Team Blacks BIGGEST LIE | House of the Dragon

  Рет қаралды 7,551

The Second Son

The Second Son

Жыл бұрын

Here's yet another reason that justifies 'Why I Support the Greens'. Team Black supporters quite often forget the claim they were fighting for in support of Rhaenyra Targaryen which was equal primogeniture all the while clinging to the Green's claim of first born son primogeniture if it means pushing their false propaganda that the Blacks won the Bloody Dance of the Dragons. Watch the video to find out more !
Thanks for tuning in !
Be sure to like, comment, and subscribe to the channel for more Fire and Blood and A Song of Ice and Fire Content.
-Lord Quicerys Quickthot of House Quickthot

Пікірлер: 216
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
Greetings my Lords & Ladies ! Just a couple of points I’d like to clear up from the video that could easily be misunderstood. Firstly, when I state “Male/First born son Primogeniture” the “legitimacy” should naturally be implicated, which is why I didn’t see it necessary to state the word legitimate every second. Just as we say ; “A King” rather than “ A King regnant” because all kings are regnant in their own right; it doesn’t need to be said. Primogeniture IS LEGITIMACY. So the “legitimacy” shouldn’t have to be stated. Having said that, Jacaerys Velaryon is not Rhaenyra’s first born “legitimate” son, Aegon III is. Who inherited from his Uncle(Aegon II, another legitimate son.) not his Mother. Secondly, when I state the Blacks are fighting for a “Rhoynish custom” I’m not implying that like elder sisters; bastards can inherit in Dorne. Because I’ve never read any evidence to support that. However what I am implying is the principality of Dorne and Rhoynar customs are much more accepting of bastards as they are of women; than the upper 6 kingdoms are. “Bastards are born of passion, aren't they? We don't despise them in Dorne.” -Oberyn Martell . Thirdly, nowhere am I saying that both sides didn’t lose a shit ton. Because they did. However what I am saying is, IMO, by the definition of “Win” (be successful or victorious in a contest or conflict) there was definitely a clear cut winner in both conflict and claim and his name was Aegon II Targaryen. And lastly, apologies if it may seem like I’m yelling. I’m not, I swear. It’s called beer passion 😂. This is why you DO NOT record a video after a Twitter debate and 6 oatmeal porters 🍻🤦‍♂️ …..and I think that’s all I had for you! 😅 Anywho, Happy Holidays guys & gals ! Hope it’s filled with a shit ton of love, laughter and food ! I’ll catch you all on my next video, take care! 💚🎁 🐉🎄
@debamlyabanerjee4067
@debamlyabanerjee4067 Жыл бұрын
Yes i aggre with you and the war will end when one of the faction leder is dead and i also aggre that a monarchs line can continue with any blood relative in my country india mewar kingdoms king rawal ratan singh was killed by his Anymys and his cousin and nephew retake the kingdom from his rivels his blood continues by his nephew but in according to history rawal lost the war and his nephew challenge the rivel after many years later then king of magadh devbhuti of sunga dynasty was deffeted and killed by kanva king and mitra dynasty a branch family of sunga dynasty retake the kingdom from kanvas and mitras also shered blood with devbhuti but but according to history devbhuti lost the battle there is faruk shiar who was deffeted and killed by king ajit singh rathore after him cousin became king
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
@@debamlyabanerjee4067 oh wow that’s useful to know. I really need to brush up on my Indian history, its so rich & broad !
@debamlyabanerjee4067
@debamlyabanerjee4067 Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSon thank you my friend please tell me about your county and i will told you mine
@innerpeacefindings671
@innerpeacefindings671 5 ай бұрын
Black team Logic: No you shouldn't take Luke eye. Also Black Team: A son for son there is debt to pay. Me: What a Hypocrite 😅
@tereza1959
@tereza1959 Жыл бұрын
Just the fact that Rhaenyra's son is named Aegon THE THIRD proves that the Greens won, Aegon III didn't inherit the throne from Rhaenyra, he inherited it from his uncle, Aegon II
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
You’re stating facts dude! And the fact that they so desperately cling to Andal law and “legitimate” first born son inheritance to somehow push their narrative of victory absolutely blows my mind.
@Kikithewildling
@Kikithewildling Жыл бұрын
But Rhaenyra’s family actually took the throne. Who cares if it’s not Aegon. And there are those who don’t claim drunk Aegon, so he’s not inheriting anything from a real king. King Viserys never changed the succession so he’s NOT a REAL KING. Girl, that some Usurper shit.
@muqki2178
@muqki2178 Жыл бұрын
And aegon only got the throne bc of his father, there was three princesses who could have the throne by birth order which was what rhaenyra was fighting for but they ignored and kept thr tradition which rhaenyra was agaisnt. So thr back definitely lost but bc thr team balck supporters are salty about it, they'll try to use anything inorder to make it seem rhaenyra won, when she didn't.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
@@muqki2178 nobody won but team black ended up getting the throne after all the chaos. But nobody won, House Targaryen was forever weakened from then on because of the traitorous actions of the greens . If it wasn’t for Rhaegar rediscovering the prophecy, the whole world could’ve ended because of the greens. Fuck Otto, and fuck Alicent for being a treasonous whore . Respect to the actors of course, they did a hell of a job.
@yusufraage8554
@yusufraage8554 Жыл бұрын
Aegon the usurper wanted to kill Aegon III to stop lord Cregan Stark's advances and why would the usurper want to his heir. Because he wasnt his heir he was a hostage then the usurper's own man killed him.
@TOMEYEARSAGO
@TOMEYEARSAGO 6 ай бұрын
Yeah I agree, The Greens won because the war was about stopping a woman and her illegitimate sons from taking the Iron throne and they succeeded. Aegon ii is remembered as king while Rhaenyra is remembered as just a princess who wanted to put her illegitimate sons on the throne and failed. The bloodline argument is weak because Aegon ii and Aegon iii are cousins and the Greens were only against Rhaenyra and her illegitimate sons.
@muqki2178
@muqki2178 Жыл бұрын
Princess jaehaera would actually take throne from her father according to the team black ideology of birth order. Not Princess baela.
@yusufraage8554
@yusufraage8554 Жыл бұрын
According to the blacks it would go to Aegon the younger because he is the oldest living child of Queen Rheanyra and it went to him. Why would the the throne go to Jaehaera she is the usurper's son.
@muqki2178
@muqki2178 Жыл бұрын
@@yusufraage8554 the war ended, when princess rhaenyra died, there was two claimants and now only one left which made aegon II the undisputed king, the green ideology is only male hiers through birth order whereas, the black ideology is the same but females are included, when aegon II became the undisputed king, according the ideology of the blacks, princess jaehaera would be the hier bc she's only remaining child of the monarch, rhaenyra was a claimant to throne and she lost the war, so she's never seen as Queen to the people of westeroes but rather a usurper to king aegon II reign.
@yusufraage8554
@yusufraage8554 Жыл бұрын
@@muqki2178 The war ended with the crowning of Rheanyra’s oldest living son being crowned by the Leader of the Blacks that kept fighting after Rheanyra died. Lord Cregan Stark had a pact with jacaerys Targaryen and he kept fighting after Jace and Rheanyra died.
@muqki2178
@muqki2178 Жыл бұрын
@@yusufraage8554 cregan kept fighting for revenge but even he can't deny that aegon became the undisputed ruler, him and rhaenyra were claimants to throne but not actual rulers until rhaenyra died, we still refer to aegon as king aegon II and we still call rhaenyra, princess. What Cregan did was for revenge for jace and rhaenyra, he didn't go to put aegon the younger on the throne, he saw it as going for revenge in his own eyes, if he truly believed that females should also succeed, he would have to put jaehaera on the throne bc he can't deny that aegon is the right ruler, not his nephew who wouldn't dare claim the throne bc he would literally die straight away if he did, aegon 3 bent the knee. If aegon 3 was a girl and jaehaera was a boy then cregan would have to put jaehaera on throne, even he believed in the male hier only rule, its just oaths for why he came to defend rhaenyra in the first place, starks are honourable people
@yusufraage8554
@yusufraage8554 Жыл бұрын
@@muqki2178 hahaha.
@kittycheshire5099
@kittycheshire5099 Жыл бұрын
Not to be that person, but if the Blacks supporters were truly wanting to follow Rhaenyra's example of equal primogeneture, then it wouldn't be Baela who should succede Aegon II, rather his still living daughter Jaehaera. Jaehaera was the only surviving child of Aegon II, while Baela was the daughter of the previous king's brother, putting her behind all of viserys's children and grandchildren. (like how Princess Anne's children are behind Prince William and Prince Harry's children in the English line of succession.) Technically, even by Andal law, Jaehaera should be queen. She is in the same position as Rhaenys, but while Team Black supports Rhaenys's claim to the throne, saying it was unfair that she wasn't made the heir after her father's death, they don't back Jaehaera's claim at all, wanting to then uphold Jaehaerys and the Great Council's prescedent not allowing any women to sit the Iron Throne just so Rhaenyra and Daemon's son can be crowned the "victor" of the dance.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
How in the hell could our sweet Jaehaera slip my mind ?! You’re spot on !
@suckerborneveryday1815
@suckerborneveryday1815 Жыл бұрын
No because Aegon the second had no claim to the throne until all of Raynreas heirs are gone.
@yusufraage8554
@yusufraage8554 Жыл бұрын
@@suckerborneveryday1815 This people dont know how succesions work. The crown always goes to the heir of the king. Rheanyra was the heir she fought a war for it. Rheanyra's kids have all the claims.after she died her crown went to her oldest living child.
@ridedamaverick
@ridedamaverick 10 күн бұрын
Or Driftmark! Why is Rhaenyra fighting for it to go to Lucerys instead of to one of Laenor's girls? HMMMM...
@MagicHurdlez
@MagicHurdlez Жыл бұрын
I always thought it was weird to suggest anyone won the war. Everyone died, not a single one of them got what they wanted. Allicent didn't protect her family, she didn't live to see her children prosper vested in the line of succession. Rhanerya was killed in a horrific way after a terrible reign. Aegon II was poisoned and Aegon III who ended it ruling when it was all said and done was traumatized his whole life. They killed the dragons, and the Targaryen dynasty as a whole never recovered. It's crazy to suggest there was an actual winner here. Well maybe Deamon if you think he lived his days with Nettles
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
George rr Martin chose one of the most bloodiest succession crisis in medieval England to exemplify for a reason. To suggest because a war brought death and destruction it’s meaningless to identify a winner is even more bogus IMO. That’s the point of war. Not to sing Kumbaya. 😂🤷
@souljamane9244
@souljamane9244 Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSonI believe defeating Rhaenyra was a short to mid term goal. While ensuring no one from her line ever sat the throne was a long term one which didn't happen. But I just see it as one big example of "Play stupid games win stupid prizes"
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
@@souljamane9244 I think you’re spot on dude ! Super valid points !
@souljamane9244
@souljamane9244 Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSon Also with all the prophecy shenanigans who knows what would happen if Aegon II's line continued.
@MagicHurdlez
@MagicHurdlez Жыл бұрын
No I'm saying that when it's all said it done neither said gained anything over the other. All either side did when it was all said and done was take out the biggest leg up the Targs had.
@thalmoragent9344
@thalmoragent9344 Жыл бұрын
Yeah, if anything, Team Green lost their bloodline, most unfortunately. However, Team Green's Ideology evidently won the Political aspect of the War. A legitimate, firstborn Male Heir is what the Greens were fighting for the entire time. Sure, they'd have preferred Aegon II Targaryen and his kids to be the main line of House Targaryen going forward, no one's doubting that, but still, Male Primogeniture is what House Targaryen goes on to adhere too.
@RubyAPBT
@RubyAPBT Жыл бұрын
And this cost everything from Greens and cripled house Targaryen forever until Daenerys in GoT. They even lost the dragons and this was the reason most future Targariens went insane. And Greens were not fighting for first born right, Otto started this shit to have his family as the royal bloodline that's why he wanted Alicent to marry Viserys and have kids. If legitimacy was his only concern he would never say to make Rhaenyra heir instead of Daemon.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
@@RubyAPBT ask yourself this. Did Otto really not want Daemon as heir because he thought he’d be “a second Maegor”? Or was it because he knew he wouldn’t be able to manipulate Daemon at all. Daemon even would’ve probably banished his family from kings landing. Daemon saw Otto for who he was, Daemon knew and could see what Otto was doing and that’s why he fucking hated him so much, and Otto knew that. That’s why he wanted Daemon gone, as long as Daemon was in kings landing close to the king, Viserys would be protected by his brother who would protect his family at all costs . Viserys allowed emotion to cloud his judgement and banished Daemon after hearing his toast to Baelon from Otto of all people. It was the wrong thing to do which is why Viserys cut himself on the throne after. This action would eventually lead to Viserys’ death and the war that would follow .
@thalmoragent9344
@thalmoragent9344 Жыл бұрын
@@mackmitchell94 I dunno, you're saying Otto and the others on the Small Council had no right to be... well, concerned about Daemon? You guys all think Daemon is solid king material? If so, then once Aegon II is born, you should all admit the firstborn son of the King should then be Heir, regardless how he grows up to be. Plus, Daemon admitted that what he said was true in front if Viserys. Otto didn't lie
@thalmoragent9344
@thalmoragent9344 Жыл бұрын
@@RubyAPBT Rhaenyra was a temporary place for the Throne till the King had a son. Cause if Daemon had a kid then Viserys gained a son, the King's son is the one who has higher claim. So really, keeping Daemon off the Throne for a while until another, higher claimant that could be raised to be better (assuming Viserys actually behaves like a decent father) would be available. So yeah... I dunno man, the Targaryens are to blame for the Dance, Viserys in particular. Keep in mind, even Otto told Viserys that the reasoning for Viserys marrying Laena was "sound". As in, if Viserys married Laena then Otto wouldn't have had issue at the moment, and find Alicemt the next best option
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
@@thalmoragent9344 no, I don’t think Daemon is king material. But I do believe that if Viserys trusted daemon with the knowledge of aegons prophecy, it could’ve changed Daemons mindset to a less chaotic one . I think Daemon would’ve made a great hand to Viserys, because he would’ve protected him from people scheming behind Viserys’ back . Daemon never really wanted the throne, he wanted to rule by his brothers side and have his approval . Viserys was one of the only people along with Rhaneyra, that Daemon would actually listen to and respect . Otto wanted Daemon out of kings landing because as long as Daemon was there, Otto wouldn’t be able to scheme as much . Otto was right about what Daemon said but Daemon was also right about Otto being a self serving ambitious cunt .
@kittycheshire5099
@kittycheshire5099 2 ай бұрын
When you play the game of thrones you either win or you die. Rhaenyra died, therefore she did not win. That’s just how it works.
@Ok-ck6pz
@Ok-ck6pz Жыл бұрын
The dance is a choice between two evils and you chose the one you believe to be lesser, just how you make almost every hard decision in life.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
In the books it is, in the show only Daemon is evil on the blacks . Rhaenyra is the clear protagonist, Alicent is portrayed as a girl getting manipulated by her father to her own detriment, something which never really changes throughout the story. Then she becomes green with envy and teaches her children to be psychos and want to murder their own family. Not a good mother, Rhaenyra is actually a good mother though . The greens are the clear antagonists in the show, I mean unless you like people who stab you in the back and are jealous of you, secretly stealing things that belong to you and acting like it’s theirs all along. Unless you like mother’s who always blame other kids for the wrong their kids were behind . If that’s for you, then you support the greens .
@richarddawkins2937
@richarddawkins2937 8 ай бұрын
Imagine a group so deluded you have to explain the CONCEPT of winning and losing to make them see reason
@Aewon84
@Aewon84 6 ай бұрын
Which he completely fails at. The Hitler example doesn't work because the Germans were losing anyway. At the end of the Dance the Black army massively outnumbered the Green forces. The boxing example doesn't work because this isn't boxing. A boxing match is a fight between two people. Once Rhaenyra died Aegon the Younger became the figurehead for the Black forces. They took King's Landing and put Aegon III on the throne. The Green line went extinct. Thus, the Blacks objectively won.
@ousseynougueye5949
@ousseynougueye5949 3 ай бұрын
The Blacks won, no matter what you say.
@archmaester6594
@archmaester6594 15 күн бұрын
_"Wars end when the defeated bend the knee and not before."_ - Cregan Stark The Greens bent the knee at the end of the Dance.
@theduxabides9274
@theduxabides9274 Жыл бұрын
If Rhaenyra had it her way, Aegon III would have been Queen's consort to Jaehaera Targaryen, First of Her Name, by virtue of the precedent her father (Viserys) would have established. That her son was allowed to claim the throne over the surviving child of Rhaenyra's supposed usurper, was an affirmation of the status quo that the Greens were upholding. If you further believe the theory that the deaths of Aegon's Regents AND the subsequent decline and disappearance of the dragons, were all orchestrated by the Maesters working out of Oldtown, then technically Aegon III's reign was a further Green victory as the Hightowers come out on top regardless.
@yusufraage8554
@yusufraage8554 Жыл бұрын
wow.
@Tormund_Giantsbrain
@Tormund_Giantsbrain Жыл бұрын
Aegon III never bothering to legitimize his mother is the biggest L Rhaenyra ever took. Blacks say "oh but he was depressed and didn't want to open fresh wounds". Ok, but what about Vizzy II? He ruled much later when the wounds from Dance of Dragons were not as fresh. Why didn't he bother? Is it because he himself had a female claimant in Daena and decided Uncle Aegon was right after all? And what does it say about Aegon III and Vizzy II fearing public backlash if they legitimized their mother? It says Rhaenyra left a legacy of being one of the worst rulers Westeros had ever seen. You know you lost the war when your main claim to "victory" is that a boy from an incredibly incestuous family that was overthrown and went almost extinct anyway, shares slightly more DNA with Rhaenyra than with Uncle Aegon.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
Slightly more DNA is a stretch. Aegon and Viserys are Rhaenyra and Daemons sons, which means they much more than DNA shared . The greens lost and so did the blacks, everybody lost . Aegon III was broken for the rest of his life because of what Aegon II did to his mother forcing him to watch. He was basically dead inside from the trauma he experienced during the war.
@Tormund_Giantsbrain
@Tormund_Giantsbrain Жыл бұрын
@@mackmitchell94 "Slightly more DNA" was just a scoffing reference to how incredibly inbr3d the Targaryen family was. And yes, everyone lost, which is what makes for a great tragedy. I'm just saying Rhaenyra Targaryen lost the most.
@notyetawomen5257
@notyetawomen5257 Жыл бұрын
Yeah Rhaeyrna definitely was NOT a good ruler or a mother. I mean sure Lucery's death was an understandable reason to start war, but Rhaenyra should've put her STILL living children first and then start a war where she increases chances of her remaining children dying during conflict.
@vitoraugusto9596
@vitoraugusto9596 Жыл бұрын
Aegon III would not be able to validate Rhaenyra because she LOST. Aegon II outlived her and won the war. Cregan Stark, the strongest Black at the end of the war, accepted that when he did the Hour of the Wolf. He started executing people in the name of Aegon II. A win is a win. Maegor I defeated Aegon the Uncrowned. Jaehaerys would not be able to turn his defeated brother into a king. Hell, Aegon III did not even try to change much of what Aegon II did. He kept some of his council during regency and it was Tyland that denied the reconstruction of the Dragonpit with the statues of Aemond and Daeron. And Aegon III named a child Daeron, even if it was a name used by a green, but he never named even a single one of his daughters after Rhaenyra. Viserys II could not care less for Rhaenyra. He even used the laws that Aegon II defended to a maximum degree to name himself King. Also, there is more characters in ASOIAF defending Aegon II than Rhaenyra. That is a detail to remember.
@Tormund_Giantsbrain
@Tormund_Giantsbrain Жыл бұрын
@@vitoraugusto9596 Completely agreed to everything you said. Also Vizzy II was quick assert male primogeniture when he felt slightly threatened by a female claimant in Daena.
@MissPagan
@MissPagan Жыл бұрын
I LOVE all the FACTS that were thrown in this video in support of the Greens winning the war. I cannot wait to see Aegon and Sunfyre body Rhaenyra in the House of The Dragon seasons to come.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
You must come with facts with these folks lol. However facts have never stop propaganda before. You know how it goes 😆
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
I can’t wait to see Aegon II get poisoned and die pathetically while Rhaenyra’s son takes his seat .
@datguy7221
@datguy7221 Жыл бұрын
Lol your right 100% Tradition and Blood right is why I'm even Team Green in the First place.
@emperorofscelnar8443
@emperorofscelnar8443 Жыл бұрын
Modern rules don’t count when it comes to the past.
@sertorrhenclegane
@sertorrhenclegane Жыл бұрын
Bastards aren't in the line of succession in Rhyonish custom. Even they aren't that liberal. The problem, I think, with your argument is that a male would've succeeded Rhaenyra (had she won the war) regardless because all of her living children are male. Had she had a daughter that lived, say from her marriage to Laenor and Aegon was given the throne in spite of that, you might have a leg to stand on.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
You should take a look at my pinned comment. I think that’d clear up some of the misconceptions. 😁 Thanks for tuning in! Appreciate the comment.
@sertorrhenclegane
@sertorrhenclegane Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSon Yeah, I wrote that comment before I read your comment. That's my bad.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
@@sertorrhenclegane no worries brother! Those are all valid points that’d definitely get brought up once the black supporters stumble along the video haha 😅 Look forward to reading more of your comments! Happy holidays! 🎁💚🐉
@datguy7221
@datguy7221 Жыл бұрын
Idc what anyone in these comments says either, if anyone won this war it was the greens, No ifs ands or butts, btw Quickthot, I wanted to mention some idiot that was trying to debate with me that Nobody would challenge or protest or even plot against the ascension of Rhaenyra's bastards sitting the iron thrones just because they would've had dragons 💀 Like I told this dude that it doesn't make a damn if they had dragons, There claims, or ascension to the throne would've been challenged regardless, doesn't matter if they have dragons or not, and I heard in the books that the people literally REVOLTED AGAINST Rhaenyra despite her having dragons in the books, if this is true then it only FURTHER proves my point, As I was already correct in the first place.
@ridedamaverick
@ridedamaverick 10 күн бұрын
Are they SERIOUS? How many dragons lived in Dorne!?
@dchhhadarklight2428
@dchhhadarklight2428 Ай бұрын
I'm not saying team Black won because of Aegon III getting the throne. I say team Black won because of Daemon having the most kids alive by the end. All the Targaryens who survived the Dance were Aegon III, Viserys II, Baela, Rhaena, and Jaehaera. Basically the only targs left were Daemon's kids and Jaehaera who would get pushed into spikes within two years anyway. Do you see what I'm getting at, as Daemon was the only person who won the Dance in any capacity and Daemon supported team Black, on a technicallity standpoint Team Black won.
@Hikaru3899
@Hikaru3899 Жыл бұрын
Well first nobody won they literally both lost. They both sort of won and lost. In certain aspects. The Blacks Won the physical fighting and their bloodline survived. However Aegon killed rhaenyra and their claim that a son comes before a daughter was followed until the present story so they both won and lost. But house Targaryen lost
@MagicHurdlez
@MagicHurdlez Жыл бұрын
Exactly
@kimberlyplatt2382
@kimberlyplatt2382 Жыл бұрын
The Black's are watching this video and having a full on seizure. Too many facts in this video. Question: how would you won the dance of the dragons, if you had to face both sides? But had a good amount of support plus dragons. Can you do a break down of how you would have beaten the blacks or greens?
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
This was a 🐐 comment Kim! Lol. That’s a badass video idea 💡 right here ! Like my brain just exploded with thought just reading it haha, will definitely get that one out for you sooner than late. And LOL @ the black supporters having a full on seizure 💀 they’re gonna be breaking their fingers to get in the comment section haha. 😆
@kimberlyplatt2382
@kimberlyplatt2382 Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSon Can't wait for that video!
@sankarkrishnan407
@sankarkrishnan407 Жыл бұрын
Who won the last battle. He won the war. Aegon 2 killed his sister and reclaimed the throne. But a large army was coming from Vale, North and Riverlands. They proclaim Aegon 2 as a Usurper and Aegon 3 as the right king. They didn't go to home after the Queen died. Aegon 2 loses the war before dead. He can't any dragon. His supporters were not in the crownlands. Even Tyland Lannister hire a sellsword company he can't win. Cregan Stark decides to defeat Stormlands , Old Town and Casterly Rock.
@alessiodandolo1460
@alessiodandolo1460 Жыл бұрын
No one won the Dance, the battle isn't the war. Aegon becomes king because he's the last knowing male of the dynasty. If Aemond, Daeron or Maelor were still alive, they would have sat the throne after Aegon. And he's crowned as Aegon the THIRD, the legitimacy of the second is established and recognized by all. And Cregan Stark... let me laugh ! The guy didn't dare go south while the dragons were alive. Having arrived at King's Landing, he talks about pursuing a war he cannot win against Aegon's former followers. He speaks, yes, no doubt to make people forget his cowardice during the war, and as usual, he does nothing.
@sankarkrishnan407
@sankarkrishnan407 Жыл бұрын
@@alessiodandolo1460 North is a far place they want an year to combine the whole army . Remember the 2000 winter wolves smashed the entire Lannister army. All the battles there participation was significant. In the case of dragons blacks also had dragons. They come to make Aegon the younger as the king. Aegon 2 the king was still alive at that time. After the Dance of dragons the targaryn dynasty lasted for 150 years. The lords of the South was aware that any move against them will provoke North and Vale. They are not at all interested in Southern politics but when a critical time they will arrive. Aerys the mad king destroyed it by his foolish actions.
@alessiodandolo1460
@alessiodandolo1460 Жыл бұрын
@@sankarkrishnan407 Yes but the Dance ends in winter. The Riverlands are burned and the North is an icy wasteland. House Hightower is the richest house of Westeros (Oldtown is untouched, Lannisport and Driftmark have been sacked during the Dance), a quarter of the royal treasure is kept at Oldtown, an other at Casterly Rock and the Hightowers can raise a new army very quickly. Cregan Stark would have had no chance of winning the war against Aegon's allies, no way to defeat the three, no possibility to take Storm's End, Casterly Rock or the Hightower (castles that never fell), and not enough resources to defeat much richer and better supplied enemies.
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
​@@sankarkrishnan407the Dance lasted 3 years . Robert in GOT season 1 went from King's Landing to Winterfell in a month 😂😂 Cregan was scared of the dragons but I don't blame him
@scorpioj3
@scorpioj3 Жыл бұрын
Both sides lost so much for this ugly throne.
@jaredbrick4722
@jaredbrick4722 23 күн бұрын
If Aegon had an heir after the war, that heir would have ruled the 7 kingdoms. That's proof that the greens won. The only reason Aegon iii was king after is because there were no Targaryens left
@realdaggerman105
@realdaggerman105 8 ай бұрын
(Spoilers for Fire and Blood and HOTD) If after mr Hitler painted his bunker with his brains magically the remaining German forces somehow won, that would have been a Nazi victory. Aegon and Rhaenyra are just the figureheads for each side. When Aegon was presumed dead for the better part of a year did the Greens collapse? No. Exemplified with the fact that Jace was the acknowledged heir of the Blacks until his death, they are less kings in this game than they are queens or rooks. A monarch can be replaced. Also remember, though it was basically scrubbed from the records, Rhaenyra did sit on the iron throne for half of a year. That makes her the real, actual ruler of Westeros by precedent and claim. At least for that period. It doesn’t matter that she isn’t officially put down as ‘Rhaenyra I Targaryen’ in the history books. The people of King’s Landing had her as their ruler for a fairly long period. Now, why does Aegon die? Rhaenyra was dead, her 3 eldest sons are dead and Aegon the Younger is captured. That sounds like a crushing Green military victory, right? Well, the Black forces (Kermit Tully really doesn’t seem to believe the war is over hey!) routes and crushes the Baratheon host and marches on King’s Landing unopposed. Out of desperation somebody poisons Aegon II. I don’t think if an army is marching on your capital you can say that war is over. Okay, so Aegon is dead. His closest living relative is Aegon, right? Well Aegon did have a daughter, Jaehaera. ‘But the Greens fought for male-only primogeniture right?’ Well…. Sort of. Originally the pseudo-green faction (long before they actually formed) fought to replace Daemon, a seemingly completely legitimate male heir directly assumed to be in line after Viserys, with Rhaenyra. I do not know if you are aware, but Rhaenyra is in fact not of the XY chromosomes. Though it turned into something more akin to what you would expect an exclusively male inheritance to look like, that was due to the birth of 3 sons and 2 grandsons in the succession. Picture this: if the Green forced crushed the Blacks, just destroyed them all, but Aemond, Daeron, little Jaehaerys and Maelor all died in the process, followed by Aegon II, would the Greens have given the throne to one of Rhaenyra’s kids? I highly doubt it. I think they would have crowned Jaehaera outside of the military block that was the Black army knocking on their door. Remember, the Greens basically disinherited Daemon. So at this point, Aegon III’s inheritance is coming from his relation to Rhaenyra. The goal of the Black’s was not ‘put Rhaenyra on the throne’, but ‘ensure Rhaenyra’s line is the ruling one’. Lo and behold, they are. In summary, the war was not over. Kermit Tully and Cregan Stark who were Black supporters were marching on the Imperial capital of King’s Landing. The Green adherence to Male-only primogeniture was out of political convenience and not hard-line policy. The goals of the Blacks (have Rhaenyra’s line sit and rule on the throne) were achieved, whereas the goals of the Greens (have Aegon II’s line sit and rule the throne) were not. When all is said and done, RIP Daeron, a real one riding possibly the coolest looking dragon (as yet described in the books, unsure yet in show) Tessarion. The most reasonable Targ of the entire generation and he who inspired the name for two famed kings in future, Daeron I ‘the Young Dragon’ conqueror of Dorne, and Daeron II ‘the Good’ who saw years of peace and plenty under skilled stewardship. Truly Daeron was taken from us too soon.
@erikdgreenlund
@erikdgreenlund Жыл бұрын
Had Cregan Stark not been pacified by Black Ally Blackwood the Blacks would have continued the War up until the point where every Green’s head in Kings Landing would have adorned a Spike. The Blacks essentially had two Kingdoms whose armies were mostly intact. The Greens on the other hand were spent. The Westerlands strength was greatly diminished after the Fish Feed and the Iron Born incursion into Fair Isle had the attention of the Rock. The Reach never really committed its strength to either side. House Hightower could have mobilized another force, but without any Military leaders left in Oldtown whom had any interest in supporting Argon II or Queen Alicent. IMO as a Black supporter no side won the War in the end. But had fighting continued, with the unified Forces of the Vale and the North under Cregan Stark fighting in Rhaenyra’s name it wouldn’t have even been a question.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
You’re stating fair points. And no where am I saying that both sides didn’t suffer a great deal of lost. Because they did. However what I’m saying is; Rhaenyra’s claim of equal primogeniture lost (since Aegon lll, a legitimate male heir inherited) that’s not a win for the blacks that’s a win for tradition, Andal Law, and the Greens claim. As well as she lost because she died before her brother Aegon ll (her challenger) who successfully sat the throne for a “short” period of time. Good points though. Thanks for tuning in. Hope to read more of your comments man
@icehouse32oz
@icehouse32oz 6 ай бұрын
Bro trigger warning for that Martell toad she jumpscarescared the heck out of me 11:05
@hotimportknight
@hotimportknight Жыл бұрын
No one wins the war. The blacks lost the battle and won the war of inheritance using the other sides claim against them after everyone else is dead. The blacks weren't fighting for rhoynar's customs they didn't know, they were fighting an heir named by will vs tradition. Like the anarchy Eustace and Stephan's line dies off, leaving the enemy the only one left to reap the rewards. But George wrote it better than real life slightly and Aegon can't enjoy shit being so damaged by war. That's the real point, war = loss all around.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
“The blacks weren’t fighting for a rhoynish custom they didn’t know. They were fighting for the heir named by Will vs tradition” THIS is actually a fair point. And a fair comment. I enjoy historical facts throw in the mix Thanks for tuning in man !
@angryyoungman66
@angryyoungman66 5 ай бұрын
What the greens fought for remained , meaning they won the idealogical conflict , as for the war in battle field the greens and the blacks had losses & victories but at the end greens were techincally victorious , maybe the blacks blood line survived but they still lost the war
@mrman9977
@mrman9977 Жыл бұрын
Now that we have found our green stronghold on youtube, what do you, fellow green fans, think about the Aemond Helaena theory? Do they love each other romantically? Are Aegon's children actually bastards? Should they be?
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
Dude the show definitely dropped some major hints that point in that direction. Much more than the books imo. From young Aemond stating “he would have done his duty” and married Helaena, to her wearing sapphire blue during Aegon’s coronation(Aemond has a sapphire eye) and just from the fact that Helaena seems most comfortable around Aemond than anyone definitely leads me to think there’s more there man! As well as it’ll give the whole blood and cheese situation more meaning since it’ll be one of Aemond’s son who die . Ironic payback. If not Maelor I’m definitely thinking jaehaerys and jaehaera may be . But what do you think man ?! I can go on about this all day 😂 Thanks for tuning in!Appreciate you brother
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
Whatt?! Totally missed that dude. Definitely going to have to rewatch that
@mrman9977
@mrman9977 Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSon I really think that they will go that route, but I'm hoping they won't. I think if these theories are true, they will give team black yet another bullet to use, namely hypocracy. I'd hate for the green heirs to also be bastards, one of the two reasons the greens started the dance. Another reason I don't like that whole theory is that blood and cheese was the turning point for Aegon. His personality changed, and he got angry much easier, leading to him taking to the field himself. This development would make less sense if he was not Aegon's son. One mught argue that he wouldn't know about their bastard nature, but since he definitly remember the few time he was with Helaena, as well as understanding timing, he would most likely know if the children was his. Not to mention that the twins were born when Aemond was 13, conceived when he was 12. I find it makes little sense for a twelve year old to be the father instead of his three year older brother. Not to mention, Aemond, at least in the show, seem more dutiful than his elder brother, so I have a hard time seeing him making sure that the children that will inherit the throne are bastards. The last reason is the tragedy of it. Having the blacks kill the son of two people who was in no esy involved in Lucerys' death really shows how unjust the blacks as well as the war is, it draws focus from the desth of this really young kid and his parent's suffering to some plot twist that really was not needed. Sorry for ranting as well as any spelling errors, this was written in the morning
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
@@mrman9977 ahhhh dude solid reasonings right there! With the way the shows leaning with the Greens, I think you may be spot on dude ! SPOT on!
@murakyo79
@murakyo79 Жыл бұрын
I don't think it's canon for the fact that the opening family tree shows Aegon II and Helaena as the parents. Just like it shows Rhaenyra and Harwin Strong as Jace and Luke's parents, instead of Laenor.
@fantazypointz1054
@fantazypointz1054 Жыл бұрын
Nice video, I always like looking at the perspective of the green side, they always have interesting arguments
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
Thanks brother! This was a spur of the moment drunken’ rant lol. But we’re definitely a minority in the fandom, no doubt about that haha.
@debamlyabanerjee4067
@debamlyabanerjee4067 Жыл бұрын
You are right my friend you are right
@KingOfWinter
@KingOfWinter 7 ай бұрын
I’m not sure the blacks were fighting for women to inherit or even the first born. Especially after the first season of HOTD. There was years where Rhaenrya wasn’t the heir and thought she would never be the heir. If anything the backs where fighting for the Kings word to be the law of the land. The Greens (and to a lesser extent Cersie in the main series) were technically making the power of the Targaryens and therefore the throne weaker by telling the rest of the kingdom the Kings word is only law if he says something the kingdom agrees with. Which probably didn’t seem like a problem while the dragons are around but would come back to bite them after the dragons all die off.
@yardknight4953
@yardknight4953 Жыл бұрын
@3:23 the difference is Rhaenyra's forces fought on that they won. Hitler's forces fought on and lost. I get what you're saying though that technically The Greens won since Aegon II took her out 1st. Just knocking the analogy.
@archmaester6594
@archmaester6594 15 күн бұрын
The Greens: [kill Aegon and put Rhaenyra's son on the throne to avoid being killed by the Blacks] The Blacks [who were about to siege King's Landing to kill the Greens and put Rhaenyra's son on the throne]: Fine, we'll call this a draw.
@9xprincess
@9xprincess 12 күн бұрын
If you applied Rhoynar customs to the Blacks Aegon III would inherit before Baela because he is the closest alive kin to the monarch. Even if Aegon III/Viserys II line is extinct it would go to Jaehaera because she is the only living child of Rhaenyra’s siblings. Baelea would only inherit if the line of King Viserys I is no more. Also the Dance of the Dragons established agnatic/salic primogeniture that totally excludes women all together, way more misogynistic than the male-preference primogeniture of Andal custom. Ironically that actually follows the examples established by King Jaehaerys that put Viserys on the throne but that Rhaenyra was trying to completely ignore one time for herself. In Dorne there is generally less social stigma towards bastards and they aren’t seen as inherently treacherous but they are still not official members of the house and this are not a part of the line of succession. They’re essentially treated like children of morganatic marriages.
@greenberry6019
@greenberry6019 Жыл бұрын
I'm sorry, I didn't even wanna argue with you because I think team Black and team Green are both wrong, but you're so aggressive I just have to play Devil's advocate. "When you play the Game of Thrones, you win or you die" oh, and how many Greens are alive at the end of the story? Literally just Jaehaera. Sounds like they're not winning then, are they? Your argument that the war is over after Dragonstone is well made, but still wrong. The historians in-universe agree that the Dance of the Dragons ends with Dragonbane's coronation, this is specified in Fire and Blood after Cregan says that Aegon III should execute the Greens. So you may think that the Blacks are just stragglers in an aftermath, but in world the Maesters agree that Aegon's poisoning happened during the war still. And besides, I don't think it's fair to count the end of the war just because the monarch is dead. Same reason Rhaenys couldn't just kill all the greens at the coronation, everyone was saying "she can end the war" and like no, what she can do is kill half the royal family and start a war. Even though the figureheads are dead doesn't mean the armies aren't still marching. The point is, the Winter Wolves were fighting for the Black cause, and they're the most powerful army in Westeros. The Greens have no dragons left, both sides had claimants left, the Hightowers were still infighting to decide if they wanted to sue for peace or attack King's Landing, the Velaryon fleet was literally waiting for a signal from the King to raid the entire coastline, so I would say the war was still happening. And the war wasn't just about Rhaenyra and Aegon II in the first place. Think about it, if Aegon died do you really think the Greens would give up? No, they would go on fighting to put Maelor, Jaeherys or Aemond on the throne, because it was never about the candidates, it was about power. For both sides. The proof that the Greens didn't want to continue the war is that they let Aegon III stay in power with no hassle, even though he's farther behind in the line of succession than Jaehaera. If they still had the power, they would have fought to put Jaehaera on the throne and kill Aegon, not marry them. I don't know if you've met Black defenders that say they're fighting for Dornish inheritance, but these people misunderstand the Blacks. In the story the Blacks aren't fighting for women's rights in general, they don't care about that at all. After all, they still think Lucerys should inherit from Corlys and not Baela. No, the Blacks are fighting for their right of rule. They don't believe Rhaenyra should inherit because the patriarchy is bullshit (which it is), but because Viserys named her and never changed his mind, and that trumps the flimsy precedent of the Council of 101. Even in a patriarchal system, the throne is legally hers. They're just following the law. If they were fighting for pure equality of primogeniture, they wouldn't make Rhaenyra the queen. They would make Rhaenys the queen.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
I’m sorry I don’t think I know you ? Especially well enough to be called aggressive from a 15 minute video 💀 But that’s what YOU people do. Throw insults because people think differently than you. CLASSIC. Also nice long winded comment. Hopefully within a fortnight or two, I’ll finish reading it and pray-fully it can help me see the light 😁 Happy holidays Greenberry. Hope it’s filled with good times ! 🥳😄
@greenberry6019
@greenberry6019 Жыл бұрын
@@TheeSecondSon I'm kind of moved that you thought all that but you still gave me a heart. But I wasn't trying to insult you or anything, just pointing out how strong you came out, calling it "the biggest lie of the blacks" and "crazy", while you had those inaccuracies. Personally I could never imagine someone winning the Dance of the Dragons. But maybe it's just your style of content like that and I misunderstood. I didn't know you were buzzed when I typed that, now I know. Or maybe it's just because there's so few Green fans in all the Internet, you're always attacked on all sides by Black supporters 😂 I'm sure that can't be easy... And in the meantime, I checked the other comments and I saw you already agreed with some of the stuff I pointed out, like the blacks fighting for will vs tradition, and the war not being over when Aegon was poisoned because of all the Black armies, so you're all good really. Merry Christmas!
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
@@greenberry6019 I think I like you Greenberry 😂 The entire reply is spot on. Craps not easy getting punched from every angle of the World Wide Web 😂 so after a few brews and a Twitter encounter I was pumped! LOL. 😂 If you watch my other videos I’m usually SUPER chill. And I mean, you had a lovable comment bro, as did others lol. There’s no doubt that I’m a biased Team Green apologist 😂 but even though I may not agree, I’m still capable of seeing others point of view. As you are yourself! Not many people would make it as far through the video as you did with someone they don’t agree with . That’s heartfelt man ! Haha And Merry Christmas back to you and your family ! Hope to read more of your comments man! 🐉🎄🥳🎁
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
Feminism is bulshit patriarchy is great
@monsterxzero
@monsterxzero Жыл бұрын
That's Exactly what I've been saying to delusional Fan Boys/Girls Online, Aegon WON the War by killing his Challenger and Rival, everything that comes after has little to no consequence in Dance of the Dragons
@waynermcmahon8214
@waynermcmahon8214 Жыл бұрын
Winner is the one who sits the throne and the people support it.and nuthen else matters.change my mind
@jdsthird
@jdsthird Жыл бұрын
This is tradition and president. You are correct! 😂😂😂
@spuzziboss1
@spuzziboss1 Жыл бұрын
The french royal house is passed down from hugh capet father to son i believe through cadet branches
@ghirahimlefabuleux8984
@ghirahimlefabuleux8984 15 күн бұрын
The french monarchy is strictly agnatic, which means that under no circumstance a woman can inherit the throne. This is different from the english monarchy (which the iron throne is based on). As a result every king since Hugh usurped the last Carolingian king can trace back a strict father to son line to Hugh himself as you said. This also means that unlike england, France has never had a reigning queen during the entire existence of the monarchy from 481 to 1870. The japanese imperial house also follow these rules, and can trace a father to son line even further back than the house of Capet.
@kittycheshire5099
@kittycheshire5099 10 күн бұрын
@@ghirahimlefabuleux8984 While Westeros is based on England, the precedent shows that the Iron Thorne passes through Agnatic Succession. If they went with Male Preference Primogeniture, then Princess Aerea and Princess Rhaenys would have been queen, as they were both the only children of the previous heir to the throne (like Queen Victoria was). Instead, for both of them they were passed over for their uncles, meaning that women are completely cut out of the line of inheritance, as are their children.
@KingOfWinter
@KingOfWinter 7 ай бұрын
I mean the boxing match is a great analogy to get your point across. Though a fight between regimes isn’t just one v one though. It’s more like a team sport. In a relay race 5v5 if the red team wins the first four legs but team blues guy gains ground at the end and passes the finish line the blue team still wins the match. Also the Hitler analogy is also off a little. No one thinks the Nazis won because after the war democracy and communism split Germany. Had Hitler died but Germany was still able to remain whole and under a fascist government then the war at best would’ve been considered a draw kind of like Vietnam. Point being it’s not crazy to think one way or the other because that’s how it was written. George wants people to think about it and debate about it. I like the video though
@chichivladinski
@chichivladinski 7 ай бұрын
Baala's not Rhanerya's kid. It would have fallen to Aagon because Baala didn't even marry Jace who died before he could sit the throne.
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
I like Jace , he would have been a good King but a Velaryon on the Iron Throne please no 😂😂 In the show it's even worse becuse he's not Laenor's , so a Strong on the Iron Throne
@Rhaenyssupporter
@Rhaenyssupporter Жыл бұрын
The Greens lost, the Blacks lost, the Black line survived, and the Targaryens ultimately lost.
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
The are alive jonh snow is the true king
@robertsmiley2207
@robertsmiley2207 Жыл бұрын
I get your point but I think the black supporters are saying sense Daemon and Rhaenyra kids survived and became king's that's a win sense all of alicents children didn't survive
@rodney347
@rodney347 Жыл бұрын
The greens cause somewhat survived I guess, but overall yeah their lineage went extinct. Both sides are horrendous anyways.
@TheeSecondSon
@TheeSecondSon Жыл бұрын
Oh that’s EXACTLY what they’re saying. And that’s exactly what I discredit in this video. Aegon III is a LEGITIMATE male heir who inherits the throne from his UNCLE, Aegon II another LEGITIMATE male heir. not his MOTHER Rhaenyra who wanted to pass it to her bastard son. He inherits because of the claim the greens were fighting for NOT the Blacks. So IMO that’s not a win for the Blacks because nothing changed, primogeniture wise. For example, Aegon the conqueror and Visenya’s “line” didn’t continue since Maegor didn’t have any sons so it went to Jaehaerys.( Eldest legitimate male heir) But I don’t necessarily see that as some sort of “win” for Rhaenys and Aegon’s line. especially since Rhaena, Jaehaerys eldest sister had a better claim but that wasn’t upheld either. Hope this makes sense. 😁 Thanks for tuning in though guys ! Appreciate the comments !
@robertsmiley2207
@robertsmiley2207 Жыл бұрын
I don't take it personally when it comes to fighting amongst family members nobody truly wins especially knowing that they lost all the dragons during this war
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
I am for male primogeniture but not for old town userpers
@siphophiri3327
@siphophiri3327 6 ай бұрын
Aegon iii was the only option. If Aegon ii's sons were still living. We wouldn't be talking about this now because the blacks were baby killers 🤷🏾
@zenomtfr
@zenomtfr Жыл бұрын
Sorry but that's not how It works. You can't Say the blacks Lost because their cause was to fight for rhoynish customes. Rhaenyra didn't give a shit about female rights. She Just wanted the throne and that her DIRECT line would in future get the throne. And that's what she got. Aegon III sits on the throne. Also when Rhaenyra died it's not like the war was magically over. Cregan Stark was fighting for Aegon III specifically because he had made a promise to Jacearys, so he was fighting for the blacks deal with It. Listen it's Just like the war of the Roses. There was the new Tudor dinasty, but Henry VII was fighting for the Lancaster from which he was a desendants. Cry all you want greeners but that's the reality
@aedenali5985
@aedenali5985 Жыл бұрын
His the third after the second
@dellavonta187
@dellavonta187 6 ай бұрын
Great video you have new viewer Let’s smoke one team green
@Binks129
@Binks129 Жыл бұрын
Nobody won
@gloriabrown6403
@gloriabrown6403 Жыл бұрын
Your comparisons are the the same.
@OurHiltsHurt
@OurHiltsHurt 8 ай бұрын
Green always win
@Kikithewildling
@Kikithewildling Жыл бұрын
But your facts aren’t real.
@samanthaedwards6154
@samanthaedwards6154 Күн бұрын
Not gonna lie this is literal propaganda. The books tell a bias story against team black first of all and second rhenerya doesn’t care if her sons don’t think she’s a queen she’s a selfless person and if team black didn’t win the greens would of killed her kids and most likely everybody associated with team black. The green also didn’t care about women being on the throne or not Otto had his daughter Marry viserys to put the hightowers in power more so they wanted aegon because he didn’t want to be king meaning the hightowers would basically be running the kingdom. I also don’t think people died the way they said they did in the books, because again the people keeping history and telling the stories in the first place are team green supporters. The blacks literally won and it’s because the children of the forest helped them
@chichivladinski
@chichivladinski 7 ай бұрын
Athtermath?
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
The stark army put agon the 3th on the thorne not you old town usurpers
@maykllidoniii2620
@maykllidoniii2620 Жыл бұрын
I'm iffy on black or green I think green has a stronger claim but my favorite character is the old man of the north Cregan Stark so I have an urge to side with the blacks
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
Old man of the North ? He's 22 at most
@SorceressWitch
@SorceressWitch Жыл бұрын
This video is very childish attacking people personally for liking different characters. Hill's Alive is a green supporter person and never attacks people like this guy. However, the war was won by neither side as the leaders both died and didn't achieve their goals. Greens were willing to surrender but Aegon refused so they had him killed. Then Cregan Stark had arrived to bring justice. However, Rhaenyra was never fighting for women to rule, she was fighting for her own claim. She wanted to continue male primogeniture through her own line. So the idea of having Baela as queen shouldn't even be brought up to begin with. Rhaenyra was fighting for herself, not other girls. In the case of Matilda, her son Henry was fighting the war when she decided to press his claim and retire, so that's not the same situation. Henry was able to get Stephen to accept him as heir over Stephen's own sons. The Anarchy may have been the influence for the dance of the dragons, but it's not a copy of it. GRRM has said he doesn't like to copy something and make things different. So Henry II is not Aegon III, both were far different from each other. GRRM himself is anti-war and both of you missed the whole point of his books. He literally shows the atrocities that happened in the war, not just in Fire and Blood but in ASOIAF too. It's sad to see grown adults get so personal and attack each other over fiction. Some of you really need to calm down over insulting each other over a fictional show/book. We can have discussions and disagreements like actual adults instead of being petty.
@tangysweat97
@tangysweat97 9 ай бұрын
Total miester victory😂
@Art.of.the.Warriors
@Art.of.the.Warriors Жыл бұрын
First
@datwhokid1
@datwhokid1 Жыл бұрын
The King named Rhaenyra the heir and the rest were traitors for for not following through with his wish ;
@jomckellan
@jomckellan Жыл бұрын
Not how anything works. Good job wrecking the Targaryen dynasty by ignoring the rules and igniting succession wars.
@30gargyraghunath14
@30gargyraghunath14 Жыл бұрын
Exactly 👍
@kittycheshire5099
@kittycheshire5099 10 күн бұрын
That’s not how anything works. There are laws, and the king is not above the law. If he was, then Robert’s Rebellion against Mad King Aerys was treason and Ned Stark was the bad guy.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
Rhaneyra was the chosen heir by king Viserys I, all the most powerful lords swore obeisance to her as the heir including the Hightower’s. The greens are nothing but traitors, they wanted a Hightower on the throne . They had no business to the throne, to say Aegon is the rightful ruler by tradition and precedence is hypocritical because it’s also tradition that the person chosen by the king and sworn in as heir is THE HEIR. There would’ve been no war if the greens just let Rhaenyra take the throne, nobody would’ve had to die. Alicent would still have her kids, Otto wouldn’t have died a traitor. But the Hightower’s were greedy and envious (represented by the color green), and caused a bloody war which they ended up not winning . The blacks didn’t win really either, nobody won.
@nicolas0402
@nicolas0402 Жыл бұрын
No, there's no tradition that a king can simply choose a daughter over a son and be done with it. I believe the entire point of the war is to show how shit feudalism is, it's a mess, Viserys was going against every law and tradition, but he's the king. In the end what matters is your opinion, the king is above the law or no? I believe he is and that Rhaenyra is the rightful heir, but I still hate her more than Aegon lol
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
@@nicolas0402 this is fair .
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
@@nicolas0402 what Viserys did is not as bad as what Aegon IV caused at least .
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
If Aegon is a Hightower then Rhaenyra is an Arryn 🤣🤣
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re 6 ай бұрын
@@nicksmithnutmilk ok but I support the claim of Daemon Targaryen
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
The black won get over it old town propagandist . The glorious line of diamond Targaryen is on the throne and your favorite Hightower userpers are dead
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
Nobody won this war. Otto got rightfully executed by Rhaenyra, Alicent’s actions get all her children killed not protected, most of Rhaenyra’s children who she loved to death get brutally killed, she has a hard and short reign thanks to the greens taking all the money and hiding it and gets killed brutally by the psycho Aegon II who ends up getting killed by poison like another psycho king. Daemon ends up killing Aemond while also killing himself, with them goes Caraxes and Vhagar. Him and Rhaenyra’s son Aegon III takes the throne as a child but is completely traumatized and just empty the rest of his life, and he marries Jaehaera who also dies tragically . House Targaryen would never be the same, and neither would the Hightower’s thankfully.
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
The Hightowers are still strong as f
@aplusrecommends9406
@aplusrecommends9406 14 күн бұрын
Dany descends from rhaenyra and daemon's line. End of story.
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
No you are mistaken. We are fighting so that true Targaryens can take the throne not some Hightower userpers
@debamlyabanerjee4067
@debamlyabanerjee4067 8 ай бұрын
Cry more baby 👶 😆😆😆😆 greens were the true targaryens
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
True Targaryens ? Who would have been the King after Rhaenyra's death ? Jace.... a Targaryen , Arryn , Strong , Tully bastard 😂😂🤣🤣 And if Aegon is not a true Targaryen then I don't know who is
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re 6 ай бұрын
@@nicksmithnutmilk I don't support rheanyra and her bastards. I support Daemon Targaryen and his blood line . Also the true Targaryens are the crazy Targaryens and Deamon is the most crazy Targaryens during the the dance
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
@@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re I support Daemon too but if the Hightowers didn't usurp the Throne then after Rhaenyra , Jace would have been the King . House Velaryon would have taken over Westeros . Aegon II saved House Targaryen.... in a way
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re 6 ай бұрын
@@nicksmithnutmilk sure but this situation happened because otto Hightower convinced veserys to make rheanyra his hair and disinherit daemon
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
Your jealous that our line of sucsetion is on the throne
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
In the books it's Jaime Lannister's bloodline and in the show it's Ned Stark's bloodline currently . The Dance was 170 years before GOT
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re 6 ай бұрын
@@nicksmithnutmilk yes I know. Still the black are both alive in the show and in the books while the greens are all dead by the end of the dance
@badyoutuber1986
@badyoutuber1986 6 ай бұрын
Your all basic this on the precedence that a man Comes before a women that's why the greens won right but what you fail to realize is that that was not the greens actual motivation but there excuse for there deciete and actions while the blacks motivation was that rheanyra line would continue .Wich of these came true pray tell? The answer to that question will reveal the victor of the dance (blacks)
@gatorboy21king
@gatorboy21king 9 ай бұрын
Greens won the battle but the Blacks won the war
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
I am also man of tradition I am for real Targaryens not some Hightower userpers
@debamlyabanerjee4067
@debamlyabanerjee4067 8 ай бұрын
Real taragaryens aegon ii is a real taragaryen
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re 8 ай бұрын
@@debamlyabanerjee4067 no he is Hightower userper the real the targaryen is daemon Targaryen the true hair of the iron throne
@debamlyabanerjee4067
@debamlyabanerjee4067 8 ай бұрын
@@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re you made a spelling mistake it's heir not hair 😆😆😆😆 and aegon got that throne he is a targaryen and about daemon he died💀 didn't get that throne even aegon didn't take that throne aegon haif sister would took that after her her bastard would take that and those bastards are not even targaryens and daemon would never become king
@kittycheshire5099
@kittycheshire5099 10 күн бұрын
If Aegon is a Hightower, then Rhaenyra is an Arryn. Same logic.
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re 10 күн бұрын
@@kittycheshire5099you are correct sorry for my nonsense comment
@tylersmith3139
@tylersmith3139 6 ай бұрын
Yes, technically, the Greens were the last ones standing(Aegon outlived Rhaenyra), but if every conceivable way, the Blacks won. They beat the Greens militarily and succession wise. It's like saying the US had 10-1 casualties in Vietnam and won x % of all battles. Still doesn't change the fact that by all measures, North Vietnam getting the US to pull out was a victory for them, not the US and they gained control of South Vietnam while the US lost control of South Vietnam. Technicalities don't win wars, results do. If the Blacks took over courts and Rhaenyra's children and descendants ruled Westeros, it doesn't matter if Aegon ii was the last man standing, functionally he's left with his almost his entire family wiped, he dies shortly after without a male heir. His daughter is forced to marry Rhaenyra's son and she dies without an heir and said son continues the Targaryen line with someone else. The Hightower-Targaryens die out while the main Targaryen house lives on with Rhaenyra's children and her followers rule the court and become the most influential people in the country. In pretty much every conceivable way, the Blacks win.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
You guys can’t be serious, y’all actually support the greens? The greens are the ones who started the war lol, the blacks are not evil at all except for Daemon, in the show at least. In the books it’s different, but in the books it’s also told from the view of people who supported the greens, so they made Rhaenyra and team black more antagonistic. In the show which is actually a reliable narrative, the greens are the clear antagonist. What bad has Rhaenyra done in the show? Yes she has bastards, guess what? So does Aegon, and he puts them in child fighting pits where they are brutally killed for his enjoyment. What a great guy, worthy of being king 👏🏾👏🏾. He rapes girls in the red keep, Alicent has perfected a routine on dealing with it because it happens so many times. What a great guy, worthy of being king 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾. You know who Aegon is? Joffrey. Y’all basically support Joffrey, but worse because he has a dragon. It’s the exact same shit Cersei does with Joffrey, she thinks she can control him, but when he gets on the throne and gets that crown on his head, he’s not gonna listen to them. I guarantee one of the first things Aegon will do as king in season 2 is make child fighting rings legal as a sport despite the disagreements from his mother and grandfather who foolishly thought they could manipulate him. What a great guy, worthy of being king 👏🏾👏🏾. Rhaenyra absolutely would be a better ruler than she was if it weren’t for the war. The dance of the dragons broke her, losing Lucerys and Jacearys. Seemingly losing Viserys to the triarchy who were working with the greens. You wanna know the type of person Rhaenyra is? When she took Kings Landing, she spared Alicent from death by fire. Despite the fact Alicent had betrayed her in the most meaningful way, and that betrayal has caused the deaths of THREE of Rhaenyra’s kids, she spared her even though she had every right to put her to death “for my father who loved you once”. You can’t compare Rhaenyra to Aegon, she has done nothing evil in the show yet. Aegon has done plenty so far .
@davidbranson1367
@davidbranson1367 Жыл бұрын
Oh no, a blackcel. Such a cringe comment.
@davidbranson1367
@davidbranson1367 Жыл бұрын
Looool. Corlys is not evil? a guy who was willing to marry his 10-year-old daughter to a 50-year-old man? Rhaenys isn't evil? Isn't it evil for her to kill a bunch of innocent people for no reason? Do you forget Mysaria and the horrible things she did? Do you forget that Rhaenyra asked for Aemond to be tortured? Rhaenyra also forgot the existence of Viserys for 6 years, she abandoned her own father and only visited him to ask for something. She also tried to take away what belonged to Vaemond Velaryon by birthright, she wanted her bastard son in a position that did not belong to him. The showrunners made Aegon a rapist cuz their blackcel propaganda, to further the fallacy of = Are you team green? so you support rapist. Aegon has NOTHING to do with Joffrey. Joffrey was a bastard, Aegon the king's eldest son, Joffrey was a psychopath who only thought of himself, Aegon took the throne to protect his family, Joffrey was a coward in the battle of blackwaters, Aegon fought his own battles and was strong as hell. The difference is that Aegon has Otto and Alicent, 2 competent politicians who kept the kingdom stable for 20 years. While Rhaenyra is trash that has no respect for traditions, and has Daemon as her consort, as the greens said: Daemon would be the true king, not Rhaenyra. Your comment is pure blackcel rubbish, the greens were the correct side due to Andal traditions, inheritance laws, Westerosi traditions. etc.
@mackmitchell94
@mackmitchell94 Жыл бұрын
@@davidbranson1367 Viserys was the one who kept the realm stable for 20 years. All Otto did was scheme behind Viserys’ back to get more power. He probably did have something to do with Baelon’s death . That’s why Daemon hated him, he saw Otto for who he was. That’s the real reason why Otto wanted Daemon gone. If Daemon became king, Otto wouldn’t be able to manipulate him at all and as long as Daemon was close to the king in the capital, Otto was limited in his manipulations. Aegon fired Otto as hand very shortly after becoming king because he thought him too peaceful, replacing him with Criston Cole . Aegon cared about his mother and brother, he doesn’t give a shit about his sister wife or his children with her . What a great guy 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾. Saying Corlys is evil for putting his 12 year old daughter to marry the king when it was normal for the time is idiotic . She didn’t have to have sex with him until years later, in fact Viserys should’ve married Laena, he should’ve steered clear away from the Hightower’s . Rhaenyra doesn’t respect traditions? Probably because half the traditions are sexist ? Aegon can father multiple bastards but Rhaenyra can’t have two without being a whore? Also Corlys and Viserys accept Rhaenyra’s boys as their grandsons. Vaemond was only out for himself, if he truly only wanted to make sure Velaryon blood inherited driftmark, then he would’ve stood down when Rhaenys revealed Lucerys would marry Rhaena. Instead he went and got himself murdered because he was only trying to bury his brother and claim the power of his seat. Aegon is still a sexual predator in the books, it clearly states that he was known to fondle serving girls in the red keep and he fathered multiple bastards. He’s a POS with no decency lol, we’re talking about a guy who celebrates his own nephew getting brutally murdered by his brother, what a great guy👏🏾👏🏾. Daemon respected Rhaenyra, she’s the only person other than her father that Daemon listens to . Rhaenyra was Daemons queen, the show makes that clear in the final episode. The greens would’ve been completely safe from Daemon if they didn’t usurp the throne from the rightful heir chosen by Viserys. You know what? Before this I really didn’t support the blacks or the greens, I just couldn’t believe people actually support the greens . Well now, I’ve changed my mind. I’m definitely a blackcel, fuck the goddamned greens 😂🥂.
@davidbranson1367
@davidbranson1367 Жыл бұрын
@@mackmitchell94 Viserys? Loooool, most of his council was pro green, like Maester Orwyle, Tyland Lannister, etc. Viserys was a fucking king, he destroyed the stability of the kingdom and wanted to destroy the tradition on a fucking whim, he didn't even put Rhaenyra on the throne because she was ready, no, he did it because she was more Targaryen than her brothers and she was the Viserys darling, how stupid. Corlys was also ambitious, as much as Otto, but did Daemon hate him? not. Otto had reasons to hate Daemon, Otto saw that he was violent, reckless and impulsive, we as viewers know that Daemon loves his brother, whereas Otto doesn't. Otto had other reasons for his hatred, just look how Daemon mocked the death of Baelon, his own nephew! Seeing that he was closer to the line of succession, or when Daemon stole the Dragon's egg, a weapon of mass destruction, without the king's permission, taking a fortress that did not belong to him and leading some rebel guards who betrayed the king . Otto Hightower had great courage when going to face his greatest enemy who has a Dragon and a small army. Otto is ambitious, yes, but he is a man who cares about the kingdom and its stability, he is a man who knows the laws and was chosen by Jahaerys himself to be his king's hand, he was so good that Viserys returned to him hand pick after Lyonel's death.
@davidbranson1367
@davidbranson1367 Жыл бұрын
@@mackmitchell94 So let me understand, Otto is evil for marrying his 15-year-old daughter to the king but Corlys is not for doing the same but worse? wtf? And how did Corlys know that Viserys hadn't raped Laena? Corlys knew that her daughter would not be happy to be taken away from her home and her brother at such a young age but she didn't care in the slightest. Daemon also saw how Corlys conspired against Viserys and spoke badly behind his back, did he hate him as much as Otto? not. LOL? She wanted to put bastards on the throne, knowing that a bastard has no rights to the laws of succession, she wanted her bastard to inherit the Driftmark over Rhaena, the eldest daughter of the firstborn, Laena, plus look what she did to Lady Rosby in the books. Rhaenyra is just hypocritical trash, she's not a feminist at all, she's just Maegora 2.0, a person who only thinks about eating and fucking. If you don't respect traditions, why do you want the throne? Dude, what you say is Mushroom garbage, if we believe everything he says, then the threesomes he had with Daemon and Rhaenyra are true? Mushroom left for Dragonstone when Aegon was a child, there's no way he knew he was a rapist, there's no other source to say that about him, Aegon was actually a nice guy, carefree and a party lover, not a psychotic as the series sells it to you. That Aegon celebrated the death of Lucerys is also a mushroom invention, what? Do you think everyone is going to celebrate the arrival of a war? Even Otto said Aemond was an idiot. Daemon respected Rhaenyra? wtf? Choking her to near death is respect? Ignoring her while giving birth is respect? Cheating on her with Mysaria and Nettles in the books is respect? wtf? Dude, Daemon doesn't have any kind of respect for Rhaenyra, he only sees her as a puppet to get the throne. Haha, do you think Daemon would have forgiven them? He thought they killed his brother, he hated Otto to death and had no sympathy for his nephew, Aegon's existence was a challenge to Rhaenyra's claim, it was common to kill rivals for the throne, so Daemon told him. I would have done it without any problem
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re
@yhvvcbhjjggjk-id1re Жыл бұрын
Yes we won because we killed your Hightower usurpers
@nicksmithnutmilk
@nicksmithnutmilk 6 ай бұрын
The Hightowers remained one of the richest House in Westeros even after the Dance . Oldtown is still untouchable
Which Houses are Team Black vs Green (House of the Dragon)
9:18
Dance of the Dragons || Full Version || History & Lore
20:28
Jeremy Ice & Fire 33
Рет қаралды 566 М.
Вечный ДВИГАТЕЛЬ!⚙️ #shorts
00:27
Гараж 54
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН
Why I Support 'The Greens' | House of The Dragon | ASOIAF
17:38
The Second Son
Рет қаралды 28 М.
Who Is The WORST Character In Team Black | House of the Dragon
1:01:37
Our Hilts Hurt
Рет қаралды 12 М.
Choosing Greens or Blacks  - House of The Dragon
9:14
D. Charles
Рет қаралды 7 М.
Lord of the Tides | Team Green's Take
16:15
The Second Son
Рет қаралды 7 М.
HOUSE OF THE DRAGON: The Burning Mill E3 Explained.
5:58
Duffthy's Box
Рет қаралды 456
Why the Greens are justified.
11:37
Tariq
Рет қаралды 33 М.
House of the Dragon Season 2 | COMPLETE History & Lore |
1:10:23
The Second Son
Рет қаралды 11 М.
How is House of the Dragon Biased
19:05
The Critical Maester
Рет қаралды 56 М.
The Broken Reign of Aegon the Dragonbane
32:03
Crusader Chris
Рет қаралды 344 М.
Why Team Green vs Team Black is kinda pointless.
10:22
TheEmpyreanSpeaks
Рет қаралды 11 М.
Вечный ДВИГАТЕЛЬ!⚙️ #shorts
00:27
Гараж 54
Рет қаралды 14 МЛН