Another quick look at the Cold Steel 1917 Bowie and a few of the ways I'm planning on using it in the field.
Пікірлер: 62
@JoeDoomsday5 жыл бұрын
I have that exact knife. I haven’t used it much but, so far mine has No Rust at all. I took off the handle scales and put Vaseline on all the metal even the screws. When I draw it from the sheath you can see the Vaseline all over the blade. I live in the North Eastern USA. It’s very wet, cold and Humid here. Everything Rusts here, But as I said: So Far , no rust. If my knife were rusting like that I would: Sand off all the rust. Put vinegar or yellow mustard on that area to Force a Patina on the steel to protect it. Finally I would coat it in petroleum jelly ( Vaseline ). - keep us updated, I love videos of this knife. 👍🏻
@S3aCa1mRa1n4 жыл бұрын
That’s the trade off because high carbon steel is durable and tough compared to stainless steel.
@DDDYLN Жыл бұрын
That's exactly what you should do as soon as you receive the knife. I have like 12 high carbon steel knives. None have even a little rust. I just use standard drug store mineral oil. I should probably get something that will last a bit longer. However, it's surprising how well cheap mineral oil does the job. A waxy coating would be better for long term storage.
@JoeDoomsday Жыл бұрын
@@DDDYLN ,… exactly. Recently I’ve been running the blade edge thru hard “Gulf Wax” then using a thin coat of Vaseline on the rest of the blade for longer storage,… like 3-12 months and it’s been working great.
@minarchist17763 жыл бұрын
As others have pointed out, a carbon steel blade will rust. The bluing helps to prevent that but it is not absolute protection. I periodically coat my 1917 Frontier Bowie with Break Free and haven't had a problem with it. Also note that there is a rounded cut out on the bottom of the blade by the handguard so you can position your index finger forward of the handguard to get more control for delicate cutting tasks.
@J.T.Stillwell35 жыл бұрын
I’m so glad we have no knife laws in NewHampshire
@BushCraftBums5 жыл бұрын
Looks like a great blade! Thanks for sharing and stay blessed
@Argento2615 жыл бұрын
Sorry, but the rust doesn´t have anything to do with quality control. it´s made of a non stainless steel, it will rust!
@gentlecaringviolence5 жыл бұрын
Yep, gotta keep it oiled. My display knives have renaissance wax and it works beautifully.
@longrider422 жыл бұрын
Yeah, its made from 1080, or 1085 high carbon steel. I love mine.
@donjuanmckenzie4897 Жыл бұрын
Except for the fact that it has some kind of coating or blueing which should PREVENT rust
@Murtagh653 Жыл бұрын
@@donjuanmckenzie4897 coatings and bluing helps steel prevent rust, but it is not a guarantee against rust, it only helps prevent rust if you take care of the knife properly. the same goes for stainless steel, it resists rust, but it is not rust proof, if you store it wet, especially if it's wet from salt water, it will rust, you have to do your part and keep the knife clean and dry, minimum.
@JoeDoomsday4 жыл бұрын
UPDATE: My 1917 Frontier Bowie started rusting pretty bad, also. I did remove all the rust and I forced a Patina on the blade & guard. It looks pretty good now.
@buckwild6587 Жыл бұрын
Would you mind doing an update video? I'd love to see that
@JoeDoomsday Жыл бұрын
@@buckwild6587 ,... I just posted two of my older update videos of the 1917 FRONTIER BOWIE after cleaning it up.
@slingshotwarrrior81053 жыл бұрын
Nice bowie, I recently bought a Honshu Boshin Toothpick!
@longrider424 жыл бұрын
Yeah, you need to keep your blade oiled. Specially in England where its damp most of the time. I live in a dry climate and I don't have much of a problem with rust on my blades, but I do keep them oiled. I've also heard that Vasaline works well too.
@lckgilmo434 жыл бұрын
Try to use a thick oil on your knife blades. I live in South West Louisiana here in America. High humidity. I use 3-in-One oil on all my firearms and knives. Thin oil doesn't protect as well as thicker oil due to humidity. I rub them down once a month or after every use. It should work for you also.
@beno2rasho4 жыл бұрын
I love 1055 steel....awesome for big blades. I have the black bear bowie and love it. (I also think 1070 is another great choice.)
@Leepatrick38683 жыл бұрын
Nice Bowie ,I’m really considering one , if I do get one I think I would remove the factory finish and redo it with a gun blue
@caesar48806 ай бұрын
Its something that Windlass uses to keep the blade in the sheath. I get a perfect square patch of rust on just about every Windlass sword I have in that same place your knife has it.
@230930345 жыл бұрын
You do need need to lubricate it, you don't want rust on your chopper! 😂
@vinniesdayoff39684 жыл бұрын
You can't blame the manufacturer for rust forming on a knife. That's your fault. Buy some oil.
@DDDYLN Жыл бұрын
I was about to say the exact same thing!
@powerplay4real1744 жыл бұрын
Would like to own one made with the 1085 carbon steel, but it is difficult to know what one the sellers are carrying because they still have them specified as 1055 carbon steel in the US.
@powerplay4real1745 жыл бұрын
They come in two steel variants 1055 & 1085 do you know which steel that one is ,and the rust may have come from the sheath ,because the bluing should have prevented that rust.
@PerceptionVsReality3335 жыл бұрын
I think it rusted because of the leather sheath, leather absorbs & holds onto moisture.
@temperedsteel1425 жыл бұрын
I have the Legacy armories Viking seax and a medieval utility knife beautiful blades..... but don't use them much in the field because they are carbon steel, and just don't like dragging their maintenance kits with me to prevent rusting
@longrider423 жыл бұрын
No clue how or why your knife rusted where it did. Since it has a nice coat of Cold Steels black paint on it. Like others have said it is a high carbon steel blade so needs to be taken care of. When I got mine the sheath was so tight I sprayed WD-40 into it let it soak then just kept putting the knife in and drawing it. Also, the WD-40 has coated the knife. As for using this knife to chap and split wood, change the edge grind to a 24 degree flat grind on each side and you will notice a big difference ih how it chops and splits wood. Oh and the edge will hold up much better.
@bushcraft_in_the_north2 жыл бұрын
it is not paint it is gun bluing. A controled rust prosess. WD-40 eats upp leather and is nt good for wood. He's knife have rusted because the lack of oil and he has probably been using the choil without remowing the fingerprints,the salts and acid from hands make everything rust.
@longrider422 жыл бұрын
@@bushcraft_in_the_north Well about 20 years ago, when I got my first sword. I hosed down the inside of the scabbard, a leather one, with WD-40, and guess what. It did not eat the leather. Or damage the wood of the handle of the sword. Can you tell me where you got this information? I'm 60 years old and I've been using WD-40 for along time, for all sorts of things.
@jimmyj48112 жыл бұрын
I believe that it was Jim's brother Rezin Bowie that made the knife.
@MrKingGator2 жыл бұрын
New subscriber Little Rock Arkansas
@Nobody_896 Жыл бұрын
It should rust if its the type of steel that its it supposed to be all of my knives are high carbon steel and they would rust to if I neglected them, but I don't ,look dude if you're not using it you need to oil it any oil will do just keep the oxygen out of the steel, I'm acturaly impressed with the fact that it rusts that means it's high carbon steel which means you can get a very sharp edge on the blade and it will stay sharp longer my high carbon steel opinel knives are dangerously sharp, I must be careful using them, and that's exactly what you want, the knife should do most of the work for you, so it must be kept sharp, a dull knife is just a piece of iron,
@dimitrivos70885 жыл бұрын
What knive is that at 7:00 ?
@eltipobigotudo21625 жыл бұрын
That's a Barlow style knife. I couldn't tell you the specific brand, but Boker makes some good Barlow knives if you're interested. Klein does as well.
@dimitrivos70885 жыл бұрын
@@eltipobigotudo2162 ok thank you 😀
@eltipobigotudo21625 жыл бұрын
@@dimitrivos7088 Happy to help!
@bushcraft_in_the_north2 жыл бұрын
the b igger the blade the more easy it is to featherstick with it, do a YT search if you dont understand how, or make it sharper or use the choil if that helps you, but there is other ways. But you have to learn how to use a knife first, then a large knife. A scandi is not the best at it, try a convex edge.
@waveman04 жыл бұрын
high carbon steel rusts, has nothing to do with quality control and everything to do with user control, keep it oiled and you will have no problems. My only complaint with this knife is its lack of a lanyard attachment point, IMHO all large knives must have one for safety and the lack of one has stopped me from buying it. I instead bought a 1849 Rifleman's Knife, and it is magnificent. It rusts too if you don't oil it up.....
@Murtagh653 Жыл бұрын
in my opinion the lack of a lanyard hole is a bonus, it's not necessary and it's harder to find a knife without one, than it is to find one with it. you are spoiled for choice if you like lanyard holes
@waveman0 Жыл бұрын
@@Murtagh653 the point is with a lanyard hole you simply don't have to add a lanyard if that's your preference, if a hole isn't there you don't have the option. I wonder why EVERY competition knife (comp chopper) requires a lanyard?
@Murtagh653 Жыл бұрын
@@waveman0 it spoils the looks for me. wonder no more, we are in the age of the nanny state, you cannot tie your shoes without tripping over regulations these days. no more common sense, or awareness of your own limits.
@waveman0 Жыл бұрын
@@Murtagh653 we most certainly live in the age of the nanny state, and the powers-to-be trying to save us from ourselves.
@Murtagh653 Жыл бұрын
@@waveman0 one rather ridiculous example, is that i can go for a swim in a river, no lifejacket, and i am not breaking the law, but if i take a kayak in that same river, i am breaking the law if i don't wear a lifejacket and can (will) be fined if i am caught without one.
@gungrabber970 Жыл бұрын
Imagine having to be on private property to use a tool
@davebetch99184 жыл бұрын
Why do people insist on doing woodwork with a Bowie? It's a weapon, not a woodworking tool. There are probably more suitable big blades out there. The Texas clip is designed to split ribs and they are front heavy, not for cutting would but for lopping arms off!
@nobodysreview61374 жыл бұрын
I know, these Bowie reviews drive me crazy, the knife if for killing people, this blade here will chop your head off or if a man has his fists up you can chop his hand clean off. Bowie knife is wicked
@deniskozlowski93703 жыл бұрын
@@nobodysreview6137 why do they always do Bushcraft stuff to test Bowie knives on KZfaq? If they disembowed people and lopped off the limbs of screaming victims their next video would be about making toilet bowl prison booze.
@nobodysreview61373 жыл бұрын
@@deniskozlowski9370Bowie is a fighting knife, Jim Bowie made it so he could carry it, and it be like a short sword but with choping power and the bowie tip for stabing, it was specificly designed to kill people. People were geting attacked and robbed while walking down trails or traveling so he came up with it to fight them. Bowie will chop a mans head clean off, chop an arm clean off and short for close quarters combat. Everything about the knife is for fighting a human being, not wood carving or hunting or skinning an animal, it wasnt a working knife that could be used for fighting. Its only purpose was for fighting a man trying to take everything you own or kill you. When you see Bowie knives with a brass guard or brass on the back of the blade, that was to absorb impact from a sword or knife so your blade wouldnt crack or break or be jared from your hand by the impact. These videos of guys cuting wood for camping or talking like they gonna carve and skin an animal or something shows they dont know anything about the knife and makes them look stupid. Its also disrespectfull to Jim Bowie. If you asked Jim Bowie to design a skinning knife i. sure he could and it wouldnt look like a Bowie knife.
@palestinevideos20253 жыл бұрын
Bowie's aren't weapons they're camping tools they're not primarily designed to be weapons
@palestinevideos20253 жыл бұрын
@@nobodysreview6137 I can assure you that Bowie is not a good design for a fighting knife. It's designed to be a jack of all trades master of none multi-tool. You can thrust with it but it's not as good as a rapier. You can sword fight with it but it doesn't have much reach and if someone has a longer weapon you're done for. You can conceal carry it but it's not as good as a smaller dagger that you can conceal better and get out faster and more discreetly. You can use it as a machete to chop vegetation but it's not as good as an actual machete. You can use it as an axe to cut down trees but it's not as good as an actual axe. you can use it for carving or wood shaving or fire starting but it's not as good as more specialised tools. it does a little of everything but doesn't do anything that well compared to a specialised tool. it's a space saving device so that you don't have to carry around an axe and a machete and a skinning knife and a dagger etc. if you want a fighting knife get a specialised fighting knife that has only one purpose though. If you want an all rounder camping knife that can do a little of everything get a Bowie.
@richardnurse2772 Жыл бұрын
the knife serves 2 reasons: First is that it is an outdoor kitchen utensil and a tool for crafting small traps and other features in the outdoors. Second, it is a combat tool for fighting large attackers such as bears, cougars, wolves, foxes, and anything that wants to harm you. You complain that it is not sensible for bushcrafting, but you are wrong, because it is meant to protect you and do crafting at the same time. Go to the convenience store and buy a small knife to support this knife
@RandoCalrisiann2 жыл бұрын
Don't store the knife in the sheath long term.
@DDDYLN Жыл бұрын
You can't expect a high carbon steel knife not to rust, no matter how dry its kept. Judging by your accent, you don't live in a very dry climate. EVERY carbon steel blade should be kept oiled at all times. As soon as you purchase it, oil it! The blueing of the 1085 steel slows the rust, it doesn't negate it. In addition, there's never a coating on the edge of the blade. Even if the coated part of the blade doesn't rust, the edge will!
@johnklockyer Жыл бұрын
Dont like the idea of Ty the blade being made in India though.
@johnmutton7993 жыл бұрын
Splitting axes are made for 6" wide logs. Not a knife you doughnut!