. Also these neck roll calls are rediculous. reduculous.

@pierreplessis973 4 ай бұрын

Funny you didn't do the France v SA video. I thought it would be funny to see u witnessing ur team cheating to win

@willscott2409 8 ай бұрын

I think it's awful... we should scrub the result of the game and have both sides play it in slow motion... then it will all come out right!

@tomattwell4867 6 ай бұрын

stop having a go at our English referees Christophe Ridley and Matthew Carley. You have 0 respect for referees. Without referees the game wouldn't happen without them.

@fidget2020 8 ай бұрын

Players in the lineout can move as soon as the lineout commences, which is when the ball leaves the throwers hands. They can't cross the line of touch (not 0.5m from the line of touch) until the ball hits the ground or touches a player. Watch the lineouts again carefully. At almost every LO in the video the ABs move AFTER the ball has left Marx's hands - perfectly legal and they don't cross the line of touch until the ball has touched a player, again legal. Both the ref and our video analyst got this wrong. Barrets 2nd Y: a) he certainly was going for the ball as it popped out right at the collision point immediately, and b) it wasn't to Marx's head, but his shoulder. (No worse than RG Snyman's smash on Retallicks shoulder a few years ago in a ruck that put BR out of the game for about 6 months and from which he has never been quite the same)

@MrAvw777 3 ай бұрын

I have always said this but I was told I am just a sore loser, NZ is masters at playing at offside making it difficult for the teams, which means they are not playing by the rules! That is why they can put teams under pressure, it is clear, clearly the Lines man should see this but they don't want to call it as it will be every lineout and NZ will be showed up as cheaters, sorry to say!

@GeorgievskiDamjan 9 ай бұрын

At one point I wasn't sure if I was watching Scott Barrett or Tomas Lavanini.

@Mimeniia 9 ай бұрын

You were watching Scott Lavanini.

@DJSteenkampMusic 8 ай бұрын

New Zealand, world champions in cheating. Sign of clear weakness before the WC trying to get an edge

@dineshdavid405 9 ай бұрын

very complicating game rugby. No one knows the exact rules. football & cricket are so much simpler.

@nerdyali4154 9 ай бұрын

In football they don't even bother applying the rules. Beaten defenders are routinely allowed to reach out and paw at the opponent and disrupt his momentum, the ref ignores it and the mongoloid commentators, if they even notice, will say "Fer me, it were 50/50 competin' fer the baw". It absolutely kills the game. George Best would end up punching someone in frustration if he played now. The standard interaction between ref and players involves lots of scowls and snarling.

@Me-ex7qg 9 ай бұрын

So many bitter South African fans. Understandable after seeing your team getting dominated for so long. To bad it took cards for your team to score points. 57-0 and it was 15 vs 15

@k11vin 9 ай бұрын

Unreadable and no voiceover

@icecold3758 8 ай бұрын

Look who is complaining about refereeing now 😂.. What a joke

@TheMarketSniper1 9 ай бұрын

1. MAULS are killing rugby😂 = They are stronger than us up front! 2. The game was too slow😂 = We were holding players long after the ball was gone, We had the longest injury where we never removed our "Stabbed!" prop Lomax, Plus you had to review all our card fouls. 3. They picked 7 forwards! 😂 = They are "Abusing their Bench", we don't have the depth to do bomb squads too, so we must stop them from properly pasting us like that with theirs. Shriek for World Rugby 4. Nobody likes stop start rugby😂 = Springboks are responsible for our injuries, cards and pressurized us into countless fumbles & knock on's, they spoil our champagne rugby game 5. The TMOs are too involved 😂 = Sorting out all our on the edge cheating, holding of players is a massive job & we expect officials to let us get away with most of it, these ones actually wanted to penalize us for everything.

@dermotquinn 8 ай бұрын

We have rugby league for the champagne rugby...boring. Union is about a balance of strength and speed. The scrums and mauls are what makes it interesting. Already the held up pushover results in the defending team getting the next call... Anything to change the game to deter sides from gaining advantage over the ABs and reduce scrums they don't like.

@jean-lucpongerard8200 9 ай бұрын

referee had paid for loss new zealand it s a bad and sad referee ....un vrai fils de.....sa maman

@user-yourmomshouse 9 ай бұрын

what are you even saying?

@wot4922 9 ай бұрын

@@user-yourmomshouse ja. Who paid the ref. We're sooo poor, don't you know.

@elg1114 7 ай бұрын

You still haven’t had time to do an analysis on South Africa against France in 1995. The biggest scandal in rugby history

@tasanalytics 7 ай бұрын

Mate it's 2023, why are you stuck on 1995? It's the same as SA fans who complain about 2011. I'm not gonna make a video on something that happened more than 20 years ago

@elg1114 7 ай бұрын

@@tasanalytics the thing is you can’t get rid of the history because it says a lot about what happens now. But you can also use your sharp eye to do an analysis about Joubert performance in final 2011